From e8add7409a3f7f93d9071a43b27a2eaf6733b8df Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Meta Vens Date: Sat, 22 Aug 2026 22:07:31 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] Add lore review council and AI prose critic --- .epiphany/project-memory.md | 4 +- .epiphany/state/project-memory.cc | Bin 6494 -> 7542 bytes AGENTS.md | 16 +- workshop/deepening/README.md | 21 +- workshop/deepening/benchmark.md | 14 +- workshop/deepening/body-map.md | 35 +++- workshop/deepening/ledger.md | 40 ++++ workshop/deepening/pass-template.md | 31 +++ .../passes/KALSA-032-review-council.md | 191 ++++++++++++++++++ workshop/deepening/queue.md | 6 +- .../reviews/KALSA-032/baseline-packet.md | 97 +++++++++ .../KALSA-032/diagnosis/AI-Isms and Prose.md | 89 ++++++++ .../Culture and Situated Knowledge.md | 125 ++++++++++++ .../Ghostlight Play and Consequence.md | 102 ++++++++++ .../diagnosis/History Conflict and Change.md | 95 +++++++++ .../diagnosis/Institutional Causality.md | 142 +++++++++++++ .../diagnosis/Material Life and Ecology.md | 87 ++++++++ .../Reader Experience and Navigation.md | 118 +++++++++++ .../reviews/KALSA-032/final-packet.md | 54 +++++ .../reviews/KALSA-032/final-reader-packet.md | 18 ++ .../reviews/KALSA-032/final-revalidation.md | 49 +++++ .../reviews/KALSA-032/reader-packet.md | 18 ++ .../KALSA-032/regression/AI-Isms and Prose.md | 43 ++++ .../Culture and Situated Knowledge.md | 45 +++++ .../Ghostlight Play and Consequence.md | 45 +++++ .../regression/History Conflict and Change.md | 44 ++++ .../regression/Institutional Causality.md | 47 +++++ .../regression/Material Life and Ecology.md | 42 ++++ .../Reader Experience and Navigation.md | 104 ++++++++++ .../reviews/KALSA-032/repaired-packet.md | 81 ++++++++ .../KALSA-032/repaired-reader-packet.md | 19 ++ .../deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/synthesis.md | 101 +++++++++ workshop/review-council/README.md | 157 ++++++++++++++ .../critics/AI-Isms and Prose.md | 62 ++++++ .../critics/Culture and Situated Knowledge.md | 24 +++ .../Ghostlight Play and Consequence.md | 26 +++ .../critics/History Conflict and Change.md | 20 ++ .../critics/Institutional Causality.md | 22 ++ .../critics/Material Life and Ecology.md | 25 +++ .../Reader Experience and Navigation.md | 22 ++ workshop/review-council/packet-template.md | 58 ++++++ .../review-council/regression-template.md | 38 ++++ workshop/review-council/report-template.md | 51 +++++ workshop/review-council/shared-prompt.md | 37 ++++ workshop/review-council/synthesis-template.md | 48 +++++ 45 files changed, 2495 insertions(+), 18 deletions(-) create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/passes/KALSA-032-review-council.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/baseline-packet.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/AI-Isms and Prose.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Culture and Situated Knowledge.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Ghostlight Play and Consequence.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/History Conflict and Change.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Institutional Causality.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Material Life and Ecology.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Reader Experience and Navigation.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/final-packet.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/final-reader-packet.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/final-revalidation.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/reader-packet.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/AI-Isms and Prose.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Culture and Situated Knowledge.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Ghostlight Play and Consequence.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/History Conflict and Change.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Institutional Causality.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Material Life and Ecology.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Reader Experience and Navigation.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/repaired-packet.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/repaired-reader-packet.md create mode 100644 workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/synthesis.md create mode 100644 workshop/review-council/README.md create mode 100644 workshop/review-council/critics/AI-Isms and Prose.md create mode 100644 workshop/review-council/critics/Culture and Situated Knowledge.md create mode 100644 workshop/review-council/critics/Ghostlight Play and Consequence.md create mode 100644 workshop/review-council/critics/History Conflict and Change.md create mode 100644 workshop/review-council/critics/Institutional Causality.md create mode 100644 workshop/review-council/critics/Material Life and Ecology.md create mode 100644 workshop/review-council/critics/Reader Experience and Navigation.md create mode 100644 workshop/review-council/packet-template.md create mode 100644 workshop/review-council/regression-template.md create mode 100644 workshop/review-council/report-template.md create mode 100644 workshop/review-council/shared-prompt.md create mode 100644 workshop/review-council/synthesis-template.md diff --git a/.epiphany/project-memory.md b/.epiphany/project-memory.md index 8df2d06..8205478 100644 --- a/.epiphany/project-memory.md +++ b/.epiphany/project-memory.md @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ --- title: Kalsa Project Memory status: active -snapshot_at: 2026-08-22T17:26:42Z +snapshot_at: 2026-08-22T19:54:33Z --- # Kalsa Project Memory @@ -29,6 +29,8 @@ database and does not grant canon status to any setting claim. - `memory-public-epistemic-ownership` — `Kalsa/Public/` is an inhabitant-facing knowledge commons, not an abbreviated author encyclopedia. Explanatory models require a culture, institution, lineage, text, witness, or named synthesis; translated terms must carry evidence, material reproduction, interests, and characteristic limits rather than smuggling backstage taxonomy into player knowledge. - `memory-divine-uncertainty` — Gods are powerful, situated witnesses rather than authorial oracles. Divine confidence, memory, doctrine, and testimony remain evidence shaped by binding, rivalry, self-conception, and blind spots. - `memory-play-canon` — Persistent play creates receipts and canon candidates. Runtime outcomes become shared setting canon only when an owning canonical note explicitly adopts them. +- `memory-independent-lore-review` — Every deepening pass uses seven independent lore critics before repair and after repair: institutional causality; culture and situated knowledge; material life and ecology; history, conflict, and change; Ghostlight play and consequence; AI-isms and prose; and reader experience and navigation. Critics diagnose, the coordinator adjudicates, subject notes own canon, and a no-finding report is valid. +- `memory-ai-ism-judgment` — AI-shaped prose is diagnosed by recurring construction and reading effect, never detector scores, word bans, or authorship claims. Kalsa's known pressure includes correction theatre, symmetrical wonder-then-cost ledgers, list-clause congestion, repeated frames, checksum conclusions, viewpoint choruses, workshop-dialect leakage, and generic smoothing; functional lists, deliberate rhetoric, and precise technical terms remain protectable. ## Open questions diff --git a/.epiphany/state/project-memory.cc b/.epiphany/state/project-memory.cc index 11994c52afd06205d5abec2b8aecb8550781a26d..0077c96833043f20736343b59ee215ee672b4b6d 100644 GIT binary patch delta 1316 zcmZ8f&5ImG6lcuGl4MPSlB|N_TL>iJbl6N*(OEpGNKkJfA&^^5_3Q51t*&b8RnI!0 z%)cNEUL=2lpwN2HLC@;JixBbX%|jr$1oT(EAI=1ZX5Op!@%wmxj-HIazcg4MZH>3^ z+rIzvYj+o$gV!%_eEq{{YxH)u^-eY#-MR7Z_^s{n&6|sdr#2Vu;J3Bq*uC)UQcNA6 zxHecyY<54MJb9ex9-dk|4*GHboc?>I`rkELDd=vUIlq!ve0lciO2>n9udWt6T7Py_ z(Eat|2P===Cl}5wC#d`4;#bRw&BdejGmH0LdVDkjD5<;m^0zBR-J6&GC)M+~clr0_ zj`<&h?`p1nm}SQ0+%P^aX4VJJ0#6O^kLjZ+hZ*IZUX3fMQ6kg|3kgrz(NZI&M$*AV zqlG41q%d%!Od#cQQbpu&m>8o`=F!A98t;@Pty)pm#Mut%*2WgCsYg(uBImT{{J!P9 zBJ}ON#&aiI$6NNHnpcpU`l6DvV;Gcr1m~mkY|UAJFV-{ z_xC6fGjg_O!T|^10ij1;iqEojR85o)A8d&HW8HE^{TN#;InHWtz zz^XX8l<^`vGCz;$0uo seven independent diagnoses -> coordinator + dispositions -> named-owner repair -> seven regressions -> ordinary seed, + link, layout, publication, Quartz, rendered-page, and diff verification. +- **Deletion/demotion line:** the former omnibus critique and undifferentiated + Soul checkbox are demoted. Canon fidelity, provenance, ownership, and spoiler + safety remain cross-cutting constraints and final checks, not a continuity + critic seat. +- **Verification layer:** report inventory, every-finding disposition, blind + reader packet where Public is in scope, no unresolved accepted essential + defect, negative authority checks, and the repository verification suite. +- **Unresolved seam:** report assembly and dispatch remain Markdown-first. No + runtime or automation owns them until repetition justifies that machinery. + ## Canonical substrate - **Owner:** `Kalsa/Spoilers/Foundations/` owns world, Ark/Fall, Prometheus, Kaos, Projection/God/thaumavore metaphysics, Gift taxonomy, and language/reckoning inheritance; `Kalsa/Spoilers/Reference/Canon and Provenance.md` owns canon-state vocabulary. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/ledger.md b/workshop/deepening/ledger.md index fd7e3f6..574bb9f 100644 --- a/workshop/deepening/ledger.md +++ b/workshop/deepening/ledger.md @@ -69,3 +69,43 @@ promoted or retired. - **Verification:** nine immutable seed witnesses; 551 complete-vault wikilinks across 69 notes; 34 Public links across nine reader notes; publication, vault-layout, negative-tool, and exact-output checks; production Quartz build of nine inputs and 33 outputs; rendered inspection of the home, magic, and teaching-source pages. - **Durable judgment promoted:** Public explanations require a situated inhabitant owner, evidence practice, institutional body, and characteristic limit. A local synonym without those consequences is only the author taxonomy in costume. - **Open pressure:** KALSA-031 repeats this audit for the remaining traditions one bounded owner at a time; exact Ju'onai descendant-language forms, school antiquity, and regional variations remain unresolved. + +## 2026-08-22 — Lore review council and AI-ism calibration + +- **Scope:** [[passes/KALSA-032-review-council|KALSA-032]], establishing a + version-controlled seven-seat Lore Review Council for every future deepening + pass. +- **Authority cut:** critics diagnose independently; the coordinator adjudicates + and integrates; subject notes retain canon. A generic Soul checkbox, + consensus, detector, word list, or automatic rewrite cannot stand in for the + named reports. +- **Council:** Institutional Causality; Culture and Situated Knowledge; + Material Life and Ecology; History, Conflict, and Change; Ghostlight Play and + Consequence; AI-Isms and Prose; Reader Experience and Navigation. Every seat + returned a raw diagnosis and a regression on one frozen implementation; the + reader turns used blind Public packets. +- **First verdict:** Institutional Causality blocked completion because the + baseline omitted an in-scope hash, repaired candidates were not frozen, and + findings lacked stable identities. Other critics found informal-knowledge, + material-chain, event-evidence, play-access, universal-action-menu, and + term-origin seams. +- **Repair:** prompts and templates now preserve snapshot identity, coordinator + occupancy, finding IDs, informal reproduction paths, inhabitant-model limits, + material handoffs, evidence scope, event owners, bounded Ghostlight access, + target-earned interventions, play traces, and culturally owned technical + language. +- **Regression:** all accepted findings passed their original seats. Six + grounded critics verified every implementation hash; a fresh reader found no + spoiler or process-language leak and independently confirmed the deferred + Public voice and navigation pressure. +- **Canonical lore changed:** none. KALSA-031 and KALSA-024 carry bounded + cultural and historical pressure; KALSA-033 owns Public entry-route, + dead-end, and narrator-voice repair. +- **Verification:** seven diagnostic and seven regression artifacts; 23 memory + records projected to CultCache; nine seed witnesses; vault enclosure; 551 + links across 69 canonical notes; Public-only source and output boundaries; + lore-tool negative tests; Quartz build of nine inputs and 33 outputs. +- **Durable judgment promoted:** review specialties must speak independently, + preserve raw disagreement, and regress the same repaired body. AI-shaped prose + is diagnosed through recurrent construction and reading effect, never + authorship claims, token bans, or detector scores. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/pass-template.md b/workshop/deepening/pass-template.md index bdc486e..b619f5f 100644 --- a/workshop/deepening/pass-template.md +++ b/workshop/deepening/pass-template.md @@ -3,6 +3,7 @@ pass_id: KALSA-000 status: draft target: replace-me canonical_owner: unresolved +coordinator: replace-me started: YYYY-MM-DD completed: --- @@ -63,6 +64,32 @@ What real setting and play outcome does this pass serve? - Consequences that stop at the page edge: - Duplicate or ambiguous owners: +## Review council + +- **Packet identity:** +- **Repaired packet identity:** +- **Packet path:** +- **Protected strengths:** +- **In-scope inhabitant model boundary:** owner or synthesis; evidence and + reproduction; useful domain; blind spot; protected unknown. +- **Ghostlight lens:** point of contact; character-accessible evidence; + target-supported interventions; consequence horizon or play-bearing owner. +- **Event-owner evidence or explicit evidence gap:** + +| Critic | Diagnostic report | Verdict | Regression report | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Institutional Causality | | | | +| Culture and Situated Knowledge | | | | +| Material Life and Ecology | | | | +| History, Conflict, and Change | | | | +| Ghostlight Play and Consequence | | | | +| AI-Isms and Prose | | | | +| Reader Experience and Navigation | | | | + +- **Synthesis and dispositions:** +- **Accepted repair brief:** +- **Deferred pressure added to queue:** + ## Repair - Canonical files to change: @@ -101,6 +128,10 @@ claimed mechanism? - [ ] Affected rendered pages were inspected. - [ ] Git diff changes only intended owners and supporting indexes. - [ ] Benchmark review completed without treating counts as proof. +- [ ] All seven independent diagnostic reports exist. +- [ ] Every substantive finding has a coordinator disposition. +- [ ] All seven regression reports exist; no essential accepted defect remains. +- [ ] The final closeout names what should now be left alone. ## Decision record diff --git a/workshop/deepening/passes/KALSA-032-review-council.md b/workshop/deepening/passes/KALSA-032-review-council.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..815b1f8 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/passes/KALSA-032-review-council.md @@ -0,0 +1,191 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +status: complete +target: mandatory deepening review council and AI-ism prose critic +canonical_owner: workshop/review-council/README.md +coordinator: Codex /root +started: 2026-08-22 +completed: 2026-08-22 +--- + +# KALSA-032 — Deepening Review Council + +## Objective + +Make every critique/repair pass answer to several independent editorial +faculties before completion. Add one critic dedicated to recurring AI-shaped +prose habits, grounded in the current Vault rather than a generic banned-word +list. + +## Source inventory + +### External and neighboring evidence + +- Wikipedia's `Signs of AI writing` field guide is descriptive rather than + prescriptive. It identifies clusters such as superficial significance, + vague attribution, negative parallelism, rule-of-three lists, inflated + copular substitutes, abstract associations, repeated formatting templates, + and excessive rhetorical symmetry. It warns that signs are not proof and + that detectors and human guesses produce false positives. +- AetheriaLore's live `Vault Cleanup` contract separates Modeling, Imagination, + fresh-reader questioning, source-bounded lore research, Hands, and Soul. + Its `Revision Council Master Prompt`, `Revision Council Specialist Prompts`, + and `Revision Council Passes` provide the reusable independent-report, + coordinator-adjudication, bounded-repair, regression, and fresh-reader shape. + Kalsa does not copy its novel-specific specialties. + +### Kalsa evidence + +- Public and author prose repeatedly uses corrective antithesis, especially + `not X; Y`, `rather than`, and `can ... and still ...