Evidence for 751b5c4 and the provenance finding behind it.
While citing revisions I checked whether they resolve. CultNet `f4ab237` and its
predecessor `e542225` are not ancestors of CultLib main. Their content is on
CultLib `85f7024` -- verified by symbol, and Ghostlight compiles against it --
but the SHAs are not, because the consolidation ported commits forward instead
of merging them. They survive only on GameCult/cultnet-rs branch
codex/idunn-runtime-authority-contract.
That changes the retirement gate. Deleting GameCult/cultnet-rs was previously
gated on its content living somewhere else, which is now satisfied. It is also
gated on citation: every contract reference in this map, the handoff, both notes
and the evidence ledger points into that repo. Either re-anchor them on CultLib
`85f7024` or keep the branch.
Odin `65cf2b2` and `d527d72` are likewise off Odin main but sit on a pushed
branch, so they resolve from a clone and need nothing.
The vendor-retirement record carried a hand-written timestamp ten hours in the
future, which sorted it after work that actually came later. Corrected through
the store to 7e73504's commit time; the export follows. All 27 records intact.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
27 lines
21 KiB
JSON
27 lines
21 KiB
JSON
{"note": "VoidBot social intelligence is a first-class Ghostlight consumer: appraiser and relationship/perception training must support human-facing reads, grounded opinions, uncertainty, repair signals, and opinion updates over repeated interaction, not only fictional scene mutation.", "status": "accepted", "ts": "2026-05-02T14:41:30+00:00", "type": "architecture"}
|
|
{"note": "Generated environment images are accepted only as concept/material reference for illustrated IF. Multi-angle or branch-consistent replay needs a durable scene-set/blockout/layout source with named cameras and staging slots; imagegen should paint over camera-specific visual input rather than preserve room topology from memory.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-05-04T11:20:03+00:00", "type": "visual-doctrine"}
|
|
{"note": "Coordinator seam correction: future training-shaped loops should sandbox coordinator turns as their own promptable organ. Codex acts as meta-coordinator, preparing inputs, launching/reviewing workers, labeling interventions, and wiring structured state; raw coordinator training data must not be silently collapsed into omniscient chat steering.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-05-04T17:14:29+00:00", "type": "architecture"}
|
|
{"note": "Character cognition seam: Ghostlight machinery should be maximally smart, but characters must reason and socially maneuver only to the level supported by their modeled intelligence, culture, role, experience, stress, and state. Coordinator/narrator prose may translate opaque high-context tactics for reader legibility without granting that explanation to characters.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-05-04T18:44:45+00:00", "type": "architecture"}
|
|
{"note": "CultCache wire contract clarified: DatabaseEntry payloads must be MessagePack arrays indexed by explicit field keys with nil gaps for reserved/deleted slots; cultcache-py now exposes define_database_entry_type for that contract and CultLib generator was patched to preserve sparse key slots.", "status": "accepted", "ts": "2026-05-06T03:57:10+00:00", "type": "architecture"}
|
|
{"note": "Ghostlight agent-state schema is now the first shared cross-runtime payload contract. CultNet clients should carry ghostlight.agent_state.v0 unchanged inside typed document envelopes, with CultLib-style auth/session semantics handled by the transport layer rather than bespoke per-repo glue.", "status": "accepted", "ts": "2026-05-06T04:49:20+00:00", "type": "architecture"}
|
|
{"branch": "codex/ghostlight-dungeon-mvp", "note": "Multiplayer is an intended post-solo extension of the existing one-WorldKernel, many-actor authority model. Multiple authenticated humans will control distinct actors through the same campaign mailbox, perception gates, initiative, and atomic commit path; no party prompt or room-state authority is introduced. The paid alpha remains single-player while multiresolution Gestalt proof stays the immediate forge priority.", "status": "accepted", "ts": "2026-08-18T14:36:02+00:00", "type": "design"}
|
|
