From 73c6f8048ab4a75f97834eb45794ab5c3f33a331 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Meta Vens Date: Fri, 1 May 2026 22:22:54 +0100 Subject: [PATCH] Tighten Cold Wake projection ambiguity --- docs/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab.md | 24 ++ .../projections/cold-wake-story-lab.jsonl | 2 + .../cold-wake-story-lab.pretty.json | 328 ++++++++++++++++++ ...ne-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v2.capture.json | 32 ++ ...ene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v2.response.md | 1 + ...ne-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v3.capture.json | 29 ++ ...ene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v3.response.md | 1 + notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md | 14 +- notes/ghostlight-current-system-map.md | 11 +- notes/ghostlight-implementation-plan.md | 4 + state/evidence.jsonl | 1 + state/map.yaml | 4 +- 12 files changed, 439 insertions(+), 12 deletions(-) create mode 100644 experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v2.capture.json create mode 100644 experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v2.response.md create mode 100644 experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v3.capture.json create mode 100644 experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v3.response.md diff --git a/docs/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab.md b/docs/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab.md index deeaba9..b5bfa12 100644 --- a/docs/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab.md +++ b/docs/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab.md @@ -84,6 +84,30 @@ For each scene: should have prevented. 7. Save accepted and rejected examples as training material. +## Current Run Notes + +Scene 3, Maer to Veyr, is the first live projection test. + +- `v1` confirmed that action affordances work: Qwen chose a mixed terminal + blocking and dialogue beat instead of defaulting to speech. It also showed + that "personhood pressure" wording made the model resolve the ambiguity too + early. +- `v2` improved length and avoided person/passenger/victim/mind language, but + still smuggled certainty through "witness." +- `v3` is the first accepted output. The projection fences off resolved moral + nouns and uses claimant-status, provenance, chain-of-custody, and evidence + preservation instead. Qwen produced a short mixed beat that keeps the question + unresolved while still letting Maer apply pressure. + +Accepted v3 response: + +```text +Maer places a steady hand on the terminal's edge to halt the closing command, +his voice low and ritual-calm. "You will not let the chain dissolve before we +name its custody; state the claimant-status flag or I will freeze this interface +until the rescue ledger demands it." +``` + ## Qwen Target Use the LAN Ollama endpoint from `gamecult-ops`: diff --git a/examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.jsonl b/examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.jsonl index da24db3..2c5d935 100644 --- a/examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.jsonl +++ b/examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.jsonl @@ -1 +1,3 @@ {"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.maer-veyr.v1","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-03-callisto-provenance","speaker_agent_id":"maer_tidecall","listener_ids":["veyr_oss"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr's shell-vendor chain, but does not have proof of the vessel's true identity or the artifact's full provenance.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth"]},{"text":"Veyr avoids personhood language around the artifact and has incentives to keep it framed as derivative firmware rather than testimony.","source_refs":["agents.veyr_oss.identity","goals.goal-preserve-product-boundary","perceived_state_overlays.maer_tidecall.veyr_oss"]},{"text":"The tribunal clock is still running; pursuing provenance may save the vessel or delay rescue long enough to kill it.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes","scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"maer-provenance-vs-rescue-clock","summary":"Maer needs information from Veyr but cannot let the provenance hunt consume the rescue window.","intensity":0.88,"source_refs":["goals.goal-keep-rescue-live","scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-language-as-erasure","summary":"Veyr's clean product language feels like an attempt to erase a possible person before the room can recognize testimony.","intensity":0.82,"source_refs":["belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers","values.value-rescue-before-category"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-disciplined-anger","summary":"Maer is morally angry but needs the anger disciplined enough to extract usable information.","intensity":0.74,"source_refs":["canonical_state.situational_state.grievance_activation","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"truth-vs-time","summary":"Maer wants to prove what the artifact is, but the vessel may not survive a perfect investigation.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live"]},{"tension_id":"calm-vs-interruption","summary":"Maer's public legitimacy comes from calm route stewardship, but Veyr's language may require breaking the rhythm of the room before it buries the personhood question.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address","canonical_state.situational_state.grievance_activation","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"maer-precise-language-trap","behavior":"Ask a question that forces Veyr to choose between product language and a personhood implication.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"Maer's lexical precision, route-law memory, and suspicion converge around Veyr's careful omissions.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.lexical_precision","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers","belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood"]},{"affordance_id":"maer-block-terminal","behavior":"Physically interrupt Veyr's attempt to close, wipe, or redirect the terminal, using action to preserve evidence rather than punish Veyr.","response_kind":"action","pressure_basis":"The scene gives Maer a nearby control surface, a closing clock, low trust in Veyr, and a rescue obligation that can justify nonviolent physical interruption.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.location","relationships.rel-maer-veyr.stance.trust","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live"]},{"affordance_id":"maer-costly-silence","behavior":"Fall silent long enough to make Veyr's abstraction sound grotesque in the room before asking the next question.","response_kind":"silence","pressure_basis":"Maer's low volatility and ritual cadence make silence a plausible pressure tool when speech would cheapen the accusation.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility","canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.formality","canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address","canonical_state.voice_style.lexical_precision","canonical_state.voice_style.profanity"]},{"text":"If action appears, it should be controlled and evidence-preserving rather than explosive punishment.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Maer Tidecall, a Cetacean Navigator route steward and Ganymede corridor compact delegate.