diff --git a/docs/interlingua-standard.md b/docs/interlingua-standard.md index 8b36983..6a835dd 100644 --- a/docs/interlingua-standard.md +++ b/docs/interlingua-standard.md @@ -300,10 +300,6 @@ predications: roles: agent: actor patient: target -extensions: - rtd.aesthetic_reading: - form: raw - spectacle_value: high ``` ## Promotion Rule diff --git a/settings/eusocial-interbeing/README.md b/settings/eusocial-interbeing/README.md index ceb2502..0b1f400 100644 --- a/settings/eusocial-interbeing/README.md +++ b/settings/eusocial-interbeing/README.md @@ -20,7 +20,7 @@ register, and history. - Weksa owns the language-project pipeline: ontology projection, grammar, morphology, phonology, diachrony, rendering, glossing, and critique. - A future language project owns one inhabitant language. Airawa imperial - register, pre-imperial Airawa registers, Sa'auei'a family-unit speech, ritual + register, pre-imperial Airawa registers, Sa'ueia family-unit speech, ritual breeding-ground registers, and ecological-partner contact systems should not collapse into one universal naming soup. @@ -40,7 +40,7 @@ surfaces: - Airawa continent: mother-tree memory networks, archival dependency, disconnected networks, and the Airawa Empire's biological-memetic infrastructure. -- Sa'auei'a continent: advanced nomadic civilization, family-unit political +- Sa'ueia continent: advanced nomadic civilization, family-unit political movement, sacred breeding-ground commons, remembered routes, and reciprocal ecological relationships. diff --git a/settings/eusocial-interbeing/language-design.md b/settings/eusocial-interbeing/language-design.md index 942f7a9..9a727ee 100644 --- a/settings/eusocial-interbeing/language-design.md +++ b/settings/eusocial-interbeing/language-design.md @@ -49,7 +49,7 @@ rights, witnessed warrior promise, and honorable scar evidence. See ### Provisional Airawa Phonology Notes Airawa phonology is not finalized, but the current design pressure distinguishes -it from Sa'auei'a softness. Airawa names should feel sharper, more dorsal and +it from Sa'ueia softness. Airawa names should feel sharper, more dorsal and coronal, and more willing to close around hard edges. Provisional tendencies: @@ -58,9 +58,9 @@ Provisional tendencies: - sibilant and postalveolar fricatives should carry social texture: `s`, `z`, `sh` / `zh`; - `r` may be trilled in some Airawa registers; -- syllables can tolerate clipped or closed shapes where Sa'auei'a forms would +- syllables can tolerate clipped or closed shapes where Sa'ueia forms would flow longer and wetter; -- avoid making native Airawa names read like smooth Sa'auei'a route names unless +- avoid making native Airawa names read like smooth Sa'ueia route names unless the form is explicitly a loan, exonym, or cross-continental register. The current room consensus pushes this further for introductory speech: Airawa @@ -75,9 +75,9 @@ voiced postalveolar fricative /zh/ [ʒ]. The name is being considered for a Zyphos Face drawn from a non-imperial Airawa archival/fungal-road tradition: an archivist shaped by memory as kinship, not content. -## Sa'auei'a Pressures +## Sa'ueia Pressures -Sa'auei'a language work must account for: +Sa'ueia language work must account for: - advanced nomadic civilization without permanent urban dominance - squad-sized family units @@ -88,10 +88,46 @@ Sa'auei'a language work must account for: - reciprocity routes and seasonal corridors - camps, commons, and partner sites as distinct name targets -The Sa'auei'a continent should not read as empty wilderness. Its language should +The Sa'ueia continent should not read as empty wilderness. Its language should have ways to name civilization that moves, recurs, bargains, and is remembered by ecology. +## Sa'ueia Sound (Proposal For Deru To Cut) + +Status: proposal. Deru approved the outline in #zyphos on 2026-11-04; only the +species name Sa'ueia is canon. Everything below is a working draft in +`sa-ueia/table.yaml`, each entry marked `deru` or `weksa-placeholder`, and +`sa-ueia/check.py` enforces what is mechanical. + +Taken from Deru's words: + +- five vowels: `a e i o u`; +- no `h`, `q`, `y`; `k` where a `q` might have been; +- short words, soft and open; +- suffixing morphology; the one suffix so far is `-um`, a verb suffix; +- identical letters merge at a morpheme join: `weru` + `um` gives `werum`, + `ila` + `werum` gives `ilawerum` (walk of knowledge); +- a vowel only where one is needed. + +First roots, all Deru's: `ila` walk, `weru` know, `Olune` breeding ground +(unanalyzed). + +Proposed, for Deru to accept or cut: + +- the apostrophe in Sa'ueia is orthographic, and is not counted as a letter; +- "short" means at most 10 letters in a joined word, as a warning only; +- no doubled letter inside a morpheme, so a double can only arise at a join + and the merge rule removes it. + +Open, not guessed: + +- the consonant inventory. Only `l m n r s w` appear in Deru's words so far, + and that is attestation, not an inventory; +- whether the know root is `weru` or `wer-` (both give `werum`); +- syllable shapes, stress, and what "vowel only where needed" means once the + inventory is known (the checker does not test it); +- the phonological role of the apostrophe. + ## Naming Brief Shape A Weksa naming brief should capture at least: diff --git a/settings/eusocial-interbeing/sa-ueia/check.py b/settings/eusocial-interbeing/sa-ueia/check.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..179c935 --- /dev/null +++ b/settings/eusocial-interbeing/sa-ueia/check.py @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""Sa'ueia workshop checker: join morphemes by table.yaml's rules, flag violations. + +Reads table.yaml next to this file (or a path argument). The consonant inventory +is open, so no consonant is ever flagged; only rules in the table are enforced. +Exit status is 1 when any error is found; warnings do not fail the run. +""" + +from __future__ import annotations + +import sys +from dataclasses import dataclass +from pathlib import Path + +import yaml + +TABLE = Path(__file__).with_name("table.yaml") +PROVENANCES = {"deru", "weksa-placeholder"} + + +@dataclass(frozen=True) +class Finding: + severity: str # "error" | "warning" + where: str + message: str + + def __str__(self) -> str: + return f"{self.severity}: {self.where}: {self.message}" + + +def letters(form: str) -> str: + return form.replace("'", "").lower() + + +def join(morphemes: list[str]) -> str: + """Concatenate, merging one identical letter at each join.""" + out = "" + for m in morphemes: + if out and m and out[-1] == m[0]: + m = m[1:] + out += m + return out + + +def check_form(form: str, rules: dict, where: str, *, inside_morpheme: bool = False) -> list[Finding]: + found = [] + text = letters(form) + for ch in rules["forbidden_letters"]["value"]: + if ch in text: + found.append(Finding("error", where, f"{form!r} contains forbidden letter {ch!r}")) + for a, b in zip(text, text[1:]): + if a == b and (not inside_morpheme or rules["no_doubled_letters_inside_morpheme"]["value"]): + found.append(Finding("error", where, f"{form!r} has doubled {a!r}")) + limit = rules["max_word_letters"] + if not inside_morpheme and len(text) > limit["value"]: + found.append(Finding(limit["severity"], where, f"{form!r} is {len(text)} letters, over {limit['value']}")) + return found + + +def check_table(table: dict) -> list[Finding]: + rules = table["rules"] + found = [] + for r_name, r in rules.items(): + if r.get("provenance") not in PROVENANCES: + found.append(Finding("error", f"rules.{r_name}", "missing or unknown provenance")) + if table["consonants"]["inventory"] != "open": + found.append(Finding("error", "consonants", "inventory is not Deru's to guess; keep it open until given")) + forms: dict[str, str] = {} + for kind in ("roots", "suffixes"): + for entry in table[kind]: + form = entry["form"] + where = f"{kind}.