From bdb4cde553f5e91e278bf5c7fc800b2a02ff3ff8 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Meta Vens Date: Fri, 7 Aug 2026 10:30:52 +0100 Subject: [PATCH] Record challenged Eyes routing boundary --- notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md | 36 ++++++++++++++++++++++--------- state/ledgers.msgpack | Bin 553716 -> 554302 bytes state/map.yaml | 12 +++++------ 3 files changed, 32 insertions(+), 16 deletions(-) diff --git a/notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md b/notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md index 77618e07..80c438a3 100644 --- a/notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md +++ b/notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md @@ -78,11 +78,27 @@ routes it to Research without granting Hands authority. Focused routing, runtime-spine eligibility, MVP-status, and full library tests pass; full library result remains 631 passed, 1 ignored. -The exact `d849b17e` release is packaging on Starfire: +The exact `d849b17e` release was published as +`sha256-90e31c86ae45683fc762f8c99e1596eb04fab6e2e39a94beb55a6aa3f1685224` +with witness +`sha256-c560200a10f263e0984759ddc846f3422c951f443422625cb071d6d9791508d8`. +Its live no-override coordinator run still returned `awaitFrontierProposal`. +The canonical item was correctly `recommended_next_organ: Eyes`; Self withheld +it because the newer repository Body challenged its target claim. That rule is +correct for Hands and Imagination, but incoherent for Eyes, whose work is to +investigate challenged claims. -- PID: `17136` -- stdout: `F:\Projects\Epiphany\.epiphany-run\package-d849b17e.stdout.log` -- stderr: `F:\Projects\Epiphany\.epiphany-run\package-d849b17e.stderr.log` +Commit `ea475aac` splits the invariant: Hands and Imagination remain blocked by +challenged targets; Eyes remains routeable when the model is uniquely admitted, +the frontier is active, scope is safe, and dependencies are terminal. Focused +challenge/routing tests and full library tests pass; full result is 631 passed, +1 ignored. + +The exact `ea475aac` release is packaging on Starfire: + +- PID: `30096` +- stdout: `F:\Projects\Epiphany\.epiphany-run\package-ea475aac.stdout.log` +- stderr: `F:\Projects\Epiphany\.epiphany-run\package-ea475aac.stderr.log` v22 is a preserved routing-deadlock witness: an explicitly selected corrective proposal could not preempt the failed verdict-incorporation route. Do not grind @@ -94,17 +110,17 @@ still unproven. ## Next action -Keep v23 live and v22 sealed as the deadlock witness. Poll PID `17136`; do not -start another Cargo build. Publish the authenticated `d849b17e` release into -the v23 local Verse, run its coordinator, and prove the already-admitted Eyes -frontier launches Research. Accept the first valid Eyes packet before choosing -another consequence. +Keep v23 live and v22 sealed as the deadlock witness. Poll PID `30096`; do not +start another Cargo build. Publish the authenticated `ea475aac` release into +the v23 local Verse, run its coordinator with no proposal override, and prove +the already-admitted challenged Eyes frontier launches Research. Accept the +first valid Eyes packet before choosing another consequence. ## Immediate re-entry 1. Run `cargo run --manifest-path .\epiphany-core\Cargo.toml --bin epiphany-state -- status`. 2. Read `state/map.yaml` and this handoff. -3. Confirm git HEAD, PID `17136`, and the d849b17e package logs. +3. Confirm git HEAD, PID `30096`, and the ea475aac package logs. 4. Treat v22 as evidence, not active authority. Replace this document when state changes. Old attempts belong in evidence and diff --git a/state/ledgers.msgpack b/state/ledgers.msgpack index b351093e6b62749b8584f9ffc1996f9435d00157..0ad9df7886b8db7686387af77ac8fcdf834e27c7 100644 GIT binary patch delta 590 zcmX|8J#Q015ao;kOSBY`Kx86XY+XJa$EJiJTp*=LMT6$<#&@Ia?H;pxHdnczphsBw z8%Pw0hLV3mL(LCh)-e=ME6u!__vY=NUk5*aAAH$M?jNVK@!^}Fw+7+i*C)xlBzgQ{ z)BCvTC5rgoR`eBj6n7Q(zHNGgx6Omk-;dIx(_wlxOedG=bQbqqW52(*?maqxk9mON z>|~l9P6&hyp(kkC%&@Ph0JH@dUJ~TaNx>F_6YznJQF3U-M$QU3ycA~xlU#^voJRu- zC5B1|(K^eyR?a)}u-NfNFkf5WP#)M>Xv8gbQ{;1?8kR1{tTiYdtkA2th%%pT2?3>~ z0J%Y~Z@Lv4L$=ffSqGL@Bx+7wu$t|LnJYS=B^P9K8o{M%ELePiHP?-ynry(W3AQ^O z(*fIxM6DF?N+VDQ|1=;oF27=1j^MegYYsqoG8rT0;Hg2uphvP@qA=RvXS?~B@W#+FgX7&r L`}V0!9PtGJ+>#Wd diff --git a/state/map.yaml b/state/map.yaml index afe5e1d8..632edffd 100644 --- a/state/map.yaml +++ b/state/map.yaml @@ -34,7 +34,7 @@ invariants: - Evidence and git retain history; this map retains only state that changes future decisions. current_status: - summary: Epiphany is a supervised engineering alpha on Starfire, not deployment-ready. Fresh v23 completed the typed proposal-to-Mind-to-Hands-to-Soul-to-Modeling circuit and then exposed two stale-authority faults at the next frontier: historical Soul evidence hijacked a new proposal launch, and Self treated an admitted Eyes frontier as if no frontier existed. Commit b27b8f41 proved proposal authority can preempt resolved verdict context in a live exact release. Commit d849b17e adds admitted Eyes frontier sensing and Research routing; its exact release is packaging on Starfire. Eyes acceptance, Imagination, Persona consequence, Continuity recovery, retention, long-duration pacing, and Linux/Yggdrasil cognition remain open. + summary: Epiphany is a supervised engineering alpha on Starfire, not deployment-ready. Fresh v23 completed the typed proposal-to-Mind-to-Hands-to-Soul-to-Modeling circuit, then proved proposal authority can preempt resolved Soul context at b27b8f41. The admitted read-only Eyes frontier exposed two Self routing faults: d849b17e added organ sensing but incorrectly inherited the Hands rule that challenged claims are unrouteable. Its exact live release correctly falsified that model. Commit ea475aac now preserves challenge blocking for Hands and Imagination while allowing Eyes to investigate challenged claims; its exact release is packaging on Starfire. Eyes acceptance, native Imagination intake, Persona consequence, Continuity recovery, retention, long-duration pacing, and Linux/Yggdrasil cognition remain open. operational_state: local_worktree: clean_at_pushed_2dd25341_before_state_refresh operator_wireguard: restored @@ -42,7 +42,7 @@ current_status: starfire: temporary_epiphany_cognition_body starfire_runtime_identity: epiphany-starfire starfire_swarm_brake: released - starfire_release: authenticated_b27b8f41_published_and_live_proven_d849b17e_packaging + starfire_release: authenticated_d849b17e_published_and_live_falsified_ea475aac_packaging starfire_repository_body: bound_and_observed starfire_verse_topology: bound_to_current_repository_body starfire_native_status: supervised_shakedown_active @@ -52,8 +52,8 @@ current_status: bifrost_feedback_crossing: authenticated_transport_only yggdrasil_epiphany_services: absent resident_physiology: heartbeat_and_self_running - unresolved_authority: v23 contains one Mind-admitted read-only Eyes frontier, but the exact d849b17e release has not yet completed packaging and live Research routing. Eyes remains unproven until that release launches Research from the admitted frontier and Mind accepts its evidence packet. Imagination has no native planning intake for this campaign; Persona consequence, Continuity crash/restart/closure, retention, long-duration behavior, and Linux/Yggdrasil cognition also remain open. - next_action: Poll PID 17136 and package-d849b17e logs without starting another build. Publish the authenticated d849b17e release into the v23 local Verse, run the exact coordinator, and prove it launches Research from the already-admitted Eyes frontier. Accept the first valid Eyes result, then inspect the next typed route. Preserve v22 and do not reopen either resolved verdict-incorporation path. + unresolved_authority: v23 contains one Mind-admitted read-only Eyes frontier whose target claim is challenged by newer repository-body evidence. Exact d849b17e live proof showed the first readiness implementation wrongly withheld Eyes alongside Hands. Commit ea475aac separates the invariants but has not yet completed exact packaging and live Research routing. Eyes remains unproven until that release launches Research and Mind accepts its evidence packet. Native Imagination intake, Persona consequence, Continuity crash/restart/closure, retention, long-duration behavior, and Linux/Yggdrasil cognition remain open. + next_action: Poll PID 30096 and package-ea475aac logs without starting another build. Publish the authenticated ea475aac release into the v23 local Verse, run its coordinator with no proposal override, and prove Self launches Research from the already-admitted challenged Eyes frontier. Accept the first valid Eyes result, then inspect the next typed route. Preserve v22 and do not reopen resolved verdict paths. active_subgoals: - Prove Persona, Self, Eyes, Modeling, Imagination, Hands, Soul, Mind, Continuity, and nervous-system behavior individually. @@ -63,8 +63,8 @@ active_subgoals: organ_readiness: persona: partial; authenticated feedback transport is live, but public cognition and speech consequence still need a fresh end-to-end proof. - self: partial; proposal recovery, Mind admission, Hands routing, Soul routing, verdict incorporation, and new-proposal preemption are live. Eyes frontier sensing and Research routing are implemented and fully tested at d849b17e but await exact live-release proof. - eyes: unproven in the current live circuit; Mind admitted a bounded read-only Eyes frontier, but exact d849b17e Research launch and accepted evidence remain pending. + self: partial; proposal recovery, Mind admission, Hands routing, Soul routing, verdict incorporation, and new-proposal preemption are live. Eyes challenge-aware Research routing is implemented and fully tested at ea475aac but awaits exact live-release proof. + eyes: unproven in the current live circuit; Mind admitted a bounded read-only frontier over a challenged claim. Exact d849b17e correctly failed because Self reused the Hands challenge rule; ea475aac Research launch and accepted evidence remain pending. modeling: proven for the current bounded circuit; proposal-bound source inspection, Mind admission, exact routed identity preservation, and first-valid verdict incorporation completed without retry churn. Broader Body-map coverage remains open. imagination: unproven in the current campaign; the planning substrate is empty. hands: proven for bounded consequences; native patch, command, commit, push, and typed receipts bind reviewed path ceilings to exact changed-path subsets.