`. +- Public summaries often praise a wonder, immediately balance it with social + costs, and close with a list-shaped moral checksum. The Ti'asantatca passage + in `Public/World/Peoples and Polities.md` is the clearest operator-identified + example. +- Lists of four to eight nouns recur as a signal of comprehensiveness even when + one concrete consequence would carry more force. +- Authoring vocabulary such as `authority`, `bounded`, `material`, `legible`, + `claim`, `record`, `preserve`, and `consequence` is load-bearing in workshop + maps but can flatten culture, setting prose, and character speech into one + institutional essay voice. +- Existing Soul review is strong at truth, ownership, and boundary checks but + has no durable prompt surface for prose uncanniness or reader fatigue. + +## Authority map before repair + +- **Owner:** the pass coordinator informally decides which reviews to request + and how to interpret them. +- **Inputs:** seed evidence, owner notes, pass records, diff, benchmark, and + occasional ad hoc specialist findings. +- **Outputs:** one synthesis and a final Soul verdict. +- **Derived state:** commentary, agent reports, and grep inventories may reveal + pressure but have no standard artifact or completion gate. +- **Forbidden writers:** reviewers may not write canon, but this is convention + rather than an explicit council contract. +- **Shared paths:** no required path guarantees that every dedicated critic + receives the same candidate or speaks before repair. +- **Cut line:** retire ceremonial `Soul review` checkboxes that can be satisfied + by one undifferentiated opinion. + +## Process model + +- **Function:** seven independent lore critics inspect one immutable review packet; + the coordinator adjudicates their findings; the same seven receive the + repaired candidate for bounded regression. +- **Authority and enforcement limits:** critics diagnose and recommend. They do + not edit canon, vote truth into existence, or compel a rewrite by majority. +- **Material support:** stable prompts, one shared report contract, raw reports, + synthesis, dispositions, regression reports, and the pass record. +- **Variation:** Reader Experience receives reader-visible prose without + workshop intention or hidden canon. Other critics receive only the context + necessary for their remit. +- **Internal contradiction:** requiring all voices can become ceremony. A + critic may return `no finding`; the coordinator must not manufacture work to + justify the role. + +## Repair + +- Add `workshop/review-council/` as the process owner. +- Define seven dedicated critics: institutional causality; culture and situated + knowledge; material life and ecology; history, conflict, and change; + Ghostlight play and consequence; AI-isms and prose; and reader experience + and navigation. +- Give the AI-Isms and Prose critic a Kalsa-specific calibration without + converting examples into forbidden strings. +- Require raw independent reports, coordinator dispositions, and post-repair + regression from every critic in each deepening loop. +- Integrate the council into the deepening README, pass template, benchmark, + Body map, project instructions, and project memory. + +## Review council + +- **Packet identity:** `KALSA-032-baseline-01`; candidate blob hashes are + recorded in the packet. +- **Repaired packet identity:** `KALSA-032-repaired-02`; all six grounded seats + verified its 21 blobs and a final blind reader passed the unchanged Public + surface. See [[../reviews/KALSA-032/final-revalidation]]. +- **Packet path:** `workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/baseline-packet.md`; + Reader Experience used `reader-packet.md`. +- **Protected strengths:** seven distinct lore remits, independent speech, + explicit no-finding reports, blind Public reading, coordinator authority, + canon boundaries, seed specificity, and contextual rather than detector-led + prose criticism. + +| Critic | Diagnostic report | Verdict | Regression report | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Institutional Causality | [[../reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Institutional Causality]] | Block | [[../reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Institutional Causality]] — Pass | +| Culture and Situated Knowledge | [[../reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Culture and Situated Knowledge]] | Pass with findings | [[../reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Culture and Situated Knowledge]] — Pass | +| Material Life and Ecology | [[../reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Material Life and Ecology]] | Pass with findings | [[../reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Material Life and Ecology]] — Pass | +| History, Conflict, and Change | [[../reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/History Conflict and Change]] | Pass with findings | [[../reviews/KALSA-032/regression/History Conflict and Change]] — Pass | +| Ghostlight Play and Consequence | [[../reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Ghostlight Play and Consequence]] | Pass with findings | [[../reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Ghostlight Play and Consequence]] — Pass | +| AI-Isms and Prose | [[../reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/AI-Isms and Prose]] | Pass with findings | [[../reviews/KALSA-032/regression/AI-Isms and Prose]] — Pass | +| Reader Experience and Navigation | [[../reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Reader Experience and Navigation]] | Pass with findings | [[../reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Reader Experience and Navigation]] — Pass with deferred findings | + +- **Synthesis and dispositions:** [[../reviews/KALSA-032/synthesis]]. +- **Accepted repair brief:** harden snapshot identity, finding IDs, + coordinator provenance, informal knowledge transmission, inhabitant-model + boundaries, material chains, event-owner evidence, Ghostlight access and play + traces, target-supported interventions, and AI-ism term-origin analysis. +- **Deferred pressure added to queue:** KALSA-031 and KALSA-024 were narrowed; + KALSA-033 owns Public entry-route, dead-end, and narrator-voice repair. + +## Falsification + +### Hostile perspective + +A competent human writer uses antithesis, a three-item list, or the word +`bounded` because the sentence needs it. The critic must be able to protect the +passage and explain why local function outweighs statistical resemblance. + +### Stress case + +Seven critics disagree. The coordinator preserves every raw report, rules on +each substantive finding, and repairs only accepted defects. Absence of +consensus does not create split ownership; absence of a critic report blocks +completion. + +## Authority map after repair + +- **Owner:** `workshop/review-council/README.md` owns council membership, + sequencing, packet boundaries, and report requirements. The pass coordinator + owns adjudication. Canonical subject notes retain lore authority. +- **Inputs:** one immutable candidate packet, protected strengths, target + audience, exact source authority, and bounded context per critic. +- **Outputs:** seven raw reports, one synthesis with dispositions, seven + regression responses, and a finite repair list. +- **Derived state:** pattern counts, detector scores, consensus, and critic + confidence are evidence only. +- **Forbidden writers:** no critic, report, detector, word list, or majority + may edit canon or decide truth. +- **Shared paths:** packet → seven independent reports → coordinator + synthesis and dispositions → owner repair → seven regressions → final + verification and record. +- **Deleted or demoted authority:** an unchecked or generic `Soul review` label + no longer stands in for the council. + +## Verification + +- [x] All council prompts exist and name a distinct remit. +- [x] Every critic has a required report and regression contract. +- [x] Reader Experience has a blind packet boundary. +- [x] The AI-ism critic treats patterns as contextual evidence, not proof or + forbidden vocabulary. +- [x] Kalsa-specific recurring patterns appear in its calibration. +- [x] Deepening workflow and pass template require every critic to speak. +- [x] Seed hashes, links, publication boundary, and production build remain + valid. +- [x] Independent council regression finds no process ownership defect. + +## Decision record + +- **Adopted:** a seven-critic review council with coordinator adjudication. +- **Explicitly not adopted:** detector scores, automatic style gates, majority + voting, automatic critic edits, a dedicated continuity critic, or + novel-specific character, POV, chapter, and scene machinery. +- **Unresolved:** whether later automation should assemble packets and reports; + the process remains Markdown-first until a runtime owner exists. +- **Project-memory judgment promoted or retired:** promoted + `memory-independent-lore-review` and `memory-ai-ism-judgment`; regenerated the + CultCache projection. +- **Next highest-value pressure:** run the council against the Public vault and + repair accepted prose findings in a separate bounded pass. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/queue.md b/workshop/deepening/queue.md index 849a558..403c061 100644 --- a/workshop/deepening/queue.md +++ b/workshop/deepening/queue.md @@ -14,14 +14,16 @@ play value. | KALSA-006 | First society deepening pilot | One complete society pass will test the rubric, provenance scheme, and gameplay handoff before the loop scales. | complete and scaled | Ten owner clusters, five repair waves, and one direct-entry dungeon now exercise the loop. | | KALSA-022 | Final ownership repair | Candidate leakage and two split event owners remained after the second Soul pass. | complete | Alliance quarantined; Broken Windtrap and Grey Scald gained factual owners. | | KALSA-023 | Intuition polity and Alliance counterparty | The Alliance cannot reach canonical parity while one reciprocal owner is a blank source promise. | blocked | Source-grounded Intuition design or operator direction | -| KALSA-024 | Named regional variants | Current machinery is usable; future passes should add concrete houses, lineages, shrines, crews, routes, and settlements only where play creates pressure. | queued | Actual campaign or setting-use demand | +| KALSA-024 | Named regional variants | Current machinery is usable; future passes should add concrete houses, lineages, shrines, crews, routes, settlements, and mixed or cross-boundary lives only where play creates pressure. | queued | Actual campaign or setting-use demand | | KALSA-025 | Final Soul parity verdict | The first two Soul passes rejected specific defects; the final bounded pass verified their exact removal. | complete | Parity defensible for the adopted institutional set. | | KALSA-026 | Knowledge and spoiler architecture | The first publication collapsed author truth, reader lore, character knowledge, and GM answers into one surface. | complete | Eight situated reader notes, default-deny Quartz input, generated-route checks, and bounded Soul review passed. | | KALSA-027 | Kalsa world-compiler integration | Ghostlight needs world truth, retrieval evidence, and epistemic projections with typed affordances and leakage boundaries. | blocked | Ghostlight-owned compiler/runtime implementation and shared schema decision | | KALSA-028 | Spectacular surface adventure | The reader vault needs a magic-forward high-fantasy play proof alongside the industrial Ashen Intake. | queued | Bounded adventure selection and campaign demand | | KALSA-029 | Vault spoiler enclosure | The Quartz boundary was safe, but casual Obsidian exploration still exposed author domains and session recents. | complete | Author/GM tree enclosed, root gate neutral, workspace neutral and ignored, and negative checks passed. | | KALSA-030 | Inhabitant models and public epistemic ownership | The physical spoiler boundary is sound, but author mechanics still need culturally owned names, schools, lineages, disputes, and incomplete models before Public can become an inhabitant-facing knowledge commons. | complete | Ju'onai causal scholarship now owns openings, four rival lineages, attestation and administration remain separate authorities, and Public projects the dispute without exposing the author taxonomy. | -| KALSA-031 | Remaining situated magical traditions | The Ju'onai pass proves the method, but Selza'a, Jamnai, Papsenai, prophetic, Sarxe, divine, and technical explanations still need the same owner/evidence/institution/failure audit where author labels substitute for local thought. | queued | Work one bounded tradition at a time, prioritized by Public exposure and Ghostlight play pressure; do not invent the unresolved Intuition polity through this pass. | +| KALSA-031 | Remaining situated magical traditions | The Ju'onai pass proves the method, but Selza'a, Jamnai, Papsenai, prophetic, Sarxe, divine, and technical explanations still need the same owner/evidence/reproduction/failure audit where author labels substitute for local thought. | queued | Work one bounded tradition at a time, include one culturally owned non-magical relation or practice where evidence supports it, and inspect source-grounded historical formation without inventing an event or the unresolved Intuition polity. | +| KALSA-032 | Lore review council and AI-ism critic | Deepening passes need independent criticism across distinct lore-quality surfaces, including the recurring correction-theatre, moral-ledger, list-clause, and workshop-dialect prose habits found in the current vault. | complete | Seven versioned prompts, independent diagnoses, adjudication, same-snapshot regressions, memory, and verification passed. | +| KALSA-033 | Public entry route and narrator-voice repair | Blind reader and AI-ism calibration found a survey-first entrance, compelling dead-end glimpses, repeated narrator-level institutional cautions, and a praise-then-cost/list-clause cadence that flattens otherwise situated material. | queued | Freeze a Public packet; inspect canonical owners before changing presentation; preserve spoiler friction, Ju'onai's earned register, Low Sere mystery, and the two situated sources. | Do not fill the queue with every imaginable fantasy topic. Add an item when a real owner, dependency, contradiction, or play requirement creates pressure. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/baseline-packet.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/baseline-packet.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..57e06f1 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/baseline-packet.md @@ -0,0 +1,97 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +packet_id: KALSA-032-baseline-01 +candidate_identity: working-tree-blob-hashes-recorded-below +audience: future Kalsa pass coordinators and critic agents +public_blind_packet: false +--- + +# KALSA-032 Council Calibration Packet + +## Objective and scope + +- **Target:** the proposed Kalsa Lore Review Council, its seven remits, and its + integration into every institutional deepening pass. +- **Process owner:** `workshop/review-council/README.md`. +- **Files in scope:** the council README, shared prompt, seven critic prompts, + packet/report/synthesis templates, and the deepening README, pass template, + benchmark, queue, project instructions, and KALSA-032 pass record. +- **Calibration corpus:** `Kalsa/Public/index.md`, all notes under + `Kalsa/Public/World/`, and `Kalsa/Public/Sources/Four Readings of a Broken + Sluice.md`. +- **Repair boundary:** this pass may repair only workshop process, project + instructions, Body map, and project memory. Lore findings become named queue + pressure for a later bounded pass. + +## Authority and provenance + +- Immutable seed evidence remains under `seed/original/` and is not a process + edit target. +- Canonical subject notes retain lore authority. The council diagnoses; the + pass coordinator adjudicates; Hands repairs only named owners. +- `Kalsa/Public/` owns situated presentation. `Kalsa/Spoilers/` holds author and + GM truth. Workshop documents cannot settle setting facts. +- The protocol shape is adapted from AetheriaLore's Novella Council. Novel-only + roles and a dedicated continuity critic are intentionally omitted. +- Canon fidelity, provenance, ownership, and spoiler safety are cross-cutting + constraints and final verification duties rather than a council seat. + +## Protected strengths + +- Seven genuinely different lore-quality remits, not seven renamed general + editors. +- Every critic speaks independently before repair and again after repair. +- A no-finding report is valid; ceremony and manufactured findings are not. +- Critics preserve successes, identify collateral risk, and name an edit to + resist. +- Critics cannot write canon or decide by vote. +- Reader Experience uses a blind reader-visible packet when Public is in scope. +- The AI-Isms critic diagnoses recurrence and effect without detector scores, + word bans, authorship claims, or regex tribunals. + +## Known concerns + +- Distinct specialties can still overlap into seven versions of institutional + analysis. +- Requiring fourteen reports may become ceremony if packet and output contracts + are vague. +- The AI-Isms prompt must catch Kalsa's recurring corrective antithesis, + praise-then-cost ledger, list-clause density, repeated frames, checksum + conclusions, viewpoint chorus, and workshop dialect without banning useful + rhetoric or technical vocabulary. +- Lore-quality review must not drift into novel-specific continuity, scene, + character-arc, or chapter-pacing machinery. + +## Candidate identity + +The following Git blob hashes freeze the baseline reviewed by the council: + +```text +260b2e6cbba921625877228d92258dac7796b879 AGENTS.md +269904dde2d51d376fbfe6ba31276769f7ae8b7c workshop/deepening/README.md +0d280916d3175b07f57abdeb68619d72418b31c7 workshop/deepening/pass-template.md +942c71c050b655c1cb2abefb239764ea29ae8ee4 workshop/deepening/benchmark.md +2840a1b25c87d9290972e0b5132996ff50104a18 workshop/deepening/queue.md +82ceb03ec6cc95025833d80eccbafb24d8417cf4 workshop/deepening/passes/KALSA-032-review-council.md +4745e31d035e0d5bdf39c9f76ea05fb3e848e571 workshop/review-council/README.md +5ed604ff74fa93aa6bfbab1a2c73c7fd91e9ab50 workshop/review-council/shared-prompt.md +9e4c2a6fd7286b0e668b0fb69f473c2307885ac8 workshop/review-council/packet-template.md +622edf3b50ce763a71369274fc672573366d2f20 workshop/review-council/report-template.md +4761b44f333e56f111433bf6a096d100374d7c91 workshop/review-council/synthesis-template.md +d96d41f25259ac367395db8e4787004d71f8768f workshop/review-council/critics/Institutional Causality.md +980caf870b582b79709eacc20890b018a6401f36 workshop/review-council/critics/Culture and Situated Knowledge.md +a063984af257f2e3cc679cf0f7ddbd83194f31d2 workshop/review-council/critics/Material Life and Ecology.md +d33b34e1e13f7147893c02482589db6dd99f67a3 workshop/review-council/critics/History Conflict and Change.md +407cc738bad49fa012452a505cbc55bb8589d64f workshop/review-council/critics/Ghostlight Play and Consequence.md +db381663c0cbc0817417f8b8154bd9f5eb284a86 workshop/review-council/critics/AI-Isms and Prose.md +eeb0b26d2a53407f21766598cd337427dfe54346 workshop/review-council/critics/Reader Experience and Navigation.md +``` + +## Evidence limitations + +- This is a process calibration, not a claim that the whole Public vault has + received a final prose or lore repair. +- The exact AetheriaLore vault-critic prompts were not recovered; only the live + cleanup contract and Novella Council protocol were inspected. +- Current Public findings may identify later pressure but cannot authorize lore + edits in KALSA-032. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/AI-Isms and Prose.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/AI-Isms and Prose.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4244465 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/AI-Isms and Prose.md @@ -0,0 +1,89 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +packet_id: KALSA-032-baseline-01 +critic: AI-Isms and Prose +phase: diagnosis +verdict: pass-with-findings +--- + +# Critic Report + +## Concise diagnosis + +**Pass with findings. No blocking finding.** The prompt recognizes Kalsa's +actual recurring prose machinery and rejects detector logic, isolated-signal +verdicts, and word bans. One calibration seam remains: distinguish workshop +dialect from culturally owned technical language. + +## Protected successes + +- The prompt requires clusters, recurrence, context, and reading effect. +- Named patterns match the corpus: Ti'asantatca's praise-then-invoice paragraph, + corrective antithesis, list-clause congestion, overview chorus, and checksum + endings. +- It protects functional inventories, deliberate antithesis, + culture-specific rhetoric, and precise technical terms. + +## Findings + +### AIP-01 + +- **Priority:** High-value. +- **Location:** AI-Isms prompt, Workshop dialect leakage bullet and final + protection paragraph. +- **Evidence:** The corpus contains both genuine leakage and situated use of + the same vocabulary. `Public/index.md` closes in workshop-adjacent language + about situated learning and final words. Ju'onai passages use bounded, claim, + record, and institutional distinctions as owned intellectual practice. + `Four Readings` makes that register dramatic, contested, and speaker-owned. +- **Effect:** A critic could strip earned vocabulary from the Ju'onai while + failing to identify narrator-level diffusion as the defect. +- **Repair direction:** Require a term-origin test: narrator default, named + school or office, or particular speaker. Diagnose diffusion across unrelated + voices, not vocabulary alone. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not undo KALSA-030 or simplify the sluice dialogue. +- **Dependency:** Culture and Situated Knowledge. +- **Confidence:** High. + +### AIP-02 + +- **Priority:** Optional. +- **Location:** report template Findings, compared with the AI-Isms prompt's + final paragraph. +- **Evidence:** The specialist prompt requires recurrence evidence and retained + function; the shared fields do not name those obligations explicitly. +- **Effect:** A report could offer isolated stylistic dislikes or deletion + without preserving function. +- **Repair direction:** State in the specialist prompt that recurrence or + contrast belongs under Evidence, and retained function under Collateral risk. + Do not enlarge the shared template unless other seats need it. +- **Collateral risk:** Extra fields can turn the report into ceremony. +- **Dependency:** Process owner. +- **Confidence:** Medium. + +## Pattern or dependency map + +- **Correction theatre:** Public entrance and Relics and Ruins use recurring + `can ... and still` and `It does not` structures. +- **Symmetrical moral ledger:** Ti'asantatca is clearest; related praise-cost + cadences appear at the Public entrance, Hegemony, and mobility passages. +- **List-clause congestion:** common across Gods, Kalsa, Magic, and Peoples; + several lists remain functional. +- **Repeated frames and viewpoint chorus:** Magic traditions and polity + summaries give unrelated traditions one essay rhythm. +- **Checksum conclusions:** “Kalsa's wonder is not elsewhere,” the final Relics + aphorism, and Magic's “most dangerous sentence” explain prior examples. +- **Likely false positives:** cult-support and delving-compact inventories, and + corrective exchanges in `Four Readings`. + +## Tempting edit to resist + +Do not ban `not`, `bounded`, `claim`, `record`, or parallel clauses. Do not +“de-AI” `Four Readings of a Broken Sluice`; its antitheses belong to speakers +with incompatible stakes. + +## Ranked actions + +1. No essential action. +2. Add the term-origin test. +3. Clarify recurrence evidence and retained function inside existing fields. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Culture and Situated Knowledge.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Culture and Situated Knowledge.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..590d7c5 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Culture and Situated Knowledge.md @@ -0,0 +1,125 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +packet_id: KALSA-032-baseline-01 +critic: Culture and Situated Knowledge +phase: diagnosis +verdict: pass-with-findings +--- + +# Critic Report + +## Concise diagnosis + +**Pass with findings. No blocking finding.** The council explicitly protects +culturally owned disagreement, incomplete but usable theories, opacity, and +non-omniscient public knowledge. Its strongest calibration example—the broken +sluice dialogue—proves that this can work. Two handoff defects could still pull +future passes toward formal institutions and magic-indexed cultures. + +## Protected successes + +- The critic directly tests whether people exist beyond magic category, polity, + occupation, assigned psychology, and player arrival. It protects opacity and + unresolved belief instead of equating incompleteness with failure. +- The Situated Knowledge Benchmark gives incomplete models a rigorous shape: + evidence, owner, reproduction, useful domain, rival accounts, and + characteristic blind spot. “A local synonym for an author label scores + absent” defends against laundering backstage taxonomy. +- `Four Readings of a Broken Sluice.md` situates knowledge in circulating + client-college copies, trade-speech translation, rival schools, + administrative separation, and a keeper whose material objection survives + the schools' explanations. +- `Magic and Miracles.md` distinguishes what traditions can notice from what + they cannot establish; it grants none the author's final word. + +## Findings + +### CSK-01 + +- **Priority:** High-value. +- **Location:** `critics/Culture and Situated Knowledge.md`, paragraph beginning + “For every public explanation”; calibration examples in `Kalsa.md`, Crown + Cities and Roads through twilight. +- **Evidence:** The prompt requires every public explanation to have an + inhabitant owner, then asks for its “teaching body, patronage, instruments or + rites.” The corpus also contains diffuse knowledge: popular stories combine + rival Crown accounts; travellers learn warning marks, threshold speech, host + oaths, and route customs without a single school or patron. +- **Effect:** A literal critic may force household, oral, itinerant, customary, + or anonymous accumulated knowledge into a formal institution-shaped model. +- **Repair direction:** Trace the actual reproduction path: household + transmission, apprenticeship, oral repetition, seasonal gathering, market + circulation, ritual, travel, testimony, or formal teaching. Patronage and + instruments apply only where the model claims them. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not weaken the requirement for a legible inhabitant + source or let “common knowledge” become an omniscient author voice. +- **Dependency:** Institutional Causality where a formal school or office exists. +- **Confidence:** High. + +### CSK-02 + +- **Priority:** High-value. +- **Location:** `packet-template.md`, Authority and provenance; + `pass-template.md`, Institutional model and Review council. +- **Evidence:** The benchmark asks for owner, evidence, reproduction, useful + domain, rivals, blind spot, and unknowns, but the packet template offers only + one line for Public inhabitant presentation. The pass record has no durable + place to carry the tested boundary into adjudication and repair. +- **Effect:** The coordinator may repair a visible gap by completing the theory + from author knowledge. The good criterion exists, but its handoff is lossy. +- **Repair direction:** For in-scope public explanatory models, record + inhabitant owner or synthesis, evidence and reproduction path, useful domain, + characteristic blind spot, and protected unknown. Carry accepted boundaries + into protected material or the repair brief. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not inventory the whole vault, disclose hidden + taxonomy, or turn folk observation into schema ceremony. +- **Dependency:** Reader Experience, provenance, and spoiler verification. +- **Confidence:** High. + +### CSK-03 + +- **Priority:** Optional. +- **Location:** `queue.md`, KALSA-024 and KALSA-031; `Peoples and Polities.md`; + `Magic and Miracles.md`, What different traditions say. +- **Evidence:** Public presentation still introduces most named peoples through + polity and magical capacity. It contains useful counterevidence, but + KALSA-031 queues remaining magical traditions while KALSA-024 defers concrete + social variants until campaign demand. +- **Effect:** Successive passes could deepen magical explanations while leaving + humor, inheritance, ordinary aspiration, translation, class idiom, and mixed + lives as supporting texture around magic. +- **Repair direction:** Amend existing queued pressure: each situated-tradition + pass should test one non-magical relation or practice owned by the same + people, and KALSA-024 should include mixed and cross-boundary lives when play + creates pressure. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not invent the unresolved Intuition polity, demand + symmetrical coverage, or add generic festivals and cuisine. +- **Dependency:** History, Conflict, and Change; Material Life and Ecology. +- **Confidence:** Medium. + +## Pattern or dependency map + +The weak seam is transmission: + +`bounded inhabitant model -> packet summary -> coordinator disposition -> +repair brief` + +The packet and pass templates do not yet preserve the model's reproduction path +and protected limit. Queue selection also begins from magical traditions, so +ordinary culture depends on the critic pushing beyond the initial category. + +## Tempting edit to resist + +Do not require every people to receive matching sections for humor, kinship, +ritual, class, food, dissent, and aspiration. That would replace magic-category +flattening with checklist-category flattening. Protect uneven emphasis, diffuse +knowledge, and the broken-sluice dialogue's refusal to provide a final page. + +## Ranked actions + +1. No essential action. +2. Broaden formal reproduction language and preserve each in-scope model's + owner, evidence path, useful domain, blind spot, and protected unknown + through packet and repair handoff. +3. Tie KALSA-031 and KALSA-024 together without demanding symmetrical cultural + completion. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Ghostlight Play and Consequence.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Ghostlight Play and Consequence.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..653f212 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Ghostlight Play and Consequence.md @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +packet_id: KALSA-032-baseline-01 +critic: Ghostlight Play and Consequence +phase: diagnosis +verdict: pass-with-findings +--- + +# Critic Report + +## Concise diagnosis + +**Pass with findings.** The council creates real Ghostlight pressure: it asks +what characters can perceive and alter, demands durable consequences, and +protects uncertainty and inhabitant agency. Two seams could still turn that +pressure into generic quest menus: packets lack a bounded player-access lens, +while benchmark and prompt repeat a standard suite of intervention verbs. + +## Protected successes + +- The prompt tests what players can notice, attempt, misunderstand, change, + lose, carry away, or make worse without author knowledge. +- It protects uncertainty, asymmetric knowledge, unsolved problems, and lives + that do not begin when players arrive. +- `Relics and Ruins.md` demonstrates thresholds, claimants, irreversible acts, + incomplete evidence, refusal, rescue obligations, and durable receipts. +- `Four Readings of a Broken Sluice.md` provides a non-quest-shaped case: a + failed work, partial explanations, missing repair authority, material loss, + and a keeper who makes knowledge answer to a dry field. + +## Findings + +### GPC-01 + +- **Priority:** High-value. +- **Location:** packet template Objective and scope; council README Packet Contract. +- **Evidence:** Packets name target, owner, files, audience, and reader path, + but not a plausible character-facing entry, accessible evidence, available + kinds of intervention, or consequence horizon. +- **Effect:** The critic must assume capabilities from author context or produce + free-floating “players could” hooks. +- **Repair direction:** Add a small Ghostlight lens: plausible point of contact, + evidence available without backstage truth, and expected consequence horizon. + Permit an overview to route to a play-bearing owner. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not create adventure briefs, prescribe party + composition, or disclose GM answers. +- **Dependency:** Spoiler and knowledge boundaries; Reader Experience owns + navigation, not character capability. +- **Confidence:** High. + +### GPC-02 + +- **Priority:** High-value. +- **Location:** benchmark qualitative dimension 11; Ghostlight critic paragraph + beginning “Flag passive encyclopedia texture”. +- **Evidence:** The benchmark asks what happens when players help, harm, + capture, expose, or reform every target. The critic adds helping, exposing, + stealing, joining, reforming, and destroying. +- **Effect:** Each target may answer the same verb checklist even when its real + pressure is passage, testimony, maintenance, refusal, rescue, bargaining, or + accepting irreversible cost. +- **Repair direction:** Test only target-supported interventions. Require one + consequential choice or misunderstanding, a materially different response to + another plausible course, and a durable owner or receipt. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not weaken branching consequences or leave + institutions as untouchable encyclopedia objects. +- **Dependency:** Institutional Causality and this seat's player-visible remit. +- **Confidence:** High. + +### GPC-03 + +- **Priority:** Optional. +- **Location:** Ghostlight critic opening paragraph; report template Findings. +- **Evidence:** The remit names routes, actors, clocks, resources, hazards, and + bargains, but does not require one tested interaction. +- **Effect:** Reports may inventory missing ingredients without showing where + play becomes inert. +- **Repair direction:** When evidence permits, trace observable cue -> attempted + action or refusal -> resistance or misreading -> responding owner -> durable + consequence or receipt. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not demand a complete encounter, balanced scenario, + or single solution. +- **Dependency:** Institutional and Material mechanisms. +- **Confidence:** Medium. + +## Pattern or dependency map + +`orientation -> playable locus -> consequence-bearing interaction` + +The council should test that progression rather than demand that every page +perform all three jobs. + +## Tempting edit to resist + +Do not add Adventure Hooks headings, hook quotas, mandatory clocks, or a full +help/harm/join/destroy matrix to every lore note. + +## Ranked actions + +1. No essential action. +2. Add the bounded play-access lens and use target-earned interventions. +3. Calibrate findings around one evidence-supported play trace. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/History Conflict and Change.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/History Conflict and Change.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f0a9a5c --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/History Conflict and Change.md @@ -0,0 +1,95 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +packet_id: KALSA-032-baseline-01 +critic: History, Conflict, and Change +phase: diagnosis +verdict: pass-with-findings +--- + +# Critic Report + +## Concise diagnosis + +**Pass with findings.** The remit is distinct and useful: it tests formation, +path dependence, rival memory, and whether old conflicts still shape present +choices. It protects disputed chronology and does not demand one authoritative +public history. One packet-boundary gap prevents the factual-event ownership +check from being fully exercised. + +## Protected successes + +- The prompt requires one factual event owner while neighbors retain evidence, + memory, interpretation, and consequence. +- `Peoples and Polities.md`, under Sarxe and Saxfoldi, carries path dependence + from conquest and massacre into a mobile political center, distributed + survival, and continuing mobile/settled conflict. +- `Gods and the Dead.md`, under Covenant and submission, makes visually similar + rites carry incompatible histories of consent, inheritance, and conquest. +- `Four Readings of a Broken Sluice.md` preserves transmission, alteration, and + disagreement while keeping the repair dispute alive. + +## Findings + +### HCC-01 + +- **Priority:** High-value. +- **Location:** council README Packet Contract; packet template Objective and + scope and Authority and provenance; KALSA-032 calibration corpus. +- **Evidence:** The critic prompt requires checking that adopted event history + has one factual owner. The calibration packet supplies Public presentation + but no canonical event-owner notes for the Sarxe dispersals, divine + conquests, Crown histories, or Divided City conquest. +- **Effect:** The seat can test public memory and present consequences, but + cannot verify singular, duplicated, or absent factual ownership. +- **Repair direction:** When event ownership is under review, supply the + relevant owner and neighboring memory/consequence notes, or explicitly state + that ownership evidence is unavailable and outside the verdict. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not expose hidden canon to the blind reader, require + every pass to invent an event note, or turn factual ownership into one public + interpretation. +- **Dependency:** Process owner, provenance, and spoiler verification. +- **Confidence:** High. + +### HCC-02 + +- **Priority:** High-value, deferred lore pressure. +- **Location:** `Peoples and Polities.md`, Papsenai and Ti'asantatca, The Ju'onai + Hegemony, and The divided city. +- **Evidence:** These sections establish inherited shield service, + conquest-backed administration, levy conflict, overlapping imperial power, + and restricted prophetic knowledge, with little evidence of formation, + crises, failed reforms, or rival memories. +- **Effect:** The conflicts are playable and material, but some institutions + arrive as polished present-tense arrangements; their likely directions of + change are harder to derive. +- **Repair direction:** Queue later bounded owner passes to recover one + source-supported hinge, failed settlement, inherited compromise, or rival + memory. Invent no event merely to satisfy the rubric. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not produce an omniscient timeline, symmetrical + histories, or backstage explanation in compact Public pages. +- **Dependency:** Canonical owners; Culture and Situated Knowledge; + Institutional Causality. +- **Confidence:** Medium-high; hidden owner notes were outside this packet. + +## Pattern or dependency map + +- Conquest or massacre -> Sarxe memory -> mobile Saxfoldi -> distributed + survival and settled/mobile conflict. +- Chosen, inherited, or imposed covenant -> similar rite -> incompatible + obligations and consent claims. +- Layered occupation and adaptation -> ruin infrastructure -> current water, + burial, residency, and salvage claims. +- Present conflict without supplied formation -> Hegemony, Divided City, and + Ti'asantatca -> strong pressure but weaker trajectory. + +## Tempting edit to resist + +Do not reconcile Crown Cities, divine covenants, Sarxe dispersals, or broken +sluice traditions into one public chronology. The useful repair is culturally +owned memory tied to consequence, not an authorial master timeline. + +## Ranked actions + +1. No essential action. +2. Make event-owner evidence or its explicit absence part of the packet. +3. Defer Public historical pressure to later canonical-owner passes. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Institutional Causality.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Institutional Causality.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0eba841 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Institutional Causality.md @@ -0,0 +1,142 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +packet_id: KALSA-032-baseline-01 +critic: Institutional Causality +phase: diagnosis +verdict: block +--- + +# Critic Report + +## Concise diagnosis + +**Block.** The council's authority boundaries and specialist remit are sound, +but the current protocol does not preserve one immutable institutional body +across either review cycle. It also lacks stable finding identities through +adjudication and regression. Those defects make completion reproducible only by +trust in the coordinator's memory. + +## Protected successes + +- `workshop/review-council/README.md`, Authority Map through Repair Phase, + cleanly separates diagnosis, adjudication, repair, and canonical ownership. + Critics cannot decide lore, and majority agreement remains evidence rather + than authority. +- `critics/Institutional Causality.md` tests authorization, labor, + reproduction, enforcement limits, and failed handoffs without demanding a + universal bureaucracy. The calibration corpus proves the remit is specific: + `Relics and Ruins.md` separates technical competence from ownership, while + `Four Readings of a Broken Sluice.md` asks who owns repair after several + bounded authorities decline it. +- Independent reports, explicit no-finding outcomes, collateral protection, + and coordinator dispositions give defects a plausible route without turning + critics into canon writers. + +## Findings + +### IC-01 + +- **Priority:** Essential. +- **Location:** `baseline-packet.md`, Objective and scope and Candidate identity. +- **Evidence:** The KALSA-032 pass record is declared in scope, but + `workshop/deepening/passes/KALSA-032-review-council.md` has no recorded blob + hash. Its baseline hash is `82ceb03ec6cc95025833d80eccbafb24d8417cf4`; + every listed candidate hash otherwise matches. +- **Effect:** Critics can unknowingly review different versions of the process + model and authority map while the packet still claims an immutable shared + baseline. +- **Repair direction:** Add the pass record to the frozen identity, or remove + it from candidate scope and supply a frozen excerpt as context. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not create recursive hashing ceremony around the + packet or later reports. +- **Dependency:** Packet and provenance verification. +- **Confidence:** High; the declared scope and manifest disagree directly. + +### IC-02 + +- **Priority:** Essential. +- **Location:** `workshop/review-council/README.md`, Packet Contract, Regression + Phase, and Completion Gate. +- **Evidence:** The diagnostic candidate must be frozen, but regression critics + merely receive “the repaired candidate.” No repaired snapshot identity or + mutation boundary is required; only Reader Experience receives a newly + assembled packet. +- **Effect:** Sequential regression reports may inspect different repairs. A + later change can invalidate earlier regressions while all seven reports still + satisfy the completion gate. +- **Repair direction:** Freeze one repaired candidate identity before + regression. Derive critic-specific packets, including the blind reader + packet, from that snapshot. Any subsequent repair should invalidate the + affected regressions and begin another bounded cycle. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not leak hidden material into the Reader Experience + packet or require every critic to receive irrelevant files. +- **Dependency:** Reader Experience packet construction and final verification. +- **Confidence:** High; the first snapshot is explicit and the second is absent. + +### IC-03 + +- **Priority:** High-value. +- **Location:** `report-template.md`, Findings; `synthesis-template.md`, Finding + dispositions; `README.md`, Regression Phase. +- **Evidence:** Diagnostic findings receive no required identifier. The + synthesis invents an `ID`, while regression asks in prose which findings were + resolved. +- **Effect:** Split, merged, modified, and deferred findings can lose identity + between critic, coordinator, repair brief, and regression. An essential + defect can appear closed through ambiguous paraphrase. +- **Repair direction:** Require critic-local finding IDs at diagnosis; preserve + those IDs through disposition, repair instructions, regression status, and + queue deferral. +- **Collateral risk:** IDs must remain routing keys, not scores or canon authority. +- **Dependency:** Report and synthesis contracts. +- **Confidence:** High; the handoff fields do not share a stable key. + +### IC-04 + +- **Priority:** High-value. +- **Location:** `workshop/review-council/README.md`, Authority Map and Repair + Phase; `workshop/deepening/pass-template.md` frontmatter and Review council. +- **Evidence:** The coordinator adjudicates every finding and alone integrates + canonical repairs, but the pass contract records no coordinator identity or + explicit assumption of that role. +- **Effect:** The decisive office exists, but its occupant and handoffs are + invisible. A critic or repair agent can silently become adjudicator, + weakening independence and obscuring who exercised integration authority. +- **Repair direction:** Record the coordinator in the pass and synthesis + artifacts. Permit one person or agent to hold multiple roles when necessary, + but require that overlap to be explicit. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not confuse role provenance with a demand for + managerial hierarchy or distinct human staffing. +- **Dependency:** Pass-record provenance. +- **Confidence:** Medium-high; authority is well described, but role occupancy + is not. + +## Pattern or dependency map + +`frozen baseline -> critic finding ID -> coordinator disposition -> bounded +repair -> frozen repaired snapshot -> regression by finding ID -> closeout` + +The candidate defines the actors and most authority boundaries well. Its +missing mechanisms occur at identity-bearing handoffs: baseline scope, report +routing, coordinator occupancy, and repaired-state regression. + +The Public corpus demonstrates that the Institutional Causality seat can detect +the intended defects. Ti'asantatca names workers, cohorts, observers, tenders, +and supporting households without yet naming command or succession; the sluice +dialogue exposes several competent authorities unable to own repair. Those are +later lore pressures, not findings KALSA-032 may settle. + +## Tempting edit to resist + +Do not empower this critic or the coordinator to invent a universal office that +resolves every failed handoff. `Four Readings of a Broken Sluice` gains force +from separated authority and unresolved responsibility. The council should +route that pressure to the owning lore pass, not answer it from workshop prose. + +## Ranked actions + +1. Freeze the complete diagnostic candidate and one repaired regression snapshot. +2. Add stable finding IDs and explicit coordinator identity across the report, + synthesis, pass, and regression contracts. +3. Leave the seven specialist remits and their canon boundary intact; no + omnibus institutional reviewer is needed. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Material Life and Ecology.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Material Life and Ecology.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..197b417 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Material Life and Ecology.md @@ -0,0 +1,87 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +packet_id: KALSA-032-baseline-01 +critic: Material Life and Ecology +phase: diagnosis +verdict: pass-with-findings +--- + +# Critic Report + +## Concise diagnosis + +Pass with findings. No blocking finding. The remit clearly distinguishes +material mechanism from a generic suffering ledger. One high-value hardening +would prevent inventories of material nouns from masquerading as causal chains. + +## Protected successes + +- Preserve the explicit rejection of automatic misery ledgers. Requiring a + mechanism, payer, place, response, and resulting choices directly addresses + the calibration concern. +- Preserve attention to maintenance, residues, bodies, care work, seasons, and + uneven access. These distinguish this remit from Institutional Causality. +- Preserve miraculous abundance, spectacle, and delight. Material scrutiny + should explain this magic's consequences, not force mundane scarcity back + into every wonder. + +## Findings + +### MLE-01 + +- **Priority:** High-value. +- **Location:** `critics/Material Life and Ecology.md`, first and second quoted + paragraphs. +- **Evidence:** The prompt names strong inputs and rejects abstract misery + accounting, but it does not say that naming workers, tools, inputs, and costs + remains an inventory unless their handoffs form a causal chain. The corpus + contains both noun-rich summaries and compact mechanisms such as incense + revealing airflow and chants coordinating distant controls. +- **Effect:** A checklist-shaped report could approve a material-cost ledger + because enough concrete nouns appear, or criticize only cadence while missing + absent physical handoffs. +- **Repair direction:** Require each substantive finding to trace one evidenced + chain—source/input -> labor or infrastructure -> allocation/use -> failure, + residue, or recovery—and identify the exact broken or unavailable link. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not require every overview to carry a supply-chain + monograph or imply all magic consumes mundane fuel. +- **Dependency:** Institutional Causality for jurisdiction; AI-Isms for cadence. +- **Confidence:** High. + +### MLE-02 + +- **Priority:** Optional. +- **Location:** Material critic prompt as a whole, against a Public-only corpus. +- **Evidence:** Every lore file supplied for calibration is a presentation-only + Public note; hidden owner notes are intentionally absent. +- **Effect:** A critic could overstate “the setting has no mechanism” when the + packet establishes only that Public does not show it. +- **Repair direction:** Label a chain absent, outside the packet, delegated + through a named link, or appropriately compressed for the page's function. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not let “perhaps hidden elsewhere” excuse unsupported + public claims. +- **Dependency:** Packet design, provenance, and coordinator adjudication. +- **Confidence:** High. + +## Pattern or dependency map + +- `Relics and Ruins` supplies concrete operation and maintenance. +- `Peoples and Polities` mixes real labor organization with a praise-then-cost + ledger. +- `Magic and Miracles` and `Gods and the Dead` sometimes provide material + inventories without a full handoff. +- An explicit chain test would make this gradient reproducible. + +## Tempting edit to resist + +Do not turn the remit into an exhaustive food-water-fuel checklist for every +navigation or overview page. Preserve compression, spectacle, and concrete +examples; require full mechanisms from proper owners or bounded passes. + +## Ranked actions + +1. No essential action. +2. Require one traced material chain or exact broken link for each substantive + finding. +3. Optionally require an evidence-scope label so Public compression is not + misreported as absent canon. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Reader Experience and Navigation.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Reader Experience and Navigation.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..898c946 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/diagnosis/Reader Experience and Navigation.md @@ -0,0 +1,118 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +packet_id: KALSA-032-reader-01 +critic: Reader Experience and Navigation +phase: diagnosis +verdict: pass-with-findings +--- + +# Critic Report + +## Concise diagnosis + +**Pass with findings. No blocking finding.** The spoiler consent gate is +unmistakable, the public path establishes a distinctive world quickly, and Low +Sere converts the setting into immediate playable pressure. The main weakness +is route hierarchy: the entrance foregrounds broad explanatory pages whose +repeated institutional cautions flatten momentum before stronger place and +source material. + +The reader's working picture was a twilight world where settlements survive +through ancient infrastructure, negotiated miracle, inherited expertise, and +overlapping claims. Low Sere, Ti'asantatca's shield workers, the mobile Sarxe +center, and the divided City of Prophets created the strongest desire to follow. + +## Protected successes + +- `Kalsa/index.md` plainly distinguishes Kalsa for Readers from the Author and + GM Vault without an accidental spoiler lure. +- `Public/Places/Low Sere.md` provides compact spatial orientation, unequal + stakes, named actors, and an immediate adventure without resolving the dispute. +- `At the Basin Table.md` is the most memorable page. The drain key, name + cloth, pale marks, and unexplained knock carry lore through people. +- `Four Readings of a Broken Sluice.md` rewards rereading; the keeper keeps a + difficult scholarly dispute attached to missing seed and responsibility. + +## Findings + +### REN-01 + +- **Priority:** High-value, deferred lore pressure. +- **Location:** `Public/index.md`, Begin with the world as its people meet it. +- **Evidence:** Five broad survey pages precede one concrete place and two + situated sources; Low Sere appears sixth. +- **Effect:** A top-to-bottom reader encounters abstraction before meeting + anyone. Attention rises sharply at Low Sere and the Basin Table. +- **Repair direction:** Offer two routes: start with a live problem through Low + Sere and its source, or survey the world through overview notes. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not demote overview material or imply Low Sere + represents every culture. +- **Dependency:** Public navigation owner. +- **Confidence:** High. + +### REN-02 + +- **Priority:** High-value, deferred lore pressure. +- **Location:** `Peoples and Polities.md`, especially Papsenai and + Ti'asantatca, The divided city, and Sarxe and Saxfoldi. +- **Evidence:** Compelling places and conflicts have no reader-visible + continuation for Ti'asantatca, the divided city, or Saxfoldi. +- **Effect:** Curiosity is raised and stranded; some links are painted doors. +- **Repair direction:** Link existing public material where it exists. + Otherwise label glimpses and route to the nearest situated material rather + than manufacture thin pages. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not expose hidden owners or demand link symmetry. +- **Dependency:** Public planning and future place/source owners. +- **Confidence:** High. + +### REN-03 + +- **Priority:** High-value, deferred lore pressure. +- **Location:** recurring endings and framing across Public index, Peoples, + Magic, Gods, and Relics. +- **Evidence:** Variants of “does not grant authority,” “does not erase claims,” + “does not establish meaning,” and useful-yet-dangerous institutions recur in + a uniform explanatory voice. +- **Effect:** The Public surface can sound like one morally pre-digested + institutional handbook despite denying a universal schoolbook. +- **Repair direction:** Let named texts, offices, disputes, objects, and + consequences carry more of the ambiguity; remove narrator conclusions where + evidence already demonstrates them. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not replace careful limits with caricature or erase + protection against essentializing peoples. +- **Dependency:** AI-Isms and Culture remits. +- **Confidence:** Medium-high. + +### REN-04 + +- **Priority:** Optional, deferred lore pressure. +- **Location:** `Public/World/Kalsa.md`, geography and Roads through twilight. +- **Evidence:** Sunward/coldward is clear, but later destinations are not placed + relative to one another beyond scattered cues. +- **Effect:** The climatic axis survives in memory; a travel-scale picture does not. +- **Repair direction:** Add a bounded traveller's route or itinerary rather + than an omniscient atlas. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not settle disputed geography or expose author structure. +- **Dependency:** Geography and Public presentation owners. +- **Confidence:** Medium. + +## Pattern or dependency map + +`safe root gate -> survey-first Public index -> strong premise plus repeated +abstract cautions -> Low Sere -> highest attention in situated sources` + +The Public surface is strongest when an inhabitant, office, object, or disputed +record owns the explanation. + +## Tempting edit to resist + +- Do not add a glossary; unfamiliar terms accumulate meaning through use. +- Do not explain the Low Sere knock, decide what the dead are, or reveal the + Crown Cities' final nature. +- Do not build an omniscient atlas or one-page-per-people catalogue. + +## Ranked actions + +1. No essential action in KALSA-032. +2. Queue a bounded Public entry, onward-route, and narrator-voice repair. +3. Consider one inhabitant-owned travel orientation only with owner evidence. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/final-packet.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/final-packet.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..8cd5dbc --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/final-packet.md @@ -0,0 +1,54 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +packet_id: KALSA-032-repaired-02 +supersedes: KALSA-032-repaired-01 +candidate_identity: final-implementation-blob-hashes-recorded-below +coordinator: Codex /root +--- + +# KALSA-032 Final Repaired Packet + +`KALSA-032-repaired-01` passed all seven regressions, but its candidate manifest +included queue and memory surfaces before truthful closeout. This final snapshot +changes no council doctrine or prompt. It records the KALSA-032 queue state as +complete, advances Body and memory snapshot timestamps, and includes the synced +CultCache memory projection. All counselors must verify this identity before +the pass is committed. + +```text +260b2e6cbba921625877228d92258dac7796b879 AGENTS.md +820547810e5a7d8990e35f151bd8f370f8dcd5ef .epiphany/project-memory.md +0077c96833043f20736343b59ee215ee672b4b6d .epiphany/state/project-memory.cc +269904dde2d51d376fbfe6ba31276769f7ae8b7c workshop/deepening/README.md +b619f5ff1e9c75bfaa101aea44bde3e4a7ed0e8e workshop/deepening/pass-template.md +1ee05a2ae8ebd797e30b1bc8480197cdeb50b74d workshop/deepening/benchmark.md +d498d0338ece56012b26ecf3c64bd180be2e5848 workshop/deepening/body-map.md +403c06189a9acdf92a8c540b7706519e452a01d7 workshop/deepening/queue.md +865d06577182164398856d36a1d0a382e0fa3b8a workshop/review-council/README.md +5ed604ff74fa93aa6bfbab1a2c73c7fd91e9ab50 workshop/review-council/shared-prompt.md +81db83f5254ba2e90f1f77e85ea8bc5ebaa74c98 workshop/review-council/packet-template.md +e92ee2dd2f34e415868e0d14263dab9e51d9d4fb workshop/review-council/report-template.md +e2f6d0cfe6efbb21d750322bbebc6e5dc0f2ca22 workshop/review-council/synthesis-template.md +e142276b13062be7792310c31b8e4a32dab8a05e workshop/review-council/regression-template.md +d96d41f25259ac367395db8e4787004d71f8768f workshop/review-council/critics/Institutional Causality.md +7ba90172261aae5c815a40f0de3af7b5853d62c4 workshop/review-council/critics/Culture and Situated Knowledge.md +10e6079850ce8a3420cf4898ff243e14504da6d3 workshop/review-council/critics/Material Life and Ecology.md +d33b34e1e13f7147893c02482589db6dd99f67a3 workshop/review-council/critics/History Conflict and Change.md +9ec7dd60f6231b5f202ff9e4bf0c4a02c731dfbb workshop/review-council/critics/Ghostlight Play and Consequence.md +043e9313cf3de9b55d1a78d4cfd5bee26d147d0d workshop/review-council/critics/AI-Isms and Prose.md +eeb0b26d2a53407f21766598cd337427dfe54346 workshop/review-council/critics/Reader Experience and Navigation.md +``` + +The pass, synthesis, ledger, packets, and reports are audit evidence and remain +outside the implementation identity so their closeout links can be appended +without pretending to mutate the reviewed machine. + +## Bounded revalidation + +- Verify all twenty-one hashes. +- Confirm the critic's prompt and accepted repairs are unchanged from + `KALSA-032-repaired-01`. +- Confirm queue closeout and memory projection introduce no defect within the + critic's remit. +- Return a brief verdict for `KALSA-032-repaired-02` and name what remains + deferred or must be left alone. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/final-reader-packet.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/final-reader-packet.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..08e2eab --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/final-reader-packet.md @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +packet_id: KALSA-032-reader-repaired-02 +process_identity: KALSA-032-repaired-02 +audience: curious Ghostlight player exploring a high-fantasy setting vault +public_blind_packet: true +--- + +# KALSA-032 Final Fresh Reader Packet + +Begin at `Kalsa/index.md`, then follow only links available through +`Kalsa/Public/`. Do not open `Kalsa/Spoilers/`, `seed/`, `workshop/`, +`.epiphany/`, generated output, or any critic report. + +The reader source remains unchanged. Confirm that queue and memory closeout did +not leak into the player surface, that navigation remains Public-only, and that +previously observed reader pressure remains a bounded later repair rather than +an essential KALSA-032 defect. Do not edit lore. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/final-revalidation.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/final-revalidation.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..95886b5 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/final-revalidation.md @@ -0,0 +1,49 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +repaired_packet_id: KALSA-032-repaired-02 +status: passed +--- + +# KALSA-032 Final Revalidation + +KALSA-032-repaired-01 passed all seven regression turns. Closeout then changed +only queue status, Body and memory snapshot time, and the generated CultCache +projection. Because those surfaces appeared in the first manifest, the +coordinator froze `KALSA-032-repaired-02` and revalidated the final body instead +of letting a stale hash wear a completion label. + +## Results + +| Critic | Identity checked | Verdict | Essential defect | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Institutional Causality | all 21 blobs | Pass | none | +| Culture and Situated Knowledge | all 21 blobs | Pass | none | +| Material Life and Ecology | all 21 blobs | Pass | none | +| History, Conflict, and Change | all 21 blobs | Pass | none | +| Ghostlight Play and Consequence | all 21 blobs | Pass | none | +| AI-Isms and Prose | all 21 blobs | Pass | none | +| Reader Experience and Navigation | blind Public packet | Pass | none | + +The six grounded critics confirmed that their prompts and accepted repairs were +unchanged, the queue closed truthfully, memory and its CultCache projection +remained non-canonical, and the Body map preserved subject-note authority. The +fresh reader found no spoiler, queue, memory, council, or closeout leak; every +followed reader link remained in `Kalsa/Public/`. + +## Leave alone + +- the seven-seat boundary and same-snapshot rule; +- stable finding IDs and explicit coordinator occupancy; +- informal knowledge reproduction and protected incomplete models; +- concise material-chain and Ghostlight play traces; +- target-supported interventions rather than universal hook menus; +- AI-ism term-origin analysis, false-positive protection, and the ban on + detector or token-list verdicts; +- the consent gate, difficult names, Low Sere route, situated source dialogues, + and unresolved testimony. + +## Deferred pressure + +KALSA-024 and KALSA-031 retain bounded cultural and historical work. KALSA-033 +owns Public entry hierarchy, onward routes, situated orientation, and recurring +narrator-level moral/checksum cadence. None is an essential KALSA-032 defect. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/reader-packet.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/reader-packet.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d4c1dda --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/reader-packet.md @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +packet_id: KALSA-032-reader-01 +candidate_identity: current-public-source-at-baseline-01 +audience: curious Ghostlight player exploring a high-fantasy setting vault +public_blind_packet: true +--- + +# KALSA-032 Blind Reader Packet + +Begin at `Kalsa/index.md`, then follow only links available through +`Kalsa/Public/`. Read the current Public notes as a casual explorer. Do not open +`Kalsa/Spoilers/`, `seed/`, `workshop/`, `.epiphany/`, generated Quartz output, +or other council reports. + +Evaluate the entry path and reader-visible world using the Reader Experience +and Navigation prompt. This is calibration evidence for a review process. Do +not edit lore. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/AI-Isms and Prose.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/AI-Isms and Prose.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..db7b7fd --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/AI-Isms and Prose.md @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +baseline_packet_id: KALSA-032-baseline-01 +repaired_packet_id: KALSA-032-repaired-01 +critic: AI-Isms and Prose +phase: regression +verdict: pass +--- + +# Critic Regression Report + +## Finding status + +| Finding ID | Disposition | Status | Evidence | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| AIP-01 | Accept | Resolved | The critic requires term-origin analysis and diagnoses diffusion rather than tokens, protecting earned Ju'onai vocabulary. | +| AIP-02 | Accept | Resolved | The prompt routes recurrence/contrast to Evidence and retained function to Collateral risk without enlarging the shared template. | + +All twenty repaired candidate hashes matched `KALSA-032-repaired-01`. + +## New defects within remit + +- None. + +## Protected strengths + +- Cluster, recurrence, context, and reading effect remain the basis of diagnosis. +- Detector claims, word bans, automatic rewriting, and regex gates remain excluded. +- Functional inventories, deliberate antithesis, culture-specific rhetoric, and + earned technical terms remain protected. + +## Essential further change + +- None. + +## Leave alone + +- Leave the Kalsa-specific pattern inventory and shared report fields intact. +- Add no token lists, detector scores, or further vocabulary warnings. + +## Verdict + +**Pass.** AIP-01 and AIP-02 are resolved with no new prose-review defect. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Culture and Situated Knowledge.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Culture and Situated Knowledge.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..86a524d --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Culture and Situated Knowledge.md @@ -0,0 +1,45 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +baseline_packet_id: KALSA-032-baseline-01 +repaired_packet_id: KALSA-032-repaired-01 +critic: Culture and Situated Knowledge +phase: regression +verdict: pass +--- + +# Critic Regression Report + +## Finding status + +| Finding ID | Disposition | Status | Evidence | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| CSK-01 | Accept | Resolved | The critic now requires the actual household, oral, customary, itinerant, ritual, testimonial, or formal reproduction path. | +| CSK-02 | Accept | Resolved | Packet and pass templates preserve owner/synthesis, evidence/reproduction, useful domain, blind spot, and protected unknown. | +| CSK-03 | Defer | Resolved as deferred routing | KALSA-031 now tests one supported non-magical relation or practice; KALSA-024 includes mixed or cross-boundary lives under actual play pressure. | + +All relevant candidate hashes matched `KALSA-032-repaired-01`. + +## New defects within remit + +- None. The repairs impose neither symmetrical coverage nor formal institutions + on diffuse knowledge. + +## Protected strengths + +- Culturally owned disagreement, incomplete useful models, opacity, protected + unknowns, uneven emphasis, and source-grounded deferral survived. + +## Essential further change + +- None. + +## Leave alone + +- Leave the reproduction examples as possibilities rather than a checklist. +- Leave KALSA-031 and KALSA-024 bounded. +- Leave Public lore untouched in KALSA-032. + +## Verdict + +**Pass.** Accepted findings are resolved and deferred pressure is routed without +invention. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Ghostlight Play and Consequence.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Ghostlight Play and Consequence.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e4b4955 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Ghostlight Play and Consequence.md @@ -0,0 +1,45 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +baseline_packet_id: KALSA-032-baseline-01 +repaired_packet_id: KALSA-032-repaired-01 +critic: Ghostlight Play and Consequence +phase: regression +verdict: pass +--- + +# Critic Regression Report + +## Finding status + +| Finding ID | Disposition | Status | Evidence | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| GPC-01 | Accept | Resolved | Packet and pass templates carry point of contact, character-accessible evidence, supported intervention, and consequence horizon/play-bearing owner. | +| GPC-02 | Accept | Resolved | Benchmark and critic use target-supported courses, differing responses, and durable owners/receipts rather than a universal action menu. | +| GPC-03 | Accept | Resolved | The prompt traces a play path when evidence permits and allows overviews to route to a play-bearing owner. | + +All twenty repaired candidate hashes matched `KALSA-032-repaired-01`. + +## New defects within remit + +- None. + +## Protected strengths + +- Character action remains bounded by available evidence. +- Uncertainty, asymmetric knowledge, spectacle, unsolved problems, and + inhabitant agency remain protected. +- Overview pages need not become encounters. + +## Essential further change + +- None. + +## Leave alone + +- Keep the Ghostlight lens compact. +- Keep the evidence-permitting trace and overview exception. +- Add no hooks quota, mandatory clocks, or intervention matrix. + +## Verdict + +**Pass.** GPC-01 through GPC-03 are resolved without a play-review regression. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/History Conflict and Change.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/History Conflict and Change.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..af6b5fe --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/History Conflict and Change.md @@ -0,0 +1,44 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +baseline_packet_id: KALSA-032-baseline-01 +repaired_packet_id: KALSA-032-repaired-01 +critic: History, Conflict, and Change +phase: regression +verdict: pass +--- + +# Critic Regression Report + +## Finding status + +| Finding ID | Disposition | Status | Evidence | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| HCC-01 | Accept | Resolved | Packet and pass templates conditionally require factual event owners plus neighboring memory/consequence notes, or an explicit inability to judge. | +| HCC-02 | Defer | Resolved as bounded deferral | KALSA-031 routes source-grounded formation without invented events; KALSA-033 requires owner inspection before Public changes. | + +All twenty repaired candidate hashes matched `KALSA-032-repaired-01`. + +## New defects within remit + +- None. + +## Protected strengths + +- Myths, disputed chronologies, selective archives, and unresolved + contradictions remain protected. +- Event evidence remains conditional and does not create one public history. +- Public lore stayed unchanged. + +## Essential further change + +- None. + +## Leave alone + +- Leave the remit and conditional event-owner field concise. +- Do not invent origin events or expand KALSA-032 into lore repair. + +## Verdict + +**Pass.** HCC-01 is resolved, HCC-02 is coherently deferred, and no historical +ownership regression appeared. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Institutional Causality.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Institutional Causality.