Close canonical RepoModel organ loop
This commit is contained in:
parent
995d783fd3
commit
0c90e4471d
28 changed files with 4070 additions and 278 deletions
|
|
@ -27,6 +27,14 @@ roadmap mythology, and Self preserved dependency order without flattening those
|
|||
different judgments into one running narrative. This is positive evidence for
|
||||
durable organ-to-organ cognition, not merely for role-flavored prompting.
|
||||
|
||||
Do not substitute the first linear frontier identity proof for that larger
|
||||
lesson. `Modeling -> Mind -> Self -> Hands -> Soul -> Modeling` proves that one
|
||||
wound can retain causal identity. The awakened anatomy also needs typed backward
|
||||
pressure: Eyes findings that challenge model claims, Imagination revisions that
|
||||
change campaign shape, Soul rejections that create new evidence requirements,
|
||||
and Self rerouting based on those admitted artifacts. Modeling is the shared
|
||||
situational substrate, not the whole organism and not the product.
|
||||
|
||||
Persistence is the connective-tissue gap exposed by that success. Modeling's
|
||||
repo anatomy, confirmed/changed/invalidated claims, freshness, frontier, and
|
||||
semantic-index consequences must live in typed searchable state; Self must route
|
||||
|
|
@ -44,14 +52,44 @@ or lost to concurrent valid patches: CultCache now provides exact-envelope CAS
|
|||
and insert-if-absent beneath its cross-process sidecar lock, with hostile race
|
||||
proofs. Soul rejected two earlier cuts before accepting this authority boundary.
|
||||
|
||||
Do not call this the complete Aetheria loop. Modeling worker output still cannot
|
||||
carry a reviewed `RepoModelPatch`; Mind has no model-admission receipt binding
|
||||
patch/result/evidence; Self does not select and bind one frontier identity into a
|
||||
Hands grant; Hands consequences and Soul verdicts do not yet carry that same
|
||||
model revision/hash/item identity; and Modeling therefore cannot close exactly
|
||||
the wound Soul judged. The next cut is that closed identity chain, not more index
|
||||
polish: `Modeling patch -> Mind admission -> Self route F -> Hands consequence F
|
||||
-> Soul verdict F -> Modeling resolves F`.
|
||||
The first causal-identity slice of that Aetheria loop is now closed. Modeling
|
||||
emits a typed `RepoModelPatch`; Mind admits the exact immutable worker result,
|
||||
patch bytes, evidence, review, and replacement model under one conditional
|
||||
store transaction; Self selects one eligible Active frontier item from the
|
||||
admitted current model; and the resulting route freezes model revision/hash,
|
||||
item hash, claims, dependency order, and path scope. Hands intent, review,
|
||||
Substrate grant, frontier authority, patch, command, and commit documents are
|
||||
immutable insert-once records. Soul receives a typed verification request bound
|
||||
to that complete chain. A later typed Modeling request binds the accepted Soul
|
||||
result and permits exactly one verdict-incorporation revision of the same item:
|
||||
`pass` yields `Resolved`; `needs-review`, `needs-evidence`, or `fail` yields
|
||||
`Blocked`. Self derives Hands readiness from the same selection predicate, so
|
||||
Blocked/Resolved items cannot be routed and no default implementation authority
|
||||
survives without an admitted actionable frontier.
|
||||
|
||||
Soul found and forced cuts of four plausible green bypasses before accepting
|
||||
the slice: ordinary Evolution could mutate routed frontier lifecycle; Hands
|
||||
receipts and their intent/review/grant foundation were mutable by identity; the
|
||||
Modeling request trusted caller-supplied temporal acceptance; and a split model
|
||||
admission/thread-state commit could wedge on retry. Evolution is now barred
|
||||
while a current-model route exists and cannot manufacture Blocked or terminal
|
||||
frontier lifecycle. Every causal companion uses absent-only cross-process CAS
|
||||
with exact retry. Final verdict admission replays the full authority and
|
||||
consequence chain immediately before the model CAS. Verification acceptance is
|
||||
reloaded from canonical thread state, and stable review identity makes the
|
||||
split commit recoverable. Hostile substitution, stale-model, counterfeit,
|
||||
concurrent-writer, crash-window retry, pass/nonpass, and nonselection tests are
|
||||
green; the full core library proof is 303 passed and 1 ignored.
|
||||
|
||||
This is still not the whole Aetheria lesson. It proves durable causal identity
|
||||
and backward Soul pressure, not the complete multi-organ correction ecology.
|
||||
Eyes challenges and Imagination campaign revisions still need typed admission
|
||||
and Self routes. The older `RepoWorkModelingRequest/Route/Finding` path is also
|
||||
misnamed parallel closure machinery: it models one already-executed work item,
|
||||
not repository anatomy. Preserve useful plan/execute receipts, but converge
|
||||
that workflow on canonical RepoFrontier route/Hands/Soul/Modeling authority and
|
||||
demote `RepoWorkMapEntry` to derived closure history. Do not let item-slug routes
|
||||
or the legacy special Modeling worker close work independently of RepoModel.
|
||||
|
||||
The next artifact-contract audit then cut `epiphany.persona_chat.v0`: its live
|
||||
writer and catalog had disagreed on field vocabulary, evidence fields, and
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
91
notes/repo-frontier-organ-loop.md
Normal file
91
notes/repo-frontier-organ-loop.md
Normal file
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,91 @@
|
|||
# Repo Frontier Organ Loop
|
||||
|
||||
## Objective
|
||||
|
||||
Preserve the Aetheria-shaped engineering loop as typed causal identity, not as
|
||||
coordinator memory or prompt roleplay. One repository wound must remain the same
|
||||
wound while Modeling describes it, Mind admits it, Self routes it, Hands acts on
|
||||
it, Soul judges it, and Modeling closes or revises it.
