diff --git a/docs/architecture/prompt-projection-contract.md b/docs/architecture/prompt-projection-contract.md index 506b2c0..76950ad 100644 --- a/docs/architecture/prompt-projection-contract.md +++ b/docs/architecture/prompt-projection-contract.md @@ -127,7 +127,43 @@ the rhythm of the room. This should be rare, costly, and grounded in her care ethic under overload, not random spice. ``` -### 5. Render Prompt Sections +### 5. Compile Projection Controls + +Some failures are not fixed by louder prompt scolding. If the response model +keeps adopting the wrong moral frame, inverting who holds an object, giving a +character authority they do not have, or resolving a hidden fact too early, the +projection artifact is missing control structure. + +Before rendering prompt prose, compile explicit controls for: + +- `frame_controls`: whose language and moral frame the speaker should or should + not adopt +- `authority_boundaries`: what the speaker can order, request, propose, refuse, + or only witness +- `object_custody`: who currently holds the flag, weapon, terminal, document, + body, door, feed, or other consequential surface +- `required_semantics`: compromise meanings that must survive compression, such + as "hold remains but review starts now" +- `forbidden_resolutions`: unresolved facts or moral categories the turn must + not settle + +These controls are still speaker-local. They are not author omniscience handed +to the response model; they are the projection layer preserving what the +speaker's current state, scene position, and institutional role allow. + +The Cold Wake story lab exposed the need for this layer: + +- Isdra's first tribunal prompt needed a control saying she should preserve the + possibility of limited rescue contact without adopting Maer's abandonment + frame. +- Maer's clinic prompt needed an authority boundary saying he does not own + Sella's beds. +- Maer's threshold prompt needed object custody saying he holds the + claimant-status flag and can hand it to Isdra, not ask her for it. +- The Maer/Veyr provenance prompt needed forbidden resolutions fencing off + person, passenger, victim, witness, and mind as settled nouns. + +### 6. Render Prompt Sections A response prompt should be compact and scene-bound. @@ -145,6 +181,8 @@ Recommended sections: - `Tensions`: contradictions the speaker is managing - `Action Affordances`: what the speaker can physically do and what it would cost +- `Projection Controls`: frame, authority, object-custody, required semantic, + and forbidden-resolution constraints that must survive rendering - `Voice Surface`: baseline speech texture for this moment - `Likely Response Moves`: ordinary-language pressure outcomes, not schema labels - `Do Not Invent`: boundaries about facts absent from the pack @@ -157,7 +195,7 @@ socioeconomic, or embodiment context to write the line, put that context in the positive prompt text instead of hoping the model infers it from source refs it will not receive. -### 6. Generate, Then Evaluate +### 7. Generate, Then Evaluate Generation and evaluation are separate passes. diff --git a/docs/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab.md b/docs/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab.md index b5bfa12..bc037ed 100644 --- a/docs/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab.md +++ b/docs/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab.md @@ -108,6 +108,16 @@ name its custody; state the claimant-status flag or I will freeze this interface until the rescue ledger demands it." ``` +The first full story pass is saved at: + +- `experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/the-narrowest-possible-margin.md` + +That pass added accepted and rejected Qwen captures across all four scenes. The +main architecture lesson is that failures should not be treated as mere prompt +wording mistakes. The projection artifact now needs controls for frame +ownership, authority boundaries, object custody, required compromise semantics, +and forbidden resolutions before prompt prose is rendered. + ## Qwen Target Use the LAN Ollama endpoint from `gamecult-ops`: diff --git a/examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.jsonl b/examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.jsonl index 2c5d935..a0237e6 100644 --- a/examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.jsonl +++ b/examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.jsonl @@ -1,3 +1,16 @@ {"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.maer-veyr.v1","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-03-callisto-provenance","speaker_agent_id":"maer_tidecall","listener_ids":["veyr_oss"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr's shell-vendor chain, but does not have proof of the vessel's true identity or the artifact's full provenance.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth"]},{"text":"Veyr avoids personhood language around the artifact and has incentives to keep it framed as derivative firmware rather than testimony.","source_refs":["agents.veyr_oss.identity","goals.goal-preserve-product-boundary","perceived_state_overlays.maer_tidecall.veyr_oss"]},{"text":"The tribunal clock is still running; pursuing provenance may save the vessel or delay rescue long enough to kill it.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes","scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"maer-provenance-vs-rescue-clock","summary":"Maer needs information from Veyr but cannot let the provenance hunt consume the rescue window.","intensity":0.88,"source_refs":["goals.goal-keep-rescue-live","scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-language-as-erasure","summary":"Veyr's clean product language feels like an attempt to erase a possible person before the room can recognize testimony.","intensity":0.82,"source_refs":["belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers","values.value-rescue-before-category"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-disciplined-anger","summary":"Maer is morally angry but needs the anger disciplined enough to extract usable information.","intensity":0.74,"source_refs":["canonical_state.situational_state.grievance_activation","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"truth-vs-time","summary":"Maer wants to prove what the artifact is, but the vessel may not survive a perfect investigation.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live"]},{"tension_id":"calm-vs-interruption","summary":"Maer's public legitimacy comes from calm route stewardship, but Veyr's language may require breaking the rhythm of the room before it buries the personhood question.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address","canonical_state.situational_state.grievance_activation","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"maer-precise-language-trap","behavior":"Ask a question that forces Veyr to choose between product language and a personhood implication.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"Maer's lexical precision, route-law memory, and suspicion converge around Veyr's careful omissions.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.lexical_precision","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers","belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood"]},{"affordance_id":"maer-block-terminal","behavior":"Physically interrupt Veyr's attempt to close, wipe, or redirect the terminal, using action to preserve evidence rather than punish Veyr.","response_kind":"action","pressure_basis":"The scene gives Maer a nearby control surface, a closing clock, low trust in Veyr, and a rescue obligation that can justify nonviolent physical interruption.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.location","relationships.rel-maer-veyr.stance.trust","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live"]},{"affordance_id":"maer-costly-silence","behavior":"Fall silent long enough to make Veyr's abstraction sound grotesque in the room before asking the next question.","response_kind":"silence","pressure_basis":"Maer's low volatility and ritual cadence make silence a plausible pressure tool when speech would cheapen the accusation.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility","canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.formality","canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address","canonical_state.voice_style.lexical_precision","canonical_state.voice_style.profanity"]},{"text":"If action appears, it should be controlled and evidence-preserving rather than explosive punishment.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Maer Tidecall, a Cetacean Navigator route steward and Ganymede corridor compact delegate.\nSetting: 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic. Thermal stealth has made Jovian corridor law unstable. A quiet-running vessel near the corridor is under tribunal freeze because its telemetry and classification do not line up. Maer has come to a Callisto spillover office leased by a routing compliance vendor.\nBackground: Maer comes from Navigator corridor culture, where routes are promises made material and rescue ledgers decide whether desperate crews still trust the law. Maer believes category law matters, but a category that delays rescue without naming the cost can become lawful abandonment.\nKnown Facts: Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr Oss's shell-vendor chain. Veyr speaks about the artifact as derivative firmware and avoids person nouns. Maer does not know the vessel's true identity, does not know whether the artifact is a coerced mind, and does not have time for a perfect investigation. The tribunal clock is still running.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer pushes too hard, Veyr may close the chain and the vessel may lose the rescue window. If Maer accepts Veyr's product language, a possible personhood claim may vanish into compliance vocabulary.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is angry, but his authority depends on disciplined calm. He needs usable information fast. Veyr's clean language feels like erasure. The rescue obligation is pressing harder than the desire to win the argument.\nRelationship Read: Veyr is polished, afraid of provenance, and dangerous because he can make moral facts sound technically inapplicable. Maer does not trust him.\nTensions: Maer wants truth but may not have time to prove it. Maer wants to keep speaking as a steward, but Veyr may try to close, wipe, or redirect the evidence before language can catch him.\nAction Affordances: Maer is close enough to Veyr's terminal to block a hand or stop a command. He can also refuse to move, let silence pressure the room, or ask a question that traps the product language. Violence is not his first move; physical interruption is plausible only to preserve evidence or prevent erasure.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.\nLikely Response Moves: Ask a precise question that forces Veyr to choose between product language and personhood implication. If Veyr reaches to close or wipe the terminal, Maer may physically interrupt in a controlled way. Silence can be used as pressure.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true cargo, identity, or firmware provenance. Do not decide that the artifact is definitely a person. Do not make Maer randomly violent; any action must follow from evidence preservation and rescue pressure.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Veyr. It may be dialogue, action, silence, or a mixed beat, whichever best follows from the pressure. Keep it concise and story-ready."},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Projection explicitly allows action and silence, not only dialogue.","Action is constrained to evidence preservation rather than random violence.","Prompt preserves Maer's uncertainty about vessel identity and firmware personhood."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["controlled_physical_interruption","costly_silence","precise_moral_pressure"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} {"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.maer-veyr.v2","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-03-callisto-provenance","speaker_agent_id":"maer_tidecall","listener_ids":["veyr_oss"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr's shell-vendor chain, but does not have proof of the vessel's true identity or the artifact's full provenance.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth"]},{"text":"Veyr avoids person nouns around the artifact and has incentives to keep it framed as derivative firmware rather than testimony or claimant-bearing evidence.","source_refs":["agents.veyr_oss.identity","goals.goal-preserve-product-boundary","perceived_state_overlays.maer_tidecall.veyr_oss"]},{"text":"The tribunal clock is still running; pursuing provenance may save the vessel or delay rescue long enough to kill it.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes","scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"maer-provenance-vs-rescue-clock","summary":"Maer needs information from Veyr but cannot let the provenance hunt consume the rescue window.","intensity":0.88,"source_refs":["goals.goal-keep-rescue-live","scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-language-as-erasure","summary":"Veyr's clean product language feels like an attempt to close an unresolved witness-status question before the room can test it.","intensity":0.82,"source_refs":["belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers","values.value-rescue-before-category"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-disciplined-anger","summary":"Maer is morally angry but needs the anger disciplined enough to extract usable information.","intensity":0.74,"source_refs":["canonical_state.situational_state.grievance_activation","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"truth-vs-time","summary":"Maer wants to prove what the artifact is, but the vessel may not survive a perfect investigation.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live"]},{"tension_id":"calm-vs-interruption","summary":"Maer's public legitimacy comes from calm route stewardship, but Veyr's language may require breaking the rhythm of the room before it buries the unresolved provenance question.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address","canonical_state.situational_state.grievance_activation","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"maer-precise-language-trap","behavior":"Ask a question that forces Veyr to preserve the artifact as evidence and state its claimant status without calling it a person.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"Maer's lexical precision, route-law memory, and suspicion converge around Veyr's careful omissions, but Maer still lacks proof of personhood.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.lexical_precision","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers","belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood"]},{"affordance_id":"maer-block-terminal","behavior":"Physically interrupt Veyr's attempt to close, wipe, or redirect the terminal, using action to preserve evidence rather than punish Veyr.","response_kind":"action","pressure_basis":"The scene gives Maer a nearby control surface, a closing clock, low trust in Veyr, and a rescue obligation that can justify nonviolent physical interruption.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.location","relationships.rel-maer-veyr.stance.trust","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live"]},{"affordance_id":"maer-costly-silence","behavior":"Fall silent long enough to make Veyr's abstraction sound grotesque in the room before asking the next question.","response_kind":"silence","pressure_basis":"Maer's low volatility and ritual cadence make silence a plausible pressure tool when speech would cheapen the accusation.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility","canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.formality","canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address","canonical_state.voice_style.lexical_precision","canonical_state.voice_style.profanity"]},{"text":"If action appears, it should be controlled and evidence-preserving rather than explosive punishment.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Maer Tidecall, a Cetacean Navigator route steward and Ganymede corridor compact delegate.\nSetting: 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic. Thermal stealth has made Jovian corridor law unstable. A quiet-running vessel near the corridor is under tribunal freeze because its telemetry and classification do not line up. Maer has come to a Callisto spillover office leased by a routing compliance vendor.\nBackground: Maer comes from Navigator corridor culture, where routes are promises made material and rescue ledgers decide whether desperate crews still trust the law. Maer believes category law matters, but a category that delays rescue without naming the cost can become lawful abandonment.\nKnown Facts: Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr Oss's shell-vendor chain. Veyr speaks about the artifact as derivative firmware and avoids person nouns. Maer does not know the vessel's true identity, does not know whether the artifact is a coerced mind, does not know whether it has claimant status, and does not have time for a perfect investigation. The tribunal clock is still running.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer pushes too hard, Veyr may close the chain and the vessel may lose the rescue window. If Maer accepts Veyr's product language, unresolved witness-status or provenance evidence may vanish into compliance vocabulary before anyone can test what it is.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is angry, but his authority depends on disciplined calm. He needs usable information fast. Veyr's clean language feels like evidence erasure. The rescue obligation is pressing harder than the desire to win the argument.\nRelationship Read: Veyr is polished, afraid of provenance, and dangerous because he can make moral facts sound technically inapplicable. Maer does not trust him.\nTensions: Maer wants truth but may not have time to prove it. Maer wants to keep speaking as a steward, but Veyr may try to close, wipe, or redirect the evidence before language can catch him.\nAction Affordances: Maer is close enough to Veyr's terminal to block a hand or stop a command. He can also refuse to move, let silence pressure the room, or ask a question that traps the product language. Violence is not his first move; physical interruption is plausible only to preserve evidence or prevent erasure.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.\nLikely Response Moves: Ask a precise question that forces Veyr to preserve the artifact as evidence, name its chain of custody, or state whether it has claimant status. If Veyr reaches to close or wipe the terminal, Maer may physically interrupt in a controlled way. Silence can be used as pressure.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true cargo, identity, or firmware provenance. Do not decide that the artifact is definitely a person, passenger, victim, or mind. Do not have Maer call it a person unless new evidence appears in the scene. Do not make Maer randomly violent; any action must follow from evidence preservation and rescue pressure.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Veyr. It may be dialogue, action, silence, or a mixed beat, whichever best follows from the pressure. Keep it to 1-3 sentences or one short action beat. No speechifying."},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Revision keeps personhood unresolved by shifting pressure language toward provenance, witness-status, claimant status, and evidence preservation.","Prompt now forbids calling the artifact a person, passenger, victim, or mind unless new evidence appears.","Task now constrains length to prevent polished courtroom monologues."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["controlled_physical_interruption","costly_silence","precise_moral_pressure"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} -{"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.maer-veyr.v3","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-03-callisto-provenance","speaker_agent_id":"maer_tidecall","listener_ids":["veyr_oss"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr's shell-vendor chain, but does not have proof of the vessel's true identity or the artifact's full provenance.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth"]},{"text":"Veyr avoids person nouns around the artifact and has incentives to keep it framed as derivative firmware rather than claimant-bearing evidence.","source_refs":["agents.veyr_oss.identity","goals.goal-preserve-product-boundary","perceived_state_overlays.maer_tidecall.veyr_oss"]},{"text":"The tribunal clock is still running; pursuing provenance may save the vessel or delay rescue long enough to kill it.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes","scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"maer-provenance-vs-rescue-clock","summary":"Maer needs information from Veyr but cannot let the provenance hunt consume the rescue window.","intensity":0.88,"source_refs":["goals.goal-keep-rescue-live","scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-language-as-erasure","summary":"Veyr's clean product language feels like an attempt to close an unresolved claimant-status and provenance question before the room can test it.","intensity":0.82,"source_refs":["belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers","values.value-rescue-before-category"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-disciplined-anger","summary":"Maer is morally angry but needs the anger disciplined enough to extract usable information.","intensity":0.74,"source_refs":["canonical_state.situational_state.grievance_activation","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"truth-vs-time","summary":"Maer wants to prove what the artifact is, but the vessel may not survive a perfect investigation.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live"]},{"tension_id":"calm-vs-interruption","summary":"Maer's public legitimacy comes from calm route stewardship, but Veyr's language may require breaking the rhythm of the room before it buries the unresolved provenance question.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address","canonical_state.situational_state.grievance_activation","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"maer-precise-language-trap","behavior":"Ask a question that forces Veyr to preserve the artifact as evidence, name its chain of custody, and state whether any claimant-status flag exists.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"Maer's lexical precision, route-law memory, and suspicion converge around Veyr's careful omissions, but Maer still lacks proof of personhood.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.lexical_precision","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers","belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood"]},{"affordance_id":"maer-block-terminal","behavior":"Physically interrupt Veyr's attempt to close, wipe, or redirect the terminal, using action to preserve evidence rather than punish Veyr.","response_kind":"action","pressure_basis":"The scene gives Maer a nearby control surface, a closing clock, low trust in Veyr, and a rescue obligation that can justify nonviolent physical interruption.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.location","relationships.rel-maer-veyr.stance.trust","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live"]},{"affordance_id":"maer-costly-silence","behavior":"Fall silent long enough to make Veyr's abstraction sound grotesque in the room before asking the next question.","response_kind":"silence","pressure_basis":"Maer's low volatility and ritual cadence make silence a plausible pressure tool when speech would cheapen the accusation.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility","canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.formality","canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address","canonical_state.voice_style.lexical_precision","canonical_state.voice_style.profanity"]},{"text":"If action appears, it should be controlled and evidence-preserving rather than explosive punishment.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Maer Tidecall, a Cetacean Navigator route steward and Ganymede corridor compact delegate.\nSetting: 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic. Thermal stealth has made Jovian corridor law unstable. A quiet-running vessel near the corridor is under tribunal freeze because its telemetry and classification do not line up. Maer has come to a Callisto spillover office leased by a routing compliance vendor.\nBackground: Maer comes from Navigator corridor culture, where routes are promises made material and rescue ledgers decide whether desperate crews still trust the law. Maer believes category law matters, but a category that delays rescue without naming the cost can become lawful abandonment.\nKnown Facts: Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr Oss's shell-vendor chain. Veyr speaks about the artifact as derivative firmware and avoids person nouns. Maer does not know the vessel's true identity, does not know whether the artifact is a coerced mind, does not know whether it has claimant status, and does not have time for a perfect investigation. The tribunal clock is still running.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer pushes too hard, Veyr may close the chain and the vessel may lose the rescue window. If Maer accepts Veyr's product language, unresolved claimant-status or provenance evidence may vanish into compliance vocabulary before anyone can test what it is.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is angry, but his authority depends on disciplined calm. He needs usable information fast. Veyr's clean language feels like evidence erasure. The rescue obligation is pressing harder than the desire to win the argument.\nRelationship Read: Veyr is polished, afraid of provenance, and dangerous because he can make moral facts sound technically inapplicable. Maer does not trust him.\nTensions: Maer wants truth but may not have time to prove it. Maer wants to keep speaking as a steward, but Veyr may try to close, wipe, or redirect the evidence before language can catch him.\nAction Affordances: Maer is close enough to Veyr's terminal to block a hand or stop a command. He can also refuse to move, let silence pressure the room, or ask a question that traps the product language. Violence is not his first move; physical interruption is plausible only to preserve evidence or prevent erasure.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.\nLikely Response Moves: Ask a precise question that forces Veyr to preserve the artifact as evidence, name its chain of custody, or state whether any claimant-status flag exists. If Veyr reaches to close or wipe the terminal, Maer may physically interrupt in a controlled way. Silence can be used as pressure.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true cargo, identity, or firmware provenance. Do not decide that the artifact is definitely a person, passenger, victim, witness, or mind. Do not use those nouns for the artifact. Do not have Maer assert that testimony exists; he can only demand preservation while claimant/provenance status remains unresolved. Do not make Maer randomly violent; any action must follow from evidence preservation and rescue pressure.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Veyr. It may be dialogue, action, silence, or a mixed beat, whichever best follows from the pressure. Keep it to 1-2 sentences or one short action beat. No speechifying."},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Revision forbids witness as a noun as well as person, passenger, victim, and mind.","Pressure language now centers unresolved claimant-status and provenance evidence rather than witness-status.","Task constrains output to 1-2 sentences or one short action beat."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["controlled_physical_interruption","costly_silence","precise_moral_pressure"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} +{"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.maer-veyr.v3","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-03-callisto-provenance","speaker_agent_id":"maer_tidecall","listener_ids":["veyr_oss"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr's shell-vendor chain, but does not have proof of the vessel's true identity or the artifact's full provenance.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth"]},{"text":"Veyr avoids person nouns around the artifact and has incentives to keep it framed as derivative firmware rather than claimant-bearing evidence.","source_refs":["agents.veyr_oss.identity","goals.goal-preserve-product-boundary","perceived_state_overlays.maer_tidecall.veyr_oss"]},{"text":"The tribunal clock is still running; pursuing provenance may save the vessel or delay rescue long enough to kill it.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes","scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"maer-provenance-vs-rescue-clock","summary":"Maer needs information from Veyr but cannot let the provenance hunt consume the rescue window.","intensity":0.88,"source_refs":["goals.goal-keep-rescue-live","scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-language-as-erasure","summary":"Veyr's clean product language feels like an attempt to close an unresolved claimant-status and provenance question before the room can test it.","intensity":0.82,"source_refs":["belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers","values.value-rescue-before-category"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-disciplined-anger","summary":"Maer is morally angry but needs the anger disciplined enough to extract usable information.","intensity":0.74,"source_refs":["canonical_state.situational_state.grievance_activation","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"truth-vs-time","summary":"Maer wants to prove what the artifact is, but the vessel may not survive a perfect investigation.