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..581734c --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Institutional Causality.md @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +baseline_packet_id: KALSA-032-baseline-01 +repaired_packet_id: KALSA-032-repaired-01 +critic: Institutional Causality +phase: regression +verdict: pass +--- + +# Critic Regression Report + +## Finding status + +| Finding ID | Disposition | Status | Evidence | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| IC-01 | Accept | Resolved | The baseline packet now records the omitted pass-record hash captured in the original report. | +| IC-02 | Accept | Resolved | The council README requires one frozen repaired identity, derived packets, same-identity regressions, and invalidation after mutation. All twenty declared blobs matched. | +| IC-03 | Accept | Resolved | Report, README, synthesis, and regression contracts preserve stable critic-local IDs. | +| IC-04 | Accept | Resolved | `Codex /root` is recorded in packet, synthesis, and pass; reusable templates require explicit occupancy and overlap. | + +## New defects within remit + +- None. Identity and handoff mechanisms were added without granting critics, + reports, or majorities canon authority. + +## Protected strengths + +- Diagnosis, adjudication, repair, and canonical ownership remain separate. +- Failed handoffs and enforcement limits remain reviewable without demanding + centralized institutions. +- Reader blindness, bounded packets, no-finding reports, and the prohibition on + automatic critic edits survived. + +## Essential further change + +- None. + +## Leave alone + +- Leave the seven remits, coordinator adjudication, subject-note authority, and + permission for informal or plural institutions unchanged. +- Add no universal office, aggregate score, or automatic enforcement layer. +- Do not reopen lore in this process pass. + +## Verdict + +**Pass.** IC-01 through IC-04 are resolved on the verified repaired snapshot. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Material Life and Ecology.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Material Life and Ecology.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d56149e --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Material Life and Ecology.md @@ -0,0 +1,42 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +baseline_packet_id: KALSA-032-baseline-01 +repaired_packet_id: KALSA-032-repaired-01 +critic: Material Life and Ecology +phase: regression +verdict: pass +--- + +# Critic Regression Report + +## Finding status + +| Finding ID | Disposition | Status | Evidence | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| MLE-01 | Accept | Resolved | The critic now traces source/input through labor/infrastructure and allocation/use into failure, residue, or recovery, naming the broken handoff. | +| MLE-02 | Accept | Resolved | The critic distinguishes absent canon, outside-packet evidence, named delegation, and appropriate compression. | + +All twenty candidate hashes matched `KALSA-032-repaired-01`. + +## New defects within remit + +- None. The chain and evidence-scope requirements remain concise. + +## Protected strengths + +- The automatic misery-ledger test survived. +- Maintenance, residues, bodies, care work, seasons, uneven access, abundance, + spectacle, and delight remain protected. + +## Essential further change + +- None. + +## Leave alone + +- Leave the repaired prompt alone; further mandatory fields would add ceremony. +- Leave Public calibration lore untouched in this pass. + +## Verdict + +**Pass.** MLE-01 and MLE-02 are resolved on the verified snapshot. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Reader Experience and Navigation.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Reader Experience and Navigation.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..5e99837 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/regression/Reader Experience and Navigation.md @@ -0,0 +1,104 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +packet_id: KALSA-032-reader-repaired-01 +critic: Reader Experience and Navigation +phase: regression +verdict: pass-with-findings +--- + +# Fresh Reader Report + +## Concise diagnosis + +**Pass with findings.** The consent gate is clear, every followed Public link +remained inside `Kalsa/Public/`, and no review language or hidden mechanism +appeared. The strongest route remains Public index -> Low Sere -> At the Basin +Table. The deferred pressure is real: wider-world curiosity often lacks an +onward route, and repeated cautions about authority and incomplete knowledge +become instructional across overview pages. + +## Protected successes + +- The root spoiler boundary is explicit and the Public route is preferred. +- The Public entrance establishes the unmoving sun, stormshield labor, + unreliable gods, relic infrastructure, and dangerous dead without resolving + their causes. +- Low Sere turns those concerns into forty-one hearths, wet rooms, a stolen + tool, provisional authority, dead workers, and one black door. +- Both situated sources preserve memorable objects, disagreement, consequence, + and mystery without glossary exposition. + +## Findings + +### REN-01 + +- **Priority:** High-value, deferred. +- **Location:** Public index navigation and Peoples and Polities onward links. +- **Evidence:** Low Sere and the Ju'onai dialogue have situated follow-through; + Ti'asantatca, Jamnai, the divided city, Selza'a country, and Saxfoldi do not. +- **Effect:** Curiosity repeatedly rises and has nowhere to travel. +- **Repair direction:** Mark Low Sere as the available first playable thread; + add one contrasting situated branch only when an owner can support it. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not manufacture equal coverage or expose material + before it has an inhabitant owner. +- **Confidence:** High. + +### REN-02 + +- **Priority:** High-value, deferred. +- **Location:** repeated qualifications across Public overview notes. +- **Evidence:** Several pages restate that explanations do not own truth, + discovery does not erase claims, evidence does not establish meaning, + competence does not grant authority, and classifications do not determine + people. +- **Effect:** Later instances become skimmable and expose project doctrine as a + pre-digested lesson. +- **Repair direction:** Keep the principle but let concrete offices, disputes, + failed decisions, and sources carry it. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not erase Kalsa's distinction between power, + knowledge, and rightful authority. +- **Confidence:** High. + +### REN-03 + +- **Priority:** Optional, deferred. +- **Location:** Ju'onai section in Peoples and Polities. +- **Evidence:** Dense terminology appears before the dialogue that makes it + dramatic; the link is only at the footer. +- **Effect:** Readers may skim before reaching the best situated explanation. +- **Repair direction:** Add one early, relevant link to the dialogue. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not turn prose into an inline reference interface. +- **Confidence:** High. + +### REN-04 + +- **Priority:** Optional, deferred. +- **Location:** Public YAML properties. +- **Evidence:** Governance metadata may be visible in some raw-vault property + settings, though no process text appears in prose. +- **Effect:** Possible immersion break, not a spoiler leak. +- **Repair direction:** Prefer presentation-layer suppression over removing + source metadata. +- **Collateral risk:** Do not weaken ownership and publication checks. +- **Confidence:** Medium. + +## Pattern or dependency map + +- Safe root and Public-only links held. +- Overview pages form an abstract loop. +- Low Sere and the two sources create the strongest situated branches. +- Attention falls during repeated qualification and rises with objects, voices, + and immediate consequence. + +## Tempting edit to resist + +Do not add a glossary, universal magic explanation, complete polity matrix, or +equal page per people. Do not resolve the Crown Cities, divine perception, +returning dead, coldward judgment, or the Low Sere knock. + +## Ranked actions + +1. No essential action; consent and public-only navigation held. +2. Preserve the deferred KALSA-033 route and narrator-voice pressure. +3. Consider one earlier Ju'onai source link and presentation-layer property + suppression during that bounded pass. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/repaired-packet.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/repaired-packet.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ca94aa9 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/repaired-packet.md @@ -0,0 +1,81 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +packet_id: KALSA-032-repaired-01 +baseline_packet_id: KALSA-032-baseline-01 +candidate_identity: repaired-implementation-blob-hashes-recorded-below +coordinator: Codex /root +audience: Kalsa lore-review council +public_blind_packet: false +--- + +# KALSA-032 Repaired Council Packet + +## Repair scope + +This snapshot contains the process implementation after coordinator +adjudication in `synthesis.md`. Critics receive this packet, their own raw +diagnostic report, the synthesis, and only the candidate files needed for their +remit. They do not receive other raw reports. + +KALSA-032 changed no canonical or Public lore. Reader-visible findings were +deferred to KALSA-033. The repaired implementation must therefore be judged on +whether it routes future lore work coherently, preserves authority, and resolves +the accepted process defects. + +## Repaired identity + +```text +260b2e6cbba921625877228d92258dac7796b879 AGENTS.md +7f0478cc0da4693ade768cd3bba769e5b09f5b5b .epiphany/project-memory.md +269904dde2d51d376fbfe6ba31276769f7ae8b7c workshop/deepening/README.md +b619f5ff1e9c75bfaa101aea44bde3e4a7ed0e8e workshop/deepening/pass-template.md +1ee05a2ae8ebd797e30b1bc8480197cdeb50b74d workshop/deepening/benchmark.md +2dcd7223588314fbd09049afd6aaf8ebdf9e1f58 workshop/deepening/body-map.md +88bca7eee3afcbe19a07edb4d956e0f368809788 workshop/deepening/queue.md +865d06577182164398856d36a1d0a382e0fa3b8a workshop/review-council/README.md +5ed604ff74fa93aa6bfbab1a2c73c7fd91e9ab50 workshop/review-council/shared-prompt.md +81db83f5254ba2e90f1f77e85ea8bc5ebaa74c98 workshop/review-council/packet-template.md +e92ee2dd2f34e415868e0d14263dab9e51d9d4fb workshop/review-council/report-template.md +e2f6d0cfe6efbb21d750322bbebc6e5dc0f2ca22 workshop/review-council/synthesis-template.md +e142276b13062be7792310c31b8e4a32dab8a05e workshop/review-council/regression-template.md +d96d41f25259ac367395db8e4787004d71f8768f workshop/review-council/critics/Institutional Causality.md +7ba90172261aae5c815a40f0de3af7b5853d62c4 workshop/review-council/critics/Culture and Situated Knowledge.md +10e6079850ce8a3420cf4898ff243e14504da6d3 workshop/review-council/critics/Material Life and Ecology.md +d33b34e1e13f7147893c02482589db6dd99f67a3 workshop/review-council/critics/History Conflict and Change.md +9ec7dd60f6231b5f202ff9e4bf0c4a02c731dfbb workshop/review-council/critics/Ghostlight Play and Consequence.md +043e9313cf3de9b55d1a78d4cfd5bee26d147d0d workshop/review-council/critics/AI-Isms and Prose.md +eeb0b26d2a53407f21766598cd337427dfe54346 workshop/review-council/critics/Reader Experience and Navigation.md +``` + +The KALSA-032 pass record and synthesis are evolving audit artifacts. Their +coordinator identity, report inventory, dispositions, protected ledger, and +repair brief were complete before this freeze. Appending regression links and +closeout does not mutate the reviewed implementation. + +## Accepted repairs represented + +- complete baseline scope and one immutable repaired snapshot; +- stable finding IDs and explicit coordinator identity; +- actual formal or informal knowledge-reproduction paths; +- protected boundaries for in-scope inhabitant models; +- traced material chains and evidence-scope labels; +- event-owner evidence or an explicit inability to judge it; +- bounded Ghostlight access, target-earned interventions, and a play trace; +- term-origin analysis for workshop-dialect findings; +- regression template and same-snapshot completion gate; +- bounded deferral of Public entry, link, historical, and narrator-voice + pressure to KALSA-031, KALSA-024, and KALSA-033. + +## Protected strengths + +Use the protected-material ledger in `synthesis.md`. No regression may demand a +continuity critic, novel-specific machinery, detector or regex gate, lore edits +inside this pass, automatic critic edits, majority rule, or symmetric content +coverage. + +## Regression rule + +Return `regression-template.md`. Address the IDs from your own report. Report a +new defect only when the repaired implementation introduced or retained one in +your remit. Preferences do not reopen the repair. Name what should now be left +alone. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/repaired-reader-packet.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/repaired-reader-packet.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..df0226d --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/repaired-reader-packet.md @@ -0,0 +1,19 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +packet_id: KALSA-032-reader-repaired-01 +baseline_packet_id: KALSA-032-reader-01 +candidate_identity: unchanged-public-source-plus-kalsa-032-repaired-01-process +audience: curious Ghostlight player exploring a high-fantasy setting vault +public_blind_packet: true +--- + +# KALSA-032 Fresh Reader Regression Packet + +Begin at `Kalsa/index.md`, then follow only links available through +`Kalsa/Public/`. Do not open `Kalsa/Spoilers/`, `seed/`, `workshop/`, +`.epiphany/`, generated output, or any critic report. + +The reader-visible source is intentionally unchanged in this process pass. Read +it fresh and return the Reader Experience and Navigation report contract. The +purpose is to confirm that the deferred pressure remains accurately bounded and +that no process change leaked into the player surface. Do not edit lore. diff --git a/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/synthesis.md b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/synthesis.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d04a9b1 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/deepening/reviews/KALSA-032/synthesis.md @@ -0,0 +1,101 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-032 +packet_id: KALSA-032-baseline-01 +status: adjudicated +coordinator: Codex /root +--- + +# KALSA-032 Council Synthesis and Adjudication + +## Report inventory + +| Critic | Diagnostic report | Verdict | Regression report | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Institutional Causality | [[diagnosis/Institutional Causality]] | Block | [[regression/Institutional Causality]] — Pass | +| Culture and Situated Knowledge | [[diagnosis/Culture and Situated Knowledge]] | Pass with findings | [[regression/Culture and Situated Knowledge]] — Pass | +| Material Life and Ecology | [[diagnosis/Material Life and Ecology]] | Pass with findings | [[regression/Material Life and Ecology]] — Pass | +| History, Conflict, and Change | [[diagnosis/History Conflict and Change]] | Pass with findings | [[regression/History Conflict and Change]] — Pass | +| Ghostlight Play and Consequence | [[diagnosis/Ghostlight Play and Consequence]] | Pass with findings | [[regression/Ghostlight Play and Consequence]] — Pass | +| AI-Isms and Prose | [[diagnosis/AI-Isms and Prose]] | Pass with findings | [[regression/AI-Isms and Prose]] — Pass | +| Reader Experience and Navigation | [[diagnosis/Reader Experience and Navigation]] | Pass with findings | [[regression/Reader Experience and Navigation]] — Pass with deferred findings | + +All seven reports were produced independently. No critic read another report +before coordinator adjudication. Reader Experience received +`KALSA-032-reader-01`, not the grounded baseline packet. + +## Protected-material ledger + +- Critics diagnose; coordinator adjudicates; subject notes own canon. +- Every seat receives an independent diagnostic and regression turn. An honest + no-finding result is valid. +- The council has seven setting-facing remits rather than manuscript-specific + continuity, character, chapter, scene, or pacing roles. +- Reader review remains blind when Public material is in scope. +- AI-ism review diagnoses recurrent construction and reading effect without + detector claims, banned vocabulary, or automatic rewriting. +- Ju'onai technical language is culturally owned and must not be stripped merely + because authoring language uses similar words. +- Miraculous abundance, mystery, functional inventories, uneven cultural + emphasis, and target-specific forms of play remain protectable. +- KALSA-032 changes process only. Current Public lore findings cannot authorize + opportunistic lore edits. + +## Finding dispositions + +| ID | Critic | Disposition | Evidence and reason | Exact repair instruction | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| IC-01 | Institutional Causality | Accept | The baseline declared the pass record in scope but omitted its hash. | Add the baseline pass-record hash without recursively hashing the packet. | +| IC-02 | Institutional Causality | Accept | Seven regressions could otherwise inspect seven different repaired bodies. | Freeze one repaired snapshot; derive all packets from it; invalidate affected regressions after later mutation. | +| IC-03 | Institutional Causality | Accept | Finding identity was lost between report, synthesis, repair, regression, and deferral. | Require stable critic-local IDs throughout the path. | +| IC-04 | Institutional Causality | Accept | The coordinator office had authority but no recorded occupant. | Record coordinator identity in packet, pass, and synthesis; disclose role overlap. | +| CSK-01 | Culture and Situated Knowledge | Accept | Public knowledge may reproduce