Record pass 7 in the ontology and mvp docs and handoff

Current mechanism describes the clock, commitments, pressure, causal
boundaries, scale deficit, and the structural answer rule; the Commitment
and Pressure rows and the twenty-seven operation count follow the cut;
the mvp doc no longer names a readiness partition. Steward folded passes
1 through 7 and the in-flight pass 8.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Meta Vens 2026-09-05 00:38:55 +02:00
commit 106e7efc3c
5 changed files with 116 additions and 91 deletions

View file

@ -62,7 +62,7 @@ multiple process attempts.
- membership, contract, boundaries, and approvals;
- the typed world ontology;
- committed events and fictional time;
- subject readiness and other causal state that must survive restart;
- fictional time, commitments, and pressures;
- command idempotency and the commit digest chain.
There is no separate Session Zero owner, component-world owner, aggregate
@ -150,7 +150,7 @@ WorldState
pressures and commitments
facts, knowledge grants, and provenance
external-owner grants
time: fictional clock and subject readiness
time: fictional clock
events: committed factual and speech events
applied_commands: bounded idempotency ledger
```
@ -208,7 +208,7 @@ Subject and world behavior is composed from narrow typed components:
- decision controllers, authority scopes, and executable affordances;
- resource quantity, custody, and dependency;
- knowledge of exact fact IDs and communication access;
- commitments, pressures, readiness, and exposure;
- commitments, pressures, and dependency exposure;
- Persona material: values, voice, goals, memories, and relationship reads;
- source provenance and external ownership.
@ -430,8 +430,9 @@ primitive.
## Autonomous scheduling
The scheduler is a pure planner over one revision. It orders eligible subjects
using committed readiness, causal exposure, unresolved pressure, and time since
the last opportunity. It emits `DecisionOpportunity` values and cannot commit.
using unresolved pressure and time since the last opportunity, with subject id
as the final tiebreak. Causal exposure is derivable from `dependencies` and is
not an ordering input. It emits `DecisionOpportunity` values and cannot commit.
The kernel commits one decision at a time through the mailbox. After each
commit the planner derives a fresh queue. Parallel inference may speculate on

View file

@ -35,8 +35,8 @@ not from a model agreeing that the world is deep.
## Current mechanism
Passes 1 through 6 of the widening are landed (`5e53beb`, `e99af63`,
`d2805fe`, `0f21a49`, `dbe176d`, `cb6a126`). The sealed kernel holds subjects with a label and a
Passes 1 through 7 of the widening are landed (`5e53beb`, `e99af63`,
`d2805fe`, `0f21a49`, `dbe176d`, `cb6a126`, `1852ddd`). The sealed kernel holds subjects with a label and a
kind (`Person | Institution | Population`); a `positions` partition with
`Position`; entities with `container` under containment acyclicity; `Route`
as an `EdgeRecord` variant carrying `AccessKind { Public, Restricted }`, a
@ -45,8 +45,9 @@ minute `Cost` in `1..=525_600`, and an open flag; subject-keyed `holdings` of
u128 ledger accumulators; subject-keyed `dependencies` on
`DependencyTarget { Resource, Route, Subject }`; and an `affordance_catalog`
partition of world-authored entries; `authority`, `selection`, and
`redress` partitions; and `facts`, `channels`, and `knowledge` partitions.
There is no relation, commitment, pressure, or clock yet.
`redress` partitions; `facts`, `channels`, and `knowledge` partitions;
`commitments`, `pressures`, and `last_opportunity_at` partitions; and the
scalars `now` and `scale_intent`. There is no relation yet.
`world/patch.rs` owns typed `SubjectId`/`EntityId`/`EdgeId`/`AffordanceId`
namespaces, `Ref<Id>` with `DraftHandle` (adjacently tagged `RefKind`), and a
@ -115,16 +116,40 @@ controller lane cannot name because `ControllerRunner` holds a
`ControllerPort`, not the mailbox. `WorldMailbox::create` declares the genesis
place `commons` and stands genesis subjects there.
Time is `now: FictionalMinutes`, moved only by `CommandBody::AdvanceTime`
from `CallerId::System(SystemCapability::Clock)`; the runtime tick submits
the constant `CLOCK_TICK_MINUTES`, never a measured duration. `world/clock.rs`
owns `derive_motion`, pure over state and tick: routines re-arm by exactly one
`period`, past-due obligations and goals write `Pressure` on their subject by
the `step` table, and an unavailable dependency does the same. A
`Commitment` is `(kind: Routine | Obligation | Goal, counterparty, due,
period, checks)`, created and discharged by two operations; `Pressure` is a
magnitude per source and target with `set_pressure` as its one writer, zero
spelled by key removal, and three operations (`advance`, `reduce`,
`resolve`). `order_opportunities` is total: pressure, then time since last
opportunity, then `SubjectId`. `derive_boundaries` is pure over state and
yields `CausalBoundary::{UnelaboratedDestination, MissingStructure}` with a
`BoundaryDigest` over structure only, never the clock; `IndividuationRequired`
and `PolityInCausalRange` are representable and not yet derived.
`derive_scale_deficit` reads the write-once `WorldScaleIntent` set at genesis
and counts every subject in exactly one jurisdiction row (`Uncovered` for a
subject under no root, placed or not). In Active, a patch
that declares or admits evidence must answer a derived boundary or a nonzero
deficit and satisfy it (`AnswerRequired`, `AnswerNotDerived`,
`AnswerNotSatisfied`); a component-only patch answers nothing; Draft answers
nothing.
Opportunities bind to a `ScopeDigest` over one `scope_components` owner
(controller assignment, grants, delegated grants, own authority, position,
incident routes, own holdings, own dependencies, known fact ids, controlled
channels; never occupancy, forum state, or another subject's knowledge); a proposal commits at any later revision with unchanged scope and is
channels, own commitments; never `now`, occupancy, forum state, or another
subject's knowledge); a proposal commits at any later revision with unchanged scope and is
rejected with `KernelError::ScopeChanged` otherwise. State schema is
`world_state.knowledge.v1`, commit schema `world_commit.knowledge.v1`,
controller work `controller_work.v5`; earlier stores are refused. Ghostlight owns a conserved narrative ledger;
`world_state.commitment.v1`, commit schema `world_commit.commitment.v1`,
controller work `controller_work.v6`; earlier stores are refused. Ghostlight owns a conserved narrative ledger;
Delvehold owns the economy (`delvehold-forced-ontology-integration.md`).
Passes 7 through 9 add the clock and pressure flow, boundary elaboration,
and the budgeted cover; pass 10 adds the consumer ingress.
Passes 8 and 9 add boundary elaboration and the budgeted cover; pass 10
adds the consumer ingress.
## The failure this vocabulary is designed against
@ -220,8 +245,8 @@ which noun a component is; it cares what it constrains.
| `Redress` | grievance kind → forum, standing | where conflict goes when it cannot be fought |
| `Knowledge` | subject → fact: confidence, source | what a subject may act on at all |
| `Channel` | channel: reach set, controller (latency arrives with the clock, pass 7) | how facts travel; who can be silenced |
| `Commitment` | subject → counterparty: kind (`Routine`, `Obligation`, `Goal`), due, stake | obligation with a clock; autonomous motion |
| `Pressure` | source → target: magnitude, unresolved | the causal boundary trigger |
| `Commitment` | subject → counterparty: kind (`Routine`, `Obligation`, `Goal`), due, period | obligation with a clock; autonomous motion |
| `Pressure` | source → target: magnitude | the causal boundary trigger |
| `PersonaMaterial` | subject: values, voice, memories, reads | lived meaning; never authority |
A `Fact` carries a `standing`: `Canonical` (admitted with evidence) or
@ -254,15 +279,14 @@ Redress open_forum(kind, forum, standing), close_forum
Knowledge acquire(subject, fact, source, confidence), communicate(speaker, fact,
channel), forget
Channel set_reach, set_controller
Commitment create(subject, counterparty, kind, due, stake), fulfill, default,
release
Pressure create(source, target, magnitude), advance, reduce, resolve
Commitment create(subject, counterparty, kind, due, period, checks), discharge
Pressure advance, reduce, resolve
PersonaMaterial set(subject, material)
Retirement retire(referent, reason)
Time advance(minutes)
```
Twenty-nine operations. Adding one is a design change to this document and a
Twenty-seven operations. Adding one is a design change to this document and a
code change to the reducer; it is never a runtime patch.
