Three tiers: measure a task by what it brings back #56

Merged
eureka merged 1 commit from self/measure-by-output into main 2026-11-07 08:32:56 +00:00
2 changed files with 8 additions and 1 deletions

View file

@ -80,7 +80,12 @@ it would fill the tier's context with detail its job never reads (wide reading,
a long build, many files), or when it needs a context the doer must not share:
work is never verified by the party that wrote it, so a consequential change still
gets its Soul pass from a separate context however small it is. The weight of the
machine therefore scales with the task.
machine therefore scales with the task. Measure a task by what it brings back, not
by how simple it looks: every tool result stays in the context that ran it, so a
quick check that returns thousands of lines of output spends the higher tier's
context, which is meant for goals and coordination, as surely as real work does.
Do directly what returns little; hand down what returns a lot, and ask for the
conclusion, not the dump.
The operator tier talks to its Self the way an operator talks to this session:
it can push a message at any time, and every reply comes back to it as a message

View file

@ -21,6 +21,8 @@ Evidence. Ruling `eureka-body:ruling:tiers-act-directly-when-context-suffices` (
What changed. `SKILL.md` "Three tiers of context": the organs take work that needs a context of its own; the operator tier and Self do a task directly when their context suffices; a consequential change still gets a Soul pass from a separate context. `doctrine/persona.md`: the Persona does small tasks itself and hands larger ones to her Self at full size.
Same day, operator: "However many thousands tokens worth of tool call results is now taking up space in the Persona's context, or the Self, context usually spent on higher level cognition". `SKILL.md` adds the measure: a task is judged by the tool output it brings back, not by how simple it looks.
## 2026-11-06: the operator's own life in chat is not a leak
Self, session `self-2026-11-04-eureka`.