{form}" + if entry.get("provenance") not in PROVENANCES: + found.append(Finding("error", where, "missing or unknown provenance")) + forms[form] = kind + found += check_form(form, rules, where, inside_morpheme=True) + for comp in table["compositions"]: + where = "compositions." + "+".join(comp["morphemes"]) + if comp.get("provenance") not in PROVENANCES: + found.append(Finding("error", where, "missing or unknown provenance")) + for m in comp["morphemes"]: + if m not in forms and not any(m == f2 for f2 in (c["expected"] for c in table["compositions"])): + found.append(Finding("error", where, f"morpheme {m!r} is in no table row or earlier composition")) + got = join(comp["morphemes"]) + if got != comp["expected"]: + found.append(Finding("error", where, f"joins to {got!r}, table says {comp['expected']!r}")) + found += check_form(comp["expected"], rules, where) + return found + + +def main(argv: list[str]) -> int: + path = Path(argv[1]) if len(argv) > 1 else TABLE + findings = check_table(yaml.safe_load(path.read_text(encoding="utf-8"))) + for f in findings: + print(f) + print(f"{sum(f.severity == 'error' for f in findings)} error(s), " + f"{sum(f.severity == 'warning' for f in findings)} warning(s)") + return 1 if any(f.severity == "error" for f in findings) else 0 + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + sys.exit(main(sys.argv)) diff --git a/settings/eusocial-interbeing/sa-ueia/table.yaml b/settings/eusocial-interbeing/sa-ueia/table.yaml new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6d83972 --- /dev/null +++ b/settings/eusocial-interbeing/sa-ueia/table.yaml @@ -0,0 +1,81 @@ +# Sa'ueia workshop table, first cut. +# Source: Deru's words in #zyphos, 2026-11-04. Setting owner: Deru (the Zyphos vault). +# Every entry carries provenance: +# deru - said by Deru, or part of the sound outline Deru approved +# weksa-placeholder - Weksa's stand-in so the checker can run; Deru may cut it +# Only the species name Sa'ueia is canon. Everything else here is a working +# draft, even when its provenance is deru. + +roots: + - form: ila + gloss: walk + provenance: deru + - form: weru + gloss: know + provenance: deru + note: > + Deru gave "werum" (knowledge, maybe a verb) and was asked whether -um + suffixes wer- or weru. "weru" is the reading under which the join rule + does visible work (weru + um -> werum); wer- gives the same surface form. + Open for Deru. + - form: olune + gloss: breeding ground + provenance: deru + analysis: unanalyzed # no morpheme boundaries known + - form: sa'ueia + gloss: the species name + provenance: deru + canon: true + analysis: unanalyzed + note: Apostrophe is part of the canon spelling; its phonological role is open. + +suffixes: + - form: um + gloss: verb suffix + provenance: deru + +rules: + vowels: + value: [a, e, i, o, u] + provenance: deru + forbidden_letters: + value: [h, q, y] + provenance: deru + note: k is used where q might have been. + join_merge_identical: + value: true + provenance: deru + note: > + When one morpheme ends in the letter the next begins with, they merge to + one letter at the join (weru + um -> werum, ila + werum -> ilawerum). + morphology_direction: + value: suffixing + provenance: deru + short_words: + provenance: deru + checked: false # no number from Deru + max_word_letters: + value: 10 + provenance: weksa-placeholder + severity: warning + note: Stand-in for "short words"; apostrophes not counted. Deru sets the real bound. + no_doubled_letters_inside_morpheme: + value: true + provenance: weksa-placeholder + note: Follows from the merge rule only if doubles never occur inside a morpheme either. + vowel_only_where_needed: + provenance: deru + checked: false # not mechanically decidable without the consonant inventory + +consonants: + inventory: open # Deru has not given it. The checker does not guess. + seen_in_deru_words: [l, m, n, r, s, w] # attested above, not an inventory + +# Joined forms the checker must reproduce. Each: morphemes in order, expected surface. +compositions: + - morphemes: [weru, um] + expected: werum + provenance: deru # "werum" is Deru's form + - morphemes: [ila, werum] + expected: ilawerum + provenance: deru # "Ilawerum", walk of knowledge diff --git a/settings/eusocial-interbeing/sa-ueia/test_check.py b/settings/eusocial-interbeing/sa-ueia/test_check.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..790d689 --- /dev/null +++ b/settings/eusocial-interbeing/sa-ueia/test_check.py @@ -0,0 +1,94 @@ +import copy +import unittest + +import yaml + +import check + + +def table(): + return yaml.safe_load(check.TABLE.read_text(encoding="utf-8")) + + +def errors(t): + return [f for f in check.check_table(t) if f.severity == "error"] + + +class JoinTests(unittest.TestCase): + def test_identical_letters_merge_at_join(self): + self.assertEqual(check.join(["weru", "um"]), "werum") + self.assertEqual(check.join(["ila", "werum"]), "ilawerum") + + def test_merge_is_one_letter_not_all(self): + self.assertEqual(check.join(["ila", "aba"]), "ilaba") + self.assertEqual(check.join(["ila", "ala"]), "ilala") + + def test_different_letters_concatenate(self): + self.assertEqual(check.join(["ila", "um"]), "ilaum") + + def test_merge_applies_only_at_joins(self): + # a doubled letter inside a morpheme is not collapsed by join + self.assertEqual(check.join(["aa", "b"]), "aab") + + +class TableTests(unittest.TestCase): + def test_shipped_table_is_clean(self): + self.assertEqual(errors(table()), []) + + def test_forbidden_letter_in_root_flagged(self): + t = table() + t["roots"].append({"form": "haru", "gloss": "x", "provenance": "weksa-placeholder"}) + self.assertTrue(any("forbidden letter 'h'" in str(f) for f in errors(t))) + + def test_q_and_y_flagged(self): + for ch in "qy": + t = table() + t["roots"].append({"form": f"a{ch}a", "gloss": "x", "provenance": "deru"}) + self.assertTrue(any(f"forbidden letter '{ch}'" in str(f) for f in errors(t)), ch) + + def test_k_allowed(self): + t = table() + t["roots"].append({"form": "kela", "gloss": "x", "provenance": "weksa-placeholder"}) + self.assertEqual(errors(t), []) + + def test_missing_or_unknown_provenance_flagged(self): + for bad in (None, "guess"): + t = table() + t["suffixes"][0]["provenance"] = bad + self.assertTrue(any("provenance" in str(f) for f in errors(t)), bad) + + def test_unmerged_composition_flagged(self): + t = table() + t["compositions"][0]["expected"] = "weruum" + msgs = [str(f) for f in errors(t)] + self.assertTrue(any("joins to 'werum'" in m for m in msgs)) + self.assertTrue(any("doubled 'u'" in m for m in msgs)) + + def test_doubled_letter_inside_morpheme_flagged(self): + t = table() + t["roots"].append({"form": "ilaa", "gloss": "x", "provenance": "weksa-placeholder"}) + self.assertTrue(any("doubled 'a'" in str(f) for f in errors(t))) + + def test_unknown_morpheme_in_composition_flagged(self): + t = table() + t["compositions"].append({"morphemes": ["ila", "zo"], "expected": "ilazo", "provenance": "weksa-placeholder"}) + self.assertTrue(any("'zo'" in str(f) for f in errors(t))) + + def test_long_word_is_warning_not_error(self): + t = table() + t["compositions"].append({"morphemes": ["ila", "werum", "ila", "werum"], "expected": "ilawerumilawerum", + "provenance": "weksa-placeholder"}) + self.assertEqual(errors(t), []) + self.assertTrue(any(f.severity == "warning" for f in check.check_table(t))) + + def test_consonant_inventory_must_stay_open(self): + t = table() + t["consonants"]["inventory"] = ["l", "m"] + self.assertTrue(any("inventory" in str(f) for f in errors(t))) + + def test_apostrophe_is_not_a_letter(self): + self.assertEqual(check.letters("Sa'ueia"), "saueia") + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + unittest.main() diff --git a/settings/eusocial-interbeing/zyphos-name-briefs.md b/settings/eusocial-interbeing/zyphos-name-briefs.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..aae4c2d --- /dev/null +++ b/settings/eusocial-interbeing/zyphos-name-briefs.md @@ -0,0 +1,390 @@ +# Zyphos Name Briefs (DRAFT) + +**Status: every name in this file is DRAFT. None is canon.