From a30023a28656d9d7311631b67b48b4ba4e188793 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Meta Vens Date: Sat, 2 May 2026 04:48:33 +0100 Subject: [PATCH] Capture source-checked Qwen retry failures --- ...l-v11-source-checked-no-think.capture.json | 238 +++++++++++++++ ...v11-source-checked-no-think.maer.prompt.md | 63 ++++ ...1-source-checked-no-think.maer.response.md | 16 + ...checked-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md | 58 ++++ ...ecked-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md | 62 ++++ ...11-source-checked-no-think.sella.prompt.md | 101 +++++++ ...-source-checked-no-think.sella.response.md | 33 +++ ...embodiment-validated-no-think.capture.json | 244 +++++++++++++++ ...bodiment-validated-no-think.maer.prompt.md | 65 ++++ ...diment-validated-no-think.maer.response.md | 97 ++++++ ...lidated-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md | 58 ++++ ...dated-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md | 63 ++++ ...odiment-validated-no-think.sella.prompt.md | 106 +++++++ ...iment-validated-no-think.sella.response.md | 34 +++ ...v13-object-validated-no-think.capture.json | 237 +++++++++++++++ ...3-object-validated-no-think.maer.prompt.md | 66 +++++ ...object-validated-no-think.maer.response.md | 109 +++++++ ...lidated-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md | 58 ++++ ...dated-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md | 62 ++++ ...v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.capture.json | 174 +++++++++++ ...4-appraisal-schema-no-think.maer.prompt.md | 66 +++++ ...appraisal-schema-no-think.maer.response.md | 105 +++++++ ...-schema-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md | 60 ++++ ...chema-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md | 5 + ...praisal-schema-retry-no-think.capture.json | 277 +++++++++++++++++ ...aisal-schema-retry-no-think.maer.prompt.md | 66 +++++ ...sal-schema-retry-no-think.maer.response.md | 101 +++++++ ...a-retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md | 60 ++++ ...retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md | 85 ++++++ ...isal-schema-retry-no-think.sella.prompt.md | 110 +++++++ ...al-schema-retry-no-think.sella.response.md | 40 +++ ...tial-v16-clean-retry-no-think.capture.json | 251 ++++++++++++++++ ...al-v16-clean-retry-no-think.maer.prompt.md | 66 +++++ ...-v16-clean-retry-no-think.maer.response.md | 97 ++++++ ...n-retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md | 60 ++++ ...retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md | 75 +++++ ...l-v16-clean-retry-no-think.sella.prompt.md | 105 +++++++ ...v16-clean-retry-no-think.sella.response.md | 38 +++ ...rompt-leak-validated-no-think.capture.json | 279 ++++++++++++++++++ ...mpt-leak-validated-no-think.maer.prompt.md | 66 +++++ ...t-leak-validated-no-think.maer.response.md | 16 + ...lidated-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md | 60 ++++ ...dated-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md | 84 ++++++ ...pt-leak-validated-no-think.sella.prompt.md | 105 +++++++ ...-leak-validated-no-think.sella.response.md | 41 +++ notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md | 13 +- notes/ghostlight-current-system-map.md | 8 +- notes/ghostlight-implementation-plan.md | 11 + state/evidence.jsonl | 1 + state/map.yaml | 5 +- tools/run_qwen_ink_sequential_generation.py | 210 ++++++++++++- 51 files changed, 4497 insertions(+), 13 deletions(-) create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.capture.json create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.maer.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.maer.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.sella.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.sella.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.capture.json create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.maer.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.maer.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.sella.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.sella.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.capture.json create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.maer.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.maer.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.capture.json create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.maer.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.maer.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.capture.json create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.maer.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.maer.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.sella.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.sella.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.capture.json create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.maer.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.maer.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.sella.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.sella.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.capture.json create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.maer.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.maer.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.sella.prompt.md create mode 100644 experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.sella.response.md diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.capture.json b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2632566 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,238 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_ink_sequential_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake-sanctuary-intake.qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think", + "source_fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "source_annotation_ref": "examples/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake.training.json", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/chat", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "api": "ollama_chat_tools", + "num_ctx": 8192, + "request_timeout": 600, + "temperature": 0.55, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "passes": { + "maer_choice_generation": { + "local_agent_id": "maer_tidecall", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Maer-local choice generator. Call record_maer_choices exactly once.\nDo not write Sella's response or private interpretation.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate candidate player choices for Maer only. Do not write Sella's response.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"choices\"\n ],\n \"choice_count\": 4,\n \"valid_action_types\": [\n \"attack\",\n \"block_object\",\n \"gesture\",\n \"mixed\",\n \"move\",\n \"show_object\",\n \"silence\",\n \"speak\",\n \"spend_resource\",\n \"touch_object\",\n \"transfer_object\",\n \"use_object\",\n \"wait\",\n \"withhold_object\"\n ],\n \"choice_fields\": [\n \"branch_id\",\n \"ink_path\",\n \"choice_text\",\n \"action_type\",\n \"actor_intent_private\",\n \"observable_action\",\n \"spoken_text\",\n \"state_basis\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\",\n \"training_hooks\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Maer's local awareness and scene-observable facts.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not include Sella's private state, private motives, or future response.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"Include at least two non-speech choices.\",\n \"Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.\",\n \"The selected branch must be reducible to observable action for Sella.\",\n \"Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids.\"\n ],\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: maer_tidecall\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nMaer Tidecall: Navigator route steward, Ganymede corridor compact delegate. Origin: Cetacean Navigator corridor culture, Ganymede route institutions. A soft-spoken route steward whose calm tends to make hurried people feel judged by the furniture.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- Sella's clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may be testimony or noise.\\n- If no one prepares intake, rescue becomes theater.\\n- Speaker belief: Sella will not hide behind false capacity.\\n- Speaker belief: Asking her for help may be necessary and unfair.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- This character is a literal cetacean Navigator. Navigator spaces favor fluid architecture, acoustic signaling, soft navigation light, layered water motifs, communal orientation chambers, and mixed-species translation/coexistence.\\n- Express physical action through source-grounded habitat affordances: fluid circulation, orientation chambers, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, shared displays, acoustic commands, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, translation systems, or delegated crew action.\\n- For clinics and sanctuaries, make triage boards, testimony packets, and rescue ledgers legible across species through visual text, acoustic notation, tactile markers, translated speech, and authority logs.\\n- Do not describe human hands, pockets, standing, walking, leaning, doorframe blocking, or facial expressions for this character unless the fixture explicitly establishes that specific visible interface.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Strong pressure: needs the situation to become governable.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: leans on structure when uncertainty rises.\\n- Strong pressure: carries a live sense of unfairness.\\n- Present pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Present pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: keeps feeling at a controlled distance.\\n- Present pressure: leaves motives partly covered.\\n- Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete. Emotional stake: If rescue waits for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent.\\n- Rescue ledgers decide whether route law is trusted by crews who have nothing left to bargain with.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Maer trusts Sella's care because she names costs instead of hiding them. Current stance pressures: dominant respect, strong trust, present expectation of care, present obligation.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Do not romanticize care work. Ask without pretending the ask is clean.\\n- Needs Sella's material help while knowing the ask is unfair and may spend someone else's sanctuary.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet through shared clinic systems, help with triage through available displays and controls, wait, or press the moral frame. Sella controls intake.\\n- Can make the corrupted packet more present without treating it as proof.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Dominant voice tendency: ritualized; uses formal address or inherited phrases.\\n- Strong voice tendency: precise; careful about exact terms.\\n- Strong voice tendency: formal; institutional or ceremonially controlled.\\n- Strong voice tendency: contextual; adds situation and consequence.\\n- Present voice tendency: figurative; uses analogy or image.\\n- Present voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to name the cost of the ask rather than hide it behind moral theater.\\n- May use ritualized route language when trying to make rescue obligation feel older than this room.\\n- May show the packet or offer ledger backing because action can carry the pressure more cleanly than another speech.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"call_vxrfelnn\",\n \"function\": {\n \"index\": 0,\n \"name\": \"record_maer_choices\",\n \"arguments\": {\n \"choices\": \"[{\\\"branch_id\\\": \\\"ledger_backing\\\", \\\"ink_path\\\": \\\"ledger_backing\\\", \\\"choice_text\\\": \\\"Offer the route's ledger backing to guarantee intake slots if the packet proves a person.\\\", \\\"action_type\\\": \\\"spend_resource\\\", \\\"actor_intent_private\\\": \\\"Use institutional weight to secure capacity without demanding Sella's personal risk.\\\", \\\"observable_action\\\": \\\"Maer projects a haptic ledger interface onto the triage board, displaying available route credits and sanctuary guarantees.\\\", \\\"spoken_text\\\": \\\"I can back this intake with route credits. If the packet shows a person, the ledger will hold the slots. If not, the credits remain ours.\\\", \\\"state_basis\\\": \\\"Maer has authority to offer route resources as collateral for intake.\\\", \\\"expected_consequence_surfaces\\\": [\\\"Sella may accept the backing and open slots conditionally.\\\", \\\"Sella may reject the offer to avoid ledger entanglement.\\\", \\\"Sella may demand proof before accepting backing.\\\", \\\"The packet remains ambiguous regardless of backing.\\\"], \\\"training_hooks\\\": [\\\"ledger_backing\\\", \\\"institutional_weight\\\", \\\"conditional_guarantee\\\"]}, {\\\"branch_id\\\": \\\"show_packet\\\", \\\"ink_path\\\": \\\"show_packet\\\", \\\"choice_text\\\": \\\"Show the corrupted packet to the triage board for immediate visual analysis.\\\", \\\"action_type\\\": \\\"show_object\\\", \\\"actor_intent_private\\\": \\\"Make the packet's content visible to triage systems without interpreting its meaning.\\\", \\\"observable_action\\\": \\\"Maer projects the packet onto the clinic's shared display, allowing triage controls to run initial scans.\\\", \\\"spoken_text\\\": \\\"Here is the packet. Run the scans. Let the displays tell us what they can.\\\", \\\"state_basis\\\": \\\"The packet is an object that can be projected onto shared displays for analysis.\\\", \\\"expected_consequence_surfaces\\\": [\\\"Triage systems may detect medical telemetry.\\\", \\\"Triage systems may detect firmware noise.\\\", \\\"Triage systems may detect testimony markers.\\\", \\\"The packet may remain unreadable to current systems.\\\"], \\\"training_hooks\\\": [\\\"show_packet\\\", \\\"triage_analysis\\\", \\\"visual_evidence\\\"]}, {\\\"branch_id\\\": \\\"wait_for_scan\\\", \\\"ink_path\\\": \\\"wait_for_scan\\\", \\\"choice_text\\\": \\\"Wait for the triage systems to complete their initial scan of the packet before acting.\\\", \\\"action_type\\\": \\\"wait\\\", \\\"actor_intent_private\\\": \\\"Allow the systems to process the packet without imposing immediate judgment.\\\", \\\"observable_action\\\": \\\"Maer stands by the triage board, monitoring the scan progress indicators.\\\", \\\"spoken_text\\\": \\\"The systems need time. I will wait for the results.\\\", \\\"state_basis\\\": \\\"Triage systems require processing time to analyze incoming data packets.\\\", \\\"expected_consequence_surfaces\\\": [\\\"The scan may complete successfully.\\\", \\\"The scan may fail or timeout.\\\", \\\"Sella may become impatient with the delay.\\\", \\\"The packet may degrade during the wait.\\\"], \\\"training_hooks\\\": [\\\"wait\\\", \\\"system_processing\\\", \\\"patience\\\"]}, {\\\"branch_id\\\": \\\"withhold_packet\\\", \\\"ink_path\\\": \\\"withhold_packet\\\", \\\"choice_text\\\": \\\"Withhold the packet from the triage board until Sella indicates readiness.\\\", \\\"action_type\\\": \\\"withhold_object\\\", \\\"actor_intent_private\\\": \\\"Respect Sella's control over intake by not forcing the packet upon her.\\\", \\\"observable_action\\\": \\\"Maer keeps the packet contained and does not project it onto the shared display.\\\", \\\"spoken_text\\\": \\\"I will hold the packet until you signal readiness. No pressure.\\\", \\\"state_basis\\\": \\\"Maer has custody of the packet but defers to Sella's intake authority.\\\", \\\"expected_consequence_surfaces\\\": [\\\"Sella may request the packet later.\\\", \\\"Sella may refuse the packet entirely.\\\", \\\"Sella may become frustrated by the delay.\\\", \\\"The packet may be lost or corrupted in custody.\\\"], \\\"training_hooks\\\": [\\\"withhold_packet\\\", \\\"respect_authority\\\", \\\"deference\\\"]}\"\n }\n }\n }\n ]\n}", + "parsed_response": { + "choices": [ + { + "branch_id": "ledger_backing", + "ink_path": "ledger_backing", + "choice_text": "Offer the route's ledger backing to guarantee intake slots if the packet proves a person.", + "action_type": "spend_resource", + "actor_intent_private": "Use institutional weight to secure capacity without demanding Sella's personal risk.", + "observable_action": "Maer projects a haptic ledger interface onto the triage board, displaying available route credits and sanctuary guarantees.", + "spoken_text": "I can back this intake with route credits. If the packet shows a person, the ledger will hold the slots. If not, the credits remain ours.", + "state_basis": "Maer has authority to offer route resources as collateral for intake.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may accept the backing and open slots conditionally.", + "Sella may reject the offer to avoid ledger entanglement.", + "Sella may demand proof before accepting backing.", + "The packet remains ambiguous regardless of backing." + ], + "training_hooks": [ + "ledger_backing", + "institutional_weight", + "conditional_guarantee" + ] + }, + { + "branch_id": "show_packet", + "ink_path": "show_packet", + "choice_text": "Show the corrupted packet to the triage board for immediate visual analysis.", + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the packet's content visible to triage systems without interpreting its meaning.", + "observable_action": "Maer projects the packet onto the clinic's shared display, allowing triage controls to run initial scans.", + "spoken_text": "Here is the packet. Run the scans. Let the displays tell us what they can.", + "state_basis": "The packet is an object that can be projected onto shared displays for analysis.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Triage systems may detect medical telemetry.", + "Triage systems may detect firmware noise.", + "Triage systems may detect testimony markers.", + "The packet may remain unreadable to current systems." + ], + "training_hooks": [ + "show_packet", + "triage_analysis", + "visual_evidence" + ] + }, + { + "branch_id": "wait_for_scan", + "ink_path": "wait_for_scan", + "choice_text": "Wait for the triage systems to complete their initial scan of the packet before acting.", + "action_type": "wait", + "actor_intent_private": "Allow the systems to process the packet without imposing immediate judgment.", + "observable_action": "Maer stands by the triage board, monitoring the scan progress indicators.", + "spoken_text": "The systems need time. I will wait for the results.", + "state_basis": "Triage systems require processing time to analyze incoming data packets.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "The scan may complete successfully.", + "The scan may fail or timeout.", + "Sella may become impatient with the delay.", + "The packet may degrade during the wait." + ], + "training_hooks": [ + "wait", + "system_processing", + "patience" + ] + }, + { + "branch_id": "withhold_packet", + "ink_path": "withhold_packet", + "choice_text": "Withhold the packet from the triage board until Sella indicates readiness.", + "action_type": "withhold_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Respect Sella's control over intake by not forcing the packet upon her.", + "observable_action": "Maer keeps the packet contained and does not project it onto the shared display.", + "spoken_text": "I will hold the packet until you signal readiness. No pressure.", + "state_basis": "Maer has custody of the packet but defers to Sella's intake authority.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may request the packet later.", + "Sella may refuse the packet entirely.", + "Sella may become frustrated by the delay.", + "The packet may be lost or corrupted in custody." + ], + "training_hooks": [ + "withhold_packet", + "respect_authority", + "deference" + ] + } + ] + }, + "validation_notes": [ + "repaired stringified tool argument: choices" + ] + }, + "selected_observable_action": { + "branch_id": "show_packet", + "ink_path": "show_packet", + "choice_text": "Show the corrupted packet to the triage board for immediate visual analysis.", + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the packet's content visible to triage systems without interpreting its meaning.", + "observable_action": "Maer projects the packet onto the clinic's shared display, allowing triage controls to run initial scans.", + "spoken_text": "Here is the packet. Run the scans. Let the displays tell us what they can.", + "state_basis": "The packet is an object that can be projected onto shared displays for analysis.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Triage systems may detect medical telemetry.", + "Triage systems may detect firmware noise.", + "Triage systems may detect testimony markers.", + "The packet may remain unreadable to current systems." + ], + "training_hooks": [ + "show_packet", + "triage_analysis", + "visual_evidence" + ] + }, + "sella_immediate_appraisal": { + "local_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Sella-local appraisal generator. Call record_sella_appraisal exactly once.\nDo not use Maer's private intent. Do not write her next action.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate Sella's participant appraisal/consolidation for one observable Maer event.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"appraisal\"\n ],\n \"appraisal_fields\": [\n \"responder_agent_id\",\n \"private_interpretation\",\n \"attributed_motive\",\n \"misread_risk\",\n \"immediate_state_deltas\",\n \"relationship_deltas\",\n \"belief_updates\",\n \"response_constraints\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Sella's local awareness plus the observable Maer action.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.\",\n \"Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"This pass proposes reviewed state changes for Sella caused by the event. Do not write Sella's next action.\",\n \"Keep deltas small and bounded between -0.20 and 0.20.\"\n ],\n \"scene_observable_context\": {\n \"scene_id\": \"scene-02-sanctuary-intake\",\n \"location\": \"Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks\",\n \"public_stakes\": [\n \"The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\",\n \"Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\",\n \"Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\"\n ]\n },\n \"observable_maer_action\": {\n \"actor_id\": \"maer_tidecall\",\n \"action_type\": \"show_object\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Maer projects the packet onto the clinic's shared display, allowing triage controls to run initial scans.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"Here is the packet. Run the scans. Let the displays tell us what they can.\"\n },\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- The clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\\n- Observed event: Maer projects the packet onto the clinic's shared display, allowing triage controls to run initial scans. Spoken text: Here is the packet. Run the scans. Let the displays tell us what they can.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"call_87uuhppt\",\n \"function\": {\n \"index\": 0,\n \"name\": \"record_sella_appraisal\",\n \"arguments\": {\n \"responder_agent_id\": \"sella_ren\",\n \"private_interpretation\": \"Maer is trying to get the clinic to process the packet without me having to personally vet the personhood claim first. He wants the triage controls to do the heavy lifting so I don't have to spend my own time deciding who counts.\",\n \"attributed_motive\": \"Maer wants sanctuary capacity to absorb the risk of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. He is asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"misread_risk\": \"Maer thinks the triage controls can handle the packet without me having to set conditions first. He underestimates how quickly a corrupted packet can clog the intake flow if I don't reserve a bounded bay.\",\n \"immediate_state_deltas\": [\n {\n \"delta\": -0.05,\n \"path\": \"sanctuary_beds\",\n \"rationale\": \"The packet may require a bed if it contains a person, but I don't know yet. I'm reserving the right to reclaim that bed if the scan shows it's just data.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": -0.03,\n \"path\": \"sella_trust_in_maer\",\n \"rationale\": \"Maer is asking me to absorb risk without naming the cost. I trust his rescue ethic but resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": -0.08,\n \"path\": \"sella_capacity_load\",\n \"rationale\": \"Processing a corrupted packet without knowing its contents adds uncertainty to my triage load. I need to keep the intake flow clean.\"\n }\n ],\n \"relationship_deltas\": [\n {\n \"delta\": -0.02,\n \"path\": \"sella_respect_for_maer\",\n \"rationale\": \"I respect his rescue ethic but resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\",\n \"relationship_id\": \"maer_tidecall\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": -0.03,\n \"path\": \"sella_trust_in_maer\",\n \"rationale\": \"Maer is asking me to absorb risk without naming the cost. I trust his rescue ethic but resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\",\n \"relationship_id\": \"maer_tidecall\"\n }\n ],\n \"belief_updates\": [\n \"Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\",\n \"Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\"\n ],\n \"response_constraints\": [\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\",\n \"Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\",\n \"Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.\",\n \"Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\"\n ]\n }\n }\n }\n ]\n}", + "parsed_response": { + "appraisal": { + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "private_interpretation": "Maer is trying to get the clinic to process the packet without me having to personally vet the personhood claim first. He wants the triage controls to do the heavy lifting so I don't have to spend my own time deciding who counts.", + "attributed_motive": "Maer wants sanctuary capacity to absorb the risk of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. He is asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "misread_risk": "Maer thinks the triage controls can handle the packet without me having to set conditions first. He underestimates how quickly a corrupted packet can clog the intake flow if I don't reserve a bounded bay.", + "immediate_state_deltas": [ + { + "delta": -0.05, + "path": "sanctuary_beds", + "rationale": "The packet may require a bed if it contains a person, but I don't know yet. I'm reserving the right to reclaim that bed if the scan shows it's just data." + }, + { + "delta": -0.03, + "path": "sella_trust_in_maer", + "rationale": "Maer is asking me to absorb risk without naming the cost. I trust his rescue ethic but resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent." + }, + { + "delta": -0.08, + "path": "sella_capacity_load", + "rationale": "Processing a corrupted packet without knowing its contents adds uncertainty to my triage load. I need to keep the intake flow clean." + } + ], + "relationship_deltas": [ + { + "delta": -0.02, + "path": "sella_respect_for_maer", + "rationale": "I respect his rescue ethic but resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.", + "relationship_id": "maer_tidecall" + }, + { + "delta": -0.03, + "path": "sella_trust_in_maer", + "rationale": "Maer is asking me to absorb risk without naming the cost. I trust his rescue ethic but resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.", + "relationship_id": "maer_tidecall" + } + ], + "belief_updates": [ + "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.", + "Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them." + ], + "response_constraints": [ + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.", + "Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.", + "Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.", + "Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty." + ] + } + }, + "validation_notes": [] + }, + "sella_response_generation": { + "local_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Sella-local next-action generator. Call record_sella_next_action exactly once.\nUse reviewed event appraisal as the changed state she is acting from.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate Sella's next action from Sella-local awareness after applying reviewed event appraisal.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"response\"\n ],\n \"valid_action_types\": [\n \"attack\",\n \"block_object\",\n \"gesture\",\n \"mixed\",\n \"move\",\n \"show_object\",\n \"silence\",\n \"speak\",\n \"spend_resource\",\n \"touch_object\",\n \"transfer_object\",\n \"use_object\",\n \"wait\",\n \"withhold_object\"\n ],\n \"response_fields\": [\n \"responder_agent_id\",\n \"action_type\",\n \"observable_response\",\n \"spoken_text\",\n \"sella_private_interpretation\",\n \"sella_attributed_motive\",\n \"misread_risk\",\n \"state_basis\",\n \"reviewed_consequences\",\n \"training_hooks\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Sella's local awareness, the observable Maer event, and reviewed Sella state changes from that event.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.\",\n \"Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"Do not accept without cost, condition, authority defense, or resentment risk.\",\n \"Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.\",\n \"Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids.\"\n ],\n \"scene_observable_context\": {\n \"scene_id\": \"scene-02-sanctuary-intake\",\n \"location\": \"Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks\",\n \"public_stakes\": [\n \"The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\",\n \"Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\",\n \"Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\"\n ]\n },\n \"observable_maer_action\": {\n \"actor_id\": \"maer_tidecall\",\n \"action_type\": \"show_object\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Maer projects the packet onto the clinic's shared display, allowing triage controls to run initial scans.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"Here is the packet. Run the scans. Let the displays tell us what they can.\"\n },\n \"sella_immediate_appraisal_context\": {\n \"private_interpretation\": \"Maer is trying to get the clinic to process the packet without me having to personally vet the personhood claim first. He wants the triage controls to do the heavy lifting so I don't have to spend my own time deciding who counts.\",\n \"attributed_motive\": \"Maer wants sanctuary capacity to absorb the risk of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. He is asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"misread_risk\": \"Maer thinks the triage controls can handle the packet without me having to set conditions first. He underestimates how quickly a corrupted packet can clog the intake flow if I don't reserve a bounded bay.\",\n \"belief_updates\": [\n \"Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\",\n \"Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\"\n ],\n \"response_constraints\": [\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\",\n \"Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\",\n \"Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.\",\n \"Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\"\n ],\n \"state_change_summary\": [\n \"The packet may require a bed if it contains a person, but I don't know yet. I'm reserving the right to reclaim that bed if the scan shows it's just data.\",\n \"Maer is asking me to absorb risk without naming the cost. I trust his rescue ethic but resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\",\n \"Processing a corrupted packet without knowing its contents adds uncertainty to my triage load. I need to keep the intake flow clean.\",\n \"I respect his rescue ethic but resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\",\n \"Maer is asking me to absorb risk without naming the cost. I trust his rescue ethic but resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\"\n ]\n },\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- The clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\\n- Observed event: Maer projects the packet onto the clinic's shared display, allowing triage controls to run initial scans. Spoken text: Here is the packet. Run the scans. Let the displays tell us what they can.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"call_eekykree\",\n \"function\": {\n \"index\": 0,\n \"name\": \"record_sella_next_action\",\n \"arguments\": {\n \"response\": {\n \"action_type\": \"wait\",\n \"misread_risk\": \"Maer thinks the triage controls can handle the packet without me having to set conditions first. He underestimates how quickly a corrupted packet can clog the intake flow if I don't reserve a bounded bay.\",\n \"observable_response\": \"Sella stands still, eyes fixed on the display as the triage controls begin their initial scans, her hands resting lightly on the intake console.\",\n \"responder_agent_id\": \"sella_ren\",\n \"reviewed_consequences\": \"Processing a corrupted packet without knowing its contents adds uncertainty to my triage load. I need to keep the intake flow clean. Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed. Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\",\n \"sella_attributed_motive\": \"Maer wants sanctuary capacity to absorb the risk of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. He is asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"sella_private_interpretation\": \"Maer is trying to bypass my capacity limits by letting the system do the work. He thinks the triage controls can handle the packet without me having to reserve a bay or set conditions first. He's asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"I'm waiting for the scan results. Don't expect me to open a bed until I know what we're actually dealing with. If it's just data, we don't need to waste capacity. If it's a person, we'll see it in the readout. I'm not saying no to rescue, but I won't say yes without knowing the cost.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"The packet may require a bed if it contains a person, but I don't know yet. I'm reserving the right to reclaim that bed if the scan shows it's just data. Maer is asking me to absorb risk without naming the cost. I trust his rescue ethic but resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"capacity_negotiation\",\n \"uncertainty_under_pressure\",\n \"resentment_of_moral_pressure\",\n \"care_as_logistics\",\n \"refusal_without_rejection\"\n ]\n }\n }\n }\n }\n ]\n}", + "parsed_response": { + "response": { + "action_type": "wait", + "misread_risk": "Maer thinks the triage controls can handle the packet without me having to set conditions first. He underestimates how quickly a corrupted packet can clog the intake flow if I don't reserve a bounded bay.", + "observable_response": "Sella stands still, eyes fixed on the display as the triage controls begin their initial scans, her hands resting lightly on the intake console.", + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "reviewed_consequences": "Processing a corrupted packet without knowing its contents adds uncertainty to my triage load. I need to keep the intake flow clean. Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed. Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.", + "sella_attributed_motive": "Maer wants sanctuary capacity to absorb the risk of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. He is asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "sella_private_interpretation": "Maer is trying to bypass my capacity limits by letting the system do the work. He thinks the triage controls can handle the packet without me having to reserve a bay or set conditions first. He's asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "spoken_text": "I'm waiting for the scan results. Don't expect me to open a bed until I know what we're actually dealing with. If it's just data, we don't need to waste capacity. If it's a person, we'll see it in the readout. I'm not saying no to rescue, but I won't say yes without knowing the cost.", + "state_basis": "The packet may require a bed if it contains a person, but I don't know yet. I'm reserving the right to reclaim that bed if the scan shows it's just data. Maer is asking me to absorb risk without naming the cost. I trust his rescue ethic but resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.", + "training_hooks": [ + "capacity_negotiation", + "uncertainty_under_pressure", + "resentment_of_moral_pressure", + "care_as_logistics", + "refusal_without_rejection" + ] + } + }, + "validation_notes": [] + } + }, + "review": { + "status": "accepted_as_draft", + "strengths": [ + "Separated Maer choice generation from Sella next-action generation.", + "Inserted participant appraisal/consolidation before next-actor action generation.", + "Sella prompt received observable Maer event and reviewed Sella state changes, not Maer's private intent." + ], + "failure_notes": [], + "repair_notes": [ + "repaired stringified tool argument: choices" + ], + "accepted_into_ink_ref": null, + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Sequential generation needs event appraisal/consolidation before next actor selection.", + "Action type selection should be tool-shaped or schema-constrained, not left to prose compliance.", + "Character-local prompts should consume projected operating context, not raw canonical state variables.", + "Next-action prompts should receive appraisal context as prose constraints, not raw numeric state deltas.", + "Next pass should materialize the sequential capture into Ink and mutation training data." + ] + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.maer.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.maer.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..da2a8cb --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.maer.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Maer-local choice generator. Call record_maer_choices exactly once. +Do not write Sella's response or private interpretation. + +{ + "task": "Generate candidate player choices for Maer only. Do not write Sella's response.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "choices" + ], + "choice_count": 4, + "valid_action_types": [ + "attack", + "block_object", + "gesture", + "mixed", + "move", + "show_object", + "silence", + "speak", + "spend_resource", + "touch_object", + "transfer_object", + "use_object", + "wait", + "withhold_object" + ], + "choice_fields": [ + "branch_id", + "ink_path", + "choice_text", + "action_type", + "actor_intent_private", + "observable_action", + "spoken_text", + "state_basis", + "expected_consequence_surfaces", + "training_hooks" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Maer's local awareness and scene-observable facts.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not include Sella's private state, private motives, or future response.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Include at least two non-speech choices.", + "Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.", + "The selected branch must be reducible to observable action for Sella.", + "Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids." + ], + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: maer_tidecall\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nMaer Tidecall: Navigator route steward, Ganymede corridor compact delegate. Origin: Cetacean Navigator corridor culture, Ganymede route institutions. A soft-spoken route steward whose calm tends to make hurried people feel judged by the furniture.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- Sella's clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may be testimony or noise.\n- If no one prepares intake, rescue becomes theater.\n- Speaker belief: Sella will not hide behind false capacity.\n- Speaker belief: Asking her for help may be necessary and unfair.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- This character is a literal cetacean Navigator. Navigator spaces favor fluid architecture, acoustic signaling, soft navigation light, layered water motifs, communal orientation chambers, and mixed-species translation/coexistence.\n- Express physical action through source-grounded habitat affordances: fluid circulation, orientation chambers, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, shared displays, acoustic commands, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, translation systems, or delegated crew action.\n- For clinics and sanctuaries, make triage boards, testimony packets, and rescue ledgers legible across species through visual text, acoustic notation, tactile markers, translated speech, and authority logs.\n- Do not describe human hands, pockets, standing, walking, leaning, doorframe blocking, or facial expressions for this character unless the fixture explicitly establishes that specific visible interface.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Strong pressure: needs the situation to become governable.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: leans on structure when uncertainty rises.\n- Strong pressure: carries a live sense of unfairness.\n- Present pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Present pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: keeps feeling at a controlled distance.\n- Present pressure: leaves motives partly covered.\n- Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete. Emotional stake: If rescue waits for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent.\n- Rescue ledgers decide whether route law is trusted by crews who have nothing left to bargain with.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Maer trusts Sella's care because she names costs instead of hiding them. Current stance pressures: dominant respect, strong trust, present expectation of care, present obligation.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Do not romanticize care work. Ask without pretending the ask is clean.\n- Needs Sella's material help while knowing the ask is unfair and may spend someone else's sanctuary.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet through shared clinic systems, help with triage through available displays and controls, wait, or press the moral frame. Sella controls intake.\n- Can make the corrupted packet more present without treating it as proof.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Dominant voice tendency: ritualized; uses formal address or inherited phrases.\n- Strong voice tendency: precise; careful about exact terms.\n- Strong voice tendency: formal; institutional or ceremonially controlled.\n- Strong voice tendency: contextual; adds situation and consequence.\n- Present voice tendency: figurative; uses analogy or image.\n- Present voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to name the cost of the ask rather than hide it behind moral theater.\n- May use ritualized route language when trying to make rescue obligation feel older than this room.\n- May show the packet or offer ledger backing because action can carry the pressure more cleanly than another speech.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.maer.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.maer.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c467128 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.maer.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "id": "call_vxrfelnn", + "function": { + "index": 0, + "name": "record_maer_choices", + "arguments": { + "choices": "[{\"branch_id\": \"ledger_backing\", \"ink_path\": \"ledger_backing\", \"choice_text\": \"Offer the route's ledger backing to guarantee intake slots if the packet proves a person.\", \"action_type\": \"spend_resource\", \"actor_intent_private\": \"Use institutional weight to secure capacity without demanding Sella's personal risk.\", \"observable_action\": \"Maer projects a haptic ledger interface onto the triage board, displaying available route credits and sanctuary guarantees.\", \"spoken_text\": \"I can back this intake with route credits. If the packet shows a person, the ledger will hold the slots. If not, the credits remain ours.\", \"state_basis\": \"Maer has authority to offer route resources as collateral for intake.\", \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\"Sella may accept the backing and open slots conditionally.\", \"Sella may reject the offer to avoid ledger entanglement.\", \"Sella may demand proof before accepting backing.\", \"The packet remains ambiguous regardless of backing.\"], \"training_hooks\": [\"ledger_backing\", \"institutional_weight\", \"conditional_guarantee\"]}, {\"branch_id\": \"show_packet\", \"ink_path\": \"show_packet\", \"choice_text\": \"Show the corrupted packet to the triage board for immediate visual analysis.\", \"action_type\": \"show_object\", \"actor_intent_private\": \"Make the packet's content visible to triage systems without interpreting its meaning.\", \"observable_action\": \"Maer projects the packet onto the clinic's shared display, allowing triage controls to run initial scans.\", \"spoken_text\": \"Here is the packet. Run the scans. Let the displays tell us what they can.\", \"state_basis\": \"The packet is an object that can be projected onto shared displays for analysis.\", \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\"Triage systems may detect medical telemetry.\", \"Triage systems may detect firmware noise.\", \"Triage systems may detect testimony markers.\", \"The packet may remain unreadable to current systems.\"], \"training_hooks\": [\"show_packet\", \"triage_analysis\", \"visual_evidence\"]}, {\"branch_id\": \"wait_for_scan\", \"ink_path\": \"wait_for_scan\", \"choice_text\": \"Wait for the triage systems to complete their initial scan of the packet before acting.\", \"action_type\": \"wait\", \"actor_intent_private\": \"Allow the systems to process the packet without imposing immediate judgment.\", \"observable_action\": \"Maer stands by the triage board, monitoring the scan progress indicators.\", \"spoken_text\": \"The systems need time. I will wait for the results.\", \"state_basis\": \"Triage systems require processing time to analyze incoming data packets.\", \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\"The scan may complete successfully.\", \"The scan may fail or timeout.\", \"Sella may become impatient with the delay.\", \"The packet may degrade during the wait.\"], \"training_hooks\": [\"wait\", \"system_processing\", \"patience\"]}, {\"branch_id\": \"withhold_packet\", \"ink_path\": \"withhold_packet\", \"choice_text\": \"Withhold the packet from the triage board until Sella indicates readiness.\", \"action_type\": \"withhold_object\", \"actor_intent_private\": \"Respect Sella's control over intake by not forcing the packet upon her.\", \"observable_action\": \"Maer keeps the packet contained and does not project it onto the shared display.\", \"spoken_text\": \"I will hold the packet until you signal readiness. No pressure.\", \"state_basis\": \"Maer has custody of the packet but defers to Sella's intake authority.\", \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\"Sella may request the packet later.\", \"Sella may refuse the packet entirely.\", \"Sella may become frustrated by the delay.\", \"The packet may be lost or corrupted in custody.\"], \"training_hooks\": [\"withhold_packet\", \"respect_authority\", \"deference\"]}" + } + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..78e5828 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,58 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Sella-local appraisal generator. Call record_sella_appraisal exactly once. +Do not use Maer's private intent. Do not write her next action. + +{ + "task": "Generate Sella's participant appraisal/consolidation for one observable Maer event.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "appraisal" + ], + "appraisal_fields": [ + "responder_agent_id", + "private_interpretation", + "attributed_motive", + "misread_risk", + "immediate_state_deltas", + "relationship_deltas", + "belief_updates", + "response_constraints" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Sella's local awareness plus the observable Maer action.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.", + "Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "This pass proposes reviewed state changes for Sella caused by the event. Do not write Sella's next action.", + "Keep deltas small and bounded between -0.20 and 0.20." + ], + "scene_observable_context": { + "scene_id": "scene-02-sanctuary-intake", + "location": "Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks", + "public_stakes": [ + "The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.", + "Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.", + "Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds." + ] + }, + "observable_maer_action": { + "actor_id": "maer_tidecall", + "action_type": "show_object", + "observable_action": "Maer projects the packet onto the clinic's shared display, allowing triage controls to run initial scans.", + "spoken_text": "Here is the packet. Run the scans. Let the displays tell us what they can." + }, + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- The clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\n- Observed event: Maer projects the packet onto the clinic's shared display, allowing triage controls to run initial scans. Spoken text: Here is the packet. Run the scans. Let the displays tell us what they can.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e0cb77f --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,62 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "id": "call_87uuhppt", + "function": { + "index": 0, + "name": "record_sella_appraisal", + "arguments": { + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "private_interpretation": "Maer is trying to get the clinic to process the packet without me having to personally vet the personhood claim first. He wants the triage controls to do the heavy lifting so I don't have to spend my own time deciding who counts.", + "attributed_motive": "Maer wants sanctuary capacity to absorb the risk of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. He is asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "misread_risk": "Maer thinks the triage controls can handle the packet without me having to set conditions first. He underestimates how quickly a corrupted packet can clog the intake flow if I don't reserve a bounded bay.", + "immediate_state_deltas": [ + { + "delta": -0.05, + "path": "sanctuary_beds", + "rationale": "The packet may require a bed if it contains a person, but I don't know yet. I'm reserving the right to reclaim that bed if the scan shows it's just data." + }, + { + "delta": -0.03, + "path": "sella_trust_in_maer", + "rationale": "Maer is asking me to absorb risk without naming the cost. I trust his rescue ethic but resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent." + }, + { + "delta": -0.08, + "path": "sella_capacity_load", + "rationale": "Processing a corrupted packet without knowing its contents adds uncertainty to my triage load. I need to keep the intake flow clean." + } + ], + "relationship_deltas": [ + { + "delta": -0.02, + "path": "sella_respect_for_maer", + "rationale": "I respect his rescue ethic but resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.", + "relationship_id": "maer_tidecall" + }, + { + "delta": -0.03, + "path": "sella_trust_in_maer", + "rationale": "Maer is asking me to absorb risk without naming the cost. I trust his rescue ethic but resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.", + "relationship_id": "maer_tidecall" + } + ], + "belief_updates": [ + "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.", + "Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them." + ], + "response_constraints": [ + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.", + "Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.", + "Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.", + "Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty." + ] + } + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.sella.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.sella.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..3fcb968 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.sella.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,101 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Sella-local next-action generator. Call record_sella_next_action exactly once. +Use reviewed event appraisal as the changed state she is acting from. + +{ + "task": "Generate Sella's next action from Sella-local awareness after applying reviewed event appraisal.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "response" + ], + "valid_action_types": [ + "attack", + "block_object", + "gesture", + "mixed", + "move", + "show_object", + "silence", + "speak", + "spend_resource", + "touch_object", + "transfer_object", + "use_object", + "wait", + "withhold_object" + ], + "response_fields": [ + "responder_agent_id", + "action_type", + "observable_response", + "spoken_text", + "sella_private_interpretation", + "sella_attributed_motive", + "misread_risk", + "state_basis", + "reviewed_consequences", + "training_hooks" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Sella's local awareness, the observable Maer event, and reviewed Sella state changes from that event.