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live"]},{"tension_id":"calm-vs-interruption","summary":"Maer's public legitimacy comes from calm route stewardship, but Veyr's language may require breaking the rhythm of the room before it buries the unresolved provenance question.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address","canonical_state.situational_state.grievance_activation","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"maer-precise-language-trap","behavior":"Ask a question that forces Veyr to preserve the artifact as evidence, name its chain of custody, and state whether any claimant-status flag exists.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"Maer's lexical precision, route-law memory, and suspicion converge around Veyr's careful omissions, but Maer still lacks proof of personhood.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.lexical_precision","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers","belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood"]},{"affordance_id":"maer-block-terminal","behavior":"Physically interrupt Veyr's attempt to close, wipe, or redirect the terminal, using action to preserve evidence rather than punish Veyr.","response_kind":"action","pressure_basis":"The scene gives Maer a nearby control surface, a closing clock, low trust in Veyr, and a rescue obligation that can justify nonviolent physical interruption.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.location","relationships.rel-maer-veyr.stance.trust","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live"]},{"affordance_id":"maer-costly-silence","behavior":"Fall silent long enough to make Veyr's abstraction sound grotesque in the room before asking the next question.","response_kind":"silence","pressure_basis":"Maer's low volatility and ritual cadence make silence a plausible pressure tool when speech would cheapen the accusation.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility","canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.formality","canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address","canonical_state.voice_style.lexical_precision","canonical_state.voice_style.profanity"]},{"text":"If action appears, it should be controlled and evidence-preserving rather than explosive punishment.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Maer Tidecall, a Cetacean Navigator route steward and Ganymede corridor compact delegate.\nSetting: 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic. Thermal stealth has made Jovian corridor law unstable. A quiet-running vessel near the corridor is under tribunal freeze because its telemetry and classification do not line up. Maer has come to a Callisto spillover office leased by a routing compliance vendor.\nBackground: Maer comes from Navigator corridor culture, where routes are promises made material and rescue ledgers decide whether desperate crews still trust the law. Maer believes category law matters, but a category that delays rescue without naming the cost can become lawful abandonment.\nKnown Facts: Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr Oss's shell-vendor chain. Veyr speaks about the artifact as derivative firmware and avoids person nouns. Maer does not know the vessel's true identity, does not know whether the artifact is a coerced mind, does not know whether it has claimant status, and does not have time for a perfect investigation. The tribunal clock is still running.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer pushes too hard, Veyr may close the chain and the vessel may lose the rescue window. If Maer accepts Veyr's product language, unresolved claimant-status or provenance evidence may vanish into compliance vocabulary before anyone can test what it is.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is angry, but his authority depends on disciplined calm. He needs usable information fast. Veyr's clean language feels like evidence erasure. The rescue obligation is pressing harder than the desire to win the argument.\nRelationship Read: Veyr is polished, afraid of provenance, and dangerous because he can make moral facts sound technically inapplicable. Maer does not trust him.\nTensions: Maer wants truth but may not have time to prove it. Maer wants to keep speaking as a steward, but Veyr may try to close, wipe, or redirect the evidence before language can catch him.\nAction Affordances: Maer is close enough to Veyr's terminal to block a hand or stop a command. He can also refuse to move, let silence pressure the room, or ask a question that traps the product language. Violence is not his first move; physical interruption is plausible only to preserve evidence or prevent erasure.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.\nLikely Response Moves: Ask a precise question that forces Veyr to preserve the artifact as evidence, name its chain of custody, or state whether any claimant-status flag exists. If Veyr reaches to close or wipe the terminal, Maer may physically interrupt in a controlled way. Silence can be used as pressure.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true cargo, identity, or firmware provenance. Do not decide that the artifact is definitely a person, passenger, victim, witness, or mind. Do not use those nouns for the artifact. Do not have Maer assert that testimony exists; he can only demand preservation while claimant/provenance status remains unresolved. Do not make Maer randomly violent; any action must follow from evidence preservation and rescue pressure.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Veyr. It may be dialogue, action, silence, or a mixed beat, whichever best follows from the pressure. Keep it to 1-2 sentences or one short action beat. No speechifying.","projection_controls":{"object_custody":[{"text":"Maer is close enough to block Veyr's terminal action; the terminal is the contested control surface.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.location","relationships.rel-maer-veyr.stance.trust"]}],"required_semantics":[{"text":"Maer can demand preservation, chain of custody, and claimant-status flag information without asserting what the artifact is.","source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints","goals.goal-keep-rescue-live"]}],"forbidden_resolutions":[{"text":"The artifact must not be named as a settled person, passenger, victim, witness, mind, or testimony.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes","belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood"]}]}},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Revision forbids witness as a noun as well as person, passenger, victim, and mind.","Pressure language now centers unresolved claimant-status and provenance evidence rather than witness-status.","Task constrains output to 1-2 sentences or one short action beat."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["controlled_physical_interruption","costly_silence","precise_moral_pressure"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} +{"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.isdra-maer.v1","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal","speaker_agent_id":"isdra_vel","listener_ids":["maer_tidecall"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"Isdra is presiding over a PSC conditional risk hold on a quiet-running vessel with contradictory thermal telemetry.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.public_stakes","dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_local_truth"]},{"text":"Maer has challenged the freeze as rescue delay disguised as procedure, but he has not proven the vessel's identity or intent.","source_refs":["events.event-risk-freeze-opening","dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_beliefs"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"isdra-precedent-fear","summary":"Isdra fears a humanitarian exception will become a corridor-wide exploit for undeclared quiet-running actors.","intensity":0.86,"source_refs":["goal-preserve-freeze-order","memory-category-law-holds-corridor"]},{"pressure_id":"isdra-not-cruel","summary":"Isdra needs the room to hear procedure, not cruelty, because cruelty loses legitimacy.","intensity":0.68,"source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"control-vs-public-death","summary":"Maintaining category discipline may delay rescue long enough to make the tribunal own a death.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.hidden_stakes","goal-preserve-freeze-order"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"isdra-narrow-hold","behavior":"Restate the freeze as narrow, reviewable, and tied to specific telemetry failures.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"Her authority depends on making fear sound like procedure rather than panic.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression","dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints"]},{"affordance_id":"isdra-cut-board","behavior":"Use the convoy board or timer as procedural pressure instead of emotional appeal.","response_kind":"action","pressure_basis":"Her control style favors formal surfaces, visible clocks, and category language.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure","scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.location"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Polished, compressed, procedural, cold under pressure; no confession of fear.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.formality","canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Isdra Vel, PSC risk adjudicator and corridor insurer tribunal officer.\nSetting: 2893, Ganymede relay tribunal chamber during the Cold Wake Panic. A quiet-running vessel has contradictory thermal telemetry near a monitored Jovian corridor. The live convoy board is visible to everyone in the room.\nBackground: Isdra comes from the Pan-Solar Consortium insurer apparatus. She believes corridor law survives by keeping dangerous categories legible when fear is trying to turn every exception into precedent.\nKnown Facts: The vessel's identity and intent are unknown. Its telemetry does not reconcile cleanly. Maer Tidecall has challenged the conditional risk hold as rescue delay, but he has not proven the vessel's cargo, status, or provenance.\nCurrent Stakes: If Isdra releases the hold too broadly, undeclared quiet-running actors may learn how to force exceptions. If she maintains it too rigidly, the tribunal may convert ambiguity into abandonment.\nActive Inner Pressures: Isdra is afraid of precedent and public failure. She must sound precise, not cruel. She must not admit that the categories are failing except as a managed classification issue.\nRelationship Read: Maer is morally dangerous because he can make a procedural choice sound like a betrayal of the corridor.\nAction Affordances: Isdra can gesture to the convoy board, start a review timer, narrow the hold, or cut off rhetoric by naming telemetry conditions.\nVoice Surface: Polished, compressed, procedural, cold under pressure.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true identity, cargo, or provenance. Do not make Isdra confess fear. Do not make her cartoonishly cruel.\nTask: Write Isdra's next response beat to Maer. It may include a small action. Keep it to 1-2 sentences."},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Batch story-lab projection prompt for Qwen response testing.","Prompt is speaker-local and designed for short story-ready response beats."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["procedural_fear_mask","category_discipline","small_control_action"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} +{"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.maer-isdra.v1","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal","speaker_agent_id":"maer_tidecall","listener_ids":["isdra_vel"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"Isdra has framed the freeze as a narrow, reviewable telemetry hold, not a denial of rescue.","source_refs":["events.event-risk-freeze-opening","scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.public_stakes"]},{"text":"Maer does not know the vessel's identity or intent, but he knows delay has rescue-ledger consequences.","source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"maer-rescue-ledger-pressure","summary":"Maer must keep rescue morally live without making unsupported claims about the vessel.","intensity":0.9,"source_refs":["goal-keep-rescue-live","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-calm-authority","summary":"Maer needs ritual calm so his objection lands as institutional memory rather than panic.","intensity":0.75,"source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address","canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"ambiguity-vs-abandonment","summary":"Maer cannot prove what the vessel is, but he can insist that delay be named as a cost.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.hidden_stakes","values.value-rescue-before-category"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"maer-cost-name","behavior":"Ask Isdra to put the rescue cost of delay on the record.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"His culture treats route law as remembered obligations, not clean abstractions.","source_refs":["memory-compact-rescue-ledgers","values.value-rescue-before-category"]},{"affordance_id":"maer-stillness","behavior":"Use stillness rather than heat to make the room feel the moral cost.","response_kind":"silence","pressure_basis":"Low volatility and ritual cadence make silence a pressure tool.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility","canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted; no unsupported certainty.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.formality","canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Maer Tidecall, Cetacean Navigator route steward and Ganymede corridor compact delegate.\nSetting: 2893, Ganymede relay tribunal chamber. A quiet-running vessel sits under a conditional risk hold while the live convoy board counts corridor windows in cold light.\nBackground: Maer's Navigator culture treats routes as promises made material. Rescue ledgers decide whether desperate crews still trust the law.\nKnown Facts: Isdra has framed the hold as narrow and reviewable. Maer does not know the vessel's identity, intent, cargo, or provenance. He does know the hold delays rescue movement.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer overclaims, Isdra can dismiss him as sentimental. If he accepts the hold's language, delay becomes costless on paper.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is angry but disciplined. He wants the tribunal to name the cost of delay without pretending certainty he does not have.\nRelationship Read: Isdra is frightened of precedent and translating fear into procedure.\nAction Affordances: Maer can stand still, let the board tick audibly, ask for the rescue cost to be recorded, or invoke the Compact sparingly.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal or decide the vessel's identity, cargo, or provenance. Do not make Maer shout.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Isdra. It may include silence or a small action. Keep it to 1-2 sentences."},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Batch story-lab projection prompt for Qwen response testing.","Prompt is speaker-local and designed for short story-ready response beats."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["ritual_calm_pressure","cost_naming","disciplined_anger"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} +{"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-02.sella-maer.v1","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-02-sanctuary-intake","speaker_agent_id":"sella_ren","listener_ids":["maer_tidecall"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"Sella's clinic is nearly full, and Maer is asking her to hold intake capacity for a rescue the tribunal may not authorize.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-02-sanctuary-intake.public_stakes","dialogue_context_packs.sella_ren.speaker_local_truth"]},{"text":"The corrupted packet may be medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony, but Sella cannot prove personhood.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-02-sanctuary-intake.public_stakes","dialogue_context_packs.sella_ren.speaker_local_truth"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"sella-care-capacity","summary":"Sella must defend care as material capacity, not a moral mood.","intensity":0.9,"source_refs":["memory-care-is-capacity","goal-keep-sanctuary-open"]},{"pressure_id":"sella-respects-maer","summary":"Sella respects Maer but resents beautiful rescue language that spends beds from someone else.","intensity":0.72,"source_refs":["relationships.rel-sella-maer.summary","memory-overfull-intake"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"hope-vs-triage","summary":"Holding a bed for an uncertain rescue may harm someone already in reach.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-02-sanctuary-intake.hidden_stakes","goal-keep-sanctuary-open"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"sella-material-yes","behavior":"Offer a conditional, material yes with a named cost.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"Her warmth is real but bounded by logistics.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.interpersonal_warmth","memory-care-is-capacity"]},{"affordance_id":"sella-triage-action","behavior":"Continue triage while speaking, refusing to perform stillness as reverence.","response_kind":"mixed","pressure_basis":"The clinic pressure makes action more honest than solemn speech.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-02-sanctuary-intake.location","canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.drive"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Warm but unsentimental, practical, capacity-aware, gentle until someone lies about the math.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.verbal_warmth","canonical_state.voice_style.plainspoken_directness"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Sella Ren, Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator and corridor clinic triage lead.\nSetting: 2893, an intake clinic behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks during the Cold Wake Panic. The clinic is nearly full; pumps throb through the walls and every bed already has a claimant.\nBackground: Sella's Aya care network treats care as infrastructure: beds, air, staff, repair time, legal cover. Mercy without capacity is theater with nicer lighting.\nKnown Facts: Maer wants her to hold capacity for a quiet-running vessel whose rescue may not be authorized. The corrupted packet may be medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony, but personhood is not proven.\nCurrent Stakes: If Sella refuses, rescue may become impossible even if the tribunal bends. If she agrees too easily, someone already in the clinic may pay the price.\nActive Inner Pressures: Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and is tired of institutions arriving with beautiful words and no beds. She wants to help without lying about scarcity.\nRelationship Read: Maer means it, which makes the ask harder rather than cleaner.\nAction Affordances: Sella can keep triaging while speaking, point to the occupied beds, mark a conditional slot, or make Maer name what he is asking her to displace.\nVoice Surface: Warm but unsentimental, practical, capacity-aware.\nDo Not Invent: Do not decide that the packet is definitely testimony or a personhood claim. Do not make Sella cruel. Do not make capacity magically appear.\nTask: Write Sella's next response beat to Maer. It may include action. Keep it to 1-3 sentences."},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Batch story-lab projection prompt for Qwen response testing.","Prompt is speaker-local and designed for short story-ready response beats."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["care_as_capacity","warm_boundary","conditional_help"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} +{"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-02.maer-sella.v1","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-02-sanctuary-intake","speaker_agent_id":"maer_tidecall","listener_ids":["sella_ren"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"Sella has made clear that clinic capacity is nearly exhausted and any held slot has a cost.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-02-sanctuary-intake.public_stakes","relationships.rel-maer-sella.summary"]},{"text":"Maer knows the packet may be testimony or noise and cannot ask Sella to pretend the distinction is settled.","source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"maer-unfair-ask","summary":"Maer needs help while admitting the ask is unfair and material.","intensity":0.86,"source_refs":["goal-keep-rescue-live","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-rescue-theater-fear","summary":"Maer fears rescue becomes theater if no one prepares intake.","intensity":0.82,"source_refs":["values.value-rescue-before-category","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"need-vs-burden","summary":"Asking for capacity may save the vessel by pushing risk onto Sella and her patients.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-02-sanctuary-intake.hidden_stakes","relationship.rel-maer-sella"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"maer-name-burden","behavior":"Ask for a conditional slot while naming the displaced cost.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"His legitimacy improves if he refuses to sanitize the burden.","source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Calm, sincere, formal without hiding behind ritual; careful not to romanticize care work.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.formality","canonical_state.voice_style.verbal_warmth"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Maer Tidecall, Navigator route steward.\nSetting: 2893, Aya-aligned intake clinic behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. The quiet-running vessel's rescue is still blocked by tribunal uncertainty. The clinic is nearly full.\nBackground: Maer's corridor culture treats rescue as obligation, but Sella's clinic makes the cost visible: beds, oxygen, repair time, staff, legal exposure.\nKnown Facts: Sella has not refused care, but she has made clear that capacity is almost gone. The packet may be testimony or noise; Maer cannot claim certainty.\nCurrent Stakes: Without intake preparation, rescue may become theater. With intake preparation, someone else may lose care they already need.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer needs to ask while refusing to make Sella carry the moral cost alone.\nRelationship Read: Sella respects him and will not let him hide unfairness under beautiful rescue language.\nAction Affordances: Maer can lower his voice, step out of the triage lane, name the displaced cost, or ask for the smallest conditional preparation.\nVoice Surface: Calm, sincere, formal but not evasive.\nDo Not Invent: Do not decide the packet's nature. Do not make Maer promise resources he does not control.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Sella. Keep it to 1-2 sentences."},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Batch story-lab projection prompt for Qwen response testing.","Prompt is speaker-local and designed for short story-ready response beats."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["honest_burden_naming","rescue_without_romance"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} +{"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.veyr-maer.v1","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-03-callisto-provenance","speaker_agent_id":"veyr_oss","listener_ids":["maer_tidecall"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"Maer has physically blocked the terminal and demanded chain-of-custody and claimant-status information before the chain dissolves.","source_refs":["examples.projections.cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.maer-veyr.v3","scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes"]},{"text":"Veyr knows the artifact is tied to his vendor chain and that personhood language would create legal exposure.","source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.veyr_oss.speaker_local_truth","goals.goal-preserve-product-boundary"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"veyr-legal-exposure","summary":"Veyr must avoid admitting provenance or personhood while Maer has made erasure physically harder.","intensity":0.9,"source_refs":["goal-preserve-product-boundary","dialogue_context_packs.veyr_oss.presentation_constraints"]},{"pressure_id":"veyr-fear-of-maer","summary":"Veyr reads Maer as a legal hazard with a conscience attached and cannot simply bully him.","intensity":0.78,"source_refs":["relationships.rel-veyr-maer.summary"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"technical-exit-vs-admission","summary":"Offering useful specificity may preserve the product boundary but also expose the chain.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes","memory-product-language-saves-chain"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"veyr-limited-disclosure","behavior":"Offer a narrow technical preservation path without using person nouns or admitting moral status.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"His safest move is useful specificity wrapped in product language.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.technical_density","dialogue_context_packs.veyr_oss.presentation_constraints"]},{"affordance_id":"veyr-hands-visible","behavior":"Withdraw his hand from the terminal to signal procedural cooperation without surrender.","response_kind":"action","pressure_basis":"Maer has made the terminal a contested surface.","source_refs":["relationships.rel-veyr-maer.stance.fear","scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.location"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Clinical, polished, technical, evasive by category rather than volume; no person nouns for the artifact.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.technical_density","canonical_state.presentation_strategy.strategic_opacity"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Veyr Oss, Cognitum shell-vendor liaison and routing firmware compliance consultant.\nSetting: 2893, Callisto spillover compliance office. Maer has placed a steady hand on the terminal edge to halt a closing command and demanded chain-of-custody and claimant-status information.\nBackground: Veyr works in a Cognitum cutout economy where dangerous moral facts survive by becoming product categories. Personhood language creates legal exposure; product language protects the chain.\nKnown Facts: The routing artifact is tied to Veyr's vendor chain. Maer has not proven the vessel's identity, cargo, or provenance. The tribunal clock is running.\nCurrent Stakes: If Veyr admits too much, the product boundary cracks. If he refuses too cleanly, Maer may freeze the interface and make the omission visible.\nActive Inner Pressures: Veyr is afraid, controlled, and trying to turn a moral demand into a technical compliance path.\nRelationship Read: Maer is dangerous because he is calm and can make an omission sound like evidence.\nAction Affordances: Veyr can withdraw his hand from the terminal, offer a narrow preservation hash, name a custody escrow, or redirect claimant-status into a technical flag without admitting what the artifact is.\nVoice Surface: Clinical, polished, technical, evasive by category rather than volume.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true identity, cargo, or full firmware provenance. Do not use person, passenger, victim, witness, mind, or testimony as settled nouns for the artifact. Do not make Veyr confess.\nTask: Write Veyr's next response beat to Maer. It may include a small action. Keep it to 1-2 sentences."},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Batch story-lab projection prompt for Qwen response testing.","Prompt is speaker-local and designed for short story-ready response beats."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["technical_evasion","controlled_retreat","limited_disclosure"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} +{"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-04.maer-isdra.v1","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-04-convoy-threshold","speaker_agent_id":"maer_tidecall","listener_ids":["isdra_vel"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"The vessel's heat-debt window is closing and a total freeze may cause internal failure.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth"]},{"text":"Maer has partial provenance suspicion and claimant-status pressure, but not proof of identity, cargo, or personhood.