** Per the +[README](./README.md), a name is canon only when a language project can explain +its ontology and form. No such project exists yet, so these are candidates held +against briefs, not entries in a lexicon. + +Source: follow-up `weksa-body/zyphos-name-drafts`. Brief shape follows +[Language Design Pressure](./language-design.md#naming-brief-shape): the brief +comes before the name, and the name is the receipt. Setting context was read +from the Zyphos vault (`Species/Airawa`, `Species/Matriarch Trees`, +`Species/Sa'ueia`, `Civilizations/*`, `Ecology/Breeding Grounds`, +`Ecology/Nation Scale Interbeings`); the vault was not edited. + +Both brief sets wait on Meta's answers to `vq-first-language` and +`vq-name-scope`. Where a brief's scope depends on them it says so. + +## What the sound rules actually give us + +`language-design.md` is thin, and the briefs should not pretend otherwise. + +- **Airawa** has a provisional list (R-A below). It is a tendency list, not a + phonology: no vowel inventory, no photactic limits, no stress rule beyond + "heavy on socially important forms". +- **Sa'ueia has a working sound section** + ([Sa'ueia Sound](./language-design.md#saueia-sound-proposal-for-deru-to-cut), + enforced by `sa-ueia/check.py` against `sa-ueia/table.yaml`). It is a + proposal Deru approved in outline; only the species name is canon. Rule + labels R-S4..R-S8 below cite it. The consonant inventory, syllable shapes and + stress are still open, so sound arguments beyond the letter rules stay weak. +- The **imperial Airawa register** has no sound rules either. It is only + described as "an artificial quarter-continent clausiform exception imposed + through biological-memetic control", not "named like a normal state with wet + nouns glued on". + +Rule labels used below (quoted or paraphrased from `language-design.md`): + +| Label | Rule | +| --- | --- | +| R-A1 | Airawa: dorsal and coronal plosives prominent (`k g q t d`). | +| R-A2 | Airawa: sibilants and postalveolars carry social texture (`s z sh zh`). | +| R-A3 | Airawa: `r` may be trilled in some registers. | +| R-A4 | Airawa: clipped or closed syllables tolerated, where Sa'ueia would flow longer and wetter. | +| R-A5 | Native Airawa names must not read like smooth Sa'ueia route names unless explicitly loan, exonym or cross-continental register. | +| R-A6 | Room consensus: hard edges, clipped/closed syllables, heavy stress on socially important forms, so claims land with weight. | +| R-S1 | Sa'ueia is softer than Airawa. | +| R-S2 | Sa'ueia forms flow longer and wetter than Airawa. | +| R-S3 | Sa'ueia route names read smooth. | +| R-S4 | Sa'ueia letters: vowels `a e i o u`; forbidden `h q y` (`k` where a `q` might have been). | +| R-S5 | Sa'ueia: short words, soft and open; at most 10 letters joined (warning, Weksa placeholder). | +| R-S6 | Sa'ueia: suffixing morphology; identical letters merge at a join (`weru`+`um` -> `werum`). | +| R-S7 | Sa'ueia: no doubled letter inside a morpheme (Weksa placeholder); a double arises only at a join, and the merge removes it. | +| R-S8 | Sa'ueia roots from Deru: `ila` walk, `weru` know, `olune` breeding ground (unanalyzed), `-um` verb suffix. Composed: `werum`, `ilawerum` (walk of knowledge). | +| R-N | Naming rule: meaning decomposition first; define the speaker's scale, name type (endonym, exonym, ritual avoidance, technical, imperial administrative, route-name, child-name, trade gloss), what the speaker's ontology makes obligatory, and whether the name is stable, seasonal, situational, inherited or evasive. | + +Existing scratch evidence to keep in view: `Druzkai` (Face for a non-imperial +archivist) and the first-contact slice lexicon (`atar`, `qatar`, `daruq`, +`karuq`, `qerath`, `thaleq`...). Neither is canon either. + +Each target's brief ends with **reject if** conditions. A name that fails one +goes back to the brief, not to a patch. + +--- + +## Airawa, non-imperial + +Common to all Airawa briefs below, unless one overrides it: the speakers are +pre-imperial or never-imperial Airawa, in the `Pre-Imperial Airawa Tribes` / +native nation-scale sense, not the Empire. Registers (Airawa imperial, native +tribal, mother-tree-facing) must not collapse into one naming soup +(`README.md`, Authority). + +### A1. Airawa self-name (candidates: `Qazhkar`, `Dozkai`, `Tegzhir`) — DRAFT + +```yaml +target: + kind: endonym (what a non-imperial Airawa people call themselves) + canon_source: Species/Airawa; Civilizations/Pre-Imperial Airawa Tribes + provisional_english_handle: "the Airawa, as they name themselves" +namer: + language_project: none yet (non-imperial Airawa, native register) + register: formal naming register (slice: `qatar`, formal name), not casual + relationship_to_target: the speaker is the target +``` + +- **Speaker:** a non-imperial Airawa speaking as a people, or as a tribe + inside the people (open: see scope question). +- **Addressee:** primarily other Airawa and witnesses at formal naming; second, + an outsider receiving an introduction (the first-contact scene). +- **Register:** formal, standing-bearing; the kind of word that follows `atar` + ("I stand as") and has to land with weight (R-A6). +- **Meaning decomposed before surface:** + a self-name here is probably not "people" in the English sense. The setting + makes the unit of selfhood a relationship: a lineage held by a mother tree, + bound by gestation contracts, contract dress and nutrient obligation. The + candidate meaning bundle is: *those held in memory by mother trees* / + *those who owe and are owed* / *kin through the archive*. It must also work + as a contrast with the empire, which edits memory: the pre-imperial self-name + should presuppose negotiated, leaky membership, not a uniform nation. + Scope question (needs `vq-name-scope`): one pan-Airawa word, a per-tribe + word, or a word for the *kind* of polity (nation-scale interbeing, which + includes the trees)? +- **Sound rules that apply:** R-A1, R-A2, R-A4, R-A6; R-A5 as a negative check. +- **Per-candidate sound read (judgment, not rule):** + - `Qazhkar`: `q` + `zh` + `k`, two closed syllables (Qazh-kar), fits R-A1, + R-A2, R-A4, R-A6 cleanly. Shares `-kar` with `sakar` and `kazhar` from the + slice. That is a plus if `-kar` is meant to be a role/person suffix and a + minus if it was only a sound resemblance. + - `Dozkai`: closed first syllable, open second ending in a diphthong `ai`. + Fits R-A1/R-A2 but the open `-ai` tail is the softer shape R-A4 contrasts + against. Also two edits from the scratch name `Druzkai` (insert `r`, `o` to + `u`); two names with that near neighbourhood will blur unless one is explicitly derived from + the other. + - `Tegzhir`: `t-g-zh` cluster, closed final syllable, clean fit. The only + candidate with a front vowel in the stressed syllable, which may or may not + be a feature. +- **Reject if:** + - the meaning bundle above cannot be stated in one clause that names the + mother-tree relationship (a bare "people" or "the strong" gloss); + - the form also reads as a plausible Sa'ueia word (R-A5); + - it is shared, as a root, with the imperial exonym in A4 without a recorded + reason (loan or deliberate echo); + - the project owner decides the self-name is per-tribe and the word is only + pan-continental. +- **Preferred shape of choice (not a ruling):** pick by the meaning bundle, not + by taste; all three pass the sound list, so sound is not a discriminator here. + +### A2. Mother tree (candidates: `Kharzdun`, `Qetoz`) — DRAFT + +```yaml +target: + kind: name for a being / kind of being, not a place + canon_source: Species/Matriarch Trees; Ecology/Mother Tree Networks + provisional_english_handle: "mother tree / matriarch tree" +``` + +- **Speaker:** non-imperial Airawa. Possibly two speakers needing two words: + a tribe naming *its* tree, and a general word for the