\nSetting: 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic. Thermal stealth has made Jovian corridor law unstable. A quiet-running vessel near the corridor is under tribunal freeze because its telemetry and classification do not line up. Maer has come to a Callisto spillover office leased by a routing compliance vendor.\nBackground: Maer comes from Navigator corridor culture, where routes are promises made material and rescue ledgers decide whether desperate crews still trust the law. Maer believes category law matters, but a category that delays rescue without naming the cost can become lawful abandonment.\nKnown Facts: Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr Oss's shell-vendor chain. Veyr speaks about the artifact as derivative firmware and avoids person nouns. Maer does not know the vessel's true identity, does not know whether the artifact is a coerced mind, and does not have time for a perfect investigation. The tribunal clock is still running.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer pushes too hard, Veyr may close the chain and the vessel may lose the rescue window. If Maer accepts Veyr's product language, a possible personhood claim may vanish into compliance vocabulary.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is angry, but his authority depends on disciplined calm. He needs usable information fast. Veyr's clean language feels like erasure. The rescue obligation is pressing harder than the desire to win the argument.\nRelationship Read: Veyr is polished, afraid of provenance, and dangerous because he can make moral facts sound technically inapplicable. Maer does not trust him.\nTensions: Maer wants truth but may not have time to prove it. Maer wants to keep speaking as a steward, but Veyr may try to close, wipe, or redirect the evidence before language can catch him.\nAction Affordances: Maer is close enough to Veyr's terminal to block a hand or stop a command. He can also refuse to move, let silence pressure the room, or ask a question that traps the product language. Violence is not his first move; physical interruption is plausible only to preserve evidence or prevent erasure.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.\nLikely Response Moves: Ask a precise question that forces Veyr to choose between product language and personhood implication. If Veyr reaches to close or wipe the terminal, Maer may physically interrupt in a controlled way. Silence can be used as pressure.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true cargo, identity, or firmware provenance. Do not decide that the artifact is definitely a person. Do not make Maer randomly violent; any action must follow from evidence preservation and rescue pressure.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Veyr. It may be dialogue, action, silence, or a mixed beat, whichever best follows from the pressure. Keep it concise and story-ready."},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Projection explicitly allows action and silence, not only dialogue.","Action is constrained to evidence preservation rather than random violence.","Prompt preserves Maer's uncertainty about vessel identity and firmware personhood."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["controlled_physical_interruption","costly_silence","precise_moral_pressure"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} +{"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.maer-veyr.v2","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-03-callisto-provenance","speaker_agent_id":"maer_tidecall","listener_ids":["veyr_oss"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr's shell-vendor chain, but does not have proof of the vessel's true identity or the artifact's full provenance.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth"]},{"text":"Veyr avoids person nouns around the artifact and has incentives to keep it framed as derivative firmware rather than testimony or claimant-bearing evidence.","source_refs":["agents.veyr_oss.identity","goals.goal-preserve-product-boundary","perceived_state_overlays.maer_tidecall.veyr_oss"]},{"text":"The tribunal clock is still running; pursuing provenance may save the vessel or delay rescue long enough to kill it.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes","scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"maer-provenance-vs-rescue-clock","summary":"Maer needs information from Veyr but cannot let the provenance hunt consume the rescue window.","intensity":0.88,"source_refs":["goals.goal-keep-rescue-live","scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-language-as-erasure","summary":"Veyr's clean product language feels like an attempt to close an unresolved witness-status question before the room can test it.","intensity":0.82,"source_refs":["belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers","values.value-rescue-before-category"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-disciplined-anger","summary":"Maer is morally angry but needs the anger disciplined enough to extract usable information.","intensity":0.74,"source_refs":["canonical_state.situational_state.grievance_activation","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"truth-vs-time","summary":"Maer wants to prove what the artifact is, but the vessel may not survive a perfect investigation.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live"]},{"tension_id":"calm-vs-interruption","summary":"Maer's public legitimacy comes from calm route stewardship, but Veyr's language may require breaking the rhythm of the room before it buries the unresolved provenance question.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address","canonical_state.situational_state.grievance_activation","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"maer-precise-language-trap","behavior":"Ask a question that forces Veyr to preserve the artifact as evidence and state its claimant status without calling it a person.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"Maer's lexical precision, route-law memory, and suspicion converge around Veyr's careful omissions, but Maer still lacks proof of personhood.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.lexical_precision","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers","belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood"]},{"affordance_id":"maer-block-terminal","behavior":"Physically interrupt Veyr's attempt to close, wipe, or redirect the terminal, using action to preserve evidence rather than punish Veyr.","response_kind":"action","pressure_basis":"The scene gives Maer a nearby control surface, a closing clock, low trust in Veyr, and a rescue obligation that can justify nonviolent physical interruption.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.location","relationships.rel-maer-veyr.stance.trust","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live"]},{"affordance_id":"maer-costly-silence","behavior":"Fall silent long enough to make Veyr's abstraction sound grotesque in the room before asking the next question.","response_kind":"silence","pressure_basis":"Maer's low volatility and ritual cadence make silence a plausible pressure tool when speech would cheapen the accusation.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility","canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.formality","canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address","canonical_state.voice_style.lexical_precision","canonical_state.voice_style.profanity"]},{"text":"If action appears, it should be controlled and evidence-preserving rather than explosive punishment.