Enforce Soul verdicts for verification

This commit is contained in:
Meta Vens 2026-05-30 01:58:27 +01:00
commit 5e97e3464e
8 changed files with 180 additions and 11 deletions

View file

@ -34,7 +34,7 @@ remembers doctrine; the branch remembers the blade.
- Do not copy exact branch or HEAD from this note. Run `git status --short --branch` and `git log --oneline -5`.
- Canonical anatomy now lives in `notes/epiphany-anatomy.md`. Embodied sub-agents are Self, Face, Imagination, Eyes, Proprioception, Hands, and Soul. Body, Mind, Continuity, and Substrate Gate are substrate/state/protocol surfaces, not sub-agent identities. State is split by layer: `work_organ` for resident Epiphany sub-agents, `persona` for portable public/person-shaped state shared by Epiphany Face, VoidBot repo Faces, and Ghostlight characters, and heartbeat/swarm state for scheduling and coordination physiology. Persona state now carries provenance, required public presentation, `date-time` timestamps, typed `candidateActions`, strict anchored thoughts with non-authoritative extensions, custom enum companion labels, and typed affect records for bonds/status reads/doctrine stances.
- The repo now has a one-command local operator path: `.\tools\epiphany_local_run.ps1`. Default mode is `smoke`; it builds the retained Codex app-server compatibility edge, builds native Epiphany operator binaries, runs the coordinator smoke, and writes launcher artifacts under `.epiphany-run/` plus coordinator artifacts under `.epiphany-dogfood/`. `-Mode status` is now Epiphany-native: it builds only Epiphany operator binaries, reads `state/thread-state.msgpack` when present, derives status through `epiphany-core`, and does not start or require `codex-app-server`. Use `-Mode plan` or `-Mode run -MaxSteps 4` for the raw bridge-equipped coordinator entrypoints; use `-Mode mvp -FaceInput "<operator request>" -MaxSteps 4` for the local product cycle that projects Face's character turn, writes a Face/Aquarium bubble, bootstraps a minimal local checkpoint for fresh threads, runs the coordinator with auto-tools, then runs heartbeat sleep/dream maintenance. Live plan/run/mvp modes use the workspace `state/runtime-spine.msgpack`, because CodexThread launch writes worker requests there; the run bundle remains artifact evidence, not runtime lifecycle authority. Add `-ThreadId <id>` and `-Workspace <path>` to inspect or continue an existing thread. `status`, `plan`, and `smoke` do not spend model calls; `run` and `mvp` build and use `epiphany-openai-runtime`. Coordinator workers now launch detached and are polled through runtime-spine instead of blocking the coordinator. MVP runs are non-ephemeral by default so `-ThreadId <id>` can resume and poll later. `-MaxRuntimeSeconds <n>` is passed into worker runtime; timeout writes a failed worker receipt and exits. Failed modeling now blocks downstream verification until the failed result is reviewed.
- Current Mom-ready status: the normal MVP pass reaches Face -> coordinator -> detached runtime -> heartbeat sleep, and modeling workers now complete through the ChatGPT subscription transport. The first failure was a stack of violated observability/runtime invariants: worker prompts prepended the whole shared persistent-memory rite, Responses frame liveness was invisible until completion, and the runtime tried to persist hundreds of text deltas before completing the worker job. Role/reorient workers now get a compact Epiphany worker boundary instead of full persistent memory; runtime-spine records sampled raw Responses frame kinds with small previews; contiguous reasoning/text deltas compact before durable storage; and live proofs completed `2fe38dcd-d99e-4c73-9a58-afcc81f851c7`, `241e3851-e3ea-4877-a63b-0d2bbd96a7e2`, and `85149a26-6975-403f-ac93-092b717c5825` instead of timing out. The second failure was stale lifecycle authority: completed runtime jobs remained as unresolved `runtime_links`, replacement launches treated historical active links as current, and one bad validation path opened an orphan job before rejecting the state patch. Latest-link-wins is now the runtime-link invariant, terminal links project completed jobs, stale active history cannot veto replacement, launch validation happens before opening runtime jobs, and completed-but-unreviewable modeling findings stop for review instead of relaunching the same lane. The Eyes/source-gather fork is now landed: Research is a fixed Eyes lane with launch/result/accept/status/coordinator/protocol support, and `regather-needed` modeling findings route to `LaunchResearch` instead of relaunching blind Proprioception. Research statePatch admission is Eyes-shaped only: observations, evidence, scratch, and optional investigationCheckpoint; no graph, planning, objective, or checkpoint authority. Mind admission now leaves typed runtime-spine proof: role/reorient acceptance persists `epiphany.mind.gateway_review` before state admission and `epiphany.mind.state_commit_receipt` after admission with the resulting durable revision. Launch contracts now split the broad receipt catalogue from effect-specific proof profiles for state admission, evidence promotion, repo action, verification, and continuity recovery, so gates do not accidentally demand the whole organ catalogue for every finding. Acceptance evaluates claimed effects against the launch-carried profiles and rereads persisted receipts from runtime-spine. Research evidence promotion now enforces Substrate Gate read/snapshot grant, Eyes evidence packet, and Mind review before state admission. The next concrete rebuild layer is Soul verdict proof for Verification.
- Current Mom-ready status: the normal MVP pass reaches Face -> coordinator -> detached runtime -> heartbeat sleep, and modeling workers now complete through the ChatGPT subscription transport. The first failure was a stack of violated observability/runtime invariants: worker prompts prepended the whole shared persistent-memory rite, Responses frame liveness was invisible until completion, and the runtime tried to persist hundreds of text deltas before completing the worker job. Role/reorient workers now get a compact Epiphany worker boundary instead of full persistent memory; runtime-spine records sampled raw Responses frame kinds with small previews; contiguous reasoning/text deltas compact before durable storage; and live proofs completed `2fe38dcd-d99e-4c73-9a58-afcc81f851c7`, `241e3851-e3ea-4877-a63b-0d2bbd96a7e2`, and `85149a26-6975-403f-ac93-092b717c5825` instead of timing out. The second failure was stale lifecycle authority: completed runtime jobs remained as unresolved `runtime_links`, replacement launches treated historical active links as current, and one bad validation path opened an orphan job before rejecting the state patch. Latest-link-wins is now the runtime-link invariant, terminal links project completed jobs, stale active history cannot veto replacement, launch validation happens before opening runtime jobs, and completed-but-unreviewable modeling findings stop for review instead of relaunching the same lane. The Eyes/source-gather fork is now landed: Research is a fixed Eyes lane with launch/result/accept/status/coordinator/protocol support, and `regather-needed` modeling findings route to `LaunchResearch` instead of relaunching blind Proprioception. Research statePatch admission is Eyes-shaped only: observations, evidence, scratch, and optional investigationCheckpoint; no graph, planning, objective, or checkpoint authority. Mind admission now leaves typed runtime-spine proof: role/reorient acceptance persists `epiphany.mind.gateway_review` before state admission and `epiphany.mind.state_commit_receipt` after admission with the resulting durable revision. Launch contracts now split the broad receipt catalogue from effect-specific proof profiles for state admission, evidence promotion, repo action, verification, and continuity recovery. Research evidence promotion enforces Substrate Gate read/snapshot grant, Eyes evidence packet, and Mind review before state admission; Verification acceptance enforces Soul verdict and Mind review. The next concrete rebuild layer is Continuity recovery proof for reorient acceptance or Hands action proof once action lanes become live.
- Local operator runs now write typed CultMesh intent/receipt documents to `.epiphany-run/cultmesh/operator-runs.ccmp` through `epiphany-operator-run`. The wrapper writes intent before acting and a completion receipt after success; this is the local consent/trace rail, not a hidden scheduler queue.
- Status-mode local runs now also write a native CultMesh operator snapshot to `.epiphany-run/cultmesh/operator-snapshots.ccmp` through `epiphany-operator-snapshot`. That snapshot distills the operator-safe MVP status artifact into typed fields such as thread id, state status, coordinator action, CRRC action, reorient action, available actions, and artifact refs; it does not preserve the raw JSON status blob as internal state.
- `epiphany-mvp-status --source native` is the current provider-neutral status boundary. It projects scene, pressure, jobs, roles, planning, reorient, CRRC, coordinator status, and runtime-linked worker lifecycle from native core surfaces. It reads runtime-spine job/result receipts for linked jobs so failed workers show as failed in role results, jobs, roles, and coordinator source signals, while successful semantic findings still require typed role/reorient worker result documents. Keep future pluggable model-provider work behind launch/result/runtime documents; do not let provider choice leak into status, prompt authority, scheduler policy, or durable `EpiphanyThreadState`.
@ -1431,8 +1431,11 @@ after the review write. Research launch now emits a typed Substrate Gate
read/snapshot access grant, and Research acceptance emits, persists, rereads,
and enforces an `epiphany.eyes.evidence_packet` built from the accepted
Eyes-shaped statePatch. Research evidence promotion therefore has a live
Substrate Gate -> Eyes -> Mind proof chain. Other non-Mind profile gaps remain
deferred because those producers are not live yet.
Substrate Gate -> Eyes -> Mind proof chain. Verification acceptance now emits a
typed `epiphany.soul.verdict_receipt`, persists/rereads it through
runtime-spine, and enforces Soul verdict proof before Mind admits
verification-shaped state. Other non-Mind profile gaps remain deferred because
those producers are not live yet.
Mind review is now a persisted receipt chain for acceptance rather than an
in-memory blessing: the bridge writes `epiphany.mind.gateway_review` before
role/reorient state admission and `epiphany.mind.state_commit_receipt` after

View file

@ -141,10 +141,13 @@ resulting state revision. Research acceptance also emits a typed
persists it in runtime-spine, rereads it, and enforces Eyes packet proof for the
evidence-promotion profile. Research launches now also persist a typed
Substrate Gate read/snapshot access grant, and Research acceptance enforces that
grant before admitting evidence-shaped state. Remaining weakness: Hands, Soul,
and Continuity receipts are still mostly launch-carried expectations, not
enforced proof chains before state/action promotion, and the current Mind state
mutation plus post-commit receipt is not a single transaction yet.
grant before admitting evidence-shaped state. Verification acceptance emits a
typed `epiphany.soul.verdict_receipt`, persists/rereads it through
runtime-spine, and enforces Soul verdict proof before Mind admits
verification-shaped state. Remaining weakness: Hands and Continuity receipts are
still mostly launch-carried expectations, not enforced proof chains before
state/action promotion, and the current Mind state mutation plus post-commit
receipt is not a single transaction yet.
### 4. Self Still Shares A Throne With Compatibility Plumbing
@ -339,8 +342,10 @@ comfort tunnels.
- Landed: Research launches produce and enforce typed Substrate Gate
read/snapshot grants, closing the Research evidence-promotion chain through
Substrate Gate -> Eyes -> Mind.
- Next: add Soul verdict receipts for Verification findings, then make that
profile proof enforceable.
- Landed: Verification acceptance produces and enforces typed Soul verdict
receipts before Mind admission.
- Next: add Continuity recovery receipts for reorient acceptance or Hands action
receipts when action lanes become live.
- Make Aquarium read the contract catalog and available receipts instead of
hard-coding the route zoo.
- Starve `codex_message_processor` down to Codex auth/model transport and