diff --git a/notes/eureka-pipeline-state-cut.md b/notes/eureka-pipeline-state-cut.md index ed72ebaf..f28e2e7e 100644 --- a/notes/eureka-pipeline-state-cut.md +++ b/notes/eureka-pipeline-state-cut.md @@ -2357,9 +2357,9 @@ Huginn: +about 2,100 lines (store 120, mind 260, receipt 220, refusal 90, admiss ### Operator questions -- **Q13. Where do the batch and outcome types live for the client?** `eureka-state` (Cut 13) must construct `PipelineAdmissionBatch` and read `PipelineAdmissionOutcome`/`MindRefusal`, and the map says it does not depend on `huginn-mind` ("would invite a second validator", Cut 13). Cut 10 puts the wire types in the `huginn-daemon` *binary* crate, which a client cannot import either. Options: **A.** `eureka-state` depends on `huginn-mind` for types, with a negative grep that it never calls `open`, `admit` or `admit_prepared`; the graph cost is one package beyond what the leaf already brings (`redb` comes with the leaf regardless). **B.** A fourth crate `huginn-wire` holding only the request/response/outcome types; doctrine's "a named external consumer with a hard dependency boundary" argument (D1) applies weakly, since the boundary is a discipline a grep can pin. **C.** Put them in `epiphany-pipeline`; refused here because D6 already rules Huginn's transport contracts are Huginn's. **Recommended: A.** Cut 8 makes the types `pub` and `JsonSchema` so A or B both work; the choice is Cut 10/13's, but it should be ruled before Cut 10 writes `wire.rs` into a binary crate. +- **Q13. Where do the batch and outcome types live for the client?** `eureka-state` (Cut 13) must construct `PipelineAdmissionBatch` and read `PipelineAdmissionOutcome`/`MindRefusal`, and the map says it does not depend on `huginn-mind` ("would invite a second validator", Cut 13). Cut 10 puts the wire types in the `huginn-daemon` *binary* crate, which a client cannot import either. Options: **A.** `eureka-state` depends on `huginn-mind` for types, with a negative grep that it never calls `open`, `admit` or `admit_prepared`; the graph cost is one package beyond what the leaf already brings (`redb` comes with the leaf regardless). **B.** A fourth crate `huginn-wire` holding only the request/response/outcome types; doctrine's "a named external consumer with a hard dependency boundary" argument (D1) applies weakly, since the boundary is a discipline a grep can pin. **C.** Put them in `epiphany-pipeline`; refused here because D6 already rules Huginn's transport contracts are Huginn's. **Recommended: A.** Cut 8 makes the types `pub` and `JsonSchema` so A or B both work; the choice is Cut 10/13's, but it should be ruled before Cut 10 writes `wire.rs` into a binary crate. **Ruled A, 2026-09-16** ("I'll take your recommendations"). Cut 13's "no dependency on `huginn-mind`" becomes "depends on it for types only, with a negative grep that it never calls `open`, `admit` or `admit_prepared`"; Cut 10's `wire.rs` moves out of the binary crate accordingly when Cut 10 is refreshed. - **Q14. How does Huginn run the mutation harness?** **A.** Add `-Repo` (default: the harness's own parent) to `tools/eureka-mutations.ps1` in Epiphany, about four lines, and keep one harness; Huginn holds only its entries file and its verification names Epiphany's path. **B.** Copy the harness into Huginn: a second copy of a 19 KB script the operator will notice, one bug away from two behaviours. **C.** Move the harness to the Eureka skill repo (`GameCult/Eureka`), the owner of cross-repo Eureka tooling, and point both repos at `~/.claude/skills/eureka/tools/`: coherent, three repos touched, and Cut 15 ("Skill wiring") is its natural home. **Recommended: A now, C in Cut 15.** *Taken as a default by Self, 2026-09-16: not a product fork.* -- **Q15. `mind.redb`, not `mind.cc`.** D3 wrote `mind.cc`; `F:\Projects\CLAUDE.md` says "all state should be CultCache `.cc` files". A redb-backed CultCache store is CultCache state in a different container, and the extension is what Epiphany's backend selector and CultCache Studio key on. **Recommended: `mind.redb`**, and the doctrine sentence reads "CultCache state", which this is. If the operator wants `.cc` literally, the cost is Epiphany's selector convention and Studio misreading the file, both real. +- **Q15. `mind.redb`, not `mind.cc`.** D3 wrote `mind.cc`; `F:\Projects\CLAUDE.md` says "all state should be CultCache `.cc` files". A redb-backed CultCache store is CultCache state in a different container, and the extension is what Epiphany's backend selector and CultCache Studio key on. **Recommended: `mind.redb`**, and the doctrine sentence reads "CultCache state", which this is. If the operator wants `.cc` literally, the cost is Epiphany's selector convention and Studio misreading the file, both real. **Ruled `mind.redb`, 2026-09-16.** The operator asked how redb got in: it entered Epiphany's runtime spine as the keyed backing store on 2026-08-08 (`5d6a7316`) and CultLib with the return of the Rust CultCache engine on 2026-09-03 (`b672fb7`); it is CultCache's own embedded keyed backend at the shared pin, not a dependency this campaign added. - **Q16 (carried, not new). Q6/ruling 18 stands:** identity is declared. This spec builds no credential path; `ForeignInstance` is collision and attribution control (D8). *Not a question: ruling 18 is in force and nothing here reopens it. Left as written so the reader sees it was checked.* ### Findings not assignable to a cut