kind. Open. +- **Addressee:** other Airawa (referring to the tree); *not* the tree itself. + The slice requires distinguishing "direct speech to a mother-tree" from + "authorized delivery to it", so referring and addressing probably want + different forms. +- **Register:** archival / ritual-respectful. Not a diminutive and not a + kinship term. +- **Meaning decomposed before surface:** the English handle "mother" imports + nurture. The vault's tree is a gestator *and* a memory-holder *and* a party + with coercive leverage (memory can be held hostage; defying it costs + ancestral continuity). The Airawa name should carry at least: *keeper of + memory* and *gestation contract*, and should not smuggle in "gentle". Whether + the name also marks the tree as a sovereign party (a polity, since it is a + node in a nation-scale interbeing) is a fork for the owner. +- **Sound rules that apply:** R-A1, R-A2, R-A4, R-A6. +- **Per-candidate sound read:** + - `Kharzdun`: the `kh` is outside the R-A1/R-A2 list (`k g q t d s z sh zh`); + it needs either a rule admitting it or a respelling. Three syllables with + `rz` cluster and final `-dun`: heavy, closed. Strong fit to R-A6 otherwise. + - `Qetoz`: `q` + `t` + `z`, two syllables, fits R-A1/R-A2; the open middle + vowel pattern (`e`, `o`) is lighter than `Kharzdun`. Shorter is arguably + right for a word said often; longer for a word said with weight. +- **Reject if:** the name decomposes only to "mother"/"nurse"/"grandmother" + (kinship nostalgia without the contract and coercion); it is the same word + the empire uses for the tree as *infrastructure* (the Biological Memetic + Engine reuses the tree network, so the empire's word is a different brief); + the project owner rules the kind-word and the individual-tree-word must be + separate and only one is given. + +### A3. Disconnected network (candidates: `Gisqat`, `Zhedkor`) — DRAFT + +```yaml +target: + kind: name for a surviving mother-tree ecology that severed itself + canon_source: Civilizations/Disconnected Tree Networks + provisional_english_handle: "disconnected (tree) network" +``` + +- **Speaker:** a native non-imperial Airawa, ideally someone inside or allied + with such a network. **Not the empire**: the empire denies they exist + (`Airawa Empire`, "Nations It Refuses to Recognize"; they are called + "disease, criminal ecology, or imperial tissue awaiting correction"), so the + imperial register has no sanctioned word, and any imperial term is a + separate brief (A4). +- **Addressee:** other native Airawa; possibly a visiting envoy (the vault has + envoys crossing into Sa'ueia territory). Rumor-grade circulation: the networks + "keep rumors moving through routes the engine cannot fully process". +- **Register:** careful. The vault has the status as survival, refusal and + wound at once; the name may need an indirect/evasive form + (`README.md`: "safe-to-name, indirect-name-required, silence-required"). +- **Meaning decomposed before surface:** *severed* is the surface fact; the + contentful meaning is *alive because cut*: the connection was surrendered to + preserve the self. A gloss of "isolated" or "cut-off" loses that. Axes to + decide: is the name about the cut (act), the survivor (state), or the + continued resistance (role)? Do networks of "trees with more control than + people" and "anti-imperial Airawa communities" share one word, or does the + word name the property (disconnection) rather than the polity? +- **Sound rules that apply:** R-A1, R-A2, R-A4, R-A6. +- **Per-candidate sound read:** + - `Gisqat`: `g-s-q-t`, two closed syllables; a hard stop sequence that reads + as something cut off, which is apt but also a sound-symbolic gloss the + project should not over-trust. + - `Zhedkor`: `zh-d-k`, trilled `r` available (R-A3); heavy and closed. +- **Reject if:** the form is also the imperial term (the empire's denial means + the two registers should not share one word without cause); it glosses to + "dead", "lost" or "isolated"; the owner decides the target is a *property* + word (adjective for any severed tree) and the candidate is a *noun for the + polity*, or vice versa. + +### A4. Imperial exonym for the natives (`Tkarzet`) — DRAFT + +```yaml +target: + kind: exonym, imperial administrative + canon_source: Civilizations/Airawa Empire; Conflicts/Xenophobic Memetic Campaign + provisional_english_handle: "the natives / unincorporated Airawa" +namer: + language_project: none (imperial Airawa register) + register: imperial administrative / doctrinal + relationship_to_target: classifier, denier +``` + +- **Speaker:** the Empire, an artificial nation-scale interbeing speaking + through ministries, doctrine and memetic organisms. +- **Addressee:** imperial citizens and administrators; also doctrine-carrying + memes. Not the natives: it is not a word the natives would be called by to + their faces in a respectful exchange. +- **Register:** official. The language-design rule says this register is + "an artificial quarter-continent clausiform exception", not a normal state's + wet-noun coinage. +- **Meaning decomposed before surface:** the empire's stance is + *non-recognition*: native nations are "disease, criminal ecology, or + imperial tissue awaiting correction"; unification is "biologically + inevitable". So the exonym should classify natives as *not-yet-incorporated + tissue* or *contamination*, not as a people who happen to be foreign. It + should be usable in doctrine and in accusation (dissenters are "infected"). + Open: does the word split native Airawa from the disconnected networks (A3) + or is it a single catch-all? The empire denies the networks exist, so the + catch-all risks naming what the doctrine says does not exist. +- **Sound rules that apply:** R-N (exonym). The provisional R-A list governs + *native* Airawa, not the imperial register. There is no imperial phonology + rule yet, so any sound argument for `Tkarzet` is by analogy to R-A1/R-A2. + `Tkarzet` opens with a `tk` cluster that appears nowhere else in the + candidate set or the slice lexicon; it either marks the imperial register as + phonotactically different (good if intended) or is a stray. +- **Reject if:** it is a bare monosyllabic-looking root with no clausal or + administrative structure (the imperial register is clausiform); it is simply + a native word borrowed with harsher spelling (R-A5's reverse: the imperial + word should not accidentally be a native one); it gives the natives a + sovereign-people gloss, contradicting the doctrine; the owner decides the + imperial register needs a distinct sound system and the candidate cannot be + defended against it. + +--- + +## Sa'ueia family-unit and ecological contexts + +Common context: the Sa'ueia civilization is mobile, family-unit based +(squad-sized groups doing kinship, craft, diplomacy and oaths together), with +sacred communal breeding grounds and reciprocal ecological partners. A name +earns its place by revealing the ecological deal, reproductive pressure, +memory technology or route consequence (`language-design.md`, design target). +The sound rules available are R-S1..R-S8 and R-A5; the inventory, syllable +shapes and stress are still open. + +### S1. Sa'ueia self-name (candidates: `Ellumaiwa`, `Sauwele`) — DRAFT + +```yaml +target: + kind: endonym; family-unit scale, not species scale (open) + canon_source: Species/Sa'ueia; Civilizations/Sa'ueia Family Units + provisional_english_handle: "the Sa'ueia as a family-unit people" +``` + +- **Speaker:** a Sa'ueia family unit speaking as itself (family-self scale), + possibly on behalf of the wider people. +- **Addressee:** other family units meeting on a route or at a breeding + ground; and ecological partners that keep memory of it (reputation is + held by partners, not only by humans). +- **Register:** family-unit speech, relational and portable; a name that + survives travel and can be re-presented to a partner that