diff --git a/AGENTS.md b/AGENTS.md index 6e65363..a16e075 100644 --- a/AGENTS.md +++ b/AGENTS.md @@ -117,6 +117,33 @@ benefit and harm, dependencies, historical formation, internal contradiction, and consequences for play. Use `workshop/deepening/benchmark.md` as the parity standard; do not turn word count into a victory condition. +## Reader Calibration + +Calibration drifts upward across passes and never downward. Writing above a +reader reads as respect and writing below them reads as condescension, so the +error is asymmetric and every pass inherits the previous pass's ceiling. Nothing +in the deepening loop resists this by default: a note is legible to precisely the +reader it was tuned for, and it was tuned for whoever wrote it. + +Three consequences bind the council: + +- Completeness does not establish legibility. A breach usually compresses rather + than omits. An argument folded into a named term is fully present and + expandable only by a reader who already holds it. A fact audit cannot detect + this, because every fact is there. +- Restatement is error correction. The concrete instance after an abstraction is + the reader's recovery path, not redundancy to be trimmed. +- The failure is silent. An over-calibrated note is understood sentence by + sentence while nothing accumulates, and names that carry weight for an + inhabitant of the project stay inert for a newcomer. Silence is the expected + symptom, so absence of complaint is not evidence. + +[[critics/Reader Experience and Navigation|Reader Experience and Navigation]] is +the only seat positioned to observe this, and only because its packet is blind. +Do not enrich that packet with authorial context, prior pass notes, or an +explanation of what the surface is trying to achieve. A blind packet that has +been helpfully contextualised has stopped being an instrument. + ## Project Memory - Project memory records durable judgment, operating lessons, adopted