Record steps 9 and 10 in flight; drop the two-call-sites claim

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Meta Vens 2026-09-05 22:40:48 +02:00
commit a62708fe33
4 changed files with 65 additions and 30 deletions

View file

@ -106,8 +106,8 @@ a `Confidence` and a `KnowledgeSource { Witnessed, Told { by, via }, Evidenced }
a telling never overwrites a holder. A `Channel` is an entity with a
`Reach { Subjects, Place }` and a controller. Speech is an affordance whose
entry declares exactly one `Audience { Colocated, Channel }`: `exercise`
mints the `Claimed` fact through `derive_id` (the second of its two call
sites, the first being `resolve_patch`) and lowers a `Communicate` whose
mints the `Claimed` fact through `derive_id` (one of the fixed set of `derive_id`
call sites; no pass adds one) and lowers a `Communicate` whose
recipients are re-derived by one pure `fan_out` over `audience` at apply
time. Audience means the declared reach; a channel's controller may broadcast
from outside it (`can_broadcast`) but receives nothing unless inside it.

View file

@ -336,24 +336,60 @@ are teardown evidence. Plan step 6 is ten implementation passes, all landed.
source, plus one integration test. The connector is stopped after the
run; the smoke substrate at `F:\Projects\Ghostlight-smoke` stays.
In flight: the operator approved the interruption pass on 2026-09-05,
plan step 9. Nothing is edited yet except the plan line; Modeling is
mapping the source into the session scratchpad `modeling-interruption.md`,
then Imagination, Hands in an isolation worktree, Soul in that tree,
coordinator integrates. Operating assumption recorded from the
coordinator: an interruption is a scope change between forming an intent
and committing it, from any cause (a neighbour, the clock, an
elaborator, a consumer, "the moon"). The Persona is never re-run. On
`ScopeChanged` the runner re-lowers once through the Interpreter with a
second input, the delta the subject perceived since its turn, rendered
from the scope components and the fan-out; the re-lowered proposal is an
ordinary `ExerciseDecision` bound to the fresh digest; one re-lowering
per subject per tick; no kernel arm changes. First invariant: the delta
shown to the Interpreter is exactly what the membrane already lets the
subject perceive, proven by a leakage test. Rejected on the way: a
joint-per-room Interpreter; the room is not the unit of interruption,
the digest is. This resolves former operator decision (a): a "bounded
in-tick re-submission" now has this shape and is no longer open.
In flight, plan step 9, the interruption pass (operator-approved
2026-09-05): Hands is cutting in the worktree
`F:\Projects\Ghostlight-interrupt` on `hands/interruption`, branched from
`a7c9b8e`, first commit `79f5a64` "Interrupt the narrative turn instead
of losing it" with further uncommitted edits in `world/controllers.rs`.
The spec is the session-scratchpad `imagination-interruption.md` (with
`modeling-interruption.md` and `interruption_tests.rs` beside it). Its
six forks, all taken: A delete the narrative lane's three scope checks
so the kernel is the sole `ScopeChanged` detector; B `SubjectSnapshot`
carries `components: ScopeComponents` and loses five duplicate fields;
C persist `Overheard { speaker, statement, confidence }`; D a fresh
opportunity without `speak` ends the turn `Interrupted`; E `NoProposal`
is re-lowered too; F the re-lowering uses the configured interpreter
model. Schema bumps: `controller_work.v11`, `persona_turn_receipt.v3`.
Shape, unchanged: the Persona is never re-run; on `ScopeChanged` the
runner re-lowers once through the Interpreter with the delta the subject
perceived since its turn, rendered from the scope components and the
fan-out; the result is an ordinary `ExerciseDecision` on the fresh
digest; one re-lowering per subject per tick; no kernel arm changes.
First invariant: the delta equals exactly what the membrane already lets
the subject perceive, proven by a leakage test. The ontology paragraph
(lines 695 to 704, `a7c9b8e`) scopes the promise to narrative subjects
in singleton cells; a grouped constituent has no Persona turn and no
Interpreter, so its refused proposal stays refused. Rejected on the way:
a joint-per-room Interpreter; the digest, not the room, is the unit.
This resolved former operator decision (a). Integration follows the
usual recipe: Soul in the worktree, fast-forward, focused test, push.
In design, plan step 10, witnessed events over a place subtree
(`e2392de`): the operator ruled that regional and global effects matter
(an asteroid over a region, the moon over a hemisphere) and that places
nest for exactly this. The answer is one operation, `Witness { fact,
place }`, landing `Witnessed` knowledge on every subject positioned
under the place subtree, recipients derived at apply time from live
positions exactly as speech `fan_out` derives its audience, never
stored, naming no speaker. Cut line from the plan: no second fan-out
owner, no stored recipient list, the subtree walk reuses the one
covering predicate, the tool surface and exemplar lists grow by exactly
one, confinement treats the place like any other ground. It lands as its
own small pass behind the interruption cut, because every witness's
scope digest moves and that is what makes a global event interrupt
whoever was mid-thought. Modeling is mapping into the session-scratchpad
`modeling-witness.md` (not on disk yet at the time of writing). Two
source facts the steward checked that the design can lean on:
`KnowledgeSource` (`patch.rs:371`) already has `Witnessed` beside
`Told { by, via }` and `Evidenced`, and `AuthoredSource::Witnessed`
(`patch.rs:393`) already lowers to it (`mod.rs:2494`), so `Witness` adds
no source variant; `ScopeComponents` (`mod.rs:2958`) carries position,
routes, holdings, dependencies, authority, delegated grants, and
knowledge keys, and no actor field, so a digest change is always noticed
and its cause is perceivable only when a `Told { by }` landed. That is
the ruling the coordinator gave the operator, "anonymous means the cause
is not perceivable, not that the change is not noticed", and it holds
against the map.
Constraint: no road run is possible until a provider is available again.
The Codex subscription lapsed mid-build and the twelve seeded runs
@ -362,7 +398,7 @@ are teardown evidence. Plan step 6 is ten implementation passes, all landed.
ports until then; the connector is stopped and the smoke substrate at
`F:\Projects\Ghostlight-smoke` stays.
Next seams after the interruption pass: the outbound consumer response
Next seams after steps 9 and 10: the outbound consumer response
batch with the non-loopback CultMesh lease; then the deployment gate
below. The elaborator swarm's ideas still sit on
`slot/<world>/<title>/<stamp>` branches and the four ledger directories;

File diff suppressed because one or more lines are too long

View file

@ -2,14 +2,13 @@
## Current Subgoal
Interruption pass (plan step 9, operator-approved 2026-09-05). Pipeline:
Modeling (`modeling-interruption.md` in the session scratchpad) -> Imagination
-> Hands in an isolation worktree -> Soul in that tree -> integrate onto
`codex/ghostlight-dungeon-mvp`. Nothing edited yet at `bcfd024` beyond the
plan line. Shape: no Persona re-run; one Interpreter re-lowering per subject
per tick on `ScopeChanged`, fed the perceived delta; ordinary
`ExerciseDecision` on the fresh digest; no kernel arm changes. No road run
until a provider is available again.
Two slices. (1) Plan step 9, interruption: Hands in
`F:\Projects\Ghostlight-interrupt` on `hands/interruption` from `a7c9b8e`
(`79f5a64` plus uncommitted `controllers.rs`), spec
`imagination-interruption.md`; then Soul in that tree, integrate. (2) Plan
step 10, `Witness { fact, place }` over a place subtree: in design, Modeling
into `modeling-witness.md`, then Imagination, Hands, Soul, integrate, behind
step 9. Main tip `e2392de`. No road run until a provider is available.
## Working Notes