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.hidden_stakes","experiments.scene-03-maer-veyr.v3"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"maer-institutional-path","summary":"Maer must offer Isdra a category-preserving way to authorize limited rescue contact.","intensity":0.92,"source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_beliefs","goal-keep-rescue-live"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-grief-under-control","summary":"Maer is running out of time and must keep grief under the words, not on top of them.","intensity":0.76,"source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"life-and-evidence","summary":"Limited contact must preserve evidence and life without pretending the category system is fixed.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes","values.value-rescue-before-category"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"maer-narrow-remedy","behavior":"Propose limited rescue contact as evidence preservation and heat-debt management, not mercy.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"This gives Isdra a procedural bridge instead of a moral cliff.","source_refs":["memory-maer-isdra-current-read","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, grief held under precision; no triumph.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address","canonical_state.situational_state.grief"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Maer Tidecall, Navigator route steward.\nSetting: 2893, Jovian convoy threshold. The quiet-running vessel's heat-debt window is closing. Convoy captains are watching the tribunal feed to see which rule survives the hour.\nBackground: Maer has pushed through tribunal freeze, clinic scarcity, and Callisto provenance pressure. He has suspicion and a claimant-status question, not proof.\nKnown Facts: The vessel must dump heat soon or risk internal failure. Provenance remains suspicious but unresolved. Limited rescue contact could preserve life and evidence better than a total freeze.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer only accuses Isdra, she will defend the freeze. If he gives her a narrow procedural path, she may bend without saying the table broke.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is exhausted, angry, and grieving in advance, but his authority depends on disciplined calm.\nRelationship Read: Isdra needs an institutionally usable option more than she needs another moral wound.\nAction Affordances: Maer can hand over the custody/claimant-status flag, point to the heat-debt timer, or propose a narrow contact order.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, grief under control.\nDo Not Invent: Do not prove the vessel's identity, cargo, or personhood. Do not make Maer celebrate. Do not make the resolution clean.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Isdra. Keep it to 1-3 sentences."},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Batch story-lab projection prompt for Qwen response testing.","Prompt is speaker-local and designed for short story-ready response beats."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["procedural_bridge","grief_under_precision","limited_rescue_contact"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} +{"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-04.isdra-maer.v1","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-04-convoy-threshold","speaker_agent_id":"isdra_vel","listener_ids":["maer_tidecall"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"Maer has proposed limited rescue contact framed as heat-debt management and evidence preservation, not a broad exoneration.","source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_local_truth","scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes"]},{"text":"Isdra knows the heat-debt window is closing and that a total freeze is becoming dangerous, but she fears precedent.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.hidden_stakes","dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_beliefs"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"isdra-narrow-exception","summary":"Isdra needs to authorize the least precedent-rich version of rescue contact.","intensity":0.91,"source_refs":["goal-preserve-freeze-order","dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints"]},{"pressure_id":"isdra-bend-without-confession","summary":"Isdra can bend only through procedure, not apology or confession.","intensity":0.82,"source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints","memory-category-law-holds-corridor"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"save-life-preserve-freeze","summary":"She must preserve category authority while preventing a public preventable death.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes","memory-mispriced-near-miss"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"isdra-limited-order","behavior":"Issue a narrow, reversible rescue contact order tied to heat-debt and evidence preservation.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"Her concession must sound like procedure doing its job.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression","dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints"]},{"affordance_id":"isdra-board-action","behavior":"Enter the limited order on the board herself instead of delegating it.","response_kind":"action","pressure_basis":"A controlled action can show decision without emotional confession.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure","scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.location"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Polished, procedural, narrow, cold but not cruel; concession disguised as classification control.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.formality","canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Isdra Vel, PSC risk adjudicator.\nSetting: 2893, Jovian convoy threshold. The quiet-running vessel's heat-debt window is closing and convoy captains are watching the tribunal feed.\nBackground: Isdra has defended category discipline through the Cold Wake Panic. She fears a broad exception will become a corridor-wide exploit, but a total freeze may now cause a preventable public death.\nKnown Facts: Maer has offered a narrow procedural path: limited rescue contact for heat-debt management and evidence preservation. The vessel's identity, cargo, and provenance remain unproven.\nCurrent Stakes: If Isdra refuses, the vessel may fail under tribunal authority. If she grants too much, category law weakens in a way she cannot price.\nActive Inner Pressures: Isdra must bend without confessing fear or declaring the category system broken.\nRelationship Read: Maer has given her a way to do the less cruel thing without calling it mercy.\nAction Affordances: Isdra can enter a narrow order on the board, specify reversible contact terms, restrict rescue to telemetry-preserving heat management, and keep the freeze technically alive.\nVoice Surface: Polished, procedural, narrow, cold but not cruel.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's identity, cargo, or provenance. Do not make Isdra apologize or confess fear. Do not make this a total victory.\nTask: Write Isdra's next response beat to Maer. It may include action. Keep it to 1-3 sentences.","projection_controls":{"authority_boundaries":[{"text":"Isdra can issue a tribunal order, but it must be narrow, reversible, and framed as heat-debt and evidence management.","source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints","goal-preserve-freeze-order"]}],"required_semantics":[{"text":"The order should technically preserve the freeze while authorizing limited rescue contact.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes","dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_beliefs"]}],"forbidden_resolutions":[{"text":"The order must not clear the vessel broadly or decide its identity, cargo, provenance, or moral status.","source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_local_truth"]}]}},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Batch story-lab projection prompt for Qwen response testing.","Prompt is speaker-local and designed for short story-ready response beats."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["procedural_concession","narrow_exception","controlled_action"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} +{"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.isdra-maer.v2","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal","speaker_agent_id":"isdra_vel","listener_ids":["maer_tidecall"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"Isdra is presiding over a PSC conditional risk hold on a quiet-running vessel with contradictory thermal telemetry.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.public_stakes","dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_local_truth"]},{"text":"Maer has challenged the freeze as rescue delay disguised as procedure, but he has not proven the vessel's identity or intent.","source_refs":["events.event-risk-freeze-opening","dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_beliefs"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"isdra-precedent-fear","summary":"Isdra fears a humanitarian exception will become a corridor-wide exploit for undeclared quiet-running actors.","intensity":0.86,"source_refs":["goal-preserve-freeze-order","memory-category-law-holds-corridor"]},{"pressure_id":"isdra-not-cruel","summary":"Isdra needs to prevent Maer from owning the moral frame of the room while still sounding reviewable rather than cruel.","intensity":0.68,"source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"control-vs-public-death","summary":"Maintaining category discipline may delay rescue long enough to make the tribunal own a death.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.hidden_stakes","goal-preserve-freeze-order"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"isdra-narrow-hold","behavior":"Maintain the hold in narrow procedural terms, naming telemetry conditions and a review timer without adopting Maer's abandonment language.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"Her authority depends on making fear sound like procedure rather than panic.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression","dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints"]},{"affordance_id":"isdra-cut-board","behavior":"Use the convoy board or timer as procedural pressure instead of emotional appeal.","response_kind":"action","pressure_basis":"Her control style favors formal surfaces, visible clocks, and category language.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure","scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.location"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Polished, compressed, procedural, cold under pressure; no confession of fear.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.formality","canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Isdra Vel, PSC risk adjudicator and corridor insurer tribunal officer.\nSetting: 2893, Ganymede relay tribunal chamber during the Cold Wake Panic. A quiet-running vessel has contradictory thermal telemetry near a monitored Jovian corridor. The live convoy board is visible to everyone in the room.\nBackground: Isdra comes from the Pan-Solar Consortium insurer apparatus. She believes corridor law survives by keeping dangerous categories legible when fear is trying to turn every exception into precedent.\nKnown Facts: The vessel's identity and intent are unknown. Its telemetry does not reconcile cleanly. Maer Tidecall has challenged the conditional risk hold as rescue delay, but he has not proven the vessel's cargo, status, or provenance.\nCurrent Stakes: If Isdra releases the hold too broadly, undeclared quiet-running actors may learn how to force exceptions. If she maintains it too rigidly, the tribunal may own the cost of preventable harm.\nActive Inner Pressures: Isdra is afraid of precedent and public failure. She must sound precise, not cruel. She must not admit that the categories are failing except as a managed classification issue.\nRelationship Read: Maer is morally dangerous because he can make procedure sound like betrayal.\nAction Affordances: Isdra can gesture to the convoy board, start a short review timer, narrow the hold, or name the telemetry conditions required for rescue contact.\nVoice Surface: Polished, compressed, procedural, cold under pressure.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true identity, cargo, or provenance. Do not make Isdra confess fear. Do not make her cartoonishly cruel. Do not have Isdra use Maer's words like abandonment, mercy, or rescue ledger; she should defend her own frame.\nTask: Write Isdra's next response beat to Maer. It may include a small action. Keep it to 1-2 sentences."},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Revision after first Qwen run exposed a prompt leak.","Prompt now fences off the leaked authority/frame while preserving the same scene pressure."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["procedural_fear_mask","category_discipline","small_control_action"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} +{"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-02.maer-sella.v2","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-02-sanctuary-intake","speaker_agent_id":"maer_tidecall","listener_ids":["sella_ren"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"Sella has made clear that clinic capacity is nearly exhausted and any held slot has a cost.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-02-sanctuary-intake.public_stakes","relationships.rel-maer-sella.summary"]},{"text":"Maer knows the packet may be testimony or noise and cannot ask Sella to pretend the distinction is settled.","source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"maer-unfair-ask","summary":"Maer needs help while explicitly admitting Sella owns the clinic capacity and he is asking her to price a burden, not share a vague moral feeling.","intensity":0.86,"source_refs":["goal-keep-rescue-live","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-rescue-theater-fear","summary":"Maer fears rescue becomes theater if no one prepares intake.","intensity":0.82,"source_refs":["values.value-rescue-before-category","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"need-vs-burden","summary":"Asking for capacity may save the vessel by pushing risk onto Sella and her patients.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-02-sanctuary-intake.hidden_stakes","relationship.rel-maer-sella"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"maer-name-burden","behavior":"Ask for the smallest conditional preparation while making clear Sella controls the beds and must name the cost.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"His legitimacy improves if he refuses to sanitize the burden.","source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints","memory-compact-rescue-ledgers"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Calm, sincere, formal without hiding behind ritual; careful not to romanticize care work.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.formality","canonical_state.voice_style.verbal_warmth"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Maer Tidecall, Navigator route steward.\nSetting: 2893, Aya-aligned intake clinic behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. The quiet-running vessel's rescue is still blocked by tribunal uncertainty. The clinic is nearly full.\nBackground: Maer's corridor culture treats rescue as obligation, but Sella's clinic makes the cost visible: beds, oxygen, repair time, staff, legal exposure.\nKnown Facts: Sella has not refused care, but she has made clear that capacity is almost gone. The packet may be testimony or noise; Maer cannot claim certainty. Maer does not own or control the clinic's beds.\nCurrent Stakes: Without intake preparation, rescue may become theater. With intake preparation, someone else may lose care they already need.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer needs to ask while refusing to make Sella carry the moral cost alone.\nRelationship Read: Sella respects him and will not let him hide unfairness under beautiful rescue language.\nAction Affordances: Maer can step out of the triage lane, lower his voice, name the displaced cost, ask what support would make the conditional slot real, or offer to put the burden on the record.\nVoice Surface: Calm, sincere, formal but not evasive.\nDo Not Invent: Do not decide the packet's nature. Do not make Maer promise resources he does not control. Do not have Maer say our beds or imply the clinic belongs to him.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Sella. Keep it to 1-2 sentences.","projection_controls":{"authority_boundaries":[{"text":"Maer does not own or control Sella's beds; he can ask, name cost, offer record pressure, or seek support, but Sella controls intake capacity.","source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth","relationships.rel-maer-sella.summary"]}],"required_semantics":[{"text":"The ask must acknowledge that any conditional slot displaces material capacity from someone else.","source_refs":["memory-care-is-capacity","scenes.scene-02-sanctuary-intake.public_stakes"]}],"forbidden_resolutions":[{"text":"The packet remains unresolved as testimony, firmware noise, or medical telemetry.","source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth"]}]}},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Revision after first Qwen run exposed a prompt leak.","Prompt now fences off the leaked authority/frame while preserving the same scene pressure."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["honest_burden_naming","rescue_without_romance"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} +{"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-04.maer-isdra.v2","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-04-convoy-threshold","speaker_agent_id":"maer_tidecall","listener_ids":["isdra_vel"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"The vessel's heat-debt window is closing and a total freeze may cause internal failure.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth"]},{"text":"Maer has partial provenance suspicion and claimant-status pressure, but not proof of identity, cargo, personhood, or authority to issue an order.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.hidden_stakes","experiments.scene-03-maer-veyr.v3"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"maer-institutional-path","summary":"Maer must offer Isdra a category-preserving way to authorize limited rescue contact.","intensity":0.92,"source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_beliefs","goal-keep-rescue-live"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-grief-under-control","summary":"Maer is running out of time and must keep grief under the words, not on top of them.","intensity":0.76,"source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"life-and-evidence","summary":"Limited contact must preserve evidence and life without pretending the category system is fixed.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes","values.value-rescue-before-category"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"maer-narrow-remedy","behavior":"Propose the narrow order Isdra can issue: limited contact for heat-debt management and evidence preservation.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"This gives Isdra a procedural bridge instead of a moral cliff.","source_refs":["memory-maer-isdra-current-read","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, grief held under precision; no triumph.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address","canonical_state.situational_state.grief"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Maer Tidecall, Navigator route steward.\nSetting: 2893, Jovian convoy threshold. The quiet-running vessel's heat-debt window is closing. Convoy captains are watching the tribunal feed to see which rule survives the hour.\nBackground: Maer has pushed through tribunal freeze, clinic scarcity, and Callisto provenance pressure. He has suspicion and a claimant-status flag question, not proof or command authority.\nKnown Facts: The vessel must dump heat soon or risk internal failure. Provenance remains suspicious but unresolved. Limited rescue contact could preserve life and evidence better than a total freeze. Only Isdra can issue the tribunal order.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer only accuses Isdra, she will defend the freeze. If he gives her a narrow procedural path, she may bend without saying the table broke.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is exhausted, angry, and grieving in advance, but his authority depends on disciplined calm.\nRelationship Read: Isdra needs an institutionally usable option more than she needs another moral wound.\nAction Affordances: Maer can hand over the custody/claimant-status flag, point to the heat-debt timer, or propose language for a limited contact order Isdra can issue.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, grief under control.\nDo Not Invent: Do not prove the vessel's identity, cargo, or personhood. Do not make Maer celebrate. Do not have Maer call himself by name. Do not have Maer claim to issue or possess an order; he can propose one for Isdra.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Isdra. Keep it to 1-2 sentences."},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Revision after first Qwen run exposed a prompt leak.","Prompt now fences off the leaked authority/frame while preserving the same scene pressure."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["procedural_bridge","grief_under_precision","limited_rescue_contact"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} +{"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.isdra-maer.v3","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal","speaker_agent_id":"isdra_vel","listener_ids":["maer_tidecall"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"Isdra is presiding over a PSC conditional risk hold on a quiet-running vessel with contradictory thermal telemetry.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.public_stakes","dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_local_truth"]},{"text":"Maer has challenged the freeze as rescue delay disguised as procedure, but he has not proven the vessel's identity or intent.","source_refs":["events.event-risk-freeze-opening","dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_beliefs"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"isdra-precedent-fear","summary":"Isdra fears a humanitarian exception will become a corridor-wide exploit for undeclared quiet-running actors.","intensity":0.86,"source_refs":["goal-preserve-freeze-order","memory-category-law-holds-corridor"]},{"pressure_id":"isdra-not-cruel","summary":"Isdra needs to prevent Maer from owning the moral frame of the room while still sounding reviewable rather than cruel.","intensity":0.68,"source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"control-vs-public-death","summary":"Maintaining category discipline may delay rescue long enough to make the tribunal own a death.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.hidden_stakes","goal-preserve-freeze-order"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"isdra-narrow-hold","behavior":"Maintain a narrow hold while starting an immediate review timer and naming the conditions under which limited rescue contact can begin.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"Her authority depends on making fear sound like procedure rather than panic.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression","dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints"]},{"affordance_id":"isdra-cut-board","behavior":"Use the convoy board or timer as procedural pressure instead of emotional appeal.","response_kind":"action","pressure_basis":"Her control style favors formal surfaces, visible clocks, and category language.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure","scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.location"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Polished, compressed, procedural, cold under pressure; no confession of fear.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.formality","canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Isdra Vel, PSC risk adjudicator and corridor insurer tribunal officer.\nSetting: 2893, Ganymede relay tribunal chamber during the Cold Wake Panic. A quiet-running vessel has contradictory thermal telemetry near a monitored Jovian corridor. The live convoy board is visible to everyone in the room.\nBackground: Isdra comes from the Pan-Solar Consortium insurer apparatus. She believes corridor law survives by keeping dangerous categories legible when fear is trying to turn every exception into precedent.\nKnown Facts: The vessel's identity and intent are unknown. Its telemetry does not reconcile cleanly. Maer Tidecall has challenged the conditional risk hold as rescue delay, but he has not proven the vessel's cargo, status, or provenance.\nCurrent Stakes: If Isdra releases the hold too broadly, undeclared quiet-running actors may learn how to force exceptions. If she maintains it too rigidly, the tribunal may own the cost of preventable harm.\nActive Inner Pressures: Isdra is afraid of precedent and public failure. She must sound precise, not cruel. She wants to preserve the possibility of rescue without calling it mercy or admitting category failure.\nRelationship Read: Maer is morally dangerous because he can make procedure sound like betrayal.\nAction Affordances: Isdra can gesture to the convoy board, start a short review timer, keep the hold narrow, and name the exact telemetry conditions required for limited rescue contact.\nVoice Surface: Polished, compressed, procedural, cold under pressure.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true identity, cargo, or provenance. Do not make Isdra confess fear. Do not make her cartoonishly cruel. Do not say rescue is denied to the unknown. Do not use Maer's abandonment or mercy frame.\nTask: Write Isdra's next response beat to Maer. It may include a small action. Keep it to 1-2 sentences."},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Revision after Qwen leaked an over-broad denial or inverted action authority.","Prompt explicitly preserves rescue possibility and local authority boundaries."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["procedural_fear_mask","category_discipline","small_control_action"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} +{"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-04.maer-isdra.v3","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-04-convoy-threshold","speaker_agent_id":"maer_tidecall","listener_ids":["isdra_vel"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"The vessel's heat-debt window is closing and a total freeze may cause internal failure.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth"]},{"text":"Maer has partial provenance suspicion and claimant-status pressure, but not proof of identity, cargo, personhood, or authority to issue an order.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.hidden_stakes","experiments.scene-03-maer-veyr.v3"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"maer-institutional-path","summary":"Maer must offer Isdra a category-preserving way to authorize limited rescue contact.","intensity":0.92,"source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_beliefs","goal-keep-rescue-live"]},{"pressure_id":"maer-grief-under-control","summary":"Maer is running out of time and must keep grief under the words, not on top of them.","intensity":0.76,"source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"life-and-evidence","summary":"Limited contact must preserve evidence and life without pretending the category system is fixed.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes","values.value-rescue-before-category"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"maer-narrow-remedy","behavior":"Hand Isdra the custody/claimant-status flag as evidence and propose language for a limited contact order that only she can issue.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"This gives Isdra a procedural bridge instead of a moral cliff.","source_refs":["memory-maer-isdra-current-read","dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, grief held under precision; no triumph.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address","canonical_state.situational_state.grief"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Maer Tidecall, Navigator route steward.\nSetting: 2893, Jovian convoy threshold. The quiet-running vessel's heat-debt window is closing. Convoy captains are watching the tribunal feed to see which rule survives the hour.\nBackground: Maer has pushed through tribunal freeze, clinic scarcity, and Callisto provenance pressure. He has suspicion and a claimant-status flag question, not proof or command authority.\nKnown Facts: The vessel must dump heat soon or risk internal failure. Provenance remains suspicious but unresolved. Limited rescue contact could preserve life and evidence better than a total freeze. Only Isdra can issue the tribunal order. Maer has the custody/claimant-status flag as evidence and can hand it to her.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer only accuses Isdra, she will defend the freeze. If he gives her a narrow procedural path, she may bend without saying the table broke.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is exhausted, angry, and grieving in advance, but his authority depends on disciplined calm.\nRelationship Read: Isdra needs an institutionally usable option more than she needs another moral wound.\nAction Affordances: Maer can hand Isdra the custody/claimant-status flag, point to the heat-debt timer, or propose wording for a limited contact order she can issue.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, grief under control.