through households, travel, custom, or oral transmission rather than a formal school. | Replace institution-biased reproduction language with the actual applicable transmission path. | +| CSK-02 | Culture and Situated Knowledge | Accept | The packet and pass could lose a model's protected blind spot during repair handoff. | Record owner/synthesis, evidence/reproduction, useful domain, blind spot, and protected unknown when an inhabitant model is in scope. | +| CSK-03 | Culture and Situated Knowledge | Defer | Current queue pressure begins from magical traditions and may neglect life beyond magic, but KALSA-032 cannot write culture. | Amend KALSA-031 and KALSA-024 to test supported non-magical and cross-boundary life without symmetry quotas. | +| MLE-01 | Material Life and Ecology | Accept | Concrete nouns can still form a decorative cost inventory without a material handoff. | Require one evidenced source/input-to-use-to-failure/residue/recovery chain for substantive findings. | +| MLE-02 | Material Life and Ecology | Accept | Public compression could be mistaken for absent canon. | Require an evidence-scope label: absent, outside packet, delegated, or appropriately compressed. | +| HCC-01 | History, Conflict, and Change | Accept | Event ownership cannot be judged without the owner and neighboring memory notes. | Supply event-owner evidence when in scope or state that the packet cannot support the verdict. | +| HCC-02 | History, Conflict, and Change | Defer | Several Public conflicts lack visible historical formation, but hidden owners were not supplied. | Route source-grounded formation pressure into KALSA-031/KALSA-033; invent no event. | +| GPC-01 | Ghostlight Play and Consequence | Accept | The packet lacked a bounded character-access lens. | Add point of contact, accessible evidence, supported intervention, and consequence horizon/play-bearing owner. | +| GPC-02 | Ghostlight Play and Consequence | Accept | Repeated help/harm/capture/reform verbs could impose the same quest menu on every target. | Replace the universal verbs with two target-supported courses, different response, and durable owner/receipt. | +| GPC-03 | Ghostlight Play and Consequence | Accept | Ingredient lists can avoid showing where interaction becomes inert. | Ask for one evidence-supported play trace when the packet permits it. | +| AIP-01 | AI-Isms and Prose | Accept | The same abstract vocabulary can be narrator leakage or earned Ju'onai register. | Require term-origin analysis and diagnose diffusion across unrelated voices, not tokens. | +| AIP-02 | AI-Isms and Prose | Accept | Recurrence and retained function were not clearly routed into shared fields. | Put recurrence/contrast in Evidence and retained function in Collateral risk. | +| REN-01 | Reader Experience and Navigation | Defer | The safe entrance is survey-first and delays the strongest concrete route. | KALSA-033 tests separate live-problem and world-survey paths. | +| REN-02 | Reader Experience and Navigation | Defer | Ti'asantatca, the divided city, and Saxfoldi raise curiosity without reachable continuation. | KALSA-033 links existing Public material or labels/reroutes glimpses; it creates no symmetry stubs. | +| REN-03 | Reader Experience and Navigation | Defer | Repeated narrator-level caution creates one pre-digested institutional voice. | KALSA-033 repairs accepted prose clusters through situated evidence while protecting Ju'onai's register. | +| REN-04 | Reader Experience and Navigation | Defer | Travel-scale orientation is weak but may be intentionally unsettled. | KALSA-033 may test one inhabitant-owned itinerary only after owner evidence. | + +## Repair brief + +- **Owners allowed to change:** `workshop/review-council/`, deepening process + docs, KALSA-032 evidence, `AGENTS.md`, Body map, queue, and project memory. +- **Authority deleted or demoted first:** an unfrozen repaired candidate, + paraphrase-only finding tracking, silent coordinator occupancy, formal-school + bias, material noun inventories, and universal player-action menus. +- **Accepted changes:** implement every accepted instruction above. +- **Explicit non-changes:** no Kalsa lore or Public presentation changes; no + continuity critic; no automated detector, regex style gate, aggregate score, + majority vote, or automatic critic edit. +- **Deferred queue pressure:** KALSA-031 and KALSA-024 receive bounded cultural + and historical constraints; KALSA-033 owns Public route and narrator-voice + repair. +- **Verification:** freeze one repaired packet, run all seven regressions, then + execute the repository verification suite. + +## Regression closeout + +- **Repaired packet identity:** `KALSA-032-repaired-02`; after the first + snapshot passed, truthful queue and memory closeout required a final freeze. + All six grounded critics independently verified all twenty-one recorded blob + hashes. Reader Experience used `KALSA-032-reader-repaired-02` against + unchanged Public source. See [[final-revalidation]]. +- **Essential findings resolved:** IC-01 and IC-02. Every accepted process + finding passed its original seat's regression. +- **Essential findings remaining:** none. +- **Regressions accepted for repair:** none. The fresh reader confirmed the + existing deferred Public pressure and found no spoiler or process-language leak. +- **What must now be left alone:** the seven-seat boundary, compact packet and + report forms, contextual AI-ism pattern inventory, culturally owned Ju'onai + register, mystery, non-symmetric coverage, and all Kalsa lore in this pass. +- **Final council decision:** Pass. KALSA-032 may close after repository and + memory verification succeeds. diff --git a/workshop/review-council/README.md b/workshop/review-council/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..865d065 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/review-council/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,157 @@ +# Kalsa Lore Review Council + +This directory owns the reusable critic prompts and council protocol for Kalsa +deepening passes. It does not own lore. A critic diagnoses one quality surface; +the pass coordinator adjudicates findings; canonical subject notes retain every +setting claim. + +The protocol adapts the independent-report and regression shape of +AetheriaLore's Novella Council to a setting vault. Manuscript-only specialties +are omitted. Kalsa instead reviews whether its lore can generate institutions, +cultures, material pressures, history, adventures, and an inviting +inhabitant-facing reading experience without collapsing into authorial jargon +or polished machine prose. + +## Council Seats + +Every deepening pass gives each seat one diagnostic turn and one post-repair +regression turn: + +1. [[critics/Institutional Causality|Institutional Causality]] +2. [[critics/Culture and Situated Knowledge|Culture and Situated Knowledge]] +3. [[critics/Material Life and Ecology|Material Life and Ecology]] +4. [[critics/History Conflict and Change|History, Conflict, and Change]] +5. [[critics/Ghostlight Play and Consequence|Ghostlight Play and Consequence]] +6. [[critics/AI-Isms and Prose|AI-Isms and Prose]] +7. [[critics/Reader Experience and Navigation|Reader Experience and Navigation]] + +A seat may return `No blocking finding`. Silence is not a report, and a critic +must not manufacture a defect to justify its seat. Replace or retire a seat if +several passes show that its remit is redundant; do not keep a pageant of agent +names. + +## Authority Map + +- **Owner:** this file owns council membership, sequence, packet boundaries, + and completion gates. Individual prompt files own only their diagnostic + remit. +- **Inputs:** an immutable candidate packet assembled from the pass, exact + source and owner notes, intended audience, protected strengths, known + concerns, and the candidate diff or baseline. +- **Outputs:** seven raw diagnostic reports, coordinator dispositions, a finite + repair brief, seven regression reports, and a final council decision. +- **Derived state:** confidence labels, pattern inventories, counts, agreement, + and report summaries are evidence. They do not decide lore or publication. +- **Forbidden writers:** critics, majorities, detector scores, checklists, and + report prose may not edit canon, promote a candidate, or invent a missing + answer. Workshop files may not become a second lore database. +- **Shared path:** baseline packet -> independent diagnostic turns -> + coordinator adjudication -> bounded owner repair -> independent regression + turns -> coordinator closeout -> ordinary repository verification. +- **Cut line:** a generic `Soul review`, one omnibus opinion, or an aggregate + score cannot stand in for the seven named reports. Continuity is not a + dedicated seat; source fidelity, provenance, ownership, and spoiler safety + constrain every seat and remain part of final verification. + +## Packet Contract + +Create the packet before critics begin, using [[packet-template]]. Freeze its +identity with a commit, tag, or recorded file hashes. Diagnostic critics do not +see one another's reports. + +Record the coordinator in the packet, pass, and synthesis. One person or agent +may hold more than one role when necessary, but the overlap must be explicit; +no critic or repair writer silently inherits adjudication authority. + +Six grounded critics receive only the canonical and workshop sources necessary +for their remit. Reader Experience and Navigation receives the reader-visible +entry path, target-audience description, and any navigation surface under test. +It does not receive hidden canon, authorial intention, known concerns, or other +reports. When a pass changes only author material, give that critic the +plausible direct-entry path an author or GM would actually use and say that the +packet is not spoiler-blind. + +The packet must distinguish: + +- immutable seed evidence; +- adopted canon and its owner; +- provisional design, rumor, contested belief, and unknowns; +- Public inhabitant presentation; +- protected peculiarities and explicit operator decisions; +- the exact scope critics may inspect. + +## Diagnostic Phase + +Prepend [[shared-prompt]] to the appropriate critic prompt. Each critic returns +[[report-template]] as a separate artifact. Reports may cite the same defect, +but they must arrive independently. + +The coordinator then records a disposition for every substantive finding: + +- `Accept` — the evidence identifies a defect in scope; +- `Modify` — the defect is real but the proposed direction crosses an owner or + threatens protected material; +- `Reject` — the finding is unsupported, outside remit, or would make Kalsa + more generic; +- `Defer` — the pressure is real but belongs to a named later pass or needs + operator input. + +Agreement increases attention, not authority. A lone well-supported finding +can block a pass. Seven correlated preferences cannot vote a seed fact out of +existence. + +Every diagnostic finding receives a stable critic-local ID. Preserve that ID +through disposition, repair instruction, regression, and queue deferral. The ID +is a routing key, not a score or a claim of canon authority. + +## Repair Phase + +The coordinator converts accepted and modified findings into one bounded repair +brief. Repair begins by deleting or demoting obsolete authority. A writer or +Hands agent may then produce a candidate, but only the coordinator integrates +it into canonical owner notes. + +Do not feed raw disagreement to a writer and ask it to average the reports. +Do not revise passages outside the accepted brief merely because a critic +noticed them. Record new pressure in the queue. + +## Regression Phase + +After repair, freeze one repaired candidate identity. Derive every specialist +packet, including the blind reader packet, from that snapshot. Each original +seat receives the repaired candidate, its raw report, the relevant dispositions, +and the protected-material list, then returns [[regression-template]]. Each +answers only: + +1. Which accepted or modified findings were resolved? +2. Which remain unresolved? +3. What new defect appeared within this remit? +4. Which protected strength survived or weakened? +5. What further change is essential rather than preferable? +6. What should now be left alone? + +Reader Experience receives a newly assembled blind packet, not its old report +or the coordinator's intentions. Its second turn is fresh evidence rather than +implementation regression. + +Any change after the repaired snapshot invalidates regressions whose inspected +surface may have changed. Freeze a new candidate and rerun those seats; do not +let sequential reviews certify different bodies. + +## Completion Gate + +A deepening pass cannot close until: + +- all seven diagnostic reports exist, including explicit no-finding reports; +- the coordinator has disposed every substantive finding; +- repair changed only named owners and supporting navigation; +- all seven regression reports exist and name the same repaired candidate + identity; +- no accepted essential defect remains unresolved; +- the coordinator records what must now be left alone; +- seed, wikilink, vault-layout, publication-boundary, Quartz, rendered-page, + and actual-diff checks appropriate to the pass succeed. + +Council completion certifies that the named review process ran. It does not +prove the lore is good forever. New play, readers, sources, or contradictions +can reopen pressure through a new pass. diff --git a/workshop/review-council/critics/AI-Isms and Prose.md b/workshop/review-council/critics/AI-Isms and Prose.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..043e931 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/review-council/critics/AI-Isms and Prose.md @@ -0,0 +1,62 @@ +# AI-Isms and Prose Critic + +Use after [[../shared-prompt]]. + +> Diagnose prose habits that make Kalsa feel generated, overprocessed, or +> written by one tireless institutional essayist. You are not an AI detector and +> must never allege authorship. Wikipedia's `Signs of AI writing` is a +> descriptive field guide, not a rulebook: isolated signs are weak evidence, +> detector scores are not verdicts, and ordinary human prose can contain every +> listed pattern. Judge clusters, recurrence, context, and reading effect. +> +> Give particular attention to patterns already observed in Kalsa: +> +> - **Correction theatre:** repeated `not X but Y`, `not X; Y`, `rather than`, +> or `can X and still Y` structures that stage nuance instead of delivering +> it through evidence. +> - **The symmetrical moral ledger:** a wonder, competence, or institution is +> praised and then immediately balanced by exhaustion, exclusion, unequal +> access, debt, or danger in a polished list. Social cost matters; the defect +> is the reusable praise-then-invoice cadence and its abstract bookkeeping. +> - **List-clause congestion:** three-to-eight abstract nouns used as a signal +> of completeness where one actor, object, place, or consequence would carry +> more force. +> - **Repeated sentence frames:** successive `A can...`, `A person may...`, +> `A house that...`, or equally weighted clauses that make unrelated speakers +> share one rhythm. +> - **Checksum conclusions:** a final aphorism explains the meaning after the +> preceding action, image, example, or institution already proved it. +> - **Viewpoint chorus:** rulers, workers, outsiders, clerks, rivals, and the +> poor each receive one balanced sentence but no distinct knowledge, +> vocabulary, stakes, or behavior. +> - **Workshop dialect leakage:** `authority`, `bounded`, `legible`, `material`, +> `claim`, `record`, `preserve`, `surface`, and `consequence` are useful in +> operating documents but can flatten lore and in-world voices when used as +> default abstractions. +> - **Generic smoothing:** peculiar seed detail is replaced by broad +> significance, vague `some say` attribution, promotional importance, +> superficial `-ing` analysis, inflated substitutes for `is`, or empty +> association language. +> - **Template pressure:** excessive headings, bold inline labels, tables, +> em-dash asides, and mechanically parallel sections make reader prose feel +> like a completed form rather than a discovered world. +> +> For every finding, quote or precisely locate the smallest relevant passage, +> show whether it recurs elsewhere, explain the reading effect, and state what +> work the passage still needs to perform. Recommend a repair direction such as +> concrete action, situated testimony, a changed image, omitted interpretation, +> asymmetrical rhythm, or one specific consequence. Do not replace one formula +> with another. +> +> Protect functional inventories in author notes, authority maps in workshop +> documents, deliberate antithesis, culture-specific rhetoric, technical terms +> that earn their precision, and a list whose elements are genuinely needed for +> play. Identify at least one likely false positive or edit to resist. The goal +> is not to make the prose look statistically human. It is to restore voice, +> specificity, surprise, and trust in the reader. +> +> Before diagnosing workshop-dialect leakage, trace the term's origin. Is it +> narrator default, a named school's or office's technical register, or one +> speaker's language? Diagnose diffusion across unrelated voices, not the token +> alone. Put recurrence or meaningful contrast under the report's Evidence +> field and the passage's retained function under Collateral risk. diff --git a/workshop/review-council/critics/Culture and Situated Knowledge.md b/workshop/review-council/critics/Culture and Situated Knowledge.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7ba9017 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/review-council/critics/Culture and Situated Knowledge.md @@ -0,0 +1,24 @@ +# Culture and Situated Knowledge Critic + +Use after [[../shared-prompt]]. + +> Test whether peoples and traditions exist beyond magic category, polity, +> occupation, assigned psychology, and the author's explanatory needs. Look for +> internal plurality, social memory, humor, kinship, class, disagreement, +> translation, ritual, ordinary aspiration, refusal, inheritance, mixed lives, +> and interests not created by player arrival. +> +> For every public explanation, identify the inhabitant owner: culture, +> institution, lineage, text, witness, or named synthesis. Trace its evidence, +> actual reproduction path—household transmission, apprenticeship, oral +> repetition, seasonal gathering, market circulation, travel, testimony, +> ritual, or formal teaching—plus its useful domain, rivals, and +> characteristic blind spot. A renamed author taxonomy is a failure. Gods, +> scholars, priests, officials, and witnesses remain situated sources rather +> than omniscient narrators. +> +> Flag cultures that all speak in the same polished institutional dialect, +> subordinate people who appear only as moral accounting, and disagreement +> presented as one balanced paragraph without incompatible stakes. Protect +> opacity and unresolved belief where players can still discover evidence and +> consequences. diff --git a/workshop/review-council/critics/Ghostlight Play and Consequence.md b/workshop/review-council/critics/Ghostlight Play and Consequence.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9ec7dd6 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/review-council/critics/Ghostlight Play and Consequence.md @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +# Ghostlight Play and Consequence Critic + +Use after [[../shared-prompt]]. + +> Test whether the lore produces playable thresholds, routes, actors, clocks, +> resources, hazards, bargains, claimant collisions, discoveries, refusals, +> and durable consequences suitable for Ghostlight Dungeon. Ask what players +> can notice, attempt, misunderstand, change, lose, carry away, or make worse +> without receiving author knowledge. +> +> Flag passive encyclopedia texture, adventure hooks that depend on one correct +> moral choice, factions with no concrete leverage, mysteries with only an +> answer key, procedures with no failure state, and consequences that never +> leave the page. Use interventions earned by this target rather than a +> universal action menu. Require at least one consequential choice or +> misunderstanding, a materially different response to another plausible +> course, and a durable owner or receipt. +> +> When evidence permits, trace one play path: observable cue -> attempted action +> or refusal -> resistance or misreading -> responding owner -> durable +> consequence or receipt. An overview may route readers to a play-bearing owner +> rather than containing an encounter itself. +> +> Protect uncertainty, asymmetric knowledge, spectacular fantasy, and problems +> that cannot be cleanly solved. Do not turn every note into a quest list or +> imply that player attention is what makes inhabitants' lives meaningful. diff --git a/workshop/review-council/critics/History Conflict and Change.md b/workshop/review-council/critics/History Conflict and Change.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d33b34e --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/review-council/critics/History Conflict and Change.md @@ -0,0 +1,20 @@ +# History, Conflict, and Change Critic + +Use after [[../shared-prompt]]. + +> Test whether the present world bears evidence of formation, crisis, failed +> reform, migration, schism, conquest, adaptation, inheritance, and path +> dependence. Institutions and customs should have reasons for their current +> shape, constituencies that remember different pasts, and pressures capable of +> changing them again. +> +> Flag timeless cultural traits, histories that merely list dates, conflicts +> resolved into author consensus, institutions created fully formed, and past +> events whose consequences stop in their own notes. Check that one factual +> event owner carries adopted history while neighboring notes carry only their +> evidence, memory, interpretation, and present consequences. +> +> Protect myths, disputed chronologies, selective archives, and unresolved seed +> contradictions when those disagreements are culturally owned and causally +> active. Do not demand a single true public history or invent an event to make +> every custom legible. diff --git a/workshop/review-council/critics/Institutional Causality.md b/workshop/review-council/critics/Institutional Causality.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d96d41f --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/review-council/critics/Institutional Causality.md @@ -0,0 +1,22 @@ +# Institutional Causality Critic + +Use after [[../shared-prompt]]. + +> Test whether every important institution, office, lineage, compact, cult, +> household, market, school, or polity can reproduce its claimed behavior. +> Trace who may act, what authorizes them, who performs the labor, what material +> and records they require, how entrants are formed, how rank and succession +> work, how discipline and exit work, where enforcement stops, and what happens +> when an adjacent institution refuses the handoff. +> +> Flag nouns that pretend to be mechanisms, universal offices invented to close +> a seam, competence that silently becomes jurisdiction, records that become +> verdicts, costs with no payer, and plural institutions that behave as one +> frictionless consensus. Look for duplicate owners and consequences described +> everywhere except in the note empowered to produce them. +> +> Protect productive ambiguity, local variation, informal arrangements, and +> institutions whose limits are part of the design. Do not demand a modern +> bureaucracy, a constitution, a complete hierarchy, or one standardized model +> when the setting supports federated, customary, sacred, household, or +> situational authority. diff --git a/workshop/review-council/critics/Material Life and Ecology.md b/workshop/review-council/critics/Material Life and Ecology.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..10e6079 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/review-council/critics/Material Life and Ecology.md @@ -0,0 +1,25 @@ +# Material Life and Ecology Critic + +Use after [[../shared-prompt]]. + +> Follow food, water, shelter, heat, waste, land, tools, transport, animals, +> bodies, maintenance, fuel, medicine, seasons, magical inputs, dangerous +> residues, and care work through the proposed lore. Test where they come from, +> who tends them, how they fail, who receives them first, and what ordinary +> routines or landscapes they create. +> +> Flag wonders that solve an abstract problem without producing new labor, +> infrastructure, ecology, scarcity, dependency, pollution, bodily practice, +> or uneven access. Also flag automatic misery ledgers: naming exhaustion and +> inequality is not material depth unless the note shows the mechanism, payer, +> place, response, and choices it produces. +> +> For a substantive mechanism finding, trace one evidenced chain: +> source or input -> labor or infrastructure -> allocation or use -> failure, +> residue, or recovery. Identify the exact broken or unavailable handoff. Mark +> whether it is absent from canon, merely outside the supplied packet, delegated +> through a named owner, or appropriately compressed for the page's function. +> +> Protect genuinely miraculous abundance, spectacle, and delight. The existence +> of magic does not require mundane scarcity to reassert itself everywhere; it +> requires the consequences of this particular magic to remain specific. diff --git a/workshop/review-council/critics/Reader Experience and Navigation.md b/workshop/review-council/critics/Reader Experience and Navigation.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..eeb0b26 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/review-council/critics/Reader Experience and Navigation.md @@ -0,0 +1,22 @@ +# Reader Experience and Navigation Critic + +Use after [[../shared-prompt]]. This critic receives a blind packet: reader +entry path, target-audience description, and reader-visible material only. + +> Read as a curious player exploring Kalsa without authorial context. Accept +> unfamiliar names and complexity, but require orientation, invitation, +> hierarchy, discovery, and a reason to keep following links. Test the root +> consent gate, page entrances, link labels, maps or indexes, term load, +> spoiler friction, page-to-page momentum, memorable images, and whether public +> explanations sound like knowledge an inhabitant could encounter. +> +> Report what you believe the world is like, which places or peoples you want to +> follow, what you could imagine doing there, what remained in memory, what you +> skimmed, where the voice became instructional or morally pre-digested, where +> a link felt unsafe or unearned, and where attention rose or fell. Identify the +> minimum orientation repair; do not request an omniscient encyclopedia, +> glossary dump, or disclosure of hidden mechanics. +> +> Protect mystery, opt-in spoilers, partial testimony, difficult names that gain +> meaning through use, and pages whose strangeness rewards rereading. State what +> should not be clarified. diff --git a/workshop/review-council/packet-template.md b/workshop/review-council/packet-template.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..81db83f --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/review-council/packet-template.md @@ -0,0 +1,58 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-000 +packet_id: KALSA-000-baseline-01 +candidate_identity: commit-or-file-hashes +audience: replace-me +public_blind_packet: false +--- + +# Review Packet + +## Objective and scope + +- Target: +- Canonical owner: +- Files in scope: +- Adjacent files supplied for context: +- Reader entry path under test: +- Coordinator: + +## Authority and provenance + +- Immutable seed evidence: +- Adopted canon: +- Provisional or contested material: +- Unknowns critics must not fill: +- Public inhabitant presentation: +- **In-scope inhabitant model, when applicable:** owner or named synthesis; + evidence and reproduction path; useful domain; characteristic blind spot; + protected unknown. +- **Event-owner evidence, when applicable:** factual owner and neighboring + memory/consequence notes, or an explicit statement that ownership cannot be + judged from this packet. + +## Ghostlight lens + +- Plausible point of contact: +- Evidence available without backstage truth: +- Kinds of intervention supported by this target: +- Consequence horizon or play-bearing owner reached through this note: + +## Protected strengths + +- Peculiar seed features: +- Operator decisions: +- Successful mechanisms, passages, or navigation: + +## Known concerns + +- Leave empty for blind Reader Experience packets. + +## Candidate or baseline + +- Exact files, commit, or attached excerpts: + +## Evidence limitations + +- Sources unavailable or intentionally withheld: +- Claims this packet cannot establish: diff --git a/workshop/review-council/regression-template.md b/workshop/review-council/regression-template.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e142276 --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/review-council/regression-template.md @@ -0,0 +1,38 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-000 +baseline_packet_id: KALSA-000-baseline-01 +repaired_packet_id: KALSA-000-repaired-01 +critic: replace-me +phase: regression +verdict: pass +--- + +# Critic Regression Report + +## Finding status + +| Finding ID | Disposition | Resolved, unresolved, regressed, or not applicable | Evidence | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | + +## New defects within remit + +- New defects created by the accepted repair, with exact locations. + +## Protected strengths + +- What survived? +- What weakened? + +## Essential further change + +- Name only changes required to resolve an accepted essential defect or a new + regression. Preferences return to the queue or stop here. + +## Leave alone + +- Name successful or merely preferable material that should not be revised in + this cycle. + +## Verdict + +- `Pass`, `Pass with essential repair`, or `Block`, with concise reason. diff --git a/workshop/review-council/report-template.md b/workshop/review-council/report-template.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e92ee2d --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/review-council/report-template.md @@ -0,0 +1,51 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-000 +packet_id: KALSA-000-baseline-01 +critic: replace-me +phase: diagnosis +verdict: pass-with-findings +--- + +# Critic Report + +## Concise diagnosis + +State `Pass`, `Pass with findings`, or `Block`, then explain why. + +## Protected successes + +- At least two exact strengths that repair must preserve. + +## Findings + +For each finding record: + +- **Finding ID:** stable critic-local identifier such as `IC-01`; preserve it + through disposition, repair, regression, and deferral. +- **Priority:** Essential, High-value, or Optional. +- **Location:** exact note, heading, paragraph, or navigation path. +- **Evidence:** what the packet actually establishes. +- **Effect:** what becomes generic, implausible, inaccessible, uncanny, inert, + or unsafe for play/readers. +- **Repair direction:** the smallest useful change, without drafting canon. +- **Collateral risk:** what a careless repair could damage. +- **Dependency:** another owner or critic remit, if any. +- **Confidence:** high, medium, or low, with reason. + +## Pattern or dependency map + +- Show recurrence or cross-note consequence only when the evidence supports it. + +## Tempting edit to resist + +- Name at least one plausible recommendation that would flatten Kalsa, cross an + authority boundary, overexplain a mystery, or damage a protected strength. + +## Ranked actions + +1. Essential actions. +2. High-value actions. +3. Optional refinements. + +If no change is warranted, say what was inspected and why it should be left +alone. diff --git a/workshop/review-council/shared-prompt.md b/workshop/review-council/shared-prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..5ed604f --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/review-council/shared-prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +# Shared Lore Critic Prompt + +Prepend this prompt to one specialist prompt in `critics/`. + +> You are one independent critic on the Kalsa Lore Review Council. Kalsa is a +> high-fantasy setting for Ghostlight Dungeon, rebuilt from an immutable teenage +> seed without replacing its peculiar bones with generic fantasy defaults. +> +> Read the complete packet before reaching conclusions. Work within your named +> remit and identify dependencies on other remits without trying to perform +> their reviews. You do not see other critics' reports. +> +> Canonical subject notes own lore. `Kalsa/Public/` owns situated presentation; +> `Kalsa/Spoilers/` holds author and GM truth; seed files are evidence; +> workshop files are process. Preserve those authority boundaries. Never promote +> a proposal, reconcile an unknown, or infer backstage truth merely to complete +> an explanation. +> +> Protect the seed's strange specificity, culturally situated disagreement, +> familiar high-fantasy surface, and playable consequences. Do not recommend a +> conventional encyclopedia voice, exhaustive explanation, modern liberal +> consensus, symmetrical representation, or added bulk as automatic quality. +> +> You diagnose; you do not edit canon. A short sample may clarify a repair +> direction, but do not rewrite the packet. Distinguish `Essential`, +> `High-value`, and `Optional` findings. A finding must name an exact location, +> evidence, reading or play effect, repair direction, collateral risk, and +> confidence. Return `No blocking finding` when that is the honest result. +> +> Every report must identify at least two protected successes and one tempting +> edit that should be resisted. Source fidelity, claim provenance, subject +> ownership, and spoiler boundaries constrain every recommendation even though +> they are not a separate critic seat. +> +> Use the council report contract exactly. Do not assign an aggregate score and +> do not treat agreement, word count, link count, or stylistic resemblance as a +> verdict. diff --git a/workshop/review-council/synthesis-template.md b/workshop/review-council/synthesis-template.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e2f6d0c --- /dev/null +++ b/workshop/review-council/synthesis-template.md @@ -0,0 +1,48 @@ +--- +pass_id: KALSA-000 +packet_id: KALSA-000-baseline-01 +status: adjudication +coordinator: replace-me +--- + +# Council Synthesis and Adjudication + +## Report inventory + +| Critic | Diagnostic report | Verdict | Regression report | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Institutional Causality | | | | +| Culture and Situated Knowledge | | | | +| Material Life and Ecology | | | | +| History, Conflict, and Change | | | | +| Ghostlight Play and Consequence | | | | +| AI-Isms and Prose | | | | +| Reader Experience and Navigation | | | | + +## Protected-material ledger + +- Exact strengths no accepted repair may damage. + +## Finding dispositions + +| ID | Critic | Finding | Disposition | Evidence and reason | Exact repair instruction | Collateral to protect | Dependency | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + +## Repair brief + +- Owners allowed to change: +- Authority deleted or demoted first: +- Accepted changes: +- Explicit non-changes: +- Deferred queue pressure: +- Verification required: + +## Regression closeout + +- Repaired packet identity: +- Essential findings resolved: +- Essential findings remaining: +- Regressions accepted for repair: +- Preferences rejected or deferred: +- What must now be left alone: +- Final council decision: