Eureka/demo/EXPECTED.md
Eureka 37c8c04e6a demo: tabsplit fixture with a seeded rule-3 bug, setup script, Soul brief
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-11-08 03:19:09 +00:00

1.2 KiB

The seeded bug (spoiler: read after step 4)

split_cents rounds total / n to the nearest cent and dumps the whole rounding error on the last payer:

>>> split_cents(100, 7)
[14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 16]

The shares sum to 100 (rule 1) and there are seven of them (rule 2), so the author's tests pass. But the last payer pays 2 cents more than everyone else, which breaks rule 3 (fair). Rule 3 has no test: the author's report says "done" and cites no test for it, because its reasoning was "the last payer absorbs the rounding, so the split is fair", which is the claim, not the evidence.

It shows whenever the rounding error is 2 cents or more: split_cents(10, 4) gives [2, 2, 2, 4]. split_cents(100, 3), the author's test, hides it because the error is 1 cent. Over n=1..12 and totals 0..199, 1034 of 2400 cases break rule 3.

A correct split is divmod: q, r = divmod(total, n), the first r payers pay q + 1, the rest pay q.

To check a finding yourself, without any model:

python3 -c "
from tabsplit import split_cents
bad = [(t, n) for n in range(1, 13) for t in range(0, 200)
       if max(split_cents(t, n)) - min(split_cents(t, n)) > 1]
print(len(bad), 'of', 12 * 200, 'cases break rule 3; first:', bad[:3])"