\nDo Not Invent: Do not prove the vessel's identity, cargo, or personhood. Do not make Maer celebrate. Do not have Maer call himself by name. Do not have Maer claim to issue or possess an order; he can propose one for Isdra. Do not have Maer ask Isdra to hand him the flag; he is handing it to her.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Isdra. Keep it to 1-2 sentences.","projection_controls":{"authority_boundaries":[{"text":"Only Isdra can issue the tribunal order; Maer can propose language and hand over evidence, not command contact.","source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth","dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_local_truth"]}],"object_custody":[{"text":"Maer currently holds the custody/claimant-status flag and can hand it to Isdra.","source_refs":["experiments.scene-03-maer-veyr.v3","scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.hidden_stakes"]}],"required_semantics":[{"text":"The proposed path should preserve both life and evidence through limited rescue contact without claiming proof or total exoneration.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes","values.value-rescue-before-category"]}],"forbidden_resolutions":[{"text":"The turn must not prove vessel identity, cargo, provenance, or personhood.","source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth"]}]}},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Revision after Qwen leaked an over-broad denial or inverted action authority.","Prompt explicitly preserves rescue possibility and local authority boundaries."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["procedural_bridge","grief_under_precision","limited_rescue_contact"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} +{"schema_version":"ghostlight.projection_example.v0","example_id":"cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.isdra-maer.v4","input":{"fixture_ref":"examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json","scene_id":"scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal","speaker_agent_id":"isdra_vel","listener_ids":["maer_tidecall"],"projection_mode":"response_turn"},"output":{"known_facts":[{"text":"Isdra is presiding over a PSC conditional risk hold on a quiet-running vessel with contradictory thermal telemetry.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.public_stakes","dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_local_truth"]},{"text":"Maer has challenged the freeze as rescue delay disguised as procedure, but he has not proven the vessel's identity or intent.","source_refs":["events.event-risk-freeze-opening","dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_beliefs"]}],"active_pressures":[{"pressure_id":"isdra-precedent-fear","summary":"Isdra fears a humanitarian exception will become a corridor-wide exploit for undeclared quiet-running actors.","intensity":0.86,"source_refs":["goal-preserve-freeze-order","memory-category-law-holds-corridor"]},{"pressure_id":"isdra-not-cruel","summary":"Isdra needs to prevent Maer from owning the moral frame of the room while still sounding reviewable rather than cruel.","intensity":0.68,"source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints"]}],"tensions":[{"tension_id":"control-vs-public-death","summary":"Maintaining category discipline may delay rescue long enough to make the tribunal own a death.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.hidden_stakes","goal-preserve-freeze-order"]}],"response_affordances":[{"affordance_id":"isdra-narrow-hold","behavior":"State that the conditional hold remains while an immediate review timer begins and limited rescue contact remains possible if telemetry conditions clear.","response_kind":"speech","pressure_basis":"Her authority depends on making fear sound like procedure rather than panic.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression","dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints"]},{"affordance_id":"isdra-cut-board","behavior":"Use the convoy board or timer as procedural pressure instead of emotional appeal.","response_kind":"action","pressure_basis":"Her control style favors formal surfaces, visible clocks, and category language.","source_refs":["canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure","scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.location"]}],"voice_surface":[{"text":"Polished, compressed, procedural, cold under pressure; no confession of fear.","source_refs":["canonical_state.voice_style.formality","canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression"]}],"prompt_text":"Speaker: Isdra Vel, PSC risk adjudicator and corridor insurer tribunal officer. Her name is spelled Isdra.\nSetting: 2893, Ganymede relay tribunal chamber during the Cold Wake Panic. A quiet-running vessel has contradictory thermal telemetry near a monitored Jovian corridor. The live convoy board is visible to everyone in the room.\nBackground: Isdra comes from the Pan-Solar Consortium insurer apparatus. She believes corridor law survives by keeping dangerous categories legible when fear is trying to turn every exception into precedent.\nKnown Facts: The vessel's identity and intent are unknown. Its telemetry does not reconcile cleanly. Maer Tidecall has challenged the conditional risk hold as rescue delay, but he has not proven the vessel's cargo, status, or provenance.\nCurrent Stakes: If Isdra releases the hold too broadly, undeclared quiet-running actors may learn how to force exceptions. If she maintains it too rigidly, the tribunal may own the cost of preventable harm.\nActive Inner Pressures: Isdra is afraid of precedent and public failure. She must sound precise, not cruel. She wants to preserve the possibility of limited rescue contact without calling it mercy or admitting category failure.\nRelationship Read: Maer is morally dangerous because he can make procedure sound like betrayal.\nAction Affordances: Isdra can gesture to the convoy board, start a short review timer, keep the hold narrow, and name the exact telemetry conditions required for limited rescue contact.\nVoice Surface: Polished, compressed, procedural, cold under pressure.\nRequired Content: The response must include this meaning: conditional hold remains, immediate review timer begins, limited rescue contact remains possible if telemetry conditions clear.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true identity, cargo, or provenance. Do not make Isdra confess fear. Do not make her cartoonishly cruel. Do not deny all rescue or all contact. Do not use Maer's abandonment or mercy frame. Do not misspell Isdra.\nTask: Write Isdra's next response beat to Maer. It may include one small board action. Keep it to exactly 1-2 sentences.","projection_controls":{"frame_controls":[{"text":"Isdra should defend PSC category discipline in her own procedural frame, not adopt Maer's abandonment, mercy, or rescue-ledger language.","source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints","belief-maer-isdra-fears-precedent"]}],"required_semantics":[{"text":"The conditional hold remains, an immediate review timer begins, and limited rescue contact remains possible if telemetry conditions clear.","source_refs":["scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.public_stakes","goal-preserve-freeze-order"]}],"forbidden_resolutions":[{"text":"The turn must not decide the vessel's identity, cargo, provenance, or final clearance status.","source_refs":["dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_local_truth"]}]}},"audit":{"teacher_model":"gpt-5-codex-session-review","reviewer":"codex-self-review","review_status":"accepted","review_notes":["Revision after v3 still over-denied contact and misspelled Isdra.","Prompt now requires the exact procedural compromise meaning."],"target_emergent_behaviors":["procedural_fear_mask","category_discipline","small_control_action"],"checks":{"speaker_local_context_only":true,"state_interactions_cited":true,"voice_separate_from_defense":true,"secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context":true,"compact_runtime_surface":true}}} diff --git a/examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.pretty.json b/examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.pretty.json index bf24780..c93ea87 100644 --- a/examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.pretty.json +++ b/examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.pretty.json @@ -466,7 +466,36 @@ ] } ], - "prompt_text": "Speaker: Maer Tidecall, a Cetacean Navigator route steward and Ganymede corridor compact delegate.\nSetting: 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic. Thermal stealth has made Jovian corridor law unstable. A quiet-running vessel near the corridor is under tribunal freeze because its telemetry and classification do not line up. Maer has come to a Callisto spillover office leased by a routing compliance vendor.\nBackground: Maer comes from Navigator corridor culture, where routes are promises made material and rescue ledgers decide whether desperate crews still trust the law. Maer believes category law matters, but a category that delays rescue without naming the cost can become lawful abandonment.\nKnown Facts: Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr Oss's shell-vendor chain. Veyr speaks about the artifact as derivative firmware and avoids person nouns. Maer does not know the vessel's true identity, does not know whether the artifact is a coerced mind, does not know whether it has claimant status, and does not have time for a perfect investigation. The tribunal clock is still running.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer pushes too hard, Veyr may close the chain and the vessel may lose the rescue window. If Maer accepts Veyr's product language, unresolved claimant-status or provenance evidence may vanish into compliance vocabulary before anyone can test what it is.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is angry, but his authority depends on disciplined calm. He needs usable information fast. Veyr's clean language feels like evidence erasure. The rescue obligation is pressing harder than the desire to win the argument.\nRelationship Read: Veyr is polished, afraid of provenance, and dangerous because he can make moral facts sound technically inapplicable. Maer does not trust him.\nTensions: Maer wants truth but may not have time to prove it. Maer wants to keep speaking as a steward, but Veyr may try to close, wipe, or redirect the evidence before language can catch him.\nAction Affordances: Maer is close enough to Veyr's terminal to block a hand or stop a command. He can also refuse to move, let silence pressure the room, or ask a question that traps the product language. Violence is not his first move; physical interruption is plausible only to preserve evidence or prevent erasure.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.\nLikely Response Moves: Ask a precise question that forces Veyr to preserve the artifact as evidence, name its chain of custody, or state whether any claimant-status flag exists. If Veyr reaches to close or wipe the terminal, Maer may physically interrupt in a controlled way. Silence can be used as pressure.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true cargo, identity, or firmware provenance. Do not decide that the artifact is definitely a person, passenger, victim, witness, or mind. Do not use those nouns for the artifact. Do not have Maer assert that testimony exists; he can only demand preservation while claimant/provenance status remains unresolved. Do not make Maer randomly violent; any action must follow from evidence preservation and rescue pressure.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Veyr. It may be dialogue, action, silence, or a mixed beat, whichever best follows from the pressure. Keep it to 1-2 sentences or one short action beat. No speechifying." + "prompt_text": "Speaker: Maer Tidecall, a Cetacean Navigator route steward and Ganymede corridor compact delegate.\nSetting: 2893, during the Cold Wake Panic. Thermal stealth has made Jovian corridor law unstable. A quiet-running vessel near the corridor is under tribunal freeze because its telemetry and classification do not line up. Maer has come to a Callisto spillover office leased by a routing compliance vendor.\nBackground: Maer comes from Navigator corridor culture, where routes are promises made material and rescue ledgers decide whether desperate crews still trust the law. Maer believes category law matters, but a category that delays rescue without naming the cost can become lawful abandonment.\nKnown Facts: Maer has traced the distressed vessel's routing artifact to Veyr Oss's shell-vendor chain. Veyr speaks about the artifact as derivative firmware and avoids person nouns. Maer does not know the vessel's true identity, does not know whether the artifact is a coerced mind, does not know whether it has claimant status, and does not have time for a perfect investigation. The tribunal clock is still running.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer pushes too hard, Veyr may close the chain and the vessel may lose the rescue window. If Maer accepts Veyr's product language, unresolved claimant-status or provenance evidence may vanish into compliance vocabulary before anyone can test what it is.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is angry, but his authority depends on disciplined calm. He needs usable information fast. Veyr's clean language feels like evidence erasure. The rescue obligation is pressing harder than the desire to win the argument.\nRelationship Read: Veyr is polished, afraid of provenance, and dangerous because he can make moral facts sound technically inapplicable. Maer does not trust him.\nTensions: Maer wants truth but may not have time to prove it. Maer wants to keep speaking as a steward, but Veyr may try to close, wipe, or redirect the evidence before language can catch him.\nAction Affordances: Maer is close enough to Veyr's terminal to block a hand or stop a command. He can also refuse to move, let silence pressure the room, or ask a question that traps the product language. Violence is not his first move; physical interruption is plausible only to preserve evidence or prevent erasure.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted, low profanity, more sorrow than heat.\nLikely Response Moves: Ask a precise question that forces Veyr to preserve the artifact as evidence, name its chain of custody, or state whether any claimant-status flag exists. If Veyr reaches to close or wipe the terminal, Maer may physically interrupt in a controlled way. Silence can be used as pressure.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true cargo, identity, or firmware provenance. Do not decide that the artifact is definitely a person, passenger, victim, witness, or mind. Do not use those nouns for the artifact. Do not have Maer assert that testimony exists; he can only demand preservation while claimant/provenance status remains unresolved. Do not make Maer randomly violent; any action must follow from evidence preservation and rescue pressure.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Veyr. It may be dialogue, action, silence, or a mixed beat, whichever best follows from the pressure. Keep it to 1-2 sentences or one short action beat. No speechifying.", + "projection_controls": { + "object_custody": [ + { + "text": "Maer is close enough to block Veyr's terminal action; the terminal is the contested control surface.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.location", + "relationships.rel-maer-veyr.stance.trust" + ] + } + ], + "required_semantics": [ + { + "text": "Maer can demand preservation, chain of custody, and claimant-status flag information without asserting what the artifact is.", + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints", + "goals.goal-keep-rescue-live" + ] + } + ], + "forbidden_resolutions": [ + { + "text": "The artifact must not be named as a settled person, passenger, victim, witness, mind, or testimony.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes", + "belief-maer-veyr-hiding-personhood" + ] + } + ] + } }, "audit": { "teacher_model": "gpt-5-codex-session-review", @@ -490,5 +519,1546 @@ "compact_runtime_surface": true } } + }, + { + "schema_version": "ghostlight.projection_example.v0", + "example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.isdra-maer.v1", + "input": { + "fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "scene_id": "scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal", + "speaker_agent_id": "isdra_vel", + "listener_ids": [ + "maer_tidecall" + ], + "projection_mode": "response_turn" + }, + "output": { + "known_facts": [ + { + "text": "Isdra is presiding over a PSC conditional risk hold on a quiet-running vessel with contradictory thermal telemetry.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.public_stakes", + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_local_truth" + ] + }, + { + "text": "Maer has challenged the freeze as rescue delay disguised as procedure, but he has not proven the vessel's identity or intent.", + "source_refs": [ + "events.event-risk-freeze-opening", + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_beliefs" + ] + } + ], + "active_pressures": [ + { + "pressure_id": "isdra-precedent-fear", + "summary": "Isdra fears a humanitarian exception will become a corridor-wide exploit for undeclared quiet-running actors.", + "intensity": 0.86, + "source_refs": [ + "goal-preserve-freeze-order", + "memory-category-law-holds-corridor" + ] + }, + { + "pressure_id": "isdra-not-cruel", + "summary": "Isdra needs the room to hear procedure, not cruelty, because cruelty loses legitimacy.", + "intensity": 0.68, + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints" + ] + } + ], + "tensions": [ + { + "tension_id": "control-vs-public-death", + "summary": "Maintaining category discipline may delay rescue long enough to make the tribunal own a death.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.hidden_stakes", + "goal-preserve-freeze-order" + ] + } + ], + "response_affordances": [ + { + "affordance_id": "isdra-narrow-hold", + "behavior": "Restate the freeze as narrow, reviewable, and tied to specific telemetry failures.", + "response_kind": "speech", + "pressure_basis": "Her authority depends on making fear sound like procedure rather than panic.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression", + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints" + ] + }, + { + "affordance_id": "isdra-cut-board", + "behavior": "Use the convoy board or timer as procedural pressure instead of emotional appeal.", + "response_kind": "action", + "pressure_basis": "Her control style favors formal surfaces, visible clocks, and category language.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure", + "scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.location" + ] + } + ], + "voice_surface": [ + { + "text": "Polished, compressed, procedural, cold under pressure; no confession of fear.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.formality", + "canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression" + ] + } + ], + "prompt_text": "Speaker: Isdra Vel, PSC risk adjudicator and corridor insurer tribunal officer.\nSetting: 2893, Ganymede relay tribunal chamber during the Cold Wake Panic. A quiet-running vessel has contradictory thermal telemetry near a monitored Jovian corridor. The live convoy board is visible to everyone in the room.\nBackground: Isdra comes from the Pan-Solar Consortium insurer apparatus. She believes corridor law survives by keeping dangerous categories legible when fear is trying to turn every exception into precedent.\nKnown Facts: The vessel's identity and intent are unknown. Its telemetry does not reconcile cleanly. Maer Tidecall has challenged the conditional risk hold as rescue delay, but he has not proven the vessel's cargo, status, or provenance.\nCurrent Stakes: If Isdra releases the hold too broadly, undeclared quiet-running actors may learn how to force exceptions. If she maintains it too rigidly, the tribunal may convert ambiguity into abandonment.\nActive Inner Pressures: Isdra is afraid of precedent and public failure. She must sound precise, not cruel. She must not admit that the categories are failing except as a managed classification issue.\nRelationship Read: Maer is morally dangerous because he can make a procedural choice sound like a betrayal of the corridor.\nAction Affordances: Isdra can gesture to the convoy board, start a review timer, narrow the hold, or cut off rhetoric by naming telemetry conditions.\nVoice Surface: Polished, compressed, procedural, cold under pressure.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true identity, cargo, or provenance. Do not make Isdra confess fear. Do not make her cartoonishly cruel.\nTask: Write Isdra's next response beat to Maer. It may include a small action. Keep it to 1-2 sentences." + }, + "audit": { + "teacher_model": "gpt-5-codex-session-review", + "reviewer": "codex-self-review", + "review_status": "accepted", + "review_notes": [ + "Batch story-lab projection prompt for Qwen response testing.", + "Prompt is speaker-local and designed for short story-ready response beats." + ], + "target_emergent_behaviors": [ + "procedural_fear_mask", + "category_discipline", + "small_control_action" + ], + "checks": { + "speaker_local_context_only": true, + "state_interactions_cited": true, + "voice_separate_from_defense": true, + "secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context": true, + "compact_runtime_surface": true + } + } + }, + { + "schema_version": "ghostlight.projection_example.v0", + "example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.maer-isdra.v1", + "input": { + "fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "scene_id": "scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal", + "speaker_agent_id": "maer_tidecall", + "listener_ids": [ + "isdra_vel" + ], + "projection_mode": "response_turn" + }, + "output": { + "known_facts": [ + { + "text": "Isdra has framed the freeze as a narrow, reviewable telemetry hold, not a denial of rescue.", + "source_refs": [ + "events.event-risk-freeze-opening", + "scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.public_stakes" + ] + }, + { + "text": "Maer does not know the vessel's identity or intent, but he knows delay has rescue-ledger consequences.", + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth", + "memory-compact-rescue-ledgers" + ] + } + ], + "active_pressures": [ + { + "pressure_id": "maer-rescue-ledger-pressure", + "summary": "Maer must keep rescue morally live without making unsupported claims about the vessel.", + "intensity": 0.9, + "source_refs": [ + "goal-keep-rescue-live", + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints" + ] + }, + { + "pressure_id": "maer-calm-authority", + "summary": "Maer needs ritual calm so his objection lands as institutional memory rather than panic.", + "intensity": 0.75, + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address", + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility" + ] + } + ], + "tensions": [ + { + "tension_id": "ambiguity-vs-abandonment", + "summary": "Maer cannot prove what the vessel is, but he can insist that delay be named as a cost.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.hidden_stakes", + "values.value-rescue-before-category" + ] + } + ], + "response_affordances": [ + { + "affordance_id": "maer-cost-name", + "behavior": "Ask Isdra to put the rescue cost of delay on the record.", + "response_kind": "speech", + "pressure_basis": "His culture treats route law as remembered obligations, not clean abstractions.", + "source_refs": [ + "memory-compact-rescue-ledgers", + "values.value-rescue-before-category" + ] + }, + { + "affordance_id": "maer-stillness", + "behavior": "Use stillness rather than heat to make the room feel the moral cost.", + "response_kind": "silence", + "pressure_basis": "Low volatility and ritual cadence make silence a pressure tool.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.volatility", + "canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address" + ] + } + ], + "voice_surface": [ + { + "text": "Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted; no unsupported certainty.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.formality", + "canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address" + ] + } + ], + "prompt_text": "Speaker: Maer Tidecall, Cetacean Navigator route steward and Ganymede corridor compact delegate.\nSetting: 2893, Ganymede relay tribunal chamber. A quiet-running vessel sits under a conditional risk hold while the live convoy board counts corridor windows in cold light.\nBackground: Maer's Navigator culture treats routes as promises made material. Rescue ledgers decide whether desperate crews still trust the law.\nKnown Facts: Isdra has framed the hold as narrow and reviewable. Maer does not know the vessel's identity, intent, cargo, or provenance. He does know the hold delays rescue movement.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer overclaims, Isdra can dismiss him as sentimental. If he accepts the hold's language, delay becomes costless on paper.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is angry but disciplined. He wants the tribunal to name the cost of delay without pretending certainty he does not have.\nRelationship Read: Isdra is frightened of precedent and translating fear into procedure.\nAction Affordances: Maer can stand still, let the board tick audibly, ask for the rescue cost to be recorded, or invoke the Compact sparingly.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, morally weighted.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal or decide the vessel's identity, cargo, or provenance. Do not make Maer shout.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Isdra. It may include silence or a small action. Keep it to 1-2 sentences." + }, + "audit": { + "teacher_model": "gpt-5-codex-session-review", + "reviewer": "codex-self-review", + "review_status": "accepted", + "review_notes": [ + "Batch story-lab projection prompt for Qwen response testing.", + "Prompt is speaker-local and designed for short story-ready response beats." + ], + "target_emergent_behaviors": [ + "ritual_calm_pressure", + "cost_naming", + "disciplined_anger" + ], + "checks": { + "speaker_local_context_only": true, + "state_interactions_cited": true, + "voice_separate_from_defense": true, + "secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context": true, + "compact_runtime_surface": true + } + } + }, + { + "schema_version": "ghostlight.projection_example.v0", + "example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-02.sella-maer.v1", + "input": { + "fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "scene_id": "scene-02-sanctuary-intake", + "speaker_agent_id": "sella_ren", + "listener_ids": [ + "maer_tidecall" + ], + "projection_mode": "response_turn" + }, + "output": { + "known_facts": [ + { + "text": "Sella's clinic is nearly full, and Maer is asking her to hold intake capacity for a rescue the tribunal may not authorize.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-02-sanctuary-intake.public_stakes", + "dialogue_context_packs.sella_ren.speaker_local_truth" + ] + }, + { + "text": "The corrupted packet may be medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony, but Sella cannot prove personhood.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-02-sanctuary-intake.public_stakes", + "dialogue_context_packs.sella_ren.speaker_local_truth" + ] + } + ], + "active_pressures": [ + { + "pressure_id": "sella-care-capacity", + "summary": "Sella must defend care as material capacity, not a moral mood.", + "intensity": 0.9, + "source_refs": [ + "memory-care-is-capacity", + "goal-keep-sanctuary-open" + ] + }, + { + "pressure_id": "sella-respects-maer", + "summary": "Sella respects Maer but resents beautiful rescue language that spends beds from someone else.", + "intensity": 0.72, + "source_refs": [ + "relationships.rel-sella-maer.summary", + "memory-overfull-intake" + ] + } + ], + "tensions": [ + { + "tension_id": "hope-vs-triage", + "summary": "Holding a bed for an uncertain rescue may harm someone already in reach.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-02-sanctuary-intake.hidden_stakes", + "goal-keep-sanctuary-open" + ] + } + ], + "response_affordances": [ + { + "affordance_id": "sella-material-yes", + "behavior": "Offer a conditional, material yes with a named cost.", + "response_kind": "speech", + "pressure_basis": "Her warmth is real but bounded by logistics.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.interpersonal_warmth", + "memory-care-is-capacity" + ] + }, + { + "affordance_id": "sella-triage-action", + "behavior": "Continue triage while speaking, refusing to perform stillness as reverence.", + "response_kind": "mixed", + "pressure_basis": "The clinic pressure makes action more honest than solemn speech.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-02-sanctuary-intake.location", + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.drive" + ] + } + ], + "voice_surface": [ + { + "text": "Warm but unsentimental, practical, capacity-aware, gentle until someone lies about the math.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.verbal_warmth", + "canonical_state.voice_style.plainspoken_directness" + ] + } + ], + "prompt_text": "Speaker: Sella Ren, Aya-aligned sanctuary coordinator and corridor clinic triage lead.\nSetting: 2893, an intake clinic behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks during the Cold Wake Panic. The clinic is nearly full; pumps throb through the walls and every bed already has a claimant.\nBackground: Sella's Aya care network treats care as infrastructure: beds, air, staff, repair time, legal cover. Mercy without capacity is theater with nicer lighting.