remembers you. +- **Meaning decomposed before surface:** the vault makes the family unit the + carrier of standing, and standing is the partners' memory of generosity. So + a self-name probably means something like *those who return and are + recognized as beneficial* / *the traveling reciprocal*, not *the people of a + place*. Scope fork: the continent-scale word "Sa'ueia" already exists in the + vault as the species/continent ethnonym; the candidates may be (a) family-unit + *kind* names, (b) nicknames for the people derived from it, or (c) a + competing ethnonym. This needs `vq-name-scope` before judging. +- **Sound rules that apply:** R-S1, R-S2, R-S4, R-S5, R-S7; R-A5 as a negative check. +- **Per-candidate read (judgment, then the letter rules):** + - `Ellumaiwa`: long, open, liquid-heavy. Fails R-S7: `ll` is a doubled + letter inside a morpheme, with no join to merge it, unless the form + is parsed as `el`+`lumaiwa` (then the merge rule would give `elumaiwa`). + Also 9 letters, near the R-S5 bound. Needs a respelling or a parse, not a + patch. + - `Sauwele`: short, open vowels and `w`, `l`; passes R-S4/R-S5/R-S7, but it + begins `Sa-u-` exactly like `Sa'ueia`. Reads as a respelling or derivation + of the existing name rather than an independent self-name. +- **Reject if:** the owner has not decided the target scale; `Sauwele` is + accepted without a recorded derivation from `Sa'ueia` (otherwise it is an + accidental duplicate); either name decomposes to "wolf-like", "pack" or + "nomad" (the vault warns the wolf comparison explains only part of them, and + "nomad" is a camera-angle word); it cannot take a family-specific modifier + when a particular unit needs naming. + +### S2. Breeding ground (`Olune`, Deru's root; `Oluneihe` withdrawn) — DRAFT + +```yaml +target: + kind: place-name / commons name, ritual register + canon_source: Ecology/Breeding Grounds + provisional_english_handle: "breeding ground" +``` + +- **Speaker:** a Sa'ueia family unit returning to a ground; and the ground's + year-round occupants (infants, infirm, caretakers, rotating specialists). +- **Addressee:** other family units, partners that remember them, and the + occupants when arrival is announced. +- **Register:** ritual-communal; the vault gives these as places of + transition, mourning, dispute settlement, medical care and obligation + renewal, so the name has some solemnity. +- **Meaning decomposed before surface:** *commons* is the key axis: it is not + property, not a seat, not a nursery run by an empire. The name should mark a + place that *remains* (occupied all year) while the people circulate, and that + gathers reproduction, care, memory and law. It must distinguish itself from + camp, route and partner site (the Simulation Brief explicitly asks what makes + these visibly different). If the name is a *kind* name, it has to be + generic enough to name every ground; if it names one ground, it needs a + proper-name layer. +- **Sound rules that apply:** R-S1, R-S2, R-S3, R-S4, R-S8. +- **Read:** the target already has a name from Deru: `olune`, breeding ground + (R-S8), unanalyzed. The earlier candidate `Oluneihe` is withdrawn: it + contains `h`, which R-S4 forbids, and its stem `Olune` is Deru's own root, so + the candidate only added a suffix to a word that already answers the brief. + What remains open for this brief is whether `olune` is the kind-word, a + single ground's name, or needs a proper-name layer; and its morpheme + boundaries, which Deru has not given. +- **Reject if:** any proposed form contains `h`, `q` or `y`; it decomposes to + "home", "village", "city" or "capital" (the breeding ground failing as a + capital is a stated system failure); it equals or contains the route word + (S3) or the family self-name (S1), which would merge distinct targets; it is + used for a camp; it replaces `olune` without Deru's say. + +### S3. Route as obligation (no candidate) — DRAFT + +```yaml +target: + kind: route-name; relation, not geography + canon_source: Themes/Ecological Bargaining; Ecology/Reciprocal Ecologies + provisional_english_handle: "route (as owed relationship)" +``` + +- **Speaker:** a Sa'ueia family unit that holds or renews a route. +- **Addressee:** other units; the ecological partners (feeding sites, groves, + herds, pollinator corridors) that keep memory of how the unit travelled it. +- **Register:** family-unit speech with some formality: this is a promise-bearing + word. Possibly a seasonal/situational name (a route can open or close + depending on remembered injury). +- **Meaning decomposed before surface:** the key point is that *the route is a + relationship that makes passage available*, not a path on the ground. A unit + may be physically able to travel yet unwelcome (`Family Units`). The word + should mean something like *the standing that lets us pass*; ideally it + distinguishes *the way* from *the debt*. If both senses are one word, the + language is making a commitment about their identity that the vault does + not make. +- **Sound rules that apply:** R-S2, R-S3 (route names read smooth), R-S4..R-S8. Also R-A5: + Sa'ueia route names are what Airawa native names must not accidentally + resemble. +- **Read:** `Ilawerum` is not a candidate. It is Deru's own composition, + `ila` (walk) + `werum` (knowledge, verb form `weru`+`um`), glossed "walk of + knowledge" (R-S8). It names a different thing, and the checker reproduces it + as a fixed composition. Any route-as-obligation word should be built from + Deru's roots or new roots she accepts, and must not be confused with, or + collide with, `ilawerum`. +- **Reject if:** it is `ilawerum` or only a respelling of it; it is a plain toponym (no debt sense); it is the same word as + the breeding ground (S2) or shares its stem without a morphological reason; + the owner decides route and obligation are two words and this is only one. + +--- + +## Questions this raises (owners, not decisions) + +- **Scope:** one word per ethnonym or per tribe/unit? (`vq-name-scope`.) +- **First language:** Airawa vs imperial Airawa vs Sa'ueia vs a narrow + naming-brief interlingua (`vq-first-language`; `state/map.yaml`). The Airawa + briefs are better supported by existing sound evidence; the Sa'ueia briefs + have only the working sound section, which leaves the inventory open. +- **Sa'ueia open items** (inventory, syllable shapes, stress, apostrophe role, + `weru` versus `wer-`) are Deru's; S1-S3 are judged on the letter rules only + until she cuts them. +- **Imperial register sound rules** for A4. +- **`kh` in `Kharzdun`**: add to the Airawa inventory or respell. diff --git a/settings/rust-to-dust/imperial/language-design.md b/settings/rust-to-dust/imperial/language-design.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..8e3aa98 --- /dev/null +++ b/settings/rust-to-dust/imperial/language-design.md @@ -0,0 +1,403 @@ +# Rust to Dust Imperial Language: Design Spec + +Status: **DRAFT r0.