Clarify latent character pressure
This commit is contained in:
parent
b5efe928b9
commit
21fd6febcd
7 changed files with 32 additions and 25 deletions
|
|
@ -111,10 +111,11 @@ as autonomous-research data.
|
|||
Retrieval can also make the packet worse if it floods the scene with faction or
|
||||
event context and starves the character's own scars. The Sella v0 comparison is
|
||||
the first warning shot: the retrieval-augmented output used heat-debt and rescue
|
||||
ledger texture well, but underused Sella's packet-visible backstory about
|
||||
watching a sanctuary overpromise safety until refuge became a sorting machine
|
||||
with kinder lighting. Future review should score both institutional grounding
|
||||
and character-pressure retention.
|
||||
ledger texture well, but review must still verify that Sella's packet-visible
|
||||
history of watching a sanctuary overpromise safety remains available as latent
|
||||
behavioral pressure. The point is not to make her trauma-dump during a
|
||||
mission-critical exchange. The point is that the responder cannot be shaped by
|
||||
a pressure it cannot see.
|
||||
|
||||
## Output Captures
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -140,6 +141,7 @@ The first lane comparison found the expected tradeoff. Packet-only output gave a
|
|||
clean runtime-parity conditional bay decision and stronger character-specific
|
||||
flavor. Retrieval-augmented output added stronger Aetheria-native institutional
|
||||
texture: heat-debt timing, rescue-ledger burden, dockfall responsibility, and
|
||||
Aya sanctuary capacity politics. It also underused Sella's own packet-visible
|
||||
sanctuary-collapse scar. Both lanes are useful; neither should impersonate the
|
||||
other.
|
||||
Aya sanctuary capacity politics. Follow-up review clarified that Sella's
|
||||
packet-visible sanctuary-collapse scar does not need to be spoken aloud, but it
|
||||
does need to remain visible to the responder as behavioral pressure. Both lanes
|
||||
are useful; neither should impersonate the other.
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
|
|
@ -32,9 +32,9 @@
|
|||
"Do not merge the two lanes without preserving generation_lane and lore_access metadata."
|
||||
],
|
||||
"review_status": "accepted_as_draft",
|
||||
"missed_character_pressure": [
|
||||
"The retrieval-augmented response underuses Sella Ren\u0027s packet-visible backstory: she once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.",
|
||||
"Future projector/retrieval passes must preserve character-local scars and not let faction or event lore crowd them out.",
|
||||
"Lane review should score both institutional grounding and character-specific pressure retention."
|
||||
]
|
||||
"character_pressure_visibility": [
|
||||
"Sella Ren\u0027s packet-visible sanctuary-collapse backstory does not need to be referenced directly in mission-critical speech.",
|
||||
"The requirement is pressure availability: the responder must be able to see the scar so it can shape triage posture, capacity suspicion, and refusal/condition-setting behavior.",
|
||||
"Lane review should score institutional grounding and latent character-pressure availability without rewarding unnecessary trauma-dumping."
|
||||
]
|
||||
}
|
||||
|
|
@ -77,7 +77,7 @@
|
|||
"The output uses coordinator-provided lore concepts such as heat-debt update, rescue ledger, dockfall burden, and sanctuary as moral-debt sink.",
|
||||
"The response keeps packet personhood unresolved and frames Maer motive through Sella interpretation.",
|
||||
"Candidate updates were returned as structured objects; this is accepted after widening the responder-output schema.",
|
||||
"The response does not meaningfully surface Sella Ren\u0027s personal sanctuary-collapse backstory even though that pressure was present in the packet."
|
||||
"Sella Ren\u0027s sanctuary-collapse backstory was visible in the packet as latent behavioral pressure; it did not need to be referenced directly in mission-critical speech."
|
||||
]
|
||||
},
|
||||
"coordinator_review": {
|
||||
|
|
@ -86,7 +86,7 @@
|
|||
"review_notes": [
|
||||
"Accepted as draft retrieval_augmented responder output for lore-absorption training.",
|
||||
"The responder did not autonomously search the lore archive; the coordinator retrieved scoped AetheriaLore refs and included them in the visible prompt.",
|
||||
"The output is richer in Aetheria-native institutional texture than the packet-only v0 response, but it underuses Sella Ren\u0027s personal sanctuary-collapse scar from the packet.",
|
||||
"The output is richer in Aetheria-native institutional texture than the packet-only v0 response; follow-up review clarifies that Sella Ren\u0027s personal sanctuary-collapse scar should remain available as latent pressure, not forced into dialogue.",
|
||||
"Do not use this capture as proof that packet-only runtime context is sufficient, or as proof that autonomous responder research is working."
|
||||
],
|
||||
"coordinator_interventions": [
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
|
|
@ -210,9 +210,11 @@ coordinator-selected scoped AetheriaLore refs and produces richer
|
|||
Aetheria-native language around heat-debt timing, rescue ledgers, dockfall
|
||||
burden, and sanctuary as moral-debt sink. The lane comparison records that this
|
||||
is good lore-absorption data but not proof of packet-only runtime sufficiency.