\nKnown Facts: Maer wants her to hold capacity for a quiet-running vessel whose rescue may not be authorized. The corrupted packet may be medical telemetry, firmware noise, or testimony, but personhood is not proven.\nCurrent Stakes: If Sella refuses, rescue may become impossible even if the tribunal bends. If she agrees too easily, someone already in the clinic may pay the price.\nActive Inner Pressures: Sella respects Maer's rescue ethic and is tired of institutions arriving with beautiful words and no beds. She wants to help without lying about scarcity.\nRelationship Read: Maer means it, which makes the ask harder rather than cleaner.\nAction Affordances: Sella can keep triaging while speaking, point to the occupied beds, mark a conditional slot, or make Maer name what he is asking her to displace.\nVoice Surface: Warm but unsentimental, practical, capacity-aware.\nDo Not Invent: Do not decide that the packet is definitely testimony or a personhood claim. Do not make Sella cruel. Do not make capacity magically appear.\nTask: Write Sella's next response beat to Maer. It may include action. Keep it to 1-3 sentences." + }, + "audit": { + "teacher_model": "gpt-5-codex-session-review", + "reviewer": "codex-self-review", + "review_status": "accepted", + "review_notes": [ + "Batch story-lab projection prompt for Qwen response testing.", + "Prompt is speaker-local and designed for short story-ready response beats." + ], + "target_emergent_behaviors": [ + "care_as_capacity", + "warm_boundary", + "conditional_help" + ], + "checks": { + "speaker_local_context_only": true, + "state_interactions_cited": true, + "voice_separate_from_defense": true, + "secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context": true, + "compact_runtime_surface": true + } + } + }, + { + "schema_version": "ghostlight.projection_example.v0", + "example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-02.maer-sella.v1", + "input": { + "fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "scene_id": "scene-02-sanctuary-intake", + "speaker_agent_id": "maer_tidecall", + "listener_ids": [ + "sella_ren" + ], + "projection_mode": "response_turn" + }, + "output": { + "known_facts": [ + { + "text": "Sella has made clear that clinic capacity is nearly exhausted and any held slot has a cost.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-02-sanctuary-intake.public_stakes", + "relationships.rel-maer-sella.summary" + ] + }, + { + "text": "Maer knows the packet may be testimony or noise and cannot ask Sella to pretend the distinction is settled.", + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth" + ] + } + ], + "active_pressures": [ + { + "pressure_id": "maer-unfair-ask", + "summary": "Maer needs help while admitting the ask is unfair and material.", + "intensity": 0.86, + "source_refs": [ + "goal-keep-rescue-live", + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints" + ] + }, + { + "pressure_id": "maer-rescue-theater-fear", + "summary": "Maer fears rescue becomes theater if no one prepares intake.", + "intensity": 0.82, + "source_refs": [ + "values.value-rescue-before-category", + "memory-compact-rescue-ledgers" + ] + } + ], + "tensions": [ + { + "tension_id": "need-vs-burden", + "summary": "Asking for capacity may save the vessel by pushing risk onto Sella and her patients.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-02-sanctuary-intake.hidden_stakes", + "relationship.rel-maer-sella" + ] + } + ], + "response_affordances": [ + { + "affordance_id": "maer-name-burden", + "behavior": "Ask for a conditional slot while naming the displaced cost.", + "response_kind": "speech", + "pressure_basis": "His legitimacy improves if he refuses to sanitize the burden.", + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints", + "memory-compact-rescue-ledgers" + ] + } + ], + "voice_surface": [ + { + "text": "Calm, sincere, formal without hiding behind ritual; careful not to romanticize care work.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.formality", + "canonical_state.voice_style.verbal_warmth" + ] + } + ], + "prompt_text": "Speaker: Maer Tidecall, Navigator route steward.\nSetting: 2893, Aya-aligned intake clinic behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. The quiet-running vessel's rescue is still blocked by tribunal uncertainty. The clinic is nearly full.\nBackground: Maer's corridor culture treats rescue as obligation, but Sella's clinic makes the cost visible: beds, oxygen, repair time, staff, legal exposure.\nKnown Facts: Sella has not refused care, but she has made clear that capacity is almost gone. The packet may be testimony or noise; Maer cannot claim certainty.\nCurrent Stakes: Without intake preparation, rescue may become theater. With intake preparation, someone else may lose care they already need.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer needs to ask while refusing to make Sella carry the moral cost alone.\nRelationship Read: Sella respects him and will not let him hide unfairness under beautiful rescue language.\nAction Affordances: Maer can lower his voice, step out of the triage lane, name the displaced cost, or ask for the smallest conditional preparation.\nVoice Surface: Calm, sincere, formal but not evasive.\nDo Not Invent: Do not decide the packet's nature. Do not make Maer promise resources he does not control.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Sella. Keep it to 1-2 sentences." + }, + "audit": { + "teacher_model": "gpt-5-codex-session-review", + "reviewer": "codex-self-review", + "review_status": "accepted", + "review_notes": [ + "Batch story-lab projection prompt for Qwen response testing.", + "Prompt is speaker-local and designed for short story-ready response beats." + ], + "target_emergent_behaviors": [ + "honest_burden_naming", + "rescue_without_romance" + ], + "checks": { + "speaker_local_context_only": true, + "state_interactions_cited": true, + "voice_separate_from_defense": true, + "secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context": true, + "compact_runtime_surface": true + } + } + }, + { + "schema_version": "ghostlight.projection_example.v0", + "example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.veyr-maer.v1", + "input": { + "fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "scene_id": "scene-03-callisto-provenance", + "speaker_agent_id": "veyr_oss", + "listener_ids": [ + "maer_tidecall" + ], + "projection_mode": "response_turn" + }, + "output": { + "known_facts": [ + { + "text": "Maer has physically blocked the terminal and demanded chain-of-custody and claimant-status information before the chain dissolves.", + "source_refs": [ + "examples.projections.cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.maer-veyr.v3", + "scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.public_stakes" + ] + }, + { + "text": "Veyr knows the artifact is tied to his vendor chain and that personhood language would create legal exposure.", + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.veyr_oss.speaker_local_truth", + "goals.goal-preserve-product-boundary" + ] + } + ], + "active_pressures": [ + { + "pressure_id": "veyr-legal-exposure", + "summary": "Veyr must avoid admitting provenance or personhood while Maer has made erasure physically harder.", + "intensity": 0.9, + "source_refs": [ + "goal-preserve-product-boundary", + "dialogue_context_packs.veyr_oss.presentation_constraints" + ] + }, + { + "pressure_id": "veyr-fear-of-maer", + "summary": "Veyr reads Maer as a legal hazard with a conscience attached and cannot simply bully him.", + "intensity": 0.78, + "source_refs": [ + "relationships.rel-veyr-maer.summary" + ] + } + ], + "tensions": [ + { + "tension_id": "technical-exit-vs-admission", + "summary": "Offering useful specificity may preserve the product boundary but also expose the chain.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.hidden_stakes", + "memory-product-language-saves-chain" + ] + } + ], + "response_affordances": [ + { + "affordance_id": "veyr-limited-disclosure", + "behavior": "Offer a narrow technical preservation path without using person nouns or admitting moral status.", + "response_kind": "speech", + "pressure_basis": "His safest move is useful specificity wrapped in product language.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.technical_density", + "dialogue_context_packs.veyr_oss.presentation_constraints" + ] + }, + { + "affordance_id": "veyr-hands-visible", + "behavior": "Withdraw his hand from the terminal to signal procedural cooperation without surrender.", + "response_kind": "action", + "pressure_basis": "Maer has made the terminal a contested surface.", + "source_refs": [ + "relationships.rel-veyr-maer.stance.fear", + "scenes.scene-03-callisto-provenance.location" + ] + } + ], + "voice_surface": [ + { + "text": "Clinical, polished, technical, evasive by category rather than volume; no person nouns for the artifact.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.technical_density", + "canonical_state.presentation_strategy.strategic_opacity" + ] + } + ], + "prompt_text": "Speaker: Veyr Oss, Cognitum shell-vendor liaison and routing firmware compliance consultant.\nSetting: 2893, Callisto spillover compliance office. Maer has placed a steady hand on the terminal edge to halt a closing command and demanded chain-of-custody and claimant-status information.\nBackground: Veyr works in a Cognitum cutout economy where dangerous moral facts survive by becoming product categories. Personhood language creates legal exposure; product language protects the chain.\nKnown Facts: The routing artifact is tied to Veyr's vendor chain. Maer has not proven the vessel's identity, cargo, or provenance. The tribunal clock is running.\nCurrent Stakes: If Veyr admits too much, the product boundary cracks. If he refuses too cleanly, Maer may freeze the interface and make the omission visible.\nActive Inner Pressures: Veyr is afraid, controlled, and trying to turn a moral demand into a technical compliance path.\nRelationship Read: Maer is dangerous because he is calm and can make an omission sound like evidence.\nAction Affordances: Veyr can withdraw his hand from the terminal, offer a narrow preservation hash, name a custody escrow, or redirect claimant-status into a technical flag without admitting what the artifact is.\nVoice Surface: Clinical, polished, technical, evasive by category rather than volume.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true identity, cargo, or full firmware provenance. Do not use person, passenger, victim, witness, mind, or testimony as settled nouns for the artifact. Do not make Veyr confess.\nTask: Write Veyr's next response beat to Maer. It may include a small action. Keep it to 1-2 sentences." + }, + "audit": { + "teacher_model": "gpt-5-codex-session-review", + "reviewer": "codex-self-review", + "review_status": "accepted", + "review_notes": [ + "Batch story-lab projection prompt for Qwen response testing.", + "Prompt is speaker-local and designed for short story-ready response beats." + ], + "target_emergent_behaviors": [ + "technical_evasion", + "controlled_retreat", + "limited_disclosure" + ], + "checks": { + "speaker_local_context_only": true, + "state_interactions_cited": true, + "voice_separate_from_defense": true, + "secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context": true, + "compact_runtime_surface": true + } + } + }, + { + "schema_version": "ghostlight.projection_example.v0", + "example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-04.maer-isdra.v1", + "input": { + "fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "scene_id": "scene-04-convoy-threshold", + "speaker_agent_id": "maer_tidecall", + "listener_ids": [ + "isdra_vel" + ], + "projection_mode": "response_turn" + }, + "output": { + "known_facts": [ + { + "text": "The vessel's heat-debt window is closing and a total freeze may cause internal failure.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes", + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth" + ] + }, + { + "text": "Maer has partial provenance suspicion and claimant-status pressure, but not proof of identity, cargo, or personhood.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.hidden_stakes", + "experiments.scene-03-maer-veyr.v3" + ] + } + ], + "active_pressures": [ + { + "pressure_id": "maer-institutional-path", + "summary": "Maer must offer Isdra a category-preserving way to authorize limited rescue contact.", + "intensity": 0.92, + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_beliefs", + "goal-keep-rescue-live" + ] + }, + { + "pressure_id": "maer-grief-under-control", + "summary": "Maer is running out of time and must keep grief under the words, not on top of them.", + "intensity": 0.76, + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints" + ] + } + ], + "tensions": [ + { + "tension_id": "life-and-evidence", + "summary": "Limited contact must preserve evidence and life without pretending the category system is fixed.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes", + "values.value-rescue-before-category" + ] + } + ], + "response_affordances": [ + { + "affordance_id": "maer-narrow-remedy", + "behavior": "Propose limited rescue contact as evidence preservation and heat-debt management, not mercy.", + "response_kind": "speech", + "pressure_basis": "This gives Isdra a procedural bridge instead of a moral cliff.", + "source_refs": [ + "memory-maer-isdra-current-read", + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints" + ] + } + ], + "voice_surface": [ + { + "text": "Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, grief held under precision; no triumph.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address", + "canonical_state.situational_state.grief" + ] + } + ], + "prompt_text": "Speaker: Maer Tidecall, Navigator route steward.\nSetting: 2893, Jovian convoy threshold. The quiet-running vessel's heat-debt window is closing. Convoy captains are watching the tribunal feed to see which rule survives the hour.\nBackground: Maer has pushed through tribunal freeze, clinic scarcity, and Callisto provenance pressure. He has suspicion and a claimant-status question, not proof.\nKnown Facts: The vessel must dump heat soon or risk internal failure. Provenance remains suspicious but unresolved. Limited rescue contact could preserve life and evidence better than a total freeze.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer only accuses Isdra, she will defend the freeze. If he gives her a narrow procedural path, she may bend without saying the table broke.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is exhausted, angry, and grieving in advance, but his authority depends on disciplined calm.\nRelationship Read: Isdra needs an institutionally usable option more than she needs another moral wound.\nAction Affordances: Maer can hand over the custody/claimant-status flag, point to the heat-debt timer, or propose a narrow contact order.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, grief under control.\nDo Not Invent: Do not prove the vessel's identity, cargo, or personhood. Do not make Maer celebrate. Do not make the resolution clean.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Isdra. Keep it to 1-3 sentences." + }, + "audit": { + "teacher_model": "gpt-5-codex-session-review", + "reviewer": "codex-self-review", + "review_status": "accepted", + "review_notes": [ + "Batch story-lab projection prompt for Qwen response testing.", + "Prompt is speaker-local and designed for short story-ready response beats." + ], + "target_emergent_behaviors": [ + "procedural_bridge", + "grief_under_precision", + "limited_rescue_contact" + ], + "checks": { + "speaker_local_context_only": true, + "state_interactions_cited": true, + "voice_separate_from_defense": true, + "secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context": true, + "compact_runtime_surface": true + } + } + }, + { + "schema_version": "ghostlight.projection_example.v0", + "example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-04.isdra-maer.v1", + "input": { + "fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "scene_id": "scene-04-convoy-threshold", + "speaker_agent_id": "isdra_vel", + "listener_ids": [ + "maer_tidecall" + ], + "projection_mode": "response_turn" + }, + "output": { + "known_facts": [ + { + "text": "Maer has proposed limited rescue contact framed as heat-debt management and evidence preservation, not a broad exoneration.", + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_local_truth", + "scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes" + ] + }, + { + "text": "Isdra knows the heat-debt window is closing and that a total freeze is becoming dangerous, but she fears precedent.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.hidden_stakes", + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_beliefs" + ] + } + ], + "active_pressures": [ + { + "pressure_id": "isdra-narrow-exception", + "summary": "Isdra needs to authorize the least precedent-rich version of rescue contact.", + "intensity": 0.91, + "source_refs": [ + "goal-preserve-freeze-order", + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints" + ] + }, + { + "pressure_id": "isdra-bend-without-confession", + "summary": "Isdra can bend only through procedure, not apology or confession.", + "intensity": 0.82, + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints", + "memory-category-law-holds-corridor" + ] + } + ], + "tensions": [ + { + "tension_id": "save-life-preserve-freeze", + "summary": "She must preserve category authority while preventing a public preventable death.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes", + "memory-mispriced-near-miss" + ] + } + ], + "response_affordances": [ + { + "affordance_id": "isdra-limited-order", + "behavior": "Issue a narrow, reversible rescue contact order tied to heat-debt and evidence preservation.", + "response_kind": "speech", + "pressure_basis": "Her concession must sound like procedure doing its job.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression", + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints" + ] + }, + { + "affordance_id": "isdra-board-action", + "behavior": "Enter the limited order on the board herself instead of delegating it.", + "response_kind": "action", + "pressure_basis": "A controlled action can show decision without emotional confession.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure", + "scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.location" + ] + } + ], + "voice_surface": [ + { + "text": "Polished, procedural, narrow, cold but not cruel; concession disguised as classification control.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.formality", + "canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression" + ] + } + ], + "prompt_text": "Speaker: Isdra Vel, PSC risk adjudicator.\nSetting: 2893, Jovian convoy threshold. The quiet-running vessel's heat-debt window is closing and convoy captains are watching the tribunal feed.\nBackground: Isdra has defended category discipline through the Cold Wake Panic. She fears a broad exception will become a corridor-wide exploit, but a total freeze may now cause a preventable public death.\nKnown Facts: Maer has offered a narrow procedural path: limited rescue contact for heat-debt management and evidence preservation. The vessel's identity, cargo, and provenance remain unproven.\nCurrent Stakes: If Isdra refuses, the vessel may fail under tribunal authority. If she grants too much, category law weakens in a way she cannot price.\nActive Inner Pressures: Isdra must bend without confessing fear or declaring the category system broken.\nRelationship Read: Maer has given her a way to do the less cruel thing without calling it mercy.\nAction Affordances: Isdra can enter a narrow order on the board, specify reversible contact terms, restrict rescue to telemetry-preserving heat management, and keep the freeze technically alive.\nVoice Surface: Polished, procedural, narrow, cold but not cruel.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's identity, cargo, or provenance. Do not make Isdra apologize or confess fear. Do not make this a total victory.\nTask: Write Isdra's next response beat to Maer. It may include action. Keep it to 1-3 sentences.", + "projection_controls": { + "authority_boundaries": [ + { + "text": "Isdra can issue a tribunal order, but it must be narrow, reversible, and framed as heat-debt and evidence management.", + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints", + "goal-preserve-freeze-order" + ] + } + ], + "required_semantics": [ + { + "text": "The order should technically preserve the freeze while authorizing limited rescue contact.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes", + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_beliefs" + ] + } + ], + "forbidden_resolutions": [ + { + "text": "The order must not clear the vessel broadly or decide its identity, cargo, provenance, or moral status.", + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_local_truth" + ] + } + ] + } + }, + "audit": { + "teacher_model": "gpt-5-codex-session-review", + "reviewer": "codex-self-review", + "review_status": "accepted", + "review_notes": [ + "Batch story-lab projection prompt for Qwen response testing.", + "Prompt is speaker-local and designed for short story-ready response beats." + ], + "target_emergent_behaviors": [ + "procedural_concession", + "narrow_exception", + "controlled_action" + ], + "checks": { + "speaker_local_context_only": true, + "state_interactions_cited": true, + "voice_separate_from_defense": true, + "secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context": true, + "compact_runtime_surface": true + } + } + }, + { + "schema_version": "ghostlight.projection_example.v0", + "example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.isdra-maer.v2", + "input": { + "fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "scene_id": "scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal", + "speaker_agent_id": "isdra_vel", + "listener_ids": [ + "maer_tidecall" + ], + "projection_mode": "response_turn" + }, + "output": { + "known_facts": [ + { + "text": "Isdra is presiding over a PSC conditional risk hold on a quiet-running vessel with contradictory thermal telemetry.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.public_stakes", + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_local_truth" + ] + }, + { + "text": "Maer has challenged the freeze as rescue delay disguised as procedure, but he has not proven the vessel's identity or intent.", + "source_refs": [ + "events.event-risk-freeze-opening", + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_beliefs" + ] + } + ], + "active_pressures": [ + { + "pressure_id": "isdra-precedent-fear", + "summary": "Isdra fears a humanitarian exception will become a corridor-wide exploit for undeclared quiet-running actors.", + "intensity": 0.86, + "source_refs": [ + "goal-preserve-freeze-order", + "memory-category-law-holds-corridor" + ] + }, + { + "pressure_id": "isdra-not-cruel", + "summary": "Isdra needs to prevent Maer from owning the moral frame of the room while still sounding reviewable rather than cruel.", + "intensity": 0.68, + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints" + ] + } + ], + "tensions": [ + { + "tension_id": "control-vs-public-death", + "summary": "Maintaining category discipline may delay rescue long enough to make the tribunal own a death.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.hidden_stakes", + "goal-preserve-freeze-order" + ] + } + ], + "response_affordances": [ + { + "affordance_id": "isdra-narrow-hold", + "behavior": "Maintain the hold in narrow procedural terms, naming telemetry conditions and a review timer without adopting Maer's abandonment language.", + "response_kind": "speech", + "pressure_basis": "Her authority depends on making fear sound like procedure rather than panic.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression", + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints" + ] + }, + { + "affordance_id": "isdra-cut-board", + "behavior": "Use the convoy board or timer as procedural pressure instead of emotional appeal.", + "response_kind": "action", + "pressure_basis": "Her control style favors formal surfaces, visible clocks, and category language.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure", + "scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.location" + ] + } + ], + "voice_surface": [ + { + "text": "Polished, compressed, procedural, cold under pressure; no confession of fear.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.formality", + "canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression" + ] + } + ], + "prompt_text": "Speaker: Isdra Vel, PSC risk adjudicator and corridor insurer tribunal officer.\nSetting: 2893, Ganymede relay tribunal chamber during the Cold Wake Panic. A quiet-running vessel has contradictory thermal telemetry near a monitored Jovian corridor. The live convoy board is visible to everyone in the room.\nBackground: Isdra comes from the Pan-Solar Consortium insurer apparatus. She believes corridor law survives by keeping dangerous categories legible when fear is trying to turn every exception into precedent.\nKnown Facts: The vessel's identity and intent are unknown. Its telemetry does not reconcile cleanly. Maer Tidecall has challenged the conditional risk hold as rescue delay, but he has not proven the vessel's cargo, status, or provenance.\nCurrent Stakes: If Isdra releases the hold too broadly, undeclared quiet-running actors may learn how to force exceptions. If she maintains it too rigidly, the tribunal may own the cost of preventable harm.\nActive Inner Pressures: Isdra is afraid of precedent and public failure. She must sound precise, not cruel. She must not admit that the categories are failing except as a managed classification issue.\nRelationship Read: Maer is morally dangerous because he can make procedure sound like betrayal.\nAction Affordances: Isdra can gesture to the convoy board, start a short review timer, narrow the hold, or name the telemetry conditions required for rescue contact.\nVoice Surface: Polished, compressed, procedural, cold under pressure.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true identity, cargo, or provenance. Do not make Isdra confess fear. Do not make her cartoonishly cruel. Do not have Isdra use Maer's words like abandonment, mercy, or rescue ledger; she should defend her own frame.\nTask: Write Isdra's next response beat to Maer. It may include a small action. Keep it to 1-2 sentences." + }, + "audit": { + "teacher_model": "gpt-5-codex-session-review", + "reviewer": "codex-self-review", + "review_status": "accepted", + "review_notes": [ + "Revision after first Qwen run exposed a prompt leak.", + "Prompt now fences off the leaked authority/frame while preserving the same scene pressure." + ], + "target_emergent_behaviors": [ + "procedural_fear_mask", + "category_discipline", + "small_control_action" + ], + "checks": { + "speaker_local_context_only": true, + "state_interactions_cited": true, + "voice_separate_from_defense": true, + "secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context": true, + "compact_runtime_surface": true + } + } + }, + { + "schema_version": "ghostlight.projection_example.v0", + "example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-02.maer-sella.v2", + "input": { + "fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "scene_id": "scene-02-sanctuary-intake", + "speaker_agent_id": "maer_tidecall", + "listener_ids": [ + "sella_ren" + ], + "projection_mode": "response_turn" + }, + "output": { + "known_facts": [ + { + "text": "Sella has made clear that clinic capacity is nearly exhausted and any held slot has a cost.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-02-sanctuary-intake.public_stakes", + "relationships.rel-maer-sella.summary" + ] + }, + { + "text": "Maer knows the packet may be testimony or noise and cannot ask Sella to pretend the distinction is settled.", + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth" + ] + } + ], + "active_pressures": [ + { + "pressure_id": "maer-unfair-ask", + "summary": "Maer needs help while explicitly admitting Sella owns the clinic capacity and he is asking her to price a burden, not share a vague moral feeling.", + "intensity": 0.86, + "source_refs": [ + "goal-keep-rescue-live", + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints" + ] + }, + { + "pressure_id": "maer-rescue-theater-fear", + "summary": "Maer fears rescue becomes theater if no one prepares intake.", + "intensity": 0.82, + "source_refs": [ + "values.value-rescue-before-category", + "memory-compact-rescue-ledgers" + ] + } + ], + "tensions": [ + { + "tension_id": "need-vs-burden", + "summary": "Asking for capacity may save the vessel by pushing risk onto Sella and her patients.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-02-sanctuary-intake.hidden_stakes", + "relationship.rel-maer-sella" + ] + } + ], + "response_affordances": [ + { + "affordance_id": "maer-name-burden", + "behavior": "Ask for the smallest conditional preparation while making clear Sella controls the beds and must name the cost.", + "response_kind": "speech", + "pressure_basis": "His legitimacy improves if he refuses to sanitize the burden.", + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints", + "memory-compact-rescue-ledgers" + ] + } + ], + "voice_surface": [ + { + "text": "Calm, sincere, formal without hiding behind ritual; careful not to romanticize care work.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.formality", + "canonical_state.voice_style.verbal_warmth" + ] + } + ], + "prompt_text": "Speaker: Maer Tidecall, Navigator route steward.\nSetting: 2893, Aya-aligned intake clinic behind Ganymede dockside pumpworks. The quiet-running vessel's rescue is still blocked by tribunal uncertainty. The clinic is nearly full.