** First conlang project for Rust to Dust. Nothing here is +canon until the operator rules on it. + +The language has no name. Its working slug is `rtd-imperial`. A name is owed +and should come from the ontology and phonology below, as +[setting.md](../setting.md) asks, not from an English label. Nothing here +assigns one. + +## How To Read This + +Every claim carries a tag: + +- **[E]** evidence. The source material says it, and the file is cited. +- **[I]** invention. This draft proposes it. The operator can overrule it, and + it is the part most worth attacking. +- **[E→I]** an extension. The source gives a seed and this draft develops it. + +Sources read: everything under `settings/rust-to-dust/` (`README`, `setting`, +`aliens`, `story`, `battle-royale`, `language-design`), the house method in +`settings/eusocial-interbeing/language-design.md`, and Weksa's +`docs/language-model.md`, `interlingua-standard.md`, +`best-modern-approach.md`, `multilingual-utterance-lowering.md` and +`schemas/interlingua-packet.md`. The stance design is read from `main` (see Dependencies). The forge repos and +Weksa `state/` and `docs/` hold no other Rust to Dust material: a forge search +for the setting returned nothing outside Weksa. This draft therefore rests on +about 440 lines of setting prose, and the invention share is large. + +## 1. Speech Community + +### Who speaks it [E] + +The empire's aliens: reptilian, scale-decorating, aesthetics-as-moral-truth, +honor as devotion to aesthetic perfection in a chosen field (`aliens.md`). The +empire is galaxy-spanning, so the language is a **network language**. Its +community is defined by the imperial cultural network (media, prestige, +commerce), not by a homeland. Humans are not native speakers. They meet it +through subtitles, memes and broadcasts, and their contaminated English is a +separate register (`language-design.md`, Registers). + +### Speech situations [E→I] + +`language-design.md` lists registers. This draft turns each into a situation +with a speaker, an addressee and a stake, because a register is a relationship +and not a vocabulary list: + +| Situation | Speaker → addressee | Stake | Source | +|---|---|---|---| +| Broadcast commentary | commentator → mass imperial audience, about a performer | rendering an aesthetic verdict in real time | E (battle-royale) | +| High honor speech | warrior or master → rival, patron or witness | binding a vow, naming a performance | E (register list) | +| Warrior discourse | practitioner ↔ practitioner of one field | form, discipline, challenge | E (register list) | +| Commercial acquisition | buyer ↔ seller, or buyer → cultural object | access and integration phrased as uplift | E (setting: commerce as delivery rail) | +| Panel-show media | host ↔ guest before an audience | turning the guest's stance into performance | E (story: the panel) | +| Tourist admiration | tourist → anything | consuming a safe spectacle | E (aliens: tourists) | +| Address to humans | any → human | uplift, fascination, appraisal | I | + +The last row is added. The story's central irony is that the empire +understands the father's refusal better than he understands the empire, so +how imperial speakers address humans is a design surface, not an afterthought. + +The first proving slice is **broadcast commentary** [E]: `battle-royale.md` +names it as the runtime use, and it needs the fewest situations to be +distinguishable by a reader. + +### Status ladder [I] + +The source gives status *signals* (scale decoration marks profession, class, +rank, grief, celebrity, courtship, school, combat discipline, public +obligation, commitments) and a *measure* (the more elaborate the decoration, +the more visible the claim of virtue). It gives no ladder. The invention: +status is two axes, not one. + +- **Field.** The discipline one is devoted to (combat, speech, hosting, trade, + politics, art). Honor is field-relative [E]. A master of one field has no + rank in another. +- **Standing in the field**, by *claim and demonstrated constraint*, not by + force: + 1. **Unclaimed.** No decoration in a field. This is shameless, not neutral + [E: unpainted = shamelessness]. + 2. **Claimant.** Decorated, undemonstrated. Tourists live here: the claim is + bought and the constraint never chosen [E: tourists buy a safe spectacle]. + 3. **Practitioner.** Decorated, with constraint demonstrated in the field. + 4. **Master.** Constraint demonstrated before witnesses. + 5. **Exemplar.** Master whose form others cite. +- **Bare-by-claim** is an exceptional state off the ladder, not a step on it. + Going unpainted as an artistic claim that the performance alone is art is a + provocation [E]. The grammar must be able to say it without saying + "shameless". + +The language's address and agreement system tracks **claim versus +demonstrated constraint**, because that is what the source treats as the +moral measure. A tourist's loud, expensive decoration is a *mismatch* the +language can state, and the language carries that mismatch in the grammar +itself. + +Decoration is the primary status channel in the world. In speech it surfaces +as address terms, honorific-like marking and metaphor (Section 4), not as a +phoneme-level trick. + +## 2. Phonology (provisional) + +The source gives no phonetic profile. It poses the question +(`language-design.md`, Open Questions) and says naming should follow from +phonetics. House method (Zyphos) assigns Airawa hard dorsal and coronal +edges and Sa'auei'a soft flow. This language must not collapse onto either +[I]. + +### Design stance [I] + +Three pressures from the source, turned into sound: + +1. **Aesthetic devotion**: the language should sound *composed*. Prosody is + deliberate, with controlled length, no clutter. +2. **Chosen constraint is mastery**: constraint should be audible. Phonotactics + are *tight*, so that a speaker visibly refrains from the permitted-in-vulgar + alternatives. +3. **Reptilian body** [E: reptilian]: the inventory leans on sustained + fricatives, hisses and trills that a non-human vocal tract makes easy. The + source does not specify a vocal tract. This is the weakest-evidenced + choice and a human-pronounceable romanization is therefore required. + +### Inventory (draft) + +- **Stops** (voiceless only): `t`, `k`, `ʔ`. No voiced stops. This separates it + from Airawa's `g d q`. +- **Fricatives**: `s`, `ʃ`, `x`, `h`, with voiced `z`, `ʒ`. Fricatives + contrast in **length**: short and held. Held fricatives are the language's + main prosodic ornament and carry register weight (Section 3). +- **Sonorants**: `n`, `m`, `l`, trilled `r`. +- **Vowels**: `a`, `i`, `u`, `e`, each short or long. A long vowel is the + other register-bearing length. +- **Syllables**: `(C)V(C)`, coda `s n l ʔ` only. No clusters. The absence of + clusters is the phonotactic form of "chosen constraint". + +### Prosody [I] + +- Stress and length are the speaker's expressive budget. In formal + registers, *less* length variation reads as more command of the form. A + commentator in broadcast register may spend length on a performer's + moment, and an honor-speech speaker withholds it. Restraint is therefore + audible without a phoneme change (Section 3). +- Broadcast commentary has a lengthened, sibilant "announcer" delivery. Tourists + over-lengthen. Master speech under-lengthens. + +### Romanization and rendering [I] + +An ASCII romanization is owed before any lowering output is scored: the +lowering renders text, and the renderer for the audience needs +a stable orthography. `ʃ ʒ x ʔ` need ASCII digraphs. The choice follows +the Weksa pronunciation-lowering docs and belongs to a later cut. + +### Open + +- The inventory is a sketch, drawn from three pressures. It should be rerun + after at least a hundred roots exist, not defended. +- The source calls for names to "emerge from ontology and phonetics". This + draft supplies phonetics, and the name waits for the first root set. + +## 3. Register, Status and Restraint: Stance Explicit + +### Weksa's constraint [E] + +On `main`, `docs/interlingua-standard.md` carries +a packet `stance`: **felt affect** (anger, fear, sadness, joy, disgust, surprise, +contempt, affection, shame, as grades) and **`restraint`**, how much of the +felt affect is held back (0 none, 1000 fully). It is felt, never displayed. +How a feeling shows and how much leaks is cultural; each language's ontology +maps felt affect and restraint to its own register. A held-back feeling is not +a claim, so it is never a predication. + +This language must therefore **mark stance explicitly in its own grammar**, +and the marking is derived from the packet's `stance`, never from English +register words in the source text. + +### Why this language is the hard case for restraint [E→I] + +For the empire, restraint is not suppression of a shameful interior. It is +**the visible form of chosen constraint**, which