voice-source-1: measured figures re-taken on main with PR #52 (renders redone; band energies noted as pre-fix)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Aqua 2026-11-13 23:02:41 +00:00
commit 51084c3059

View file

@ -10,7 +10,7 @@
"file": "saw_a.wav",
"group": "pulse",
"pair": "pulse-rosenberg",
"title": "Measured: HNR 29.9 dB, output rms 0.0530, peak 0.224. Scaffold source: band-limited saw through the tilt lowpass.",
"title": "Measured: HNR 30.3 dB, output rms 0.0537, peak 0.227. Scaffold source: band-limited saw through the tilt lowpass.",
"feel": "the short made-up phrase 'ah-mee' in a synthetic voice; listen to the voice itself (buzz, edge, breath), not the words"
},
{
@ -18,7 +18,7 @@
"file": "ros.wav",
"group": "pulse",
"pair": "pulse-saw",
"title": "Measured: HNR 29.1 dB, output rms 0.0400 (-2.4 dB re saw), peak 0.102 (-6.8 dB). Band energy re total, 0-0.5/0.5-1.5/1.5-3/3-6 kHz: saw -2.3/-4.0/-24.0/-24.9 dB, Rosenberg -0.3/-12.4/-43.7/-40.3 dB. PREDICTION: darker and rounder than the saw, less buzz and edge, F2 of /i/ weaker; loudness the same (that last part is already falsified at the output: it is 2.4 dB quieter). FALSIFIED if no difference is heard, if it is heard as buzzier or brighter, or if it is heard as the same kazoo quality.",
"title": "Measured: HNR 29.5 dB, output rms 0.0401 (-2.5 dB re saw), peak 0.102 (-6.9 dB). Band energy re total, 0-0.5/0.5-1.5/1.5-3/3-6 kHz, from the render before the tract fix (a different FFT estimate on the new render differs by under 1 dB; not re-measured with the original method): saw -2.3/-4.0/-24.0/-24.9 dB, Rosenberg -0.3/-12.4/-43.7/-40.3 dB. PREDICTION: darker and rounder than the saw, less buzz and edge, F2 of /i/ weaker; loudness the same (that last part is already falsified at the output: it is 2.5 dB quieter). FALSIFIED if no difference is heard, if it is heard as buzzier or brighter, or if it is heard as the same kazoo quality.",
"feel": "the short made-up phrase 'ah-mee' in a synthetic voice; listen to the voice itself (buzz, edge, breath), not the words"
},
{
@ -26,7 +26,7 @@
"file": "saw_b.wav",
"group": "pulsematch",
"pair": "pulsematch-rosenberg",
"title": "Measured: HNR 29.9 dB, output rms 0.0530, peak 0.224. Byte copy of pulse-saw's render.",
"title": "Measured: HNR 30.3 dB, output rms 0.0537, peak 0.227. Byte copy of pulse-saw's render.",
"feel": "the short made-up phrase 'ah-mee' in a synthetic voice; listen to the voice itself (buzz, edge, breath), not the words"
},
{
@ -34,7 +34,7 @@
"file": "ros_matched.wav",
"group": "pulsematch",
"pair": "pulsematch-saw",
"title": "Measured: HNR 29.1 dB, output rms 0.0529 (matched to the saw), peak 0.135. The Rosenberg render times 1.324 (+2.44 dB). PREDICTION: the same darker, rounder voice as in pair 'pulse', and no longer the quieter one. FALSIFIED if at matched rms it is no longer heard as darker/rounder (then loudness carried the first pair), or if it is heard as louder or brighter.",
"title": "Measured: HNR 29.5 dB, output rms 0.0537 (matched to the saw), peak 0.137. The Rosenberg render times 1.341 (+2.55 dB). PREDICTION: the same darker, rounder voice as in pair 'pulse', and no longer the quieter one. FALSIFIED if at matched rms it is no longer heard as darker/rounder (then loudness carried the first pair), or if it is heard as louder or brighter.",
"feel": "the short made-up phrase 'ah-mee' in a synthetic voice; listen to the voice itself (buzz, edge, breath), not the words"
},
{
@ -42,7 +42,7 @@
"file": "clean.wav",
"group": "noise",
"pair": "noise-hnr20",
"title": "Measured: HNR 29.9 dB, output rms 0.0530, peak 0.224. The scaffold's noise floor (0.05); noise 0 measures 30.8, the method's ceiling here.",
"title": "Measured: HNR 30.3 dB, output rms 0.0537, peak 0.227. The scaffold's noise floor (0.05); noise 0 measured 30.8 before the tract fix, the method's ceiling here.",
