Cut false Body continuity authority

This commit is contained in:
Meta Vens 2026-07-15 21:17:59 +01:00
commit 645fcf38fe
7 changed files with 48 additions and 50 deletions

View file

@ -776,7 +776,7 @@ canonical Git root, object format, scope, and ignore policy; observe cannot mint
identity. Two disposable-index `read-tree`/`git add --all -- .`/
`write-tree` scans must agree. CultCache MessagePack persists immutable
generations and an exact-CAS current head; unchanged raw manifest preserves the
generation. `continuity_status` is always `unproven`; there is no Ready field.
generation. The observer makes no historical continuity claim and has no Ready field.
Sparse checkout fails closed, submodules are gitlink-only, and RepoModel/
retrieval/scheduler/Mind integration is absent. The CultCache store must remain
outside the observed worktree so observer writes cannot become observed input.
@ -797,21 +797,23 @@ Gitlinks remain nonrecursive. Unsafe or unrepresentable paths fail closed.
A truthful whole-repository readiness join does not yet exist. Mind must own a
derived `RepositoryReadinessProjection`; Body observation, Modeling, retrieval,
semantic projection, schedulers, watchers, jobs, and UI are forbidden writers.
Its required inputs are the current validated Body chain, a continuity receipt
covering that exact Body head, the canonical RepoModel plus its exact Mind
admission receipt, a RepoModel grounding receipt bound to that Body manifest,
Its required inputs are a fresh validated Body observation, the canonical
RepoModel plus its exact Mind admission receipt, a RepoModel grounding receipt
bound to that Body manifest,
the authenticated Modeling semantic projection receipt for that admitted model,
and exact workspace-retrieval coverage bound to the same Body manifest and a
named inclusion policy. Derivation must retry if any participating head advances.
The joined projection may report Missing, Pending/Unknown, Stale, or Ready with
exact evidence identities and mismatch reasons. It may report Ready only when
every binding agrees and coverage is complete. Two equal Body scans prove one
stable observation interval, not gap-free continuity. The current observer's
`continuity_status=unproven` therefore makes Ready structurally unavailable.
The join is a race-bounded operation: observe Body root R1, validate every exact
artifact against R1, then observe again and require R2=R1 before emitting an
`observed-ready-at` receipt whose truth interval ends at the second scan. Later
reads must revalidate rather than present it as timeless Ready. A→B→A is harmless
when all artifacts are content-addressed to A. Gap-free watcher or journal
continuity is not required and cannot prove truth after its own final event.
Legacy retrieval `Ready`, empty dirty paths, timestamps, watcher silence, Git
tree or HEAD OIDs, Qdrant existence, counts, and unrelated generations are not
substitutes. The lossy JSON workspace manifest remains cache metadata, not
substitutes. Watchers and Hands receipts may trigger recomputation but cannot
replace either Body observation. The lossy JSON workspace manifest remains cache metadata, not
coverage authority. Semantic-projector Ready remains exact query eligibility for
the admitted RepoModel projection; it does not prove repository Body coverage.