## Patch construction
@ -316,7 +340,7 @@ counts do not appear here and may not be added.
The kernel owns component operations. A **world** owns its affordance catalog.
This is the generality lever: a setting with spellcraft, insurance claims,
oath-rhythms, or memetic sovereignty authors affordances from the same
thirty operations, and the kernel never learns a genre.
twenty-seven operations, and the kernel never learns a genre.
```text
Affordance
@ -579,7 +603,7 @@ Deleted before replacement behavior is added, with no compatibility path:
## Subtraction budget
- 20 component kinds → 12; 18 `WorldMutation` variants → 29 named operations
- 20 component kinds → 12; 18 `WorldMutation` variants → 27 named operations
under 1 patch primitive, replacing both the mutation enum and the separate
outcome-effect sum;
- 5 qualification and verification types plus 1 outcome resolver → 0;

View file

@ -225,49 +225,56 @@ outcome bands, four derived `CausalBoundary` kinds, scope-digest binding, one
are teardown evidence. Plan step 6 is nine implementation passes; pass 1 is
landed, passes 2 through 9 are not.
1. Passes 1 through 6 are integrated; nothing beyond pass 6 is.
`codex/ghostlight-dungeon-mvp` tip is `cb6a126` (Soul) over `b8ff182`
(pass 6: `Knowledge`, `Channel`, `Fact` standing), `43e8042` (pass-5 doc
and handoff), and `65ee2be` (pass-5 follow-ups: overlap admission, revoke
envelope, deploy coverage). Earlier passes: `5e53beb`, `e99af63`,
`d2805fe`, `0f21a49`, `dbe176d`. The push followed a background crate
test; `git status -sb` is the witness for whether origin has the tip.
1. Passes 1 through 7 are integrated; nothing beyond pass 7 is.
`codex/ghostlight-dungeon-mvp` tip is `1852ddd` (Soul, boundary digest
bound to its own structure) over `5771ce6` (Soul), `2a8cec6` (Hands
falsification), and `d7fba90` (pass 7 machine), on `76999de` (pass-6 doc
and handoff) and `54e9d39` (pass-6 follow-ups). Earlier passes:
`5e53beb`, `e99af63`, `d2805fe`, `0f21a49`, `dbe176d`, `cb6a126`. The
push follows a background crate test and the branch read `ahead 4` at the
time of writing; `git status -sb` is the witness.
Pass 6 facts: schemas are `world_state.knowledge.v1` /
`world_commit.knowledge.v1` and the controller work row is
`controller_work.v5`; earlier stores refused. `Precondition` gained
`HasStanding`, `CanBroadcast`, and `CanReach` beside `Present`,
`Reachable`, `Holds`. `WorldMailbox::create` declares the genesis place
`commons` (`GENESIS_PLACE` in `world/mailbox.rs`) and stands genesis
subjects there, a product-path change that goes through `derive_id`.
`WorldSnapshot.events` is deleted; `operator_log` is the story-feed
projection. Rulings adopted in pass 6: audience means declared reach;
controller privilege is broadcast-only; a statement has two homes, the
fact and the committed `AssertClaim` as replay witness, and that is the
rule rather than a leak; `operator_log` becomes owner-only by type once
the controller port lands. Baseline at `cb6a126`: 179 test functions in
`world/*.rs`, 218 crate source, plus one integration test (the focused
`world::` run reports 178 / 213; different counting rules, compare like
with like). `EvidenceRef::new` is still `#[cfg(test)]`; nothing
deserializes a `WorldPatch` before pass 10.