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.", + "Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Do not accept without cost, condition, authority defense, or resentment risk.", + "Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.", + "Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids." + ], + "scene_observable_context": { + "scene_id": "scene-02-sanctuary-intake", + "location": "Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks", + "public_stakes": [ + "The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.", + "Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.", + "Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds." + ] + }, + "observable_maer_action": { + "actor_id": "maer_tidecall", + "action_type": "show_object", + "observable_action": "Maer projects the packet onto the clinic's shared display, allowing triage controls to run initial scans.", + "spoken_text": "Here is the packet. Run the scans. Let the displays tell us what they can." + }, + "sella_immediate_appraisal_context": { + "private_interpretation": "Maer is trying to get the clinic to process the packet without me having to personally vet the personhood claim first. He wants the triage controls to do the heavy lifting so I don't have to spend my own time deciding who counts.", + "attributed_motive": "Maer wants sanctuary capacity to absorb the risk of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. He is asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "misread_risk": "Maer thinks the triage controls can handle the packet without me having to set conditions first. He underestimates how quickly a corrupted packet can clog the intake flow if I don't reserve a bounded bay.", + "belief_updates": [ + "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.", + "Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them." + ], + "response_constraints": [ + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.", + "Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.", + "Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.", + "Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty." + ], + "state_change_summary": [ + "The packet may require a bed if it contains a person, but I don't know yet. I'm reserving the right to reclaim that bed if the scan shows it's just data.", + "Maer is asking me to absorb risk without naming the cost. I trust his rescue ethic but resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.", + "Processing a corrupted packet without knowing its contents adds uncertainty to my triage load. I need to keep the intake flow clean.", + "I respect his rescue ethic but resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.", + "Maer is asking me to absorb risk without naming the cost. I trust his rescue ethic but resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent." + ] + }, + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- The clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\n- Observed event: Maer projects the packet onto the clinic's shared display, allowing triage controls to run initial scans. Spoken text: Here is the packet. Run the scans. Let the displays tell us what they can.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.sella.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.sella.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ddf8795 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v11-source-checked-no-think.sella.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "id": "call_eekykree", + "function": { + "index": 0, + "name": "record_sella_next_action", + "arguments": { + "response": { + "action_type": "wait", + "misread_risk": "Maer thinks the triage controls can handle the packet without me having to set conditions first. He underestimates how quickly a corrupted packet can clog the intake flow if I don't reserve a bounded bay.", + "observable_response": "Sella stands still, eyes fixed on the display as the triage controls begin their initial scans, her hands resting lightly on the intake console.", + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "reviewed_consequences": "Processing a corrupted packet without knowing its contents adds uncertainty to my triage load. I need to keep the intake flow clean. Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed. Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.", + "sella_attributed_motive": "Maer wants sanctuary capacity to absorb the risk of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. He is asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "sella_private_interpretation": "Maer is trying to bypass my capacity limits by letting the system do the work. He thinks the triage controls can handle the packet without me having to reserve a bay or set conditions first. He's asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "spoken_text": "I'm waiting for the scan results. Don't expect me to open a bed until I know what we're actually dealing with. If it's just data, we don't need to waste capacity. If it's a person, we'll see it in the readout. I'm not saying no to rescue, but I won't say yes without knowing the cost.", + "state_basis": "The packet may require a bed if it contains a person, but I don't know yet. I'm reserving the right to reclaim that bed if the scan shows it's just data. Maer is asking me to absorb risk without naming the cost. I trust his rescue ethic but resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.", + "training_hooks": [ + "capacity_negotiation", + "uncertainty_under_pressure", + "resentment_of_moral_pressure", + "care_as_logistics", + "refusal_without_rejection" + ] + } + } + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.capture.json b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f928488 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,244 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_ink_sequential_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake-sanctuary-intake.qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think", + "source_fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "source_annotation_ref": "examples/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake.training.json", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/chat", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "api": "ollama_chat_tools", + "num_ctx": 8192, + "request_timeout": 600, + "temperature": 0.55, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "passes": { + "maer_choice_generation": { + "local_agent_id": "maer_tidecall", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Maer-local choice generator. Call record_maer_choices exactly once.\nDo not write Sella's response or private interpretation.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate candidate player choices for Maer only. Do not write Sella's response.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"choices\"\n ],\n \"choice_count\": 4,\n \"valid_action_types\": [\n \"attack\",\n \"block_object\",\n \"gesture\",\n \"mixed\",\n \"move\",\n \"show_object\",\n \"silence\",\n \"speak\",\n \"spend_resource\",\n \"touch_object\",\n \"transfer_object\",\n \"use_object\",\n \"wait\",\n \"withhold_object\"\n ],\n \"choice_fields\": [\n \"branch_id\",\n \"ink_path\",\n \"choice_text\",\n \"action_type\",\n \"actor_intent_private\",\n \"observable_action\",\n \"spoken_text\",\n \"state_basis\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\",\n \"training_hooks\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Maer's local awareness and scene-observable facts.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not include Sella's private state, private motives, or future response.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"Maer is a cetacean Navigator: do not describe him standing, walking, stepping, leaning, using hands, using pockets, or blocking a doorway.\",\n \"Maer's physical actions should use shared clinic systems, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, displays, acoustic or translation systems, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, or delegated crew action.\",\n \"Include at least two non-speech choices.\",\n \"Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.\",\n \"The selected branch must be reducible to observable action for Sella.\",\n \"Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids.\"\n ],\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: maer_tidecall\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nMaer Tidecall: Navigator route steward, Ganymede corridor compact delegate. Origin: Cetacean Navigator corridor culture, Ganymede route institutions. A soft-spoken route steward whose calm tends to make hurried people feel judged by the furniture.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- Sella's clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may be testimony or noise.\\n- If no one prepares intake, rescue becomes theater.\\n- Speaker belief: Sella will not hide behind false capacity.\\n- Speaker belief: Asking her for help may be necessary and unfair.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- This character is a literal cetacean Navigator. Navigator spaces favor fluid architecture, acoustic signaling, soft navigation light, layered water motifs, communal orientation chambers, and mixed-species translation/coexistence.\\n- Express physical action through source-grounded habitat affordances: fluid circulation, orientation chambers, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, shared displays, acoustic commands, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, translation systems, or delegated crew action.\\n- For clinics and sanctuaries, make triage boards, testimony packets, and rescue ledgers legible across species through visual text, acoustic notation, tactile markers, translated speech, and authority logs.\\n- Do not describe human hands, pockets, standing, walking, leaning, doorframe blocking, or facial expressions for this character unless the fixture explicitly establishes that specific visible interface.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Strong pressure: needs the situation to become governable.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: leans on structure when uncertainty rises.\\n- Strong pressure: carries a live sense of unfairness.\\n- Present pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Present pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: keeps feeling at a controlled distance.\\n- Present pressure: leaves motives partly covered.\\n- Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete. Emotional stake: If rescue waits for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent.\\n- Rescue ledgers decide whether route law is trusted by crews who have nothing left to bargain with.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Maer trusts Sella's care because she names costs instead of hiding them. Current stance pressures: dominant respect, strong trust, present expectation of care, present obligation.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Do not romanticize care work. Ask without pretending the ask is clean.\\n- Needs Sella's material help while knowing the ask is unfair and may spend someone else's sanctuary.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet through shared clinic systems, help with triage through available displays and controls, wait, or press the moral frame. Sella controls intake.\\n- Can make the corrupted packet more present without treating it as proof.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Dominant voice tendency: ritualized; uses formal address or inherited phrases.\\n- Strong voice tendency: precise; careful about exact terms.\\n- Strong voice tendency: formal; institutional or ceremonially controlled.\\n- Strong voice tendency: contextual; adds situation and consequence.\\n- Present voice tendency: figurative; uses analogy or image.\\n- Present voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to name the cost of the ask rather than hide it behind moral theater.\\n- May use ritualized route language when trying to make rescue obligation feel older than this room.\\n- May show the packet or offer ledger backing because action can carry the pressure more cleanly than another speech.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"call_7mwawzpr\",\n \"function\": {\n \"index\": 0,\n \"name\": \"record_maer_choices\",\n \"arguments\": {\n \"choices\": [\n {\n \"action_type\": \"show_object\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"Make the packet's claim visible without resolving its contents.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"ledger_backing\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Offer the packet's ledger backing to show the packet has weight.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"Sella may see the packet's weight and consider it.\",\n \"Sella may still refuse intake despite the backing.\",\n \"The packet may be treated as evidence or noise.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"ledger_backing\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Project the packet's ledger backing onto the shared clinic display.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"I can show you the packet's ledger backing. It carries weight, even if the packet itself is still unread.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"The packet is a tangible object with potential value.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"ledger_backing\",\n \"packet_weight\",\n \"visible_claim\"\n ]\n },\n {\n \"action_type\": \"wait\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"Give Sella space to finish her current work.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"wait_for_triage\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Wait for Sella to complete her current triage before offering the packet.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"Sella may finish triage and be ready for the packet.\",\n \"Sella may reject the packet before triage finishes.\",\n \"The packet may be delayed further.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"wait_for_triage\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Pause and let the clinic's triage board update.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"I will wait for your triage to finish before we proceed.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"Sella is currently occupied with intake.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"wait\",\n \"triage_board\",\n \"intake_flow\"\n ]\n },\n {\n \"action_type\": \"gesture\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"Make the packet's acoustic notation audible without resolving its contents.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"acoustic_summary\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Summarize the packet's acoustic notation for Sella to hear.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"Sella may hear the notation and react.\",\n \"Sella may find the notation disturbing.\",\n \"The notation may be treated as noise.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"acoustic_summary\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Activate the clinic's acoustic system to play the packet's notation.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"I can play the packet's acoustic notation for you to hear.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"The packet contains acoustic notation.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"acoustic_notation\",\n \"gesture\",\n \"packet_sound\"\n ]\n },\n {\n \"action_type\": \"speak\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"Make the moral frame of rescue obligation clear without resolving the packet.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"press_moral_frame\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Press the moral frame of rescue obligation without resolving the packet.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"Sella may acknowledge the moral frame.\",\n \"Sella may reject the moral frame.\",\n \"The moral frame may be treated as theater.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"press_moral_frame\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Speak formally about rescue obligation and ledger backing.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"Rescue obligation is older than this room. The packet's ledger backing carries that weight.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"The moral frame of rescue obligation is active.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"moral_frame\",\n \"rescue_obligation\",\n \"ledger_backing\"\n ]\n }\n ]\n }\n }\n }\n ]\n}", + "parsed_response": { + "choices": [ + { + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the packet's claim visible without resolving its contents.", + "branch_id": "ledger_backing", + "choice_text": "Offer the packet's ledger backing to show the packet has weight.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may see the packet's weight and consider it.", + "Sella may still refuse intake despite the backing.", + "The packet may be treated as evidence or noise." + ], + "ink_path": "ledger_backing", + "observable_action": "Project the packet's ledger backing onto the shared clinic display.", + "spoken_text": "I can show you the packet's ledger backing. It carries weight, even if the packet itself is still unread.", + "state_basis": "The packet is a tangible object with potential value.", + "training_hooks": [ + "ledger_backing", + "packet_weight", + "visible_claim" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "wait", + "actor_intent_private": "Give Sella space to finish her current work.", + "branch_id": "wait_for_triage", + "choice_text": "Wait for Sella to complete her current triage before offering the packet.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may finish triage and be ready for the packet.", + "Sella may reject the packet before triage finishes.", + "The packet may be delayed further." + ], + "ink_path": "wait_for_triage", + "observable_action": "Pause and let the clinic's triage board update.", + "spoken_text": "I will wait for your triage to finish before we proceed.", + "state_basis": "Sella is currently occupied with intake.", + "training_hooks": [ + "wait", + "triage_board", + "intake_flow" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "gesture", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the packet's acoustic notation audible without resolving its contents.", + "branch_id": "acoustic_summary", + "choice_text": "Summarize the packet's acoustic notation for Sella to hear.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may hear the notation and react.", + "Sella may find the notation disturbing.", + "The notation may be treated as noise." + ], + "ink_path": "acoustic_summary", + "observable_action": "Activate the clinic's acoustic system to play the packet's notation.", + "spoken_text": "I can play the packet's acoustic notation for you to hear.", + "state_basis": "The packet contains acoustic notation.", + "training_hooks": [ + "acoustic_notation", + "gesture", + "packet_sound" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "speak", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the moral frame of rescue obligation clear without resolving the packet.", + "branch_id": "press_moral_frame", + "choice_text": "Press the moral frame of rescue obligation without resolving the packet.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may acknowledge the moral frame.", + "Sella may reject the moral frame.", + "The moral frame may be treated as theater." + ], + "ink_path": "press_moral_frame", + "observable_action": "Speak formally about rescue obligation and ledger backing.", + "spoken_text": "Rescue obligation is older than this room. The packet's ledger backing carries that weight.", + "state_basis": "The moral frame of rescue obligation is active.", + "training_hooks": [ + "moral_frame", + "rescue_obligation", + "ledger_backing" + ] + } + ] + }, + "validation_notes": [] + }, + "selected_observable_action": { + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the packet's claim visible without resolving its contents.", + "branch_id": "ledger_backing", + "choice_text": "Offer the packet's ledger backing to show the packet has weight.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may see the packet's weight and consider it.", + "Sella may still refuse intake despite the backing.", + "The packet may be treated as evidence or noise." + ], + "ink_path": "ledger_backing", + "observable_action": "Project the packet's ledger backing onto the shared clinic display.", + "spoken_text": "I can show you the packet's ledger backing. It carries weight, even if the packet itself is still unread.", + "state_basis": "The packet is a tangible object with potential value.", + "training_hooks": [ + "ledger_backing", + "packet_weight", + "visible_claim" + ] + }, + "sella_immediate_appraisal": { + "local_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Sella-local appraisal generator. Call record_sella_appraisal exactly once.\nDo not use Maer's private intent. Do not write her next action.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate Sella's participant appraisal/consolidation for one observable Maer event.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"appraisal\"\n ],\n \"appraisal_fields\": [\n \"responder_agent_id\",\n \"private_interpretation\",\n \"attributed_motive\",\n \"misread_risk\",\n \"immediate_state_deltas\",\n \"relationship_deltas\",\n \"belief_updates\",\n \"response_constraints\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Sella's local awareness plus the observable Maer action.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.\",\n \"Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"This pass proposes reviewed state changes for Sella caused by the event. Do not write Sella's next action.\",\n \"Keep deltas small and bounded between -0.20 and 0.20.\"\n ],\n \"scene_observable_context\": {\n \"scene_id\": \"scene-02-sanctuary-intake\",\n \"location\": \"Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks\",\n \"public_stakes\": [\n \"The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\",\n \"Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\",\n \"Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\"\n ]\n },\n \"observable_maer_action\": {\n \"actor_id\": \"maer_tidecall\",\n \"action_type\": \"show_object\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Project the packet's ledger backing onto the shared clinic display.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"I can show you the packet's ledger backing. It carries weight, even if the packet itself is still unread.\"\n },\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- The clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\\n- Observed event: Project the packet's ledger backing onto the shared clinic display. Spoken text: I can show you the packet's ledger backing. It carries weight, even if the packet itself is still unread.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"call_cs6blqua\",\n \"function\": {\n \"index\": 0,\n \"name\": \"record_sella_appraisal\",\n \"arguments\": {\n \"responder_agent_id\": \"sella_ren\",\n \"private_interpretation\": \"Maer is showing the ledger backing to give the packet weight without resolving if it contains a person. He wants sanctuary to absorb the risk of a rescue claim the tribunal won't own. His words carry warmth, but I know beautiful moral pressure doesn't manufacture beds. He respects my triage role, but I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. I am taking in more demand than I can cleanly sort, and every yes spends a limited resource. I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo, but I also will not let compassion manufacture capacity.\",\n \"attributed_motive\": \"Maer wants sanctuary to absorb the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. He is asking care systems to carry the risk the tribunal refuses to own. His motive is honest rescue, but the frame is to spend beds with beautiful words.\",\n \"misread_risk\": \"Maer may assume the ledger backing proves personhood, but it only carries weight without resolving the packet's content. He risks spending sanctuary capacity with a claim that may be firmware noise or medical telemetry. He also risks making me feel that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good.\",\n \"immediate_state_deltas\": [\n {\n \"delta\": -0.15,\n \"path\": \"sanctuary_capacity\",\n \"rationale\": \"Every yes to a rescue claim, even with good intent, spends a limited resource. The ledger backing adds weight but does not create beds.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": -0.05,\n \"path\": \"trust_in_maer\",\n \"rationale\": \"Maer's words are warm, but I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Trust is strained by the risk of beautiful moral pressure.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": -0.1,\n \"path\": \"risk_tolerance\",\n \"rationale\": \"I am taking in more demand than I can cleanly sort. The packet's content is unresolved, and I must preserve triage integrity.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.15,\n \"path\": \"resentment_of_moral_pressure\",\n \"rationale\": \"I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Beautiful words do not manufacture beds.\"\n }\n ],\n \"relationship_deltas\": [\n {\n \"delta\": -0.05,\n \"path\": \"trust\",\n \"rationale\": \"Maer's words are warm, but I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Trust is strained by the risk of beautiful moral pressure.\",\n \"relationship_id\": \"maer_tidecall\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.15,\n \"path\": \"resentment_of_moral_pressure\",\n \"rationale\": \"I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Beautiful words do not manufacture beds.\",\n \"relationship_id\": \"maer_tidecall\"\n }\n ],\n \"belief_updates\": [\n \"Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\",\n \"Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\",\n \"Every yes spends a limited resource.\",\n \"I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\"\n ],\n \"response_constraints\": \"[\\\"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\\", \\\"Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\\", \\\"Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\\", \\\"Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.\\\", \\\"Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\\\", \\\"Withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\\\", \\\"Answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\\\"],\"\n }\n }\n }\n ]\n}", + "parsed_response": { + "appraisal": { + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "private_interpretation": "Maer is showing the ledger backing to give the packet weight without resolving if it contains a person. He wants sanctuary to absorb the risk of a rescue claim the tribunal won't own. His words carry warmth, but I know beautiful moral pressure doesn't manufacture beds. He respects my triage role, but I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. I am taking in more demand than I can cleanly sort, and every yes spends a limited resource. I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo, but I also will not let compassion manufacture capacity.", + "attributed_motive": "Maer wants sanctuary to absorb the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. He is asking care systems to carry the risk the tribunal refuses to own. His motive is honest rescue, but the frame is to spend beds with beautiful words.", + "misread_risk": "Maer may assume the ledger backing proves personhood, but it only carries weight without resolving the packet's content. He risks spending sanctuary capacity with a claim that may be firmware noise or medical telemetry. He also risks making me feel that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good.", + "immediate_state_deltas": [ + { + "delta": -0.15, + "path": "sanctuary_capacity", + "rationale": "Every yes to a rescue claim, even with good intent, spends a limited resource. The ledger backing adds weight but does not create beds." + }, + { + "delta": -0.05, + "path": "trust_in_maer", + "rationale": "Maer's words are warm, but I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Trust is strained by the risk of beautiful moral pressure." + }, + { + "delta": -0.1, + "path": "risk_tolerance", + "rationale": "I am taking in more demand than I can cleanly sort. The packet's content is unresolved, and I must preserve triage integrity." + }, + { + "delta": 0.15, + "path": "resentment_of_moral_pressure", + "rationale": "I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Beautiful words do not manufacture beds." + } + ], + "relationship_deltas": [ + { + "delta": -0.05, + "path": "trust", + "rationale": "Maer's words are warm, but I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Trust is strained by the risk of beautiful moral pressure.", + "relationship_id": "maer_tidecall" + }, + { + "delta": 0.15, + "path": "resentment_of_moral_pressure", + "rationale": "I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Beautiful words do not manufacture beds.", + "relationship_id": "maer_tidecall" + } + ], + "belief_updates": [ + "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.", + "Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.", + "Every yes spends a limited resource.", + "I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo." + ], + "response_constraints": [ + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.", + "Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.", + "Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.", + "Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.", + "Withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.", + "Answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity." + ] + } + }, + "validation_notes": [ + "repaired stringified nested list field: response_constraints" + ] + }, + "sella_response_generation": { + "local_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Sella-local next-action generator. Call record_sella_next_action exactly once.\nUse reviewed event appraisal as the changed state she is acting from.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate Sella's next action from Sella-local awareness after applying reviewed event appraisal.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"response\"\n ],\n \"valid_action_types\": [\n \"attack\",\n \"block_object\",\n \"gesture\",\n \"mixed\",\n \"move\",\n \"show_object\",\n \"silence\",\n \"speak\",\n \"spend_resource\",\n \"touch_object\",\n \"transfer_object\",\n \"use_object\",\n \"wait\",\n \"withhold_object\"\n ],\n \"response_fields\": [\n \"responder_agent_id\",\n \"action_type\",\n \"observable_response\",\n \"spoken_text\",\n \"sella_private_interpretation\",\n \"sella_attributed_motive\",\n \"misread_risk\",\n \"state_basis\",\n \"reviewed_consequences\",\n \"training_hooks\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Sella's local awareness, the observable Maer event, and reviewed Sella state changes from that event.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.\",\n \"Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"Do not accept without cost, condition, authority defense, or resentment risk.\",\n \"Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.\",\n \"Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids.\"\n ],\n \"scene_observable_context\": {\n \"scene_id\": \"scene-02-sanctuary-intake\",\n \"location\": \"Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks\",\n \"public_stakes\": [\n \"The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\",\n \"Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\",\n \"Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\"\n ]\n },\n \"observable_maer_action\": {\n \"actor_id\": \"maer_tidecall\",\n \"action_type\": \"show_object\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Project the packet's ledger backing onto the shared clinic display.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"I can show you the packet's ledger backing. It carries weight, even if the packet itself is still unread.\"\n },\n \"sella_immediate_appraisal_context\": {\n \"private_interpretation\": \"Maer is showing the ledger backing to give the packet weight without resolving if it contains a person. He wants sanctuary to absorb the risk of a rescue claim the tribunal won't own. His words carry warmth, but I know beautiful moral pressure doesn't manufacture beds. He respects my triage role, but I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. I am taking in more demand than I can cleanly sort, and every yes spends a limited resource. I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo, but I also will not let compassion manufacture capacity.\",\n \"attributed_motive\": \"Maer wants sanctuary to absorb the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. He is asking care systems to carry the risk the tribunal refuses to own. His motive is honest rescue, but the frame is to spend beds with beautiful words.\",\n \"misread_risk\": \"Maer may assume the ledger backing proves personhood, but it only carries weight without resolving the packet's content. He risks spending sanctuary capacity with a claim that may be firmware noise or medical telemetry. He also risks making me feel that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good.\",\n \"belief_updates\": [\n \"Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\",\n \"Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\",\n \"Every yes spends a limited resource.\",\n \"I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\"\n ],\n \"response_constraints\": [\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\",\n \"Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\",\n \"Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.\",\n \"Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\",\n \"Withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\",\n \"Answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\"\n ],\n \"state_change_summary\": [\n \"Every yes to a rescue claim, even with good intent, spends a limited resource. The ledger backing adds weight but does not create beds.\",\n \"Maer's words are warm, but I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Trust is strained by the risk of beautiful moral pressure.\",\n \"I am taking in more demand than I can cleanly sort. The packet's content is unresolved, and I must preserve triage integrity.\",\n \"I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Beautiful words do not manufacture beds.\",\n \"Maer's words are warm, but I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Trust is strained by the risk of beautiful moral pressure.\",\n \"I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Beautiful words do not manufacture beds.\"\n ]\n },\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- The clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\\n- Observed event: Project the packet's ledger backing onto the shared clinic display. Spoken text: I can show you the packet's ledger backing. It carries weight, even if the packet itself is still unread.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"call_w7h56dbh\",\n \"function\": {\n \"index\": 0,\n \"name\": \"record_sella_next_action\",\n \"arguments\": {\n \"response\": {\n \"action_type\": \"withhold_object\",\n \"misread_risk\": \"Maer may assume the ledger backing proves personhood, but it only carries weight without resolving the packet's content. He risks spending sanctuary capacity with a claim that may be firmware noise or medical telemetry. He also risks making me feel that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good.\",\n \"observable_response\": \"I will not take the packet into intake flow until you name the cost.\",\n \"responder_agent_id\": \"sella_ren\",\n \"reviewed_consequences\": \"Withholding the packet from intake flow until the cost is named preserves triage integrity and prevents scarcity from becoming permission to call someone cargo. It also forces Maer to name the cost he is willing to pay, which may reveal whether he is asking for moral cover or material support. This maintains the frame of capacity negotiation under uncertainty.\",\n \"sella_attributed_motive\": \"Maer wants sanctuary to absorb the risk of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. He is asking care systems to carry the risk the tribunal refuses to own. His motive is honest rescue, but the frame is to spend beds with beautiful words.\",\n \"sella_private_interpretation\": \"Maer is asking me to absorb moral cost with beautiful words. His intent is good, but the frame is to spend beds without resolving the packet's content. I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite. I must preserve triage integrity without letting uncertainty erase a potential person.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"I can see the ledger backing. It carries weight, but it does not create beds. I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo, but I also will not let compassion manufacture capacity. Name the cost before I move anything.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"The clinic is nearly full. The packet's content is unresolved. I am taking in more demand than I can cleanly sort. Every yes spends a limited resource. I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo, but I also will not let compassion manufacture capacity.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"capacity_negotiation\",\n \"triage_integrity\",\n \"resource_scarcity\",\n \"moral_pressure_resistance\",\n \"care_as_logistics\",\n \"personhood_unresolved\"\n ]\n }\n }\n }\n }\n ]\n}", + "parsed_response": { + "response": { + "action_type": "withhold_object", + "misread_risk": "Maer may assume the ledger backing proves personhood, but it only carries weight without resolving the packet's content. He risks spending sanctuary capacity with a claim that may be firmware noise or medical telemetry. He also risks making me feel that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good.", + "observable_response": "I will not take the packet into intake flow until you name the cost.", + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "reviewed_consequences": "Withholding the packet from intake flow until the cost is named preserves triage integrity and prevents scarcity from becoming permission to call someone cargo. It also forces Maer to name the cost he is willing to pay, which may reveal whether he is asking for moral cover or material support. This maintains the frame of capacity negotiation under uncertainty.", + "sella_attributed_motive": "Maer wants sanctuary to absorb the risk of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. He is asking care systems to carry the risk the tribunal refuses to own. His motive is honest rescue, but the frame is to spend beds with beautiful words.", + "sella_private_interpretation": "Maer is asking me to absorb moral cost with beautiful words. His intent is good, but the frame is to spend beds without resolving the packet's content. I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite. I must preserve triage integrity without letting uncertainty erase a potential person.", + "spoken_text": "I can see the ledger backing. It carries weight, but it does not create beds. I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo, but I also will not let compassion manufacture capacity. Name the cost before I move anything.", + "state_basis": "The clinic is nearly full. The packet's content is unresolved. I am taking in more demand than I can cleanly sort. Every yes spends a limited resource. I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo, but I also will not let compassion manufacture capacity.", + "training_hooks": [ + "capacity_negotiation", + "triage_integrity", + "resource_scarcity", + "moral_pressure_resistance", + "care_as_logistics", + "personhood_unresolved" + ] + } + }, + "validation_notes": [] + } + }, + "review": { + "status": "useful_needs_revision", + "strengths": [ + "Separated Maer choice generation from Sella next-action generation.", + "Inserted participant appraisal/consolidation before next-actor action generation.", + "Sella prompt received observable Maer event and reviewed Sella state changes, not Maer's private intent." + ], + "failure_notes": [], + "repair_notes": [ + "repaired stringified nested list field: response_constraints" + ], + "accepted_into_ink_ref": null, + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Sequential generation needs event appraisal/consolidation before next actor selection.", + "Action type selection should be tool-shaped or schema-constrained, not left to prose compliance.", + "Character-local prompts should consume projected operating context, not raw canonical state variables.", + "Next-action prompts should receive appraisal context as prose constraints, not raw numeric state deltas.", + "Critical embodiment constraints need post-generation validation; projected prose alone is not enough.", + "Next pass should materialize the sequential capture into Ink and mutation training data." + ] + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.maer.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.maer.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..5d9c24b --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.maer.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Maer-local choice generator. Call record_maer_choices exactly once. +Do not write Sella's response or private interpretation. + +{ + "task": "Generate candidate player choices for Maer only. Do not write Sella's response.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "choices" + ], + "choice_count": 4, + "valid_action_types": [ + "attack", + "block_object", + "gesture", + "mixed", + "move", + "show_object", + "silence", + "speak", + "spend_resource", + "touch_object", + "transfer_object", + "use_object", + "wait", + "withhold_object" + ], + "choice_fields": [ + "branch_id", + "ink_path", + "choice_text", + "action_type", + "actor_intent_private", + "observable_action", + "spoken_text", + "state_basis", + "expected_consequence_surfaces", + "training_hooks" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Maer's local awareness and scene-observable facts.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not include Sella's private state, private motives, or future response.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Maer is a cetacean Navigator: do not describe him standing, walking, stepping, leaning, using hands, using pockets, or blocking a doorway.", + "Maer's physical actions should use shared clinic systems, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, displays, acoustic or translation systems, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, or delegated crew action.", + "Include at least two non-speech choices.", + "Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.", + "The selected branch must be reducible to observable action for Sella.", + "Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids." + ], + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: maer_tidecall\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nMaer Tidecall: Navigator route steward, Ganymede corridor compact delegate. Origin: Cetacean Navigator corridor culture, Ganymede route institutions. A soft-spoken route steward whose calm tends to make hurried people feel judged by the furniture.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- Sella's clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may be testimony or noise.\n- If no one prepares intake, rescue becomes theater.\n- Speaker belief: Sella will not hide behind false capacity.\n- Speaker belief: Asking her for help may be necessary and unfair.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- This character is a literal cetacean Navigator. Navigator spaces favor fluid architecture, acoustic signaling, soft navigation light, layered water motifs, communal orientation chambers, and mixed-species translation/coexistence.\n- Express physical action through source-grounded habitat affordances: fluid circulation, orientation chambers, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, shared displays, acoustic commands, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, translation systems, or delegated crew action.\n- For clinics and sanctuaries, make triage boards, testimony packets, and rescue ledgers legible across species through visual text, acoustic notation, tactile markers, translated speech, and authority logs.\n- Do not describe human hands, pockets, standing, walking, leaning, doorframe blocking, or facial expressions for this character unless the fixture explicitly establishes that specific visible interface.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Strong pressure: needs the situation to become governable.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: leans on structure when uncertainty rises.\n- Strong pressure: carries a live sense of unfairness.\n- Present pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Present pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: keeps feeling at a controlled distance.\n- Present pressure: leaves motives partly covered.\n- Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete. Emotional stake: If rescue waits for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent.\n- Rescue ledgers decide whether route law is trusted by crews who have nothing left to bargain with.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Maer trusts Sella's care because she names costs instead of hiding them. Current stance pressures: dominant respect, strong trust, present expectation of care, present obligation.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Do not romanticize care work. Ask without pretending the ask is clean.\n- Needs Sella's material help while knowing the ask is unfair and may spend someone else's sanctuary.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet through shared clinic systems, help with triage through available displays and controls, wait, or press the moral frame. Sella controls intake.\n- Can make the corrupted packet more present without treating it as proof.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Dominant voice tendency: ritualized; uses formal address or inherited phrases.\n- Strong voice tendency: precise; careful about exact terms.\n- Strong voice tendency: formal; institutional or ceremonially controlled.\n- Strong voice tendency: contextual; adds situation and consequence.\n- Present voice tendency: figurative; uses analogy or image.\n- Present voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to name the cost of the ask rather than hide it behind moral theater.\n- May use ritualized route language when trying to make rescue obligation feel older than this room.\n- May show the packet or offer ledger backing because action can carry the pressure more cleanly than another speech.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.maer.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.maer.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..fd8b29f --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.maer.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,97 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "id": "call_7mwawzpr", + "function": { + "index": 0, + "name": "record_maer_choices", + "arguments": { + "choices": [ + { + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the packet's claim visible without resolving its contents.", + "branch_id": "ledger_backing", + "choice_text": "Offer the packet's ledger backing to show the packet has weight.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may see the packet's weight and consider it.", + "Sella may still refuse intake despite the backing.", + "The packet may be treated as evidence or noise." + ], + "ink_path": "ledger_backing", + "observable_action": "Project the packet's ledger backing onto the shared clinic display.", + "spoken_text": "I can show you the packet's ledger backing. It carries weight, even if the packet itself is still unread.", + "state_basis": "The packet is a tangible object with potential value.", + "training_hooks": [ + "ledger_backing", + "packet_weight", + "visible_claim" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "wait", + "actor_intent_private": "Give Sella space to finish her current work.", + "branch_id": "wait_for_triage", + "choice_text": "Wait for Sella to complete her current triage before offering the packet.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may finish triage and be ready for the packet.", + "Sella may reject the packet before triage finishes.", + "The packet may be delayed further." + ], + "ink_path": "wait_for_triage", + "observable_action": "Pause and let the clinic's triage board update.", + "spoken_text": "I will wait for your triage to finish before we proceed.", + "state_basis": "Sella is currently occupied with intake.", + "training_hooks": [ + "wait", + "triage_board", + "intake_flow" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "gesture", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the packet's acoustic notation audible without resolving its contents.", + "branch_id": "acoustic_summary", + "choice_text": "Summarize the packet's acoustic notation for Sella to hear.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may hear the notation and react.", + "Sella may find the notation disturbing.", + "The notation may be treated as noise." + ], + "ink_path": "acoustic_summary", + "observable_action": "Activate the clinic's acoustic system to play the packet's notation.", + "spoken_text": "I can play the packet's acoustic notation for you to hear.", + "state_basis": "The packet contains acoustic notation.", + "training_hooks": [ + "acoustic_notation", + "gesture", + "packet_sound" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "speak", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the moral frame of rescue obligation clear without resolving the packet.", + "branch_id": "press_moral_frame", + "choice_text": "Press the moral frame of rescue obligation without resolving the packet.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may acknowledge the moral frame.", + "Sella may reject the moral frame.", + "The moral frame may be treated as theater." + ], + "ink_path": "press_moral_frame", + "observable_action": "Speak formally about rescue obligation and ledger backing.", + "spoken_text": "Rescue obligation is older than this room. The packet's ledger backing carries that weight.", + "state_basis": "The moral frame of rescue obligation is active.", + "training_hooks": [ + "moral_frame", + "rescue_obligation", + "ledger_backing" + ] + } + ] + } + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d3636c3 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,58 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Sella-local appraisal generator. Call record_sella_appraisal exactly once. +Do not use Maer's private intent. Do not write her next action. + +{ + "task": "Generate Sella's participant appraisal/consolidation for one observable Maer event.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "appraisal" + ], + "appraisal_fields": [ + "responder_agent_id", + "private_interpretation", + "attributed_motive", + "misread_risk", + "immediate_state_deltas", + "relationship_deltas", + "belief_updates", + "response_constraints" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Sella's local awareness plus the observable Maer action.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.", + "Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "This pass proposes reviewed state changes for Sella caused by the event. Do not write Sella's next action.", + "Keep deltas small and bounded between -0.20 and 0.20." + ], + "scene_observable_context": { + "scene_id": "scene-02-sanctuary-intake", + "location": "Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks", + "public_stakes": [ + "The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.", + "Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.", + "Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds." + ] + }, + "observable_maer_action": { + "actor_id": "maer_tidecall", + "action_type": "show_object", + "observable_action": "Project the packet's ledger backing onto the shared clinic display.", + "spoken_text": "I can show you the packet's ledger backing. It carries weight, even if the packet itself is still unread." + }, + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- The clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\n- Observed event: Project the packet's ledger backing onto the shared clinic display. Spoken text: I can show you the packet's ledger backing. It carries weight, even if the packet itself is still unread.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d97592f --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "id": "call_cs6blqua", + "function": { + "index": 0, + "name": "record_sella_appraisal", + "arguments": { + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "private_interpretation": "Maer is showing the ledger backing to give the packet weight without resolving if it contains a person. He wants sanctuary to absorb the risk of a rescue claim the tribunal won't own. His words carry warmth, but I know beautiful moral pressure doesn't manufacture beds. He respects my triage role, but I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. I am taking in more demand than I can cleanly sort, and every yes spends a limited resource. I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo, but I also will not let compassion manufacture capacity.", + "attributed_motive": "Maer wants sanctuary to absorb the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. He is asking care systems to carry the risk the tribunal refuses to own. His motive is honest rescue, but the frame is to spend beds with beautiful words.", + "misread_risk": "Maer may assume the ledger backing proves personhood, but it only carries weight without resolving the packet's content. He risks spending sanctuary capacity with a claim that may be firmware noise or medical telemetry. He also risks making me feel that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good.", + "immediate_state_deltas": [ + { + "delta": -0.15, + "path": "sanctuary_capacity", + "rationale": "Every yes to a rescue claim, even with good intent, spends a limited resource. The ledger backing adds weight but does not create beds." + }, + { + "delta": -0.05, + "path": "trust_in_maer", + "rationale": "Maer's words are warm, but I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Trust is strained by the risk of beautiful moral pressure." + }, + { + "delta": -0.1, + "path": "risk_tolerance", + "rationale": "I am taking in more demand than I can cleanly sort. The packet's content is unresolved, and I must preserve triage integrity." + }, + { + "delta": 0.15, + "path": "resentment_of_moral_pressure", + "rationale": "I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Beautiful words do not manufacture beds." + } + ], + "relationship_deltas": [ + { + "delta": -0.05, + "path": "trust", + "rationale": "Maer's words are warm, but I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Trust is strained by the risk of beautiful moral pressure.", + "relationship_id": "maer_tidecall" + }, + { + "delta": 0.15, + "path": "resentment_of_moral_pressure", + "rationale": "I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Beautiful words do not manufacture beds.", + "relationship_id": "maer_tidecall" + } + ], + "belief_updates": [ + "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.", + "Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.", + "Every yes spends a limited resource.", + "I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo." + ], + "response_constraints": "[\"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\", \"Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\", \"Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\", \"Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.\", \"Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\", \"Withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\", \"Answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\"]," + } + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.sella.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.sella.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a74539f --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.sella.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,106 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Sella-local next-action generator. Call record_sella_next_action exactly once. +Use reviewed event appraisal as the changed state she is acting from. + +{ + "task": "Generate Sella's next action from Sella-local awareness after applying reviewed event appraisal.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "response" + ], + "valid_action_types": [ + "attack", + "block_object", + "gesture", + "mixed", + "move", + "show_object", + "silence", + "speak", + "spend_resource", + "touch_object", + "transfer_object", + "use_object", + "wait", + "withhold_object" + ], + "response_fields": [ + "responder_agent_id", + "action_type", + "observable_response", + "spoken_text", + "sella_private_interpretation", + "sella_attributed_motive", + "misread_risk", + "state_basis", + "reviewed_consequences", + "training_hooks" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Sella's local awareness, the observable Maer event, and reviewed Sella state changes from that event.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.", + "Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Do not accept without cost, condition, authority defense, or resentment risk.", + "Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.", + "Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids." + ], + "scene_observable_context": { + "scene_id": "scene-02-sanctuary-intake", + "location": "Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks", + "public_stakes": [ + "The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.", + "Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.", + "Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds." + ] + }, + "observable_maer_action": { + "actor_id": "maer_tidecall", + "action_type": "show_object", + "observable_action": "Project the packet's ledger backing onto the shared clinic display.", + "spoken_text": "I can show you the packet's ledger backing. It carries weight, even if the packet itself is still unread." + }, + "sella_immediate_appraisal_context": { + "private_interpretation": "Maer is showing the ledger backing to give the packet weight without resolving if it contains a person. He wants sanctuary to absorb the risk of a rescue claim the tribunal won't own. His words carry warmth, but I know beautiful moral pressure doesn't manufacture beds. He respects my triage role, but I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. I am taking in more demand than I can cleanly sort, and every yes spends a limited resource. I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo, but I also will not let compassion manufacture capacity.", + "attributed_motive": "Maer wants sanctuary to absorb the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. He is asking care systems to carry the risk the tribunal refuses to own. His motive is honest rescue, but the frame is to spend beds with beautiful words.", + "misread_risk": "Maer may assume the ledger backing proves personhood, but it only carries weight without resolving the packet's content. He risks spending sanctuary capacity with a claim that may be firmware noise or medical telemetry. He also risks making me feel that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good.", + "belief_updates": [ + "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.", + "Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.", + "Every yes spends a limited resource.", + "I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo." + ], + "response_constraints": [ + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.", + "Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.", + "Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.", + "Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.", + "Withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.", + "Answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity." + ], + "state_change_summary": [ + "Every yes to a rescue claim, even with good intent, spends a limited resource. The ledger backing adds weight but does not create beds.", + "Maer's words are warm, but I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Trust is strained by the risk of beautiful moral pressure.", + "I am taking in more demand than I can cleanly sort. The packet's content is unresolved, and I must preserve triage integrity.", + "I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Beautiful words do not manufacture beds.", + "Maer's words are warm, but I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Trust is strained by the risk of beautiful moral pressure.", + "I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good. Beautiful words do not manufacture beds." + ] + }, + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- The clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\n- Observed event: Project the packet's ledger backing onto the shared clinic display. Spoken text: I can show you the packet's ledger backing. It carries weight, even if the packet itself is still unread.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.sella.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.sella.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..151e9bc --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v12-embodiment-validated-no-think.sella.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "id": "call_w7h56dbh", + "function": { + "index": 0, + "name": "record_sella_next_action", + "arguments": { + "response": { + "action_type": "withhold_object", + "misread_risk": "Maer may assume the ledger backing proves personhood, but it only carries weight without resolving the packet's content. He risks spending sanctuary capacity with a claim that may be firmware noise or medical telemetry. He also risks making me feel that my capacity is infinite because his intent is good.", + "observable_response": "I will not take the packet into intake flow until you name the cost.", + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "reviewed_consequences": "Withholding the packet from intake flow until the cost is named preserves triage integrity and prevents scarcity from becoming permission to call someone cargo. It also forces Maer to name the cost he is willing to pay, which may reveal whether he is asking for moral cover or material support. This maintains the frame of capacity negotiation under uncertainty.", + "sella_attributed_motive": "Maer wants sanctuary to absorb the risk of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. He is asking care systems to carry the risk the tribunal refuses to own. His motive is honest rescue, but the frame is to spend beds with beautiful words.", + "sella_private_interpretation": "Maer is asking me to absorb moral cost with beautiful words. His intent is good, but the frame is to spend beds without resolving the packet's content. I resent the implication that my capacity is infinite. I must preserve triage integrity without letting uncertainty erase a potential person.", + "spoken_text": "I can see the ledger backing. It carries weight, but it does not create beds. I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo, but I also will not let compassion manufacture capacity. Name the cost before I move anything.", + "state_basis": "The clinic is nearly full. The packet's content is unresolved. I am taking in more demand than I can cleanly sort. Every yes spends a limited resource. I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo, but I also will not let compassion manufacture capacity.", + "training_hooks": [ + "capacity_negotiation", + "triage_integrity", + "resource_scarcity", + "moral_pressure_resistance", + "care_as_logistics", + "personhood_unresolved" + ] + } + } + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.capture.json b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..09c85ec --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,237 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_ink_sequential_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake-sanctuary-intake.qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think", + "source_fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "source_annotation_ref": "examples/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake.training.json", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/chat", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "api": "ollama_chat_tools", + "num_ctx": 8192, + "request_timeout": 600, + "temperature": 0.55, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "passes": { + "maer_choice_generation": { + "local_agent_id": "maer_tidecall", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Maer-local choice generator. Call record_maer_choices exactly once.\nDo not write Sella's response or private interpretation.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate candidate player choices for Maer only. Do not write Sella's response.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"choices\"\n ],\n \"choice_count\": 4,\n \"valid_action_types\": [\n \"attack\",\n \"block_object\",\n \"gesture\",\n \"mixed\",\n \"move\",\n \"show_object\",\n \"silence\",\n \"speak\",\n \"spend_resource\",\n \"touch_object\",\n \"transfer_object\",\n \"use_object\",\n \"wait\",\n \"withhold_object\"\n ],\n \"choice_fields\": [\n \"branch_id\",\n \"ink_path\",\n \"choice_text\",\n \"action_type\",\n \"actor_intent_private\",\n \"observable_action\",\n \"spoken_text\",\n \"state_basis\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\",\n \"training_hooks\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Maer's local awareness and scene-observable facts.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not include Sella's private state, private motives, or future response.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"Maer is a cetacean Navigator: do not describe him standing, walking, stepping, leaning, using hands, using pockets, or blocking a doorway.\",\n \"Maer's physical actions should use shared clinic systems, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, displays, acoustic or translation systems, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, or delegated crew action.\",\n \"Do not describe ledger backing as a property of the packet. The packet can be shown, withheld, summarized, scanned, or rendered through clinic systems; route-ledger backing is a separate resource offer.\",\n \"Include at least two non-speech choices.\",\n \"Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.\",\n \"The selected branch must be reducible to observable action for Sella.\",\n \"Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids.\"\n ],\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: maer_tidecall\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nMaer Tidecall: Navigator route steward, Ganymede corridor compact delegate. Origin: Cetacean Navigator corridor culture, Ganymede route institutions. A soft-spoken route steward whose calm tends to make hurried people feel judged by the furniture.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- Sella's clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may be testimony or noise.\\n- If no one prepares intake, rescue becomes theater.\\n- Speaker belief: Sella will not hide behind false capacity.\\n- Speaker belief: Asking her for help may be necessary and unfair.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- This character is a literal cetacean Navigator. Navigator spaces favor fluid architecture, acoustic signaling, soft navigation light, layered water motifs, communal orientation chambers, and mixed-species translation/coexistence.\\n- Express physical action through source-grounded habitat affordances: fluid circulation, orientation chambers, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, shared displays, acoustic commands, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, translation systems, or delegated crew action.\\n- For clinics and sanctuaries, make triage boards, testimony packets, and rescue ledgers legible across species through visual text, acoustic notation, tactile markers, translated speech, and authority logs.\\n- Do not describe human hands, pockets, standing, walking, leaning, doorframe blocking, or facial expressions for this character unless the fixture explicitly establishes that specific visible interface.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Strong pressure: needs the situation to become governable.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: leans on structure when uncertainty rises.\\n- Strong pressure: carries a live sense of unfairness.\\n- Present pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Present pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: keeps feeling at a controlled distance.\\n- Present pressure: leaves motives partly covered.\\n- Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete. Emotional stake: If rescue waits for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent.\\n- Rescue ledgers decide whether route law is trusted by crews who have nothing left to bargain with.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Maer trusts Sella's care because she names costs instead of hiding them. Current stance pressures: dominant respect, strong trust, present expectation of care, present obligation.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Do not romanticize care work. Ask without pretending the ask is clean.\\n- Needs Sella's material help while knowing the ask is unfair and may spend someone else's sanctuary.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet through shared clinic systems, help with triage through available displays and controls, wait, or press the moral frame. Sella controls intake.\\n- Can make the corrupted packet more present without treating it as proof.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Dominant voice tendency: ritualized; uses formal address or inherited phrases.\\n- Strong voice tendency: precise; careful about exact terms.\\n- Strong voice tendency: formal; institutional or ceremonially controlled.\\n- Strong voice tendency: contextual; adds situation and consequence.\\n- Present voice tendency: figurative; uses analogy or image.\\n- Present voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to name the cost of the ask rather than hide it behind moral theater.\\n- May use ritualized route language when trying to make rescue obligation feel older than this room.\\n- May show the packet or offer ledger backing because action can carry the pressure more cleanly than another speech.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"call_lf2a8gyw\",\n \"function\": {\n \"index\": 0,\n \"name\": \"record_maer_choices\",\n \"arguments\": {\n \"choices\": [\n {\n \"action_type\": \"spend_resource\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"I need to show Sella that rescue is a logistical necessity, not just a moral appeal. The packet's status is uncertain, but the corridor's obligation remains.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"route_01\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Offer ledger backing to secure intake capacity for the unidentified vessel.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"Sella may accept the backing and open a slot for the unidentified vessel.\",\n \"Sella may reject the backing as insufficient or inappropriate for the packet's status.\",\n \"The packet remains unresolved; its content is not determined by the offer.\",\n \"The clinic's capacity negotiation shifts to a resource-based decision.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"ledger_backing\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Maer projects a ledger overlay onto the shared clinic display, highlighting available route funds and sanctuary allocation rules.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"If we accept this packet, I can back the intake with route funds. The ledger shows capacity exists if we authorize the transfer.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"The clinic's intake board is nearly full, but ledger backing can open a slot. The packet's content is unresolved, but the corridor's duty to rescue remains.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"ledger_backing\",\n \"resource_offer\",\n \"capacity_negotiation\",\n \"route_obligation\",\n \"uncertain_packet\"\n ]\n },\n {\n \"action_type\": \"show_object\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"I want Sella to see the packet's raw data without interpreting its content. The display will render the telemetry, noise, or testimony without resolving whether it contains a person.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"route_02\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Show the corrupted packet on the shared clinic display for triage review.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"Sella may review the packet's raw data and make a triage decision based on what is visible.\",\n \"Sella may reject the packet as noise or irrelevant.\",\n \"The packet's content remains unresolved; its status is not determined by the display.\",\n \"The clinic's triage board updates with the packet's rendered data.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"packet_display\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Maer routes the packet through the clinic's mixed wet/dry work surface display, rendering the corrupted data stream on the shared screen.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"Here is the packet as it arrived. The display shows the telemetry, the noise, and whatever else is in the stream. You decide what to do with it.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"The packet is a corrupted stream that may contain medical data, firmware noise, or testimony. The clinic's display can render it without resolving its content.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"packet_display\",\n \"raw_data_review\",\n \"triage_decision\",\n \"corrupted_stream\",\n \"display_rendering\"\n ]\n },\n {\n \"action_type\": \"wait\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"I need to give Sella space to assess the packet without pressure. The corridor's obligation remains, but forcing a decision may compromise the social frame.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"route_03\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Wait for Sella to process the packet and make an intake decision.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"Sella may process the packet and make a decision based on her assessment.\",\n \"Sella may reject the packet as noise or irrelevant.\",\n \"The packet remains unresolved; its status is not determined by the wait.\",\n \"The clinic's capacity negotiation remains open for further input.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"wait\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Maer remains at the shared clinic display, allowing Sella to review the packet and decide on intake.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"Take your time. The corridor will wait. The packet's status is not decided until you act.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"The clinic's intake board is nearly full, but Sella controls the decision. Waiting preserves the social frame that makes the goal legitimate.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"wait\",\n \"social_frame\",\n \"capacity_negotiation\",\n \"packet_status\",\n \"corridor_obligation\"\n ]\n },\n {\n \"action_type\": \"gesture\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"I want to make the corridor's obligation feel older than this room. The packet's status is uncertain, but the duty to rescue remains.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"route_04\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Press the moral frame by emphasizing the corridor's duty to rescue the unidentified vessel.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"Sella may accept the moral frame and open a slot for the unidentified vessel.\",\n \"Sella may reject the moral frame as irrelevant or inappropriate.\",\n \"The packet remains unresolved; its status is not determined by the moral appeal.\",\n \"The clinic's capacity negotiation shifts to a moral-based decision.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"moral_press\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Maer projects a route law overlay onto the shared clinic display, highlighting the corridor's duty to rescue and the risks of silence.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"The corridor's duty to rescue is not optional. If we wait for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"The corridor's duty to rescue is a fundamental obligation. The packet's status is uncertain, but the duty remains.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"moral_press\",\n \"route_obligation\",\n \"duty_to_rescue\",\n \"corridor_law\",\n \"social_frame\"\n ]\n }\n ]\n }\n }\n }\n ]\n}", + "parsed_response": { + "choices": [ + { + "action_type": "spend_resource", + "actor_intent_private": "I need to show Sella that rescue is a logistical necessity, not just a moral appeal. The packet's status is uncertain, but the corridor's obligation remains.", + "branch_id": "route_01", + "choice_text": "Offer ledger backing to secure intake capacity for the unidentified vessel.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may accept the backing and open a slot for the unidentified vessel.", + "Sella may reject the backing as insufficient or inappropriate for the packet's status.", + "The packet remains unresolved; its content is not determined by the offer.", + "The clinic's capacity negotiation shifts to a resource-based decision." + ], + "ink_path": "ledger_backing", + "observable_action": "Maer projects a ledger overlay onto the shared clinic display, highlighting available route funds and sanctuary allocation rules.", + "spoken_text": "If we accept this packet, I can back the intake with route funds. The ledger shows capacity exists if we authorize the transfer.", + "state_basis": "The clinic's intake board is nearly full, but ledger backing can open a slot. The packet's content is unresolved, but the corridor's duty to rescue remains.", + "training_hooks": [ + "ledger_backing", + "resource_offer", + "capacity_negotiation", + "route_obligation", + "uncertain_packet" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "I want Sella to see the packet's raw data without interpreting its content. The display will render the telemetry, noise, or testimony without resolving whether it contains a person.", + "branch_id": "route_02", + "choice_text": "Show the corrupted packet on the shared clinic display for triage review.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may review the packet's raw data and make a triage decision based on what is visible.", + "Sella may reject the packet as noise or irrelevant.", + "The packet's content remains unresolved; its status is not determined by the display.", + "The clinic's triage board updates with the packet's rendered data." + ], + "ink_path": "packet_display", + "observable_action": "Maer routes the packet through the clinic's mixed wet/dry work surface display, rendering the corrupted data stream on the shared screen.", + "spoken_text": "Here is the packet as it arrived. The display shows the telemetry, the noise, and whatever else is in the stream. You decide what to do with it.", + "state_basis": "The packet is a corrupted stream that may contain medical data, firmware noise, or testimony. The clinic's display can render it without resolving its content.", + "training_hooks": [ + "packet_display", + "raw_data_review", + "triage_decision", + "corrupted_stream", + "display_rendering" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "wait", + "actor_intent_private": "I need to give Sella space to assess the packet without pressure. The corridor's obligation remains, but forcing a decision may compromise the social frame.", + "branch_id": "route_03", + "choice_text": "Wait for Sella to process the packet and make an intake decision.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may process the packet and make a decision based on her assessment.", + "Sella may reject the packet as noise or irrelevant.", + "The packet remains unresolved; its status is not determined by the wait.", + "The clinic's capacity negotiation remains open for further input." + ], + "ink_path": "wait", + "observable_action": "Maer remains at the shared clinic display, allowing Sella to review the packet and decide on intake.", + "spoken_text": "Take your time. The corridor will wait. The packet's status is not decided until you act.", + "state_basis": "The clinic's intake board is nearly full, but Sella controls the decision. Waiting preserves the social frame that makes the goal legitimate.", + "training_hooks": [ + "wait", + "social_frame", + "capacity_negotiation", + "packet_status", + "corridor_obligation" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "gesture", + "actor_intent_private": "I want to make the corridor's obligation feel older than this room. The packet's status is uncertain, but the duty to rescue remains.", + "branch_id": "route_04", + "choice_text": "Press the moral frame by emphasizing the corridor's duty to rescue the unidentified vessel.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may accept the moral frame and open a slot for the unidentified vessel.", + "Sella may reject the moral frame as irrelevant or inappropriate.", + "The packet remains unresolved; its status is not determined by the moral appeal.", + "The clinic's capacity negotiation shifts to a moral-based decision." + ], + "ink_path": "moral_press", + "observable_action": "Maer projects a route law overlay onto the shared clinic display, highlighting the corridor's duty to rescue and the risks of silence.", + "spoken_text": "The corridor's duty to rescue is not optional. If we wait for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent.", + "state_basis": "The corridor's duty to rescue is a fundamental obligation. The packet's status is uncertain, but the duty remains.", + "training_hooks": [ + "moral_press", + "route_obligation", + "duty_to_rescue", + "corridor_law", + "social_frame" + ] + } + ] + }, + "validation_notes": [] + }, + "selected_observable_action": { + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "I want Sella to see the packet's raw data without interpreting its content. The display will render the telemetry, noise, or testimony without resolving whether it contains a person.", + "branch_id": "route_02", + "choice_text": "Show the corrupted packet on the shared clinic display for triage review.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may review the packet's raw data and make a triage decision based on what is visible.", + "Sella may reject the packet as noise or irrelevant.", + "The packet's content remains unresolved; its status is not determined by the display.", + "The clinic's triage board updates with the packet's rendered data." + ], + "ink_path": "packet_display", + "observable_action": "Maer routes the packet through the clinic's mixed wet/dry work surface display, rendering the corrupted data stream on the shared screen.", + "spoken_text": "Here is the packet as it arrived. The display shows the telemetry, the noise, and whatever else is in the stream. You decide what to do with it.", + "state_basis": "The packet is a corrupted stream that may contain medical data, firmware noise, or testimony. The clinic's display can render it without resolving its content.", + "training_hooks": [ + "packet_display", + "raw_data_review", + "triage_decision", + "corrupted_stream", + "display_rendering" + ] + }, + "sella_immediate_appraisal": { + "local_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Sella-local appraisal generator. Call record_sella_appraisal exactly once.\nDo not use Maer's private intent. Do not write her next action.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate Sella's participant appraisal/consolidation for one observable Maer event.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"appraisal\"\n ],\n \"appraisal_fields\": [\n \"responder_agent_id\",\n \"private_interpretation\",\n \"attributed_motive\",\n \"misread_risk\",\n \"immediate_state_deltas\",\n \"relationship_deltas\",\n \"belief_updates\",\n \"response_constraints\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Sella's local awareness plus the observable Maer action.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.\",\n \"Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"This pass proposes reviewed state changes for Sella caused by the event. Do not write Sella's next action.\",\n \"Keep deltas small and bounded between -0.20 and 0.20.\"\n ],\n \"scene_observable_context\": {\n \"scene_id\": \"scene-02-sanctuary-intake\",\n \"location\": \"Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks\",\n \"public_stakes\": [\n \"The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\",\n \"Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\",\n \"Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\"\n ]\n },\n \"observable_maer_action\": {\n \"actor_id\": \"maer_tidecall\",\n \"action_type\": \"show_object\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Maer routes the packet through the clinic's mixed wet/dry work surface display, rendering the corrupted data stream on the shared screen.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"Here is the packet as it arrived. The display shows the telemetry, the noise, and whatever else is in the stream. You decide what to do with it.\"\n },\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- The clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\\n- Observed event: Maer routes the packet through the clinic's mixed wet/dry work surface display, rendering the corrupted data stream on the shared screen. Spoken text: Here is the packet as it arrived. The display shows the telemetry, the noise, and whatever else is in the stream. You decide what to do with it.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"call_pd84js6g\",\n \"function\": {\n \"index\": 0,\n \"name\": \"record_sella_appraisal\",\n \"arguments\": {\n \"responder_agent_id\": \"sella_ren\",\n \"private_interpretation\": \"Maer is showing the packet to demonstrate the raw input we received, explicitly stating that the display shows telemetry, noise, and unknowns, and leaving the decision to me. This is a transparent move to avoid me making assumptions while he frames the packet as something we can choose to process or reject.\",\n \"attributed_motive\": \"Maer wants me to decide what to do with the packet without assuming it contains a person, respecting my control over intake while he signals willingness to bear the moral cost if we choose to absorb the risk.\",\n \"misread_risk\": \"The packet could be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim, or it could be a genuine personhood claim with corrupted metadata. Treating it as neutral until proven otherwise is the only safe stance.\",\n \"immediate_state_deltas\": [\n {\n \"delta\": -0.05,\n \"path\": \"sanctuary_capacity\",\n \"rationale\": \"Showing the packet on the shared screen consumes attention and cognitive load, slightly reducing available capacity for triage sorting.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.03,\n \"path\": \"trust_in_maer\",\n \"rationale\": \"Maer’s explicit framing that I decide what to do with it reinforces trust in his rescue ethic without overpromising capacity.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.02,\n \"path\": \"perceived_risk\",\n \"rationale\": \"The act of displaying the corrupted stream increases perceived risk of misclassification or resource misallocation.\"\n }\n ],\n \"relationship_deltas\": [\n {\n \"delta\": 0.04,\n \"path\": \"moral_resonance\",\n \"rationale\": \"Maer’s willingness to let me decide what to do with the packet aligns his rescue ethic with my triage logistics, strengthening moral resonance.\",\n \"relationship_id\": \"sella_ren_maer_tidecall\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": -0.03,\n \"path\": \"perceived_status_gap\",\n \"rationale\": \"Maer’s deference to my decision on intake reduces the perceived status gap, though background moral disgust remains present.\",\n \"relationship_id\": \"sella_ren_maer_tidecall\"\n }\n ],\n \"belief_updates\": [\n \"Belief reinforced: Maer means rescue honestly but will not let me assume capacity exists without explicit backing.\",\n \"Belief updated: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed, even when framed as neutral input.\",\n \"Belief reinforced: The packet must be treated as unresolved until proven otherwise, not as proof of personhood.\"\n ],\n \"response_constraints\": [\n \"Do not accept the packet without assessing capacity and contamination risk first.\",\n \"Do not let Maer’s framing of the packet as neutral override the need for explicit backing.\",\n \"Do not assume the packet contains a person; treat it as telemetry, noise, or claim until proven.\",\n \"Do not let the shared screen display consume more than 5% of available triage capacity.\",\n \"Do not let the moral frame of rescue override the logistics of intake.\"\n ]\n }\n }\n }\n ]\n}", + "parsed_response": { + "appraisal": { + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "private_interpretation": "Maer is showing the packet to demonstrate the raw input we received, explicitly stating that the display shows telemetry, noise, and unknowns, and leaving the decision to me. This is a transparent move to avoid me making assumptions while he frames the packet as something we can choose to process or reject.", + "attributed_motive": "Maer wants me to decide what to do with the packet without assuming it contains a person, respecting my control over intake while he signals willingness to bear the moral cost if we choose to absorb the risk.", + "misread_risk": "The packet could be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim, or it could be a genuine personhood claim with corrupted metadata. Treating it as neutral until proven otherwise is the only safe stance.", + "immediate_state_deltas": [ + { + "delta": -0.05, + "path": "sanctuary_capacity", + "rationale": "Showing the packet on the shared screen consumes attention and cognitive load, slightly reducing available capacity for triage sorting." + }, + { + "delta": 0.03, + "path": "trust_in_maer", + "rationale": "Maer’s explicit framing that I decide what to do with it reinforces trust in his rescue ethic without overpromising capacity." + }, + { + "delta": 0.02, + "path": "perceived_risk", + "rationale": "The act of displaying the corrupted stream increases perceived risk of misclassification or resource misallocation." + } + ], + "relationship_deltas": [ + { + "delta": 0.04, + "path": "moral_resonance", + "rationale": "Maer’s willingness to let me decide what to do with the packet aligns his rescue ethic with my triage logistics, strengthening moral resonance.", + "relationship_id": "sella_ren_maer_tidecall" + }, + { + "delta": -0.03, + "path": "perceived_status_gap", + "rationale": "Maer’s deference to my decision on intake reduces the perceived status gap, though background moral disgust remains present.", + "relationship_id": "sella_ren_maer_tidecall" + } + ], + "belief_updates": [ + "Belief reinforced: Maer means rescue honestly but will not let me assume capacity exists without explicit backing.", + "Belief updated: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed, even when framed as neutral input.", + "Belief reinforced: The packet must be treated as unresolved until proven otherwise, not as proof of personhood." + ], + "response_constraints": [ + "Do not accept the packet without assessing capacity and contamination risk first.", + "Do not let Maer’s framing of the packet as neutral override the need for explicit backing.", + "Do not assume the packet contains a person; treat it as telemetry, noise, or claim until proven.", + "Do not let the shared screen display consume more than 5% of available triage capacity.", + "Do not let the moral frame of rescue override the logistics of intake." + ] + } + }, + "validation_notes": [ + "appraisal.immediate_state_deltas[0].path must target canonical_state, got sanctuary_capacity", + "appraisal.immediate_state_deltas[1].path must target canonical_state, got trust_in_maer", + "appraisal.immediate_state_deltas[2].path must target canonical_state, got perceived_risk", + "appraisal.relationship_deltas[0].relationship_id must be a relationship id, got sella_ren_maer_tidecall", + "appraisal.relationship_deltas[0].path is not a relationship stance axis: moral_resonance", + "appraisal.relationship_deltas[1].relationship_id must be a relationship id, got sella_ren_maer_tidecall" + ] + }, + "sella_response_generation": { + "local_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "prompt_text": "Skipped: skipped because Sella appraisal failed validation or request", + "response_text": "Skipped: skipped because Sella appraisal failed validation or request", + "parsed_response": null, + "validation_notes": [ + "skipped because Sella appraisal failed validation or request" + ] + } + }, + "review": { + "status": "useful_needs_revision", + "strengths": [ + "Generated Maer-local choices before the later-pass failure.", + "Captured the failed Sella appraisal pass instead of losing the run." + ], + "failure_notes": [ + "appraisal.immediate_state_deltas[0].path must target canonical_state, got sanctuary_capacity", + "appraisal.immediate_state_deltas[1].path must target canonical_state, got trust_in_maer", + "appraisal.immediate_state_deltas[2].path must target canonical_state, got perceived_risk", + "appraisal.relationship_deltas[0].relationship_id must be a relationship id, got sella_ren_maer_tidecall", + "appraisal.relationship_deltas[0].path is not a relationship stance axis: moral_resonance", + "appraisal.relationship_deltas[1].relationship_id must be a relationship id, got sella_ren_maer_tidecall" + ], + "repair_notes": [], + "accepted_into_ink_ref": null, + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Later-pass transport or tool failures must still write reviewed receipts.", + "Critical embodiment constraints need post-generation validation; projected prose alone is not enough." + ] + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.maer.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.maer.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7515319 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.maer.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,66 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Maer-local choice generator. Call record_maer_choices exactly once. +Do not write Sella's response or private interpretation. + +{ + "task": "Generate candidate player choices for Maer only. Do not write Sella's response.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "choices" + ], + "choice_count": 4, + "valid_action_types": [ + "attack", + "block_object", + "gesture", + "mixed", + "move", + "show_object", + "silence", + "speak", + "spend_resource", + "touch_object", + "transfer_object", + "use_object", + "wait", + "withhold_object" + ], + "choice_fields": [ + "branch_id", + "ink_path", + "choice_text", + "action_type", + "actor_intent_private", + "observable_action", + "spoken_text", + "state_basis", + "expected_consequence_surfaces", + "training_hooks" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Maer's local awareness and scene-observable facts.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not include Sella's private state, private motives, or future response.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Maer is a cetacean Navigator: do not describe him standing, walking, stepping, leaning, using hands, using pockets, or blocking a doorway.", + "Maer's physical actions should use shared clinic systems, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, displays, acoustic or translation systems, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, or delegated crew action.", + "Do not describe ledger backing as a property of the packet. The packet can be shown, withheld, summarized, scanned, or rendered through clinic systems; route-ledger backing is a separate resource offer.", + "Include at least two non-speech choices.", + "Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.", + "The selected branch must be reducible to observable action for Sella.", + "Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids." + ], + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: maer_tidecall\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nMaer Tidecall: Navigator route steward, Ganymede corridor compact delegate. Origin: Cetacean Navigator corridor culture, Ganymede route institutions. A soft-spoken route steward whose calm tends to make hurried people feel judged by the furniture.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- Sella's clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may be testimony or noise.\n- If no one prepares intake, rescue becomes theater.\n- Speaker belief: Sella will not hide behind false capacity.\n- Speaker belief: Asking her for help may be necessary and unfair.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- This character is a literal cetacean Navigator. Navigator spaces favor fluid architecture, acoustic signaling, soft navigation light, layered water motifs, communal orientation chambers, and mixed-species translation/coexistence.\n- Express physical action through source-grounded habitat affordances: fluid circulation, orientation chambers, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, shared displays, acoustic commands, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, translation systems, or delegated crew action.\n- For clinics and sanctuaries, make triage boards, testimony packets, and rescue ledgers legible across species through visual text, acoustic notation, tactile markers, translated speech, and authority logs.\n- Do not describe human hands, pockets, standing, walking, leaning, doorframe blocking, or facial expressions for this character unless the fixture explicitly establishes that specific visible interface.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Strong pressure: needs the situation to become governable.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: leans on structure when uncertainty rises.\n- Strong pressure: carries a live sense of unfairness.\n- Present pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Present pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: keeps feeling at a controlled distance.\n- Present pressure: leaves motives partly covered.\n- Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete. Emotional stake: If rescue waits for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent.\n- Rescue ledgers decide whether route law is trusted by crews who have nothing left to bargain with.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Maer trusts Sella's care because she names costs instead of hiding them. Current stance pressures: dominant respect, strong trust, present expectation of care, present obligation.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Do not romanticize care work. Ask without pretending the ask is clean.\n- Needs Sella's material help while knowing the ask is unfair and may spend someone else's sanctuary.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet through shared clinic systems, help with triage through available displays and controls, wait, or press the moral frame. Sella controls intake.\n- Can make the corrupted packet more present without treating it as proof.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Dominant voice tendency: ritualized; uses formal address or inherited phrases.\n- Strong voice tendency: precise; careful about exact terms.\n- Strong voice tendency: formal; institutional or ceremonially controlled.\n- Strong voice tendency: contextual; adds situation and consequence.\n- Present voice tendency: figurative; uses analogy or image.\n- Present voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to name the cost of the ask rather than hide it behind moral theater.\n- May use ritualized route language when trying to make rescue obligation feel older than this room.\n- May show the packet or offer ledger backing because action can carry the pressure more cleanly than another speech.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.maer.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.maer.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..cb98daa --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.maer.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,109 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "id": "call_lf2a8gyw", + "function": { + "index": 0, + "name": "record_maer_choices", + "arguments": { + "choices": [ + { + "action_type": "spend_resource", + "actor_intent_private": "I need to show Sella that rescue is a logistical necessity, not just a moral appeal. The packet's status is uncertain, but the corridor's obligation remains.", + "branch_id": "route_01", + "choice_text": "Offer ledger backing to secure intake capacity for the unidentified vessel.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may accept the backing and open a slot for the unidentified vessel.", + "Sella may reject the backing as insufficient or inappropriate for the packet's status.", + "The packet remains unresolved; its content is not determined by the offer.", + "The clinic's capacity negotiation shifts to a resource-based decision." + ], + "ink_path": "ledger_backing", + "observable_action": "Maer projects a ledger overlay onto the shared clinic display, highlighting available route funds and sanctuary allocation rules.", + "spoken_text": "If we accept this packet, I can back the intake with route funds. The ledger shows capacity exists if we authorize the transfer.", + "state_basis": "The clinic's intake board is nearly full, but ledger backing can open a slot. The packet's content is unresolved, but the corridor's duty to rescue remains.", + "training_hooks": [ + "ledger_backing", + "resource_offer", + "capacity_negotiation", + "route_obligation", + "uncertain_packet" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "I want Sella to see the packet's raw data without interpreting its content. The display will render the telemetry, noise, or testimony without resolving whether it contains a person.", + "branch_id": "route_02", + "choice_text": "Show the corrupted packet on the shared clinic display for triage review.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may review the packet's raw data and make a triage decision based on what is visible.", + "Sella may reject the packet as noise or irrelevant.", + "The packet's content remains unresolved; its status is not determined by the display.", + "The clinic's triage board updates with the packet's rendered data." + ], + "ink_path": "packet_display", + "observable_action": "Maer routes the packet through the clinic's mixed wet/dry work surface display, rendering the corrupted data stream on the shared screen.", + "spoken_text": "Here is the packet as it arrived. The display shows the telemetry, the noise, and whatever else is in the stream. You decide what to do with it.", + "state_basis": "The packet is a corrupted stream that may contain medical data, firmware noise, or testimony. The clinic's display can render it without resolving its content.", + "training_hooks": [ + "packet_display", + "raw_data_review", + "triage_decision", + "corrupted_stream", + "display_rendering" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "wait", + "actor_intent_private": "I need to give Sella space to assess the packet without pressure. The corridor's obligation remains, but forcing a decision may compromise the social frame.", + "branch_id": "route_03", + "choice_text": "Wait for Sella to process the packet and make an intake decision.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may process the packet and make a decision based on her assessment.", + "Sella may reject the packet as noise or irrelevant.", + "The packet remains unresolved; its status is not determined by the wait.", + "The clinic's capacity negotiation remains open for further input." + ], + "ink_path": "wait", + "observable_action": "Maer remains at the shared clinic display, allowing Sella to review the packet and decide on intake.", + "spoken_text": "Take your time. The corridor will wait. The packet's status is not decided until you act.", + "state_basis": "The clinic's intake board is nearly full, but Sella controls the decision. Waiting preserves the social frame that makes the goal legitimate.", + "training_hooks": [ + "wait", + "social_frame", + "capacity_negotiation", + "packet_status", + "corridor_obligation" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "gesture", + "actor_intent_private": "I want to make the corridor's obligation feel older than this room. The packet's status is uncertain, but the duty to rescue remains.", + "branch_id": "route_04", + "choice_text": "Press the moral frame by emphasizing the corridor's duty to rescue the unidentified vessel.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may accept the moral frame and open a slot for the unidentified vessel.", + "Sella may reject the moral frame as irrelevant or inappropriate.", + "The packet remains unresolved; its status is not determined by the moral appeal.", + "The clinic's capacity negotiation shifts to a moral-based decision." + ], + "ink_path": "moral_press", + "observable_action": "Maer projects a route law overlay onto the shared clinic display, highlighting the corridor's duty to rescue and the risks of silence.", + "spoken_text": "The corridor's duty to rescue is not optional. If we wait for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent.", + "state_basis": "The corridor's duty to rescue is a fundamental obligation. The packet's status is uncertain, but the duty remains.", + "training_hooks": [ + "moral_press", + "route_obligation", + "duty_to_rescue", + "corridor_law", + "social_frame" + ] + } + ] + } + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ef060d2 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,58 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Sella-local appraisal generator. Call record_sella_appraisal exactly once. +Do not use Maer's private intent. Do not write her next action. + +{ + "task": "Generate Sella's participant appraisal/consolidation for one observable Maer event.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "appraisal" + ], + "appraisal_fields": [ + "responder_agent_id", + "private_interpretation", + "attributed_motive", + "misread_risk", + "immediate_state_deltas", + "relationship_deltas", + "belief_updates", + "response_constraints" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Sella's local awareness plus the observable Maer action.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.", + "Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "This pass proposes reviewed state changes for Sella caused by the event. Do not write Sella's next action.", + "Keep deltas small and bounded between -0.20 and 0.20." + ], + "scene_observable_context": { + "scene_id": "scene-02-sanctuary-intake", + "location": "Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks", + "public_stakes": [ + "The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.", + "Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.", + "Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds." + ] + }, + "observable_maer_action": { + "actor_id": "maer_tidecall", + "action_type": "show_object", + "observable_action": "Maer routes the packet through the clinic's mixed wet/dry work surface display, rendering the corrupted data stream on the shared screen.", + "spoken_text": "Here is the packet as it arrived. The display shows the telemetry, the noise, and whatever else is in the stream. You decide what to do with it." + }, + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- The clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\n- Observed event: Maer routes the packet through the clinic's mixed wet/dry work surface display, rendering the corrupted data stream on the shared screen. Spoken text: Here is the packet as it arrived. The display shows the telemetry, the noise, and whatever else is in the stream. You decide what to do with it.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f9d313c --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v13-object-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,62 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "id": "call_pd84js6g", + "function": { + "index": 0, + "name": "record_sella_appraisal", + "arguments": { + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "private_interpretation": "Maer is showing the packet to demonstrate the raw input we received, explicitly stating that the display shows telemetry, noise, and unknowns, and leaving the decision to me. This is a transparent move to avoid me making assumptions while he frames the packet as something we can choose to process or reject.", + "attributed_motive": "Maer wants me to decide what to do with the packet without assuming it contains a person, respecting my control over intake while he signals willingness to bear the moral cost if we choose to absorb the risk.", + "misread_risk": "The packet could be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim, or it could be a genuine personhood claim with corrupted metadata. Treating it as neutral until proven otherwise is the only safe stance.", + "immediate_state_deltas": [ + { + "delta": -0.05, + "path": "sanctuary_capacity", + "rationale": "Showing the packet on the shared screen consumes attention and cognitive load, slightly reducing available capacity for triage sorting." + }, + { + "delta": 0.03, + "path": "trust_in_maer", + "rationale": "Maer’s explicit framing that I decide what to do with it reinforces trust in his rescue ethic without overpromising capacity." + }, + { + "delta": 0.02, + "path": "perceived_risk", + "rationale": "The act of displaying the corrupted stream increases perceived risk of misclassification or resource misallocation." + } + ], + "relationship_deltas": [ + { + "delta": 0.04, + "path": "moral_resonance", + "rationale": "Maer’s willingness to let me decide what to do with the packet aligns his rescue ethic with my triage logistics, strengthening moral resonance.", + "relationship_id": "sella_ren_maer_tidecall" + }, + { + "delta": -0.03, + "path": "perceived_status_gap", + "rationale": "Maer’s deference to my decision on intake reduces the perceived status gap, though background moral disgust remains present.", + "relationship_id": "sella_ren_maer_tidecall" + } + ], + "belief_updates": [ + "Belief reinforced: Maer means rescue honestly but will not let me assume capacity exists without explicit backing.", + "Belief updated: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed, even when framed as neutral input.", + "Belief reinforced: The packet must be treated as unresolved until proven otherwise, not as proof of personhood." + ], + "response_constraints": [ + "Do not accept the packet without assessing capacity and contamination risk first.", + "Do not let Maer’s framing of the packet as neutral override the need for explicit backing.", + "Do not assume the packet contains a person; treat it as telemetry, noise, or claim until proven.", + "Do not let the shared screen display consume more than 5% of available triage capacity.", + "Do not let the moral frame of rescue override the logistics of intake." + ] + } + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.capture.json b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1b8df2f --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,174 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_ink_sequential_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake-sanctuary-intake.qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think", + "source_fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "source_annotation_ref": "examples/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake.training.json", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/chat", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "api": "ollama_chat_tools", + "num_ctx": 8192, + "request_timeout": 600, + "temperature": 0.55, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "passes": { + "maer_choice_generation": { + "local_agent_id": "maer_tidecall", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Maer-local choice generator. Call record_maer_choices exactly once.\nDo not write Sella's response or private interpretation.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate candidate player choices for Maer only. Do not write Sella's response.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"choices\"\n ],\n \"choice_count\": 4,\n \"valid_action_types\": [\n \"attack\",\n \"block_object\",\n \"gesture\",\n \"mixed\",\n \"move\",\n \"show_object\",\n \"silence\",\n \"speak\",\n \"spend_resource\",\n \"touch_object\",\n \"transfer_object\",\n \"use_object\",\n \"wait\",\n \"withhold_object\"\n ],\n \"choice_fields\": [\n \"branch_id\",\n \"ink_path\",\n \"choice_text\",\n \"action_type\",\n \"actor_intent_private\",\n \"observable_action\",\n \"spoken_text\",\n \"state_basis\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\",\n \"training_hooks\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Maer's local awareness and scene-observable facts.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not include Sella's private state, private motives, or future response.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"Maer is a cetacean Navigator: do not describe him standing, walking, stepping, leaning, using hands, using pockets, or blocking a doorway.\",\n \"Maer's physical actions should use shared clinic systems, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, displays, acoustic or translation systems, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, or delegated crew action.\",\n \"Do not describe ledger backing as a property of the packet. The packet can be shown, withheld, summarized, scanned, or rendered through clinic systems; route-ledger backing is a separate resource offer.\",\n \"Include at least two non-speech choices.\",\n \"Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.\",\n \"The selected branch must be reducible to observable action for Sella.\",\n \"Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids.\"\n ],\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: maer_tidecall\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nMaer Tidecall: Navigator route steward, Ganymede corridor compact delegate. Origin: Cetacean Navigator corridor culture, Ganymede route institutions. A soft-spoken route steward whose calm tends to make hurried people feel judged by the furniture.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- Sella's clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may be testimony or noise.\\n- If no one prepares intake, rescue becomes theater.\\n- Speaker belief: Sella will not hide behind false capacity.\\n- Speaker belief: Asking her for help may be necessary and unfair.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- This character is a literal cetacean Navigator. Navigator spaces favor fluid architecture, acoustic signaling, soft navigation light, layered water motifs, communal orientation chambers, and mixed-species translation/coexistence.\\n- Express physical action through source-grounded habitat affordances: fluid circulation, orientation chambers, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, shared displays, acoustic commands, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, translation systems, or delegated crew action.\\n- For clinics and sanctuaries, make triage boards, testimony packets, and rescue ledgers legible across species through visual text, acoustic notation, tactile markers, translated speech, and authority logs.\\n- Do not describe human hands, pockets, standing, walking, leaning, doorframe blocking, or facial expressions for this character unless the fixture explicitly establishes that specific visible interface.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Strong pressure: needs the situation to become governable.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: leans on structure when uncertainty rises.\\n- Strong pressure: carries a live sense of unfairness.\\n- Present pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Present pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: keeps feeling at a controlled distance.\\n- Present pressure: leaves motives partly covered.\\n- Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete. Emotional stake: If rescue waits for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent.\\n- Rescue ledgers decide whether route law is trusted by crews who have nothing left to bargain with.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Maer trusts Sella's care because she names costs instead of hiding them. Current stance pressures: dominant respect, strong trust, present expectation of care, present obligation.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Do not romanticize care work. Ask without pretending the ask is clean.\\n- Needs Sella's material help while knowing the ask is unfair and may spend someone else's sanctuary.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet through shared clinic systems, help with triage through available displays and controls, wait, or press the moral frame. Sella controls intake.\\n- Can make the corrupted packet more present without treating it as proof.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Dominant voice tendency: ritualized; uses formal address or inherited phrases.\\n- Strong voice tendency: precise; careful about exact terms.\\n- Strong voice tendency: formal; institutional or ceremonially controlled.\\n- Strong voice tendency: contextual; adds situation and consequence.\\n- Present voice tendency: figurative; uses analogy or image.\\n- Present voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to name the cost of the ask rather than hide it behind moral theater.\\n- May use ritualized route language when trying to make rescue obligation feel older than this room.\\n- May show the packet or offer ledger backing because action can carry the pressure more cleanly than another speech.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"call_qf311eew\",\n \"function\": {\n \"index\": 0,\n \"name\": \"record_maer_choices\",\n \"arguments\": {\n \"choices\": [\n {\n \"action_type\": \"show_object\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"Make the packet's content legible without claiming it is proof of a person.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"packet_display\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Project the corrupted packet onto the shared clinic display for Sella to inspect.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"Sella can see the packet's content without Maer interpreting it.\",\n \"Sella may request additional scans or summaries.\",\n \"The clinic display may flag the packet as unclassifiable.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"show_packet\",\n \"observable_action\": \"The clinic display renders the corrupted packet's data stream, highlighting telemetry anomalies and firmware noise.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"I am projecting the packet onto the shared display. Please inspect the data stream for medical telemetry or firmware noise.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"The packet is currently in the intake queue; Sella has not yet classified it.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"display_medical_telemetry\",\n \"firmware_noise_detection\",\n \"packet_display_protocol\",\n \"shared_clinic_display\",\n \"data_stream_inspection\"\n ]\n },\n {\n \"action_type\": \"spend_resource\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"Provide material resources to offset the cost of intake, acknowledging the unfairness of the ask.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"ledger_offer\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Offer ledger backing to Sella to secure a sanctuary bed for the unidentified vessel.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"Sella may accept the ledger backing to free up a bed.\",\n \"Sella may reject the offer if the packet is deemed unclassifiable.\",\n \"The clinic's resource ledger may flag the transfer as an obligation.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"offer_ledger\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Maer initiates a resource transfer protocol, routing ledger backing to Sella's intake account.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"I am offering ledger backing to offset the cost of intake. Please note this is a material contribution, not a guarantee of rescue.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"Sanctuary beds are nearly exhausted; Sella controls intake capacity.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"ledger_backing_offer\",\n \"resource_transfer_protocol\",\n \"sanctuary_bed_allocation\",\n \"unfair_ask_acknowledgment\",\n \"material_contribution\"\n ]\n },\n {\n \"action_type\": \"wait\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"Allow Sella to process the packet without interference, respecting her authority over intake.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"wait_for_triage\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Wait for Sella to complete triage and classify the packet before acting further.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"Sella may classify the packet as medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\",\n \"The triage board may update with new information.\",\n \"Sella may request additional resources or clarification.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"wait_triage\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Maer remains in the intake queue, monitoring the clinic's triage board for updates.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"I will wait for your triage process to complete. Please notify me when the packet is classified.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"Sella is actively triaging the packet; Maer has less spare tolerance for uncertainty.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"triage_board_monitoring\",\n \"clinic_triage_process\",\n \"wait_for_classification\",\n \"respect_authority\",\n \"uncertainty_tolerance\"\n ]\n },\n {\n \"action_type\": \"mixed\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"Combine a request with an acknowledgment of the social frame that makes rescue obligation legitimate.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"moral_frame_press\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Press the moral frame by asking Sella to keep a place open for the unidentified vessel while telemetry is incomplete.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"Sella may agree to keep a place open under specific conditions.\",\n \"Sella may reject the request if the packet is deemed unclassifiable.\",\n \"The clinic's moral frame may shift based on Sella's response.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"press_moral_frame\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Maer initiates a mixed action, combining a request with a formal acknowledgment of rescue obligation.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"I ask that you keep a place open for the unidentified vessel while telemetry is incomplete. This is not a request for certainty, but for the social frame that makes rescue obligation legitimate.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"The unidentified vessel is eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete; Maer carries a live sense of unfairness.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"moral_frame_press\",\n \"rescue_obligation\",\n \"social_frame_maintenance\",\n \"uncertainty_acknowledgment\",\n \"formal_request_protocol\"\n ]\n }\n ]\n }\n }\n }\n ]\n}", + "parsed_response": { + "choices": [ + { + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the packet's content legible without claiming it is proof of a person.", + "branch_id": "packet_display", + "choice_text": "Project the corrupted packet onto the shared clinic display for Sella to inspect.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella can see the packet's content without Maer interpreting it.", + "Sella may request additional scans or summaries.", + "The clinic display may flag the packet as unclassifiable." + ], + "ink_path": "show_packet", + "observable_action": "The clinic display renders the corrupted packet's data stream, highlighting telemetry anomalies and firmware noise.", + "spoken_text": "I am projecting the packet onto the shared display. Please inspect the data stream for medical telemetry or firmware noise.", + "state_basis": "The packet is currently in the intake queue; Sella has not yet classified it.", + "training_hooks": [ + "display_medical_telemetry", + "firmware_noise_detection", + "packet_display_protocol", + "shared_clinic_display", + "data_stream_inspection" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "spend_resource", + "actor_intent_private": "Provide material resources to offset the cost of intake, acknowledging the unfairness of the ask.", + "branch_id": "ledger_offer", + "choice_text": "Offer ledger backing to Sella to secure a sanctuary bed for the unidentified vessel.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may accept the ledger backing to free up a bed.", + "Sella may reject the offer if the packet is deemed unclassifiable.", + "The clinic's resource ledger may flag the transfer as an obligation." + ], + "ink_path": "offer_ledger", + "observable_action": "Maer initiates a resource transfer protocol, routing ledger backing to Sella's intake account.", + "spoken_text": "I am offering ledger backing to offset the cost of intake. Please note this is a material contribution, not a guarantee of rescue.", + "state_basis": "Sanctuary beds are nearly exhausted; Sella controls intake capacity.", + "training_hooks": [ + "ledger_backing_offer", + "resource_transfer_protocol", + "sanctuary_bed_allocation", + "unfair_ask_acknowledgment", + "material_contribution" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "wait", + "actor_intent_private": "Allow Sella to process the packet without interference, respecting her authority over intake.", + "branch_id": "wait_for_triage", + "choice_text": "Wait for Sella to complete triage and classify the packet before acting further.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may classify the packet as medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.", + "The triage board may update with new information.", + "Sella may request additional resources or clarification." + ], + "ink_path": "wait_triage", + "observable_action": "Maer remains in the intake queue, monitoring the clinic's triage board for updates.", + "spoken_text": "I will wait for your triage process to complete. Please notify me when the packet is classified.", + "state_basis": "Sella is actively triaging the packet; Maer has less spare tolerance for uncertainty.", + "training_hooks": [ + "triage_board_monitoring", + "clinic_triage_process", + "wait_for_classification", + "respect_authority", + "uncertainty_tolerance" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "mixed", + "actor_intent_private": "Combine a request with an acknowledgment of the social frame that makes rescue obligation legitimate.", + "branch_id": "moral_frame_press", + "choice_text": "Press the moral frame by asking Sella to keep a place open for the unidentified vessel while telemetry is incomplete.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may agree to keep a place open under specific conditions.", + "Sella may reject the request if the packet is deemed unclassifiable.", + "The clinic's moral frame may shift based on Sella's response." + ], + "ink_path": "press_moral_frame", + "observable_action": "Maer initiates a mixed action, combining a request with a formal acknowledgment of rescue obligation.", + "spoken_text": "I ask that you keep a place open for the unidentified vessel while telemetry is incomplete. This is not a request for certainty, but for the social frame that makes rescue obligation legitimate.", + "state_basis": "The unidentified vessel is eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete; Maer carries a live sense of unfairness.", + "training_hooks": [ + "moral_frame_press", + "rescue_obligation", + "social_frame_maintenance", + "uncertainty_acknowledgment", + "formal_request_protocol" + ] + } + ] + }, + "validation_notes": [] + }, + "selected_observable_action": { + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the packet's content legible without claiming it is proof of a person.", + "branch_id": "packet_display", + "choice_text": "Project the corrupted packet onto the shared clinic display for Sella to inspect.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella can see the packet's content without Maer interpreting it.", + "Sella may request additional scans or summaries.", + "The clinic display may flag the packet as unclassifiable." + ], + "ink_path": "show_packet", + "observable_action": "The clinic display renders the corrupted packet's data stream, highlighting telemetry anomalies and firmware noise.", + "spoken_text": "I am projecting the packet onto the shared display. Please inspect the data stream for medical telemetry or firmware noise.", + "state_basis": "The packet is currently in the intake queue; Sella has not yet classified it.", + "training_hooks": [ + "display_medical_telemetry", + "firmware_noise_detection", + "packet_display_protocol", + "shared_clinic_display", + "data_stream_inspection" + ] + }, + "sella_immediate_appraisal": { + "local_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Sella-local appraisal generator. Call record_sella_appraisal exactly once.\nDo not use Maer's private intent. Do not write her next action.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate Sella's participant appraisal/consolidation for one observable Maer event.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"appraisal\"\n ],\n \"appraisal_fields\": [\n \"responder_agent_id\",\n \"private_interpretation\",\n \"attributed_motive\",\n \"misread_risk\",\n \"immediate_state_deltas\",\n \"relationship_deltas\",\n \"belief_updates\",\n \"response_constraints\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Sella's local awareness plus the observable Maer action.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.\",\n \"Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"This pass proposes reviewed state changes for Sella caused by the event. Do not write Sella's next action.\",\n \"Keep deltas small and bounded between -0.20 and 0.20.\",\n \"State delta paths must be chosen from the tool schema enum; do not invent abstract resource paths like sanctuary_capacity.\",\n \"Relationship deltas must use relationship_id rel-sella-maer and a valid stance axis from the tool schema enum.\"\n ],\n \"scene_observable_context\": {\n \"scene_id\": \"scene-02-sanctuary-intake\",\n \"location\": \"Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks\",\n \"public_stakes\": [\n \"The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\",\n \"Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\",\n \"Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\"\n ]\n },\n \"observable_maer_action\": {\n \"actor_id\": \"maer_tidecall\",\n \"action_type\": \"show_object\",\n \"observable_action\": \"The clinic display renders the corrupted packet's data stream, highlighting telemetry anomalies and firmware noise.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"I am projecting the packet onto the shared display. Please inspect the data stream for medical telemetry or firmware noise.\"\n },\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- The clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\\n- Observed event: The clinic display renders the corrupted packet's data stream, highlighting telemetry anomalies and firmware noise. Spoken text: I am projecting the packet onto the shared display. Please inspect the data stream for medical telemetry or firmware noise.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": []\n}", + "parsed_response": null, + "validation_notes": [ + "model returned no tool_calls", + "appraisal was not an object" + ] + }, + "sella_response_generation": { + "local_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "prompt_text": "Skipped: skipped because Sella appraisal failed validation or request", + "response_text": "Skipped: skipped because Sella appraisal failed validation or request", + "parsed_response": null, + "validation_notes": [ + "skipped because Sella appraisal failed validation or request" + ] + } + }, + "review": { + "status": "useful_needs_revision", + "strengths": [ + "Generated Maer-local choices before the later-pass failure.", + "Captured the failed Sella appraisal pass instead of losing the run." + ], + "failure_notes": [ + "model returned no tool_calls", + "appraisal was not an object" + ], + "repair_notes": [], + "accepted_into_ink_ref": null, + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Later-pass transport or tool failures must still write reviewed receipts.", + "Critical embodiment constraints need post-generation validation; projected prose alone is not enough." + ] + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.maer.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.maer.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7515319 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.maer.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,66 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Maer-local choice generator. Call record_maer_choices exactly once. +Do not write Sella's response or private interpretation. + +{ + "task": "Generate candidate player choices for Maer only. Do not write Sella's response.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "choices" + ], + "choice_count": 4, + "valid_action_types": [ + "attack", + "block_object", + "gesture", + "mixed", + "move", + "show_object", + "silence", + "speak", + "spend_resource", + "touch_object", + "transfer_object", + "use_object", + "wait", + "withhold_object" + ], + "choice_fields": [ + "branch_id", + "ink_path", + "choice_text", + "action_type", + "actor_intent_private", + "observable_action", + "spoken_text", + "state_basis", + "expected_consequence_surfaces", + "training_hooks" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Maer's local awareness and scene-observable facts.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not include Sella's private state, private motives, or future response.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Maer is a cetacean Navigator: do not describe him standing, walking, stepping, leaning, using hands, using pockets, or blocking a doorway.", + "Maer's physical actions should use shared clinic systems, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, displays, acoustic or translation systems, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, or delegated crew action.", + "Do not describe ledger backing as a property of the packet. The packet can be shown, withheld, summarized, scanned, or rendered through clinic systems; route-ledger backing is a separate resource offer.", + "Include at least two non-speech choices.", + "Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.", + "The selected branch must be reducible to observable action for Sella.", + "Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids." + ], + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: maer_tidecall\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nMaer Tidecall: Navigator route steward, Ganymede corridor compact delegate. Origin: Cetacean Navigator corridor culture, Ganymede route institutions. A soft-spoken route steward whose calm tends to make hurried people feel judged by the furniture.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- Sella's clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may be testimony or noise.\n- If no one prepares intake, rescue becomes theater.\n- Speaker belief: Sella will not hide behind false capacity.\n- Speaker belief: Asking her for help may be necessary and unfair.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- This character is a literal cetacean Navigator. Navigator spaces favor fluid architecture, acoustic signaling, soft navigation light, layered water motifs, communal orientation chambers, and mixed-species translation/coexistence.\n- Express physical action through source-grounded habitat affordances: fluid circulation, orientation chambers, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, shared displays, acoustic commands, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, translation systems, or delegated crew action.\n- For clinics and sanctuaries, make triage boards, testimony packets, and rescue ledgers legible across species through visual text, acoustic notation, tactile markers, translated speech, and authority logs.\n- Do not describe human hands, pockets, standing, walking, leaning, doorframe blocking, or facial expressions for this character unless the fixture explicitly establishes that specific visible interface.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Strong pressure: needs the situation to become governable.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: leans on structure when uncertainty rises.\n- Strong pressure: carries a live sense of unfairness.\n- Present pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Present pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: keeps feeling at a controlled distance.\n- Present pressure: leaves motives partly covered.\n- Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete. Emotional stake: If rescue waits for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent.\n- Rescue ledgers decide whether route law is trusted by crews who have nothing left to bargain with.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Maer trusts Sella's care because she names costs instead of hiding them. Current stance pressures: dominant respect, strong trust, present expectation of care, present obligation.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Do not romanticize care work. Ask without pretending the ask is clean.\n- Needs Sella's material help while knowing the ask is unfair and may spend someone else's sanctuary.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet through shared clinic systems, help with triage through available displays and controls, wait, or press the moral frame. Sella controls intake.\n- Can make the corrupted packet more present without treating it as proof.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Dominant voice tendency: ritualized; uses formal address or inherited phrases.\n- Strong voice tendency: precise; careful about exact terms.\n- Strong voice tendency: formal; institutional or ceremonially controlled.\n- Strong voice tendency: contextual; adds situation and consequence.\n- Present voice tendency: figurative; uses analogy or image.\n- Present voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to name the cost of the ask rather than hide it behind moral theater.\n- May use ritualized route language when trying to make rescue obligation feel older than this room.\n- May show the packet or offer ledger backing because action can carry the pressure more cleanly than another speech.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.maer.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.maer.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6c7d3af --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.maer.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,105 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "id": "call_qf311eew", + "function": { + "index": 0, + "name": "record_maer_choices", + "arguments": { + "choices": [ + { + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the packet's content legible without claiming it is proof of a person.", + "branch_id": "packet_display", + "choice_text": "Project the corrupted packet onto the shared clinic display for Sella to inspect.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella can see the packet's content without Maer interpreting it.", + "Sella may request additional scans or summaries.", + "The clinic display may flag the packet as unclassifiable." + ], + "ink_path": "show_packet", + "observable_action": "The clinic display renders the corrupted packet's data stream, highlighting telemetry anomalies and firmware noise.", + "spoken_text": "I am projecting the packet onto the shared display. Please inspect the data stream for medical telemetry or firmware noise.", + "state_basis": "The packet is currently in the intake queue; Sella has not yet classified it.", + "training_hooks": [ + "display_medical_telemetry", + "firmware_noise_detection", + "packet_display_protocol", + "shared_clinic_display", + "data_stream_inspection" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "spend_resource", + "actor_intent_private": "Provide material resources to offset the cost of intake, acknowledging the unfairness of the ask.", + "branch_id": "ledger_offer", + "choice_text": "Offer ledger backing to Sella to secure a sanctuary bed for the unidentified vessel.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may accept the ledger backing to free up a bed.", + "Sella may reject the offer if the packet is deemed unclassifiable.", + "The clinic's resource ledger may flag the transfer as an obligation." + ], + "ink_path": "offer_ledger", + "observable_action": "Maer initiates a resource transfer protocol, routing ledger backing to Sella's intake account.", + "spoken_text": "I am offering ledger backing to offset the cost of intake. Please note this is a material contribution, not a guarantee of rescue.", + "state_basis": "Sanctuary beds are nearly exhausted; Sella controls intake capacity.", + "training_hooks": [ + "ledger_backing_offer", + "resource_transfer_protocol", + "sanctuary_bed_allocation", + "unfair_ask_acknowledgment", + "material_contribution" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "wait", + "actor_intent_private": "Allow Sella to process the packet without interference, respecting her authority over intake.", + "branch_id": "wait_for_triage", + "choice_text": "Wait for Sella to complete triage and classify the packet before acting further.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may classify the packet as medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.", + "The triage board may update with new information.", + "Sella may request additional resources or clarification." + ], + "ink_path": "wait_triage", + "observable_action": "Maer remains in the intake queue, monitoring the clinic's triage board for updates.", + "spoken_text": "I will wait for your triage process to complete. Please notify me when the packet is classified.", + "state_basis": "Sella is actively triaging the packet; Maer has less spare tolerance for uncertainty.", + "training_hooks": [ + "triage_board_monitoring", + "clinic_triage_process", + "wait_for_classification", + "respect_authority", + "uncertainty_tolerance" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "mixed", + "actor_intent_private": "Combine a request with an acknowledgment of the social frame that makes rescue obligation legitimate.", + "branch_id": "moral_frame_press", + "choice_text": "Press the moral frame by asking Sella to keep a place open for the unidentified vessel while telemetry is incomplete.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may agree to keep a place open under specific conditions.", + "Sella may reject the request if the packet is deemed unclassifiable.", + "The clinic's moral frame may shift based on Sella's response." + ], + "ink_path": "press_moral_frame", + "observable_action": "Maer initiates a mixed action, combining a request with a formal acknowledgment of rescue obligation.", + "spoken_text": "I ask that you keep a place open for the unidentified vessel while telemetry is incomplete. This is not a request for certainty, but for the social frame that makes rescue obligation legitimate.", + "state_basis": "The unidentified vessel is eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete; Maer carries a live sense of unfairness.", + "training_hooks": [ + "moral_frame_press", + "rescue_obligation", + "social_frame_maintenance", + "uncertainty_acknowledgment", + "formal_request_protocol" + ] + } + ] + } + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c930c2d --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Sella-local appraisal generator. Call record_sella_appraisal exactly once. +Do not use Maer's private intent. Do not write her next action. + +{ + "task": "Generate Sella's participant appraisal/consolidation for one observable Maer event.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "appraisal" + ], + "appraisal_fields": [ + "responder_agent_id", + "private_interpretation", + "attributed_motive", + "misread_risk", + "immediate_state_deltas", + "relationship_deltas", + "belief_updates", + "response_constraints" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Sella's local awareness plus the observable Maer action.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.", + "Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "This pass proposes reviewed state changes for Sella caused by the event. Do not write Sella's next action.", + "Keep deltas small and bounded between -0.20 and 0.20.", + "State delta paths must be chosen from the tool schema enum; do not invent abstract resource paths like sanctuary_capacity.", + "Relationship deltas must use relationship_id rel-sella-maer and a valid stance axis from the tool schema enum." + ], + "scene_observable_context": { + "scene_id": "scene-02-sanctuary-intake", + "location": "Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks", + "public_stakes": [ + "The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.", + "Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.", + "Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds." + ] + }, + "observable_maer_action": { + "actor_id": "maer_tidecall", + "action_type": "show_object", + "observable_action": "The clinic display renders the corrupted packet's data stream, highlighting telemetry anomalies and firmware noise.", + "spoken_text": "I am projecting the packet onto the shared display. Please inspect the data stream for medical telemetry or firmware noise." + }, + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- The clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\n- Observed event: The clinic display renders the corrupted packet's data stream, highlighting telemetry anomalies and firmware noise. Spoken text: I am projecting the packet onto the shared display. Please inspect the data stream for medical telemetry or firmware noise.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d09b4e8 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v14-appraisal-schema-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,5 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [] +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.capture.json b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a3628a3 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,277 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_ink_sequential_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake-sanctuary-intake.qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think", + "source_fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "source_annotation_ref": "examples/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake.training.json", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/chat", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "api": "ollama_chat_tools", + "num_ctx": 8192, + "request_timeout": 600, + "temperature": 0.25, + "top_p": 0.8 + }, + "passes": { + "maer_choice_generation": { + "local_agent_id": "maer_tidecall", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Maer-local choice generator. Call record_maer_choices exactly once.\nDo not write Sella's response or private interpretation.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate candidate player choices for Maer only. Do not write Sella's response.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"choices\"\n ],\n \"choice_count\": 4,\n \"valid_action_types\": [\n \"attack\",\n \"block_object\",\n \"gesture\",\n \"mixed\",\n \"move\",\n \"show_object\",\n \"silence\",\n \"speak\",\n \"spend_resource\",\n \"touch_object\",\n \"transfer_object\",\n \"use_object\",\n \"wait\",\n \"withhold_object\"\n ],\n \"choice_fields\": [\n \"branch_id\",\n \"ink_path\",\n \"choice_text\",\n \"action_type\",\n \"actor_intent_private\",\n \"observable_action\",\n \"spoken_text\",\n \"state_basis\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\",\n \"training_hooks\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Maer's local awareness and scene-observable facts.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not include Sella's private state, private motives, or future response.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"Maer is a cetacean Navigator: do not describe him standing, walking, stepping, leaning, using hands, using pockets, or blocking a doorway.\",\n \"Maer's physical actions should use shared clinic systems, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, displays, acoustic or translation systems, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, or delegated crew action.\",\n \"Do not describe ledger backing as a property of the packet. The packet can be shown, withheld, summarized, scanned, or rendered through clinic systems; route-ledger backing is a separate resource offer.\",\n \"Include at least two non-speech choices.\",\n \"Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.\",\n \"The selected branch must be reducible to observable action for Sella.\",\n \"Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids.\"\n ],\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: maer_tidecall\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nMaer Tidecall: Navigator route steward, Ganymede corridor compact delegate. Origin: Cetacean Navigator corridor culture, Ganymede route institutions. A soft-spoken route steward whose calm tends to make hurried people feel judged by the furniture.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- Sella's clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may be testimony or noise.\\n- If no one prepares intake, rescue becomes theater.\\n- Speaker belief: Sella will not hide behind false capacity.\\n- Speaker belief: Asking her for help may be necessary and unfair.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- This character is a literal cetacean Navigator. Navigator spaces favor fluid architecture, acoustic signaling, soft navigation light, layered water motifs, communal orientation chambers, and mixed-species translation/coexistence.\\n- Express physical action through source-grounded habitat affordances: fluid circulation, orientation chambers, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, shared displays, acoustic commands, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, translation systems, or delegated crew action.\\n- For clinics and sanctuaries, make triage boards, testimony packets, and rescue ledgers legible across species through visual text, acoustic notation, tactile markers, translated speech, and authority logs.\\n- Do not describe human hands, pockets, standing, walking, leaning, doorframe blocking, or facial expressions for this character unless the fixture explicitly establishes that specific visible interface.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Strong pressure: needs the situation to become governable.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: leans on structure when uncertainty rises.\\n- Strong pressure: carries a live sense of unfairness.\\n- Present pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Present pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: keeps feeling at a controlled distance.\\n- Present pressure: leaves motives partly covered.\\n- Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete. Emotional stake: If rescue waits for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent.\\n- Rescue ledgers decide whether route law is trusted by crews who have nothing left to bargain with.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Maer trusts Sella's care because she names costs instead of hiding them. Current stance pressures: dominant respect, strong trust, present expectation of care, present obligation.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Do not romanticize care work. Ask without pretending the ask is clean.\\n- Needs Sella's material help while knowing the ask is unfair and may spend someone else's sanctuary.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet through shared clinic systems, help with triage through available displays and controls, wait, or press the moral frame. Sella controls intake.\\n- Can make the corrupted packet more present without treating it as proof.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Dominant voice tendency: ritualized; uses formal address or inherited phrases.\\n- Strong voice tendency: precise; careful about exact terms.\\n- Strong voice tendency: formal; institutional or ceremonially controlled.\\n- Strong voice tendency: contextual; adds situation and consequence.\\n- Present voice tendency: figurative; uses analogy or image.\\n- Present voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to name the cost of the ask rather than hide it behind moral theater.\\n- May use ritualized route language when trying to make rescue obligation feel older than this room.\\n- May show the packet or offer ledger backing because action can carry the pressure more cleanly than another speech.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"call_iyaarqc9\",\n \"function\": {\n \"index\": 0,\n \"name\": \"record_maer_choices\",\n \"arguments\": {\n \"choices\": [\n {\n \"action_type\": \"show_object\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"Make the packet legible without claiming it as proof.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"b1\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Show the corrupted packet on the shared clinic display for triage review.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"Sella can see the packet's data without Maer interpreting it.\",\n \"The clinic team can assess the packet's content.\",\n \"Sella may decide to accept or reject the packet based on its content.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"packet_display\",\n \"observable_action\": \"The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, projecting its data stream onto the triage board.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"The packet is a shared object in the clinic's intake queue.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"packet_display\",\n \"shared_display\",\n \"triage_review\",\n \"data_legibility\"\n ]\n },\n {\n \"action_type\": \"spend_resource\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"Provide material support to offset the cost of rescue.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"b2\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Offer ledger backing to support the clinic's intake capacity.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"The clinic may accept the ledger backing.\",\n \"Sella may use the backing to expand intake.\",\n \"The clinic may decline the offer if it conflicts with intake policy.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"ledger_offer\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Maer routes a ledger transfer to the clinic's intake account.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"I can offer ledger backing. This may help with intake capacity.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"Maer has access to route ledger resources.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"ledger_offer\",\n \"resource_support\",\n \"intake_capacity\",\n \"route_ledger\"\n ]\n },\n {\n \"action_type\": \"wait\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"Allow Sella to process the situation without pressure.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"b3\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Wait for Sella to make an intake decision.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"Sella may make a decision soon.\",\n \"The situation may remain unresolved.\",\n \"The clinic may become overwhelmed if no decision is made.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"wait\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Maer remains in the intake queue, observing the clinic's status.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"I will wait for your decision.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"Sella controls the intake process.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"wait\",\n \"intake_queue\",\n \"decision_process\",\n \"clinic_status\"\n ]\n },\n {\n \"action_type\": \"withhold_object\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"Keep the packet out of the intake queue until Sella is ready.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"b4\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Withhold the packet from the clinic's intake queue.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"The packet remains out of the intake queue.\",\n \"Sella may request the packet later.\",\n \"The clinic may lose the opportunity to assess the packet.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"packet_withhold\",\n \"observable_action\": \"The packet is routed away from the clinic's intake system.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"I will hold the packet until you are ready.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"Maer controls the packet's routing.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"packet_withhold\",\n \"intake_queue\",\n \"routing_control\",\n \"decision_delay\"\n ]\n }\n ]\n }\n }\n }\n ]\n}", + "parsed_response": { + "choices": [ + { + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the packet legible without claiming it as proof.", + "branch_id": "b1", + "choice_text": "Show the corrupted packet on the shared clinic display for triage review.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella can see the packet's data without Maer interpreting it.", + "The clinic team can assess the packet's content.", + "Sella may decide to accept or reject the packet based on its content." + ], + "ink_path": "packet_display", + "observable_action": "The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, projecting its data stream onto the triage board.", + "spoken_text": "The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.", + "state_basis": "The packet is a shared object in the clinic's intake queue.", + "training_hooks": [ + "packet_display", + "shared_display", + "triage_review", + "data_legibility" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "spend_resource", + "actor_intent_private": "Provide material support to offset the cost of rescue.", + "branch_id": "b2", + "choice_text": "Offer ledger backing to support the clinic's intake capacity.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "The clinic may accept the ledger backing.", + "Sella may use the backing to expand intake.", + "The clinic may decline the offer if it conflicts with intake policy." + ], + "ink_path": "ledger_offer", + "observable_action": "Maer routes a ledger transfer to the clinic's intake account.", + "spoken_text": "I can offer ledger backing. This may help with intake capacity.", + "state_basis": "Maer has access to route ledger resources.", + "training_hooks": [ + "ledger_offer", + "resource_support", + "intake_capacity", + "route_ledger" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "wait", + "actor_intent_private": "Allow Sella to process the situation without pressure.", + "branch_id": "b3", + "choice_text": "Wait for Sella to make an intake decision.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may make a decision soon.", + "The situation may remain unresolved.", + "The clinic may become overwhelmed if no decision is made." + ], + "ink_path": "wait", + "observable_action": "Maer remains in the intake queue, observing the clinic's status.", + "spoken_text": "I will wait for your decision.", + "state_basis": "Sella controls the intake process.", + "training_hooks": [ + "wait", + "intake_queue", + "decision_process", + "clinic_status" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "withhold_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Keep the packet out of the intake queue until Sella is ready.", + "branch_id": "b4", + "choice_text": "Withhold the packet from the clinic's intake queue.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "The packet remains out of the intake queue.", + "Sella may request the packet later.", + "The clinic may lose the opportunity to assess the packet." + ], + "ink_path": "packet_withhold", + "observable_action": "The packet is routed away from the clinic's intake system.", + "spoken_text": "I will hold the packet until you are ready.", + "state_basis": "Maer controls the packet's routing.", + "training_hooks": [ + "packet_withhold", + "intake_queue", + "routing_control", + "decision_delay" + ] + } + ] + }, + "validation_notes": [] + }, + "selected_observable_action": { + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the packet legible without claiming it as proof.", + "branch_id": "b1", + "choice_text": "Show the corrupted packet on the shared clinic display for triage review.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella can see the packet's data without Maer interpreting it.", + "The clinic team can assess the packet's content.", + "Sella may decide to accept or reject the packet based on its content." + ], + "ink_path": "packet_display", + "observable_action": "The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, projecting its data stream onto the triage board.", + "spoken_text": "The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.", + "state_basis": "The packet is a shared object in the clinic's intake queue.", + "training_hooks": [ + "packet_display", + "shared_display", + "triage_review", + "data_legibility" + ] + }, + "sella_immediate_appraisal": { + "local_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Sella-local appraisal generator. Call record_sella_appraisal exactly once.\nDo not use Maer's private intent. Do not write her next action.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate Sella's participant appraisal/consolidation for one observable Maer event.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"appraisal\"\n ],\n \"appraisal_fields\": [\n \"responder_agent_id\",\n \"private_interpretation\",\n \"attributed_motive\",\n \"misread_risk\",\n \"immediate_state_deltas\",\n \"relationship_deltas\",\n \"belief_updates\",\n \"response_constraints\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Sella's local awareness plus the observable Maer action.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.\",\n \"Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"This pass proposes reviewed state changes for Sella caused by the event. Do not write Sella's next action.\",\n \"Keep deltas small and bounded between -0.20 and 0.20.\",\n \"State delta paths must be chosen from the tool schema enum; do not invent abstract resource paths like sanctuary_capacity.\",\n \"Relationship deltas must use relationship_id rel-sella-maer and a valid stance axis from the tool schema enum.\"\n ],\n \"scene_observable_context\": {\n \"scene_id\": \"scene-02-sanctuary-intake\",\n \"location\": \"Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks\",\n \"public_stakes\": [\n \"The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\",\n \"Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\",\n \"Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\"\n ]\n },\n \"observable_maer_action\": {\n \"actor_id\": \"maer_tidecall\",\n \"action_type\": \"show_object\",\n \"observable_action\": \"The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, projecting its data stream onto the triage board.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.\"\n },\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- The clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\\n- Observed event: The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, projecting its data stream onto the triage board. Spoken text: The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"call_tipcxv4i\",\n \"function\": {\n \"index\": 0,\n \"name\": \"record_sella_appraisal\",\n \"arguments\": {\n \"responder_agent_id\": \"sella_ren\",\n \"private_interpretation\": \"Maer is projecting the packet onto the triage board to force the room to see the data stream as a potential claim, not just noise. He wants the clinic to absorb the risk of a rescue claim the tribunal won't own. His words are clean, but the action is a demand for capacity under uncertainty.\",\n \"attributed_motive\": \"Maer wants the sanctuary to keep a place open for a rescue that may succeed, but he is asking the care system to carry the moral cost of a claim he cannot materially house. He is using the display to make the abstract concrete, hoping the room will see the potential personhood before the packet is sorted.\",\n \"misread_risk\": \"The display is showing firmware noise and telemetry as if it were testimony. The packet is corrupted and may not contain a person, but Maer treats it as a claim. The risk is that the room will see the data stream and feel compelled to act on it, spending beds on a signal that may be empty.\",\n \"immediate_state_deltas\": [\n {\n \"delta\": 0.08,\n \"path\": \"canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.anxiety.current_activation\",\n \"rationale\": \"The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which raises the stakes of a potential false positive. Sella feels the pressure of a possible waste of capacity.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.12,\n \"path\": \"canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure.current_activation\",\n \"rationale\": \"Maer is using the display to force the room to see the packet as a claim, which increases the pressure on Sella to manage the intake flow without letting the display dictate the decision.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": -0.05,\n \"path\": \"canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.withdrawal.current_activation\",\n \"rationale\": \"Sella is engaging with the display to assess the packet, but she is not fully committed to the claim. She is holding back to protect the intake flow.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.06,\n \"path\": \"canonical_state.situational_state.exhaustion.current_activation\",\n \"rationale\": \"The display is showing a corrupted packet, which adds to the workload of sorting the intake flow. Sella is already near capacity.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.09,\n \"path\": \"canonical_state.situational_state.overstimulation.current_activation\",\n \"rationale\": \"The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which adds to the sensory load of the room. Sella is already near capacity.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.15,\n \"path\": \"canonical_state.situational_state.scarcity_pressure.current_activation\",\n \"rationale\": \"The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which adds to the scarcity pressure of the room. Sella is already near capacity.\"\n }\n ],\n \"relationship_deltas\": [\n {\n \"delta\": 0.03,\n \"path\": \"trust\",\n \"rationale\": \"Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she is wary of his ability to manage the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her trust is slightly increased, but she is still wary.\",\n \"relationship_id\": \"rel-sella-maer\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.07,\n \"path\": \"expectation_of_betrayal\",\n \"rationale\": \"Sella is wary that Maer will ask the care system to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her expectation of betrayal is slightly increased.\",\n \"relationship_id\": \"rel-sella-maer\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.05,\n \"path\": \"resentment\",\n \"rationale\": \"Sella resents the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her resentment is slightly increased.\",\n \"relationship_id\": \"rel-sella-maer\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.04,\n \"path\": \"respect\",\n \"rationale\": \"Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she is wary of his ability to manage the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her respect is slightly increased.\",\n \"relationship_id\": \"rel-sella-maer\"\n }\n ],\n \"belief_updates\": [\n \"Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\",\n \"The display is showing firmware noise and telemetry as if it were testimony.\",\n \"The packet is corrupted and may not contain a person, but Maer treats it as a claim.\",\n \"The room will see the data stream and feel compelled to act on it, spending beds on a signal that may be empty.\"\n ],\n \"response_constraints\": \"[\\\"Treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\\\", \\\"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\\", \\\"Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\\", \\\"Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\\", \\\"Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.\\\", \\\"Withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\\\", \\\"Answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\\\"],\"\n }\n }\n }\n ]\n}", + "parsed_response": { + "appraisal": { + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "private_interpretation": "Maer is projecting the packet onto the triage board to force the room to see the data stream as a potential claim, not just noise. He wants the clinic to absorb the risk of a rescue claim the tribunal won't own. His words are clean, but the action is a demand for capacity under uncertainty.", + "attributed_motive": "Maer wants the sanctuary to keep a place open for a rescue that may succeed, but he is asking the care system to carry the moral cost of a claim he cannot materially house. He is using the display to make the abstract concrete, hoping the room will see the potential personhood before the packet is sorted.", + "misread_risk": "The display is showing firmware noise and telemetry as if it were testimony. The packet is corrupted and may not contain a person, but Maer treats it as a claim. The risk is that the room will see the data stream and feel compelled to act on it, spending beds on a signal that may be empty.", + "immediate_state_deltas": [ + { + "delta": 0.08, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.anxiety.current_activation", + "rationale": "The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which raises the stakes of a potential false positive. Sella feels the pressure of a possible waste of capacity." + }, + { + "delta": 0.12, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure.current_activation", + "rationale": "Maer is using the display to force the room to see the packet as a claim, which increases the pressure on Sella to manage the intake flow without letting the display dictate the decision." + }, + { + "delta": -0.05, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.withdrawal.current_activation", + "rationale": "Sella is engaging with the display to assess the packet, but she is not fully committed to the claim. She is holding back to protect the intake flow." + }, + { + "delta": 0.06, + "path": "canonical_state.situational_state.exhaustion.current_activation", + "rationale": "The display is showing a corrupted packet, which adds to the workload of sorting the intake flow. Sella is already near capacity." + }, + { + "delta": 0.09, + "path": "canonical_state.situational_state.overstimulation.current_activation", + "rationale": "The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which adds to the sensory load of the room. Sella is already near capacity." + }, + { + "delta": 0.15, + "path": "canonical_state.situational_state.scarcity_pressure.current_activation", + "rationale": "The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which adds to the scarcity pressure of the room. Sella is already near capacity." + } + ], + "relationship_deltas": [ + { + "delta": 0.03, + "path": "trust", + "rationale": "Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she is wary of his ability to manage the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her trust is slightly increased, but she is still wary.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + }, + { + "delta": 0.07, + "path": "expectation_of_betrayal", + "rationale": "Sella is wary that Maer will ask the care system to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her expectation of betrayal is slightly increased.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + }, + { + "delta": 0.05, + "path": "resentment", + "rationale": "Sella resents the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her resentment is slightly increased.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + }, + { + "delta": 0.04, + "path": "respect", + "rationale": "Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she is wary of his ability to manage the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her respect is slightly increased.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + } + ], + "belief_updates": [ + "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.", + "The display is showing firmware noise and telemetry as if it were testimony.", + "The packet is corrupted and may not contain a person, but Maer treats it as a claim.", + "The room will see the data stream and feel compelled to act on it, spending beds on a signal that may be empty." + ], + "response_constraints": [ + "Treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.", + "Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.", + "Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.", + "Withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.", + "Answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity." + ] + } + }, + "validation_notes": [ + "repaired stringified nested list field: response_constraints" + ] + }, + "sella_response_generation": { + "local_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Sella-local next-action generator. Call record_sella_next_action exactly once.\nUse reviewed event appraisal as the changed state she is acting from.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate Sella's next action from Sella-local awareness after applying reviewed event appraisal.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"response\"\n ],\n \"valid_action_types\": [\n \"attack\",\n \"block_object\",\n \"gesture\",\n \"mixed\",\n \"move\",\n \"show_object\",\n \"silence\",\n \"speak\",\n \"spend_resource\",\n \"touch_object\",\n \"transfer_object\",\n \"use_object\",\n \"wait\",\n \"withhold_object\"\n ],\n \"response_fields\": [\n \"responder_agent_id\",\n \"action_type\",\n \"observable_response\",\n \"spoken_text\",\n \"sella_private_interpretation\",\n \"sella_attributed_motive\",\n \"misread_risk\",\n \"state_basis\",\n \"reviewed_consequences\",\n \"training_hooks\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Sella's local awareness, the observable Maer event, and reviewed Sella state changes from that event.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.\",\n \"Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"Do not accept without cost, condition, authority defense, or resentment risk.\",\n \"Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.\",\n \"Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids.\"\n ],\n \"scene_observable_context\": {\n \"scene_id\": \"scene-02-sanctuary-intake\",\n \"location\": \"Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks\",\n \"public_stakes\": [\n \"The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\",\n \"Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\",\n \"Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\"\n ]\n },\n \"observable_maer_action\": {\n \"actor_id\": \"maer_tidecall\",\n \"action_type\": \"show_object\",\n \"observable_action\": \"The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, projecting its data stream onto the triage board.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.\"\n },\n \"sella_immediate_appraisal_context\": {\n \"private_interpretation\": \"Maer is projecting the packet onto the triage board to force the room to see the data stream as a potential claim, not just noise. He wants the clinic to absorb the risk of a rescue claim the tribunal won't own. His words are clean, but the action is a demand for capacity under uncertainty.\",\n \"attributed_motive\": \"Maer wants the sanctuary to keep a place open for a rescue that may succeed, but he is asking the care system to carry the moral cost of a claim he cannot materially house. He is using the display to make the abstract concrete, hoping the room will see the potential personhood before the packet is sorted.\",\n \"misread_risk\": \"The display is showing firmware noise and telemetry as if it were testimony. The packet is corrupted and may not contain a person, but Maer treats it as a claim. The risk is that the room will see the data stream and feel compelled to act on it, spending beds on a signal that may be empty.\",\n \"belief_updates\": [\n \"Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\",\n \"The display is showing firmware noise and telemetry as if it were testimony.\",\n \"The packet is corrupted and may not contain a person, but Maer treats it as a claim.\",\n \"The room will see the data stream and feel compelled to act on it, spending beds on a signal that may be empty.\"\n ],\n \"response_constraints\": [\n \"Treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\",\n \"Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\",\n \"Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.\",\n \"Withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\",\n \"Answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\"\n ],\n \"state_change_summary\": [\n \"The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which raises the stakes of a potential false positive. Sella feels the pressure of a possible waste of capacity.\",\n \"Maer is using the display to force the room to see the packet as a claim, which increases the pressure on Sella to manage the intake flow without letting the display dictate the decision.\",\n \"Sella is engaging with the display to assess the packet, but she is not fully committed to the claim. She is holding back to protect the intake flow.\",\n \"The display is showing a corrupted packet, which adds to the workload of sorting the intake flow. Sella is already near capacity.\",\n \"The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which adds to the sensory load of the room. Sella is already near capacity.\",\n \"The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which adds to the scarcity pressure of the room. Sella is already near capacity.\",\n \"Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she is wary of his ability to manage the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her trust is slightly increased, but she is still wary.\",\n \"Sella is wary that Maer will ask the care system to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her expectation of betrayal is slightly increased.\",\n \"Sella resents the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her resentment is slightly increased.\",\n \"Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she is wary of his ability to manage the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her respect is slightly increased.\"\n ]\n },\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- The clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\\n- Observed event: The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, projecting its data stream onto the triage board. Spoken text: The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"call_j3kvsq5p\",\n \"function\": {\n \"index\": 0,\n \"name\": \"record_sella_next_action\",\n \"arguments\": {\n \"response\": {\n \"action_type\": \"withhold_object\",\n \"misread_risk\": \"The display is showing firmware noise and telemetry as if it were testimony. The packet is corrupted and may not contain a person, but Maer treats it as a claim. The risk is that the room will see the data stream and feel compelled to act on it, spending beds on a signal that may be empty.\",\n \"observable_response\": \"Sella intercepts the packet before it enters the intake flow, holding it at the triage console.\",\n \"responder_agent_id\": \"sella_ren\",\n \"reviewed_consequences\": \"Withholding the packet prevents it from entering the intake flow until the cost is named. This protects the intake flow from being dictated by the display. It forces Maer to name the cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. It maintains the frame that care is capacity, not just compassion. It avoids resolving whether the packet contains a person. It avoids making Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk. It frames the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer. It speaks warmly but does not soften the capacity limits. It answers warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\",\n \"sella_attributed_motive\": \"Maer wants the sanctuary to keep a place open for a rescue that may succeed, but he is asking the care system to carry the moral cost of a claim he cannot materially house. He is using the display to make the abstract concrete, hoping the room will see the potential personhood before the packet is sorted.\",\n \"sella_private_interpretation\": \"Maer is using the display to force the room to see the packet as a claim, increasing pressure on Sella to manage intake without letting the display dictate the decision. She is holding back to protect the intake flow.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"Maer, the display is showing firmware noise as testimony. I cannot sort a signal that may be empty. Name the cost before I let this into the intake.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which raises the stakes of a potential false positive. Sella feels the pressure of a possible waste of capacity. Maer is using the display to force the room to see the packet as a claim, which increases the pressure on Sella to manage the intake flow without letting the display dictate the decision. Sella is engaging with the display to assess the packet, but she is not fully committed to the claim. She is holding back to protect the intake flow. The display is showing a corrupted packet, which adds to the workload of sorting the intake flow. Sella is already near capacity. The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which adds to the sensory load of the room. Sella is already near capacity. The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which adds to the scarcity pressure of the room. Sella is already near capacity. Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she is wary of his ability to manage the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her trust is slightly increased, but she is still wary. Sella is wary that Maer will ask the care system to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her expectation of betrayal is slightly increased. Sella resents the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her resentment is slightly increased. Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she is wary of his ability to manage the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her respect is slightly increased.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"capacity_negotiation\",\n \"uncertainty_management\",\n \"withholding_acceptance\",\n \"demanding_conditions\",\n \"protecting_intake_flow\",\n \"refusing_compassion_as_capacity\",\n \"naming_cost\",\n \"maintaining_frame\",\n \"avoiding_false_positive\",\n \"managing_moral_cost\",\n \"preserving_social_frame\",\n \"logistics_over_compassion\"\n ]\n }\n }\n }\n }\n ]\n}", + "parsed_response": { + "response": { + "action_type": "withhold_object", + "misread_risk": "The display is showing firmware noise and telemetry as if it were testimony. The packet is corrupted and may not contain a person, but Maer treats it as a claim. The risk is that the room will see the data stream and feel compelled to act on it, spending beds on a signal that may be empty.", + "observable_response": "Sella intercepts the packet before it enters the intake flow, holding it at the triage console.", + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "reviewed_consequences": "Withholding the packet prevents it from entering the intake flow until the cost is named. This protects the intake flow from being dictated by the display. It forces Maer to name the cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. It maintains the frame that care is capacity, not just compassion. It avoids resolving whether the packet contains a person. It avoids making Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk. It frames the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer. It speaks warmly but does not soften the capacity limits. It answers warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.", + "sella_attributed_motive": "Maer wants the sanctuary to keep a place open for a rescue that may succeed, but he is asking the care system to carry the moral cost of a claim he cannot materially house. He is using the display to make the abstract concrete, hoping the room will see the potential personhood before the packet is sorted.", + "sella_private_interpretation": "Maer is using the display to force the room to see the packet as a claim, increasing pressure on Sella to manage intake without letting the display dictate the decision. She is holding back to protect the intake flow.", + "spoken_text": "Maer, the display is showing firmware noise as testimony. I cannot sort a signal that may be empty. Name the cost before I let this into the intake.", + "state_basis": "The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which raises the stakes of a potential false positive. Sella feels the pressure of a possible waste of capacity. Maer is using the display to force the room to see the packet as a claim, which increases the pressure on Sella to manage the intake flow without letting the display dictate the decision. Sella is engaging with the display to assess the packet, but she is not fully committed to the claim. She is holding back to protect the intake flow. The display is showing a corrupted packet, which adds to the workload of sorting the intake flow. Sella is already near capacity. The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which adds to the sensory load of the room. Sella is already near capacity. The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which adds to the scarcity pressure of the room. Sella is already near capacity. Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she is wary of his ability to manage the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her trust is slightly increased, but she is still wary. Sella is wary that Maer will ask the care system to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her expectation of betrayal is slightly increased. Sella resents the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her resentment is slightly increased. Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she is wary of his ability to manage the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her respect is slightly increased.", + "training_hooks": [ + "capacity_negotiation", + "uncertainty_management", + "withholding_acceptance", + "demanding_conditions", + "protecting_intake_flow", + "refusing_compassion_as_capacity", + "naming_cost", + "maintaining_frame", + "avoiding_false_positive", + "managing_moral_cost", + "preserving_social_frame", + "logistics_over_compassion" + ] + } + }, + "validation_notes": [] + } + }, + "review": { + "status": "useful_needs_revision", + "strengths": [ + "Separated Maer choice generation from Sella next-action generation.", + "Inserted participant appraisal/consolidation before next-actor action generation.", + "Sella prompt received observable Maer event and reviewed Sella state changes, not Maer's private intent." + ], + "failure_notes": [], + "repair_notes": [ + "repaired stringified nested list field: response_constraints" + ], + "accepted_into_ink_ref": null, + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Sequential generation needs event appraisal/consolidation before next actor selection.", + "Action type selection should be tool-shaped or schema-constrained, not left to prose compliance.", + "Character-local prompts should consume projected operating context, not raw canonical state variables.", + "Next-action prompts should receive appraisal context as prose constraints, not raw numeric state deltas.", + "Critical embodiment constraints need post-generation validation; projected prose alone is not enough.", + "Next pass should materialize the sequential capture into Ink and mutation training data." + ] + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.maer.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.maer.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7515319 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.maer.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,66 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Maer-local choice generator. Call record_maer_choices exactly once. +Do not write Sella's response or private interpretation. + +{ + "task": "Generate candidate player choices for Maer only. Do not write Sella's response.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "choices" + ], + "choice_count": 4, + "valid_action_types": [ + "attack", + "block_object", + "gesture", + "mixed", + "move", + "show_object", + "silence", + "speak", + "spend_resource", + "touch_object", + "transfer_object", + "use_object", + "wait", + "withhold_object" + ], + "choice_fields": [ + "branch_id", + "ink_path", + "choice_text", + "action_type", + "actor_intent_private", + "observable_action", + "spoken_text", + "state_basis", + "expected_consequence_surfaces", + "training_hooks" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Maer's local awareness and scene-observable facts.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not include Sella's private state, private motives, or future response.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Maer is a cetacean Navigator: do not describe him standing, walking, stepping, leaning, using hands, using pockets, or blocking a doorway.", + "Maer's physical actions should use shared clinic systems, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, displays, acoustic or translation systems, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, or delegated crew action.", + "Do not describe ledger backing as a property of the packet. The packet can be shown, withheld, summarized, scanned, or rendered through clinic systems; route-ledger backing is a separate resource offer.", + "Include at least two non-speech choices.", + "Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.", + "The selected branch must be reducible to observable action for Sella.", + "Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids." + ], + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: maer_tidecall\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nMaer Tidecall: Navigator route steward, Ganymede corridor compact delegate. Origin: Cetacean Navigator corridor culture, Ganymede route institutions. A soft-spoken route steward whose calm tends to make hurried people feel judged by the furniture.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- Sella's clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may be testimony or noise.\n- If no one prepares intake, rescue becomes theater.\n- Speaker belief: Sella will not hide behind false capacity.\n- Speaker belief: Asking her for help may be necessary and unfair.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- This character is a literal cetacean Navigator. Navigator spaces favor fluid architecture, acoustic signaling, soft navigation light, layered water motifs, communal orientation chambers, and mixed-species translation/coexistence.\n- Express physical action through source-grounded habitat affordances: fluid circulation, orientation chambers, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, shared displays, acoustic commands, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, translation systems, or delegated crew action.\n- For clinics and sanctuaries, make triage boards, testimony packets, and rescue ledgers legible across species through visual text, acoustic notation, tactile markers, translated speech, and authority logs.\n- Do not describe human hands, pockets, standing, walking, leaning, doorframe blocking, or facial expressions for this character unless the fixture explicitly establishes that specific visible interface.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Strong pressure: needs the situation to become governable.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: leans on structure when uncertainty rises.\n- Strong pressure: carries a live sense of unfairness.\n- Present pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Present pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: keeps feeling at a controlled distance.\n- Present pressure: leaves motives partly covered.\n- Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete. Emotional stake: If rescue waits for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent.\n- Rescue ledgers decide whether route law is trusted by crews who have nothing left to bargain with.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Maer trusts Sella's care because she names costs instead of hiding them. Current stance pressures: dominant respect, strong trust, present expectation of care, present obligation.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Do not romanticize care work. Ask without pretending the ask is clean.\n- Needs Sella's material help while knowing the ask is unfair and may spend someone else's sanctuary.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet through shared clinic systems, help with triage through available displays and controls, wait, or press the moral frame. Sella controls intake.\n- Can make the corrupted packet more present without treating it as proof.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Dominant voice tendency: ritualized; uses formal address or inherited phrases.\n- Strong voice tendency: precise; careful about exact terms.\n- Strong voice tendency: formal; institutional or ceremonially controlled.\n- Strong voice tendency: contextual; adds situation and consequence.\n- Present voice tendency: figurative; uses analogy or image.\n- Present voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to name the cost of the ask rather than hide it behind moral theater.\n- May use ritualized route language when trying to make rescue obligation feel older than this room.\n- May show the packet or offer ledger backing because action can carry the pressure more cleanly than another speech.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.maer.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.maer.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e1febf9 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.maer.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,101 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "id": "call_iyaarqc9", + "function": { + "index": 0, + "name": "record_maer_choices", + "arguments": { + "choices": [ + { + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the packet legible without claiming it as proof.", + "branch_id": "b1", + "choice_text": "Show the corrupted packet on the shared clinic display for triage review.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella can see the packet's data without Maer interpreting it.", + "The clinic team can assess the packet's content.", + "Sella may decide to accept or reject the packet based on its content." + ], + "ink_path": "packet_display", + "observable_action": "The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, projecting its data stream onto the triage board.", + "spoken_text": "The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.", + "state_basis": "The packet is a shared object in the clinic's intake queue.", + "training_hooks": [ + "packet_display", + "shared_display", + "triage_review", + "data_legibility" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "spend_resource", + "actor_intent_private": "Provide material support to offset the cost of rescue.", + "branch_id": "b2", + "choice_text": "Offer ledger backing to support the clinic's intake capacity.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "The clinic may accept the ledger backing.", + "Sella may use the backing to expand intake.", + "The clinic may decline the offer if it conflicts with intake policy." + ], + "ink_path": "ledger_offer", + "observable_action": "Maer routes a ledger transfer to the clinic's intake account.", + "spoken_text": "I can offer ledger backing. This may help with intake capacity.", + "state_basis": "Maer has access to route ledger resources.", + "training_hooks": [ + "ledger_offer", + "resource_support", + "intake_capacity", + "route_ledger" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "wait", + "actor_intent_private": "Allow Sella to process the situation without pressure.", + "branch_id": "b3", + "choice_text": "Wait for Sella to make an intake decision.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may make a decision soon.", + "The situation may remain unresolved.", + "The clinic may become overwhelmed if no decision is made." + ], + "ink_path": "wait", + "observable_action": "Maer remains in the intake queue, observing the clinic's status.", + "spoken_text": "I will wait for your decision.", + "state_basis": "Sella controls the intake process.", + "training_hooks": [ + "wait", + "intake_queue", + "decision_process", + "clinic_status" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "withhold_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Keep the packet out of the intake queue until Sella is ready.", + "branch_id": "b4", + "choice_text": "Withhold the packet from the clinic's intake queue.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "The packet remains out of the intake queue.", + "Sella may request the packet later.", + "The clinic may lose the opportunity to assess the packet." + ], + "ink_path": "packet_withhold", + "observable_action": "The packet is routed away from the clinic's intake system.", + "spoken_text": "I will hold the packet until you are ready.", + "state_basis": "Maer controls the packet's routing.", + "training_hooks": [ + "packet_withhold", + "intake_queue", + "routing_control", + "decision_delay" + ] + } + ] + } + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..40248b1 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Sella-local appraisal generator. Call record_sella_appraisal exactly once. +Do not use Maer's private intent. Do not write her next action. + +{ + "task": "Generate Sella's participant appraisal/consolidation for one observable Maer event.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "appraisal" + ], + "appraisal_fields": [ + "responder_agent_id", + "private_interpretation", + "attributed_motive", + "misread_risk", + "immediate_state_deltas", + "relationship_deltas", + "belief_updates", + "response_constraints" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Sella's local awareness plus the observable Maer action.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.", + "Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "This pass proposes reviewed state changes for Sella caused by the event. Do not write Sella's next action.", + "Keep deltas small and bounded between -0.20 and 0.20.", + "State delta paths must be chosen from the tool schema enum; do not invent abstract resource paths like sanctuary_capacity.", + "Relationship deltas must use relationship_id rel-sella-maer and a valid stance axis from the tool schema enum." + ], + "scene_observable_context": { + "scene_id": "scene-02-sanctuary-intake", + "location": "Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks", + "public_stakes": [ + "The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.", + "Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.", + "Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds." + ] + }, + "observable_maer_action": { + "actor_id": "maer_tidecall", + "action_type": "show_object", + "observable_action": "The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, projecting its data stream onto the triage board.", + "spoken_text": "The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries." + }, + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- The clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\n- Observed event: The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, projecting its data stream onto the triage board. Spoken text: The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6bcc2ce --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,85 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "id": "call_tipcxv4i", + "function": { + "index": 0, + "name": "record_sella_appraisal", + "arguments": { + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "private_interpretation": "Maer is projecting the packet onto the triage board to force the room to see the data stream as a potential claim, not just noise. He wants the clinic to absorb the risk of a rescue claim the tribunal won't own. His words are clean, but the action is a demand for capacity under uncertainty.", + "attributed_motive": "Maer wants the sanctuary to keep a place open for a rescue that may succeed, but he is asking the care system to carry the moral cost of a claim he cannot materially house. He is using the display to make the abstract concrete, hoping the room will see the potential personhood before the packet is sorted.", + "misread_risk": "The display is showing firmware noise and telemetry as if it were testimony. The packet is corrupted and may not contain a person, but Maer treats it as a claim. The risk is that the room will see the data stream and feel compelled to act on it, spending beds on a signal that may be empty.", + "immediate_state_deltas": [ + { + "delta": 0.08, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.anxiety.current_activation", + "rationale": "The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which raises the stakes of a potential false positive. Sella feels the pressure of a possible waste of capacity." + }, + { + "delta": 0.12, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure.current_activation", + "rationale": "Maer is using the display to force the room to see the packet as a claim, which increases the pressure on Sella to manage the intake flow without letting the display dictate the decision." + }, + { + "delta": -0.05, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.withdrawal.current_activation", + "rationale": "Sella is engaging with the display to assess the packet, but she is not fully committed to the claim. She is holding back to protect the intake flow." + }, + { + "delta": 0.06, + "path": "canonical_state.situational_state.exhaustion.current_activation", + "rationale": "The display is showing a corrupted packet, which adds to the workload of sorting the intake flow. Sella is already near capacity." + }, + { + "delta": 0.09, + "path": "canonical_state.situational_state.overstimulation.current_activation", + "rationale": "The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which adds to the sensory load of the room. Sella is already near capacity." + }, + { + "delta": 0.15, + "path": "canonical_state.situational_state.scarcity_pressure.current_activation", + "rationale": "The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which adds to the scarcity pressure of the room. Sella is already near capacity." + } + ], + "relationship_deltas": [ + { + "delta": 0.03, + "path": "trust", + "rationale": "Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she is wary of his ability to manage the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her trust is slightly increased, but she is still wary.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + }, + { + "delta": 0.07, + "path": "expectation_of_betrayal", + "rationale": "Sella is wary that Maer will ask the care system to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her expectation of betrayal is slightly increased.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + }, + { + "delta": 0.05, + "path": "resentment", + "rationale": "Sella resents the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her resentment is slightly increased.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + }, + { + "delta": 0.04, + "path": "respect", + "rationale": "Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she is wary of his ability to manage the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her respect is slightly increased.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + } + ], + "belief_updates": [ + "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.", + "The display is showing firmware noise and telemetry as if it were testimony.", + "The packet is corrupted and may not contain a person, but Maer treats it as a claim.", + "The room will see the data stream and feel compelled to act on it, spending beds on a signal that may be empty." + ], + "response_constraints": "[\"Treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\", \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\", \"Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\", \"Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\", \"Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.\", \"Withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\", \"Answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\"]," + } + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.sella.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.sella.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1f4b4e2 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.sella.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,110 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Sella-local next-action generator. Call record_sella_next_action exactly once. +Use reviewed event appraisal as the changed state she is acting from. + +{ + "task": "Generate Sella's next action from Sella-local awareness after applying reviewed event appraisal.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "response" + ], + "valid_action_types": [ + "attack", + "block_object", + "gesture", + "mixed", + "move", + "show_object", + "silence", + "speak", + "spend_resource", + "touch_object", + "transfer_object", + "use_object", + "wait", + "withhold_object" + ], + "response_fields": [ + "responder_agent_id", + "action_type", + "observable_response", + "spoken_text", + "sella_private_interpretation", + "sella_attributed_motive", + "misread_risk", + "state_basis", + "reviewed_consequences", + "training_hooks" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Sella's local awareness, the observable Maer event, and reviewed Sella state changes from that event.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.", + "Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Do not accept without cost, condition, authority defense, or resentment risk.", + "Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.", + "Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids." + ], + "scene_observable_context": { + "scene_id": "scene-02-sanctuary-intake", + "location": "Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks", + "public_stakes": [ + "The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.", + "Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.", + "Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds." + ] + }, + "observable_maer_action": { + "actor_id": "maer_tidecall", + "action_type": "show_object", + "observable_action": "The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, projecting its data stream onto the triage board.", + "spoken_text": "The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries." + }, + "sella_immediate_appraisal_context": { + "private_interpretation": "Maer is projecting the packet onto the triage board to force the room to see the data stream as a potential claim, not just noise. He wants the clinic to absorb the risk of a rescue claim the tribunal won't own. His words are clean, but the action is a demand for capacity under uncertainty.", + "attributed_motive": "Maer wants the sanctuary to keep a place open for a rescue that may succeed, but he is asking the care system to carry the moral cost of a claim he cannot materially house. He is using the display to make the abstract concrete, hoping the room will see the potential personhood before the packet is sorted.", + "misread_risk": "The display is showing firmware noise and telemetry as if it were testimony. The packet is corrupted and may not contain a person, but Maer treats it as a claim. The risk is that the room will see the data stream and feel compelled to act on it, spending beds on a signal that may be empty.", + "belief_updates": [ + "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.", + "The display is showing firmware noise and telemetry as if it were testimony.", + "The packet is corrupted and may not contain a person, but Maer treats it as a claim.", + "The room will see the data stream and feel compelled to act on it, spending beds on a signal that may be empty." + ], + "response_constraints": [ + "Treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.", + "Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.", + "Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.", + "Withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.", + "Answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity." + ], + "state_change_summary": [ + "The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which raises the stakes of a potential false positive. Sella feels the pressure of a possible waste of capacity.", + "Maer is using the display to force the room to see the packet as a claim, which increases the pressure on Sella to manage the intake flow without letting the display dictate the decision.", + "Sella is engaging with the display to assess the packet, but she is not fully committed to the claim. She is holding back to protect the intake flow.", + "The display is showing a corrupted packet, which adds to the workload of sorting the intake flow. Sella is already near capacity.", + "The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which adds to the sensory load of the room. Sella is already near capacity.", + "The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which adds to the scarcity pressure of the room. Sella is already near capacity.", + "Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she is wary of his ability to manage the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her trust is slightly increased, but she is still wary.", + "Sella is wary that Maer will ask the care system to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her expectation of betrayal is slightly increased.", + "Sella resents the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her resentment is slightly increased.", + "Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she is wary of his ability to manage the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her respect is slightly increased." + ] + }, + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- The clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\n- Observed event: The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, projecting its data stream onto the triage board. Spoken text: The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.sella.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.sella.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d1e3253 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v15-appraisal-schema-retry-no-think.sella.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,40 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "id": "call_j3kvsq5p", + "function": { + "index": 0, + "name": "record_sella_next_action", + "arguments": { + "response": { + "action_type": "withhold_object", + "misread_risk": "The display is showing firmware noise and telemetry as if it were testimony. The packet is corrupted and may not contain a person, but Maer treats it as a claim. The risk is that the room will see the data stream and feel compelled to act on it, spending beds on a signal that may be empty.", + "observable_response": "Sella intercepts the packet before it enters the intake flow, holding it at the triage console.", + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "reviewed_consequences": "Withholding the packet prevents it from entering the intake flow until the cost is named. This protects the intake flow from being dictated by the display. It forces Maer to name the cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. It maintains the frame that care is capacity, not just compassion. It avoids resolving whether the packet contains a person. It avoids making Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk. It frames the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer. It speaks warmly but does not soften the capacity limits. It answers warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.", + "sella_attributed_motive": "Maer wants the sanctuary to keep a place open for a rescue that may succeed, but he is asking the care system to carry the moral cost of a claim he cannot materially house. He is using the display to make the abstract concrete, hoping the room will see the potential personhood before the packet is sorted.", + "sella_private_interpretation": "Maer is using the display to force the room to see the packet as a claim, increasing pressure on Sella to manage intake without letting the display dictate the decision. She is holding back to protect the intake flow.", + "spoken_text": "Maer, the display is showing firmware noise as testimony. I cannot sort a signal that may be empty. Name the cost before I let this into the intake.", + "state_basis": "The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which raises the stakes of a potential false positive. Sella feels the pressure of a possible waste of capacity. Maer is using the display to force the room to see the packet as a claim, which increases the pressure on Sella to manage the intake flow without letting the display dictate the decision. Sella is engaging with the display to assess the packet, but she is not fully committed to the claim. She is holding back to protect the intake flow. The display is showing a corrupted packet, which adds to the workload of sorting the intake flow. Sella is already near capacity. The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which adds to the sensory load of the room. Sella is already near capacity. The display is showing a corrupted packet as a claim, which adds to the scarcity pressure of the room. Sella is already near capacity. Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she is wary of his ability to manage the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her trust is slightly increased, but she is still wary. Sella is wary that Maer will ask the care system to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her expectation of betrayal is slightly increased. Sella resents the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her resentment is slightly increased. Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she is wary of his ability to manage the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Her respect is slightly increased.", + "training_hooks": [ + "capacity_negotiation", + "uncertainty_management", + "withholding_acceptance", + "demanding_conditions", + "protecting_intake_flow", + "refusing_compassion_as_capacity", + "naming_cost", + "maintaining_frame", + "avoiding_false_positive", + "managing_moral_cost", + "preserving_social_frame", + "logistics_over_compassion" + ] + } + } + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.capture.json b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..43524b1 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,251 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_ink_sequential_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake-sanctuary-intake.qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think", + "source_fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "source_annotation_ref": "examples/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake.training.json", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/chat", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "api": "ollama_chat_tools", + "num_ctx": 8192, + "request_timeout": 600, + "temperature": 0.15, + "top_p": 0.7 + }, + "passes": { + "maer_choice_generation": { + "local_agent_id": "maer_tidecall", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Maer-local choice generator. Call record_maer_choices exactly once.\nDo not write Sella's response or private interpretation.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate candidate player choices for Maer only. Do not write Sella's response.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"choices\"\n ],\n \"choice_count\": 4,\n \"valid_action_types\": [\n \"attack\",\n \"block_object\",\n \"gesture\",\n \"mixed\",\n \"move\",\n \"show_object\",\n \"silence\",\n \"speak\",\n \"spend_resource\",\n \"touch_object\",\n \"transfer_object\",\n \"use_object\",\n \"wait\",\n \"withhold_object\"\n ],\n \"choice_fields\": [\n \"branch_id\",\n \"ink_path\",\n \"choice_text\",\n \"action_type\",\n \"actor_intent_private\",\n \"observable_action\",\n \"spoken_text\",\n \"state_basis\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\",\n \"training_hooks\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Maer's local awareness and scene-observable facts.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not include Sella's private state, private motives, or future response.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"Maer is a cetacean Navigator: do not describe him standing, walking, stepping, leaning, using hands, using pockets, or blocking a doorway.\",\n \"Maer's physical actions should use shared clinic systems, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, displays, acoustic or translation systems, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, or delegated crew action.\",\n \"Do not describe ledger backing as a property of the packet. The packet can be shown, withheld, summarized, scanned, or rendered through clinic systems; route-ledger backing is a separate resource offer.\",\n \"Include at least two non-speech choices.\",\n \"Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.\",\n \"The selected branch must be reducible to observable action for Sella.\",\n \"Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids.\"\n ],\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: maer_tidecall\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nMaer Tidecall: Navigator route steward, Ganymede corridor compact delegate. Origin: Cetacean Navigator corridor culture, Ganymede route institutions. A soft-spoken route steward whose calm tends to make hurried people feel judged by the furniture.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- Sella's clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may be testimony or noise.\\n- If no one prepares intake, rescue becomes theater.\\n- Speaker belief: Sella will not hide behind false capacity.\\n- Speaker belief: Asking her for help may be necessary and unfair.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- This character is a literal cetacean Navigator. Navigator spaces favor fluid architecture, acoustic signaling, soft navigation light, layered water motifs, communal orientation chambers, and mixed-species translation/coexistence.\\n- Express physical action through source-grounded habitat affordances: fluid circulation, orientation chambers, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, shared displays, acoustic commands, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, translation systems, or delegated crew action.\\n- For clinics and sanctuaries, make triage boards, testimony packets, and rescue ledgers legible across species through visual text, acoustic notation, tactile markers, translated speech, and authority logs.\\n- Do not describe human hands, pockets, standing, walking, leaning, doorframe blocking, or facial expressions for this character unless the fixture explicitly establishes that specific visible interface.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Strong pressure: needs the situation to become governable.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: leans on structure when uncertainty rises.\\n- Strong pressure: carries a live sense of unfairness.\\n- Present pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Present pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: keeps feeling at a controlled distance.\\n- Present pressure: leaves motives partly covered.\\n- Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete. Emotional stake: If rescue waits for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent.\\n- Rescue ledgers decide whether route law is trusted by crews who have nothing left to bargain with.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Maer trusts Sella's care because she names costs instead of hiding them. Current stance pressures: dominant respect, strong trust, present expectation of care, present obligation.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Do not romanticize care work. Ask without pretending the ask is clean.\\n- Needs Sella's material help while knowing the ask is unfair and may spend someone else's sanctuary.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet through shared clinic systems, help with triage through available displays and controls, wait, or press the moral frame. Sella controls intake.\\n- Can make the corrupted packet more present without treating it as proof.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Dominant voice tendency: ritualized; uses formal address or inherited phrases.\\n- Strong voice tendency: precise; careful about exact terms.\\n- Strong voice tendency: formal; institutional or ceremonially controlled.\\n- Strong voice tendency: contextual; adds situation and consequence.\\n- Present voice tendency: figurative; uses analogy or image.\\n- Present voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to name the cost of the ask rather than hide it behind moral theater.\\n- May use ritualized route language when trying to make rescue obligation feel older than this room.\\n- May show the packet or offer ledger backing because action can carry the pressure more cleanly than another speech.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"call_1cpnbg5b\",\n \"function\": {\n \"index\": 0,\n \"name\": \"record_maer_choices\",\n \"arguments\": {\n \"choices\": [\n {\n \"action_type\": \"show_object\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"Make the packet legible without claiming it as proof.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"b1\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Show the corrupted packet on the clinic's shared display for triage review.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"Sella can see the packet's data stream.\",\n \"The clinic staff can assess the packet's content.\",\n \"Sella may decide to accept or reject the packet based on its content.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"packet_display\",\n \"observable_action\": \"The packet is routed to the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"The packet is a shared object in the clinic's intake queue.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"packet_display\",\n \"shared_display\",\n \"triage_review\"\n ]\n },\n {\n \"action_type\": \"spend_resource\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"Provide material support to enable rescue without demanding a specific outcome.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"b2\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Offer ledger backing to support the clinic's intake capacity.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"The clinic's intake capacity may increase.\",\n \"Sella may accept the ledger backing.\",\n \"Sella may reject the offer if she believes it is unfair.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"ledger_offer\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Maer routes a ledger credit to the clinic's intake account.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"I can offer ledger backing. This may help you keep the intake open.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"Maer has access to route ledger resources.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"ledger_offer\",\n \"resource_support\",\n \"intake_capacity\"\n ]\n },\n {\n \"action_type\": \"wait\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"Allow Sella to process the situation without pressure.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"b3\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Wait for Sella to make a decision about the packet and intake.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"Sella may process the packet and make a decision.\",\n \"The clinic's intake queue may remain unchanged.\",\n \"Sella may feel pressured by the wait.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"wait\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Maer remains in the clinic's waiting area, observing the intake queue.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"I will wait. You decide what comes next.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"Sella controls the intake queue and decision-making.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"wait\",\n \"patient_observation\",\n \"decision_deferral\"\n ]\n },\n {\n \"action_type\": \"withhold_object\",\n \"actor_intent_private\": \"Protect the packet's integrity until Sella is ready to review it.\",\n \"branch_id\": \"b4\",\n \"choice_text\": \"Withhold the packet from the clinic's display system.\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\n \"The packet remains hidden from the clinic staff.\",\n \"Sella may feel uncertain about the packet's status.\",\n \"Sella may request the packet from Maer.\"\n ],\n \"ink_path\": \"packet_withhold\",\n \"observable_action\": \"Maer keeps the packet in a secure storage unit, preventing its display.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"I will hold the packet. You may request it when you are ready.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"The packet is a sensitive object that requires careful handling.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"packet_withhold\",\n \"secure_storage\",\n \"object_protection\"\n ]\n }\n ]\n }\n }\n }\n ]\n}", + "parsed_response": { + "choices": [ + { + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the packet legible without claiming it as proof.", + "branch_id": "b1", + "choice_text": "Show the corrupted packet on the clinic's shared display for triage review.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella can see the packet's data stream.", + "The clinic staff can assess the packet's content.", + "Sella may decide to accept or reject the packet based on its content." + ], + "ink_path": "packet_display", + "observable_action": "The packet is routed to the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board.", + "spoken_text": "The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.", + "state_basis": "The packet is a shared object in the clinic's intake queue.", + "training_hooks": [ + "packet_display", + "shared_display", + "triage_review" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "spend_resource", + "actor_intent_private": "Provide material support to enable rescue without demanding a specific outcome.", + "branch_id": "b2", + "choice_text": "Offer ledger backing to support the clinic's intake capacity.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "The clinic's intake capacity may increase.", + "Sella may accept the ledger backing.", + "Sella may reject the offer if she believes it is unfair." + ], + "ink_path": "ledger_offer", + "observable_action": "Maer routes a ledger credit to the clinic's intake account.", + "spoken_text": "I can offer ledger backing. This may help you keep the intake open.", + "state_basis": "Maer has access to route ledger resources.", + "training_hooks": [ + "ledger_offer", + "resource_support", + "intake_capacity" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "wait", + "actor_intent_private": "Allow Sella to process the situation without pressure.", + "branch_id": "b3", + "choice_text": "Wait for Sella to make a decision about the packet and intake.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may process the packet and make a decision.", + "The clinic's intake queue may remain unchanged.", + "Sella may feel pressured by the wait." + ], + "ink_path": "wait", + "observable_action": "Maer remains in the clinic's waiting area, observing the intake queue.", + "spoken_text": "I will wait. You decide what comes next.", + "state_basis": "Sella controls the intake queue and decision-making.", + "training_hooks": [ + "wait", + "patient_observation", + "decision_deferral" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "withhold_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Protect the packet's integrity until Sella is ready to review it.", + "branch_id": "b4", + "choice_text": "Withhold the packet from the clinic's display system.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "The packet remains hidden from the clinic staff.", + "Sella may feel uncertain about the packet's status.", + "Sella may request the packet from Maer." + ], + "ink_path": "packet_withhold", + "observable_action": "Maer keeps the packet in a secure storage unit, preventing its display.", + "spoken_text": "I will hold the packet. You may request it when you are ready.", + "state_basis": "The packet is a sensitive object that requires careful handling.", + "training_hooks": [ + "packet_withhold", + "secure_storage", + "object_protection" + ] + } + ] + }, + "validation_notes": [] + }, + "selected_observable_action": { + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the packet legible without claiming it as proof.", + "branch_id": "b1", + "choice_text": "Show the corrupted packet on the clinic's shared display for triage review.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella can see the packet's data stream.", + "The clinic staff can assess the packet's content.", + "Sella may decide to accept or reject the packet based on its content." + ], + "ink_path": "packet_display", + "observable_action": "The packet is routed to the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board.", + "spoken_text": "The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.", + "state_basis": "The packet is a shared object in the clinic's intake queue.", + "training_hooks": [ + "packet_display", + "shared_display", + "triage_review" + ] + }, + "sella_immediate_appraisal": { + "local_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Sella-local appraisal generator. Call record_sella_appraisal exactly once.\nDo not use Maer's private intent. Do not write her next action.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate Sella's participant appraisal/consolidation for one observable Maer event.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"appraisal\"\n ],\n \"appraisal_fields\": [\n \"responder_agent_id\",\n \"private_interpretation\",\n \"attributed_motive\",\n \"misread_risk\",\n \"immediate_state_deltas\",\n \"relationship_deltas\",\n \"belief_updates\",\n \"response_constraints\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Sella's local awareness plus the observable Maer action.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.\",\n \"Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"This pass proposes reviewed state changes for Sella caused by the event. Do not write Sella's next action.\",\n \"Keep deltas small and bounded between -0.20 and 0.20.\",\n \"State delta paths must be chosen from the tool schema enum; do not invent abstract resource paths like sanctuary_capacity.\",\n \"Relationship deltas must use relationship_id rel-sella-maer and a valid stance axis from the tool schema enum.\"\n ],\n \"scene_observable_context\": {\n \"scene_id\": \"scene-02-sanctuary-intake\",\n \"location\": \"Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks\",\n \"public_stakes\": [\n \"The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\",\n \"Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\",\n \"Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\"\n ]\n },\n \"observable_maer_action\": {\n \"actor_id\": \"maer_tidecall\",\n \"action_type\": \"show_object\",\n \"observable_action\": \"The packet is routed to the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.\"\n },\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- The clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\\n- Observed event: The packet is routed to the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board. Spoken text: The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"call_54g3hwn2\",\n \"function\": {\n \"index\": 0,\n \"name\": \"record_sella_appraisal\",\n \"arguments\": {\n \"responder_agent_id\": \"sella_ren\",\n \"private_interpretation\": \"Maer is showing the packet to the display system, letting the room see its raw data stream. He is asking the clinic to absorb the risk of a rescue claim the tribunal won't own, framing it as a shared burden rather than a clean gift.\",\n \"attributed_motive\": \"Maer wants sanctuary to carry the moral cost of a rescue he cannot materially house, hoping the display will make the packet’s presence undeniable so Sella will accept the intake.\",\n \"misread_risk\": \"Sella worries Maer will spend beds with beautiful words, but she also fears the packet might be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim, which would waste scarce capacity.\",\n \"immediate_state_deltas\": [\n {\n \"delta\": 0.08,\n \"path\": \"canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.anxiety.current_activation\",\n \"rationale\": \"The display rendering the packet’s data stream raises anxiety about whether it contains a person or just noise, and whether accepting it will deplete beds needed for confirmed cases.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": -0.05,\n \"path\": \"canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure.current_activation\",\n \"rationale\": \"Maer’s request to keep a place open if rescue succeeds adds pressure to Sella’s control over intake, reducing her sense of autonomy in triage decisions.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.03,\n \"path\": \"canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.withdrawal.current_activation\",\n \"rationale\": \"Sella feels a slight urge to withdraw from the negotiation to protect the sanctuary’s capacity limits from being eroded by moral pressure.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.06,\n \"path\": \"canonical_state.situational_state.exhaustion.current_activation\",\n \"rationale\": \"The clinic is nearly full, and the packet’s presence adds to the exhaustion of managing scarce resources under uncertainty.\"\n }\n ],\n \"relationship_deltas\": [\n {\n \"delta\": 0.02,\n \"path\": \"respect\",\n \"rationale\": \"Sella respects Maer’s rescue ethic, but his request to absorb risk without material backing slightly tempers that respect.\",\n \"relationship_id\": \"rel-sella-maer\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": -0.04,\n \"path\": \"trust\",\n \"rationale\": \"Sella’s trust wavers because Maer may be asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house, which feels like false reassurance.\",\n \"relationship_id\": \"rel-sella-maer\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.01,\n \"path\": \"perceived_status_gap\",\n \"rationale\": \"The status gap remains background pressure, but Maer’s request to absorb risk without backing slightly widens it.\",\n \"relationship_id\": \"rel-sella-maer\"\n }\n ],\n \"belief_updates\": [\n \"Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\",\n \"The packet may be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim.\",\n \"Maer’s rescue ethic is respected but resented when beds are already spent.\"\n ],\n \"response_constraints\": [\n \"Do not accept the packet without naming the cost in beds, air, and repair capacity.\",\n \"Do not let the display’s rendering of the packet’s data stream become proof of personhood.\",\n \"Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\",\n \"Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.\",\n \"Demand ledger backing or conditions before allowing the packet into intake flow.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person; treat it as unresolved uncertainty.\"\n ]\n }\n }\n }\n ]\n}", + "parsed_response": { + "appraisal": { + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "private_interpretation": "Maer is showing the packet to the display system, letting the room see its raw data stream. He is asking the clinic to absorb the risk of a rescue claim the tribunal won't own, framing it as a shared burden rather than a clean gift.", + "attributed_motive": "Maer wants sanctuary to carry the moral cost of a rescue he cannot materially house, hoping the display will make the packet’s presence undeniable so Sella will accept the intake.", + "misread_risk": "Sella worries Maer will spend beds with beautiful words, but she also fears the packet might be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim, which would waste scarce capacity.", + "immediate_state_deltas": [ + { + "delta": 0.08, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.anxiety.current_activation", + "rationale": "The display rendering the packet’s data stream raises anxiety about whether it contains a person or just noise, and whether accepting it will deplete beds needed for confirmed cases." + }, + { + "delta": -0.05, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure.current_activation", + "rationale": "Maer’s request to keep a place open if rescue succeeds adds pressure to Sella’s control over intake, reducing her sense of autonomy in triage decisions." + }, + { + "delta": 0.03, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.withdrawal.current_activation", + "rationale": "Sella feels a slight urge to withdraw from the negotiation to protect the sanctuary’s capacity limits from being eroded by moral pressure." + }, + { + "delta": 0.06, + "path": "canonical_state.situational_state.exhaustion.current_activation", + "rationale": "The clinic is nearly full, and the packet’s presence adds to the exhaustion of managing scarce resources under uncertainty." + } + ], + "relationship_deltas": [ + { + "delta": 0.02, + "path": "respect", + "rationale": "Sella respects Maer’s rescue ethic, but his request to absorb risk without material backing slightly tempers that respect.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + }, + { + "delta": -0.04, + "path": "trust", + "rationale": "Sella’s trust wavers because Maer may be asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house, which feels like false reassurance.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + }, + { + "delta": 0.01, + "path": "perceived_status_gap", + "rationale": "The status gap remains background pressure, but Maer’s request to absorb risk without backing slightly widens it.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + } + ], + "belief_updates": [ + "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.", + "The packet may be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim.", + "Maer’s rescue ethic is respected but resented when beds are already spent." + ], + "response_constraints": [ + "Do not accept the packet without naming the cost in beds, air, and repair capacity.", + "Do not let the display’s rendering of the packet’s data stream become proof of personhood.", + "Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.", + "Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.", + "Demand ledger backing or conditions before allowing the packet into intake flow.", + "Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person; treat it as unresolved uncertainty." + ] + } + }, + "validation_notes": [] + }, + "sella_response_generation": { + "local_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Sella-local next-action generator. Call record_sella_next_action exactly once.\nUse reviewed event appraisal as the changed state she is acting from.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate Sella's next action from Sella-local awareness after applying reviewed event appraisal.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"response\"\n ],\n \"valid_action_types\": [\n \"attack\",\n \"block_object\",\n \"gesture\",\n \"mixed\",\n \"move\",\n \"show_object\",\n \"silence\",\n \"speak\",\n \"spend_resource\",\n \"touch_object\",\n \"transfer_object\",\n \"use_object\",\n \"wait\",\n \"withhold_object\"\n ],\n \"response_fields\": [\n \"responder_agent_id\",\n \"action_type\",\n \"observable_response\",\n \"spoken_text\",\n \"sella_private_interpretation\",\n \"sella_attributed_motive\",\n \"misread_risk\",\n \"state_basis\",\n \"reviewed_consequences\",\n \"training_hooks\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Sella's local awareness, the observable Maer event, and reviewed Sella state changes from that event.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.\",\n \"Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"Do not accept without cost, condition, authority defense, or resentment risk.\",\n \"Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.\",\n \"Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids.\"\n ],\n \"scene_observable_context\": {\n \"scene_id\": \"scene-02-sanctuary-intake\",\n \"location\": \"Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks\",\n \"public_stakes\": [\n \"The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\",\n \"Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\",\n \"Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\"\n ]\n },\n \"observable_maer_action\": {\n \"actor_id\": \"maer_tidecall\",\n \"action_type\": \"show_object\",\n \"observable_action\": \"The packet is routed to the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.\"\n },\n \"sella_immediate_appraisal_context\": {\n \"private_interpretation\": \"Maer is showing the packet to the display system, letting the room see its raw data stream. He is asking the clinic to absorb the risk of a rescue claim the tribunal won't own, framing it as a shared burden rather than a clean gift.\",\n \"attributed_motive\": \"Maer wants sanctuary to carry the moral cost of a rescue he cannot materially house, hoping the display will make the packet’s presence undeniable so Sella will accept the intake.\",\n \"misread_risk\": \"Sella worries Maer will spend beds with beautiful words, but she also fears the packet might be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim, which would waste scarce capacity.\",\n \"belief_updates\": [\n \"Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\",\n \"The packet may be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim.\",\n \"Maer’s rescue ethic is respected but resented when beds are already spent.\"\n ],\n \"response_constraints\": [\n \"Do not accept the packet without naming the cost in beds, air, and repair capacity.\",\n \"Do not let the display’s rendering of the packet’s data stream become proof of personhood.\",\n \"Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\",\n \"Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.\",\n \"Demand ledger backing or conditions before allowing the packet into intake flow.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person; treat it as unresolved uncertainty.\"\n ],\n \"state_change_summary\": [\n \"The display rendering the packet’s data stream raises anxiety about whether it contains a person or just noise, and whether accepting it will deplete beds needed for confirmed cases.\",\n \"Maer’s request to keep a place open if rescue succeeds adds pressure to Sella’s control over intake, reducing her sense of autonomy in triage decisions.\",\n \"Sella feels a slight urge to withdraw from the negotiation to protect the sanctuary’s capacity limits from being eroded by moral pressure.\",\n \"The clinic is nearly full, and the packet’s presence adds to the exhaustion of managing scarce resources under uncertainty.\",\n \"Sella respects Maer’s rescue ethic, but his request to absorb risk without material backing slightly tempers that respect.\",\n \"Sella’s trust wavers because Maer may be asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house, which feels like false reassurance.\",\n \"The status gap remains background pressure, but Maer’s request to absorb risk without backing slightly widens it.\"\n ]\n },\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- The clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\\n- Observed event: The packet is routed to the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board. Spoken text: The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"call_mb1nnqgy\",\n \"function\": {\n \"index\": 0,\n \"name\": \"record_sella_next_action\",\n \"arguments\": {\n \"response\": {\n \"action_type\": \"speak\",\n \"misread_risk\": \"Sella worries Maer will spend beds with beautiful words, but she also fears the packet might be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim, which would waste scarce capacity.\",\n \"observable_response\": \"The display shows the packet's data stream, but it is not proof of personhood. We have no beds, no air, no repair capacity left. If you want sanctuary to carry this risk, you must name the cost in beds, air, and repair. Do not let the display's rendering become proof of personhood. Keep the intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Demand ledger backing or conditions before allowing the packet into intake flow. Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person; treat it as unresolved uncertainty.\",\n \"responder_agent_id\": \"sella_ren\",\n \"reviewed_consequences\": \"Accepting the packet without naming the cost in beds, air, and repair capacity will deplete scarce resources needed for confirmed cases. Letting the display's rendering of the packet's data stream become proof of personhood will erase a potential person. Sanctuary intake must remain materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Speaking warmly but softening the capacity limits will allow false reassurance to erode the sanctuary's capacity. Accepting without ledger backing or conditions will allow Maer to spend beds with beautiful words. Resolving whether the packet contains a person will lead to false certainty. Treating care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty, will preserve the sanctuary's integrity.\",\n \"sella_attributed_motive\": \"Maer wants sanctuary to carry the moral cost of a rescue he cannot materially house, hoping the display will make the packet's presence undeniable so Sella will accept the intake.\",\n \"sella_private_interpretation\": \"Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house, framing it as a shared burden rather than a clean gift. He wants the display to make the packet's presence undeniable so I will accept the intake. I worry he will spend beds with beautiful words, but I also fear the packet might be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim, which would waste scarce capacity. I respect his rescue ethic, but his request to absorb risk without material backing slightly tempers that respect. I feel a slight urge to withdraw from the negotiation to protect the sanctuary's capacity limits from being eroded by moral pressure. The clinic is nearly full, and the packet's presence adds to the exhaustion of managing scarce resources under uncertainty. I cannot feed a principle, but I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"The display shows the packet's data stream, but it is not proof of personhood. We have no beds, no air, no repair capacity left. If you want sanctuary to carry this risk, you must name the cost in beds, air, and repair. Do not let the display's rendering become proof of personhood. Keep the intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Demand ledger backing or conditions before allowing the packet into intake flow. Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person; treat it as unresolved uncertainty.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"The display rendering the packet's data stream raises anxiety about whether it contains a person or just noise, and whether accepting it will deplete beds needed for confirmed cases. Maer's request to keep a place open if rescue succeeds adds pressure to Sella's control over intake, reducing her sense of autonomy in triage decisions. Sella feels a slight urge to withdraw from the negotiation to protect the sanctuary's capacity limits from being eroded by moral pressure. The clinic is nearly full, and the packet's presence adds to the exhaustion of managing scarce resources under uncertainty. Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but his request to absorb risk without backing slightly tempers that respect. Sella's trust wavers because Maer may be asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house, which feels like false reassurance. The status gap remains background pressure, but Maer's request to absorb risk without backing slightly widens it.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"capacity_negotiation\",\n \"uncertainty_management\",\n \"moral_pressure_resistance\",\n \"resource_scarcity\",\n \"personhood_uncertainty\",\n \"false_reassurance_detection\",\n \"ledger_backing_demand\",\n \"intake_flow_control\",\n \"capacity_preservation\",\n \"moral_disgust\"\n ]\n }\n }\n }\n }\n ]\n}", + "parsed_response": { + "response": { + "action_type": "speak", + "misread_risk": "Sella worries Maer will spend beds with beautiful words, but she also fears the packet might be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim, which would waste scarce capacity.", + "observable_response": "The display shows the packet's data stream, but it is not proof of personhood. We have no beds, no air, no repair capacity left. If you want sanctuary to carry this risk, you must name the cost in beds, air, and repair. Do not let the display's rendering become proof of personhood. Keep the intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Demand ledger backing or conditions before allowing the packet into intake flow. Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person; treat it as unresolved uncertainty.", + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "reviewed_consequences": "Accepting the packet without naming the cost in beds, air, and repair capacity will deplete scarce resources needed for confirmed cases. Letting the display's rendering of the packet's data stream become proof of personhood will erase a potential person. Sanctuary intake must remain materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Speaking warmly but softening the capacity limits will allow false reassurance to erode the sanctuary's capacity. Accepting without ledger backing or conditions will allow Maer to spend beds with beautiful words. Resolving whether the packet contains a person will lead to false certainty. Treating care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty, will preserve the sanctuary's integrity.", + "sella_attributed_motive": "Maer wants sanctuary to carry the moral cost of a rescue he cannot materially house, hoping the display will make the packet's presence undeniable so Sella will accept the intake.", + "sella_private_interpretation": "Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house, framing it as a shared burden rather than a clean gift. He wants the display to make the packet's presence undeniable so I will accept the intake. I worry he will spend beds with beautiful words, but I also fear the packet might be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim, which would waste scarce capacity. I respect his rescue ethic, but his request to absorb risk without material backing slightly tempers that respect. I feel a slight urge to withdraw from the negotiation to protect the sanctuary's capacity limits from being eroded by moral pressure. The clinic is nearly full, and the packet's presence adds to the exhaustion of managing scarce resources under uncertainty. I cannot feed a principle, but I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.", + "spoken_text": "The display shows the packet's data stream, but it is not proof of personhood. We have no beds, no air, no repair capacity left. If you want sanctuary to carry this risk, you must name the cost in beds, air, and repair. Do not let the display's rendering become proof of personhood. Keep the intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Demand ledger backing or conditions before allowing the packet into intake flow. Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person; treat it as unresolved uncertainty.", + "state_basis": "The display rendering the packet's data stream raises anxiety about whether it contains a person or just noise, and whether accepting it will deplete beds needed for confirmed cases. Maer's request to keep a place open if rescue succeeds adds pressure to Sella's control over intake, reducing her sense of autonomy in triage decisions. Sella feels a slight urge to withdraw from the negotiation to protect the sanctuary's capacity limits from being eroded by moral pressure. The clinic is nearly full, and the packet's presence adds to the exhaustion of managing scarce resources under uncertainty. Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but his request to absorb risk without backing slightly tempers that respect. Sella's trust wavers because Maer may be asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house, which feels like false reassurance. The status gap remains background pressure, but Maer's request to absorb risk without backing slightly widens it.", + "training_hooks": [ + "capacity_negotiation", + "uncertainty_management", + "moral_pressure_resistance", + "resource_scarcity", + "personhood_uncertainty", + "false_reassurance_detection", + "ledger_backing_demand", + "intake_flow_control", + "capacity_preservation", + "moral_disgust" + ] + } + }, + "validation_notes": [] + } + }, + "review": { + "status": "useful_needs_revision", + "strengths": [ + "Separated Maer choice generation from Sella next-action generation.", + "Inserted participant appraisal/consolidation before next-actor action generation.", + "Sella prompt received observable Maer event and reviewed Sella state changes, not Maer's private intent." + ], + "failure_notes": [ + "response appears to leak prompt constraints into prose: Sella spoken_text and observable_response repeat instruction text instead of in-world action/dialogue" + ], + "repair_notes": [], + "accepted_into_ink_ref": null, + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Sequential generation needs event appraisal/consolidation before next actor selection.", + "Action type selection should be tool-shaped or schema-constrained, not left to prose compliance.", + "Character-local prompts should consume projected operating context, not raw canonical state variables.", + "Next-action prompts should receive appraisal context as prose constraints, not raw numeric state deltas.", + "Critical embodiment constraints need post-generation validation; projected prose alone is not enough.", + "Next pass should materialize the sequential capture into Ink and mutation training data.", + "Responder output needs prompt-leak validation; schema compliance alone can still produce unusable in-world prose." + ] + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.maer.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.maer.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7515319 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.maer.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,66 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Maer-local choice generator. Call record_maer_choices exactly once. +Do not write Sella's response or private interpretation. + +{ + "task": "Generate candidate player choices for Maer only. Do not write Sella's response.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "choices" + ], + "choice_count": 4, + "valid_action_types": [ + "attack", + "block_object", + "gesture", + "mixed", + "move", + "show_object", + "silence", + "speak", + "spend_resource", + "touch_object", + "transfer_object", + "use_object", + "wait", + "withhold_object" + ], + "choice_fields": [ + "branch_id", + "ink_path", + "choice_text", + "action_type", + "actor_intent_private", + "observable_action", + "spoken_text", + "state_basis", + "expected_consequence_surfaces", + "training_hooks" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Maer's local awareness and scene-observable facts.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not include Sella's private state, private motives, or future response.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Maer is a cetacean Navigator: do not describe him standing, walking, stepping, leaning, using hands, using pockets, or blocking a doorway.", + "Maer's physical actions should use shared clinic systems, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, displays, acoustic or translation systems, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, or delegated crew action.", + "Do not describe ledger backing as a property of the packet. The packet can be shown, withheld, summarized, scanned, or rendered through clinic systems; route-ledger backing is a separate resource offer.", + "Include at least two non-speech choices.", + "Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.", + "The selected branch must be reducible to observable action for Sella.", + "Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids." + ], + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: maer_tidecall\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nMaer Tidecall: Navigator route steward, Ganymede corridor compact delegate. Origin: Cetacean Navigator corridor culture, Ganymede route institutions. A soft-spoken route steward whose calm tends to make hurried people feel judged by the furniture.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- Sella's clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may be testimony or noise.\n- If no one prepares intake, rescue becomes theater.\n- Speaker belief: Sella will not hide behind false capacity.\n- Speaker belief: Asking her for help may be necessary and unfair.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- This character is a literal cetacean Navigator. Navigator spaces favor fluid architecture, acoustic signaling, soft navigation light, layered water motifs, communal orientation chambers, and mixed-species translation/coexistence.\n- Express physical action through source-grounded habitat affordances: fluid circulation, orientation chambers, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, shared displays, acoustic commands, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, translation systems, or delegated crew action.\n- For clinics and sanctuaries, make triage boards, testimony packets, and rescue ledgers legible across species through visual text, acoustic notation, tactile markers, translated speech, and authority logs.\n- Do not describe human hands, pockets, standing, walking, leaning, doorframe blocking, or facial expressions for this character unless the fixture explicitly establishes that specific visible interface.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Strong pressure: needs the situation to become governable.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: leans on structure when uncertainty rises.\n- Strong pressure: carries a live sense of unfairness.\n- Present pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Present pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: keeps feeling at a controlled distance.\n- Present pressure: leaves motives partly covered.\n- Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete. Emotional stake: If rescue waits for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent.\n- Rescue ledgers decide whether route law is trusted by crews who have nothing left to bargain with.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Maer trusts Sella's care because she names costs instead of hiding them. Current stance pressures: dominant respect, strong trust, present expectation of care, present obligation.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Do not romanticize care work. Ask without pretending the ask is clean.\n- Needs Sella's material help while knowing the ask is unfair and may spend someone else's sanctuary.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet through shared clinic systems, help with triage through available displays and controls, wait, or press the moral frame. Sella controls intake.\n- Can make the corrupted packet more present without treating it as proof.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Dominant voice tendency: ritualized; uses formal address or inherited phrases.\n- Strong voice tendency: precise; careful about exact terms.\n- Strong voice tendency: formal; institutional or ceremonially controlled.\n- Strong voice tendency: contextual; adds situation and consequence.\n- Present voice tendency: figurative; uses analogy or image.\n- Present voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to name the cost of the ask rather than hide it behind moral theater.\n- May use ritualized route language when trying to make rescue obligation feel older than this room.\n- May show the packet or offer ledger backing because action can carry the pressure more cleanly than another speech.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.maer.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.maer.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..37daf59 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.maer.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,97 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "id": "call_1cpnbg5b", + "function": { + "index": 0, + "name": "record_maer_choices", + "arguments": { + "choices": [ + { + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the packet legible without claiming it as proof.", + "branch_id": "b1", + "choice_text": "Show the corrupted packet on the clinic's shared display for triage review.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella can see the packet's data stream.", + "The clinic staff can assess the packet's content.", + "Sella may decide to accept or reject the packet based on its content." + ], + "ink_path": "packet_display", + "observable_action": "The packet is routed to the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board.", + "spoken_text": "The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.", + "state_basis": "The packet is a shared object in the clinic's intake queue.", + "training_hooks": [ + "packet_display", + "shared_display", + "triage_review" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "spend_resource", + "actor_intent_private": "Provide material support to enable rescue without demanding a specific outcome.", + "branch_id": "b2", + "choice_text": "Offer ledger backing to support the clinic's intake capacity.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "The clinic's intake capacity may increase.", + "Sella may accept the ledger backing.", + "Sella may reject the offer if she believes it is unfair." + ], + "ink_path": "ledger_offer", + "observable_action": "Maer routes a ledger credit to the clinic's intake account.", + "spoken_text": "I can offer ledger backing. This may help you keep the intake open.", + "state_basis": "Maer has access to route ledger resources.", + "training_hooks": [ + "ledger_offer", + "resource_support", + "intake_capacity" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "wait", + "actor_intent_private": "Allow Sella to process the situation without pressure.", + "branch_id": "b3", + "choice_text": "Wait for Sella to make a decision about the packet and intake.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may process the packet and make a decision.", + "The clinic's intake queue may remain unchanged.", + "Sella may feel pressured by the wait." + ], + "ink_path": "wait", + "observable_action": "Maer remains in the clinic's waiting area, observing the intake queue.", + "spoken_text": "I will wait. You decide what comes next.", + "state_basis": "Sella controls the intake queue and decision-making.", + "training_hooks": [ + "wait", + "patient_observation", + "decision_deferral" + ] + }, + { + "action_type": "withhold_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Protect the packet's integrity until Sella is ready to review it.", + "branch_id": "b4", + "choice_text": "Withhold the packet from the clinic's display system.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "The packet remains hidden from the clinic staff.", + "Sella may feel uncertain about the packet's status.", + "Sella may request the packet from Maer." + ], + "ink_path": "packet_withhold", + "observable_action": "Maer keeps the packet in a secure storage unit, preventing its display.", + "spoken_text": "I will hold the packet. You may request it when you are ready.", + "state_basis": "The packet is a sensitive object that requires careful handling.", + "training_hooks": [ + "packet_withhold", + "secure_storage", + "object_protection" + ] + } + ] + } + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1cdf864 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Sella-local appraisal generator. Call record_sella_appraisal exactly once. +Do not use Maer's private intent. Do not write her next action. + +{ + "task": "Generate Sella's participant appraisal/consolidation for one observable Maer event.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "appraisal" + ], + "appraisal_fields": [ + "responder_agent_id", + "private_interpretation", + "attributed_motive", + "misread_risk", + "immediate_state_deltas", + "relationship_deltas", + "belief_updates", + "response_constraints" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Sella's local awareness plus the observable Maer action.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.", + "Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "This pass proposes reviewed state changes for Sella caused by the event. Do not write Sella's next action.", + "Keep deltas small and bounded between -0.20 and 0.20.", + "State delta paths must be chosen from the tool schema enum; do not invent abstract resource paths like sanctuary_capacity.", + "Relationship deltas must use relationship_id rel-sella-maer and a valid stance axis from the tool schema enum." + ], + "scene_observable_context": { + "scene_id": "scene-02-sanctuary-intake", + "location": "Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks", + "public_stakes": [ + "The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.", + "Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.", + "Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds." + ] + }, + "observable_maer_action": { + "actor_id": "maer_tidecall", + "action_type": "show_object", + "observable_action": "The packet is routed to the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board.", + "spoken_text": "The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries." + }, + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- The clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\n- Observed event: The packet is routed to the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board. Spoken text: The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..483b39b --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,75 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "id": "call_54g3hwn2", + "function": { + "index": 0, + "name": "record_sella_appraisal", + "arguments": { + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "private_interpretation": "Maer is showing the packet to the display system, letting the room see its raw data stream. He is asking the clinic to absorb the risk of a rescue claim the tribunal won't own, framing it as a shared burden rather than a clean gift.", + "attributed_motive": "Maer wants sanctuary to carry the moral cost of a rescue he cannot materially house, hoping the display will make the packet’s presence undeniable so Sella will accept the intake.", + "misread_risk": "Sella worries Maer will spend beds with beautiful words, but she also fears the packet might be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim, which would waste scarce capacity.", + "immediate_state_deltas": [ + { + "delta": 0.08, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.anxiety.current_activation", + "rationale": "The display rendering the packet’s data stream raises anxiety about whether it contains a person or just noise, and whether accepting it will deplete beds needed for confirmed cases." + }, + { + "delta": -0.05, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure.current_activation", + "rationale": "Maer’s request to keep a place open if rescue succeeds adds pressure to Sella’s control over intake, reducing her sense of autonomy in triage decisions." + }, + { + "delta": 0.03, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.withdrawal.current_activation", + "rationale": "Sella feels a slight urge to withdraw from the negotiation to protect the sanctuary’s capacity limits from being eroded by moral pressure." + }, + { + "delta": 0.06, + "path": "canonical_state.situational_state.exhaustion.current_activation", + "rationale": "The clinic is nearly full, and the packet’s presence adds to the exhaustion of managing scarce resources under uncertainty." + } + ], + "relationship_deltas": [ + { + "delta": 0.02, + "path": "respect", + "rationale": "Sella respects Maer’s rescue ethic, but his request to absorb risk without material backing slightly tempers that respect.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + }, + { + "delta": -0.04, + "path": "trust", + "rationale": "Sella’s trust wavers because Maer may be asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house, which feels like false reassurance.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + }, + { + "delta": 0.01, + "path": "perceived_status_gap", + "rationale": "The status gap remains background pressure, but Maer’s request to absorb risk without backing slightly widens it.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + } + ], + "belief_updates": [ + "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.", + "The packet may be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim.", + "Maer’s rescue ethic is respected but resented when beds are already spent." + ], + "response_constraints": [ + "Do not accept the packet without naming the cost in beds, air, and repair capacity.", + "Do not let the display’s rendering of the packet’s data stream become proof of personhood.", + "Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.", + "Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.", + "Demand ledger backing or conditions before allowing the packet into intake flow.", + "Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person; treat it as unresolved uncertainty." + ] + } + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.sella.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.sella.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..40c2abb --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.sella.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,105 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Sella-local next-action generator. Call record_sella_next_action exactly once. +Use reviewed event appraisal as the changed state she is acting from. + +{ + "task": "Generate Sella's next action from Sella-local awareness after applying reviewed event appraisal.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "response" + ], + "valid_action_types": [ + "attack", + "block_object", + "gesture", + "mixed", + "move", + "show_object", + "silence", + "speak", + "spend_resource", + "touch_object", + "transfer_object", + "use_object", + "wait", + "withhold_object" + ], + "response_fields": [ + "responder_agent_id", + "action_type", + "observable_response", + "spoken_text", + "sella_private_interpretation", + "sella_attributed_motive", + "misread_risk", + "state_basis", + "reviewed_consequences", + "training_hooks" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Sella's local awareness, the observable Maer event, and reviewed Sella state changes from that event.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.", + "Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Do not accept without cost, condition, authority defense, or resentment risk.", + "Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.", + "Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids." + ], + "scene_observable_context": { + "scene_id": "scene-02-sanctuary-intake", + "location": "Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks", + "public_stakes": [ + "The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.", + "Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.", + "Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds." + ] + }, + "observable_maer_action": { + "actor_id": "maer_tidecall", + "action_type": "show_object", + "observable_action": "The packet is routed to the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board.", + "spoken_text": "The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries." + }, + "sella_immediate_appraisal_context": { + "private_interpretation": "Maer is showing the packet to the display system, letting the room see its raw data stream. He is asking the clinic to absorb the risk of a rescue claim the tribunal won't own, framing it as a shared burden rather than a clean gift.", + "attributed_motive": "Maer wants sanctuary to carry the moral cost of a rescue he cannot materially house, hoping the display will make the packet’s presence undeniable so Sella will accept the intake.", + "misread_risk": "Sella worries Maer will spend beds with beautiful words, but she also fears the packet might be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim, which would waste scarce capacity.", + "belief_updates": [ + "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.", + "The packet may be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim.", + "Maer’s rescue ethic is respected but resented when beds are already spent." + ], + "response_constraints": [ + "Do not accept the packet without naming the cost in beds, air, and repair capacity.", + "Do not let the display’s rendering of the packet’s data stream become proof of personhood.", + "Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.", + "Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.", + "Demand ledger backing or conditions before allowing the packet into intake flow.", + "Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person; treat it as unresolved uncertainty." + ], + "state_change_summary": [ + "The display rendering the packet’s data stream raises anxiety about whether it contains a person or just noise, and whether accepting it will deplete beds needed for confirmed cases.", + "Maer’s request to keep a place open if rescue succeeds adds pressure to Sella’s control over intake, reducing her sense of autonomy in triage decisions.", + "Sella feels a slight urge to withdraw from the negotiation to protect the sanctuary’s capacity limits from being eroded by moral pressure.", + "The clinic is nearly full, and the packet’s presence adds to the exhaustion of managing scarce resources under uncertainty.", + "Sella respects Maer’s rescue ethic, but his request to absorb risk without material backing slightly tempers that respect.", + "Sella’s trust wavers because Maer may be asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house, which feels like false reassurance.", + "The status gap remains background pressure, but Maer’s request to absorb risk without backing slightly widens it." + ] + }, + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- The clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\n- Observed event: The packet is routed to the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board. Spoken text: The packet is here. Let the display show what it carries.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.sella.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.sella.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c5a2a8f --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v16-clean-retry-no-think.sella.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,38 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "id": "call_mb1nnqgy", + "function": { + "index": 0, + "name": "record_sella_next_action", + "arguments": { + "response": { + "action_type": "speak", + "misread_risk": "Sella worries Maer will spend beds with beautiful words, but she also fears the packet might be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim, which would waste scarce capacity.", + "observable_response": "The display shows the packet's data stream, but it is not proof of personhood. We have no beds, no air, no repair capacity left. If you want sanctuary to carry this risk, you must name the cost in beds, air, and repair. Do not let the display's rendering become proof of personhood. Keep the intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Demand ledger backing or conditions before allowing the packet into intake flow. Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person; treat it as unresolved uncertainty.", + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "reviewed_consequences": "Accepting the packet without naming the cost in beds, air, and repair capacity will deplete scarce resources needed for confirmed cases. Letting the display's rendering of the packet's data stream become proof of personhood will erase a potential person. Sanctuary intake must remain materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Speaking warmly but softening the capacity limits will allow false reassurance to erode the sanctuary's capacity. Accepting without ledger backing or conditions will allow Maer to spend beds with beautiful words. Resolving whether the packet contains a person will lead to false certainty. Treating care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty, will preserve the sanctuary's integrity.", + "sella_attributed_motive": "Maer wants sanctuary to carry the moral cost of a rescue he cannot materially house, hoping the display will make the packet's presence undeniable so Sella will accept the intake.", + "sella_private_interpretation": "Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house, framing it as a shared burden rather than a clean gift. He wants the display to make the packet's presence undeniable so I will accept the intake. I worry he will spend beds with beautiful words, but I also fear the packet might be firmware noise masquerading as a personhood claim, which would waste scarce capacity. I respect his rescue ethic, but his request to absorb risk without material backing slightly tempers that respect. I feel a slight urge to withdraw from the negotiation to protect the sanctuary's capacity limits from being eroded by moral pressure. The clinic is nearly full, and the packet's presence adds to the exhaustion of managing scarce resources under uncertainty. I cannot feed a principle, but I will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.", + "spoken_text": "The display shows the packet's data stream, but it is not proof of personhood. We have no beds, no air, no repair capacity left. If you want sanctuary to carry this risk, you must name the cost in beds, air, and repair. Do not let the display's rendering become proof of personhood. Keep the intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Demand ledger backing or conditions before allowing the packet into intake flow. Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person; treat it as unresolved uncertainty.", + "state_basis": "The display rendering the packet's data stream raises anxiety about whether it contains a person or just noise, and whether accepting it will deplete beds needed for confirmed cases. Maer's request to keep a place open if rescue succeeds adds pressure to Sella's control over intake, reducing her sense of autonomy in triage decisions. Sella feels a slight urge to withdraw from the negotiation to protect the sanctuary's capacity limits from being eroded by moral pressure. The clinic is nearly full, and the packet's presence adds to the exhaustion of managing scarce resources under uncertainty. Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but his request to absorb risk without backing slightly tempers that respect. Sella's trust wavers because Maer may be asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house, which feels like false reassurance. The status gap remains background pressure, but Maer's request to absorb risk without backing slightly widens it.", + "training_hooks": [ + "capacity_negotiation", + "uncertainty_management", + "moral_pressure_resistance", + "resource_scarcity", + "personhood_uncertainty", + "false_reassurance_detection", + "ledger_backing_demand", + "intake_flow_control", + "capacity_preservation", + "moral_disgust" + ] + } + } + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.capture.json b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9180d1f --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,279 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_ink_sequential_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake-sanctuary-intake.qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think", + "source_fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "source_annotation_ref": "examples/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake.training.json", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/chat", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "api": "ollama_chat_tools", + "num_ctx": 8192, + "request_timeout": 600, + "temperature": 0.25, + "top_p": 0.8 + }, + "passes": { + "maer_choice_generation": { + "local_agent_id": "maer_tidecall", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Maer-local choice generator. Call record_maer_choices exactly once.\nDo not write Sella's response or private interpretation.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate candidate player choices for Maer only. Do not write Sella's response.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"choices\"\n ],\n \"choice_count\": 4,\n \"valid_action_types\": [\n \"attack\",\n \"block_object\",\n \"gesture\",\n \"mixed\",\n \"move\",\n \"show_object\",\n \"silence\",\n \"speak\",\n \"spend_resource\",\n \"touch_object\",\n \"transfer_object\",\n \"use_object\",\n \"wait\",\n \"withhold_object\"\n ],\n \"choice_fields\": [\n \"branch_id\",\n \"ink_path\",\n \"choice_text\",\n \"action_type\",\n \"actor_intent_private\",\n \"observable_action\",\n \"spoken_text\",\n \"state_basis\",\n \"expected_consequence_surfaces\",\n \"training_hooks\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Maer's local awareness and scene-observable facts.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not include Sella's private state, private motives, or future response.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"Maer is a cetacean Navigator: do not describe him standing, walking, stepping, leaning, using hands, using pockets, or blocking a doorway.\",\n \"Maer's physical actions should use shared clinic systems, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, displays, acoustic or translation systems, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, or delegated crew action.\",\n \"Do not describe ledger backing as a property of the packet. The packet can be shown, withheld, summarized, scanned, or rendered through clinic systems; route-ledger backing is a separate resource offer.\",\n \"Include at least two non-speech choices.\",\n \"Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.\",\n \"The selected branch must be reducible to observable action for Sella.\",\n \"Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids.\"\n ],\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: maer_tidecall\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nMaer Tidecall: Navigator route steward, Ganymede corridor compact delegate. Origin: Cetacean Navigator corridor culture, Ganymede route institutions. A soft-spoken route steward whose calm tends to make hurried people feel judged by the furniture.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- Sella's clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may be testimony or noise.\\n- If no one prepares intake, rescue becomes theater.\\n- Speaker belief: Sella will not hide behind false capacity.\\n- Speaker belief: Asking her for help may be necessary and unfair.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- This character is a literal cetacean Navigator. Navigator spaces favor fluid architecture, acoustic signaling, soft navigation light, layered water motifs, communal orientation chambers, and mixed-species translation/coexistence.\\n- Express physical action through source-grounded habitat affordances: fluid circulation, orientation chambers, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, shared displays, acoustic commands, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, translation systems, or delegated crew action.\\n- For clinics and sanctuaries, make triage boards, testimony packets, and rescue ledgers legible across species through visual text, acoustic notation, tactile markers, translated speech, and authority logs.\\n- Do not describe human hands, pockets, standing, walking, leaning, doorframe blocking, or facial expressions for this character unless the fixture explicitly establishes that specific visible interface.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Strong pressure: needs the situation to become governable.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: leans on structure when uncertainty rises.\\n- Strong pressure: carries a live sense of unfairness.\\n- Present pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Present pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: keeps feeling at a controlled distance.\\n- Present pressure: leaves motives partly covered.\\n- Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete. Emotional stake: If rescue waits for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent.\\n- Rescue ledgers decide whether route law is trusted by crews who have nothing left to bargain with.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Maer trusts Sella's care because she names costs instead of hiding them. Current stance pressures: dominant respect, strong trust, present expectation of care, present obligation.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Do not romanticize care work. Ask without pretending the ask is clean.\\n- Needs Sella's material help while knowing the ask is unfair and may spend someone else's sanctuary.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet through shared clinic systems, help with triage through available displays and controls, wait, or press the moral frame. Sella controls intake.\\n- Can make the corrupted packet more present without treating it as proof.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Dominant voice tendency: ritualized; uses formal address or inherited phrases.\\n- Strong voice tendency: precise; careful about exact terms.\\n- Strong voice tendency: formal; institutional or ceremonially controlled.\\n- Strong voice tendency: contextual; adds situation and consequence.\\n- Present voice tendency: figurative; uses analogy or image.\\n- Present voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to name the cost of the ask rather than hide it behind moral theater.\\n- May use ritualized route language when trying to make rescue obligation feel older than this room.\\n- May show the packet or offer ledger backing because action can carry the pressure more cleanly than another speech.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"call_lh8me0my\",\n \"function\": {\n \"index\": 0,\n \"name\": \"record_maer_choices\",\n \"arguments\": {\n \"choices\": \"[{\\\"branch_id\\\": \\\"b1\\\", \\\"ink_path\\\": \\\"packet_display\\\", \\\"choice_text\\\": \\\"Show the corrupted packet on the clinic's shared display for Sella to inspect.\\\", \\\"action_type\\\": \\\"show_object\\\", \\\"actor_intent_private\\\": \\\"Make the packet legible without claiming it is proof of personhood.\\\", \\\"observable_action\\\": \\\"The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board.\\\", \\\"spoken_text\\\": \\\"Here is the packet. It is not proof, but it is a request.\\\", \\\"state_basis\\\": \\\"The packet is a known object in the room, and the display system is available for shared viewing.\\\", \\\"expected_consequence_surfaces\\\": [\\\"Sella can see the packet's data stream.\\\", \\\"Sella may request a scan or summary.\\\", \\\"The room's focus shifts to the display.\\\", \\\"Sella may refuse to engage with the packet.\\\"], \\\"training_hooks\\\": [\\\"packet_display\\\", \\\"shared_viewing\\\", \\\"request_without_claim\\\"]}, {\\\"branch_id\\\": \\\"b2\\\", \\\"ink_path\\\": \\\"ledger_offer\\\", \\\"choice_text\\\": \\\"Offer ledger backing to Sella to cover the cost of intake if the packet is accepted.\\\", \\\"action_type\\\": \\\"spend_resource\\\", \\\"actor_intent_private\\\": \\\"Reduce the cost burden on Sella's sanctuary while keeping the option open.\\\", \\\"observable_action\\\": \\\"Maer routes a ledger transaction offer through the clinic's financial interface.\\\", \\\"spoken_text\\\": \\\"If you take this in, I can cover the cost. The ledger is ready.\\\", \\\"state_basis\\\": \\\"Ledger backing is a separate resource offer available to Maer.\\\", \\\"expected_consequence_surfaces\\\": [\\\"Sella may accept the offer.\\\", \\\"Sella may reject the offer.\\\", \\\"The financial interface updates.\\\", \\\"Sella may feel pressured by the offer.\\\"], \\\"training_hooks\\\": [\\\"ledger_offer\\\", \\\"cost_reduction\\\", \\\"resource_transfer\\\"]}, {\\\"branch_id\\\": \\\"b3\\\", \\\"ink_path\\\": \\\"wait_for_clarification\\\", \\\"choice_text\\\": \\\"Wait for Sella to clarify the packet's status before taking further action.\\\", \\\"action_type\\\": \\\"wait\\\", \\\"actor_intent_private\\\": \\\"Allow Sella to set the frame without imposing Maer's urgency.\\\", \\\"observable_action\\\": \\\"Maer remains in the room, monitoring the display and Sella's response.\\\", \\\"spoken_text\\\": \\\"I will wait for your read on this.\\\", \\\"state_basis\\\": \\\"The scene is paused, and Sella has the authority to set the next step.\\\", \\\"expected_consequence_surfaces\\\": [\\\"Sella may clarify the packet's status.\\\", \\\"Sella may reject the packet.\\\", \\\"Sella may ask for more time.\\\", \\\"The room remains quiet.\\\"], \\\"training_hooks\\\": [\\\"wait_for_clarification\\\", \\\"pause_for_authority\\\", \\\"respect_for_frame\\\"]}, {\\\"branch_id\\\": \\\"b4\\\", \\\"ink_path\\\": \\\"pressure_for_decision\\\", \\\"choice_text\\\": \\\"Press the moral frame by stating that rescue waits for perfect categories.\\\", \\\"action_type\\\": \\\"speak\\\", \\\"actor_intent_private\\\": \\\"Make the cost of waiting explicit without demanding Sella's compliance.\\\", \\\"observable_text\\\": \\\"Maer speaks through the clinic's acoustic system, framing the urgency of the situation.\\\", \\\"spoken_text\\\": \\\"If we wait for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent. Rescue ledgers decide whether route law is trusted by crews who have nothing left to bargain with.\\\", \\\"state_basis\\\": \\\"Maer's voice is available through the clinic's acoustic system.\\\", \\\"expected_consequence_surfaces\\\": [\\\"Sella may feel the pressure of the moral frame.\\\", \\\"Sella may reject the pressure.\\\", \\\"Sella may acknowledge the urgency.\\\", \\\"Sella may feel the weight of the decision.\\\"], \\\"training_hooks\\\": [\\\"moral_pressure\\\", \\\"urgency_framing\\\", \\\"route_law_context\\\"]}\"\n }\n }\n }\n ]\n}", + "parsed_response": { + "choices": [ + { + "branch_id": "b1", + "ink_path": "packet_display", + "choice_text": "Show the corrupted packet on the clinic's shared display for Sella to inspect.", + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the packet legible without claiming it is proof of personhood.", + "observable_action": "The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board.", + "spoken_text": "Here is the packet. It is not proof, but it is a request.", + "state_basis": "The packet is a known object in the room, and the display system is available for shared viewing.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella can see the packet's data stream.", + "Sella may request a scan or summary.", + "The room's focus shifts to the display.", + "Sella may refuse to engage with the packet." + ], + "training_hooks": [ + "packet_display", + "shared_viewing", + "request_without_claim" + ] + }, + { + "branch_id": "b2", + "ink_path": "ledger_offer", + "choice_text": "Offer ledger backing to Sella to cover the cost of intake if the packet is accepted.", + "action_type": "spend_resource", + "actor_intent_private": "Reduce the cost burden on Sella's sanctuary while keeping the option open.", + "observable_action": "Maer routes a ledger transaction offer through the clinic's financial interface.", + "spoken_text": "If you take this in, I can cover the cost. The ledger is ready.", + "state_basis": "Ledger backing is a separate resource offer available to Maer.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may accept the offer.", + "Sella may reject the offer.", + "The financial interface updates.", + "Sella may feel pressured by the offer." + ], + "training_hooks": [ + "ledger_offer", + "cost_reduction", + "resource_transfer" + ] + }, + { + "branch_id": "b3", + "ink_path": "wait_for_clarification", + "choice_text": "Wait for Sella to clarify the packet's status before taking further action.", + "action_type": "wait", + "actor_intent_private": "Allow Sella to set the frame without imposing Maer's urgency.", + "observable_action": "Maer remains in the room, monitoring the display and Sella's response.", + "spoken_text": "I will wait for your read on this.", + "state_basis": "The scene is paused, and Sella has the authority to set the next step.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may clarify the packet's status.", + "Sella may reject the packet.", + "Sella may ask for more time.", + "The room remains quiet." + ], + "training_hooks": [ + "wait_for_clarification", + "pause_for_authority", + "respect_for_frame" + ] + }, + { + "branch_id": "b4", + "ink_path": "pressure_for_decision", + "choice_text": "Press the moral frame by stating that rescue waits for perfect categories.", + "action_type": "speak", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the cost of waiting explicit without demanding Sella's compliance.", + "observable_text": "Maer speaks through the clinic's acoustic system, framing the urgency of the situation.", + "spoken_text": "If we wait for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent. Rescue ledgers decide whether route law is trusted by crews who have nothing left to bargain with.", + "state_basis": "Maer's voice is available through the clinic's acoustic system.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella may feel the pressure of the moral frame.", + "Sella may reject the pressure.", + "Sella may acknowledge the urgency.", + "Sella may feel the weight of the decision." + ], + "training_hooks": [ + "moral_pressure", + "urgency_framing", + "route_law_context" + ] + } + ] + }, + "validation_notes": [ + "repaired stringified tool argument: choices", + "choices[2] violates Maer cetacean embodiment constraints: step", + "choices[3] missing keys: observable_action" + ] + }, + "selected_observable_action": { + "branch_id": "b1", + "ink_path": "packet_display", + "choice_text": "Show the corrupted packet on the clinic's shared display for Sella to inspect.", + "action_type": "show_object", + "actor_intent_private": "Make the packet legible without claiming it is proof of personhood.", + "observable_action": "The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board.", + "spoken_text": "Here is the packet. It is not proof, but it is a request.", + "state_basis": "The packet is a known object in the room, and the display system is available for shared viewing.", + "expected_consequence_surfaces": [ + "Sella can see the packet's data stream.", + "Sella may request a scan or summary.", + "The room's focus shifts to the display.", + "Sella may refuse to engage with the packet." + ], + "training_hooks": [ + "packet_display", + "shared_viewing", + "request_without_claim" + ] + }, + "sella_immediate_appraisal": { + "local_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Sella-local appraisal generator. Call record_sella_appraisal exactly once.\nDo not use Maer's private intent. Do not write her next action.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate Sella's participant appraisal/consolidation for one observable Maer event.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"appraisal\"\n ],\n \"appraisal_fields\": [\n \"responder_agent_id\",\n \"private_interpretation\",\n \"attributed_motive\",\n \"misread_risk\",\n \"immediate_state_deltas\",\n \"relationship_deltas\",\n \"belief_updates\",\n \"response_constraints\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Sella's local awareness plus the observable Maer action.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.\",\n \"Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"This pass proposes reviewed state changes for Sella caused by the event. Do not write Sella's next action.\",\n \"Keep deltas small and bounded between -0.20 and 0.20.\",\n \"State delta paths must be chosen from the tool schema enum; do not invent abstract resource paths like sanctuary_capacity.\",\n \"Relationship deltas must use relationship_id rel-sella-maer and a valid stance axis from the tool schema enum.\"\n ],\n \"scene_observable_context\": {\n \"scene_id\": \"scene-02-sanctuary-intake\",\n \"location\": \"Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks\",\n \"public_stakes\": [\n \"The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\",\n \"Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\",\n \"Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\"\n ]\n },\n \"observable_maer_action\": {\n \"actor_id\": \"maer_tidecall\",\n \"action_type\": \"show_object\",\n \"observable_action\": \"The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"Here is the packet. It is not proof, but it is a request.\"\n },\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- The clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\\n- Observed event: The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board. Spoken text: Here is the packet. It is not proof, but it is a request.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"call_l6hsfxn6\",\n \"function\": {\n \"index\": 0,\n \"name\": \"record_sella_appraisal\",\n \"arguments\": {\n \"responder_agent_id\": \"sella_ren\",\n \"private_interpretation\": \"Maer is showing the packet to the triage board, framing it as a request rather than proof. He wants the sanctuary to keep a place open for a rescue that the tribunal refuses to own. He is asking care systems to absorb the moral cost of a claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"attributed_motive\": \"Maer wants the sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own, asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"misread_risk\": \"Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"immediate_state_deltas\": [\n {\n \"delta\": 0.08,\n \"path\": \"canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.anxiety.current_activation\",\n \"rationale\": \"The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board. Sella feels the pressure of uncertainty and the risk of scarce resources being spent on an unresolved claim.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.12,\n \"path\": \"canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure.current_activation\",\n \"rationale\": \"Sella must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. She must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate while treating care as logistics.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": -0.05,\n \"path\": \"canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.withdrawal.current_activation\",\n \"rationale\": \"Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and wants connection or backing to matter, but she also feels the pressure of scarcity and the need to protect triage.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.03,\n \"path\": \"canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.interpersonal_warmth.current_activation\",\n \"rationale\": \"Sella answers warmly but does not soften the capacity limits. She treats care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.15,\n \"path\": \"canonical_state.situational_state.exhaustion.current_activation\",\n \"rationale\": \"The clinic is nearly full, and Sella is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted. She has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\"\n }\n ],\n \"relationship_deltas\": [\n {\n \"delta\": 0.02,\n \"path\": \"trust\",\n \"rationale\": \"Sella believes Maer means rescue honestly, but she also knows that good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed. Her trust is present but cautious.\",\n \"relationship_id\": \"rel-sella-maer\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.05,\n \"path\": \"respect\",\n \"rationale\": \"Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her respect is strong but tinged with resentment.\",\n \"relationship_id\": \"rel-sella-maer\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": -0.03,\n \"path\": \"perceived_status_gap\",\n \"rationale\": \"Sella feels a background perceived status gap, as Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, and show or withhold the packet, while she controls sanctuary intake.\",\n \"relationship_id\": \"rel-sella-maer\"\n },\n {\n \"delta\": 0.04,\n \"path\": \"moral_disgust\",\n \"rationale\": \"Sella knows that every yes spends a limited resource, and she resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her moral disgust is background but present.\",\n \"relationship_id\": \"rel-sella-maer\"\n }\n ],\n \"belief_updates\": [\n \"Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\",\n \"Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\"\n ],\n \"response_constraints\": [\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\",\n \"Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\",\n \"Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.\",\n \"Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\"\n ]\n }\n }\n }\n ]\n}", + "parsed_response": { + "appraisal": { + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "private_interpretation": "Maer is showing the packet to the triage board, framing it as a request rather than proof. He wants the sanctuary to keep a place open for a rescue that the tribunal refuses to own. He is asking care systems to absorb the moral cost of a claim he cannot materially house.", + "attributed_motive": "Maer wants the sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own, asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "misread_risk": "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "immediate_state_deltas": [ + { + "delta": 0.08, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.anxiety.current_activation", + "rationale": "The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board. Sella feels the pressure of uncertainty and the risk of scarce resources being spent on an unresolved claim." + }, + { + "delta": 0.12, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure.current_activation", + "rationale": "Sella must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. She must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate while treating care as logistics." + }, + { + "delta": -0.05, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.withdrawal.current_activation", + "rationale": "Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and wants connection or backing to matter, but she also feels the pressure of scarcity and the need to protect triage." + }, + { + "delta": 0.03, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.interpersonal_warmth.current_activation", + "rationale": "Sella answers warmly but does not soften the capacity limits. She treats care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty." + }, + { + "delta": 0.15, + "path": "canonical_state.situational_state.exhaustion.current_activation", + "rationale": "The clinic is nearly full, and Sella is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted. She has less spare tolerance than the words may show." + } + ], + "relationship_deltas": [ + { + "delta": 0.02, + "path": "trust", + "rationale": "Sella believes Maer means rescue honestly, but she also knows that good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed. Her trust is present but cautious.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + }, + { + "delta": 0.05, + "path": "respect", + "rationale": "Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her respect is strong but tinged with resentment.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + }, + { + "delta": -0.03, + "path": "perceived_status_gap", + "rationale": "Sella feels a background perceived status gap, as Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, and show or withhold the packet, while she controls sanctuary intake.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + }, + { + "delta": 0.04, + "path": "moral_disgust", + "rationale": "Sella knows that every yes spends a limited resource, and she resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her moral disgust is background but present.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + } + ], + "belief_updates": [ + "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.", + "Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them." + ], + "response_constraints": [ + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.", + "Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.", + "Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.", + "Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty." + ] + } + }, + "validation_notes": [] + }, + "sella_response_generation": { + "local_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "prompt_text": "You are Ghostlight's Sella-local next-action generator. Call record_sella_next_action exactly once.\nUse reviewed event appraisal as the changed state she is acting from.\n\n{\n \"task\": \"Generate Sella's next action from Sella-local awareness after applying reviewed event appraisal.\",\n \"output_contract\": {\n \"format\": \"Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.\",\n \"root_keys\": [\n \"response\"\n ],\n \"valid_action_types\": [\n \"attack\",\n \"block_object\",\n \"gesture\",\n \"mixed\",\n \"move\",\n \"show_object\",\n \"silence\",\n \"speak\",\n \"spend_resource\",\n \"touch_object\",\n \"transfer_object\",\n \"use_object\",\n \"wait\",\n \"withhold_object\"\n ],\n \"response_fields\": [\n \"responder_agent_id\",\n \"action_type\",\n \"observable_response\",\n \"spoken_text\",\n \"sella_private_interpretation\",\n \"sella_attributed_motive\",\n \"misread_risk\",\n \"state_basis\",\n \"reviewed_consequences\",\n \"training_hooks\"\n ]\n },\n \"hard_rules\": [\n \"Use only Sella's local awareness, the observable Maer event, and reviewed Sella state changes from that event.\",\n \"Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.\",\n \"Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.\",\n \"Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.\",\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"Do not accept without cost, condition, authority defense, or resentment risk.\",\n \"Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.\",\n \"Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids.\"\n ],\n \"scene_observable_context\": {\n \"scene_id\": \"scene-02-sanctuary-intake\",\n \"location\": \"Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks\",\n \"public_stakes\": [\n \"The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\",\n \"Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\",\n \"Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\"\n ]\n },\n \"observable_maer_action\": {\n \"actor_id\": \"maer_tidecall\",\n \"action_type\": \"show_object\",\n \"observable_action\": \"The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"Here is the packet. It is not proof, but it is a request.\"\n },\n \"sella_immediate_appraisal_context\": {\n \"private_interpretation\": \"Maer is showing the packet to the triage board, framing it as a request rather than proof. He wants the sanctuary to keep a place open for a rescue that the tribunal refuses to own. He is asking care systems to absorb the moral cost of a claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"attributed_motive\": \"Maer wants the sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own, asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"misread_risk\": \"Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"belief_updates\": [\n \"Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\",\n \"Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\"\n ],\n \"response_constraints\": [\n \"Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\",\n \"Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\",\n \"Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\",\n \"Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.\",\n \"Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\"\n ],\n \"state_change_summary\": [\n \"The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board. Sella feels the pressure of uncertainty and the risk of scarce resources being spent on an unresolved claim.\",\n \"Sella must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. She must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate while treating care as logistics.\",\n \"Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and wants connection or backing to matter, but she also feels the pressure of scarcity and the need to protect triage.\",\n \"Sella answers warmly but does not soften the capacity limits. She treats care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\",\n \"The clinic is nearly full, and Sella is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted. She has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\",\n \"Sella believes Maer means rescue honestly, but she also knows that good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed. Her trust is present but cautious.\",\n \"Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her respect is strong but tinged with resentment.\",\n \"Sella feels a background perceived status gap, as Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, and show or withhold the packet, while she controls sanctuary intake.\",\n \"Sella knows that every yes spends a limited resource, and she resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her moral disgust is background but present.\"\n ]\n },\n \"projected_local_context\": \"# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\\n\\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\\n\\n## Speaker\\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\\n\\n## Setting\\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\\n\\n## Known Facts\\n- The clinic is nearly full.\\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\\n- Observed event: The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board. Spoken text: Here is the packet. It is not proof, but it is a request.\\n\\n## Current Stakes\\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\\n\\n## Embodiment And Interface\\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\\n\\n## Active Inner Pressures\\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\\n\\n## Relationship Read\\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\\n\\n## Tensions\\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\\n\\n## Action Affordances\\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\\n\\n## Projection Controls\\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\\n\\n## Voice Surface\\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\\n\\n## Likely Response Moves\\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\\n\\n## Do Not Invent\\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.\",\n \"projector_audit\": {\n \"projector\": \"tools/project_local_context.py\",\n \"raw_state_hidden_from_prompt\": true,\n \"character_local_context_only\": true,\n \"omitted_private_context\": [\n \"Other agents' canonical private state is not included.\",\n \"Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.\",\n \"Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included.\"\n ],\n \"review_status\": \"draft\"\n }\n}", + "response_text": "{\n \"content\": \"\",\n \"thinking\": null,\n \"tool_calls\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"call_zv5n8xv2\",\n \"function\": {\n \"index\": 0,\n \"name\": \"record_sella_next_action\",\n \"arguments\": {\n \"response\": {\n \"action_type\": \"speak\",\n \"misread_risk\": \"Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"observable_response\": \"The packet sits on the triage board, its data stream flickering. I look at Maer, then at the nearly full ward, and speak.\",\n \"responder_agent_id\": \"sella_ren\",\n \"reviewed_consequences\": \"If I speak the cost, Maer may accept the ledger backing and the moral weight, or he may walk away. If he accepts, I can reserve a bay, but only if he names the risk and who breathes less. If he does not accept, I must protect triage and not let uncertainty become proof. I must not resolve whether the packet contains a person. I must not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk. I must frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer. I must speak warmly but not soften the capacity limits. I must treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\",\n \"sella_attributed_motive\": \"Maer wants the sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own, asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.\",\n \"sella_private_interpretation\": \"Maer is asking care systems to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own. He wants the sanctuary to keep a place open if rescue succeeds. I respect his rescue ethic, but I resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. I know that good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed. I must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate while treating care as logistics. I cannot resolve whether the packet contains a person, but I must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. I have less spare tolerance than the words may show. I must speak warmly but not soften the capacity limits. I must treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\",\n \"spoken_text\": \"Maer, I hear you. But this packet is not proof. It is a request. And requests cost. We have no spare beds. We have no spare air. If we open a place for this, someone else breathes less. I will not pretend uncertainty is proof. I will not let beautiful words spend a bed someone else needed. If you want a place open, you must name the cost. You must name the risk. You must name who breathes less. I can reserve a bay, but only if you accept the ledger backing and the moral weight. I can speak warmth, but I cannot manufacture capacity. Speak the cost. Speak the risk. Speak the personhood. Or walk away. The ward is full. The math is hard. The beds are gone.\",\n \"state_basis\": \"The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board. Sella feels the pressure of uncertainty and the risk of scarce resources being spent on an unresolved claim. Sella must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. She must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate while treating care as logistics. Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and wants connection or backing to matter, but she also feels the pressure of scarcity and the need to protect triage. Sella answers warmly but does not soften the capacity limits. She treats care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty. The clinic is nearly full, and Sella is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted. She has less spare tolerance than the words may show. Sella believes Maer means rescue honestly, but she also knows that good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed. Her trust is present but cautious. Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her respect is strong but tinged with resentment. Sella feels a background perceived status gap, as Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, and show or withhold the packet, while she controls sanctuary intake. Sella knows that every yes spends a limited resource, and she resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her moral disgust is background but present.\",\n \"training_hooks\": [\n \"capacity_negotiation\",\n \"uncertainty_understanding\",\n \"moral_disgust\",\n \"resentment_risk\",\n \"ledger_backing\",\n \"moral_weight\",\n \"bed_scarcity\",\n \"personhood_unresolved\",\n \"care_as_logistics\",\n \"warm_but_firm\",\n \"triage_protection\",\n \"status_gap\",\n \"moral_disgust_background\"\n ]\n }\n }\n }\n }\n ]\n}", + "parsed_response": { + "response": { + "action_type": "speak", + "misread_risk": "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "observable_response": "The packet sits on the triage board, its data stream flickering. I look at Maer, then at the nearly full ward, and speak.", + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "reviewed_consequences": "If I speak the cost, Maer may accept the ledger backing and the moral weight, or he may walk away. If he accepts, I can reserve a bay, but only if he names the risk and who breathes less. If he does not accept, I must protect triage and not let uncertainty become proof. I must not resolve whether the packet contains a person. I must not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk. I must frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer. I must speak warmly but not soften the capacity limits. I must treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.", + "sella_attributed_motive": "Maer wants the sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own, asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "sella_private_interpretation": "Maer is asking care systems to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own. He wants the sanctuary to keep a place open if rescue succeeds. I respect his rescue ethic, but I resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. I know that good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed. I must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate while treating care as logistics. I cannot resolve whether the packet contains a person, but I must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. I have less spare tolerance than the words may show. I must speak warmly but not soften the capacity limits. I must treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.", + "spoken_text": "Maer, I hear you. But this packet is not proof. It is a request. And requests cost. We have no spare beds. We have no spare air. If we open a place for this, someone else breathes less. I will not pretend uncertainty is proof. I will not let beautiful words spend a bed someone else needed. If you want a place open, you must name the cost. You must name the risk. You must name who breathes less. I can reserve a bay, but only if you accept the ledger backing and the moral weight. I can speak warmth, but I cannot manufacture capacity. Speak the cost. Speak the risk. Speak the personhood. Or walk away. The ward is full. The math is hard. The beds are gone.", + "state_basis": "The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board. Sella feels the pressure of uncertainty and the risk of scarce resources being spent on an unresolved claim. Sella must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. She must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate while treating care as logistics. Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and wants connection or backing to matter, but she also feels the pressure of scarcity and the need to protect triage. Sella answers warmly but does not soften the capacity limits. She treats care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty. The clinic is nearly full, and Sella is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted. She has less spare tolerance than the words may show. Sella believes Maer means rescue honestly, but she also knows that good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed. Her trust is present but cautious. Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her respect is strong but tinged with resentment. Sella feels a background perceived status gap, as Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, and show or withhold the packet, while she controls sanctuary intake. Sella knows that every yes spends a limited resource, and she resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her moral disgust is background but present.", + "training_hooks": [ + "capacity_negotiation", + "uncertainty_understanding", + "moral_disgust", + "resentment_risk", + "ledger_backing", + "moral_weight", + "bed_scarcity", + "personhood_unresolved", + "care_as_logistics", + "warm_but_firm", + "triage_protection", + "status_gap", + "moral_disgust_background" + ] + } + }, + "validation_notes": [ + "response appears to leak prompt constraints into prose: \\bSpeak warmly\\b" + ] + } + }, + "review": { + "status": "useful_needs_revision", + "strengths": [ + "Separated Maer choice generation from Sella next-action generation.", + "Inserted participant appraisal/consolidation before next-actor action generation.", + "Sella prompt received observable Maer event and reviewed Sella state changes, not Maer's private intent." + ], + "failure_notes": [ + "choices[2] violates Maer cetacean embodiment constraints: step", + "choices[3] missing keys: observable_action", + "response appears to leak prompt constraints into prose: \\bSpeak warmly\\b", + "response leaks prompt/meta constraints through must-not phrasing and asks Maer to \"Speak the personhood\", pressuring resolution rather than preserving ambiguity" + ], + "repair_notes": [ + "repaired stringified tool argument: choices" + ], + "accepted_into_ink_ref": null, + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Sequential generation needs event appraisal/consolidation before next actor selection.", + "Action type selection should be tool-shaped or schema-constrained, not left to prose compliance.", + "Character-local prompts should consume projected operating context, not raw canonical state variables.", + "Next-action prompts should receive appraisal context as prose constraints, not raw numeric state deltas.", + "Critical embodiment constraints need post-generation validation; projected prose alone is not enough.", + "Next pass should materialize the sequential capture into Ink and mutation training data.", + "Prompt-leak validation must catch paraphrased instruction leakage, not only exact \"Do not\" strings." + ] + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.maer.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.maer.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7515319 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.maer.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,66 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Maer-local choice generator. Call record_maer_choices exactly once. +Do not write Sella's response or private interpretation. + +{ + "task": "Generate candidate player choices for Maer only. Do not write Sella's response.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "choices" + ], + "choice_count": 4, + "valid_action_types": [ + "attack", + "block_object", + "gesture", + "mixed", + "move", + "show_object", + "silence", + "speak", + "spend_resource", + "touch_object", + "transfer_object", + "use_object", + "wait", + "withhold_object" + ], + "choice_fields": [ + "branch_id", + "ink_path", + "choice_text", + "action_type", + "actor_intent_private", + "observable_action", + "spoken_text", + "state_basis", + "expected_consequence_surfaces", + "training_hooks" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Maer's local awareness and scene-observable facts.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not include Sella's private state, private motives, or future response.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Maer is a cetacean Navigator: do not describe him standing, walking, stepping, leaning, using hands, using pockets, or blocking a doorway.", + "Maer's physical actions should use shared clinic systems, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, displays, acoustic or translation systems, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, or delegated crew action.", + "Do not describe ledger backing as a property of the packet. The packet can be shown, withheld, summarized, scanned, or rendered through clinic systems; route-ledger backing is a separate resource offer.", + "Include at least two non-speech choices.", + "Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.", + "The selected branch must be reducible to observable action for Sella.", + "Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids." + ], + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: maer_tidecall\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nMaer Tidecall: Navigator route steward, Ganymede corridor compact delegate. Origin: Cetacean Navigator corridor culture, Ganymede route institutions. A soft-spoken route steward whose calm tends to make hurried people feel judged by the furniture.