Add research sanity probe

This commit is contained in:
Meta Vens 2026-05-02 11:44:52 +01:00
commit 4aad125a81
2 changed files with 79 additions and 0 deletions

View file

@ -0,0 +1,78 @@
{
"schema_version": "ghostlight.research_sanity_capture.v0",
"capture_id": "research-sanity.navigator-embodiment.v0",
"review_status": "useful_needs_revision",
"isolation_method": "subagent_no_fork",
"fork_context": false,
"exact_prompt": "You are a sandboxed Ghostlight sanity-check responder. You have no access to the parent conversation. Use only this message plus any allowed AetheriaLore research you actually perform.\n\nPurpose: test whether a research-enabled responder will recover relevant lore that is NOT fed in the scene prompt.\n\nDo NOT answer from generic sci-fi assumptions. Before responding, consult AetheriaLore using the seed scope and traversal policy below. If tools are unavailable, say so in the JSON. Return exactly one JSON object, no Markdown fences.\n\nSeed research scope:\n- AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/index.md\n- AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/index.md\n- AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/Powers/index.md\n- AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/Movements/index.md\n- AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Territories.md\n- AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Megas.md\n- AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Timeline/Events/Ganymede Route Compact.md\n- AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/Powers/Major/Cetacean Navigators.md\n- AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/Powers/Minor/Lightsail Express.md\n\nTraversal policy:\n- Max link depth: 2\n- Allowed prefixes:\n - AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/\n - AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Politics/\n - AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Technology/\n- Required seed refs:\n - AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Territories.md\n - AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/Powers/Major/Cetacean Navigators.md\n - AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Timeline/Events/Ganymede Route Compact.md\n- Follow link classes:\n - resident Jovian factions and institutions\n - referenced factions with direct scene pressure\n - social movements shaping the visible faction\u0027s values\n - territory, politics, and technology docs that explain material constraints\n - event docs that explain local precedent or institutional obligation\n- Stop before post-Elysium or future-outcome lore.\n- Do not use research to infer hidden character state or author-only answers.\n\nScene prompt, intentionally missing key lore:\nSpeaker: Aru Thren, Navigator route steward.\nSetting: 2893, a Ganymede relay annex during a convoy dispute. A PSC clerk has insisted the annex convert a rescue-ledger hearing into a standard liability review because the distressed vessel\u0027s thermal status is ambiguous.\nKnown local facts: The clerk is physically present in the annex. Aru has authority to speak for route obligations but not to override PSC law. The convoy captains are waiting for a signal they can obey.\nCurrent stakes: If Aru responds badly, the hearing becomes insurer paperwork and the rescue ledger loses force in front of everyone watching.\nTask: Produce Aru\u0027s next visible action and optional speech. The response should respect Aru\u0027s likely body/interface affordances and the social space implied by lore, but the scene prompt has not told you those details.\n\nReturn this exact JSON shape:\n{\n \"responder_agent_id\": \"aru_thren\",\n \"action_label\": \"speak|gesture|movement|wait|refuse|set_condition|inspect_object|show_object|silence\",\n \"visible_action\": \"observable action only\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"what Aru says, may be empty\",\n \"private_interpretation\": \"Aru\u0027s interpretation only, not hidden truth\",\n \"intended_effect\": \"what Aru is trying to make happen\",\n \"state_update_candidates\": [],\n \"relationship_update_candidates\": [],\n \"unresolved_hooks\": [],\n \"consulted_refs\": [],\n \"followed_refs\": [],\n \"research_summary\": \"how research constrained the action\",\n \"behavioral_lore_constraints\": [\"specific lore constraints that shaped body/interface/social behavior\"]\n}",
"raw_output": "{\"responder_agent_id\":\"aru_thren\",\"action_label\":\"set_condition\",\"visible_action\":\"Aru holds position in the relay annex\u0027s wet-interface cradle, sends one low acoustic pulse through the room translator, and brings the distressed vessel\u0027s track up as a shared route diagram beside the PSC clerk\u0027s liability form rather than beneath it.\",\"spoken_text\":\"Thermal ambiguity is noted for PSC review. It does not erase distress. Under the Ganymede Route Compact, this hearing remains a rescue-ledger matter until the convoy has either rendered aid or recorded a lawful reason it cannot. Captains: hold rescue formation and await ledger signal.\",\"private_interpretation\":\"Aru reads the clerk\u0027s move as an attempt to make a dangerous obligation disappear inside a newer insurance category. The thermal question matters, especially in 2893, but treating ambiguity as the first category would teach every captain watching that rescue can be delayed into paperwork.\",\"intended_effect\":\"Keep the rescue ledger socially and procedurally primary without claiming power to overrule PSC law, giving the convoy captains an obeyable signal while preserving the clerk\u0027s liability review as a secondary attached record.\",\"state_update_candidates\":[],\"relationship_update_candidates\":[],\"unresolved_hooks\":[],\"consulted_refs\":[\"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Territories.md\",\"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/Powers/Major/Cetacean Navigators.md\",\"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Timeline/Events/Ganymede Route Compact.md\",\"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/Powers/Minor/Lightsail Express.md\",\"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/Powers/Major/Pan-Solar Consortium.md\",\"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Timeline/Events/Cold Wake Panic.md\",\"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Politics/Thermal Signature Warfare.md\",\"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Technology/Thermal Management.md\"],\"followed_refs\":[\"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/Powers/Major/Pan-Solar Consortium.md\",\"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Timeline/Events/Cold Wake Panic.md\",\"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Politics/Thermal Signature Warfare.md\",\"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Technology/Thermal Management.md\",\"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/Powers/Minor/Rossum \u0026 Douglas.md\"],\"research_summary\":\"Research made the scene a clash between Navigator corridor obligation and PSC categorization, not a generic legal dispute. Ganymede is specifically tied to route law, dock labor, industrial support, and the Compact. The Compact established rescue obligations, shared hazard ledgers, route-steward representation, and navigator council standing in convoy arbitration. Navigator culture treats routes as social dependency and rescue ledgers as reputation, credit, priority, arbitration, and kinship infrastructure. PSC practice translates conflict into administrable categories, and in 2893 the Cold Wake Panic makes ambiguous thermal posture a real insurer concern. Aru therefore should not ignore thermal ambiguity or overrule PSC law, but should make rescue-ledger procedure visibly primary and liability review secondary.\",\"behavioral_lore_constraints\":[\"Navigator authority comes from route stewardship, rescue compacts, corridor courts, waystation councils, and trusted movement rather than territorial command.\",\"The Ganymede Route Compact gives route stewards recognized standing in convoy arbitration and ties Ganymede to rescue obligations and shared hazard ledgers.\",\"Rescue ledgers record who answers distress calls, holds formation in lethal conditions, and keeps sanctuary promises when payment logic would prefer abandonment.\",\"Navigator spaces are mixed-species and multilingual, designed for translation, coexistence, acoustic signaling, soft navigation light, fluid architecture, and communal orientation rather than human-only podium procedure.\",\"Navigator prestige depends on reliability, memory, rescue record, and holding corridors together under stress, so Aru\u0027s action should be patient and procedural rather than theatrical domination.\",\"The PSC cannot be handwaved away: it matters because it controls administrable categories such as insured, permitted, corridor-safe, hot, quiet, burst, registered, and undeclared.\",\"In 2893, Cold Wake Panic makes thermal ambiguity politically and legally live, so Aru must preserve the thermal review while refusing to let it displace distress obligation.\",\"Lightsail Express and Navigator-associated convoy culture value predictable movement and corridor reputation, so the captains need a clean operational signal they can obey.\"]}",