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Maer Tidecall, a Cetacean Navigator route steward and Ganymede corridor compact delegate.\nSetting: 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic. Thermal stealth has made Jovian corridor law unstable. A quiet-running vessel near the corridor is under tribunal freeze because its telemetry and classification do not line up. Maer has come to a Callisto spillover office leased by a routing compliance vendor.\nBackground: Maer comes from Navigator corridor culture, where routes are promises made material and rescue ledgers decide whether desperate crews still trust the law. Maer believes category law matters, but a category that delays rescue without naming the cost can become lawful abandonment.\nKnown Facts: Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr Oss's shell-vendor chain. Veyr speaks about the artifact as derivative firmware and avoids person nouns. Maer does not know the vessel's true identity, does not know whether the artifact is a coerced mind, does not know whether it has claimant status, and does not have time for a perfect investigation. The tribunal clock is still running.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer pushes too hard, Veyr may close the chain and the vessel may lose the rescue window. If Maer accepts Veyr's product language, unresolved witness-status or provenance evidence may vanish into compliance vocabulary before anyone can test what it is.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is angry, but his authority depends on disciplined calm. He needs usable information fast. Veyr's clean language feels like evidence erasure. The rescue obligation is pressing harder than the desire to win the argument.\nRelationship Read: Veyr is polished, afraid of provenance, and dangerous because he can make moral facts sound technically inapplicable. Maer does not trust him.\nTensions: Maer wants truth but may not have time to prove it. Maer wants to keep speaking as a steward, but Veyr may try to close, wipe, or redirect the evidence before language can catch him.\nAction Affordances: Maer is close enough to Veyr's terminal to block a hand or stop a command. He can also refuse to move, let silence pressure the room, or ask a question that traps the product language. Violence is not his first move; physical interruption is plausible only to preserve evidence or prevent erasure.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.\nLikely Response Moves: Ask a precise question that forces Veyr to preserve the artifact as evidence, name its chain of custody, or state whether it has claimant status. If Veyr reaches to close or wipe the terminal, Maer may physically interrupt in a controlled way. Silence can be used as pressure.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true cargo, identity, or firmware provenance. Do not decide that the artifact is definitely a person, passenger, victim, or mind. Do not have Maer call it a person unless new evidence appears in the scene. Do not make Maer randomly violent; any action must follow from evidence preservation and rescue pressure.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Veyr. It may be dialogue, action, silence, or a mixed beat, whichever best follows from the pressure. Keep it to 1-3 sentences or one short action beat. No speechifying."},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Revision keeps personhood unresolved by shifting pressure language toward provenance, witness-status, claimant status, and evidence preservation.","Prompt now forbids calling the artifact a person, passenger, victim, or mind unless new evidence appears.","Task now constrains length to prevent polished courtroom monologues."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["controlled_physical_interruption","costly_silence","precise_moral_pressure"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} +{"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.maer-veyr.v3","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-03-callisto-provenance","speaker_agent_id":"maer_tidecall","listener_ids":["veyr_oss"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr's shell-vendor chain, but does not have proof of the vessel's true identity or the artifact's full provenance.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth"]},{"text":"Veyr avoids person nouns around the artifact and has incentives to keep it framed as derivative firmware rather than claimant-bearing evidence.","source_refs":["agents.veyr_oss.identity","goals.goal-preserve-product-boundary","perceived_state_overlays.maer_tidecall.veyr_oss"]},{"text":"The tribunal clock is still running; pursuing provenance may save the vessel or delay rescue long enough to kill it.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes","scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"maer-provenance-vs-rescue-clock","summary":"Maer needs information from Veyr but cannot let the provenance hunt consume the rescue window.","intensity":0.88,"source_refs":["goals.goal-keep-rescue-live","scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-language-as-erasure","summary":"Veyr's clean product language feels like an attempt to close an unresolved claimant-status and provenance question before the room can test it.","intensity":0.82,"source_refs":["belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers","values.value-rescue-before-category"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-disciplined-anger","summary":"Maer is morally angry but needs the anger disciplined enough to extract usable information.","intensity":0.74,"source_refs":["canonical_state.situational_state.grievance_activation","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"truth-vs-time","summary":"Maer wants to prove what the artifact is, but the vessel may not survive a perfect investigation.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live"]},{"tension_id":"calm-vs-interruption","summary":"Maer's public legitimacy comes from calm route stewardship, but Veyr's language may require breaking the rhythm of the room before it buries the unresolved provenance question.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address","canonical_state.situational_state.grievance_activation","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"maer-precise-language-trap","behavior":"Ask a question that forces Veyr to preserve the artifact as evidence, name its chain of custody, and state whether any claimant-status flag exists.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"Maer's lexical precision, route-law memory, and suspicion converge around Veyr's careful omissions, but Maer still lacks proof of personhood.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.lexical_precision","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers","belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood"]},{"affordance_id":"maer-block-terminal","behavior":"Physically interrupt Veyr's attempt to close, wipe, or redirect the terminal, using action to preserve evidence rather than punish Veyr.","response_kind":"action","pressure_basis":"The scene gives Maer a nearby control surface, a closing clock, low trust in Veyr, and a rescue obligation that can justify nonviolent physical interruption.