{"note": "DELVE/HOLD boundary: live Ghostlight WorldKernel, multiresolution agency, typed transitions, persistence, and receipts are reusable, but current InstitutionState and strategic resource handles do not implement HOLD quantities, prices, recipes, capacity, inventories, orders, contracts, or conservation. Delvehold therefore retains quantitative economy authority; a forced ontology may bypass world generation but never WorldKernel validation. Owner witnesses: crates/ghostlight-dungeon/src/domain.rs and F:\\Projects\\Delvehold\\Delvehold\\Game Design\\Shared World\\World State Model.md.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-08-26T00:50:11+00:00", "type": "architecture"}
|
|
{"note": "Delvehold is a proving consumer of Ghostlight's generic world-simulation API, not a Ghostlight integration organ. Ghostlight may add only generic capabilities: one seed admission primitive shared by compiler and consumer producers, generic externally owned subject authority, consumer-supplied effect schemas, and typed proposals and receipts. The greathold ID, all delvehold.* bindings, and detailed projection/economy translation remain Delvehold-owned. Cells and WorldKernel never switch on consumer-specific names.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-08-26T15:55:05+00:00", "type": "architecture"}
|
|
{"note": "Supersedes the 2026-08-26T15:51 research note only where it called Delvehold the redirected primary play target: Delvehold is the first proving consumer of the generic world API, while adversarial single-player Dungeon play remains an active regression and context-discovery path. Implemented one compiler/consumer WorldSeed admission transaction, institution-scoped ExternalSubjectAuthority, WorldKernel-owned revisioned snapshots, atomic strategic-wave proposals, acknowledgement receipts, and typed loopback CultNet RUDP operations. Consumer-specific IDs and quantitative economy semantics remain outside Ghostlight.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-08-26T16:46:55+00:00", "type": "architecture"}
|
|
{"note": "The generic external authority/snapshot contract admits both institution and Gestalt subjects. This closes the Delvehold sovereign-gestalt requirement without adding a Delvehold-specific type: one tagged ExternalSubjectProjection carries either canonical shape, WorldKernel validates exact authority kind and subject ID, refreshes derived agency facets, and keeps the subject non-simulation-eligible while still targetable by foreign proposals.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-08-26T17:12:55+00:00", "type": "architecture"}
|
|
{"note": "Operator architecture directive: a newspaper is a persistent political/editorial Persona, not a neutral fact summary. Each publication owns audience, remembered beats, narrative memeplex, selective pickup, recurring throughlines, ideological framing, and rivals; competing Delvehold publications may frame one committed event substrate differently. Grounding owns factual assertion/provenance constraints but must preserve clearly legible interpretation, selection, framing, and insinuation. Current Canopy Ledger acceptance remains one publication instance. Do not patch this into the fact-check prompt or derail run43. The detailed owner/state cut belongs in the implementation plan after current acceptance.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-08-29T05:15:35+00:00", "type": "correction"}
|
|
{"note": "Read-only inspection of immutable Delvehold Run 108 through the focused CampaignStore explorer found a strong authored crisis theater but a failed whole-world complexity shape. The canonical state has 55 locations, 68 institutions, 164 facts, 3,141 Gestalts, 366 Actors, 371 member records, and 2,430 agency relations; exactly 2,400 active leaves are distributed across five realms plus the boundary scene. The eight titled elaborators produce excellent distinct lanes for texture, civic authority, economy, care, politics, secrets, urgent pressure, and numinous meaning. Repeated fission then substitutes taxonomy for novelty: 557 searchable records contain other-unknown, 780 contain residual, many active leaves inherit identical goals, and identity generation repeats public names across distinct people (including at least eight materialized Actors named Mara Venn and four named Nera Quill). Treat this as promising base material for one international crisis region, not yet a plausible entire world or training-ready autonomous narrative substrate. The next world-shape design must gate semantic distinctness, identity diversity, relation/pressure contribution, and horizontal geographic and cultural expansion rather than counting active leaves alone.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-09-01T03:06:42+00:00", "type": "research"}
|
|