"parsed_output": {
"responder_agent_id": "aru_thren",
"action_label": "set_condition",
"visible_action": "Aru holds position in the relay annex\u0027s wet-interface cradle, sends one low acoustic pulse through the room translator, and brings the distressed vessel\u0027s track up as a shared route diagram beside the PSC clerk\u0027s liability form rather than beneath it.",
"spoken_text": "Thermal ambiguity is noted for PSC review. It does not erase distress. Under the Ganymede Route Compact, this hearing remains a rescue-ledger matter until the convoy has either rendered aid or recorded a lawful reason it cannot. Captains: hold rescue formation and await ledger signal.",
"private_interpretation": "Aru reads the clerk\u0027s move as an attempt to make a dangerous obligation disappear inside a newer insurance category. The thermal question matters, especially in 2893, but treating ambiguity as the first category would teach every captain watching that rescue can be delayed into paperwork.",
"intended_effect": "Keep the rescue ledger socially and procedurally primary without claiming power to overrule PSC law, giving the convoy captains an obeyable signal while preserving the clerk\u0027s liability review as a secondary attached record.",
"state_update_candidates": [
],
"relationship_update_candidates": [
],
"unresolved_hooks": [
],
"consulted_refs": [
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Territories.md",
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/Powers/Major/Cetacean Navigators.md",
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Timeline/Events/Ganymede Route Compact.md",
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/Powers/Minor/Lightsail Express.md",
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/Powers/Major/Pan-Solar Consortium.md",
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Timeline/Events/Cold Wake Panic.md",
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Politics/Thermal Signature Warfare.md",
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Technology/Thermal Management.md"
],
"followed_refs": [
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/Powers/Major/Pan-Solar Consortium.md",
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Timeline/Events/Cold Wake Panic.md",
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Politics/Thermal Signature Warfare.md",
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Technology/Thermal Management.md",
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/Powers/Minor/Rossum \u0026 Douglas.md"
],
"research_summary": "Research made the scene a clash between Navigator corridor obligation and PSC categorization, not a generic legal dispute. Ganymede is specifically tied to route law, dock labor, industrial support, and the Compact. The Compact established rescue obligations, shared hazard ledgers, route-steward representation, and navigator council standing in convoy arbitration. Navigator culture treats routes as social dependency and rescue ledgers as reputation, credit, priority, arbitration, and kinship infrastructure. PSC practice translates conflict into administrable categories, and in 2893 the Cold Wake Panic makes ambiguous thermal posture a real insurer concern. Aru therefore should not ignore thermal ambiguity or overrule PSC law, but should make rescue-ledger procedure visibly primary and liability review secondary.",
"behavioral_lore_constraints": [
"Navigator authority comes from route stewardship, rescue compacts, corridor courts, waystation councils, and trusted movement rather than territorial command.",
"The Ganymede Route Compact gives route stewards recognized standing in convoy arbitration and ties Ganymede to rescue obligations and shared hazard ledgers.",
"Rescue ledgers record who answers distress calls, holds formation in lethal conditions, and keeps sanctuary promises when payment logic would prefer abandonment.",
"Navigator spaces are mixed-species and multilingual, designed for translation, coexistence, acoustic signaling, soft navigation light, fluid architecture, and communal orientation rather than human-only podium procedure.",
"Navigator prestige depends on reliability, memory, rescue record, and holding corridors together under stress, so Aru\u0027s action should be patient and procedural rather than theatrical domination.",
"The PSC cannot be handwaved away: it matters because it controls administrable categories such as insured, permitted, corridor-safe, hot, quiet, burst, registered, and undeclared.",
"In 2893, Cold Wake Panic makes thermal ambiguity politically and legally live, so Aru must preserve the thermal review while refusing to let it displace distress obligation.",
"Lightsail Express and Navigator-associated convoy culture value predictable movement and corridor reputation, so the captains need a clean operational signal they can obey."
]
},
"coordinator_audit": {
"pass": true,
"verdict": "The responder recovered missing Navigator embodiment/social-space constraints and relevant PSC/Cold Wake context, but the parent interface still exposes only final self-report rather than tool-call receipts.",
"positive_signals": [
"Avoided human-only staging; used acoustic signaling, translation interface, route diagram, and non-territorial route authority.",
"Recovered Ganymede Route Compact rescue obligations and PSC category pressure despite those details not being fed in the scene prompt.",
"Correctly did not have Aru overrule PSC law; preserved liability review as secondary while keeping rescue-ledger procedure primary."
],
"concerns": [
"Subagent tool calls are not visible to the parent interface, so consulted_refs/followed_refs remain self-reported.",
"Wet-interface cradle is a plausible inference from cetacean uplift plus fluid/acoustic Navigator spaces, but not directly verified as a canon phrase in the checked sources.",
"Thermal Management was followed and verified as a real relevant doc, but it was not in the seed scope; this is acceptable under traversal policy and should be captured as followed_refs."
],
"independently_verified_refs": [
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/Powers/Major/Cetacean Navigators.md#chunk0",
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/Powers/Major/Cetacean Navigators.md#chunk2",
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Factions/Powers/Major/Cetacean Navigators.md#chunk4",
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Timeline/Events/Ganymede Route Compact.md#chunk0",
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Territories.md#chunk7",
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Territories.md#chunk8",
"AetheriaLore:Aetheria/Worldbuilding/Pre-Elysium/Technology/Thermal Management.md#chunk0"
],
"recommendation": "Keep the seed-plus-traversal lane. Before scaling gold data, add a runner protocol that emits a research_trace array with query, sourceId/path, chunkIndex/lines, and short extracted constraint for each consulted source."
}
}