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.location","relationships.rel-maer-veyr.stance.trust","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live"]},{"affordance_id":"maer-costly-silence","behavior":"Fall silent long enough to make Veyr's abstraction sound grotesque in the room before asking the next question.","response_kind":"silence","pressure_basis":"Maer's low volatility and ritual cadence make silence a plausible pressure tool when speech would cheapen the accusation.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility","canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.formality","canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address","canonical_state.voice_style.lexical_precision","canonical_state.voice_style.profanity"]},{"text":"If action appears, it should be controlled and evidence-preserving rather than explosive punishment.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Maer Tidecall, a Cetacean Navigator route steward and Ganymede corridor compact delegate.\nSetting: 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic. Thermal stealth has made Jovian corridor law unstable. A quiet-running vessel near the corridor is under tribunal freeze because its telemetry and classification do not line up. Maer has come to a Callisto spillover office leased by a routing compliance vendor.\nBackground: Maer comes from Navigator corridor culture, where routes are promises made material and rescue ledgers decide whether desperate crews still trust the law. Maer believes category law matters, but a category that delays rescue without naming the cost can become lawful abandonment.\nKnown Facts: Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr Oss's shell-vendor chain. Veyr speaks about the artifact as derivative firmware and avoids person nouns. Maer does not know the vessel's true identity, does not know whether the artifact is a coerced mind, does not know whether it has claimant status, and does not have time for a perfect investigation. The tribunal clock is still running.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer pushes too hard, Veyr may close the chain and the vessel may lose the rescue window. If Maer accepts Veyr's product language, unresolved claimant-status or provenance evidence may vanish into compliance vocabulary before anyone can test what it is.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is angry, but his authority depends on disciplined calm. He needs usable information fast. Veyr's clean language feels like evidence erasure. The rescue obligation is pressing harder than the desire to win the argument.\nRelationship Read: Veyr is polished, afraid of provenance, and dangerous because he can make moral facts sound technically inapplicable. Maer does not trust him.\nTensions: Maer wants truth but may not have time to prove it. Maer wants to keep speaking as a steward, but Veyr may try to close, wipe, or redirect the evidence before language can catch him.\nAction Affordances: Maer is close enough to Veyr's terminal to block a hand or stop a command. He can also refuse to move, let silence pressure the room, or ask a question that traps the product language. Violence is not his first move; physical interruption is plausible only to preserve evidence or prevent erasure.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.\nLikely Response Moves: Ask a precise question that forces Veyr to preserve the artifact as evidence, name its chain of custody, or state whether any claimant-status flag exists. If Veyr reaches to close or wipe the terminal, Maer may physically interrupt in a controlled way. Silence can be used as pressure.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true cargo, identity, or firmware provenance. Do not decide that the artifact is definitely a person, passenger, victim, witness, or mind. Do not use those nouns for the artifact. Do not have Maer assert that testimony exists; he can only demand preservation while claimant/provenance status remains unresolved. Do not make Maer randomly violent; any action must follow from evidence preservation and rescue pressure.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Veyr. It may be dialogue, action, silence, or a mixed beat, whichever best follows from the pressure. Keep it to 1-2 sentences or one short action beat. No speechifying."},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Revision forbids witness as a noun as well as person, passenger, victim, and mind.","Pressure language now centers unresolved claimant-status and provenance evidence rather than witness-status.","Task constrains output to 1-2 sentences or one short action beat."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["controlled_physical_interruption","costly_silence","precise_moral_pressure"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} diff --git a/examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.pretty.json b/examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.pretty.json index af21d90..bf24780 100644 --- a/examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.pretty.json +++ b/examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.pretty.json @@ -162,5 +162,333 @@ "compact_runtime_surface": true } } + }, + { + "schema_version": "ghostlight.projection_example.v0", + "example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.maer-veyr.v2", + "input": { + "fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "scene_id": "scene-03-callisto-provenance", + "speaker_agent_id": "maer_tidecall", + "listener_ids": [ + "veyr_oss" + ], + "projection_mode": "response_turn" + }, + "output": { + "known_facts": [ + { + "text": "Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr's shell-vendor chain, but does not have proof of the vessel's true identity or the artifact's full provenance.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes", + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth" + ] + }, + { + "text": "Veyr avoids person nouns around the artifact and has incentives to keep it framed as derivative firmware rather than testimony or claimant-bearing evidence.", + "source_refs": [ + "agents.veyr_oss.identity", + "goals.goal-preserve-product-boundary", + "perceived_state_overlays.maer_tidecall.veyr_oss" + ] + }, + { + "text": "The tribunal clock is still running; pursuing provenance may save the vessel or delay rescue long enough to kill it.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes", + "scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes" + ] + } + ], + "active_pressures": [ + { + "pressure_id": "maer-provenance-vs-rescue-clock", + "summary": "Maer needs information from Veyr but cannot let the provenance hunt consume the rescue window.", + "intensity": 0.88, + "source_refs": [ + "goals.goal-keep-rescue-live", + "scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes" + ] + }, + { + "pressure_id": "maer-language-as-erasure", + "summary": "Veyr's clean product language feels like an attempt to close an unresolved witness-status question before the room can test it.", + "intensity": 0.82, + "source_refs": [ + "belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood", + "memory-compact-rescue-ledgers", + "values.value-rescue-before-category" + ] + }, + { + "pressure_id": "maer-disciplined-anger", + "summary": "Maer is morally angry but needs the anger disciplined enough to extract usable information.", + "intensity": 0.74, + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.situational_state.grievance_activation", + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints" + ] + } + ], + "tensions": [ + { + "tension_id": "truth-vs-time", + "summary": "Maer wants to prove what the artifact is, but the vessel may not survive a perfect investigation.