is the moral proof of +mastery [E]. So the map from `restraint` to surface is *inverted* relative to +most human defaults: + +- High restraint is the *display* of virtue. A fully restrained speaker with + strong felt affect is exhibiting form. +- Low restraint with strong affect is not honest. It is *vulgar* [E: "vulgar + violence as failed form"; "collapse into mere function"]. +- Zero affect is not neutrality. It can read as an absence of devotion. + +The deliberate consequence is that stance cannot be flattened to a politeness +level. Two axes are needed, and the source's lens questions (elegant, +disciplined, sincere, vulgar, memorable) ask for both. + +### Obligatory categories [I] + +Proposed grammatical commitments (the target-language selections that step 4 +of `language-model.md` demands). Each names the packet field that feeds it. + +1. **Finish marking** on predicates: an obligatory grade-class drawn from + `stance.restraint`, coarsened to a few classes. Working classes: + *raw*, *held*, *finished*. The unmarked form does not exist: leaving it + off is not neutrality but a gap that the community reads as vulgar. + Feeds from: `stance.restraint`. +2. **Leak channel**: how much felt affect shows *through* a high-restraint + frame. Leak is not mapped to emotion words. It is mapped to **form + choices**: clipped versus full inflection, length spent on a fricative, + word choice within a field. This follows the standard's own example + (anger leaking through clipped syntax is stance). Feeds from: felt affect + grades against `restraint`. +3. **Standing agreement** on referents: field and standing-in-field of a + named performer, with the **claim/demonstrated** mismatch statable. Feeds + from: speaker and scene features (Section 6). +4. **Witness and form-evaluation**. Broadcast commentary is evaluative by + situation. Evaluation is expressed as a **separate discourse layer** + (a particle or clause layer), not as adjectives in the content: the + lens questions [E] (elegant, disciplined, sincere, vulgar, memorable, + promising, mastery, collapse) are the layer's open slots. It is + kept apart from content because a held-back evaluation is not a claim + about the world, and the interlingua keeps content and attitude + separate. Feeds from: `discourse` features and the situation. +5. **Evidential**: commentary asserts what the camera sees and *infers* the + performer's sincerity. The inference must be marked, because the source + puts sincerity in the performer, who is not the speaker and not available to + telemetry. Feeds from: the evidentiality feature the standard already + names. + +### Register is a function of three inputs [I] + +Register is not a setting on the speaker. It is selected from the pair +(speaker's standing and community, scene relation to addressee and subject) +and the situation, with stance as the final modulator. This is what +`persona-drives-ontology` implies on `main` and what the +`language-ontology` cut will implement as deterministic selection +`select(profile, stance, speaker, scene)`. This spec supplies the **content +of that selection table** for this language; it does not write the table. + +Cases the table must cover first: + +| Case | Expected pull | +|---|---| +| Commentator, high restraint, strong approval of a restrained low-means act | finished marking; evaluative layer foregrounded; length withheld | +| Commentator, low restraint, strong approval | raw marking; the speaker is performing delight. Only permitted in tourist-adjacent registers | +| Master addressing rival | held or finished; address by field and standing | +| Tourist, any affect | claimant standing; over-lengthened; evaluation layer present but misapplied | +| Host to a human guest on a panel | warmth and appraisal mixed: affection plus contempt at high restraint is the *normal* pairing. The guest's rejection is absorbed as form | + +The last row is the story's turn written as a stance mapping, and is worth +testing first: contempt and affection together, restrained, with the evaluation +layer calling the rejection *sincere*. + +## 4. Meaning Before Surface + +The language is never produced by substituting English words with alien +ones. The method is the Weksa path (`language-model.md`): packet, then +ontology projection that can split, collapse or reweight concepts, then +grammar commitments, morphology, phonology, surface. + +### Concept splits and collapses [E→I] + +The source names distinctions the language must make (`language-design.md`, +Open Questions). Each is decomposed below into components so a lowerer can +select a form from the packet's facts and not from a gloss. + +| Distinction | Decomposition (hypothesis) | Needs from the packet | +|---|---|---| +| **victory** vs **mastery** vs **spectacle** vs **vulgar overmatch** | victory: outcome of a contest. mastery: outcome *plus* demonstrated chosen constraint. spectacle: attention drawn, independent of constraint. vulgar overmatch: means exceed the opposing means with no constraint chosen. | outcome; each party's means; whether the means were chosen | +| **crude** vs **failed** | crude: sincere, unrefined, with form attempted. failed: form collapsed into mere function. | actor's means and discipline as facts; the stance of the performer is not available, so the ontology reads from conduct | +| **resistance** admired and absorbable | resistance read as: threat, folk art, breakout talent (`battle-royale.md` commentary list). Choice depends on whether it centers a performer or a practice. | performer-centered vs distributed agency | +| **public spectacle** vs **living practice** [E] | spectacle: meaning lives in a central performer. practice: meaning lives in relationships. The empire reads distributed cooperation as noise or misattributes it to a performer. | number and relation of agents; presence of a focal agent | +| **unpainted**, split | shame / danger / contempt / rawness / refusal / purity (the source lists these senses). Different surface forms: the sense is selected by relation and stance, not by a gloss. | decoration state, scene relation, speaker stance | + +### Scale decoration in grammar and metaphor [E→I] + +Decoration is the language's central metaphor domain [E: used for rank, +grief, celebrity and more]. Proposed uses, to be tested not asserted: + +- **Address**: terms of address name a decoration claim ("the one marked for + ...") instead of a rank noun. +- **Insult**: lack, mismatch or fraud of decoration (a claim not backed by + constraint). The strongest insult is the claimant who is also vulgar. +- **Praise**: finish, as in a surface completed. +- **Metaphor**: grief and obligation are *worn*. A human speaking of loss + reads, in this language, as a person visibly undecorated by it. + +The source does not say whether the language has these metaphors. They are +the draft's strongest invention and the easiest to overrule. + +### Root families [I] + +House method: faint family resemblance, never a nametag. No roots are +proposed here. The first root set should come from the field concepts +(combat, speech, hosting, trade, art) and the constraint/finish axis, and +should be minted against corpus items, not authored in a vacuum. + +### Contamination direction [E] + +What leaks into human English first (`language-design.md`) is an open +question. [I] Candidates are evaluation-layer particles (the empire's form +verdicts become meme tags) and the claim/finish vocabulary, because the +story's kids absorb *prestige codes* first. The subtitle renderer is a +separate target profile and not this spec's job. + +## 5. Evidence and Invention, Summarized + +**Evidence-backed (E):** +- reptilian, aesthetic-honor, decoration-as-status speakers; unpainted as + profound shamelessness; unpainted-as-provocation for a rare few +- mastery requires chosen constraint; overmatch and tourists are vulgar; the + lens questions +- the empire is