Record Eyes challenge authority cut

notes/epiphany-current-algorithmic-map.md

@@ -372,6 +372,17 @@ runtime plus proposal identity, then binds it to the current Body/domain and
 the exact Imagination request/result/worker chain. Proposal schema is v3;
 Mind/runtime writable epochs are v7/v10.
 
+Exact `2dfd8c72` removes the producerless Eyes claim-challenge side channel.
+Eyes owned no terminal outcome that could create this document; its only
+producer was a test that fabricated both the evidence and the challenge. Eyes
+therefore cannot maintain a parallel status that suppresses Planning or Hands.
+Authenticated external evidence creates a Modeling obligation; Modeling then
+commits a fresh keyed node/frontier state through the normal exact-envelope
+transaction. Existing Planning and Hands passes still refuse when their exact
+claim/frontier envelopes change. Claim-obligation documents now contain only
+their real unresolved frontier identities (v3); Mind/runtime writable epochs
+are v8/v11.
+
 External lifecycle boundary: Idunn remains available when Epiphany is missing,
 failed, or braked. Epiphany's swarm brake is an input only to an Idunn
 transaction that changes Epiphany's deployed body; it cannot gate Idunn startup,

notes/fresh-workspace-handoff.md

@@ -1185,6 +1185,20 @@ Mind/runtime writable epochs are v7/v10. The broad lifecycle proof, epoch
 refusal, and coordinator compile pass. `runtime_spine.rs` is 10,500 lines.
 Resume the public runtime-spine/test-liability audit next.
 
+Exact `2dfd8c72` removes the producerless Eyes claim-challenge side channel.
+No live role result, interpreter, or admission owner could create it; one
+capstone fixture fabricated an Eyes packet and challenge, called the only
+writer, and then proved the gating it had manufactured. The contract, writer,
+registry row, validation/routing branches, `active_challenge_ids` cargo, and
+fixture-only packet inserter are gone: 465 net source deletions. Exact keyed
+claim/frontier envelopes still own stale-state refusal. External evidence must
+enter Modeling and change the keyed RepoModel rather than let Eyes separately
+decide Planning or Hands actionability. Claim-obligation documents are v3;
+Mind/runtime writable epochs are v8/v11. `runtime_spine.rs` is 10,216 lines,
+with 63 public functions and 29 public structs. The focused core check, keyed
+lifecycle proof, and epoch-refusal proof pass without warnings. Continue the
+public runtime-spine and test-liability audit.
+
 ## Competitive Eyes/Imagination pass
 
