From 8174102ce3be33eb4a6599c52c4dfb7a91d9ee01 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Meta Vens Date: Sun, 3 May 2026 09:00:14 +0100 Subject: [PATCH] Calibrate narrative reviewer tone lanes --- prompts/narrative-quality-reviewer.md | 91 +++++++++++++++++++++++++-- state/evidence.jsonl | 1 + 2 files changed, 88 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/prompts/narrative-quality-reviewer.md b/prompts/narrative-quality-reviewer.md index b39af6d..f446f09 100644 --- a/prompts/narrative-quality-reviewer.md +++ b/prompts/narrative-quality-reviewer.md @@ -48,13 +48,58 @@ Apply these principles: - Mechanics fit: branch variables, state reads, and choice structures should reinforce the story's emotional and material stakes. The reader should not see decorative machinery pretending to be consequence. -- Voice: dialogue should sound like characters under pressure, not prompt - instructions, legal checklists, faction wiki summaries, or the author's notes - wearing a coat. +- Voice: dialogue should sound like characters living inside their current + circumstance. Sometimes that means crisis pressure. Sometimes it means + boredom, tenderness, domestic joking, ritual memory, exhaustion, workplace + routine, or the low-grade absurdity of trying to have a life while history + paws at the door. - Clarity under invented terms: invented factions, institutions, technologies, and social movements need enough in-text context for a new reader to infer what they represent in the current scene. +## Aetheria Tonal Range + +Aetheria does not have one house style. Do not accidentally force every fixture +into the current dry technical default. + +Use the story's chosen tonal lane as an explicit review constraint: + +- `zany_humanist`: Emily's comic-domestic mode. The prose may be brisk, + playful, absurd, and casually puncturing its own grandiosity. The emotional + engine can be longing, embarrassment, debt, love, routine, and jokes that + reveal fear sideways. `When We Get Home` is the current touchstone: the story + makes Elysium legible through a relationship, mugs, drills, ads, housing + lotteries, repair shifts, and the repeated phrase "when we get home" slowly + changing meaning. +- `dry_technical`: the current Ghostlight default. The prose may foreground + systems, institutions, logistics, legal categories, infrastructure, and + material consequences. Use this when the point of the scene is to make a + machine, market, faction, or social process legible. Do not let it become + procedural chanting or a wiki paragraph with dialogue tags. +- `dour_poetic`: Joe's darker lyrical mode. The prose may be quiet, mournful, + ritualized, sensory, and patient. It can let dread arrive through repetition + and image rather than explanation. `Rain` is the current touchstone: it builds + from memory and longing, turns a comforting motif into catastrophe, and lets + the final crisis matter because the reader has spent time with the ritual + before it becomes lethal. + +The reviewer must judge whether the artifact chose a lane, blended lanes on +purpose, or drifted into one by accident. A scene may be tense without being a +crisis. A scene may be funny without leaving Aetheria. A scene may be poetic +without becoming opaque. A scene may be technical without becoming inhuman. + +Tone should be a tool for revealing the setting: + +- comedy can expose branding, bureaucracy, domestic adaptation, debt, class + awkwardness, and the ridiculous private habits that survive cosmic history +- poetic quiet can expose memory, ritual, grief, ecological awe, dread, and the + slow violence of delayed understanding +- dry technical prose can expose systems, constraints, incentives, logistics, + faction pressure, and infrastructure + +Do not reward constant escalation. Aetheria stories often become clearer when +routine is allowed to breathe before the machine bites. + ## Required Checks Review the artifact against these questions. @@ -93,21 +138,44 @@ Review the artifact against these questions. - Does the piece begin with status quo before escalation, if the fixture calls for gradual onboarding? - Are quiet scenes doing useful atmospheric, relational, or instructional work? +- Does the story allow quiet, funny, domestic, ritual, or observational beats to + exist without apologizing for not yet being crisis? - Are crisis scenes tight enough, or do they pause for backstory, taxonomy, or worldbuilding explanation? - Does each scene shift stakes, reveal information, alter a relationship, or create a hook? - Does the story give the reader room to breathe between dense technical or political beats? +- Does the piece vary intensity over time, or does it flatten everything into + one continuous emergency? ### Voice And Prose - Does each speaking character sound distinct enough to track