The resolver's retired set in patch.rs seeded itself with its own
`matches!(assignment, ControllerAssignment::Retired)`, a second reading of
the same predicate the kernel's `is_retired` already owns. Made
`is_retired` `pub(crate)` and had the resolver call it (over
`controller_assignments.keys()`, then `Key::Existing(scope.subject_id)`)
instead of matching the assignment enum itself, so "is this subject
retired" has exactly one reader — the kernel's own statement of
retirement, the one audience derivation and preconditions already trust.
The exercise revision had two independent computations of the same
`state.revision + 1` arithmetic (action.rs's `exercise`, written out
inline, and the kernel's own `resolution_revision`), and `apply_effect`'s
`DecisionExercised` arm then called `resolution_revision` a second time
per invocation even though `exercise` had already produced the identical
value into `event.revision` moments earlier (and the arm had just proved
`derived == *event`, so `event.revision` is provably that same value).
Collapsed to one arithmetic owner — `exercise` now calls
`super::resolution_revision(state)` instead of duplicating the `+1`
inline — and cut the redundant call site: `DecisionExercised` now reads
`event.revision` for `apply_operations`'s `resolves_to` rather than
recomputing it.
Mutation: `is_retired` forced to always return `false`. Both the kernel's
own retirement tests (`tests::a_retired_institution_lends_no_authority_to_
its_office_holder`, 12 of the `clock_tests::a_retired_*`/`retiring_*`
cases) and the resolver's own test
(`patch::tests::a_grant_after_retiring_the_lending_institution_is_admitted`)
fail together — 14 failures total — which is the shared-ownership proof;
restored after confirming.
PA.f48's and PA.f49's existing tests stay green (34 retirement-shaped
tests including both PA.f48 resolver tests; the two PA.f49
`acquired_at`-revision tests). Full lib suite: 620 passed, 0 failed, 1
ignored. Dungeon bin suite: 63 passed, 0 failed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>