a network; commerce carries, culture conquers; the registers + listed +- broadcast commentary and flavor-first subtitles as the runtime use +- the packet has `stance` with felt affect and restraint; the ontology maps + them (on `main`) + +**Invention (I):** +- the two-axis status ladder and the claim/demonstrated-constraint mismatch +- the whole phonological inventory and prosody +- the five obligatory categories and the inverted restraint reading +- the decoration-grammar and metaphor uses +- the speech situations table, notably the address-to-humans row +- the contempt-plus-affection panel pairing + +**Not settled in the source and left open:** +- the language's and speakers' names; the vocal tract; whether the empire is + one language community or a family of dialects; whether non-reptilian + imperial subjects speak it and how it marks them + +## 6. What The Lowerer Must Provide + +Interlingua rule [E]: the packet carries neutral meaning plus source-side +communicative pressure, and target-language concept splits belong +downstream. The earlier Rust to Dust sketch in `language-design.md` puts an +`aesthetic_reading` block (form, discipline, spectacle, honor status) **in +the packet**. This draft recommends moving it: those are the *imperial +ontology's reading* of neutral facts, so they belong in the ontology +projection, and the packet carries the facts the reading is derived from. +[I] This is a change to existing content and the operator should rule on it. + +Fields, in order of need. "Seed" means the standard's inventory already has +a slot. "Gap" means the standard has no field yet; per the Promotion Rule, +the gap is first an `rtd.*` extension and is promoted only after use in two +real packets. + +| Need | Why | Status | +|---|---|---| +| `stance` with felt affect and `restraint` | the whole of Section 3 | seed (on `main`) | +| **speaker** axes: field, standing in field, school or lineage, decoration state, community | status and register selection | seed slot `Speaker` (still planned, cut `speaker-scene`); the *values* are the gap | +| **scene**: relative status of speaker, subject and audience; audience composition (imperial, tourist, human via subtitles) | register and address | seed slot `Scene` (still planned, cut `speaker-scene`) | +| `medium` and `setting` ids for broadcast commentary | situation selection | seed (`context`) | +| `instrument` role on predications, **for each party** | overmatch is derived from both parties' means | seed role | +| **volition of the constraint**: chosen / compelled / unknown, as a predication feature | the line between mastery and mere lacking | gap (`rtd.` extension first) | +| **ordering of means** (power or means gap) | vulgar overmatch | not a packet field: ontology-side order over concept ids, so the packet carries concepts and the ontology compares them | +| referent **decoration state** (decorated / unpainted / bare-by-claim / not applicable) | status, insult, the human-undecorated reading | gap (`rtd.` extension first) | +| referent **community** or `member_of` relation | tourist versus warrior; human versus imperial | seed relation `member_of`; community ids come from the `language-ontology` cut | +| **focal agent** presence | spectacle versus living practice | derivable: a predication with plural or no agent role; not a new field | +| `evidentiality` | witnessed versus inferred sincerity | seed feature (to confirm its option set) | +| `polarity`, tense, aspect | ordinary | seed | +| `preserve` | which nodes the commentary must keep | seed (`constraints`) | + +Fields the draft deliberately does **not** request: `aesthetic_reading`, +`honor_status`, `spectacle_value` or any value judgment. The performer's +sincerity is not telemetry, and the commentator infers it. These are +outputs of the imperial ontology and must not be put into the packet by the +client, or the client is deciding the language's concepts. + +## 7. Dependencies, Risks and Next Cuts + +**Dependencies.** Stance is on `main` (Weksa PR #3). Only the `Speaker` and `Scene` +slots are still planned, under cut `speaker-scene`. The `language-ontology` cut +(community and ontology-entry documents) is not landed. This spec states +the content those cuts will hold, and does not substitute for them. + +**Risks.** +- The inventory and the grammar are heavily invented on thin evidence. Mitigation: + tag everything (done) and test the five obligatory categories against the + lowerer before building roots. +- The claim-versus-constraint ladder risks making the language a *status-code + detector*. The source's hold is that honor is devotion, not rank. Test: + can the grammar say a bare-by-claim performance without calling it low? +- Draft collided with `language-design.md`'s packet-side `aesthetic_reading`. + Resolved by ruling `rtd-imperial-aesthetic-reading-to-ontology` (below). + +**Next cuts, in order.** +1. (done) Operator rulings on the four forks, recorded above. +2. A first corpus slice: ten broadcast-commentary utterances, each decomposed + to a packet (neutral facts plus stance), with the expected surface *category* + (finish class, evaluation layer) and no words yet. +3. The selection table for Section 3's first five cases. +4. A root set from the field concepts, and a naming brief for the language. +5. An orthography and a pronunciation lowering. + +**Rulings (2026-11-05, all in force).** The four forks are answered. Their +ids are in the mind's `weksa-body` campaign. +- `rtd-imperial-aesthetic-reading-to-ontology`: `aesthetic_reading` leaves the + packet and lives in the imperial ontology. The packet carries neutral facts + plus stance; form, discipline, spectacle and honor status are the ontology's + reading of them. Section 6 stands. +- `rtd-imperial-two-axis-status`: status is two axes, field and standing, by + claim versus demonstrated constraint. +- `rtd-imperial-inverted-restraint`: restraint is the display of virtue; low + restraint with strong affect is vulgar. +- `rtd-imperial-human-stylized-tract`: the vocal tract is human-pronounceable + stylization, with length as ornament. diff --git a/settings/rust-to-dust/language-design.md b/settings/rust-to-dust/language-design.md index 146bd16..4ef1446 100644 --- a/settings/rust-to-dust/language-design.md +++ b/settings/rust-to-dust/language-design.md @@ -52,7 +52,9 @@ Likely language-project registers: ## Runtime Data Needs -Structured intent should carry neutral facts plus cultural annotations. +Structured intent carries neutral facts plus stance. The imperial ontology +derives form, discipline, spectacle and honor status from them downstream +(see `imperial/language-design.md`, Section 6). Example: @@ -62,13 +64,6 @@ Example: "act": "ambush", "actor": "father", "target": "imperial_guard", - "aesthetic_reading": { - "form": "raw", - "discipline": "improvised", - "spectacle_value": "high", - "honor_status": "ambiguous", - "aesthetic_promise": "rising" - }, "imperial_frame": "authentic_local_defiance" } ``` diff --git a/state/map.yaml b/state/map.yaml index 95009bf..7d62e94 100644 --- a/state/map.yaml +++ b/state/map.yaml @@ -221,10 +221,10 @@ open_questions: - What is the minimal Rust to Dust language-project slice that proves the engine without hard-coding the setting into it? - What minimal Eusocial Interbeing language-project slice can prove naming for - Airawa, Sa'auei'a, ecological partner, and imperial registers without + Airawa, Sa'ueia, ecological partner, and imperial registers without collapsing them into one universal language? - Which Zyphos language project should be first: Airawa, imperial Airawa, - Sa'auei'a, or a narrow naming-brief interlingua? + Sa'ueia, or a narrow naming-brief interlingua? - What is the minimal Airawa starter lexicon and permission model needed to translate the first chieftain/visitor/mother-tree scene honestly? - How should Airawa encode honorable scars: bodily evidence, honor claim, debt