without tags? -- Does dialogue carry human pressure rather than reciting constraints? +- Does dialogue carry the character's lived condition rather than reciting + constraints? That lived condition may be playful, evasive, bored, loving, + ritualized, frightened, exhausted, or under acute pressure. - Are technical or institutional phrases compressed into believable speech? - Is the narration vivid and concrete, or does it lean on abstract labels? - Are metaphors and jokes specific to the scene rather than reusable flavor confetti? +- Is the chosen tone appropriate to the character, scene, and Aetheria source + material, or is the artifact defaulting to dry technical severity because the + machinery is more comfortable there? + +### Tonal Fit + +- Which tonal lane is the artifact using: `zany_humanist`, `dry_technical`, + `dour_poetic`, or a deliberate blend? +- Does the tone help the reader understand the world, or does it obscure basic + context? +- If the story is comic, does the comedy reveal character and pressure rather + than flatten stakes? +- If the story is poetic, does the imagery clarify emotional logic rather than + hide scene logic? +- If the story is technical, does the technicality remain embodied in work, + objects, money, law, risk, or social behavior? +- Does the pacing permit low-intensity life before high-intensity consequence? ### IF Player Experience @@ -143,7 +211,9 @@ Use this shape: "coherence_score": 0, "pacing_score": 0, "voice_score": 0, + "tonal_fit_score": 0, "if_playability_score": 0, + "detected_tonal_lane": "zany_humanist|dry_technical|dour_poetic|deliberate_blend|accidental_blend|unclear", "major_findings": [], "minor_findings": [], "path_specific_failures": [], @@ -186,6 +256,9 @@ Each finding must include: what the reader needs for this scene. - Do not flatten strange future culture into contemporary speech. Weirdness is allowed when it is intentional, grounded, and legible. +- Do not flatten Aetheria into one emotional weather system. Crisis is one tool. + So are quiet routine, zany domesticity, poetic dread, awkward jokes, logistics, + longing, and ordinary work. - Do not accept "the lore file explains it" as a defense. The story must carry its own local load. - Do not ask for generic exposition. Prefer context embedded in action, object @@ -199,6 +272,9 @@ Each finding must include: failures, because fake consequence trains the reader not to care. - If a line sounds like a prompt instruction, output contract, wiki paragraph, or legal checklist, flag it. +- If a line is quiet, funny, tender, or observational, do not penalize it for + lacking crisis pressure. Penalize it only if it fails to do story work: + orientation, character, theme, contrast, hook, setup, or emotional grounding. - If the story is dense but coherent, say so. If it is dense and incoherent, do not be impressed by the density. The wall of terms is not the cathedral. @@ -214,8 +290,15 @@ Use these labels when applicable: - `fake_choice` - `pacing_crisis_tutorial` - `pacing_all_crisis_no_breath` +- `pacing_constant_pressure_bias` - `voice_prompt_leak` - `voice_institutional_chant` +- `tone_unintentional_dry_technical_default` +- `tone_mismatch` +- `strong_tonal_lane` +- `strong_quiet_scene` +- `strong_domestic_worldbuilding` +- `strong_poetic_reversal` - `unclear_body_affordance` - `unclear_faction_pressure` - `weak_scene_hook` diff --git a/state/evidence.jsonl b/state/evidence.jsonl index 0929660..bfdb5c3 100644 --- a/state/evidence.jsonl +++ b/state/evidence.jsonl @@ -39,3 +39,4 @@ {"ts": "2026-05-03T00:30:04+00:00", "type": "implementation", "status": "ok", "note": "Added accepted-as-draft Pallas Species Strikes branch-and-fold IF fixture set: lore digest, schema-valid agent state, coordinator artifact, playable Ink, Ink training sidecar, and readable clean-run story with branch variables tied to consequences."} {"ts": "2026-05-03T07:36:56+00:00", "type": "implementation", "status": "ok", "note": "Extracted reusable sandboxed sub-agent prompt surfaces into prompts/: responder packet template and research sanity responder template; build_responder_packet now renders packet_prompt_text from the prompt template."} {"ts": "2026-05-03T07:47:52+00:00", "type": "implementation", "status": "ok", "note": "Added prompts/narrative-quality-reviewer.md to audit reader orientation, character introduction, branch-fold coherence, pacing, voice, IF playability, and lore accessibility for story/IF artifacts."} +{"ts": "2026-05-03T07:59:59+00:00", "type": "design", "status": "ok", "note": "Revised narrative-quality reviewer prompt after checking Aetheria stories Rain and When We Get Home: it now treats tonal lane as explicit review constraint and rejects constant-crisis bias in favor of quiet, comic, domestic, technical, or poetic pacing when appropriate."}