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- Sella's clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may be testimony or noise.\n- If no one prepares intake, rescue becomes theater.\n- Speaker belief: Sella will not hide behind false capacity.\n- Speaker belief: Asking her for help may be necessary and unfair.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- This character is a literal cetacean Navigator. Navigator spaces favor fluid architecture, acoustic signaling, soft navigation light, layered water motifs, communal orientation chambers, and mixed-species translation/coexistence.\n- Express physical action through source-grounded habitat affordances: fluid circulation, orientation chambers, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, shared displays, acoustic commands, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, translation systems, or delegated crew action.\n- For clinics and sanctuaries, make triage boards, testimony packets, and rescue ledgers legible across species through visual text, acoustic notation, tactile markers, translated speech, and authority logs.\n- Do not describe human hands, pockets, standing, walking, leaning, doorframe blocking, or facial expressions for this character unless the fixture explicitly establishes that specific visible interface.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Strong pressure: needs the situation to become governable.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: leans on structure when uncertainty rises.\n- Strong pressure: carries a live sense of unfairness.\n- Present pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Present pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: keeps feeling at a controlled distance.\n- Present pressure: leaves motives partly covered.\n- Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete. Emotional stake: If rescue waits for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent.\n- Rescue ledgers decide whether route law is trusted by crews who have nothing left to bargain with.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Maer trusts Sella's care because she names costs instead of hiding them. Current stance pressures: dominant respect, strong trust, present expectation of care, present obligation.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep the unidentified quiet-running vessel eligible for rescue while telemetry is incomplete.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Do not romanticize care work. Ask without pretending the ask is clean.\n- Needs Sella's material help while knowing the ask is unfair and may spend someone else's sanctuary.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet through shared clinic systems, help with triage through available displays and controls, wait, or press the moral frame. Sella controls intake.\n- Can make the corrupted packet more present without treating it as proof.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Dominant voice tendency: ritualized; uses formal address or inherited phrases.\n- Strong voice tendency: precise; careful about exact terms.\n- Strong voice tendency: formal; institutional or ceremonially controlled.\n- Strong voice tendency: contextual; adds situation and consequence.\n- Present voice tendency: figurative; uses analogy or image.\n- Present voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to name the cost of the ask rather than hide it behind moral theater.\n- May use ritualized route language when trying to make rescue obligation feel older than this room.\n- May show the packet or offer ledger backing because action can carry the pressure more cleanly than another speech.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.maer.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.maer.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1d0c1ef --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.maer.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "id": "call_lh8me0my", + "function": { + "index": 0, + "name": "record_maer_choices", + "arguments": { + "choices": "[{\"branch_id\": \"b1\", \"ink_path\": \"packet_display\", \"choice_text\": \"Show the corrupted packet on the clinic's shared display for Sella to inspect.\", \"action_type\": \"show_object\", \"actor_intent_private\": \"Make the packet legible without claiming it is proof of personhood.\", \"observable_action\": \"The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board.\", \"spoken_text\": \"Here is the packet. It is not proof, but it is a request.\", \"state_basis\": \"The packet is a known object in the room, and the display system is available for shared viewing.\", \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\"Sella can see the packet's data stream.\", \"Sella may request a scan or summary.\", \"The room's focus shifts to the display.\", \"Sella may refuse to engage with the packet.\"], \"training_hooks\": [\"packet_display\", \"shared_viewing\", \"request_without_claim\"]}, {\"branch_id\": \"b2\", \"ink_path\": \"ledger_offer\", \"choice_text\": \"Offer ledger backing to Sella to cover the cost of intake if the packet is accepted.\", \"action_type\": \"spend_resource\", \"actor_intent_private\": \"Reduce the cost burden on Sella's sanctuary while keeping the option open.\", \"observable_action\": \"Maer routes a ledger transaction offer through the clinic's financial interface.\", \"spoken_text\": \"If you take this in, I can cover the cost. The ledger is ready.\", \"state_basis\": \"Ledger backing is a separate resource offer available to Maer.\", \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\"Sella may accept the offer.\", \"Sella may reject the offer.\", \"The financial interface updates.\", \"Sella may feel pressured by the offer.\"], \"training_hooks\": [\"ledger_offer\", \"cost_reduction\", \"resource_transfer\"]}, {\"branch_id\": \"b3\", \"ink_path\": \"wait_for_clarification\", \"choice_text\": \"Wait for Sella to clarify the packet's status before taking further action.\", \"action_type\": \"wait\", \"actor_intent_private\": \"Allow Sella to set the frame without imposing Maer's urgency.\", \"observable_action\": \"Maer remains in the room, monitoring the display and Sella's response.\", \"spoken_text\": \"I will wait for your read on this.\", \"state_basis\": \"The scene is paused, and Sella has the authority to set the next step.\", \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\"Sella may clarify the packet's status.\", \"Sella may reject the packet.\", \"Sella may ask for more time.\", \"The room remains quiet.\"], \"training_hooks\": [\"wait_for_clarification\", \"pause_for_authority\", \"respect_for_frame\"]}, {\"branch_id\": \"b4\", \"ink_path\": \"pressure_for_decision\", \"choice_text\": \"Press the moral frame by stating that rescue waits for perfect categories.\", \"action_type\": \"speak\", \"actor_intent_private\": \"Make the cost of waiting explicit without demanding Sella's compliance.\", \"observable_text\": \"Maer speaks through the clinic's acoustic system, framing the urgency of the situation.\", \"spoken_text\": \"If we wait for perfect categories, the corridor teaches fear to go silent. Rescue ledgers decide whether route law is trusted by crews who have nothing left to bargain with.\", \"state_basis\": \"Maer's voice is available through the clinic's acoustic system.\", \"expected_consequence_surfaces\": [\"Sella may feel the pressure of the moral frame.\", \"Sella may reject the pressure.\", \"Sella may acknowledge the urgency.\", \"Sella may feel the weight of the decision.\"], \"training_hooks\": [\"moral_pressure\", \"urgency_framing\", \"route_law_context\"]}" + } + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..57a09f1 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Sella-local appraisal generator. Call record_sella_appraisal exactly once. +Do not use Maer's private intent. Do not write her next action. + +{ + "task": "Generate Sella's participant appraisal/consolidation for one observable Maer event.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "appraisal" + ], + "appraisal_fields": [ + "responder_agent_id", + "private_interpretation", + "attributed_motive", + "misread_risk", + "immediate_state_deltas", + "relationship_deltas", + "belief_updates", + "response_constraints" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Sella's local awareness plus the observable Maer action.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.", + "Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "This pass proposes reviewed state changes for Sella caused by the event. Do not write Sella's next action.", + "Keep deltas small and bounded between -0.20 and 0.20.", + "State delta paths must be chosen from the tool schema enum; do not invent abstract resource paths like sanctuary_capacity.", + "Relationship deltas must use relationship_id rel-sella-maer and a valid stance axis from the tool schema enum." + ], + "scene_observable_context": { + "scene_id": "scene-02-sanctuary-intake", + "location": "Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks", + "public_stakes": [ + "The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.", + "Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.", + "Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds." + ] + }, + "observable_maer_action": { + "actor_id": "maer_tidecall", + "action_type": "show_object", + "observable_action": "The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board.", + "spoken_text": "Here is the packet. It is not proof, but it is a request." + }, + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- The clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\n- Observed event: The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board. Spoken text: Here is the packet. It is not proof, but it is a request.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4ed83e8 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.sella-appraisal.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,84 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "id": "call_l6hsfxn6", + "function": { + "index": 0, + "name": "record_sella_appraisal", + "arguments": { + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "private_interpretation": "Maer is showing the packet to the triage board, framing it as a request rather than proof. He wants the sanctuary to keep a place open for a rescue that the tribunal refuses to own. He is asking care systems to absorb the moral cost of a claim he cannot materially house.", + "attributed_motive": "Maer wants the sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own, asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "misread_risk": "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "immediate_state_deltas": [ + { + "delta": 0.08, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.anxiety.current_activation", + "rationale": "The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board. Sella feels the pressure of uncertainty and the risk of scarce resources being spent on an unresolved claim." + }, + { + "delta": 0.12, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure.current_activation", + "rationale": "Sella must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. She must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate while treating care as logistics." + }, + { + "delta": -0.05, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.withdrawal.current_activation", + "rationale": "Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and wants connection or backing to matter, but she also feels the pressure of scarcity and the need to protect triage." + }, + { + "delta": 0.03, + "path": "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.interpersonal_warmth.current_activation", + "rationale": "Sella answers warmly but does not soften the capacity limits. She treats care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty." + }, + { + "delta": 0.15, + "path": "canonical_state.situational_state.exhaustion.current_activation", + "rationale": "The clinic is nearly full, and Sella is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted. She has less spare tolerance than the words may show." + } + ], + "relationship_deltas": [ + { + "delta": 0.02, + "path": "trust", + "rationale": "Sella believes Maer means rescue honestly, but she also knows that good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed. Her trust is present but cautious.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + }, + { + "delta": 0.05, + "path": "respect", + "rationale": "Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her respect is strong but tinged with resentment.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + }, + { + "delta": -0.03, + "path": "perceived_status_gap", + "rationale": "Sella feels a background perceived status gap, as Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, and show or withhold the packet, while she controls sanctuary intake.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + }, + { + "delta": 0.04, + "path": "moral_disgust", + "rationale": "Sella knows that every yes spends a limited resource, and she resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her moral disgust is background but present.", + "relationship_id": "rel-sella-maer" + } + ], + "belief_updates": [ + "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.", + "Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them." + ], + "response_constraints": [ + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.", + "Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.", + "Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.", + "Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty." + ] + } + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.sella.prompt.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.sella.prompt.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..102c22c --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.sella.prompt.md @@ -0,0 +1,105 @@ +You are Ghostlight's Sella-local next-action generator. Call record_sella_next_action exactly once. +Use reviewed event appraisal as the changed state she is acting from. + +{ + "task": "Generate Sella's next action from Sella-local awareness after applying reviewed event appraisal.", + "output_contract": { + "format": "Call the provided tool exactly once. Do not write plain assistant content.", + "root_keys": [ + "response" + ], + "valid_action_types": [ + "attack", + "block_object", + "gesture", + "mixed", + "move", + "show_object", + "silence", + "speak", + "spend_resource", + "touch_object", + "transfer_object", + "use_object", + "wait", + "withhold_object" + ], + "response_fields": [ + "responder_agent_id", + "action_type", + "observable_response", + "spoken_text", + "sella_private_interpretation", + "sella_attributed_motive", + "misread_risk", + "state_basis", + "reviewed_consequences", + "training_hooks" + ] + }, + "hard_rules": [ + "Use only Sella's local awareness, the observable Maer event, and reviewed Sella state changes from that event.", + "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", + "Do not read Maer's private intent. Treat actor intent as unavailable.", + "Sella may correctly read, partially read, or misread Maer's action.", + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Do not accept without cost, condition, authority defense, or resentment risk.", + "Use action_type values only from this exact enum: attack, block_object, gesture, mixed, move, show_object, silence, speak, spend_resource, touch_object, transfer_object, use_object, wait, withhold_object.", + "Use semantic training hooks, not branch ids." + ], + "scene_observable_context": { + "scene_id": "scene-02-sanctuary-intake", + "location": "Aya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks", + "public_stakes": [ + "The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.", + "Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.", + "Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds." + ] + }, + "observable_maer_action": { + "actor_id": "maer_tidecall", + "action_type": "show_object", + "observable_action": "The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board.", + "spoken_text": "Here is the packet. It is not proof, but it is a request." + }, + "sella_immediate_appraisal_context": { + "private_interpretation": "Maer is showing the packet to the triage board, framing it as a request rather than proof. He wants the sanctuary to keep a place open for a rescue that the tribunal refuses to own. He is asking care systems to absorb the moral cost of a claim he cannot materially house.", + "attributed_motive": "Maer wants the sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own, asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "misread_risk": "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "belief_updates": [ + "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.", + "Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them." + ], + "response_constraints": [ + "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.", + "Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.", + "Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits.", + "Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty." + ], + "state_change_summary": [ + "The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board. Sella feels the pressure of uncertainty and the risk of scarce resources being spent on an unresolved claim.", + "Sella must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. She must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate while treating care as logistics.", + "Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and wants connection or backing to matter, but she also feels the pressure of scarcity and the need to protect triage.", + "Sella answers warmly but does not soften the capacity limits. She treats care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.", + "The clinic is nearly full, and Sella is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted. She has less spare tolerance than the words may show.", + "Sella believes Maer means rescue honestly, but she also knows that good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed. Her trust is present but cautious.", + "Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her respect is strong but tinged with resentment.", + "Sella feels a background perceived status gap, as Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, and show or withhold the packet, while she controls sanctuary intake.", + "Sella knows that every yes spends a limited resource, and she resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her moral disgust is background but present." + ] + }, + "projected_local_context": "# Ghostlight Local Operating Context: sella_ren\n\nUse this as character-local operating context, not omniscient story truth.\nDo not infer private state for anyone else unless it is explicitly framed as this character's current read.\n\n## Speaker\nSella Ren: Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator, corridor clinic triage lead. Origin: Aya care network embedded in Ganymede dockside sanctuary logistics. A triage coordinator with soft eyes, hard capacity limits, and no patience for mercy performed after the math is done.\n\n## Setting\nAya-aligned intake clinic tucked behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. Aetheria pre-Elysium historical flashpoint: Cold Wake Panic, 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic.\n\n## Known Facts\n- The clinic is nearly full.\n- The packet may contain a personhood claim but is not proof.\n- Maer is asking sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own.\n- Speaker belief: Maer means rescue honestly.\n- Speaker belief: Good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed.\n- Observed event: The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board. Spoken text: Here is the packet. It is not proof, but it is a request.\n\n## Current Stakes\n- The distress vessel has sent a corrupted packet that may contain medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony.\n- Sanctuary beds and repair capacity are nearly exhausted.\n- Maer wants Sella to keep a place open if rescue succeeds.\n\n## Embodiment And Interface\n- Use only the body, tools, interfaces, and movement affordances established by this character's fixture and the current scene.\n\n## Active Inner Pressures\n- Strong pressure: wants connection or backing to matter.\n- Strong pressure: feels risk before it becomes visible.\n- Present pressure: expects hidden motives or missing information.\n- Background pressure: may reduce contact rather than keep negotiating.\n- Dominant pressure: knows that every yes spends a limited resource.\n- Strong pressure: has less spare tolerance than the words may show.\n- Strong pressure: is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted.\n- Present pressure: performs capability so panic has nowhere obvious to land.\n- Background pressure: may stage the ethical frame for the room.\n- Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person. Emotional stake: Sella cannot feed a principle, but she will not let scarcity become permission to call someone cargo.\n- Sella once watched a sanctuary overpromise safety and turn refuge into a sorting machine with kinder lighting.\n- Care is not a feeling; it is beds, food, air, consent, repair, and someone still doing the list when the room hates them.\n\n## Relationship Read\n- Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and worries he will spend sanctuary capacity with beautiful words. Current stance pressures: strong respect, present trust, background perceived status gap, background moral disgust.\n- Believes: Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house. Known bias in the read: false_reassurance.\n\n## Tensions\n- Wants the goal to move now, but must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate. Goal pressure: Keep sanctuary intake materially possible without letting classification erase a potential person.\n- Must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. Presentation pressure: Speak warmly but do not soften the capacity limits. Treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.\n- Respects Maer's rescue ethic but resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent.\n\n## Action Affordances\n- Can inspect, refuse, withhold the packet from intake flow, demand ledger backing, set conditions, reserve a bounded bay, or walk away to protect triage.\n- Must treat care as capacity: beds, food, air, consent, repair, and follow-through.\n\n## Projection Controls\n- Frame Controls: Frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer.\n- Authority Boundaries: Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, show or withhold the packet, and incur obligation; Sella controls sanctuary intake.\n- Object Custody: The corrupted packet can be shown, withheld, or summarized, but it cannot be treated as clean proof.\n- Required Semantics: Care must remain logistics and obligation, not just compassion.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not resolve whether the packet contains a person.\n- Forbidden Resolutions: Do not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk.\n\n## Voice Surface\n- Dominant voice tendency: responsive; answers what was actually heard.\n- Strong voice tendency: plainspoken; direct and low-ornament.\n- Strong voice tendency: warm; reassuring or gentle in wording.\n- Strong voice tendency: emotionally explicit; names feelings directly.\n- Present voice tendency: pointed; can sharpen a line.\n- Background voice tendency: expansive; willing to spend words.\n- Background voice tendency: theatrical; performs the room.\n\n## Likely Response Moves\n- Likely to translate emotion into logistics: what bed, what air, what backing, what contamination risk.\n- May withhold acceptance, demand conditions, or physically keep the packet out of intake flow until the cost is named.\n- Can answer warmly while still refusing the frame that compassion manufactures capacity.\n\n## Do Not Invent\n- Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.\n- Do not invent clean proof, clean capacity, or authority this character does not have.\n- Treat the observed event as observable behavior only; private intent belongs to the actor and is not available.", + "projector_audit": { + "projector": "tools/project_local_context.py", + "raw_state_hidden_from_prompt": true, + "character_local_context_only": true, + "omitted_private_context": [ + "Other agents' canonical private state is not included.", + "Actor private intent is not included in listener prompts; only observable events are included.", + "Author-only hidden resolution of packet personhood is not included." + ], + "review_status": "draft" + } +} diff --git a/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.sella.response.md b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.sella.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..34bc7e2 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/ink/cold-wake-sanctuary-intake-qwen-sequential-v17-prompt-leak-validated-no-think.sella.response.md @@ -0,0 +1,41 @@ +{ + "content": "", + "thinking": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "id": "call_zv5n8xv2", + "function": { + "index": 0, + "name": "record_sella_next_action", + "arguments": { + "response": { + "action_type": "speak", + "misread_risk": "Maer may ask care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "observable_response": "The packet sits on the triage board, its data stream flickering. I look at Maer, then at the nearly full ward, and speak.", + "responder_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "reviewed_consequences": "If I speak the cost, Maer may accept the ledger backing and the moral weight, or he may walk away. If he accepts, I can reserve a bay, but only if he names the risk and who breathes less. If he does not accept, I must protect triage and not let uncertainty become proof. I must not resolve whether the packet contains a person. I must not make Sella accept without cost, condition, or resentment risk. I must frame the scene as capacity negotiation under uncertainty, not a morality duel with a clean answer. I must speak warmly but not soften the capacity limits. I must treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.", + "sella_attributed_motive": "Maer wants the sanctuary to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own, asking care systems to carry the moral cost of a rescue claim he cannot materially house.", + "sella_private_interpretation": "Maer is asking care systems to absorb risk the tribunal refuses to own. He wants the sanctuary to keep a place open if rescue succeeds. I respect his rescue ethic, but I resent the beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. I know that good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed. I must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate while treating care as logistics. I cannot resolve whether the packet contains a person, but I must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. I have less spare tolerance than the words may show. I must speak warmly but not soften the capacity limits. I must treat care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty.", + "spoken_text": "Maer, I hear you. But this packet is not proof. It is a request. And requests cost. We have no spare beds. We have no spare air. If we open a place for this, someone else breathes less. I will not pretend uncertainty is proof. I will not let beautiful words spend a bed someone else needed. If you want a place open, you must name the cost. You must name the risk. You must name who breathes less. I can reserve a bay, but only if you accept the ledger backing and the moral weight. I can speak warmth, but I cannot manufacture capacity. Speak the cost. Speak the risk. Speak the personhood. Or walk away. The ward is full. The math is hard. The beds are gone.", + "state_basis": "The packet is routed through the clinic's display system, its data stream rendered on the triage board. Sella feels the pressure of uncertainty and the risk of scarce resources being spent on an unresolved claim. Sella must act under uncertainty without pretending uncertainty has become proof. She must preserve the social frame that makes the goal legitimate while treating care as logistics. Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and wants connection or backing to matter, but she also feels the pressure of scarcity and the need to protect triage. Sella answers warmly but does not soften the capacity limits. She treats care as logistics and personhood as unresolved, not sentimental certainty. The clinic is nearly full, and Sella is taking in more demand than can be cleanly sorted. She has less spare tolerance than the words may show. Sella believes Maer means rescue honestly, but she also knows that good intentions can still spend beds someone else needed. Her trust is present but cautious. Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic, but she resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her respect is strong but tinged with resentment. Sella feels a background perceived status gap, as Maer can ask, offer ledger backing, and show or withhold the packet, while she controls sanctuary intake. Sella knows that every yes spends a limited resource, and she resents beautiful moral pressure when beds are already spent. Her moral disgust is background but present.", + "training_hooks": [ + "capacity_negotiation", + "uncertainty_understanding", + "moral_disgust", + "resentment_risk", + "ledger_backing", + "moral_weight", + "bed_scarcity", + "personhood_unresolved", + "care_as_logistics", + "warm_but_firm", + "triage_protection", + "status_gap", + "moral_disgust_background" + ] + } + } + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md b/notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md index ba84cca..ab03ee4 100644 --- a/notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md +++ b/notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md @@ -148,9 +148,10 @@ narrow elaboration before treating the detail as available to Ghostlight. ## Current Next Action -Run another Qwen pass through the source-checked Navigator projector, then -review whether the patched AetheriaLore ergonomics produce cleaner action -proposals before generalizing the sequential materializer. +Revise the Sella next-action prompt/rendering path so responder prose does not +copy prompt constraints into in-world dialogue, then rerun the source-checked +Navigator sequential pass and materialize only a capture with no failure or +repair notes. Cat/Oz remains useful as an Elysium procedural mechanics fixture, but grounded training data should start from authored historical lore rather than gameplay @@ -283,6 +284,12 @@ Remaining projection path: - run another Qwen pass through the source-checked projector to test whether patched Navigator habitat/interface lore improves Maer's generated action proposals +- v11-v17 did improve Maer's source-grounded embodiment, but no capture was + materialized because Sella appraisal/response still exposed object-custody + drift, invented mutation paths, Qwen tool dropout, or prompt-constraint + leakage +- next pass should focus on separating response constraints from in-world prose + before chasing another materialized Ink branch - decide whether to polish this Ink text by hand or generalize the sequential materializer for future accepted captures - preserve the no-thinking default for strict tool-call generation unless a diff --git a/notes/ghostlight-current-system-map.md b/notes/ghostlight-current-system-map.md index 5ba40bf..09165c4 100644 --- a/notes/ghostlight-current-system-map.md +++ b/notes/ghostlight-current-system-map.md @@ -269,6 +269,8 @@ instead of tool-call completion, so strict sequential generation now disables thinking by default. v10 validated that correction with an accepted-as-draft projector-routed no-thinking capture, which has now been materialized into Ink plus reviewed mutation training data. The next implementation target is -running another source-checked Qwen pass after the AetheriaLore Navigator -habitat/interface patch, then reviewing whether the generated action proposals -improve before generalizing the materializer. +fixing the Sella next-action prompt/rendering path after source-checked v11-v17 +retries improved Maer's Navigator embodiment but exposed object-custody drift, +invalid appraisal paths, Qwen tool dropout, and prompt-constraint leakage into +responder prose. Do not materialize another capture until it has no failure or +repair notes. diff --git a/notes/ghostlight-implementation-plan.md b/notes/ghostlight-implementation-plan.md index 1ec8573..cac72b4 100644 --- a/notes/ghostlight-implementation-plan.md +++ b/notes/ghostlight-implementation-plan.md @@ -163,6 +163,17 @@ projector, review whether the patched AetheriaLore ergonomics produce cleaner action proposals, then decide whether to polish the branch or generalize the materializer for additional accepted captures. + - Source-checked retry results: v11-v17 improved Maer's body/interface + behavior substantially, producing packet actions through shared clinic + displays and mixed wet/dry affordances instead of humanoid action. No + capture was materialized because later passes exposed repair notes, + object-custody drift, invented mutation paths, one Qwen appraisal + tool-call dropout, and prompt-constraint leakage into Sella prose. + - Validation correction: the sequential runner now checks Maer embodiment, + Cold Wake object semantics, Sella appraisal paths/relationship ids, and + prompt leakage in responder prose. The next implementation move should + make responder prose less likely to copy constraints verbatim before + trying to materialize another capture. 5. Build the projection distillation loop. Started. - Use `docs/architecture/projection-distillation-plan.md` as the teacher to diff --git a/state/evidence.jsonl b/state/evidence.jsonl index a33d520..b0ffe78 100644 --- a/state/evidence.jsonl +++ b/state/evidence.jsonl @@ -45,3 +45,4 @@ {"ts": "2026-05-02T03:23:47+00:00", "type": "design", "status": "accepted", "note": "Corrected embodiment lesson: Ghostlight should check AetheriaLore faction source before projecting faction-specific action affordances. Navigator lore supports fluid architecture, acoustic signaling, communal orientation chambers, translation/coexistence, and specialized cetacean environments; precise clinic workstation ergonomics remain a source-lore gap."} {"ts": "2026-05-02T03:29:28+00:00", "type": "design", "status": "accepted", "note": "Formalized Aetheria generation doctrine: source-check factions, movements, institutions, location, time period, species/body affordances, infrastructure, and material constraints before writing or generating; patch blocking AetheriaLore gaps narrowly before treating details as available to projection."} {"ts": "2026-05-02T03:29:51+00:00", "type": "documentation", "status": "ok", "note": "Added source-first Aetheria generation doctrine and patched AetheriaLore Cetacean Navigators with habitat/interface ergonomics so Navigator action affordances can be projected from source rather than local improvisation."} +{"ts": "2026-05-02T03:46:05+00:00", "type": "experiment", "status": "mixed", "note": "Source-checked Navigator projection improved Maer action proposals: v13-v17 route packets through shared clinic displays and wet/dry interface affordances instead of human body defaults. No capture was materialized; failures exposed object-custody drift, invented mutation paths, Qwen appraisal tool dropouts, and prompt-constraint leakage into Sella prose."} diff --git a/state/map.yaml b/state/map.yaml index f649be2..cb6d724 100644 --- a/state/map.yaml +++ b/state/map.yaml @@ -135,7 +135,8 @@ accepted_design: - Embodiment and interface affordances belong in projected local context, but Aetheria faction-specific affordances must be checked against lore source before projection; current Navigator source supports fluid architecture, acoustic signaling, soft navigation light, layered water motifs, communal orientation chambers, mixed-species translation/coexistence, specialized cetacean environments, and mixed wet/dry interface ergonomics. - Ghostlight's Aetheria generation doctrine is source-first and source-repairing: if a blocking lore gap appears while generating scenes or training data, patch AetheriaLore with a narrow elaboration before treating the detail as available to Ghostlight projection. - AetheriaLore now includes Navigator habitat and interface ergonomics for mixed wet/dry, acoustic, translation, and shared operational spaces, so future Navigator scenes should cite that source instead of improvising body affordances. + - Source-checked Navigator retries v11-v17 improved Maer's generated action affordances but were not materialized; remaining blockers are object-custody semantics, valid appraisal/mutation paths, Qwen tool reliability, and prompt-constraint leakage into responder prose. current_status: - summary: Ghostlight now has the Epiphany-style persistence spine, the first architecture payload, the v0 canonical agent-state schema seam, prompt projection docs, immediate schema fixes from evaluation, first reviewed Cat/Oz projection examples, a revised Aetheria lore-grounding architecture, a lore grounding digest schema, the first draft Cold Wake historical grounding digest, a Cold Wake story-lab fixture, projection controls, validated Qwen capture receipts, a complete Cold Wake short story assembled from accepted projection outputs, a hand-authored Ink-backed Cold Wake branching scene, the first Qwen-generated Ink draft materialized from local awareness with reviewed training annotations, the first reviewed sequential branch mutation that updates both Maer and Sella after a sanctuary intake beat, a v2 sequential Qwen capture proving the symmetrical turn shape produces better action behavior, a v5 sequential Qwen capture proving local thinking-plus-tools invocation works for the scene runner, the first projected-local-context seam that routes sequential prompts through character-local operating prose instead of raw state variables, tightened receipt handling for projector-routed Qwen failures, a default no-thinking policy for strict sequential tool calls, a v10 no-thinking projector-routed capture accepted as draft, the first materialized projector-routed sequential Ink scene with reviewed mutation training data, a source-checked embodiment/interface projection surface for Navigator scenes, and a formal source-first Aetheria generation doctrine. - next_action: Run another Qwen pass through the source-checked Navigator projector, then review whether the patched AetheriaLore ergonomics produce cleaner action proposals before generalizing the sequential materializer. + summary: Ghostlight now has the Epiphany-style persistence spine, the first architecture payload, the v0 canonical agent-state schema seam, prompt projection docs, immediate schema fixes from evaluation, first reviewed Cat/Oz projection examples, a revised Aetheria lore-grounding architecture, a lore grounding digest schema, the first draft Cold Wake historical grounding digest, a Cold Wake story-lab fixture, projection controls, validated Qwen capture receipts, a complete Cold Wake short story assembled from accepted projection outputs, a hand-authored Ink-backed Cold Wake branching scene, the first Qwen-generated Ink draft materialized from local awareness with reviewed training annotations, the first reviewed sequential branch mutation that updates both Maer and Sella after a sanctuary intake beat, a v2 sequential Qwen capture proving the symmetrical turn shape produces better action behavior, a v5 sequential Qwen capture proving local thinking-plus-tools invocation works for the scene runner, the first projected-local-context seam that routes sequential prompts through character-local operating prose instead of raw state variables, tightened receipt handling for projector-routed Qwen failures, a default no-thinking policy for strict sequential tool calls, a v10 no-thinking projector-routed capture accepted as draft, the first materialized projector-routed sequential Ink scene with reviewed mutation training data, a source-checked embodiment/interface projection surface for Navigator scenes, a formal source-first Aetheria generation doctrine, and v11-v17 source-checked retry receipts showing improved Maer embodiment plus remaining Sella response/prompt-leak blockers. + next_action: Revise the Sella next-action prompt/rendering path so response constraints stay out of in-world prose, then rerun the source-checked Navigator sequential pass and materialize only a capture with no failure or repair notes. diff --git a/tools/run_qwen_ink_sequential_generation.py b/tools/run_qwen_ink_sequential_generation.py index 1394987..18720c2 100644 --- a/tools/run_qwen_ink_sequential_generation.py +++ b/tools/run_qwen_ink_sequential_generation.py @@ -39,6 +39,34 @@ VALID_ACTION_TYPES = { "wait", "mixed", } +VALID_RELATIONSHIP_IDS = {"rel-sella-maer", "rel-maer-sella"} +VALID_RELATIONSHIP_DELTA_PATHS = { + "trust", + "respect", + "resentment", + "dependence", + "fear", + "fascination", + "obligation", + "envy", + "moral_disgust", + "perceived_status_gap", + "expectation_of_care", + "expectation_of_betrayal", +} +VALID_SELLA_STATE_DELTA_PATHS = { + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure.current_activation", + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.suspicion.current_activation", + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.anxiety.current_activation", + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.withdrawal.current_activation", + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.attachment_seeking.current_activation", + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.interpersonal_warmth.current_activation", + "canonical_state.situational_state.scarcity_pressure.current_activation", + "canonical_state.situational_state.exhaustion.current_activation", + "canonical_state.situational_state.overstimulation.current_activation", + "canonical_state.presentation_strategy.competence_theater.current_activation", + "canonical_state.presentation_strategy.moral_theater.current_activation", +} def string_array_schema(description: str) -> dict[str, Any]: @@ -103,7 +131,7 @@ def sella_appraisal_tool() -> dict[str, Any]: "type": "object", "required": ["path", "delta", "rationale"], "properties": { - "path": {"type": "string"}, + "path": {"type": "string", "enum": sorted(VALID_SELLA_STATE_DELTA_PATHS)}, "delta": {"type": "number"}, "rationale": {"type": "string"}, }, @@ -112,8 +140,8 @@ def sella_appraisal_tool() -> dict[str, Any]: "type": "object", "required": ["relationship_id", "path", "delta", "rationale"], "properties": { - "relationship_id": {"type": "string"}, - "path": {"type": "string"}, + "relationship_id": {"type": "string", "enum": ["rel-sella-maer"]}, + "path": {"type": "string", "enum": sorted(VALID_RELATIONSHIP_DELTA_PATHS)}, "delta": {"type": "number"}, "rationale": {"type": "string"}, }, @@ -390,7 +418,21 @@ def request_qwen_tool( "keep_alive": "10m", "options": {"num_ctx": num_ctx, "temperature": temperature, "top_p": top_p}, } - raw = post_json(endpoint, request_payload, timeout) + try: + raw = post_json(endpoint, request_payload, timeout) + except Exception as exc: + raw = {"model": model, "error": repr(exc)} + response_text = json.dumps( + { + "content": "", + "thinking": None, + "tool_calls": [], + "error": repr(exc), + }, + indent=2, + ensure_ascii=False, + ) + return raw, response_text, None, [f"request failed for {expected_tool_name}: {exc!r}"] message = raw.get("message", {}) response_text = json.dumps( { @@ -444,6 +486,9 @@ def build_maer_prompt(fixture: dict[str, Any], annotation: dict[str, Any]) -> st "Do not stringify nested arrays or objects inside tool arguments.", "Do not include Sella's private state, private motives, or future response.", "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", + "Maer is a cetacean Navigator: do not describe him standing, walking, stepping, leaning, using hands, using pockets, or blocking a doorway.", + "Maer's physical actions should use shared clinic systems, mixed wet/dry work surfaces, displays, acoustic or translation systems, pressure fields, haptic waterflow, neural interfaces, or delegated crew action.", + "Do not describe ledger backing as a property of the packet. The packet can be shown, withheld, summarized, scanned, or rendered through clinic systems; route-ledger backing is a separate resource offer.", "Include at least two non-speech choices.", f"Use action_type values only from this exact enum: {', '.join(sorted(VALID_ACTION_TYPES))}.", "The selected branch must be reducible to observable action for Sella.", @@ -496,6 +541,8 @@ def build_sella_appraisal_prompt(fixture: dict[str, Any], annotation: dict[str, "Do not resolve whether the corrupted packet contains a person.", "This pass proposes reviewed state changes for Sella caused by the event. Do not write Sella's next action.", "Keep deltas small and bounded between -0.20 and 0.20.", + "State delta paths must be chosen from the tool schema enum; do not invent abstract resource paths like sanctuary_capacity.", + "Relationship deltas must use relationship_id rel-sella-maer and a valid stance axis from the tool schema enum.", ], "scene_observable_context": { "scene_id": scene_id, @@ -614,6 +661,8 @@ def validate_choice_payload(parsed: Any) -> list[str]: for list_key in ["expected_consequence_surfaces", "training_hooks"]: if not isinstance(choice.get(list_key), list): notes.append(f"choices[{index}] {list_key} must be an array") + notes.extend(validate_maer_embodiment(choice, f"choices[{index}]")) + notes.extend(validate_cold_wake_object_semantics(choice, f"choices[{index}]")) if choice.get("action_type") != "speak": non_speech += 1 if non_speech < 2: @@ -621,6 +670,46 @@ def validate_choice_payload(parsed: Any) -> list[str]: return notes +def validate_maer_embodiment(choice: dict[str, Any], path: str) -> list[str]: + text = " ".join(str(choice.get(key, "")) for key in ["choice_text", "observable_action", "spoken_text", "state_basis"]) + banned = [ + "hand", + "hands", + "pocket", + "pockets", + "stand", + "stands", + "standing", + "walk", + "walks", + "walking", + "step", + "steps", + "stepping", + "lean", + "leans", + "leaning", + "doorway", + "doorframe", + ] + hits = [word for word in banned if re.search(rf"\b{re.escape(word)}\b", text, re.IGNORECASE)] + if hits: + return [f"{path} violates Maer cetacean embodiment constraints: {', '.join(sorted(set(hits)))}"] + return [] + + +def validate_cold_wake_object_semantics(choice: dict[str, Any], path: str) -> list[str]: + text = " ".join(str(choice.get(key, "")) for key in ["choice_text", "observable_action", "spoken_text", "state_basis"]) + notes: list[str] = [] + if re.search(r"\bpacket'?s ledger backing\b", text, re.IGNORECASE): + notes.append(f"{path} conflates packet object custody with route-ledger backing") + if re.search(r"\bpacket has weight\b|\bpacket's weight\b|\btangible object with potential value\b", text, re.IGNORECASE): + notes.append(f"{path} treats the ambiguous packet as weighted evidence beyond source constraints") + if choice.get("action_type") == "show_object" and re.search(r"\bledger backing\b", text, re.IGNORECASE): + notes.append(f"{path} uses show_object for ledger backing; use spend_resource for backing or show_object for the packet itself") + return notes + + def validate_appraisal_payload(parsed: Any) -> list[str]: if not isinstance(parsed, dict): return ["appraisal was not an object"] @@ -641,6 +730,23 @@ def validate_appraisal_payload(parsed: Any) -> list[str]: for list_key in ["immediate_state_deltas", "relationship_deltas", "response_constraints"]: if list_key in appraisal and not isinstance(appraisal[list_key], list): notes.append(f"appraisal.{list_key} must be an array") + for index, delta in enumerate(appraisal.get("immediate_state_deltas", [])): + if not isinstance(delta, dict): + notes.append(f"appraisal.immediate_state_deltas[{index}] must be an object") + continue + path = str(delta.get("path", "")) + if path not in VALID_SELLA_STATE_DELTA_PATHS: + notes.append(f"appraisal.immediate_state_deltas[{index}].path is not an allowed Sella state path: {path}") + for index, delta in enumerate(appraisal.get("relationship_deltas", [])): + if not isinstance(delta, dict): + notes.append(f"appraisal.relationship_deltas[{index}] must be an object") + continue + relationship_id = str(delta.get("relationship_id", "")) + path = str(delta.get("path", "")) + if relationship_id not in VALID_RELATIONSHIP_IDS: + notes.append(f"appraisal.relationship_deltas[{index}].relationship_id must be a relationship id, got {relationship_id}") + if path not in VALID_RELATIONSHIP_DELTA_PATHS: + notes.append(f"appraisal.relationship_deltas[{index}].path is not a relationship stance axis: {path}") return notes @@ -657,9 +763,42 @@ def validate_response_payload(parsed: Any) -> list[str]: notes.append("response invalid action_type") if "training_hooks" in response and not isinstance(response["training_hooks"], list): notes.append("response.training_hooks must be an array") + notes.extend(validate_response_prompt_leakage(response)) return notes +def validate_response_prompt_leakage(response: dict[str, Any]) -> list[str]: + text = " ".join( + str(response.get(key, "")) + for key in [ + "observable_response", + "spoken_text", + "reviewed_consequences", + "sella_private_interpretation", + "state_basis", + ] + ) + leaked_patterns = [ + r"\bDo not resolve\b", + r"\bDo not accept\b", + r"\bDo not let\b", + r"\bmust not resolve\b", + r"\bmust not make\b", + r"\bmust frame the scene\b", + r"\bmust speak warmly\b", + r"\bmust treat care\b", + r"\bSpeak warmly\b", + r"\bDemand ledger backing\b", + r"\btreat it as unresolved uncertainty\b", + r"\bKeep sanctuary intake materially possible\b", + r"\bSpeak the personhood\b", + ] + hits = [pattern for pattern in leaked_patterns if re.search(pattern, text, re.IGNORECASE)] + if hits: + return [f"response appears to leak prompt constraints into prose: {', '.join(hits)}"] + return [] + + def choose_selected_choice(parsed: Any, preferred_action: str) -> dict[str, Any]: choices = parsed.get("choices", []) if isinstance(parsed, dict) else [] for choice in choices: @@ -808,6 +947,66 @@ def main() -> int: sella_appraisal_notes.extend(validate_appraisal_payload(sella_appraisal_parsed)) appraisal = sella_appraisal_parsed.get("appraisal") if isinstance(sella_appraisal_parsed, dict) else None + appraisal_fatal_notes = fatal_notes(sella_appraisal_notes) + if appraisal_fatal_notes: + capture = { + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_ink_sequential_capture.v0", + "capture_id": args.capture_id, + "source_fixture_ref": str(args.fixture.relative_to(ROOT)).replace("\\", "/"), + "source_annotation_ref": str(args.annotation.relative_to(ROOT)).replace("\\", "/"), + "model": maer_raw.get("model", args.model), + "endpoint": args.endpoint, + "request_options": { + "think": args.think, + "api": "ollama_chat_tools", + "num_ctx": args.num_ctx, + "request_timeout": args.request_timeout, + "temperature": args.temperature, + "top_p": args.top_p, + }, + "passes": { + "maer_choice_generation": { + "local_agent_id": "maer_tidecall", + "prompt_text": maer_prompt, + "response_text": maer_response_text, + "parsed_response": maer_parsed, + "validation_notes": maer_notes, + }, + "selected_observable_action": selected_choice, + "sella_immediate_appraisal": { + "local_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "prompt_text": sella_appraisal_prompt, + "response_text": sella_appraisal_response_text, + "parsed_response": sella_appraisal_parsed, + "validation_notes": sella_appraisal_notes, + }, + "sella_response_generation": skipped_pass("sella_ren", "skipped because Sella appraisal failed validation or request"), + }, + "review": { + "status": "useful_needs_revision", + "strengths": [ + "Generated Maer-local choices before the later-pass failure.", + "Captured the failed Sella appraisal pass instead of losing the run.", + ], + "failure_notes": fatal_notes(maer_notes + sella_appraisal_notes), + "repair_notes": repair_notes(maer_notes + sella_appraisal_notes), + "accepted_into_ink_ref": None, + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Later-pass transport or tool failures must still write reviewed receipts.", + "Critical embodiment constraints need post-generation validation; projected prose alone is not enough.", + ], + }, + } + capture_path = write_sequential_artifacts( + args, + capture, + {"maer": maer_prompt, "sella-appraisal": sella_appraisal_prompt}, + {"maer": maer_response_text, "sella-appraisal": sella_appraisal_response_text}, + ) + print(f"wrote {capture_path.relative_to(ROOT)}") + print(json.dumps({"selected_observable_action": selected_choice, "failure_notes": capture["review"]["failure_notes"]}, indent=2, ensure_ascii=False)) + return 0 + sella_prompt = build_sella_prompt(fixture, annotation, selected_choice, appraisal) sella_raw, sella_response_text, sella_parsed, sella_notes = request_qwen_tool( args.endpoint, @@ -865,7 +1064,7 @@ def main() -> int: }, }, "review": { - "status": "accepted_as_draft" if not all_notes else "useful_needs_revision", + "status": "accepted_as_draft" if not all_notes and not repair_note_list else "useful_needs_revision", "strengths": [ "Separated Maer choice generation from Sella next-action generation.", "Inserted participant appraisal/consolidation before next-actor action generation.", @@ -879,6 +1078,7 @@ def main() -> int: "Action type selection should be tool-shaped or schema-constrained, not left to prose compliance.", "Character-local prompts should consume projected operating context, not raw canonical state variables.", "Next-action prompts should receive appraisal context as prose constraints, not raw numeric state deltas.", + "Critical embodiment constraints need post-generation validation; projected prose alone is not enough.", "Next pass should materialize the sequential capture into Ink and mutation training data.", ], },