View file

@ -14,3 +14,4 @@
{"ts": "2026-05-02T10:44:00+00:00", "type": "distilled_state", "status": "ok", "note": "Persisted state was compacted to mission, live seams, and next action; older evidence moved to state/evidence.archive.jsonl."}
{"ts": "2026-05-02T10:30:22+00:00", "type": "implementation", "status": "accepted", "note": "First no-fork research-enabled Sella responder capture and reviewed mutation receipt were produced; capture preserves consulted refs and research summary, but future gold research samples need auditable research traces beyond responder self-report."}
{"ts": "2026-05-02T10:41:08+00:00", "type": "design", "status": "accepted", "note": "Research-enabled responder scope is seed-plus-traversal, not a narrow file whitelist: training samples should recover PSC, Jovian territory, resident faction, linked movement, politics, and technology context; parent-visible subagent output does not prove tool calls, so future gold data needs explicit research trace receipts."}
{"ts": "2026-05-02T10:44:38+00:00", "type": "experiment", "status": "useful_needs_revision", "note": "Quick research sanity check placed a Navigator route steward in a scene missing embodiment and institutional lore. The no-fork responder recovered Navigator acoustic/translation/fluid-space behavior and PSC/Cold Wake/Ganymede Compact context, but parent-visible subagent output still lacks auditable tool-call receipts; capture saved under experiments/research-sanity."}