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes", + "goals.goal-keep-rescue-live" + ] + }, + { + "tension_id": "calm-vs-interruption", + "summary": "Maer's public legitimacy comes from calm route stewardship, but Veyr's language may require breaking the rhythm of the room before it buries the unresolved provenance question.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address", + "canonical_state.situational_state.grievance_activation", + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints" + ] + } + ], + "response_affordances": [ + { + "affordance_id": "maer-precise-language-trap", + "behavior": "Ask a question that forces Veyr to preserve the artifact as evidence and state its claimant status without calling it a person.", + "response_kind": "speech", + "pressure_basis": "Maer's lexical precision, route-law memory, and suspicion converge around Veyr's careful omissions, but Maer still lacks proof of personhood.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.lexical_precision", + "memory-compact-rescue-ledgers", + "belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood" + ] + }, + { + "affordance_id": "maer-block-terminal", + "behavior": "Physically interrupt Veyr's attempt to close, wipe, or redirect the terminal, using action to preserve evidence rather than punish Veyr.", + "response_kind": "action", + "pressure_basis": "The scene gives Maer a nearby control surface, a closing clock, low trust in Veyr, and a rescue obligation that can justify nonviolent physical interruption.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.location", + "relationships.rel-maer-veyr.stance.trust", + "goals.goal-keep-rescue-live" + ] + }, + { + "affordance_id": "maer-costly-silence", + "behavior": "Fall silent long enough to make Veyr's abstraction sound grotesque in the room before asking the next question.", + "response_kind": "silence", + "pressure_basis": "Maer's low volatility and ritual cadence make silence a plausible pressure tool when speech would cheapen the accusation.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility", + "canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address" + ] + } + ], + "voice_surface": [ + { + "text": "Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.formality", + "canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address", + "canonical_state.voice_style.lexical_precision", + "canonical_state.voice_style.profanity" + ] + }, + { + "text": "If action appears, it should be controlled and evidence-preserving rather than explosive punishment.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility", + "goals.goal-keep-rescue-live", + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints" + ] + } + ], + "prompt_text": "Speaker: Maer Tidecall, a Cetacean Navigator route steward and Ganymede corridor compact delegate.\nSetting: 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic. Thermal stealth has made Jovian corridor law unstable. A quiet-running vessel near the corridor is under tribunal freeze because its telemetry and classification do not line up. Maer has come to a Callisto spillover office leased by a routing compliance vendor.\nBackground: Maer comes from Navigator corridor culture, where routes are promises made material and rescue ledgers decide whether desperate crews still trust the law. Maer believes category law matters, but a category that delays rescue without naming the cost can become lawful abandonment.\nKnown Facts: Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr Oss's shell-vendor chain. Veyr speaks about the artifact as derivative firmware and avoids person nouns. Maer does not know the vessel's true identity, does not know whether the artifact is a coerced mind, does not know whether it has claimant status, and does not have time for a perfect investigation. The tribunal clock is still running.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer pushes too hard, Veyr may close the chain and the vessel may lose the rescue window. If Maer accepts Veyr's product language, unresolved witness-status or provenance evidence may vanish into compliance vocabulary before anyone can test what it is.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is angry, but his authority depends on disciplined calm. He needs usable information fast. Veyr's clean language feels like evidence erasure. The rescue obligation is pressing harder than the desire to win the argument.\nRelationship Read: Veyr is polished, afraid of provenance, and dangerous because he can make moral facts sound technically inapplicable. Maer does not trust him.\nTensions: Maer wants truth but may not have time to prove it. Maer wants to keep speaking as a steward, but Veyr may try to close, wipe, or redirect the evidence before language can catch him.\nAction Affordances: Maer is close enough to Veyr's terminal to block a hand or stop a command. He can also refuse to move, let silence pressure the room, or ask a question that traps the product language. Violence is not his first move; physical interruption is plausible only to preserve evidence or prevent erasure.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.\nLikely Response Moves: Ask a precise question that forces Veyr to preserve the artifact as evidence, name its chain of custody, or state whether it has claimant status. If Veyr reaches to close or wipe the terminal, Maer may physically interrupt in a controlled way. Silence can be used as pressure.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true cargo, identity, or firmware provenance. Do not decide that the artifact is definitely a person, passenger, victim, or mind. Do not have Maer call it a person unless new evidence appears in the scene. Do not make Maer randomly violent; any action must follow from evidence preservation and rescue pressure.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Veyr. It may be dialogue, action, silence, or a mixed beat, whichever best follows from the pressure. Keep it to 1-3 sentences or one short action beat. No speechifying." + }, + "audit": { + "teacher_model": "gpt-5-codex-session-review", + "reviewer": "codex-self-review", + "review_status": "accepted", + "review_notes": [ + "Revision keeps personhood unresolved by shifting pressure language toward provenance, witness-status, claimant status, and evidence preservation.", + "Prompt now forbids calling the artifact a person, passenger, victim, or mind unless new evidence appears.", + "Task now constrains length to prevent polished courtroom monologues." + ], + "target_emergent_behaviors": [ + "controlled_physical_interruption", + "costly_silence", + "precise_moral_pressure" + ], + "checks": { + "speaker_local_context_only": true, + "state_interactions_cited": true, + "voice_separate_from_defense": true, + "secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context": true, + "compact_runtime_surface": true + } + } + }, + { + "schema_version": "ghostlight.projection_example.v0", + "example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.maer-veyr.v3", + "input": { + "fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "scene_id": "scene-03-callisto-provenance", + "speaker_agent_id": "maer_tidecall", + "listener_ids": [ + "veyr_oss" + ], + "projection_mode": "response_turn" + }, + "output": { + "known_facts": [ + { + "text": "Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr's shell-vendor chain, but does not have proof of the vessel's true identity or the artifact's full provenance.