 `notes/munder-difflin-launch-intelligence-2026-08-23.md` distills the

state/map.yaml

@@ -52,7 +52,7 @@ current_status:
   summary: The keyed RepoModel hard cut, decision-context foundation, Model Atlas code slice, complete Body, Proposal, frontier-verdict Modeling, frontier Research, frontier Verification, frontier Planning/PlanMind, Reorientation, and Persona decision-context lifecycles are landed on codex/epiphany-shakedown-live. Keyed Mind plus exact runtime receipts own coordinator presence, work discovery, deterministic launch, job-bound continuation, review, typed failure, semantic admission, and retained decision reachability. Exact 07d891ba and ec1431ff delete the persisted/global thread aggregate and its generic coordinator/prompt/revision surfaces. Exact f7948795 deletes MindGatewayReview, MindStateCommitReceipt v0, the generic interpreter prompt, runtime registration/read APIs, false thought/state-effect/adoption CultNet mouths, and stale launch proof profiles. CultMesh now projects only reasoning basis, decision context, and exact Mind commit receipt, read-only. Exact 1c9aafd8 seals the terminal decision context before model-backed frontier-Planning failure and binds the typed failure plus generic job result to it. Exact e0e75a30 deletes the residual aggregate role patch/parser/policy surface, gives Research one closed typed decision, and deletes the unowned generic Imagination planning patch. Exact 12b1b285 makes runtime model/tool binding validation the shared owner for execution and decision sealing; hostile provider, receipt, and stored-binding substitutions refuse, while retained basis/context audit survives transcript-delta deletion. Exact 01602fd3 advances Mind/runtime to v2/v1 and refuses historical or split writable identity pairs before registered writers see them. Exact 26b6a5bf proves simultaneous disjoint Modeling writes, simultaneous Verification+Modeling admission, same-identity conflict, exact replay, and reopened graph assembly; raw mutation primitives are crate-private. Exact 7c2ebd81 moves Persona state-note admission from the legacy agent-memory aggregate into keyed Mind documents and proves a concrete Hands consequence can commit simultaneously. Exact 79c0e373 seals the assembled Persona input and observed source versions in Mind before inference. Exact d3300bba authenticates that input through its one exact Mind commit, refuses naked typed documents, re-enters without external observation or model inference, and proves current-work reconstruction is identical and read-only across Launch, Wait, completed, and post-Research boundaries. No compatibility reader, bootstrap aggregate, schema migrator, or dual reader survives. The source-level Decision-Auditable Concurrent Mind migration is accepted; the fresh exact-package capstone remains open. The machine remains a supervised engineering alpha; Model Atlas operational Gate 1 stays paused.
   public_positioning: docs/positioning.md is the current public claim owner. Epiphany is the organizational layer above frontier AI workers; global coherence collapse is the primary failure; prompts are bounded projections of governed organizational state; humans retain purpose, judgment, authority, disagreement, exceptions, and acceptance. GameCult is the forge and longitudinal evidence program for a target federation of one locally owned Epiphany project organism per living project Body. Model Atlas carries typed offers, claims, evidence, and derived technical relationships; Bifrost is the intended external work, membership, governance, attribution, and identity-linked receipt rail. Public Persona relationships and visitor surfaces are intended social infrastructure, while private Mind and consequence authority remain local. The fleet, real three-repository Gate 1, complete Bifrost attribution, sustained autonomous production, visitor experience, and external design-partner pilots remain gated alpha targets.
   competitive_launch_signal: The 2026-08-22 Munder Difflin launch analysis in notes/munder-difflin-launch-intelligence-2026-08-23.md is the current Eyes/Imagination owner for this category signal. It establishes strong demand to try a packaged, local, visual multi-agent control plane and supplies repeated qualitative demand for an operator-attention surface over plans, questions, blockers, decisions, consequences, and liveness; it does not establish retention, reliable autonomy, or paid product-market fit. Munder is materially ahead in installation, cross-platform reach, provider reuse, category compression, community formation, and feedback velocity. Its public failures make renderer-owned physiology, cross-Body restoration, proxy safety metrics, false consequence receipts, provider parity, and marketed-but-unavailable federation concrete falsification targets. Epiphany does not yet own a general operator UI: Persona projection into shared asynchronous chat is the concrete human surface, while CultMesh remains projection-neutral. Social Aquarium, a dense operator cockpit, TUI, and audit surfaces may use distinct Eve compositions over the same provider-owned facts. A one-hour projection experiment and managed continuity/federation remain evidence-led options rather than adopted roadmap authority; the source-subtraction and test-authority audit remains next.
-  latest_phase: The fresh-package Ox17 lane remains paused for source subtraction. Exact 856648de is the largest current cut: 32,866 net source lines, four binaries, one competing daemon-survival authority, and the entire unconsumed semantic/workspace projection stack are gone. Exact 6e600e8d removes the test-only user proposal mouth and the User/Persona/Bifrost source-kind fiction: only an exact admitted Imagination direction result plus its worker launch/result and autonomous binding can create proposal Modeling work. Exact 82f4733d removes the proposal's duplicated desired outcome, permanently empty scope hints, and copied timestamp. Exact 6fbd8184 removes repository/workspace/thread/runtime mirrors from inert proposal content; the atomic Modeling request owns those coordinates and the autonomous validator binds them back to exact Body/domain and Imagination provenance. Exact e7c1166b repairs the stale Body whitepaper; live code, manifests, scripts, and schemas contain no Rider or Unity integration authority. Brokkr owns Unity through Eve/CultMesh, and a future Rider daemon must own Rider. Native runtime, keyed Mind, Persona, direct Body-to-Modeling flow, exact provider requests, provider-owned Bifrost feedback, and Odin/Idunn deployment receipts remain. Mind/runtime writable epochs are v7/v10; old stores refuse with no migrator or dual reader. No Idunn build, package, deployment, or Ox root is authorized yet. Ox16 remains sealed historical evidence and must never resume.
+  latest_phase: The fresh-package Ox17 lane remains paused for source subtraction. Exact 856648de is the largest current cut: 32,866 net source lines, four binaries, one competing daemon-survival authority, and the entire unconsumed semantic/workspace projection stack are gone. Exact 6e600e8d removes the test-only user proposal mouth and the User/Persona/Bifrost source-kind fiction: only an exact admitted Imagination direction result plus its worker launch/result and autonomous binding can create proposal Modeling work. Exact 82f4733d removes the proposal's duplicated desired outcome, permanently empty scope hints, and copied timestamp. Exact 6fbd8184 removes repository/workspace/thread/runtime mirrors from inert proposal content; the atomic Modeling request owns those coordinates and the autonomous validator binds them back to exact Body/domain and Imagination provenance. Exact 2dfd8c72 deletes the test-only Eyes claim-challenge side channel: no live agent pass produced it, while one fixture manufactured the packet, challenge, writer call, and downstream gating. Eyes evidence must now enter Modeling and change the keyed model itself; it cannot separately decide Planning or Hands actionability. Exact e7c1166b repairs the stale Body whitepaper; live code, manifests, scripts, and schemas contain no Rider or Unity integration authority. Brokkr owns Unity through Eve/CultMesh, and a future Rider daemon must own Rider. Native runtime, keyed Mind, Persona, direct Body-to-Modeling flow, exact provider requests, provider-owned Bifrost feedback, and Odin/Idunn deployment receipts remain. Mind/runtime writable epochs are v8/v11; old stores refuse with no migrator or dual reader. No Idunn build, package, deployment, or Ox root is authorized yet. Ox16 remains sealed historical evidence and must never resume.
   supervisor_subtraction: Exact 856648de completes the supervisor deletion. Epiphany owns no local generic daemon supervisor, semantic projector service, workspace-coverage projector, Windows Task Scheduler integration, or service-policy/lifecycle/heartbeat/recovery mirror. Idunn on Yggdrasil owns source-triggered compilation, testing, packaging, deployment, signed health, and daemon survival. The canonical Epiphany brake gates Epiphany cognition and consequence authority, not Idunn startup or unrelated lifecycle.
   launch_dependency_cut: Exact 2aeab7a9 deletes the generic organ dependency matrix, generic receipt catalogue/proof profiles, persisted worker-launch cargo, Persona prompt injection, evaluator, and three self-certifying tests: 700 net lines. Family admission owners derive exact dependencies from typed state. Worker-launch schema v2 and Persona projector prompt v1 refuse the old writable shape. Core 378/378, OpenRouter runtime 27/27, packaged runtime 13/13, and Persona re-entry 1/1 pass.
   operator_surface_subtraction: Exact ef92e853 deletes the callerless view-lens registry, legacy acceptance-bundle builders, test-only raw-JSON result interpreters, and six tests: 797 net lines. Exact a292979d and 77e817c1 delete the duplicate CRRC recommendation algorithm, its unused input model, and four tests: 206 lines. Exact 3b94bf6e and 59c5e3a6 delete the nested duplicate status view, false auxiliary mode, and ignored status arguments. Exact 7c9b0cf3 deletes the fixed synthetic job table, role-board job cargo/mappers, and its test: 338 net lines. Exact 2ce91461 deletes the scene/planning Mind reconstructions, duplicate self-policy crate, unused prompt templates, four counterfeit schemas, and ten producer/source-text tests: 1,723 net lines. Exact 78836f3b deletes eight unconsumed status tableaux, the pressure calculator production only called without telemetry, its unreachable compaction action, one counterfeit schema, and six tests: 518 net lines. Exact f10f7fb3 deletes the final twelve epiphany.surface.* schemas and ten catalog entries after every one proved producerless and consumerless: 692 pure deletions. Exact ab3cacfb deletes thirty-one more producerless contracts, the false runtime-session mutation mouth, every Epiphany-owned Rider/Unity command schema, a callerless prompt-context module, its test-only specialist prompt system, and four self-affirming tests: 3,514 net lines. Exact 16d85b1b deletes six duplicate JSON-schema builder tests and two OpenAI-runtime self-source searches: 209 pure test-line deletions. Exact 06f93f70 deletes the test-only inverse OpenAI-to-native request mapper and makes two retained tests follow canonical native-to-provider derivation: sixty net lines. The local catalog now has twenty-three live or portable contracts. Brokkr owns Unity capabilities through CultMesh/Eve; a future Rider daemon owns Rider. Status retains Mind identity, exact current work, one action/reason decision, readable role lanes, and operator thought sealing. Core checks cleanly; retained provider and focused request-flow tests pass.
@@ -114,10 +114,10 @@ current_status:
     starfire_linux_modeling_peak: 109887488_bytes_resident_body_plus_modeling_circuit
     yggdrasil_epiphany_service_contract: idunn_source_change_owner_eve_and_local_typed_operator_surfaces_no_discord_control_plane
     resident_physiology: historical_c011_exact_465af24d_zero_zombie_proof_accepted_current_containers_exited_255
-  unresolved_authority: The local daemon-supervisor, semantic projector, workspace-coverage projector, generic event authority, Rider/Unity editor organs, and their false proofs are gone. `runtime_spine.rs` remains the largest central liability at 10,500 lines, 64 public functions, and 29 public structs; it still mixes immutable identity, sessions/jobs, process claims, model/tool execution binding, family request admission, consequence receipts, retention, and operator status. Continue splitting only by deleting callerless or duplicate authority; do not create family frameworks or adapters. The current gamecult-ops Epiphany unit has retired agent-store and daemon-id argv that its owning lane must fix before deployment. Fresh exact-package Ox17 and Model Atlas Gate 1 remain paused until subtraction closes. Bifrost remains Persona and governed external-consequence transport. Its Discord delivery path is a real consumer of Epiphany's short-lived request-bound permit signature, so the distinct permit identity/process is retained as an earned privilege boundary; current Ygg deployment doctrine still points that crossing at the old Starfire endpoint and installs no issuer unit, which the Idunn lane must repair before Persona consequence readiness. Historical c011 and partial Gate roots stay untouched/read-only.
-  next_action: Resume the public runtime-spine and test-liability audit after exact 6fbd8184. Trace each remaining public API and verifier to a live owner and consequential invariant; delete callerless mouths, checked mirrors, and tests of implementation spelling. Preserve immutable runtime identity, exact job/session terminality, decision contexts and failures, model/tool bindings and receipts, atomic Hands-to-Verification admission, conflict/replay, and retention fences. Do not run a local full-workspace compile, package, deployment, or Ox root.
+  unresolved_authority: The local daemon-supervisor, semantic projector, workspace-coverage projector, generic event authority, Rider/Unity editor organs, and their false proofs are gone. `runtime_spine.rs` remains the largest central liability at 10,216 lines, 63 public functions, and 29 public structs; it still mixes immutable identity, sessions/jobs, process claims, model/tool execution binding, family request admission, consequence receipts, retention, and operator status. Continue splitting only by deleting callerless or duplicate authority; do not create family frameworks or adapters. The current gamecult-ops Epiphany unit has retired agent-store and daemon-id argv that its owning lane must fix before deployment. Fresh exact-package Ox17 and Model Atlas Gate 1 remain paused until subtraction closes. Bifrost remains Persona and governed external-consequence transport. Its Discord delivery path is a real consumer of Epiphany's short-lived request-bound permit signature, so the distinct permit identity/process is retained as an earned privilege boundary; current Ygg deployment doctrine still points that crossing at the old Starfire endpoint and installs no issuer unit, which the Idunn lane must repair before Persona consequence readiness. Historical c011 and partial Gate roots stay untouched/read-only.
+  next_action: Resume the public runtime-spine and test-liability audit after exact 2dfd8c72. Trace each remaining public API and verifier to a live owner and consequential invariant; delete callerless mouths, checked mirrors, and tests of implementation spelling. Preserve immutable runtime identity, exact job/session terminality, decision contexts and failures, model/tool bindings and receipts, atomic Hands-to-Verification admission, conflict/replay, and retention fences. Do not run a local full-workspace compile, package, deployment, or Ox root.
 
-  runtime_spine_surface_cut: Exact 25d4d1fa deletes twenty-four callerless public runtime readers, mutation wrappers, status projections, their exports, and the tool-invocation status DTO. It also deletes the entirely unconsumed Hands route-relinquishment writer, refusal receipt, Mind relinquishment receipt, schema registration, and validation branch. Exact 1fea7bde deletes the final callerless Hands-chain timestamp reader and demotes the chain summary to private commit cargo. Exact 40d00bc5 deletes the unconsumed detailed planning-eligibility tableau, its two DTOs, and its two public APIs; Hands and Imagination now share the existing actionable-frontier predicate. Exact ac6455c5 removes five dormant transaction-injection callbacks and demotes three archive actuators behind their retention owners without weakening snapshot/CAS fences. Exact 6e600e8d rebuilds the broad proposal/Hands/Persona lifecycle proof through real Imagination provenance, then deletes the generic proposal writer, selector, input DTO, four-way source enum, constant provenance/privacy/public-source fields, compatibility hash branch, and provider branch. Exact 82f4733d removes three more constant/copy-only proposal fields. Exact 6fbd8184 moves repository/workspace/thread/runtime coordinates out of inert proposal content and into their atomic Modeling request owner; autonomous validation derives that request identity from binding runtime plus proposal identity and checks it against Body/domain and Imagination provenance. Mind/runtime epochs are v7/v10. Proposal Modeling may recommend only Eyes or Imagination; Hands still requires adopted-plan authority. Across these cuts the spine falls to 10,500 lines, 64 public functions, and 29 public structs. Core, swarm, coordinator, epoch-refusal, proposal lifecycle, provider mapping, and strict-schema focused checks pass.
+  runtime_spine_surface_cut: Exact 25d4d1fa deletes twenty-four callerless public runtime readers, mutation wrappers, status projections, their exports, and the tool-invocation status DTO. It also deletes the entirely unconsumed Hands route-relinquishment writer, refusal receipt, Mind relinquishment receipt, schema registration, and validation branch. Exact 1fea7bde deletes the final callerless Hands-chain timestamp reader and demotes the chain summary to private commit cargo. Exact 40d00bc5 deletes the unconsumed detailed planning-eligibility tableau, its two DTOs, and its two public APIs; Hands and Imagination now share the existing actionable-frontier predicate. Exact ac6455c5 removes five dormant transaction-injection callbacks and demotes three archive actuators behind their retention owners without weakening snapshot/CAS fences. Exact 6e600e8d rebuilds the broad proposal/Hands/Persona lifecycle proof through real Imagination provenance, then deletes the generic proposal writer, selector, input DTO, four-way source enum, constant provenance/privacy/public-source fields, compatibility hash branch, and provider branch. Exact 82f4733d removes three more constant/copy-only proposal fields. Exact 6fbd8184 moves repository/workspace/thread/runtime coordinates out of inert proposal content and into their atomic Modeling request owner; autonomous validation derives that request identity from binding runtime plus proposal identity and checks it against Body/domain and Imagination provenance. Exact 2dfd8c72 removes the producerless Eyes claim-challenge contract, writer, registry row, validation and routing branches, claim-obligation challenge vector, fixture-only packet inserter, and 76 lines of self-authored test scenario: 465 net source deletions. Exact keyed claim/frontier envelopes still own stale-state refusal; new external evidence must create a Modeling obligation and a fresh keyed model mutation rather than gate work through a parallel Eyes-owned status. Mind/runtime epochs are v8/v11 and claim-obligation documents are v3. Proposal Modeling may recommend only Eyes or Imagination; Hands still requires adopted-plan authority. Across these cuts the spine falls to 10,216 lines, 63 public functions, and 29 public structs. The focused core library check, broad keyed lifecycle proof, and epoch-refusal proof pass without warnings.
 
   runtime_event_cut: Exact 27fe11ae deletes persisted generic runtime events, their registry and CultNet contract, CLI/status surfaces, coordinator and lifecycle shadows, archival dependencies, and the obsolete legacy coordinator repair path. Exact d66baa27, 058751fb, and 573ddc8b first removed provider-event duplication, the arbitrary event writer, and paired lifecycle events. Runtime session/job state plus exact typed results, failures, coordinator run receipts, and coordinator death recoveries solely own terminal facts. Events cannot route work, authenticate terminality, or resurrect authority because no runtime-event document remains.
 

state/scratch.md

@@ -146,7 +146,14 @@ and janitors may reduce the symptom but cannot substitute for deleting code.
    autonomous validation derives that request from binding runtime plus proposal
    identity and checks it against exact Body/domain and Imagination provenance.
    Mind/runtime epochs are v7/v10.
-26. Next: resume the public runtime-spine and test-liability audit by live owner
+26. Done: exact `2dfd8c72` deletes the test-only Eyes claim-challenge side
+   channel. No live agent pass produced it; one fixture authored both evidence
+   and challenge, then invoked the sole writer and asserted its own gating.
+   Exact keyed claim/frontier envelopes still refuse stale Planning and Hands
+   admission. External evidence must now flow into Modeling and change the
+   keyed model itself. The cut removes 465 net source lines; Mind/runtime are
+   v8/v11 and claim-obligation documents are v3.
+27. Next: resume the public runtime-spine and test-liability audit by live owner
    and consequential invariant.
-27. Run focused tests after each cut. Only after source subtraction stabilizes
+28. Run focused tests after each cut. Only after source subtraction stabilizes
    should Idunn's build scratch contract be reconsidered.