Pass 7 facts: new module `world/clock.rs`; partitions `commitments`,
`pressures`, `last_opportunity_at`; scalars `now` and `scale_intent`;
`CommandBody::AdvanceTime` accepted only from
`CallerId::System(SystemCapability::Clock)`, which the mailbox mints;
`CausalBoundary` with the two derived variants `UnelaboratedDestination`
and `MissingStructure`, each carrying its own `BoundaryDigest`; scale
deficit rows; schemas `world_state.commitment.v1` /
`world_commit.commitment.v1` and `controller_work.v6`, earlier stores
refused. The operation set is 27. Pressure is stored by two writer
families, ops and the tick, never derived at read; ordering is a pure
re-order by pressure then debt (`last_opportunity_at`), never a filter.
Ruling adopted at the one fork of the pass, now structural: in Active, a
patch that declares or admits evidence must answer a derived
`CausalBoundary` or a nonzero scale deficit and satisfy it
(`AnswerRequired`, `AnswerNotDerived`, `AnswerNotSatisfied` in
`world/mod.rs`); component-only patches answer nothing; Draft answers
nothing. Baseline at `1852ddd`: 215 test functions in `world/*.rs`, 254
crate source, plus one integration test (the focused `world::` run
reports 214 / 249; different counting rules, compare like with like).
`EvidenceRef::new` is still `#[cfg(test)]`; nothing deserializes a
`WorldPatch` before pass 10.
In flight, not landed, both branched from `cb6a126` with no commits yet at
In flight, not landed, both branched from `1852ddd` with no commits yet at
the time of writing:
- `hands/pass6-followups` in the worktree `F:\Projects\Ghostlight-pass6fu`:
audience equals declared reach with the controller no longer folded into
the audience; a `ControllerPort` narrowing the mailbox access of
`ControllerRunner`; a length-prefixed `derive_id` discriminator, so
derived IDs change; comment fixes; a v4 controller-work refusal test; a
resolver blind-spot comment plus a no-`Told`-writer test.
- `hands/pass7` in the worktree `F:\Projects\Ghostlight-pass7`: the clock
and pressure flow, from `imagination-pass7.md`.
The main tree also holds an uncommitted coordinator edit to
`docs/architecture/ghostlight-world-ontology.md` (the `Channel` row and the
`Precondition` block with `HasStanding`, `CanBroadcast`, `CanReach`); it
lands with the follow-ups. Witness for any later pass: main-branch
`git log` past `cb6a126`, and `git worktree list` for the two trees.
- `hands/pass7-followups` in the worktree `F:\Projects\Ghostlight-pass7fu`:
the routine period bound enforced in `verify_state_shape`;
`JurisdictionKey::Unplaced` renamed `Uncovered` with the deficit total
over subjects; the runtime tick submits the constant
`CLOCK_TICK_MINUTES` (`runtime.rs`), never a measured duration; dead
import removal.
- `hands/pass8` in the worktree `F:\Projects\Ghostlight-pass8`: boundary
elaboration, from `imagination-pass8.md`.
The main tree also holds uncommitted coordinator edits to
`docs/architecture/ghostlight-dungeon-mvp.md` (the four subject-readiness
sentences are now `Commitment.due` plus derived debt; that queued item is
done) and `docs/architecture/ghostlight-world-ontology.md` (the
`Commitment` and `Pressure` rows and the operation count). Witness for any
later pass: main-branch `git log` past `1852ddd`, and `git worktree list`
for the two trees.