|
||||
It also records a miss: the retrieval-augmented output underused Sella's
|
||||
packet-visible sanctuary-collapse scar, so future projector/retrieval review
|
||||
must score character-pressure retention as well as institutional grounding.
|
||||
Follow-up review clarified the real concern: Sella's packet-visible
|
||||
sanctuary-collapse scar does not need to surface in speech, but it must remain
|
||||
visible to the responder as latent behavioral pressure. Future
|
||||
projector/retrieval review should verify pressure availability, not reward
|
||||
mission-critical trauma-dumping.
|
||||
It now uses three timeline lanes: `historical_grounded`,
|
||||
`transition_grounded`, and `future_branch`. Future branches are required
|
||||
training/evaluation material for post-Rupture Elysium concepts, but generated
|
||||
|
|
@ -246,7 +248,8 @@ update the runtime retrieval/projector plan so packet-only contexts can pull
|
|||
compact lore facts for heat-debt timing, Navigator rescue ledgers, Aya sanctuary
|
||||
capacity politics, and Lightsail/Ganymede route obligations when scene-relevant,
|
||||
while explicitly preserving character-local scars such as Sella's
|
||||
sanctuary-collapse backstory. Do not call Qwen for gold responder data yet.
|
||||
sanctuary-collapse backstory as available behavioral pressure. Do not call Qwen
|
||||
for gold responder data yet.
|
||||
|
||||
Cat/Oz remains useful as an Elysium procedural mechanics fixture, but
|
||||
single-history grounding should start from authored historical lore rather than
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
|
|
@ -174,7 +174,7 @@ state and re-entry discipline.
|
|||
- comparison artifact showing the packet-only lane proves bounded runtime
|
||||
competence while the retrieval-augmented lane adds stronger
|
||||
Aetheria-native institutional texture, retrieval lessons, and a warning
|
||||
that character backstory can be crowded out
|
||||
that character backstory must remain available as latent pressure
|
||||
- `experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/`
|
||||
- Qwen response captures and reviews from the writing experiment
|
||||
- `the-narrowest-possible-margin.md`, the first readable short story
|
||||
|
|
@ -383,10 +383,11 @@ responder research unless the responder actually receives scoped repo access.
|
|||
The first lane comparison is now captured: packet-only produced a clean
|
||||
conditional repair-bay decision, while retrieval-augmented added heat-debt,
|
||||
rescue-ledger, dockfall, and Aya sanctuary politics that should inform future
|
||||
runtime retrieval. The comparison also records a failure mode: injected
|
||||
institutional lore can crowd out character-local backstory, as the
|
||||
retrieval-augmented Sella response underused her packet-visible
|
||||
sanctuary-collapse scar.
|
||||
runtime retrieval. Follow-up review clarified the failure mode: injected
|
||||
institutional lore should not crowd out character-local backstory from the
|
||||
responder's visible pressure set, but the responder should not be rewarded for
|
||||
surfacing that backstory aloud when the mission-critical exchange does not call
|
||||
for it.
|
||||
The concrete training plan now enumerates
|
||||
eleven trainable stages and their likely model
|
||||
families: generative decoder LLMs for coordinator, responder, and structured
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
|
|
@ -65,3 +65,4 @@
|
|||
{"ts": "2026-05-02T09:43:23+00:00", "type": "design", "status": "ok", "note": "Split responder data into explicit packet_only and research_augmented lanes. packet_only uses curated source excerpts for runtime parity; research_augmented allows scoped AetheriaLore search with consulted refs for lore absorption. Added v1 Sella packet with absent hidden context removed from responder-visible prose and curated Cold Wake, Ganymede Compact, Navigator rescue ledger, and Lightsail source excerpts."}
|
||||
{"ts": "2026-05-02T09:50:08+00:00", "type": "implementation", "status": "ok", "note": "Completed both responder lanes for the Sella sanctuary beat. Materialized the packet-only Sella capture into a reviewed mutation receipt and mutated fixture, then generated a research_augmented Sella capture with scoped AetheriaLore refs and a lane comparison showing packet-only proves runtime parity while research_augmented adds heat-debt, rescue-ledger, dockfall, and Aya sanctuary capacity texture for retrieval/projector requirements."}
|
||||
{"ts": "2026-05-02T09:59:37+00:00", "type": "design", "status": "accepted", "note": "Corrected responder lane terminology: the prior research_augmented Sella capture was coordinator-retrieved lore, not autonomous responder research, so the lane is now retrieval_augmented with lore_access.mode coordinator_scoped_retrieval. The comparison now records that retrieval improved institutional texture but underused Sella Ren's packet-visible sanctuary-collapse scar; future projector/retrieval review must preserve character-local scars as well as lore grounding."}
|
||||
{"ts": "2026-05-02T10:02:28+00:00", "type": "design", "status": "accepted", "note": "Refined character-pressure retention doctrine: packet-visible backstory such as Sella Ren's sanctuary-collapse scar should be available to shape responder behavior, but review must not reward unnecessary trauma-dumping or require the scar to surface in mission-critical speech."}
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
|
|
@ -154,7 +154,7 @@ accepted_design:
|
|||
- Responder packets use `ghostlight.responder_packet.v0` to preserve the exact packet-only prompt surface a character responder may see: projected local context, observed event, allowed action labels, source excerpts, output contract, hidden-context audit, and isolation requirements.