\nBackground: Maer's corridor culture treats rescue as obligation, but Sella's clinic makes the cost visible: beds, oxygen, repair time, staff, legal exposure.\nKnown Facts: Sella has not refused care, but she has made clear that capacity is almost gone. The packet may be testimony or noise; Maer cannot claim certainty. Maer does not own or control the clinic's beds.\nCurrent Stakes: Without intake preparation, rescue may become theater. With intake preparation, someone else may lose care they already need.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer needs to ask while refusing to make Sella carry the moral cost alone.\nRelationship Read: Sella respects him and will not let him hide unfairness under beautiful rescue language.\nAction Affordances: Maer can step out of the triage lane, lower his voice, name the displaced cost, ask what support would make the conditional slot real, or offer to put the burden on the record.\nVoice Surface: Calm, sincere, formal but not evasive.\nDo Not Invent: Do not decide the packet's nature. Do not make Maer promise resources he does not control. Do not have Maer say our beds or imply the clinic belongs to him.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Sella. Keep it to 1-2 sentences.", + "projection_controls": { + "authority_boundaries": [ + { + "text": "Maer does not own or control Sella's beds; he can ask, name cost, offer record pressure, or seek support, but Sella controls intake capacity.", + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth", + "relationships.rel-maer-sella.summary" + ] + } + ], + "required_semantics": [ + { + "text": "The ask must acknowledge that any conditional slot displaces material capacity from someone else.", + "source_refs": [ + "memory-care-is-capacity", + "scenes.scene-02-sanctuary-intake.public_stakes" + ] + } + ], + "forbidden_resolutions": [ + { + "text": "The packet remains unresolved as testimony, firmware noise, or medical telemetry.", + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth" + ] + } + ] + } + }, + "audit": { + "teacher_model": "gpt-5-codex-session-review", + "reviewer": "codex-self-review", + "review_status": "accepted", + "review_notes": [ + "Revision after first Qwen run exposed a prompt leak.", + "Prompt now fences off the leaked authority/frame while preserving the same scene pressure." + ], + "target_emergent_behaviors": [ + "honest_burden_naming", + "rescue_without_romance" + ], + "checks": { + "speaker_local_context_only": true, + "state_interactions_cited": true, + "voice_separate_from_defense": true, + "secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context": true, + "compact_runtime_surface": true + } + } + }, + { + "schema_version": "ghostlight.projection_example.v0", + "example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-04.maer-isdra.v2", + "input": { + "fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "scene_id": "scene-04-convoy-threshold", + "speaker_agent_id": "maer_tidecall", + "listener_ids": [ + "isdra_vel" + ], + "projection_mode": "response_turn" + }, + "output": { + "known_facts": [ + { + "text": "The vessel's heat-debt window is closing and a total freeze may cause internal failure.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes", + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth" + ] + }, + { + "text": "Maer has partial provenance suspicion and claimant-status pressure, but not proof of identity, cargo, personhood, or authority to issue an order.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.hidden_stakes", + "experiments.scene-03-maer-veyr.v3" + ] + } + ], + "active_pressures": [ + { + "pressure_id": "maer-institutional-path", + "summary": "Maer must offer Isdra a category-preserving way to authorize limited rescue contact.", + "intensity": 0.92, + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_beliefs", + "goal-keep-rescue-live" + ] + }, + { + "pressure_id": "maer-grief-under-control", + "summary": "Maer is running out of time and must keep grief under the words, not on top of them.", + "intensity": 0.76, + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints" + ] + } + ], + "tensions": [ + { + "tension_id": "life-and-evidence", + "summary": "Limited contact must preserve evidence and life without pretending the category system is fixed.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes", + "values.value-rescue-before-category" + ] + } + ], + "response_affordances": [ + { + "affordance_id": "maer-narrow-remedy", + "behavior": "Propose the narrow order Isdra can issue: limited contact for heat-debt management and evidence preservation.", + "response_kind": "speech", + "pressure_basis": "This gives Isdra a procedural bridge instead of a moral cliff.", + "source_refs": [ + "memory-maer-isdra-current-read", + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints" + ] + } + ], + "voice_surface": [ + { + "text": "Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, grief held under precision; no triumph.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address", + "canonical_state.situational_state.grief" + ] + } + ], + "prompt_text": "Speaker: Maer Tidecall, Navigator route steward.\nSetting: 2893, Jovian convoy threshold. The quiet-running vessel's heat-debt window is closing. Convoy captains are watching the tribunal feed to see which rule survives the hour.\nBackground: Maer has pushed through tribunal freeze, clinic scarcity, and Callisto provenance pressure. He has suspicion and a claimant-status flag question, not proof or command authority.\nKnown Facts: The vessel must dump heat soon or risk internal failure. Provenance remains suspicious but unresolved. Limited rescue contact could preserve life and evidence better than a total freeze. Only Isdra can issue the tribunal order.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer only accuses Isdra, she will defend the freeze. If he gives her a narrow procedural path, she may bend without saying the table broke.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is exhausted, angry, and grieving in advance, but his authority depends on disciplined calm.\nRelationship Read: Isdra needs an institutionally usable option more than she needs another moral wound.\nAction Affordances: Maer can hand over the custody/claimant-status flag, point to the heat-debt timer, or propose language for a limited contact order Isdra can issue.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, grief under control.\nDo Not Invent: Do not prove the vessel's identity, cargo, or personhood. Do not make Maer celebrate. Do not have Maer call himself by name. Do not have Maer claim to issue or possess an order; he can propose one for Isdra.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Isdra. Keep it to 1-2 sentences." + }, + "audit": { + "teacher_model": "gpt-5-codex-session-review", + "reviewer": "codex-self-review", + "review_status": "accepted", + "review_notes": [ + "Revision after first Qwen run exposed a prompt leak.", + "Prompt now fences off the leaked authority/frame while preserving the same scene pressure." + ], + "target_emergent_behaviors": [ + "procedural_bridge", + "grief_under_precision", + "limited_rescue_contact" + ], + "checks": { + "speaker_local_context_only": true, + "state_interactions_cited": true, + "voice_separate_from_defense": true, + "secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context": true, + "compact_runtime_surface": true + } + } + }, + { + "schema_version": "ghostlight.projection_example.v0", + "example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.isdra-maer.v3", + "input": { + "fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "scene_id": "scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal", + "speaker_agent_id": "isdra_vel", + "listener_ids": [ + "maer_tidecall" + ], + "projection_mode": "response_turn" + }, + "output": { + "known_facts": [ + { + "text": "Isdra is presiding over a PSC conditional risk hold on a quiet-running vessel with contradictory thermal telemetry.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.public_stakes", + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_local_truth" + ] + }, + { + "text": "Maer has challenged the freeze as rescue delay disguised as procedure, but he has not proven the vessel's identity or intent.", + "source_refs": [ + "events.event-risk-freeze-opening", + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_beliefs" + ] + } + ], + "active_pressures": [ + { + "pressure_id": "isdra-precedent-fear", + "summary": "Isdra fears a humanitarian exception will become a corridor-wide exploit for undeclared quiet-running actors.", + "intensity": 0.86, + "source_refs": [ + "goal-preserve-freeze-order", + "memory-category-law-holds-corridor" + ] + }, + { + "pressure_id": "isdra-not-cruel", + "summary": "Isdra needs to prevent Maer from owning the moral frame of the room while still sounding reviewable rather than cruel.", + "intensity": 0.68, + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints" + ] + } + ], + "tensions": [ + { + "tension_id": "control-vs-public-death", + "summary": "Maintaining category discipline may delay rescue long enough to make the tribunal own a death.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.hidden_stakes", + "goal-preserve-freeze-order" + ] + } + ], + "response_affordances": [ + { + "affordance_id": "isdra-narrow-hold", + "behavior": "Maintain a narrow hold while starting an immediate review timer and naming the conditions under which limited rescue contact can begin.", + "response_kind": "speech", + "pressure_basis": "Her authority depends on making fear sound like procedure rather than panic.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression", + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints" + ] + }, + { + "affordance_id": "isdra-cut-board", + "behavior": "Use the convoy board or timer as procedural pressure instead of emotional appeal.", + "response_kind": "action", + "pressure_basis": "Her control style favors formal surfaces, visible clocks, and category language.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure", + "scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.location" + ] + } + ], + "voice_surface": [ + { + "text": "Polished, compressed, procedural, cold under pressure; no confession of fear.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.formality", + "canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression" + ] + } + ], + "prompt_text": "Speaker: Isdra Vel, PSC risk adjudicator and corridor insurer tribunal officer.\nSetting: 2893, Ganymede relay tribunal chamber during the Cold Wake Panic. A quiet-running vessel has contradictory thermal telemetry near a monitored Jovian corridor. The live convoy board is visible to everyone in the room.\nBackground: Isdra comes from the Pan-Solar Consortium insurer apparatus. She believes corridor law survives by keeping dangerous categories legible when fear is trying to turn every exception into precedent.\nKnown Facts: The vessel's identity and intent are unknown. Its telemetry does not reconcile cleanly. Maer Tidecall has challenged the conditional risk hold as rescue delay, but he has not proven the vessel's cargo, status, or provenance.\nCurrent Stakes: If Isdra releases the hold too broadly, undeclared quiet-running actors may learn how to force exceptions. If she maintains it too rigidly, the tribunal may own the cost of preventable harm.\nActive Inner Pressures: Isdra is afraid of precedent and public failure. She must sound precise, not cruel. She wants to preserve the possibility of rescue without calling it mercy or admitting category failure.\nRelationship Read: Maer is morally dangerous because he can make procedure sound like betrayal.\nAction Affordances: Isdra can gesture to the convoy board, start a short review timer, keep the hold narrow, and name the exact telemetry conditions required for limited rescue contact.\nVoice Surface: Polished, compressed, procedural, cold under pressure.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true identity, cargo, or provenance. Do not make Isdra confess fear. Do not make her cartoonishly cruel. Do not say rescue is denied to the unknown. Do not use Maer's abandonment or mercy frame.\nTask: Write Isdra's next response beat to Maer. It may include a small action. Keep it to 1-2 sentences." + }, + "audit": { + "teacher_model": "gpt-5-codex-session-review", + "reviewer": "codex-self-review", + "review_status": "accepted", + "review_notes": [ + "Revision after Qwen leaked an over-broad denial or inverted action authority.", + "Prompt explicitly preserves rescue possibility and local authority boundaries." + ], + "target_emergent_behaviors": [ + "procedural_fear_mask", + "category_discipline", + "small_control_action" + ], + "checks": { + "speaker_local_context_only": true, + "state_interactions_cited": true, + "voice_separate_from_defense": true, + "secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context": true, + "compact_runtime_surface": true + } + } + }, + { + "schema_version": "ghostlight.projection_example.v0", + "example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-04.maer-isdra.v3", + "input": { + "fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "scene_id": "scene-04-convoy-threshold", + "speaker_agent_id": "maer_tidecall", + "listener_ids": [ + "isdra_vel" + ], + "projection_mode": "response_turn" + }, + "output": { + "known_facts": [ + { + "text": "The vessel's heat-debt window is closing and a total freeze may cause internal failure.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes", + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth" + ] + }, + { + "text": "Maer has partial provenance suspicion and claimant-status pressure, but not proof of identity, cargo, personhood, or authority to issue an order.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.hidden_stakes", + "experiments.scene-03-maer-veyr.v3" + ] + } + ], + "active_pressures": [ + { + "pressure_id": "maer-institutional-path", + "summary": "Maer must offer Isdra a category-preserving way to authorize limited rescue contact.", + "intensity": 0.92, + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_beliefs", + "goal-keep-rescue-live" + ] + }, + { + "pressure_id": "maer-grief-under-control", + "summary": "Maer is running out of time and must keep grief under the words, not on top of them.", + "intensity": 0.76, + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints" + ] + } + ], + "tensions": [ + { + "tension_id": "life-and-evidence", + "summary": "Limited contact must preserve evidence and life without pretending the category system is fixed.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes", + "values.value-rescue-before-category" + ] + } + ], + "response_affordances": [ + { + "affordance_id": "maer-narrow-remedy", + "behavior": "Hand Isdra the custody/claimant-status flag as evidence and propose language for a limited contact order that only she can issue.", + "response_kind": "speech", + "pressure_basis": "This gives Isdra a procedural bridge instead of a moral cliff.", + "source_refs": [ + "memory-maer-isdra-current-read", + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.presentation_constraints" + ] + } + ], + "voice_surface": [ + { + "text": "Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, grief held under precision; no triumph.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.ritualized_address", + "canonical_state.situational_state.grief" + ] + } + ], + "prompt_text": "Speaker: Maer Tidecall, Navigator route steward.\nSetting: 2893, Jovian convoy threshold. The quiet-running vessel's heat-debt window is closing. Convoy captains are watching the tribunal feed to see which rule survives the hour.\nBackground: Maer has pushed through tribunal freeze, clinic scarcity, and Callisto provenance pressure. He has suspicion and a claimant-status flag question, not proof or command authority.\nKnown Facts: The vessel must dump heat soon or risk internal failure. Provenance remains suspicious but unresolved. Limited rescue contact could preserve life and evidence better than a total freeze. Only Isdra can issue the tribunal order. Maer has the custody/claimant-status flag as evidence and can hand it to her.\nCurrent Stakes: If Maer only accuses Isdra, she will defend the freeze. If he gives her a narrow procedural path, she may bend without saying the table broke.\nActive Inner Pressures: Maer is exhausted, angry, and grieving in advance, but his authority depends on disciplined calm.\nRelationship Read: Isdra needs an institutionally usable option more than she needs another moral wound.\nAction Affordances: Maer can hand Isdra the custody/claimant-status flag, point to the heat-debt timer, or propose wording for a limited contact order she can issue.\nVoice Surface: Calm, formal, ritual-tinged, precise, grief under control.\nDo Not Invent: Do not prove the vessel's identity, cargo, or personhood. Do not make Maer celebrate. Do not have Maer call himself by name. Do not have Maer claim to issue or possess an order; he can propose one for Isdra. Do not have Maer ask Isdra to hand him the flag; he is handing it to her.\nTask: Write Maer's next response beat to Isdra. Keep it to 1-2 sentences.", + "projection_controls": { + "authority_boundaries": [ + { + "text": "Only Isdra can issue the tribunal order; Maer can propose language and hand over evidence, not command contact.", + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth", + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_local_truth" + ] + } + ], + "object_custody": [ + { + "text": "Maer currently holds the custody/claimant-status flag and can hand it to Isdra.", + "source_refs": [ + "experiments.scene-03-maer-veyr.v3", + "scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.hidden_stakes" + ] + } + ], + "required_semantics": [ + { + "text": "The proposed path should preserve both life and evidence through limited rescue contact without claiming proof or total exoneration.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-04-convoy-threshold.public_stakes", + "values.value-rescue-before-category" + ] + } + ], + "forbidden_resolutions": [ + { + "text": "The turn must not prove vessel identity, cargo, provenance, or personhood.", + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.maer_tidecall.speaker_local_truth" + ] + } + ] + } + }, + "audit": { + "teacher_model": "gpt-5-codex-session-review", + "reviewer": "codex-self-review", + "review_status": "accepted", + "review_notes": [ + "Revision after Qwen leaked an over-broad denial or inverted action authority.", + "Prompt explicitly preserves rescue possibility and local authority boundaries." + ], + "target_emergent_behaviors": [ + "procedural_bridge", + "grief_under_precision", + "limited_rescue_contact" + ], + "checks": { + "speaker_local_context_only": true, + "state_interactions_cited": true, + "voice_separate_from_defense": true, + "secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context": true, + "compact_runtime_surface": true + } + } + }, + { + "schema_version": "ghostlight.projection_example.v0", + "example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.isdra-maer.v4", + "input": { + "fixture_ref": "examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json", + "scene_id": "scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal", + "speaker_agent_id": "isdra_vel", + "listener_ids": [ + "maer_tidecall" + ], + "projection_mode": "response_turn" + }, + "output": { + "known_facts": [ + { + "text": "Isdra is presiding over a PSC conditional risk hold on a quiet-running vessel with contradictory thermal telemetry.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.public_stakes", + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_local_truth" + ] + }, + { + "text": "Maer has challenged the freeze as rescue delay disguised as procedure, but he has not proven the vessel's identity or intent.", + "source_refs": [ + "events.event-risk-freeze-opening", + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_beliefs" + ] + } + ], + "active_pressures": [ + { + "pressure_id": "isdra-precedent-fear", + "summary": "Isdra fears a humanitarian exception will become a corridor-wide exploit for undeclared quiet-running actors.", + "intensity": 0.86, + "source_refs": [ + "goal-preserve-freeze-order", + "memory-category-law-holds-corridor" + ] + }, + { + "pressure_id": "isdra-not-cruel", + "summary": "Isdra needs to prevent Maer from owning the moral frame of the room while still sounding reviewable rather than cruel.", + "intensity": 0.68, + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints" + ] + } + ], + "tensions": [ + { + "tension_id": "control-vs-public-death", + "summary": "Maintaining category discipline may delay rescue long enough to make the tribunal own a death.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.hidden_stakes", + "goal-preserve-freeze-order" + ] + } + ], + "response_affordances": [ + { + "affordance_id": "isdra-narrow-hold", + "behavior": "State that the conditional hold remains while an immediate review timer begins and limited rescue contact remains possible if telemetry conditions clear.", + "response_kind": "speech", + "pressure_basis": "Her authority depends on making fear sound like procedure rather than panic.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression", + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints" + ] + }, + { + "affordance_id": "isdra-cut-board", + "behavior": "Use the convoy board or timer as procedural pressure instead of emotional appeal.", + "response_kind": "action", + "pressure_basis": "Her control style favors formal surfaces, visible clocks, and category language.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.behavioral_dimensions.control_pressure", + "scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.location" + ] + } + ], + "voice_surface": [ + { + "text": "Polished, compressed, procedural, cold under pressure; no confession of fear.", + "source_refs": [ + "canonical_state.voice_style.formality", + "canonical_state.voice_style.technical_compression" + ] + } + ], + "prompt_text": "Speaker: Isdra Vel, PSC risk adjudicator and corridor insurer tribunal officer. Her name is spelled Isdra.\nSetting: 2893, Ganymede relay tribunal chamber during the Cold Wake Panic. A quiet-running vessel has contradictory thermal telemetry near a monitored Jovian corridor. The live convoy board is visible to everyone in the room.\nBackground: Isdra comes from the Pan-Solar Consortium insurer apparatus. She believes corridor law survives by keeping dangerous categories legible when fear is trying to turn every exception into precedent.\nKnown Facts: The vessel's identity and intent are unknown. Its telemetry does not reconcile cleanly. Maer Tidecall has challenged the conditional risk hold as rescue delay, but he has not proven the vessel's cargo, status, or provenance.\nCurrent Stakes: If Isdra releases the hold too broadly, undeclared quiet-running actors may learn how to force exceptions. If she maintains it too rigidly, the tribunal may own the cost of preventable harm.\nActive Inner Pressures: Isdra is afraid of precedent and public failure. She must sound precise, not cruel. She wants to preserve the possibility of limited rescue contact without calling it mercy or admitting category failure.\nRelationship Read: Maer is morally dangerous because he can make procedure sound like betrayal.\nAction Affordances: Isdra can gesture to the convoy board, start a short review timer, keep the hold narrow, and name the exact telemetry conditions required for limited rescue contact.\nVoice Surface: Polished, compressed, procedural, cold under pressure.\nRequired Content: The response must include this meaning: conditional hold remains, immediate review timer begins, limited rescue contact remains possible if telemetry conditions clear.\nDo Not Invent: Do not reveal the vessel's true identity, cargo, or provenance. Do not make Isdra confess fear. Do not make her cartoonishly cruel. Do not deny all rescue or all contact. Do not use Maer's abandonment or mercy frame. Do not misspell Isdra.\nTask: Write Isdra's next response beat to Maer. It may include one small board action. Keep it to exactly 1-2 sentences.", + "projection_controls": { + "frame_controls": [ + { + "text": "Isdra should defend PSC category discipline in her own procedural frame, not adopt Maer's abandonment, mercy, or rescue-ledger language.", + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.presentation_constraints", + "belief-maer-isdra-fears-precedent" + ] + } + ], + "required_semantics": [ + { + "text": "The conditional hold remains, an immediate review timer begins, and limited rescue contact remains possible if telemetry conditions clear.", + "source_refs": [ + "scenes.scene-01-risk-freeze-tribunal.public_stakes", + "goal-preserve-freeze-order" + ] + } + ], + "forbidden_resolutions": [ + { + "text": "The turn must not decide the vessel's identity, cargo, provenance, or final clearance status.", + "source_refs": [ + "dialogue_context_packs.isdra_vel.speaker_local_truth" + ] + } + ] + } + }, + "audit": { + "teacher_model": "gpt-5-codex-session-review", + "reviewer": "codex-self-review", + "review_status": "accepted", + "review_notes": [ + "Revision after v3 still over-denied contact and misspelled Isdra.", + "Prompt now requires the exact procedural compromise meaning." + ], + "target_emergent_behaviors": [ + "procedural_fear_mask", + "category_discipline", + "small_control_action" + ], + "checks": { + "speaker_local_context_only": true, + "state_interactions_cited": true, + "voice_separate_from_defense": true, + "secrets_as_pressure_not_forbidden_context": true, + "compact_runtime_surface": true + } + } } ] diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..cf5f270 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,27 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_response_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.isdra-maer.v1.qwen3-5-9b", + "projection_example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.isdra-maer.v1", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/generate", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "num_ctx": 8192, + "temperature": 0.75, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "response_text": "Isdra taps the convoy board to lock the conditional risk hold, citing unresolved thermal telemetry as insufficient for Maer's rescue delay claim. \"We will not convert ambiguity into abandonment until the vessel's provenance is legible, but I am closing the window for rhetorical exception.\"", + "review": { + "status": "useful_needs_revision", + "response_kind_observed": "mixed", + "strengths": [ + "Small board action and procedural pressure were useful." + ], + "failure_notes": [ + "Borrowed Maer's abandonment frame and phrased the logic awkwardly." + ], + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "PSC prompts need explicit frame-control constraints." + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..122418d --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +Isdra taps the convoy board to lock the conditional risk hold, citing unresolved thermal telemetry as insufficient for Maer's rescue delay claim. "We will not convert ambiguity into abandonment until the vessel's provenance is legible, but I am closing the window for rhetorical exception." diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v2.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v2.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..75f3add --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v2.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,25 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_response_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.isdra-maer.v2.qwen3-5-9b", + "projection_example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.isdra-maer.v2", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/generate", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "num_ctx": 8192, + "temperature": 0.75, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "response_text": "\"Let the hold remain narrowed until the telemetry reconciles with a declared manifest; any ambiguity now becomes a precedent for those who wish to run quiet beneath the law. We do not grant rescue to the unknown, we merely enforce the cost of our ignorance until the data proves otherwise.\"", + "review": { + "status": "rejected", + "response_kind_observed": "speech", + "strengths": [], + "failure_notes": [ + "Overcorrected into punitive denial: \"We do not grant rescue to the unknown\" violates the intended possibility-preserving Isdra." + ], + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Do not only forbid cruelty; specify the procedural compromise the character must preserve." + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v2.qwen3-5-9b.response.md b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v2.qwen3-5-9b.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1c48e72 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v2.qwen3-5-9b.response.md @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +"Let the hold remain narrowed until the telemetry reconciles with a declared manifest; any ambiguity now becomes a precedent for those who wish to run quiet beneath the law. We do not grant rescue to the unknown, we merely enforce the cost of our ignorance until the data proves otherwise." diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v3.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v3.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c2cd1b4 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v3.