{"note": "Run 115 terminated at revision 2 with 2/8 regions and 0/1 waves after an SSE timeout and a dangling institution location exhausted the model reconciliation workbench. The qualification/verifier/reconciliation/context/timeout/routing patch sequence through 8964a92 did not establish structural ownership. Operator ordered a whole-machine rebuild: one WorldKernel, one typed ontology reducer, one CommandEnvelope/CultCache commit path; NarrativePersona retains Projector-Persona-Interpreter prose isolation, while OperationalAgent is an explicit disjoint controller for operator-shaped cognition. Actor counts and qualitative interest remain evaluation evidence, never admission or completeness authority.", "status": "accepted", "ts": "2026-09-01T12:11:39+00:00", "type": "architecture"}
|
|
{"note": "Mind maintenance falsified stale rebuild steering: the map still claimed subtraction had not begun and the handoff later revived Run 111 as an active continuation. Rebuilt the handoff and implementation plan around the adopted one-WorldState authority, landed cuts 64f50de/a144c33, total interpretation, current deletion line, and focused verification gate; chronology remains in Git, evidence, and the frozen teardown map.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-09-01T12:37:47+00:00", "type": "architecture"}
|
|
{"note": "Rejected and deleted the uncommitted first world.rs foundation after focused tests passed. Review found the public module exposed mutable WorldState and ID issuance, translation-gap inference had become canonical world mutation, empty batches could advance revision, controller commands lacked consumed opportunity/readiness/affordance binding, external ownership was bypassed by world-author authority, command evidence did not bind fact evidence, and batch self-digests were unverifiable. Next cut is private-first: seal WorldKernel/aggregate/journal ownership before reintroducing a minimal reducer behind it.", "status": "rejected", "ts": "2026-09-01T13:03:26+00:00", "type": "architecture"}
|
|
{"note": "Commit b53251f lands a private provisional foundation.v0 WorldKernel owner: immutable genesis and exact create retry, sealed authentication evidence, one live CultCache owner, canonical WorldId issuance and reduction kept private, digest/replay recovery, persisted no-op and rejection non-commit, path-identity revocation, and poison/reopen after a simulated post-durable lost acknowledgement. Nine focused world tests pass. The legacy exported kernel remains live; this is the sealed foundation, not cutover.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-09-01T14:18:40+00:00", "type": "implementation"}
|
|
{"note": "Commit d49b907 makes the replacement Persona interpretation contract structurally total. Persona source prose is immutable noncanonical evidence bound to typed world/controller/opportunity/revision and inference receipts; only exact typed captures may propose state, actual quoted dialogue is required for speech, malformed spans or raw tool payloads become exact whole-source translation gaps, normal step exhaustion adds an unresolved-source gap, and infrastructure interruption discards partial captures and returns the source pending. Ten focused projection tests pass. Legacy exported Persona runners still contain terminal failure paths and do not expose record_gap; they remain deletion targets, so totality is not yet a live-runtime claim.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-09-01T14:37:59+00:00", "type": "implementation"}
|
|
{"note": "Commits 12ee9f4 and 66ed2ec advance the authority rebuild past the private reducer phase. The first removes 686 lines of dead legacy Elaboration and Mutation ingress without a compatibility writer. The second completes the sealed Draft-to-Active authority loop with canonical controller assignments and affordance grants, revision-bound opportunities, one shared human and autonomous ExerciseDecision reducer, one serialized mailbox, atomic replay, and exact rejection and lost-ack behavior; eighteen focused world tests pass. This is not runtime cutover: the legacy exported kernel and startup, Session Zero, player, autonomous, and recovery paths remain live owners. The next move exposes and wires the replacement runtime identity and mailbox, deleting each old owner without dual-write.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-09-01T17:40:32+00:00", "type": "implementation"}
|
|
