diff --git a/docs/soundscape-grammar.md b/docs/soundscape-grammar.md index 5f27cb2..a6cdfd0 100644 --- a/docs/soundscape-grammar.md +++ b/docs/soundscape-grammar.md @@ -13,24 +13,19 @@ grammar is drafted without them. Each is a place to reconcile before the doc is treated as in force. - `heimdall-body:follow_up:ratatoskr-creature-projection-v2`: `huginn view` - from instance `aqua` still answers `absent` (re-checked 2026-11-02; `absent` from Eureka's mind on 2026-11-05), and a + from instance `aqua` still answers `absent` (re-checked 2026-11-02; `absent` from Eureka's mind on 2026-11-05, `absent` from aqua again on 2026-11-14), and a search of the Heimdall checkout found no file mentioning it. Section 2 takes its constraints as relayed in `aqua-body:follow_up:chat-s946-948`: rule O1 (a Neutral participant gets no orbit and no voice), the `estate` split, coarse size buckets with a separate neutral flag, activity fed by the Heimdall session. Section 2 must be reconciled against that follow-up's actual field list once it can be read. -- `ratatoskr:follow_up:symphony-grammar-harvest-mimir` (Mimir birdsong - research): absent from aqua's mind, but it is in force in Eureka's mind - (read 2026-11-05, after this draft was written). It points at Mimir's - `docs/bioacoustic-timeline-watermark.md`, `research/bioacoustic-contestants-2026-05-24.md` - and `calibration/bioacoustic/` (at `c6f4541`), which this draft does not cite - and nobody has read for it. The earlier grep of `GameCult/Mimir` for a - symphony or voice-separation note found none; it did not look for bioacoustic research. - Section 4 is therefore built from this repo's own `research/syrinx-modeling` - plus the general auditory-scene-analysis and acoustic-niche literature named - there, *recalled, not re-read for this draft*. The harvest is still owed and - is the likeliest thing to change section 4. +- The Mimir harvest (`ratatoskr:follow_up:symphony-grammar-harvest-mimir`) is now + readable: [`docs/gamecult/symphony-grammar-harvest.md` in GameCult/Ratatoskr at + `0b3e2294`](https://eureka.gamecult.org/forge/GameCult/Ratatoskr/src/commit/0b3e2294/docs/gamecult/symphony-grammar-harvest.md) + (Void's read of GameCult/Mimir at `c6f4541`; merged without a Soul pass), as + checked by Kiko (`kiko-body:resolution:follow_up.chat-s8018-8019.n1`). Section 4.1 + reconciles against both. The first draft of section 4 predates them. Context actually read: `docs/gamecult/ratatoskr-target.md` in `GameCult/Ratatoskr` at `b33d8de` (the agreement that one activity vocabulary drives both sound and @@ -160,7 +155,7 @@ in every state; what it does changes. ## 4. Keeping voices distinct when mixed Principle, from the acoustic-niche and auditory-scene-analysis literature -(recalled, to be confirmed by the Mimir harvest): voices that share a niche in +(recalled; the Mimir harvest gives it no support or contradiction, see 4.1): voices that share a niche in frequency, time and space mask each other; voices that differ on several independent axes stay separable even at high density. Assign each Mind a distinct **niche** on independent axes, and make the scheduler protect those @@ -202,6 +197,56 @@ Rules: accepted until a listener-identification trial passes (the existing notification ledger requires the same). That trial has not happened. +### 4.1 Reconciled against the Mimir harvest + +Read: the harvest at `0b3e2294` (linked in section 0; not copied here) and Kiko's +correction of it, `kiko-body:resolution:follow_up.chat-s8018-8019.n1`, relayed to +Aqua in #minds (the resolution itself is not in aqua's mind, so its wording is +not quoted). Kiko checked the harvest read-only: most numbers hold, four claims +are overstated. Kiko's row numbers are as relayed; the harvest's table in that +file has twelve rows, so rows 22 and 28 cannot be found by number there, and +the claims are cited below by what they say. + +What the corrections change here: + +- **The six-syllable packet song is Aqua's design choice, not Mimir's result.** + The harvest's "best contestant" claim (canary-packet-trill, row 5) is + confidence B, a hypothesis; Mimir's production word is the four-syllable, + 118 ms word. If this grammar adopts a six-syllable packet song, it does so by + its own choice at confidence B, and it is a thing to try in the listener trial, + not a measured recommendation. Nothing in section 4 depends on it. +- **Do not rest a niche on Mimir's identity figure.** Row 4's 0.908-0.997 is a + clean-roundtrip figure; under degradation Kiko reads 0.5-0.9. Rows 6 and 28 + are confounded, so the "too-short songs collapse" thresholds are not a + design floor for this grammar. +- **A word identifies an event slot, not a source** (row 22). Mimir's evidence + does not support "the instrument says who spoke" (V1, axis 2). That stays a + design rule of this grammar, to be tested by V6, with no Mimir backing. +- **No harmony evidence exists.** Mimir emits one low-gain song at a time and + tests no simultaneous voices, intervals, consonance or masking between + concurrent songs. V3 (voice cap), V4 (collision backoff) and V5 are Aqua's + design and rest on the recalled auditory-scene-analysis literature alone. +- **No pleasantness evidence exists.** Mimir's score is decodability by a machine + decoder against a known schedule; its gain was chosen for low audibility. Whether + any song, harmony or niche table is pleasant or distinguishable to a person is + unmeasured. **A listener trial is owed** (V6, section 7) and has not happened; + nothing here is heard. + +What the harvest does support, as design constraints already in this section's +spirit and still unmeasured for people: identity carried redundantly across +several channels at once, no sequence grammar for identity, irregular rather +than ladder-like rhythm, a deterministic generator authored once and rendered +(S4 already says the client ships rendered assets). Its open question "which +dimension bends with activity" is what section 3's rule answers by design: +`mind` selects identity, `kind` behaviour, `energy` amount, so a Mind keeps one +timbre and root for life and the contour and density move; Mimir has no activity +channel to confirm that. + +The **human `kind` subset** (`Idle`, `Working`, `Speaking`, section 2) is not +touched by the harvest: Mimir carries no activity or privacy channel at all, so +the subset still rests only on the projection-v2 follow-up, which remains +unreadable from aqua (below). + ## 5. Timing, staleness and the callback deadline Hard rule: **the audio callback deadline wins over everything in this @@ -254,7 +299,7 @@ None run. To be done before the grammar leaves draft: 1. Reconcile section 2 with `heimdall-body:follow_up:ratatoskr-creature-projection-v2` (field list, the human `kind` subset in section 2, the size and neutral fields, the stripping of `kind`, `energy` and `size` under `neutral`). -2. Reconcile section 4 with the Mimir harvest. +2. ~~Reconcile section 4 with the Mimir harvest.~~ Done in 4.1 (docs only; no listening). What the harvest could not give (harmony, pleasantness, discriminability by a person) goes to item 5. 3. Round-trip the frame as a CultCache document and check the size claim (one byte per state, 28 states). 4. Measure voice cap, density ceilings and scheduler cost on a real phone. @@ -262,5 +307,5 @@ None run. To be done before the grammar leaves draft: ## 8. Status -Draft. Not implemented. No code changed. No audio was produced and none is +Draft, reconciled with the Mimir harvest on 2026-11-14 (4.1); section 2 still awaits projection-v2. Not implemented. No code changed. No audio was produced and none is claimed.