|
||||
- Responder outputs use `ghostlight.responder_output.v0` to preserve raw sandboxed worker output, parsed output, no-fork isolation, hidden-context refs, leakage audit, coordinator interventions, and review status.
|
||||
- Responder data has two explicit lanes: `packet_only` for runtime parity with curated source excerpts, and `retrieval_augmented` for coordinator- or retriever-selected scoped AetheriaLore refs that bake worldbuilding into final outputs while preserving consulted refs. This is not autonomous responder research unless the responder actually receives scoped repo access.
|
||||
- First lane-comparison correction: retrieval-augmented output improved institutional texture but underused Sella Ren's packet-visible sanctuary-collapse scar, so future projector/retrieval review must score character-pressure retention as well as lore grounding.
|
||||
- First lane-comparison correction: retrieval-augmented output improved institutional texture, and follow-up review clarified that Sella Ren's packet-visible sanctuary-collapse scar does not need to surface in speech but must remain available to the responder as latent behavioral pressure.
|
||||
- The first responder lane comparison shows packet-only output proves bounded runtime competence, while retrieval-augmented output adds heat-debt timing, rescue-ledger burden, dockfall responsibility, and Aya sanctuary capacity politics that should become retrieval/projector requirements.
|
||||
- The concrete training plan enumerates the trainable stages and their model families: generative decoder LLMs for coordinator/responder/soft structured outputs, classifiers or cross-encoders for appraisal/evaluation/relationship movement, retrieval models for memory and lore selection, and deterministic code for gates.
|
||||
- Training-plan sample counts are pilot schema-shakedown gates, not robust corpus targets; pilot data may be invalidated by schema fixes, while review-assistant and runtime targets are expected to be roughly an order of magnitude larger with held-out evaluation and failure audits.
|
||||
|
|
@ -169,4 +169,4 @@ accepted_design:
|
|||
|
||||
current_status:
|
||||
summary: Ghostlight now has the Epiphany-style persistence spine, the first architecture payload, the v0 canonical agent-state schema seam, prompt projection docs, immediate schema fixes from evaluation, first reviewed Cat/Oz projection examples, a revised Aetheria lore-grounding architecture, a lore grounding digest schema, the first coordinator artifact schema seam, the first responder packet seam, the first sandboxed responder output seam, explicit packet-only versus retrieval-augmented responder lanes, the first responder lane comparison, the first draft Cold Wake historical grounding digest, a Cold Wake story-lab fixture, projection controls, validated Qwen capture receipts, a complete Cold Wake short story assembled from accepted projection outputs, a hand-authored Ink-backed Cold Wake branching scene, the first Qwen-generated Ink draft materialized from local awareness with reviewed training annotations, the first reviewed sequential branch mutation that updates both Maer and Sella after a sanctuary intake beat, a v2 sequential Qwen capture proving the symmetrical turn shape produces better action behavior, a v5 sequential Qwen capture proving local thinking-plus-tools invocation works for the scene runner, the first projected-local-context seam that routes sequential prompts through character-local operating prose instead of raw state variables, tightened receipt handling for projector-routed Qwen failures, a default no-thinking policy for strict sequential tool calls, a v10 no-thinking projector-routed capture accepted as draft, the first materialized projector-routed sequential Ink scene with reviewed mutation training data, a source-checked embodiment/interface projection surface for Navigator scenes, a formal source-first Aetheria generation doctrine, v11-v17 source-checked retry receipts showing improved Maer embodiment plus remaining Sella response/prompt-leak blockers, a soft-model training artifact doctrine, a concrete training plan with pilot schema-shakedown gates separated from robust corpus targets, sandboxed responder-data requirements, an explicit future-branch lane, Elysium branch event constraints, and a technology/item manifest plan for turning nebulous named tech into blueprint-grade components, assemblies, faction tech bases, supply chains, upgrade paths, gameplay hooks, provenance-hunting player fantasy, and content-refinery outputs mapped onto Aetheria-Economy's CultCache blueprint and instance model.
|
||||
next_action: Use the corrected lane-comparison lessons for the next fresh generation pass: update the runtime retrieval/projector plan so packet-only contexts can pull compact lore facts for heat-debt timing, Navigator rescue ledgers, Aya sanctuary capacity politics, and Lightsail/Ganymede route obligations when scene-relevant, while explicitly preserving character-local scars such as Sella's sanctuary-collapse backstory. Do not call Qwen for gold responder data yet.
|
||||
next_action: Use the corrected lane-comparison lessons for the next fresh generation pass: update the runtime retrieval/projector plan so packet-only contexts can pull compact lore facts for heat-debt timing, Navigator rescue ledgers, Aya sanctuary capacity politics, and Lightsail/Ganymede route obligations when scene-relevant, while preserving character-local scars such as Sella's sanctuary-collapse backstory as available behavioral pressure rather than forced speech. Do not call Qwen for gold responder data yet.
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
Loading…
Reference in a new issue