"feel": "the short made-up phrase 'ah-mee' in a synthetic voice; listen to the voice itself (buzz, edge, breath), not the words"
},
{
@ -50,7 +50,7 @@
"file": "w20.wav",
"group": "noise",
"pair": "noise-clean",
"title": "Measured: HNR 19.8 dB, output rms 0.0532, peak 0.231. White glottal noise raised to 0.33. PREDICTION: audible breath/hiss under the voice; a listener who called the clean voice a kazoo or buzzer hears this as less pure-tone but still a machine. FALSIFIED if B is not noisier; if the noise is heard as a separate hiss stream not fused with the voice; or if A and B are the same kazoo to the same degree (then purity of the periodicity is not what makes it a kazoo).",
"title": "Measured: HNR 19.9 dB, output rms 0.0539, peak 0.242. White glottal noise raised to 0.33. PREDICTION: audible breath/hiss under the voice; a listener who called the clean voice a kazoo or buzzer hears this as less pure-tone but still a machine. FALSIFIED if B is not noisier; if the noise is heard as a separate hiss stream not fused with the voice; or if A and B are the same kazoo to the same degree (then purity of the periodicity is not what makes it a kazoo).",
"feel": "the short made-up phrase 'ah-mee' in a synthetic voice; listen to the voice itself (buzz, edge, breath), not the words"
},
{
@ -58,7 +58,7 @@
"file": "w20_b.wav",
"group": "colour",
"pair": "colour-hp20",
"title": "Measured: HNR 19.8 dB, output rms 0.0532, peak 0.231. Byte copy of noise-hnr20's render.",
"title": "Measured: HNR 19.9 dB, output rms 0.0539, peak 0.242. Byte copy of noise-hnr20's render.",
"feel": "the short made-up phrase 'ah-mee' in a synthetic voice; listen to the voice itself (buzz, edge, breath), not the words"
},
{
@ -66,7 +66,7 @@
"file": "h20.wav",
"group": "colour",
"pair": "colour-white20",
"title": "Measured: HNR 20.1 dB, output rms 0.0532, peak 0.238. Noise high-passed at 2 kHz (2nd order), level 0.33. PREDICTION: reads as hiss or 's'-like air, more separable from the voice than the white noise at the same HNR; the white one reads as roughness or breathy voice. FALSIFIED if no difference is heard, or if B is less hissy than A.",
"title": "Measured: HNR 19.9 dB, output rms 0.0540, peak 0.238. Noise high-passed at 2 kHz (2nd order), level 0.33. PREDICTION: reads as hiss or 's'-like air, more separable from the voice than the white noise at the same HNR; the white one reads as roughness or breathy voice. FALSIFIED if no difference is heard, or if B is less hissy than A.",
"feel": "the short made-up phrase 'ah-mee' in a synthetic voice; listen to the voice itself (buzz, edge, breath), not the words"
},
{
@ -74,7 +74,7 @@
"file": "h25.wav",
"group": "aspiration",
"pair": "aspiration-hp15",
"title": "Measured: HNR 25.7 dB, output rms 0.0530, peak 0.231. High-passed noise at level 0.165. PREDICTION: at most faintly airy, may be called no different from a clean voice. FALSIFIED if A is already clearly hissy.",
"title": "Measured: HNR 25.8 dB, output rms 0.0538, peak 0.231. High-passed noise at level 0.165. PREDICTION: at most faintly airy, may be called no different from a clean voice. FALSIFIED if A is already clearly hissy.",
"feel": "the short made-up phrase 'ah-mee' in a synthetic voice; listen to the voice itself (buzz, edge, breath), not the words"
},
{
@ -82,7 +82,7 @@
"file": "h15.wav",
"group": "aspiration",
"pair": "aspiration-hp25",
"title": "Measured: HNR 14.9 dB, output rms 0.0538, peak 0.250. High-passed noise at level 0.6. PREDICTION: clearly hissy, breathier than A. FALSIFIED if B is not hissier than A.",
"title": "Measured: HNR 14.9 dB, output rms 0.0546, peak 0.250. High-passed noise at level 0.6. PREDICTION: clearly hissy, breathier than A. FALSIFIED if B is not hissier than A.",
"feel": "the short made-up phrase 'ah-mee' in a synthetic voice; listen to the voice itself (buzz, edge, breath), not the words"
}
]