Add model verdict gate for repo closure
This commit is contained in:
parent
3fb2f04ded
commit
80cf753d58
6 changed files with 570 additions and 29 deletions
|
|
@ -659,10 +659,15 @@ sealed under `.epiphany/work/`. Closure also writes a structured
|
|||
`.epiphany/work/work-close-<item>-review.json`, recording the verification
|
||||
command/exit code, declared Hands paths, actual git commit paths, commit stat,
|
||||
optional model-review provenance from `--closure-model-ref` / `--model-authored`,
|
||||
safe-family assertions for known Imagination families, and authority seals. Soul
|
||||
passes only when the verification command succeeds, actual git changed paths
|
||||
match the Hands-declared path scope, and the committed target content satisfies
|
||||
the deterministic safe-family assertions when the plan family is known. Soul
|
||||
optional hard model closure verdicts from `--closure-model-verdict`, safe-family
|
||||
assertions for known Imagination families, and authority seals. Soul passes only
|
||||
when the verification command succeeds, actual git changed paths match the
|
||||
Hands-declared path scope, the committed target content satisfies the
|
||||
deterministic safe-family assertions when the plan family is known, and any
|
||||
supplied or required model-authored closure verdict passes.
|
||||
`--require-closure-model-verdict` turns missing model verdicts into a closure
|
||||
refusal; without that flag, older provenance-only model refs remain
|
||||
compatibility evidence instead of a hard gate. Soul
|
||||
then writes `epiphany.soul.verdict_receipt`, Modeling records the
|
||||
execution/commit/closure-review summary, and Mind writes gateway review plus
|
||||
state-commit receipts into runtime-spine. The final
|
||||
|
|
@ -713,6 +718,18 @@ Soul `failed`, `familyAssertions.status=failed`, and failed assertions
|
|||
`status-section-summary-present`, and `status-section-private-seal`, with
|
||||
`privateStateExposed=false`.
|
||||
|
||||
A model-closure gate smoke proved the new source-grounded review tooth:
|
||||
`.epiphany-smoke\closure-model-gate-20260620-135103` created a disposable repo,
|
||||
ran `epiphany-repo init`, `epiphany-swarm online`, two `repo-status-section`
|
||||
items through accept -> derive-plan -> tick run/adopt/execute, then closed one
|
||||
item with `--require-closure-model-verdict --closure-model-verdict passed` and
|
||||
one with `--closure-model-verdict needs-work`. The pass item returned
|
||||
`closed` with `modelingReview.closureReview.status=passed` and
|
||||
`gateEnforced=true`. The blocked item returned `verification-failed`, Soul
|
||||
`failed`, `modelingReview.closureReview.status=failed`, while
|
||||
`familyAssertions.status=passed` and `pathScopeMatched=true`; private state
|
||||
remained sealed.
|
||||
|
||||
`epiphany-work overview` is the first compact repo work sight/proof surface:
|
||||
|
||||
```powershell
|
||||
|
|
@ -967,15 +984,16 @@ sync proof.
|
|||
`tick` now also proves brake refusal, active-turn refusal,
|
||||
completion-anchored cooldown refusal, and stale active-turn recovery through
|
||||
typed scheduler receipts; `serve` now proves bounded cadence around that same
|
||||
tick artery; `close` now proves first deterministic Soul/Modeling/Mind closure
|
||||
over Hands commit receipts; `derive-plan` now proves a deterministic
|
||||
tick artery; `close` now proves deterministic Soul/Modeling/Mind closure over
|
||||
Hands commit receipts plus an optional/required model-authored closure verdict
|
||||
gate; `derive-plan` now proves a deterministic
|
||||
Persona/Bifrost pressure-to-plan bridge with no operator-authored shell
|
||||
details; `overview` now proves compact local proof-bundle sight over the
|
||||
receipt chain; `queue-run` now proves that Self can select tick-actionable rows
|
||||
from the typed repo-work overview queue without reading private thought or
|
||||
taking publication/service authority. The chain does not yet prove fully
|
||||
model-authored Imagination planning, deeper model-authored Soul/Modeling
|
||||
closure, optional Idunn-hosted lifecycle for queue pulses, or richer published
|
||||
model-authored Imagination planning beyond allowlisted safe-family lowering,
|
||||
optional Idunn-hosted lifecycle for queue pulses, or richer published
|
||||
proof bundles.
|
||||
|
||||
The MVP target is narrower than the full Perfect Machine and wider than a demo:
|
||||
|
|
@ -1033,14 +1051,12 @@ No: the machine is not yet Epiphany Online in the full MVP sense. The remaining
|
|||
gap is not "more permission prompts." The remaining gap is to make the
|
||||
existing typed artery run as a living repo organism:
|
||||
|
||||
- deeper model-authored closure review beyond the first typed
|
||||
`epiphany.repo_work_closure_review.v0` packet
|
||||
- further non-planning action classes where Imagination can propose useful
|
||||
branch-local work beyond planning cargo without arbitrary shell authority
|
||||
- an Idunn-owned service lifecycle path for the queue-run pulse when the
|
||||
operator explicitly grants service mutation or elevated host authority
|
||||
- a repeatable fresh-repo acceptance smoke that proves the whole path without
|
||||
supervisor target-repo edits
|
||||
- richer model-authored planning depth beyond deterministic safe-family command
|
||||
lowering
|
||||
|
||||
The MVP is functional when a human can talk to the repo Persona, the swarm can
|
||||
turn that pressure into typed work, keep advancing lawful branch-local steps
|
||||
|
|
@ -1332,17 +1348,19 @@ Required organs before MVP:
|
|||
`section-note`, and `task-card` now prove richer model-authored planning cargo
|
||||
without operator shell details. `repo-status-section` now proves the first
|
||||
repo-visible non-planning safe family by updating a marker-bounded README
|
||||
status section with the same authority seals. Remaining work is richer closure
|
||||
depth and any later model-authored action classes that move beyond
|
||||
documentation/status cargo while preserving the same authority seals.
|
||||
status section with the same authority seals. Remaining work is later
|
||||
model-authored action classes that move beyond documentation/status cargo
|
||||
while preserving the same authority seals.
|
||||
- Closure depth: `close` now writes a structured
|
||||
`epiphany.repo_work_closure_review.v0` packet for Hands commits, records
|
||||
model-review provenance when supplied, refuses actual-vs-declared path-scope
|
||||
mismatch before Soul passes, runs committed-content assertions for known safe
|
||||
families, refuses assertion failures even when the path scope matches, and
|
||||
exposes the closure-review artifact through overview/export proof rows.
|
||||
Deeper model-authored Soul/Modeling review remains a later upgrade on top of
|
||||
this typed packet.
|
||||
families, refuses assertion failures even when the path scope matches, can
|
||||
require a model-authored closure verdict before Soul passes, and exposes the
|
||||
closure-review artifact through overview/export proof rows. The verdict packet
|
||||
records reviewed inputs, finding text, enforced/skipped gate state, and
|
||||
private-state seals; focused smoke proves a model `needs-work` verdict blocks
|
||||
closure even when path scope and safe-family assertions pass.
|
||||
- Repo work projection/run surface: local `epiphany-work overview` proof bundles, typed
|
||||
`epiphany.cultmesh.repo_work_overview.v0` event history plus latest-key
|
||||
projection, and Gjallar multi-item `repo-work-overview` action/readback rows
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
File diff suppressed because one or more lines are too long
Reference in a new issue