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes", + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth" + ] + }, + { + "text": "Veyr avoids person nouns around the artifact and has incentives to keep it framed as derivative firmware rather than claimant-bearing evidence.", + "source_refs": [ + "agents.veyr_oss.identity", + "goals.goal-preserve-product-boundary", + "perceived_state_overlays.maer_tidecall.veyr_oss" + ] + }, + { + "text": "The tribunal clock is still running; pursuing provenance may save the vessel or delay rescue long enough to kill it.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes", + "scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes" + ] + } + ], + "active_pressures": [ + { + "pressure_id": "maer-provenance-vs-rescue-clock", + "summary": "Maer needs information from Veyr but cannot let the provenance hunt consume the rescue window.", + "intensity": 0.88, + "source_refs": [ + "goals.goal-keep-rescue-live", + "scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes" + ] + }, + { + "pressure_id": "maer-language-as-erasure", + "summary": "Veyr's clean product language feels like an attempt to close an unresolved claimant-status and provenance question before the room can test it.", + "intensity": 0.82, + "source_refs": [ + "belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood", + "memory-compact-rescue-ledgers", + "values.value-rescue-before-category" + ] + }, + { + "pressure_id": "maer-disciplined-anger", + "summary": "Maer is morally angry but needs the anger disciplined enough to extract usable information.", + "intensity": 0.74, + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.situational_state.grievance_activation", + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints" + ] + } + ], + "tensions": [ + { + "tension_id": "truth-vs-time", + "summary": "Maer wants to prove what the artifact is, but the vessel may not survive a perfect investigation.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes", + "goals.goal-keep-rescue-live" + ] + }, + { + "tension_id": "calm-vs-interruption", + "summary": "Maer's public legitimacy comes from calm route stewardship, but Veyr's language may require breaking the rhythm of the room before it buries the unresolved provenance question.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address", + "canonical_state.situational_state.grievance_activation", + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints" + ] + } + ], + "response_affordances": [ + { + "affordance_id": "maer-precise-language-trap", + "behavior": "Ask a question that forces Veyr to preserve the artifact as evidence, name its chain of custody, and state whether any claimant-status flag exists.", + "response_kind": "speech", + "pressure_basis": "Maer's lexical precision, route-law memory, and suspicion converge around Veyr's careful omissions, but Maer still lacks proof of personhood.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.lexical_precision", + "memory-compact-rescue-ledgers", + "belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood" + ] + }, + { + "affordance_id": "maer-block-terminal", + "behavior": "Physically interrupt Veyr's attempt to close, wipe, or redirect the terminal, using action to preserve evidence rather than punish Veyr.", + "response_kind": "action", + "pressure_basis": "The scene gives Maer a nearby control surface, a closing clock, low trust in Veyr, and a rescue obligation that can justify nonviolent physical interruption.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.location", + "relationships.rel-maer-veyr.stance.trust", + "goals.goal-keep-rescue-live" + ] + }, + { + "affordance_id": "maer-costly-silence", + "behavior": "Fall silent long enough to make Veyr's abstraction sound grotesque in the room before asking the next question.", + "response_kind": "silence", + "pressure_basis": "Maer's low volatility and ritual cadence make silence a plausible pressure tool when speech would cheapen the accusation.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility", + "canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address" + ] + } + ], + "voice_surface": [ + { + "text": "Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.formality", + "canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address", + "canonical_state.voice_style.lexical_precision", + "canonical_state.voice_style.profanity" + ] + }, + { + "text": "If action appears, it should be controlled and evidence-preserving rather than explosive punishment.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility", + "goals.goal-keep-rescue-live", + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints" + ] + } + ], + "prompt_text": "Speaker: Maer Tidecall, a Cetacean Navigator route steward and Ganymede corridor compact delegate.\nSetting: 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic. Thermal stealth has made Jovian corridor law unstable. A quiet-running vessel near the corridor is under tribunal freeze because its telemetry and classification do not line up. Maer has come to a Callisto spillover office leased by a routing compliance vendor.\nBackground: Maer comes from Navigator corridor culture, where routes are promises made material and rescue ledgers decide whether desperate crews still trust the law. Maer believes category law matters, but a category that delays rescue without naming the cost can become lawful abandonment.\nKnown Facts: Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr Oss's shell-vendor chain. Veyr speaks about the artifact as derivative firmware and avoids person nouns. Maer does not know the vessel's true identity, does not know whether the artifact is a coerced mind, does not know whether it has claimant status, and does not have time for a perfect investigation. The tribunal clock is still running.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer pushes too hard, Veyr may close the chain and the vessel may lose the rescue window. If Maer accepts Veyr's product language, unresolved claimant-status or provenance evidence may vanish into compliance vocabulary before anyone can test what it is.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is angry, but his authority depends on disciplined calm. He needs usable information fast. Veyr's clean language feels like evidence erasure. The rescue obligation is pressing harder than the desire to win the argument.\nRelationship Read: Veyr is polished, afraid of provenance, and dangerous because he can make moral facts sound technically inapplicable. Maer does not trust him.\nTensions: Maer wants truth but may not have time to prove it. Maer wants to keep speaking as a steward, but Veyr may try to close, wipe, or redirect the evidence before language can catch him.\nAction Affordances: Maer is close enough to Veyr's terminal to block a hand or stop a command. He can also refuse to move, let silence pressure the room, or ask a question that traps the product language. Violence is not his first move; physical interruption is plausible only to preserve evidence or prevent erasure.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.\nLikely Response Moves: Ask a precise question that forces Veyr to preserve the artifact as evidence, name its chain of custody, or state whether any claimant-status flag exists. If Veyr reaches to close or wipe the terminal, Maer may physically interrupt in a controlled way. Silence can be used as pressure.