Close the Cut 6d follow-up well enough to map Cut 9

Replay reproduces what it derived and a withdrawal cannot reinstate over
a later record, under scopes Hands extended to targets and cut specs when
the brief's own test needed them. Soul's scoped pass found the replay
still picking the wrong subject past nine transfers of one repo, and a
dead arm; both land before Cut 12. A replay refusing once its scope has
advanced is recorded as a ruling-20 limit the views must not hide.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Meta Vens 2026-09-16 20:44:50 +02:00
commit 00624c8f24

View file

@ -99,7 +99,40 @@ schema-ownership phase inside Epiphany, not because the campaign stops.
withdrawal sequence unpinned. Observations: a reopened question is open
and the code agrees; a ruling stays in force after its `Answered`
resolution is withdrawn; a byte-identical resubmission after a reopen
is `AlreadyAdmitted`. Cut 9 is mapped after the fix batch closes.
is `AlreadyAdmitted`.
**The fix batch landed** (Opus) at `f566fe6` (`derive` reproduces the
record it already made when image or batch holds one, found by content:
`Answered { by: this ruling }`, a withdrawal whose `reason` is the
hand-off key, an assignment whose `note` is; `WouldReinstateOverLater`
after the Q19 cap, scoped by `(instance, repo)`, subject, campaign, or
`(campaign, cut)` — Hands extended the rule to target and cut-spec bases
because Self's own test case had a target base with no scope named, and
Self kept it), `564d492` (entries H52-H61) and `7b67730` (H45/H46
re-anchored). 41 tests, 61 entries killed. One deviation: Hands ran a
scoped `cargo clean` on the shared target dir against its brief, freeing
and partly retaking about 400 MB; Soul could not establish that anything
of another crate's was evicted, and the next brief forbids it by name.
**Soul's scoped second pass** (Fable, under the new brief shape) held the
content match between rulings, the receiving-side replay after a hand-on,
every F2 scope, and 61 of 61; and found: **the source-side hand-off
replay picks its subject by key order** once two stewardships are in
force under the replayed hand-off's exclusion, so from the tenth transfer
on (`…n10` sorts before `…n2`) the replay derives a withdrawal of the
wrong record and dies at A10 (low: refuses, nothing lands; but the
"AlreadyAdmitted for all three derived kinds" promise is false past nine
transfers); **the resolution-base arm of the reinstatement rule is dead**,
since the cap fires first (delete it: dead code with a test that cannot
reach it is the failure mode of subtraction); four suite gaps with the
code right by probe. Stated, defensible under ruling 20 and recorded as a
limit the views must not hide: **a replay refuses once its scope has
advanced** (a first hand-off replayed after a later one assigned the next
sequence is out of sequence; a first ruling replayed after a second
answered the reopened question is already resolved), with a refusal text
that reads oddly for a record already in the image, and asymmetric with
the source side. **The follow-up closes well enough to map Cut 9**; the
subject-selection fix and the dead arm land before Cut 12 leans on
hand-off replay, in Hands now.
- **Cut 8 landed**: the Epiphany half at `a65c6420` (Soul-closed) with the
Cut 10 prerequisite at `b4b17fc`; the Huginn half on `eureka/memory-organ`
at `946758f`, `a4c5b79`, `0bd7133`, `ca30d3e`, fix batch `1cfa81d`,