{"note": "Pushed Ghostlight 13d5136 has no legacy runtime modules and one CultCache owner, but Yggdrasil still runs legacy a4080d4. Read-only cutover audit proved the current Idunn path structurally unfit: source/ref/floor policy is duplicated across compiled Rust, raw executable command records, a privileged shell dispatcher, and large gamecult-ops target programs; root Git cannot inspect correctly idunn-owned mirrors; Ghostlight world-v2 purity checks ignore most legacy state; and fixed-port activation stops the incumbent before the candidate is green. Adopted cut: visible target-owned recipes and unit templates, Idunn-configured refs/runner containers/affordances/host bindings, Git and recipe materialization as idunn, narrow sealed privileged consequences, candidate staged health behind a stable router, process/write-lease handoff, atomic route change, and separate deployment versus continuity authority. Do not issue the current Connector or Ghostlight redeploy requests.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-09-02T14:10:03+00:00", "type": "research"}
|
|
{"note": "Supersedes the 2026-09-02T14:10:03+00:00 Idunn cutover design receipt where it named target-owned unit templates, an executable-affecting-commit selector, and staged health. Odin cebe425 rejects raw repository unit/container templates: targets own constrained launch declarations and the operator-selected workload driver lowers them. Deterministic plan validation retains commit, tree, recipe, and Gitlink facts but does not prove ancestry, signatures, or object custody; a future narrow Idunn source driver must. CultNet 87d0b0f and Odin cebe425 establish Expected, Idunn-observed activation, service-signed Present, process lease before writable state, Odin Ready, and route membership only after Ready. Actuation and Idunn main integration remain absent.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-09-02T19:30:00+00:00", "type": "research"}
|
|
{"note": "Supersedes the 2026-09-02T19:30:00+00:00 deployment integration checkpoint. Owning Body inspection found CultNet pushed through e542225 (generation-bound activation, lifecycle brake, process lease, provider-observed capabilities, and explicit disagreements) and Odin pushed through d527d72 (exact source freezing and narrow actuator ports), with an uncommitted four-file integration for dynamic systemd isolation, authenticated Ready-only provider selection, protected one-shot activation delivery, and the e542225 gitlink. The remaining deployment owner is not another driver gate: replace control_plane.rs command ownership with exactly DeploymentCommand, DeploymentTransaction, and AdmittedGeneration; persist each of the nine phases before effects; persist prepared activation before start; reject pre-persistence orphans; and atomically complete the transaction with exact admitted-generation CAS. Production cutover remains unproven.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-09-03T00:58:55+00:00", "type": "research"}
|
|
{"note": "Supersedes the 2026-09-03T00:58:55+00:00 deployment-owner checkpoint. CultNet f4ab237, Odin 65cf2b2, Ghostlight a0b16b9, and CodexConnector ede3c30 land the routed runtime contracts, durable three-record/nine-phase transaction owner, and provider sides. Live admission remains absent. Current Odin projection/RUDP/UDP-route and Rust Odin correlation work is uncommitted; the Nginx route receipt proves configuration plus nginx -T visibility only, not live-worker adoption or packet delivery, so an exact data-plane observation remains required before fence clearance, drain, or cutover acceptance.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-09-03T06:13:20+00:00", "type": "research"}
|
|
{"note": "Mind and workspace compaction. The evidence ledger was 258 records of which 235 were per-release/per-run receipts, self-consuming falsification chains, and May fixture doctrine already owned by docs/architecture and map hard_boundaries; those moved to state/evidence.archive.jsonl and were deleted from the CultCache evidence document, since evidence.jsonl is a regenerated export and a store-only deletion is the sole durable compaction. Twenty-three records remain: still-binding contracts (CultCache wire format, agent_state.v0, cognition ceiling, image-geometry authority, sandboxed coordinator, VoidBot appraisal, multiplayer extension, the Delvehold boundary set, newspaper-as-Persona) plus the whole rebuild era from Run 108 forward. A duplicate multiplayer note recorded twice under different timestamps was reduced to one. The worktree shed 87MB of untracked debris: three Git bundles whose commits are all ancestors of HEAD, ~60 legacy live-fire run scripts and sftp batches, the forbidden redeploy helpers, downloaded run61-63 acceptance copies whose authoritative roots remain on Yggdrasil and whose frozen copy is digest-bound in output/tex, a redb file created by a stray --help argument, and 71MB of tmp/ legacy campaign caches and newspaper renders. .gitignore now refuses all of it. map.yaml and the handoff had stale frontiers naming 13d5136 and a0b16b9; both now name 6a79cb0.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-09-03T20:00:00+00:00", "type": "maintenance"}
|
|
{"note": "Core GameCult stack ownership resolved. CultLib is the canonical home for CultCache, CultNet and CultMesh across every runtime because wire parity conformance lives only there; a runtime-specific repo cannot own the engine other runtimes must agree with. The standalone GameCult/cultcache-rs and GameCult/cultnet-rs repos are pre-consolidation origins that kept receiving work after the 5c69bfc import, and Ghostlight became a third lineage by written charter: vendor/README.md declares a locally owned compatible protocol generation, which is duplicate authority over the wire stack held outside the only harness that checks parity. That is why runtime_authority_contracts.rs forked: Ghostlight vendors e542225 while map and handoff declare CultNet f4ab237 authoritative, and the two disagree on whether Present may coexist with a disagreement -- Ghostlight's copy makes them exclusive, f4ab237 separates presence from readiness and gates through into_undisputed_present. Re-vendoring fixes that instance, not the mechanism. CultLib branch claude/consolidate-rust-core-stack commit 34488e8 returns the Rust CultCache engine to CultLib: the standalone body as base (3,714 lines, 46 passing tests) over CultLib's 1,554, with the cultnet-rs RUDP gate passing 20 unchanged. Two CultLib-only commits remain unported debt. cultmesh-rs is homeless: the only Rust CultMesh implementation in existence is 1,363 lines inside Ghostlight's vendor, absent from CultLib and from any repo, so it has never been parity tested against the browser, Kotlin and TypeScript implementations it must interoperate with. Ghostlight must consume CultLib by pinned rev and stop vendoring before the standalone repos are retired.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-09-03T21:00:00+00:00", "type": "architecture"}
|
|
{"note": "Ghostlight's vendored core-stack fork is retired at d0510ac: cultcache-rs, cultnet-rs and cultmesh-rs now come from CultLib pinned at 85f7024 and vendor/README.md's 'locally owned compatible protocol generation' charter is deleted with them. The predicted migration did not exist. RuntimePresenceCorrelation moving from enum to struct is Odin's side of the contract and no Ghostlight file references it; with line endings normalised the e542225 and f4ab237 copies differ by 132 lines, and the only production change reaching a provider is IdunnExpectedRoute requiring rudp:// schemes for rudp transport, which this service does not use. Ghostlight compiled unchanged and passes 89 workspace tests against the pinned rev. One thing was nearly lost: the vendored transport.rs alone checked a framed payload length against the advertised maximum before allocating, so a four-byte header could otherwise size a buffer to whatever a peer claims; it is now CultLib 85f7024 with a test. Verified by diffing all twelve vendored cultnet files against CultLib before deleting rather than after. vendor/ still holds the cultcache-py and eve submodules; cultcache-py is the same runtime-specific-repo pattern and CultLib carries packages/cultcache-py, but it backs the state tooling rather than the daemon.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-09-03T23:13:55+00:00", "type": "architecture"}
|
|
{"note": "The pre-existing worktree drift is landed at 751b5c4 and 322cc11. The daemon no longer names GHOSTLIGHT_RUNTIME_ID, GHOSTLIGHT_DUNGEON_BIND or GHOSTLIGHT_DUNGEON_ROOT under management; Idunn supplies the runtime id in the activation bundle, the candidate bind, and the state root as a recipe argument binding. That binding is required rather than cosmetic: Odin deployment.rs refuses a stateful workload with no state_root argument binding and refuses one whose binding disagrees with the admitted root, so the old recipe could not have deployed. The acceptance harness identity is renamed GHOSTLIGHT_ACCEPTANCE_RUNTIME_ID so a test-supplied id cannot be read as the managed one. 89 workspace tests pass. Provenance finding that changes the cultnet-rs retirement gate: the contract revisions the Mind cites, CultNet f4ab237 and its predecessor e542225, are not ancestors of CultLib main and exist only on GameCult/cultnet-rs branch codex/idunn-runtime-authority-contract. Their content is on CultLib main at 85f7024, verified by symbol, but the SHAs are not, because the consolidation ported commits forward rather than merging them. Deleting GameCult/cultnet-rs therefore breaks every citation in map.yaml, the handoff, both notes and the evidence ledger. Odin 65cf2b2 and d527d72 are likewise off Odin main, on pushed branch codex/ygg-idunn-independent-bootstrap, which is resolvable and needs no action.", "status": "ok", "ts": "2026-09-03T23:26:24+00:00", "type": "architecture"}
|