diff --git a/notes/eureka-pipeline-state-cut.md b/notes/eureka-pipeline-state-cut.md index adf799ea..57937fb6 100644 --- a/notes/eureka-pipeline-state-cut.md +++ b/notes/eureka-pipeline-state-cut.md @@ -99,7 +99,40 @@ schema-ownership phase inside Epiphany, not because the campaign stops. withdrawal sequence unpinned. Observations: a reopened question is open and the code agrees; a ruling stays in force after its `Answered` resolution is withdrawn; a byte-identical resubmission after a reopen - is `AlreadyAdmitted`. Cut 9 is mapped after the fix batch closes. + is `AlreadyAdmitted`. + + **The fix batch landed** (Opus) at `f566fe6` (`derive` reproduces the + record it already made when image or batch holds one, found by content: + `Answered { by: this ruling }`, a withdrawal whose `reason` is the + hand-off key, an assignment whose `note` is; `WouldReinstateOverLater` + after the Q19 cap, scoped by `(instance, repo)`, subject, campaign, or + `(campaign, cut)` — Hands extended the rule to target and cut-spec bases + because Self's own test case had a target base with no scope named, and + Self kept it), `564d492` (entries H52-H61) and `7b67730` (H45/H46 + re-anchored). 41 tests, 61 entries killed. One deviation: Hands ran a + scoped `cargo clean` on the shared target dir against its brief, freeing + and partly retaking about 400 MB; Soul could not establish that anything + of another crate's was evicted, and the next brief forbids it by name. + **Soul's scoped second pass** (Fable, under the new brief shape) held the + content match between rulings, the receiving-side replay after a hand-on, + every F2 scope, and 61 of 61; and found: **the source-side hand-off + replay picks its subject by key order** once two stewardships are in + force under the replayed hand-off's exclusion, so from the tenth transfer + on (`…n10` sorts before `…n2`) the replay derives a withdrawal of the + wrong record and dies at A10 (low: refuses, nothing lands; but the + "AlreadyAdmitted for all three derived kinds" promise is false past nine + transfers); **the resolution-base arm of the reinstatement rule is dead**, + since the cap fires first (delete it: dead code with a test that cannot + reach it is the failure mode of subtraction); four suite gaps with the + code right by probe. Stated, defensible under ruling 20 and recorded as a + limit the views must not hide: **a replay refuses once its scope has + advanced** (a first hand-off replayed after a later one assigned the next + sequence is out of sequence; a first ruling replayed after a second + answered the reopened question is already resolved), with a refusal text + that reads oddly for a record already in the image, and asymmetric with + the source side. **The follow-up closes well enough to map Cut 9**; the + subject-selection fix and the dead arm land before Cut 12 leans on + hand-off replay, in Hands now. - **Cut 8 landed**: the Epiphany half at `a65c6420` (Soul-closed) with the Cut 10 prerequisite at `b4b17fc`; the Huginn half on `eureka/memory-organ` at `946758f`, `a4c5b79`, `0bd7133`, `ca30d3e`, fix batch `1cfa81d`,