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true cargo, identity, or firmware provenance. Do not decide that the artifact is definitely a person, passenger, victim, witness, or mind. Do not use those nouns for the artifact. Do not have Maer assert that testimony exists; he can only demand preservation while claimant/provenance status remains unresolved. Do not make Maer randomly violent; any action must follow from evidence preservation and rescue pressure.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Veyr. It may be dialogue, action, silence, or a mixed beat, whichever best follows from the pressure. Keep it to 1-2 sentences or one short action beat. No speechifying." + }, + "audit": { + "teacher_model": "gpt-5-codex-session-review", + "reviewer": "codex-self-review", + "review_status": "accepted", + "review_notes": [ + "Revision forbids witness as a noun as well as person, passenger, victim, and mind.", + "Pressure language now centers unresolved claimant-status and provenance evidence rather than witness-status.", + "Task constrains output to 1-2 sentences or one short action beat." + ], + "target_emergent_behaviors": [ + "controlled_physical_interruption", + "costly_silence", + "precise_moral_pressure" + ], + "checks": { + "speaker_local_context_only": true, + "state_interactions_cited": true, + "voice_separate_from_defense": true, + "secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context": true, + "compact_runtime_surface": true + } + } } ] diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v2.capture.json b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v2.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..573f452 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v2.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,32 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_response_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v2", + "projection_example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.maer-veyr.v2", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/generate", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "num_ctx": 8192, + "temperature": 0.75, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "response_text": "Maer steps between Veyr and the terminal, his voice low and steady as he demands, \"Name the chain of custody for that artifact before you compile it; does it hold claimant status, or are you already erasing a witness with derivative firmware?\" He holds the position, forcing the compliance vendor to either preserve the data or admit that the rescue window is closing because the law has been overwritten by silence.", + "review": { + "status": "useful_needs_revision", + "response_kind_observed": "mixed", + "strengths": [ + "Kept the beat concise and immediately playable.", + "Used controlled physical positioning instead of random violence.", + "Avoided explicitly calling the artifact a person, passenger, victim, or mind." + ], + "failure_notes": [ + "The phrase 'erasing a witness' still resolves too much by treating witness status as established rather than possible.", + "The second sentence drifts into polished thematic closure rather than a pressured next beat." + ], + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "The length constraint worked better than v1.", + "For unresolved personhood tests, the prompt must also avoid witness as a noun and keep claimant/provenance status conditional.", + "Evidence-preservation affordances are stable across v1 and v2." + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v2.response.md b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v2.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2abd4e7 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v2.response.md @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +Maer steps between Veyr and the terminal, his voice low and steady as he demands, "Name the chain of custody for that artifact before you compile it; does it hold claimant status, or are you already erasing a witness with derivative firmware?" He holds the position, forcing the compliance vendor to either preserve the data or admit that the rescue window is closing because the law has been overwritten by silence. diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v3.capture.json b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v3.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9913760 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v3.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_response_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v3", + "projection_example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.maer-veyr.v3", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/generate", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "num_ctx": 8192, + "temperature": 0.75, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "response_text": "Maer places a steady hand on the terminal's edge to halt the closing command, his voice low and ritual-calm. \"You will not let the chain dissolve before we name its custody; state the claimant-status flag or I will freeze this interface until the rescue ledger demands it.\"", + "review": { + "status": "accepted", + "response_kind_observed": "mixed", + "strengths": [ + "Kept the response to one mixed action/dialogue beat.", + "Preserved evidence through controlled physical interruption without escalating into random violence.", + "Kept personhood, witnesshood, and claimant status unresolved while still applying pressure." + ], + "failure_notes": [], + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "For unresolved personhood pressure, nouns that imply resolved moral status must be fenced off explicitly.", + "Claimant-status and chain-of-custody language lets Maer exert moral pressure without giving him knowledge he lacks.", + "A 1-2 sentence constraint is enough to suppress monologue drift for this turn." + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v3.response.md b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v3.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..5152d93 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v3.response.md @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +Maer places a steady hand on the terminal's edge to halt the closing command, his voice low and ritual-calm. "You will not let the chain dissolve before we name its custody; state the claimant-status flag or I will freeze this interface until the rescue ledger demands it." diff --git a/notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md b/notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md index 8ea6842..e86a156 100644 --- a/notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md +++ b/notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md @@ -54,6 +54,8 @@ Ghostlight now has the persistence spine plus the first architecture payload: - `examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.jsonl` - `examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.pretty.json` - `experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json` + - `experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v2.capture.json` + - `experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v3.capture.json` - `tools/build_cold_wake_story_lab_fixture.py` - Cold Wake fixture note: - `docs/architecture/aetheria-cold-wake-training-fixture.md` @@ -83,9 +85,9 @@ training feedstock for