Kalsa/workshop/deepening/pass-template.md

pass_id	status	target	canonical_owner	coordinator	started	completed	intake_base_commit
KALSA-000	draft	replace-me	unresolved	replace-me	YYYY-MM-DD		replace-with-full-commit-before-pass-work

KALSA-000 — Pass Title

Objective

What real setting and play outcome does this pass serve?

Phase-boundary intake

Run scripts/lore/check-phase-boundary-intake.ps1 before the first review turn and again against the exact final packet before closure. A changed proposal or handoff note passes automatically when its raw SHA-1 and path are in the frozen packet. Record only out-of-packet dispositions here.

Proposal or handoff note	Disposition	Reason or destination
	defer or reject	Named later pass/queue destination, or concrete rejection reason.

Source inventory

Seed evidence

• Exact paths and claims.

Adopted canon

• Current owner notes and claims.

Provisional, contested, rumored, or deprecated material

• Keep authority states separate.

Contradictions and unknowns

• What cannot yet be reconciled or assumed?

Authority map before repair

• Owner:
• Inputs:
• Outputs:
• Derived state:
• Forbidden writers:
• Shared paths:
• Cut line:

Institutional model

• Function:
• Authority and enforcement limits:
• Recruitment, training, rank, compensation, discipline, succession, exit:
• Material support, records, places, tools, maintenance, supply:
• Doctrine versus practice:
• Beneficiaries, costs, exclusion, refusal:
• Dependencies and neighboring institutions:
• Variation by class, region, lineage, language, magic:
• Historical formation and path dependence:
• Internal contradiction and factions:
• Player-facing consequences:

Critique

• Generic fantasy defaults:
• Missing material constraints:
• False consensus or absent subordinate perspectives:
• Consequences that stop at the page edge:
• Duplicate or ambiguous owners:

Review council

• Packet identity:
• Repaired packet identity:
• Packet path:
• Council mode snapshot: active Critics, Guardians, counters, and any sanity trigger for this pass.
• Guardian diff base and changed-note packet:
• Protected strengths:
• In-scope inhabitant model boundary: owner or synthesis; evidence and reproduction; useful domain; blind spot; protected unknown.
• Ghostlight lens: point of contact; character-accessible evidence; target-supported interventions; consequence horizon or play-bearing owner.
• Event-owner evidence or explicit evidence gap:

Seat	Mode	Diagnostic or sanity report	Verdict	Regression or Guardian change report
Institutional Causality	Critic
Culture and Situated Knowledge	Critic
Material Life and Ecology	Critic
History, Conflict, and Change	Critic
Ghostlight Play and Consequence	Critic
Oracle Ecology and Timeline Competition	Critic
AI-Isms and Prose	Guardian	n/a unless sanity triggered
Reader Experience and Navigation	Critic

• Synthesis and dispositions:
• Accepted repair brief:
• Deferred pressure added to queue:

Repair

• Canonical files to change:
• Obsolete authority to delete or demote first:
• Smallest coherent new model:
• Links and downstream consequences to add:

Falsification

Hostile or marginal perspective

Who sees the institution from below, outside, or under coercion, and what does their experience reveal?

Historical stress case

What crisis, scarcity, succession, war, migration, or magical failure tests the claimed mechanism?

Authority map after repair

• Owner:
• Inputs:
• Outputs:
• Derived state:
• Forbidden writers:
• Shared paths:
• Deleted or demoted authority:

Verification

• Seed hashes unchanged.
• Wikilinks resolve without new ambiguity.
• Workshop, seed, and memory remain outside the publication root.
• Production Quartz build succeeds.
• Affected rendered pages were inspected.
• Git diff changes only intended owners and supporting indexes.
• Benchmark review completed without treating counts as proof.
• Every active Critic diagnostic report exists; Guardian diagnostic absence is explained by recorded mode or a sanity report exists.
• Every substantive finding has a coordinator disposition.
• Every active Critic regression and required Guardian change or sanity report exists on the exact final candidate; no essential accepted defect remains.
• Phase-boundary intake passed before review and against the exact final packet before closure.
• Guardian counters and mode transitions are updated.
• The final closeout names what should now be left alone.

Decision record

• Adopted:
• Explicitly not adopted:
• Unresolved:
• Project-memory judgment promoted or retired:
• Next highest-value pressure: