# Elaborator campaign Four waves completed: 64 Astra Low passes at concurrency 16, including eight explicit refinements. All candidate branch pairs are published and verified: 20 shortlisted, 18 marked for revision, and 26 declined for this shortlist. No campaign worker or reviewer remains running. Codex owned wave dispatch and review; no external scheduler ran. The existing titled Elaborators, paired lore/Ghostlight clones, ledgers and candidate branches are retained. Current main supplies lore context. Assignments emphasize underdeveloped cultural life, including new cultures, with grounded prose and understatement. A reviewer read all sixteen candidates after each wave and selected the strongest for operator review. Promotion did not merge canon. Codex used each review to change the next wave's assignments and prompt calibration. No fifth wave is scheduled. Worker PID, logs and exit receipts are under `work/elaboration/waves/004/` in this task directory. Explicit plans and prompts are under `work/elaboration/`. Prior additions retain their existing approval statuses. [Read the shortlist](./elaboration-shortlist.md). [Completion and verification report](./elaboration-completion.md).