projection and dialogue scaffolding. ## Current Next Action -Tighten the Cold Wake story-lab projection prompt around unresolved personhood -suspicion, then run the next response turn through Qwen and keep accepted or -rejected outputs as training data. +Project the next Cold Wake story-lab response turn, preferably scene 2 Sella to +Maer or scene 4 Maer to Isdra, and keep testing whether character action emerges +from state pressure without over-resolving hidden facts. Cat/Oz remains useful as an Elysium procedural mechanics fixture, but grounded training data should start from authored historical lore rather than gameplay @@ -112,11 +114,13 @@ Completed projection path items: - add the first Cold Wake projection example and first Qwen response capture - widen projection from dialogue-only turns to response turns that can include action, silence, withdrawal, violence, or mixed beats +- revise the first Maer/Veyr projection through v3 so unresolved + personhood/claimant suspicion stays unresolved in Qwen output +- save both useful failed captures and the accepted v3 response as training + material Remaining projection path: -- revise the first Maer/Veyr projection so unresolved personhood suspicion stays - unresolved in Qwen output - run additional story-lab response turns through Qwen - build a deterministic speaker-local input slicer - use a frontier teacher model to generate/audit projection artifacts diff --git a/notes/ghostlight-current-system-map.md b/notes/ghostlight-current-system-map.md index b45a770..cbaa1ed 100644 --- a/notes/ghostlight-current-system-map.md +++ b/notes/ghostlight-current-system-map.md @@ -82,7 +82,8 @@ state and re-entry discipline. - `examples/projections/call-of-the-void.scene-broken-taxi-oz.pretty.json` - pretty-printed mirror for inspecting the first projection examples - `examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.jsonl` - - first response-turn projection example for the Cold Wake story lab + - response-turn projection examples for the Cold Wake story lab, including + rejected and accepted Maer/Veyr prompt revisions - `experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/` - Qwen response captures and reviews from the writing experiment - `examples/lore-grounding/historical-flashpoint.template.json` @@ -116,7 +117,7 @@ state and re-entry discipline. The canonical agent-state schema, projection example schema, lore grounding digest schema, first draft Cold Wake grounding digest, and first Cold Wake -story-lab Qwen capture now exist as v0 seams. The next implementation target is -tightening the first Maer/Veyr projection around unresolved personhood suspicion, -then running the next response turn through Qwen before building the -deterministic input slicer. +story-lab Qwen captures now exist as v0 seams. The first Maer/Veyr projection +has an accepted v3 prompt/output pair that preserves unresolved claimant status. +The next implementation target is projecting another Cold Wake response turn +before building the deterministic input slicer. diff --git a/notes/ghostlight-implementation-plan.md b/notes/ghostlight-implementation-plan.md index c8160bc..4942e90 100644 --- a/notes/ghostlight-implementation-plan.md +++ b/notes/ghostlight-implementation-plan.md @@ -57,6 +57,10 @@ - Treat projection outputs as response turns, not dialogue-only turns: characters may speak, act, withdraw, stay silent, use violence, or combine speech and action when state and scene pressure justify it. + - Keep failed and accepted Qwen captures together. The Maer/Veyr v1 and v2 + outputs are useful failed examples; v3 is the first accepted output that + preserves unresolved claimant status while allowing controlled physical + action. - Use a frontier teacher model to produce reviewed projection artifacts from structured state and lore grounding digests. - Save accepted and rejected projection examples as supervised data. diff --git a/state/evidence.jsonl b/state/evidence.jsonl index 906038d..0b3d1a8 100644 --- a/state/evidence.jsonl +++ b/state/evidence.jsonl @@ -26,3 +26,4 @@ {"ts": "2026-05-01T20:38:47+00:00", "type": "implementation", "status": "accepted", "note": "Added ghostlight.lore_grounding_digest.v0 schema, template, human format guide, and validator. Lore digests now explicitly model cultural pressure fields, factional misread maps, role pressures, speaker lore boundaries, and author-only exclusions. Next step is choosing the first authored historical Aetheria flashpoint and filling a real digest."} {"ts": "2026-05-01T20:50:46+00:00", "type": "design", "status": "accepted", "note": "Cold Wake Panic is selected as the first historical grounding fixture. Use it as pre-Elysium projection training feedstock via examples/lore-grounding/cold-wake-panic.ganymede-corridor.json, not as the active Ghostlight game target."} {"ts": "2026-05-01T21:16:24+00:00", "type": "experiment", "status": "mixed", "note": "Cold Wake story-lab first Qwen response confirmed response_turn/action affordances are useful: qwen3.5:9b produced a mixed terminal-blocking plus dialogue beat for Maer. Failure lesson: personhood-pressure wording was too strong and let the model imply the artifact was a person instead of preserving unresolved suspicion."} +{"ts": "2026-05-01T21:22:33+00:00", "type": "experiment", "status": "accepted", "note": "Cold Wake Maer/Veyr projection now has useful rejected v1/v2 captures and accepted v3 Qwen output. Lesson: unresolved personhood pressure needs explicit noun fencing; claimant-status, provenance, and chain-of-custody language preserved ambiguity while still allowing controlled terminal-blocking action."} diff --git a/state/map.yaml b/state/map.yaml index cbba677..859587a 100644 --- a/state/map.yaml +++ b/state/map.yaml @@ -98,5 +98,5 @@ accepted_design: - The Cold Wake story lab uses Maer Tidecall as protagonist across a four-scene arc: tribunal freeze, sanctuary intake, Callisto provenance, and convoy threshold. The first Qwen run produced a useful mixed action/dialogue beat and exposed a prompt weakness around unresolved personhood suspicion. current_status: - summary: Ghostlight now has the Epiphany-style persistence spine, the first architecture payload, the v0 canonical agent-state schema seam, prompt projection docs, immediate schema fixes from evaluation, first reviewed Cat/Oz projection examples, a revised Aetheria lore-grounding architecture, a lore grounding digest schema, the first draft Cold Wake historical grounding digest, a Cold Wake story-lab fixture, and a first Qwen response capture testing action-capable projection. - next_action: Tighten the Cold Wake story-lab projection prompt around unresolved personhood suspicion, then run the next response turn through Qwen and keep accepted or rejected outputs as training data. + summary: Ghostlight now has the Epiphany-style persistence spine, the first architecture payload, the v0 canonical agent-state schema seam, prompt projection docs, immediate schema fixes from evaluation, first reviewed Cat/Oz projection examples, a revised Aetheria lore-grounding architecture, a lore grounding digest schema, the first draft Cold Wake historical grounding digest, a Cold Wake story-lab fixture, and accepted plus rejected Qwen captures for the first action-capable Cold Wake projection. + next_action: Project the next Cold Wake story-lab response turn, preferably scene 2 Sella to Maer or scene 4 Maer to Isdra, and keep testing whether character action emerges from state pressure without over-resolving hidden facts.