|
||||
|
||||
This closed route is the first proof slice, not the whole Aetheria lesson. The
|
||||
larger success was corrective circulation between distinct organs: Eyes could
|
||||
invalidate substrate assumptions, Imagination could revise campaign shape, Soul
|
||||
could reject a locally green implementation, and Self could reorder work from
|
||||
those durable artifacts. RepoModel is connective tissue for that cognition; it
|
||||
is not a substitute for it. Later slices must admit typed challenges and plan
|
||||
revisions from those organs without giving any of them direct model-write
|
||||
authority.
|
||||
|
||||
## Authority Map
|
||||
|
||||
- Owner: the canonical `RepoModel` entry inside the runtime-spine CultCache.
|
||||
- Inputs: immutable Modeling worker result, exact patch bytes and base model
|
||||
identity, accepted evidence, and—when resolving work—the exact frontier route,
|
||||
Hands consequence chain, and Soul verdict.
|
||||
- Outputs: a replacement model plus immutable specialized Mind review and model
|
||||
admission receipt committed in one conditional batch.
|
||||
- Derived state: thread-state graphs/frontier/checkpoint are continuity and UI
|
||||
projections; semantic indexes rank eligible typed claims; prompt context and
|
||||
gate JSON explain admitted authority but never create it.
|
||||
- Forbidden writers: sibling-store refresh, generic Modeling `statePatch`
|
||||
anatomy, coordinator reason strings, `frontierNodeIds`, evidence-id prefix
|
||||
matching, and dashboard/operator projections.
|
||||
- Shared path: `Modeling patch -> Mind admission -> Self route F -> Hands intent
|
||||
and consequence F -> Soul request and verdict F -> Modeling resolves F`.
|
||||
- Deletion line: remove sibling `memory-graph.msgpack` as a live authority after
|
||||
one explicit import; remove Modeling graph/frontier writes from generic role
|
||||
acceptance; refuse `ContinueImplementation` without an admitted current route;
|
||||
replace prefix-based Hands-chain inference with typed reload and validation.
|
||||
|
||||
## Atomic Boundaries
|
||||
|
||||
1. Modeling result is immutable worker evidence.
|
||||
2. Exact current-model compare-and-swap plus specialized Mind review and model
|
||||
admission receipt is one runtime-spine store transaction.
|
||||
3. Self route insertion verifies the same current model and frontier item under
|
||||
the conditional store lock.
|
||||
4. Hands preflight verifies current route before consequence; immutable receipts
|
||||
preserve historical truth afterward.
|
||||
5. Soul request binds one complete typed Hands chain; accepted verdict binds that
|
||||
request and route.
|
||||
6. Resolution admission validates the same route and verdict before replacing the
|
||||
model and making the frontier ineligible for subsequent selection.
|
||||
|
||||
## Invariants
|
||||
|
||||
- No model effect exists without its admission receipt in the same snapshot.
|
||||
- No admission receipt can claim a model revision/hash absent from that snapshot.
|
||||
- A route freezes model revision/hash, frontier item hash, target claims, source
|
||||
scope, and selected organ.
|
||||
- Hands cannot act from prompt prose or gate JSON; it requires the persisted route.
|
||||
- Soul cannot judge a substituted or partial Hands chain.
|
||||
- A resolution patch can affect only the routed frontier item in the first closed
|
||||
loop slice.
|
||||
- Once F is resolved, retired, or superseded, Self cannot select F again.
|
||||
|
||||
## Landed Causal Slice
|
||||
|
||||
1. Conditional atomic batches and absent-only insertions protect the single-file
|
||||
CultCache store under its cross-process lock.
|
||||
2. Runtime-spine owns the imported canonical RepoModel and specialized Modeling
|
||||
result plus Mind admission documents.
|
||||
3. Self selects an eligible frontier item and binds the main-agent Hands gate to
|
||||
an immutable route; no actionable route means no Hands authority.
|
||||
4. Immutable Substrate, Hands, Soul verification, and Modeling request documents
|
||||
preserve exact causal identity. Final admission replays the complete chain.
|
||||
5. Verdict incorporation changes exactly the routed frontier item. Pass resolves;
|
||||
nonpass blocks. Hostile substitution, concurrent identity, stale model,
|
||||
split-retry, and terminal nonselection proofs pass, and independent Soul review
|
||||
accepts this slice.
|
||||
|
||||
## Next Deletion Line
|
||||
|
||||
`RepoWorkModelingRequest`, `RepoWorkModelingRoute`, and
|
||||
`RepoWorkModelingFinding` describe post-execution workflow closure, not repository
|
||||
anatomy. Their item-slug route and `RepoWorkMapEntry` closure ledger must not
|
||||
remain a second Modeling/Self/Mind truth. Preserve useful repo-work planning and
|
||||
execution receipts only behind canonical `RepoFrontierRoute` and
|
||||
`RepoFrontierHandsAuthority`; use the canonical Hands/Soul/verdict-incorporation
|
||||
path; demote the old map to derived closure history or delete it. After that,
|
||||
admit typed Eyes challenges and Imagination campaign revisions so blocked
|
||||
frontier pressure can circulate to the correct organ.
|
||||
Reference in a new issue