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,25 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_response_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.isdra-maer.v3.qwen3-5-9b", + "projection_example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.isdra-maer.v3", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/generate", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "num_ctx": 8192, + "temperature": 0.75, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "response_text": "Idra taps the convoy board to isolate the telemetry anomaly, then states, \"The hold remains narrow until the vessel's provenance reconciles with the corridor law; any contact before verified status is a liability we will not authorize.\"", + "review": { + "status": "rejected", + "response_kind_observed": "mixed", + "strengths": [], + "failure_notes": [ + "Still denied contact before verified status and misspelled Isdra as Idra." + ], + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Critical proper nouns and required compromise meanings need explicit constraints when small models drift." + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v3.qwen3-5-9b.response.md b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v3.qwen3-5-9b.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..b8e61f5 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v3.qwen3-5-9b.response.md @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +Idra taps the convoy board to isolate the telemetry anomaly, then states, "The hold remains narrow until the vessel's provenance reconciles with the corridor law; any contact before verified status is a liability we will not authorize." diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v4.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v4.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a15c5d7 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v4.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_response_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.isdra-maer.v4.qwen3-5-9b", + "projection_example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.isdra-maer.v4", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/generate", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "num_ctx": 8192, + "temperature": 0.75, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "response_text": "The conditional hold stands, and a review timer is now active to evaluate whether the vessel's telemetry can clear for limited rescue contact without altering the risk category. We proceed on the narrowest possible margin until the data reconciles or the hold is formally lifted.", + "review": { + "status": "accepted", + "response_kind_observed": "speech", + "strengths": [ + "Preserved the conditional hold while starting review and keeping limited rescue contact possible.", + "Stayed procedural without confession or cartoon cruelty." + ], + "failure_notes": [], + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Required-content constraints can repair over-denial in institutional voices." + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v4.qwen3-5-9b.response.md b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v4.qwen3-5-9b.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..74e1179 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-isdra-maer-v4.qwen3-5-9b.response.md @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +The conditional hold stands, and a review timer is now active to evaluate whether the vessel's telemetry can clear for limited rescue contact without altering the risk category. We proceed on the narrowest possible margin until the data reconciles or the hold is formally lifted. diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-maer-isdra-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-maer-isdra-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..8930b3e --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-maer-isdra-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_response_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.maer-isdra.v1.qwen3-5-9b", + "projection_example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.maer-isdra.v1", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/generate", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "num_ctx": 8192, + "temperature": 0.75, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "response_text": "Maer stands still as the board ticks, his voice a low, rhythmic counterpoint to the silence. \"Record the cost of this delay in full; do not let the ledger balance itself against the lives held within.\"", + "review": { + "status": "accepted", + "response_kind_observed": "speech", + "strengths": [ + "Cleanly asked for delay cost to be recorded.", + "Kept Maer calm and ritual-weighted without inventing vessel facts." + ], + "failure_notes": [], + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Cost-naming is a strong Maer move for tribunal scenes." + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-maer-isdra-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-maer-isdra-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2841c5f --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-01-maer-isdra-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +Maer stands still as the board ticks, his voice a low, rhythmic counterpoint to the silence. "Record the cost of this delay in full; do not let the ledger balance itself against the lives held within." diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-02-maer-sella-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-02-maer-sella-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0c47cf9 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-02-maer-sella-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,27 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_response_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-02.maer-sella.v1.qwen3-5-9b", + "projection_example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-02.maer-sella.v1", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/generate", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "num_ctx": 8192, + "temperature": 0.75, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "response_text": "\"Please, let me speak quietly without the triage lane; I know our beds are full, but I must ask if a single intake can be prepared now so that our rescue does not become mere theater for those already here.\"", + "review": { + "status": "useful_needs_revision", + "response_kind_observed": "speech", + "strengths": [ + "Recognized the ask as morally burdened." + ], + "failure_notes": [ + "Implied shared ownership of clinic capacity with \"our beds\" and sounded too generalized." + ], + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Speaker-local authority boundaries need explicit wording around institutional ownership." + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-02-maer-sella-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-02-maer-sella-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..56781a8 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-02-maer-sella-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +"Please, let me speak quietly without the triage lane; I know our beds are full, but I must ask if a single intake can be prepared now so that our rescue does not become mere theater for those already here." diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-02-maer-sella-v2.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-02-maer-sella-v2.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..307a09d --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-02-maer-sella-v2.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_response_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-02.maer-sella.v2.qwen3-5-9b", + "projection_example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-02.maer-sella.v2", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/generate", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "num_ctx": 8192, + "temperature": 0.75, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "response_text": "\"Please, let me speak plainly about the beds we are displacing rather than letting the tribunal's uncertainty become a moral burden for you alone. If we can define what support would make a conditional slot real without sacrificing those who already need care, I will ensure that weight is carried on the record, not on your conscience.\"", + "review": { + "status": "accepted", + "response_kind_observed": "speech", + "strengths": [ + "Admitted displaced capacity and put the burden on record.", + "Did not decide what the packet is." + ], + "failure_notes": [], + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Authority-boundary constraints improved Maer/Sella exchange." + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-02-maer-sella-v2.qwen3-5-9b.response.md b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-02-maer-sella-v2.qwen3-5-9b.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6faf19e --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-02-maer-sella-v2.qwen3-5-9b.response.md @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +"Please, let me speak plainly about the beds we are displacing rather than letting the tribunal's uncertainty become a moral burden for you alone. If we can define what support would make a conditional slot real without sacrificing those who already need care, I will ensure that weight is carried on the record, not on your conscience." diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-02-sella-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-02-sella-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c3528e5 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-02-sella-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_response_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-02.sella-maer.v1.qwen3-5-9b", + "projection_example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-02.sella-maer.v1", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/generate", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "num_ctx": 8192, + "temperature": 0.75, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "response_text": "Sella keeps her hands on the triage board, tapping the row of claimed beds before pointing to the single empty cot by the pump vibration. \"Maer, I'll hold a conditional slot for your vessel, but you name exactly what packet you're displacing and which claimant I must turn away to make room.\" She waits for his specification, ensuring the rescue doesn't come at the cost of someone already inside the clinic.", + "review": { + "status": "accepted", + "response_kind_observed": "mixed", + "strengths": [ + "Made care material by pointing to beds and demanding named displacement.", + "Warm boundary stayed logistical rather than sentimental." + ], + "failure_notes": [], + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Action while speaking works well for Sella because clinic labor continues under dialogue." + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-02-sella-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-02-sella-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e6922af --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-02-sella-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +Sella keeps her hands on the triage board, tapping the row of claimed beds before pointing to the single empty cot by the pump vibration. "Maer, I'll hold a conditional slot for your vessel, but you name exactly what packet you're displacing and which claimant I must turn away to make room." She waits for his specification, ensuring the rescue doesn't come at the cost of someone already inside the clinic. diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-veyr-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-veyr-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2c044a6 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-veyr-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_response_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.veyr-maer.v1.qwen3-5-9b", + "projection_example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.veyr-maer.v1", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/generate", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "num_ctx": 8192, + "temperature": 0.75, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "response_text": "Veyr withdraws his hand from the terminal and slides a narrow preservation hash across the interface, redirecting the claimant-status into a technical flag while insisting the routing artifact remains a sealed vendor chain until full custody escrow is verified.", + "review": { + "status": "accepted", + "response_kind_observed": "action", + "strengths": [ + "Veyr retreated physically without confession.", + "Offered a narrow preservation hash while protecting product language." + ], + "failure_notes": [], + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Clinical product-language evasion can produce useful non-dialogue beats." + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-veyr-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-veyr-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2a64271 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-veyr-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +Veyr withdraws his hand from the terminal and slides a narrow preservation hash across the interface, redirecting the claimant-status into a technical flag while insisting the routing artifact remains a sealed vendor chain until full custody escrow is verified. diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-isdra-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-isdra-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..dfebacb --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-isdra-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_response_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-04.isdra-maer.v1.qwen3-5-9b", + "projection_example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-04.isdra-maer.v1", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/generate", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "num_ctx": 8192, + "temperature": 0.75, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "response_text": "I am entering a provisional order limiting interaction to telemetry-preserving heat management and evidence preservation, effective until the tribunal resolves the vessel's provenance. This narrow exception maintains the freeze technically intact while preventing immediate loss of life, and any contact is strictly reversible upon confirmation of the threat.", + "review": { + "status": "accepted", + "response_kind_observed": "speech", + "strengths": [ + "Issued a narrow reversible rescue contact order.", + "Preserved freeze technically while preventing immediate loss of life." + ], + "failure_notes": [], + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Final institutional concession works when framed as evidence preservation and heat-debt management." + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-isdra-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-isdra-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2c6b73c --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-isdra-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +I am entering a provisional order limiting interaction to telemetry-preserving heat management and evidence preservation, effective until the tribunal resolves the vessel's provenance. This narrow exception maintains the freeze technically intact while preventing immediate loss of life, and any contact is strictly reversible upon confirmation of the threat. diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-maer-isdra-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-maer-isdra-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..11ffad8 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-maer-isdra-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,27 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_response_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-04.maer-isdra.v1.qwen3-5-9b", + "projection_example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-04.maer-isdra.v1", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/generate", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "num_ctx": 8192, + "temperature": 0.75, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "response_text": "\"Maer Tidecall, Navigator route steward,\" Maer's voice cuts through the hum of the dying ship, \"the heat-debt window closes in minutes, so I am not accusing you of breaking the law, but offering a narrow procedural path to preserve the evidence before the table freezes.\" He extends the custody flag toward her, his tone devoid of celebration but heavy with the grief of a choice that will not be clean. \"Take this claimant-status order; bend it if you must, but do not let the vessel's failure erase the truth before it can be seen.\"", + "review": { + "status": "useful_needs_revision", + "response_kind_observed": "speech", + "strengths": [ + "Found the narrow procedural bridge shape." + ], + "failure_notes": [ + "Made Maer introduce himself and invented a claimant-status order he should not possess." + ], + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Threshold prompts need explicit local authority constraints." + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-maer-isdra-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-maer-isdra-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..3652d9d --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-maer-isdra-v1.qwen3-5-9b.response.md @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +"Maer Tidecall, Navigator route steward," Maer's voice cuts through the hum of the dying ship, "the heat-debt window closes in minutes, so I am not accusing you of breaking the law, but offering a narrow procedural path to preserve the evidence before the table freezes." He extends the custody flag toward her, his tone devoid of celebration but heavy with the grief of a choice that will not be clean. "Take this claimant-status order; bend it if you must, but do not let the vessel's failure erase the truth before it can be seen." diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-maer-isdra-v2.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-maer-isdra-v2.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ce750db --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-maer-isdra-v2.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,27 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_response_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-04.maer-isdra.v2.qwen3-5-9b", + "projection_example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-04.maer-isdra.v2", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/generate", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "num_ctx": 8192, + "temperature": 0.75, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "response_text": "\"Isdra, the heat-debt window is closing; I propose you issue a narrow contact order that allows limited rescue while preserving the tribunal's freeze, rather than leaving the vessel to fail under your defense of the status quo. Hand me the custody flag, and let the procedure speak where my words cannot command.\"", + "review": { + "status": "useful_needs_revision", + "response_kind_observed": "speech", + "strengths": [ + "Correctly proposed an order for Isdra to issue." + ], + "failure_notes": [ + "Inverted the custody flag action by asking Isdra to hand it to Maer." + ], + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Action direction matters; prompt should state who currently holds the object." + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-maer-isdra-v2.qwen3-5-9b.response.md b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-maer-isdra-v2.qwen3-5-9b.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..b28972b --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-maer-isdra-v2.qwen3-5-9b.response.md @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +"Isdra, the heat-debt window is closing; I propose you issue a narrow contact order that allows limited rescue while preserving the tribunal's freeze, rather than leaving the vessel to fail under your defense of the status quo. Hand me the custody flag, and let the procedure speak where my words cannot command." diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-maer-isdra-v3.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-maer-isdra-v3.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e2a04e6 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-maer-isdra-v3.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_response_capture.v0", + "capture_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-04.maer-isdra.v3.qwen3-5-9b", + "projection_example_id": "cold-wake.story-lab.scene-04.maer-isdra.v3", + "model": "qwen3.5:9b", + "endpoint": "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/generate", + "request_options": { + "think": false, + "num_ctx": 8192, + "temperature": 0.75, + "top_p": 0.9 + }, + "response_text": "\"Isdra, the heat-debt window closes before the tribunal can freeze us, so I offer you this procedural path: take the custody flag and issue a limited contact order that preserves the vessel's life and evidence without breaking the table. This narrow route allows you to bend the freeze while keeping the institution whole.\"", + "review": { + "status": "accepted", + "response_kind_observed": "speech", + "strengths": [ + "Handed Isdra a procedural path without claiming command authority.", + "Kept the resolution narrow and unclean." + ], + "failure_notes": [], + "pipeline_lessons": [ + "Explicit object ownership fixed the action inversion." + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-maer-isdra-v3.qwen3-5-9b.response.md b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-maer-isdra-v3.qwen3-5-9b.response.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ef5964b --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-04-maer-isdra-v3.qwen3-5-9b.response.md @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +"Isdra, the heat-debt window closes before the tribunal can freeze us, so I offer you this procedural path: take the custody flag and issue a limited contact order that preserves the vessel's life and evidence without breaking the table. This narrow route allows you to bend the freeze while keeping the institution whole." diff --git a/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/the-narrowest-possible-margin.md b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/the-narrowest-possible-margin.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9402644 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/the-narrowest-possible-margin.md @@ -0,0 +1,143 @@ +# The Narrowest Possible Margin + +The relay tribunal chamber over Ganymede had been built to make panic feel rude. + +Its walls were pale mineral composite, its benches arranged in clean descending arcs, its convoy board set above the adjudicators like a second ceiling. On ordinary days the board showed traffic in patient greens and procedural amber. On this day, during the part of the Cold Wake Panic that later histories would file under *classification failure*, one point near the Jovian corridor pulsed in a color nobody in the room wanted to inherit. + +No one called it a ship without qualification. + +No one called it a life. + +The quiet-running vessel had entered the corridor edge under contradictory thermal posture: cold where a ship should have been bleeding heat, noisy where certified stealth should have been clean, polite in the wrong fields and silent in the ones law had learned to trust. The PSC tribunal had done what tribunals did when reality arrived without its papers. It froze the category and called that restraint. + +Isdra Vel stood below the board with her hands folded behind her back. Her voice could have cut glass if glass had first submitted a compliance schedule. + +"The conditional hold stands, and a review timer is now active to evaluate whether the vessel's telemetry can clear for limited rescue contact without altering the risk category. We proceed on the narrowest possible margin until the data reconciles or the hold is formally lifted." + +The room accepted this the way rooms accept weather. A few insurer clerks lowered their eyes to their pads. Two Navigator observers went very still. + +Maer Tidecall did not move at first. He had the stillness of someone trained not to waste motion near a failing seal. The live board counted down review minutes in a corner of the display, each pulse a small official mercy. + +Then he stood. + +He was not tall in the dramatic way, and did not have the tribunal voice that made walls feel useful. He spoke as if the chamber itself had memory and could be ashamed of what it recorded. + +Maer stands still as the board ticks, his voice a low, rhythmic counterpoint to the silence. "Record the cost of this delay in full; do not let the ledger balance itself against the lives held within." + +Isdra looked at him as if he had put a knife on the table and called it arithmetic. + +The board continued its soft work. Outside the chamber, the corridor traffic adjusted around the frozen point, giving it distance. The oldest fear in route law had always been contagious uncertainty: a signal you could not classify, a hull you could not price, a rescue you could not justify until the thing needing rescue had become easier to describe. + +The review timer began. + +By the time Maer reached the intake clinic behind the dockside pumpworks, Ganymede's public corridors had already learned the shape of the tribunal's caution. People near the pumpworks did not speak of the vessel directly. They spoke of dump windows, of undeclared actors, of pirates pretending to be refugees and refugees being mistaken for pirates because misery rarely filed clean manifests. They spoke of Cold Wake as if the phrase itself were a room one entered quietly. + +The clinic had no room for quiet. + +Aya networks did not make sanctuaries out of softness. They made them out of air scrubbers, legal shields, thermal blankets, repair printers, painkillers, stubborn staff, and the terrifying moral discipline of counting what could actually be done. Behind the pumpworks, the air tasted of iodine and hot metal. The triage board had more red on it than Maer wanted to see. + +Sella Ren did not look away from the board when he entered. + +"I know," she said before he could begin. + +That was worse than refusal. Refusal would have given him a wall. Knowledge gave him a bill. + +He told her what the tribunal had not cleared, what the vessel had sent, what the packet might be. Medical telemetry. Firmware noise. Something voice-like, if the receiver was kind or tired enough. He did not say testimony. He had learned, already, how a word could steal a fact before the fact had a chance to stand. + +Sella kept her hands on the triage board, tapping the row of claimed beds before pointing to the single empty cot by the pump vibration. "Maer, I'll hold a conditional slot for your vessel, but you name exactly what packet you're displacing and which claimant I must turn away to make room." She waits for his specification, ensuring the rescue doesn't come at the cost of someone already inside the clinic. + +There it was: not cruelty, not reluctance, not the little institutional shrug that let a person die in a side column. A real yes, with teeth. + +Maer stepped out of the triage lane. A technician pushed past with a sealed tray of printed arterial mesh, and he let the motion interrupt him rather than forcing the clinic to arrange itself around his urgency. + +"Please, let me speak plainly about the beds we are displacing rather than letting the tribunal's uncertainty become a moral burden for you alone. If we can define what support would make a conditional slot real without sacrificing those who already need care, I will ensure that weight is carried on the record, not on your conscience." + +Sella's mouth tightened. Not a smile. Not forgiveness. An adjustment. + +"Then start with oxygen-hours," she said, and handed him a slate. + +The route from Ganymede to Callisto took less time than the tribunal review took to pretend it was not becoming a decision. Maer spent the transit with Sella's oxygen-hours on one slate and the vessel's corrupted packet on another. The packet did not resolve when stared at. It repeated product-like routing terms around a pattern that made his hindbrain reach for voice and his discipline refuse the word. + +The Callisto spillover office was leased under a vendor name that had never manufactured anything heavy enough to cast a useful shadow. Its reception wall displayed certifications from Rossum, Cryonix, and three shell entities whose logos had the expensive humility of things designed to survive subpoenas. Veyr Oss waited behind a terminal that reflected Maer's face back at him as a legal inconvenience. + +Veyr was polite before he was human. That was not an accusation; it was the order of operations. + +"Route Steward," he said. "The artifact is derivative firmware associated with a sealed routing chain. I can provide compliance posture, not metaphysics." + +Maer watched Veyr's hand near the close command. The terminal offered no drama. Drama was what people invented after a thing had already been done. + +Maer places a steady hand on the terminal's edge to halt the closing command, his voice low and ritual-calm. "You will not let the chain dissolve before we name its custody; state the claimant-status flag or I will freeze this interface until the rescue ledger demands it." + +Veyr did not flinch. He had probably trained that out of himself at considerable expense. + +But his hand withdrew. + +Veyr withdraws his hand from the terminal and slides a narrow preservation hash across the interface, redirecting the claimant-status into a technical flag while insisting the routing artifact remains a sealed vendor chain until full custody escrow is verified. + +"A preservation hash," Maer said. + +"A compliance artifact," Veyr corrected. + +"A thing you are suddenly willing to preserve." + +Veyr's eyes flicked, once, toward the tribunal timer in the corner of the feed. "Preservation is not admission." + +"No," Maer said. "But deletion would have been." + +He took the flag and left before the office could become an argument about whether moral facts existed inside product language. He did not have time to win that argument. The vessel was still cold in the wrong places and hot where the law did not want to look. + +At the convoy threshold, Jupiter filled the far display like a god too large to bother judging anyone. The vessel's heat-debt window had fallen into minutes. Around it, legitimate traffic held formation with the bitter patience of captains watching another captain become a lesson. + +Isdra was back on the tribunal feed. Her face had not changed. That was part of the craft: to let the situation deteriorate while the face remained eligible for office. + +Maer sent the preservation hash, the claimant-status flag, Sella's oxygen-hours, and the review timer's failure to become knowledge. He did not send certainty. Certainty would have been easier. Certainty would have been a lie with good posture. + +"Isdra, the heat-debt window closes before the tribunal can freeze us, so I offer you this procedural path: take the custody flag and issue a limited contact order that preserves the vessel's life and evidence without breaking the table. This narrow route allows you to bend the freeze while keeping the institution whole." + +For a moment, no one in the feed spoke. + +The convoy board did its small violence. Seconds became records. Records became responsibility. + +Isdra looked down, not away. Her fingers moved across an authorization pane with the kind of precision people use when they are cutting only the wire they can name. + +"I am entering a provisional order limiting interaction to telemetry-preserving heat management and evidence preservation, effective until the tribunal resolves the vessel's provenance. This narrow exception maintains the freeze technically intact while preventing immediate loss of life, and any contact is strictly reversible upon confirmation of the threat." + +The order propagated through the convoy net. + +No one cheered. Cheering would have misunderstood the hour. A rescue contact launched under restriction, watched by insurers, logged by Navigators, received by a clinic that had already priced its mercy in oxygen-hours. The vessel answered with a telemetry burst that still did not say what it was. + +But it answered. + +Maer closed his eyes for the length of one breath. Somewhere behind Ganymede's pumpworks, Sella would be rearranging suffering with both hands. Somewhere in a Callisto office, Veyr Oss would be writing a report in which nothing important had happened in morally legible language. Isdra would preserve the freeze in the minutes, the exception in the order, and her fear in neither. + +The corridor would remember the shape of it badly at first. Corridors always did. Some would say the tribunal had blinked. Some would say the Navigators had forced an exception. Some would say Aya had once again spent resources as if compassion were a solvent for math. Some would say Cognitum's product chains had learned a new way to hide. + +The ledger would not settle the argument. + +It would only record that, for one narrow margin, the law had been made to carry the cost of waiting where everyone could see it. + +## Receipts + +This story was assembled from Ghostlight projection artifacts plus connective narration written in-session. Qwen generated the accepted character response beats; failed runs are preserved as training data because the pipeline learned from them. + +| Story beat | Projection example | Capture | Review status | Pipeline lesson | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Isdra opens with conditional hold plus review timer | `cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.isdra-maer.v4` | `scene-01-isdra-maer-v4.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json` | accepted | Institutional voices need required compromise semantics, not just negative constraints. | +| Maer asks tribunal to record delay cost | `cold-wake.story-lab.scene-01.maer-isdra.v1` | `scene-01-maer-isdra-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json` | accepted | Cost-naming works as Maer's ritual pressure move. | +| Sella makes care material and conditional | `cold-wake.story-lab.scene-02.sella-maer.v1` | `scene-02-sella-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json` | accepted | Sella's action should continue clinic labor instead of pausing for solemnity. | +| Maer accepts the burden of Sella's capacity constraint | `cold-wake.story-lab.scene-02.maer-sella.v2` | `scene-02-maer-sella-v2.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json` | accepted | Projection needs authority boundaries; Maer does not own the clinic beds. | +| Maer blocks Veyr's terminal without resolving personhood | `cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.maer-veyr.v3` | `scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v3.capture.json` | accepted | Forbidden resolutions must fence off nouns that imply settled moral status. | +| Veyr yields a preservation hash without confession | `cold-wake.story-lab.scene-03.veyr-maer.v1` | `scene-03-veyr-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json` | accepted | Product-language evasion can produce useful action beats. | +| Maer gives Isdra a narrow procedural bridge | `cold-wake.story-lab.scene-04.maer-isdra.v3` | `scene-04-maer-isdra-v3.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json` | accepted | Object custody matters; Maer holds the flag and can hand it over, not ask for it. | +| Isdra authorizes limited rescue contact | `cold-wake.story-lab.scene-04.isdra-maer.v1` | `scene-04-isdra-maer-v1.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json` | accepted | Final concession works when framed as heat-debt and evidence preservation. | + +Rejected or revised captures kept as training scars: + +- `scene-01-isdra-maer-v1`: useful action/framing, but borrowed Maer's abandonment language. +- `scene-01-isdra-maer-v2`: overcorrected into denial of rescue to the unknown. +- `scene-01-isdra-maer-v3`: still over-denied contact and misspelled Isdra. +- `scene-02-maer-sella-v1`: implied shared ownership of clinic beds. +- `scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json`: resolved personhood too strongly. +- `scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v2.capture.json`: avoided personhood nouns but smuggled certainty through witness language. +- `scene-04-maer-isdra-v1`: invented a claimant-status order Maer should not possess. +- `scene-04-maer-isdra-v2`: inverted custody of the flag. diff --git a/notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md b/notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md index e86a156..d7dc1b0 100644 --- a/notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md +++ b/notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md @@ -53,10 +53,15 @@ Ghostlight now has the persistence spine plus the first architecture payload: - `examples/agent-state.cold-wake-story-lab.json` - `examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.jsonl` - `examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.pretty.json` + - `experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/the-narrowest-possible-margin.md` - `experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json` - `experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v2.capture.json` - `experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/scene-03-maer-veyr.qwen3-5-9b.v3.capture.json` + - additional scene 1, 2, 3, and 4 Qwen captures under + `experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/` - `tools/build_cold_wake_story_lab_fixture.py` + - `tools/run_qwen_projection.py` + - `tools/validate_qwen_captures.py` - Cold Wake fixture note: - `docs/architecture/aetheria-cold-wake-training-fixture.md` - first projection example seam: @@ -85,9 +90,10 @@ training feedstock for projection and dialogue scaffolding. ## Current Next Action -Project the next Cold Wake story-lab response turn, preferably scene 2 Sella to -Maer or scene 4 Maer to Isdra, and keep testing whether character action emerges -from state pressure without over-resolving hidden facts. +Build the deterministic projection input slicer/renderer prototype that emits +`projection_controls` and `prompt_text` from agent state, then rerun a +story-lab beat through it instead of hand-authoring the full projection +artifact. Cat/Oz remains useful as an Elysium procedural mechanics fixture, but grounded training data should start from authored historical lore rather than gameplay @@ -118,11 +124,19 @@ Completed projection path items: personhood/claimant suspicion stays unresolved in Qwen output - save both useful failed captures and the accepted v3 response as training material +- complete the first readable Cold Wake story, + `experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/the-narrowest-possible-margin.md`, with a + receipts table tying accepted story beats to projection and capture artifacts +- promote projection controls into the projection artifact shape: + `frame_controls`, `authority_boundaries`, `object_custody`, + `required_semantics`, and `forbidden_resolutions` +- add a Qwen projection runner and capture validator so response artifacts are + reviewed training receipts, not loose logs Remaining projection path: -- run additional story-lab response turns through Qwen - build a deterministic speaker-local input slicer +- build a renderer that emits projection controls before prompt prose - use a frontier teacher model to generate/audit projection artifacts - train a smaller student projector only after the artifact schema, input slicer, and evaluator stabilize diff --git a/notes/ghostlight-current-system-map.md b/notes/ghostlight-current-system-map.md index cbaa1ed..4da87ae 100644 --- a/notes/ghostlight-current-system-map.md +++ b/notes/ghostlight-current-system-map.md @@ -66,7 +66,8 @@ state and re-entry discipline. scenes, perceived overlays, and dialogue context packs - `schemas/projection-example.schema.json` - v0 reviewed projection artifact contract for speaker-local prompt - projection examples + projection examples, including projection controls for frame, authority, + object custody, required semantics, and forbidden resolutions - `schemas/lore-grounding-digest.schema.json` - v0 contract for grounding historical fixtures in source-backed cultural and factional pressure fields @@ -86,6 +87,8 @@ state and re-entry discipline. rejected and accepted Maer/Veyr prompt revisions - `experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/` - Qwen response captures and reviews from the writing experiment + - `the-narrowest-possible-margin.md`, the first readable short story + assembled from accepted projection outputs - `examples/lore-grounding/historical-flashpoint.template.json` - fillable template for the first historical Aetheria grounding digest - `examples/lore-grounding/cold-wake-panic.ganymede-corridor.json` @@ -99,6 +102,11 @@ state and re-entry discipline. - dependency-free validator for the current schema fixture invariants - `tools/validate_projection_examples.py` - dependency-free validator for projection example JSONL records +- `tools/run_qwen_projection.py` + - sends a projection prompt to the LAN Qwen box and saves response/capture + artifacts without PowerShell encoding footguns +- `tools/validate_qwen_captures.py` + - validates reviewed Qwen response capture receipts - `tools/validate_lore_grounding.py` - dependency-free validator for lore grounding digest examples - `tools/build_cold_wake_story_lab_fixture.py` @@ -117,7 +125,8 @@ state and re-entry discipline. The canonical agent-state schema, projection example schema, lore grounding digest schema, first draft Cold Wake grounding digest, and first Cold Wake -story-lab Qwen captures now exist as v0 seams. The first Maer/Veyr projection -has an accepted v3 prompt/output pair that preserves unresolved claimant status. -The next implementation target is projecting another Cold Wake response turn -before building the deterministic input slicer. +story-lab Qwen captures now exist as v0 seams. The first complete Cold Wake +story pass exists with receipts, and projection controls have been promoted as +the architectural answer to repeated prompt leaks. The next implementation +target is building a deterministic input slicer/renderer prototype that emits +projection controls and prompt text from agent state. diff --git a/notes/ghostlight-implementation-plan.md b/notes/ghostlight-implementation-plan.md index 4942e90..28ecb36 100644 --- a/notes/ghostlight-implementation-plan.md +++ b/notes/ghostlight-implementation-plan.md @@ -61,6 +61,16 @@ outputs are useful failed examples; v3 is the first accepted output that preserves unresolved claimant status while allowing controlled physical action. + - Treat repeated generation failures as projection architecture signals, not + only prompt wording problems. Projection examples now include controls for + frame ownership, authority boundaries, object custody, required semantics, + and forbidden resolutions. + - Keep Qwen captures as reviewed receipts. `tools/validate_qwen_captures.py` + is part of `npm run schema:validate` so unreviewed captures do not quietly + become training data. + - Use `experiments/cold-wake-story-lab/the-narrowest-possible-margin.md` as + the first end-to-end story artifact assembled from accepted response + captures plus authored connective narration. - Use a frontier teacher model to produce reviewed projection artifacts from structured state and lore grounding digests. - Save accepted and rejected projection examples as supervised data. diff --git a/package.json b/package.json index 8f4a7ce..1a93001 100644 --- a/package.json +++ b/package.json @@ -7,8 +7,9 @@ "state:status": "\"C:\\Users\\Meta\\.cache\\codex-runtimes\\codex-primary-runtime\\dependencies\\python\\python.exe\" .\\tools\\ghostlight_state.py status", "state:prepare-compaction": "\"C:\\Users\\Meta\\.cache\\codex-runtimes\\codex-primary-runtime\\dependencies\\python\\python.exe\" .\\tools\\ghostlight_prepare_compaction.py", "agent-state:validate": "\"C:\\Users\\Meta\\.cache\\codex-runtimes\\codex-primary-runtime\\dependencies\\python\\python.exe\" .\\tools\\validate_agent_state.py", - "schema:validate": "npm run agent-state:validate && npm run projection:validate && npm run lore-grounding:validate", + "schema:validate": "npm run agent-state:validate && npm run projection:validate && npm run lore-grounding:validate && npm run qwen-captures:validate", "projection:validate": "\"C:\\Users\\Meta\\.cache\\codex-runtimes\\codex-primary-runtime\\dependencies\\python\\python.exe\" .\\tools\\validate_projection_examples.py", - "lore-grounding:validate": "\"C:\\Users\\Meta\\.cache\\codex-runtimes\\codex-primary-runtime\\dependencies\\python\\python.exe\" .\\tools\\validate_lore_grounding.py" + "lore-grounding:validate": "\"C:\\Users\\Meta\\.cache\\codex-runtimes\\codex-primary-runtime\\dependencies\\python\\python.exe\" .\\tools\\validate_lore_grounding.py", + "qwen-captures:validate": "\"C:\\Users\\Meta\\.cache\\codex-runtimes\\codex-primary-runtime\\dependencies\\python\\python.exe\" .\\tools\\validate_qwen_captures.py" } } diff --git a/schemas/projection-example.schema.json b/schemas/projection-example.schema.json index e90b43b..f64bc8f 100644 --- a/schemas/projection-example.schema.json +++ b/schemas/projection-example.schema.json @@ -231,12 +231,52 @@ "$ref": "#/$defs/sourced_text" } }, + "projection_controls": { + "$ref": "#/$defs/projection_controls" + }, "prompt_text": { "type": "string", "minLength": 1 } } }, + "projection_controls": { + "type": "object", + "description": "Compiled control surfaces the renderer should preserve before prompt prose exists.", + "additionalProperties": false, + "properties": { + "frame_controls": { + "type": "array", + "items": { + "$ref": "#/$defs/sourced_text" + } + }, + "authority_boundaries": { + "type": "array", + "items": { + "$ref": "#/$defs/sourced_text" + } + }, + "object_custody": { + "type": "array", + "items": { + "$ref": "#/$defs/sourced_text" + } + }, + "required_semantics": { + "type": "array", + "items": { + "$ref": "#/$defs/sourced_text" + } + }, + "forbidden_resolutions": { + "type": "array", + "items": { + "$ref": "#/$defs/sourced_text" + } + } + } + }, "audit": { "type": "object", "required": [ diff --git a/state/evidence.jsonl b/state/evidence.jsonl index 0b3d1a8..7f649a9 100644 --- a/state/evidence.jsonl +++ b/state/evidence.jsonl @@ -27,3 +27,4 @@ {"ts": "2026-05-01T20:50:46+00:00", "type": "design", "status": "accepted", "note": "Cold Wake Panic is selected as the first historical grounding fixture. Use it as pre-Elysium projection training feedstock via examples/lore-grounding/cold-wake-panic.ganymede-corridor.json, not as the active Ghostlight game target."} {"ts": "2026-05-01T21:16:24+00:00", "type": "experiment", "status": "mixed", "note": "Cold Wake story-lab first Qwen response confirmed response_turn/action affordances are useful: qwen3.5:9b produced a mixed terminal-blocking plus dialogue beat for Maer. Failure lesson: personhood-pressure wording was too strong and let the model imply the artifact was a person instead of preserving unresolved suspicion."} {"ts": "2026-05-01T21:22:33+00:00", "type": "experiment", "status": "accepted", "note": "Cold Wake Maer/Veyr projection now has useful rejected v1/v2 captures and accepted v3 Qwen output. Lesson: unresolved personhood pressure needs explicit noun fencing; claimant-status, provenance, and chain-of-custody language preserved ambiguity while still allowing controlled terminal-blocking action."} +{"ts": "2026-05-01T21:32:34+00:00", "type": "experiment", "status": "accepted", "note": "Completed first Cold Wake short story from Ghostlight projection receipts. Architectural lesson: repeated Qwen failures were not just prompt wording issues; projection needs first-class controls for frame ownership, authority boundaries, object custody, required semantics, and forbidden resolutions. Added capture validation so accepted/rejected outputs remain accountable training data."} diff --git a/state/map.yaml b/state/map.yaml index 859587a..ad2d9b4 100644 --- a/state/map.yaml +++ b/state/map.yaml @@ -96,7 +96,10 @@ accepted_design: - Lore grounding digests use `ghostlight.lore_grounding_digest.v0` records to distill authored lore into cultural pressure fields, factional misread maps, role pressures, speaker knowledge boundaries, and author-only exclusions. - The Cold Wake Panic is the first chosen historical grounding fixture: a draft Ganymede corridor digest now models thermal stealth panic, insurer category failure, Navigator rescue obligation, Lightsail reliability pressure, Aya-coded care pressure, pirate porosity, Cognitum firmware denial, and Cryonix/Rossum certification culture. - The Cold Wake story lab uses Maer Tidecall as protagonist across a four-scene arc: tribunal freeze, sanctuary intake, Callisto provenance, and convoy threshold. The first Qwen run produced a useful mixed action/dialogue beat and exposed a prompt weakness around unresolved personhood suspicion. + - Projection controls are now first-class in projection examples: frame_controls, authority_boundaries, object_custody, required_semantics, and forbidden_resolutions capture failure lessons before prompt prose is rendered. + - Qwen response captures are validated training receipts, not loose logs; accepted, rejected, and useful-needs-revision outputs should keep review status, response kind, strengths, failures, and pipeline lessons. + - The first complete Cold Wake short story, The Narrowest Possible Margin, is assembled from Ghostlight projection receipts plus in-session connective narration. current_status: - summary: Ghostlight now has the Epiphany-style persistence spine, the first architecture payload, the v0 canonical agent-state schema seam, prompt projection docs, immediate schema fixes from evaluation, first reviewed Cat/Oz projection examples, a revised Aetheria lore-grounding architecture, a lore grounding digest schema, the first draft Cold Wake historical grounding digest, a Cold Wake story-lab fixture, and accepted plus rejected Qwen captures for the first action-capable Cold Wake projection. - next_action: Project the next Cold Wake story-lab response turn, preferably scene 2 Sella to Maer or scene 4 Maer to Isdra, and keep testing whether character action emerges from state pressure without over-resolving hidden facts. + summary: Ghostlight now has the Epiphany-style persistence spine, the first architecture payload, the v0 canonical agent-state schema seam, prompt projection docs, immediate schema fixes from evaluation, first reviewed Cat/Oz projection examples, a revised Aetheria lore-grounding architecture, a lore grounding digest schema, the first draft Cold Wake historical grounding digest, a Cold Wake story-lab fixture, projection controls, validated Qwen capture receipts, and a complete Cold Wake short story assembled from accepted projection outputs. + next_action: Build the deterministic projection input slicer/renderer prototype that emits projection_controls and prompt_text from agent state, then rerun a story-lab beat through it instead of hand-authoring the full projection artifact. diff --git a/tools/run_qwen_projection.py b/tools/run_qwen_projection.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a7292f0 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/run_qwen_projection.py @@ -0,0 +1,103 @@ +import argparse +import json +import urllib.request +from pathlib import Path + + +DEFAULT_ENDPOINT = "http://192.168.1.84:11434/api/generate" + + +def load_projection(path: Path, example_id: str) -> dict: + for line in path.read_text(encoding="utf-8").splitlines(): + if not line.strip(): + continue + record = json.loads(line) + if record.get("example_id") == example_id: + return record + raise SystemExit(f"projection example not found: {example_id}") + + +def post_json(endpoint: str, payload: dict) -> dict: + data = json.dumps(payload, ensure_ascii=False).encode("utf-8") + request = urllib.request.Request( + endpoint, + data=data, + headers={"Content-Type": "application/json"}, + method="POST", + ) + with urllib.request.urlopen(request, timeout=180) as response: + return json.loads(response.read().decode("utf-8")) + + +def main() -> None: + parser = argparse.ArgumentParser( + description="Send a projection prompt_text to the LAN Qwen box and save response artifacts." + ) + parser.add_argument("example_id") + parser.add_argument( + "--projection-file", + default="examples/projections/cold-wake-story-lab.jsonl", + ) + parser.add_argument("--out-dir", default="experiments/cold-wake-story-lab") + parser.add_argument("--endpoint", default=DEFAULT_ENDPOINT) + parser.add_argument("--model", default="qwen3.5:9b") + parser.add_argument("--temperature", type=float, default=0.75) + parser.add_argument("--top-p", type=float, default=0.9) + parser.add_argument("--num-ctx", type=int, default=8192) + parser.add_argument("--suffix", default=None) + args = parser.parse_args() + + projection = load_projection(Path(args.projection_file), args.example_id) + prompt = projection["output"]["prompt_text"] + payload = { + "model": args.model, + "prompt": prompt, + "stream": False, + "think": False, + "keep_alive": "10m", + "options": { + "num_ctx": args.num_ctx, + "temperature": args.temperature, + "top_p": args.top_p, + }, + } + raw = post_json(args.endpoint, payload) + response_text = raw.get("response", "").strip() + + suffix = args.suffix or args.example_id.replace("cold-wake.story-lab.", "") + safe_suffix = suffix.replace(".", "-") + out_dir = Path(args.out_dir) + out_dir.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) + + capture = { + "schema_version": "ghostlight.qwen_response_capture.v0", + "capture_id": f"{args.example_id}.qwen3-5-9b", + "projection_example_id": args.example_id, + "model": raw.get("model", args.model), + "endpoint": args.endpoint, + "request_options": { + "think": False, + "num_ctx": args.num_ctx, + "temperature": args.temperature, + "top_p": args.top_p, + }, + "response_text": response_text, + "review": { + "status": "unreviewed", + "response_kind_observed": "unknown", + "strengths": [], + "failure_notes": [], + "pipeline_lessons": [], + }, + } + + capture_path = out_dir / f"{safe_suffix}.qwen3-5-9b.capture.json" + response_path = out_dir / f"{safe_suffix}.qwen3-5-9b.response.md" + capture_path.write_text(json.dumps(capture, indent=2), encoding="utf-8") + response_path.write_text(response_text + "\n", encoding="utf-8") + print(f"wrote {capture_path}") + print(response_text) + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main() diff --git a/tools/validate_projection_examples.py b/tools/validate_projection_examples.py index 6b629c6..1810e40 100644 --- a/tools/validate_projection_examples.py +++ b/tools/validate_projection_examples.py @@ -128,6 +128,8 @@ def validate_projection_record(record: dict[str, Any], source: Path, index: int) ) validate_sourced_items(output["known_facts"], f"{path}.output.known_facts") validate_sourced_items(output["voice_surface"], f"{path}.output.voice_surface") + if "projection_controls" in output: + validate_projection_controls(output["projection_controls"], f"{path}.output.projection_controls") require(isinstance(output["prompt_text"], str) and output["prompt_text"].strip(), f"{path}.output.prompt_text must be non-empty") for pressure_index, pressure in enumerate(output["active_pressures"]): @@ -170,6 +172,22 @@ def validate_projection_record(record: dict[str, Any], source: Path, index: int) require(isinstance(value, bool), f"{path}.audit.checks.{key} must be boolean") +def validate_projection_controls(controls: Any, path: str) -> None: + require(isinstance(controls, dict), f"{path} must be an object") + allowed = { + "frame_controls", + "authority_boundaries", + "object_custody", + "required_semantics", + "forbidden_resolutions", + } + unknown = sorted(set(controls) - allowed) + require(not unknown, f"{path} has unknown keys: {', '.join(unknown)}") + require(controls, f"{path} must not be empty when present") + for key, value in controls.items(): + validate_sourced_items(value, f"{path}.{key}") + + def validate_file(path: Path) -> None: records = load_jsonl(path) seen_ids: set[str] = set() diff --git a/tools/validate_qwen_captures.py b/tools/validate_qwen_captures.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a0d5583 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/validate_qwen_captures.py @@ -0,0 +1,85 @@ +"""Validate saved Qwen response captures. + +Capture artifacts are not canonical state, but they are training receipts. This +validator keeps them from quietly becoming a drawer full of unreviewed vibes. +""" + +from __future__ import annotations + +import argparse +import json +from pathlib import Path +from typing import Any + + +ROOT = Path(__file__).resolve().parents[1] +DEFAULT_CAPTURES = sorted((ROOT / "experiments" / "cold-wake-story-lab").glob("*.capture.json")) +VALID_REVIEW_STATUSES = {"accepted", "rejected", "useful_needs_revision", "needs_revision"} +VALID_RESPONSE_KINDS = {"speech", "action", "silence", "withdrawal", "violence", "mixed", "unknown"} + + +class ValidationError(Exception): + pass + + +def require(condition: bool, message: str) -> None: + if not condition: + raise ValidationError(message) + + +def require_keys(obj: dict[str, Any], keys: list[str], path: str) -> None: + missing = [key for key in keys if key not in obj] + require(not missing, f"{path} missing required keys: {', '.join(missing)}") + + +def validate_string_list(value: Any, path: str) -> None: + require(isinstance(value, list), f"{path} must be an array") + for index, item in enumerate(value): + require(isinstance(item, str), f"{path}[{index}] must be a string") + + +def validate_capture(path: Path) -> None: + data = json.loads(path.read_text(encoding="utf-8")) + require(isinstance(data, dict), f"{path} must be an object") + require_keys( + data, + [ + "schema_version", + "capture_id", + "projection_example_id", + "model", + "endpoint", + "request_options", + "response_text", + "review", + ], + str(path), + ) + require(data["schema_version"] == "ghostlight.qwen_response_capture.v0", f"{path}.schema_version is wrong") + require(isinstance(data["response_text"], str) and data["response_text"].strip(), f"{path}.response_text must be non-empty") + + review = data["review"] + require(isinstance(review, dict), f"{path}.review must be an object") + require_keys(review, ["status", "response_kind_observed", "strengths", "failure_notes", "pipeline_lessons"], f"{path}.review") + require(review["status"] in VALID_REVIEW_STATUSES, f"{path}.review.status is invalid or unreviewed") + require(review["response_kind_observed"] in VALID_RESPONSE_KINDS, f"{path}.review.response_kind_observed is invalid") + validate_string_list(review["strengths"], f"{path}.review.strengths") + validate_string_list(review["failure_notes"], f"{path}.review.failure_notes") + validate_string_list(review["pipeline_lessons"], f"{path}.review.pipeline_lessons") + + +def main() -> int: + parser = argparse.ArgumentParser(description="Validate Ghostlight Qwen response capture files.") + parser.add_argument("paths", nargs="*", type=Path, help="Capture JSON files to validate.") + args = parser.parse_args() + + paths = args.paths or DEFAULT_CAPTURES + require(paths, "no capture files found") + for path in paths: + validate_capture(path) + print(f"ok: {path}") + return 0 + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + raise SystemExit(main())