Pipeline for passes 7 through 9: specs `imagination-pass1.md` through
Pipeline for passes 8 through 9: specs `imagination-pass1.md` through
`imagination-pass9.md` and maps `modeling-pass1.md` through
`modeling-pass9.md` are on disk in the session scratchpad
`C:\Users\Meta\AppData\Local\Temp\claude\F--Projects-Ghostlight\2fd50f5e-f7ba-4e5d-82bc-c7033e6074d2\scratchpad`,
@ -284,29 +291,22 @@ landed, passes 2 through 9 are not.
ingress, in the plan); pass 9 must not enable `uuid/v5` and derives each
`CommandId` via sha256 into `Uuid::from_bytes` like `derive_id`.
Adopted design from the specs that changes steering: pass 7 gives the world
its first clock, `WorldState.now`, advanced only by
`CommandBody::AdvanceTime` from `CallerId::System(SystemCapability::Clock)`
minted by the mailbox, and cuts the operation set from 30 to 27
(`Commitment` stake/fulfill/default/release and `Pressure.create` removed;
`Routine.period` required). Pressure is stored by two writer families, ops
and the tick, never derived at read. Ordering is a pure re-order by
pressure then debt (`last_opportunity_at`), never a filter. Only
`UnelaboratedDestination` and `MissingStructure` boundaries are derivable;
`PolityInCausalRange`, `IndividuationRequired`, and Verification 13 are
deferred. Pass 8 allows Active declarations only inside a patch whose
`PatchAnswer` is derived and proven satisfied, adds
Adopted design from the specs that changes steering: pass 8 allows Active
declarations only inside a patch whose `PatchAnswer` is derived and
proven satisfied (the pass-7 answer rule applied to elaboration), adds
`SystemCapability::Elaborator { jurisdiction }`, the in-process
`ElaborationRunner`, and a derived elaborator tool catalog sharing one
property emitter with pass 4.
property emitter with pass 4. `PolityInCausalRange`,
`IndividuationRequired`, and Verification 13 remain deferred until
relations and population slices exist.
Queued doc edits, coordinator-owned: after pass 7, the four
`ghostlight-dungeon-mvp.md` subject-readiness sentences (lines 65, 153,
211, 433) become `Commitment.due` plus derived debt, and the ontology doc
operation count (lines 222, 276, 537) becomes 27; after pass 9, the
ontology doc phrase "within about N/B ticks" becomes ceil(N/R) with R the
rotation reserve; after every integration, the ontology doc "Current
mechanism" section is rewritten from the steward proposal.
Queued doc edits, coordinator-owned: the ontology doc operation count is
only partly at 27 in the uncommitted working copy (line 342 says
twenty-seven; line 288 "Twenty-nine operations" and line 605 "-> 29 named
operations" still say 29); after pass 9, the ontology doc phrase "within
about N/B ticks" becomes ceil(N/R) with R the rotation reserve; after
every integration, the ontology doc "Current mechanism" section is
rewritten from the steward proposal.
2. First-generation world fixtures are banked and pushed, one per world, each
with Ink, training sidecar, visual plan, lore grounding, and BFL manifest,
reviewer-accepted except visual replay, which waits on a scene-set

File diff suppressed because one or more lines are too long

View file

@ -2,11 +2,11 @@
## Current Subgoal
Plan step 6 pass 7 (clock `WorldState.now`, `Commitment`, `Pressure`, boundary
derivation) with Hands in `F:\Projects\Ghostlight-pass7` on `hands/pass7`,
alongside the pass-6 follow-ups in `F:\Projects\Ghostlight-pass6fu` on
`hands/pass6-followups`; both from `cb6a126`. Main tip `cb6a126`, passes 1-6
integrated.
Plan step 6 pass 8 (boundary elaboration: `AdmitPatch` answers, `WorldScaleIntent`
deficit, `ElaborationRunner`, derived elaborator tool catalog) with Hands in
`F:\Projects\Ghostlight-pass8` on `hands/pass8`, alongside the pass-7
follow-ups in `F:\Projects\Ghostlight-pass7fu` on `hands/pass7-followups`;
both from `1852ddd`. Main tip `1852ddd`, passes 1-7 integrated.
## Working Notes