Merge remote-tracking branch 'origin/master' into eureka/aetheria-release-package-agent-hull-guards
This commit is contained in:
soul
commit
2f4b617e50
11 changed files with 913 additions and 147 deletions
|
|
@ -11334,10 +11334,10 @@ PIDs are in `S\out\pids.log`, the first 3404 and the last 20348. It then writes
|
|||
|---|---|---|---|
|
||||
| Faction language, `factions/<faction>.scad` | The faction slug. One file per faction. A Pirate hull includes its donor's file as well. | Drafted by an agent from the lore and the operator's art, marked draft, then approved by an operator ruling. A revision rebuilds every hull of that faction at its next Build. | The operator decides the language (`zhestokost-language-source` is the first). Agents propose; nothing else edits it. |
|
||||
| Hull source, `GameData/Mods/<id>/hull.scad` | The package id, equal to `ShipAuthoring.Id`. One per package. | Created by an agent pass for a hull with no operator art and revised by agents. Deleted by Package in the same act that packages operator art into that package. | Agents (Imagination designs, Hands lands). The operator decides when it dies, by packaging her art. |
|
||||
| "Agent-built" status | Presence of `hull.scad`. No field. | Ends when the file is deleted. | Derived. "Which hulls are agent-built" is a directory listing. |
|
||||
| "Agent-built" status | Derived by `_hull_state` from hull.scad, Build's maker record, its untouched zones and her meshes (section HS). No field. | Ends when the state leaves agent and unbuilt: Package retiring hull.scad for her art. | Derived. The state table is in section HS. |
|
||||
| Zone meshes and anchor objects in Blender | Marked `aetheria.hull_source`, with ids `aetheria.id`. | Replaced on every Build. Never hand-edited. | Build From Hull Source. Build refuses a collection holding meshes it did not make. |
|
||||
| `ship.glb` and ShipAuthoring anchors | `ShipAuthoring.ModelAsset`, with anchor ids equal to mount ids. | Rewritten by every Package, whether from an agent hull or operator art. The ids are stable across the swap, so loadouts and saves survive it. | Package Ship, the only writer. |
|
||||
| HullData layout (schematic) | `mod-hull:<id>`. | Authored through Save Layout. Linked to the model by mount name only. | The schematic author: agents for agent hulls, the operator for hers. Never Build. AH-B3 is the open conflict. |
|
||||
| HullData layout (schematic) | `mod-hull:<id>`. | Authored through Save Layout. Linked to the model by mount name only. | The schematic author: agents for agent hulls, the operator for hers. Never Build. AH-B3 is closed by cut `package-agent-hull-guards` (section PG). |
|
||||
| Hero asset | A package with no `hull.scad` that is named as its faction's hero. | Set by an operator ruling (`agent-hull-hero-assets`). | The operator. |
|
||||
|
||||
### Questions admitted
|
||||
|
|
@ -11369,3 +11369,205 @@ Neither blocks the first cut.
|
|||
- The model read was one agent judging its own sheets.
|
||||
- Lucent and AU languages are not drafted.
|
||||
- The hero comparison is weak until the heroes exist.
|
||||
|
||||
## Package on agent hulls (PG)
|
||||
|
||||
Imagination pass `imag-ag7-hull-guards`, session `self-2026-10-19-ag7`, 2026-10-19, pinned to Aetheria `origin/master`
|
||||
5acbaa1b (worktree `C:\aeth-wt\ag7-hull-guards-imag`). It maps cut `package-agent-hull-guards` (spec
|
||||
`aetheria-release:cut_spec:cut-package-agent-hull-guards.r1`) for follow-ups `package-agent-hull-guards` and
|
||||
`hull-copy-refusals` and finding `cut-agent-hull-source.s2.hull-names-its-own-faction`. It rests on rulings
|
||||
`remove-package-schematic-derivation`, `hull-faction-is-product-maker`, `schematic-and-model-are-separate-spaces` and
|
||||
`package-carries-product`.
|
||||
|
||||
### Body facts (source reads and one probe at 5acbaa1b)
|
||||
|
||||
- **PG-B1. The derivation has three writers.** `_derived_position` (`__init__.py:253`) maps a model point to a cell
|
||||
through `hull_grid.cell_at` and `mounted_position`. Add Weapon (`_add_mount`, :302) and Mirror Mount (:359) call it.
|
||||
Package calls `_plan_mounts` (:409), which plans every weapon row's Position, and then `_apply_mounts` (:432), which
|
||||
writes those Positions, sets each mount object's yaw from its row's Rotation, and saves the layout. So Package writes
|
||||
each space from the other: the schematic from the model, and the model's yaw from the schematic. Package would turn
|
||||
a hull source's turned mount (smoke step 1.10, yaw 90) back to its row's facing.
|
||||
- **PG-B2. After the delete, `cell_at`, `mounted_position`, `mounted_cell` and `_centre_offset` have no caller** outside
|
||||
`tests/test_hull_grid.py` (grep of `tools/blender`). `cell_centre`, `mirror_position`, `mirror_footprint`,
|
||||
`mirror_rotation` and `facing_yaw` keep callers (Rasterise, the grid drawing, `_frame_ship`, Mirror Mount, Add
|
||||
Weapon).
|
||||
- **PG-B3. A product names its maker by an opaque Faction record key.** `FactionProductData.Manufacturer` is
|
||||
`CultRecordRef<Faction>` at `[Key(4)]` (`Assets/Scripts/ServerShared/FactionProduct.cs:26`), and
|
||||
`CultRecordRefFormatter` writes it as the key string. Probe `probe_factions.py` (cultcache-py from
|
||||
`F:\Projects\CultLib\packages\cultcache-py\src`, read of `GameData/Aetheria.cc`) listed 16 `aetheria.faction`
|
||||
records. Among them are Zhestokost `16bad4f9-7fb5-41c5-8da0-dc76709eb7d3`, Pirates
|
||||
`1d8a168def994a76a1ce7cb18f59c038` and Rossum & Douglas `adfb9b08-aabc-45c6-9586-915698a9c4b0`. Product makers are
|
||||
these keys: Juggernaut's, for example, is Zhestokost's. The language files are named by slug (`zhestokost`, `pirate`,
|
||||
`rnd`), and nothing maps a slug to a Faction key today.
|
||||
- **PG-B4. New Ship makes no product.** `AetherDb ship-authoring create` writes only a HullData and a ShipAuthoring
|
||||
(`tools/AetherDb/ShipAuthoringCommands.cs:56`). `ship-authoring product <ship.cc> <maker> --name <name>` (:94)
|
||||
writes a product, resolving the maker by Faction `Name` or `ShortName` (:136). The agent-hull smoke packages ships
|
||||
that have no product (Soul s2 noted it).
|
||||
- **PG-B5. The duplicate-id refusal names nothing.** `ship_cc.replace_visual` raises "An anchor ID is used twice"
|
||||
(`ship_cc.py:171`), and it does so after Package has framed the ship and written `ship.glb`. Build never looks at
|
||||
ids, because `_own_meshes` skips every object that carries `aetheria.role`. The add-on already has a way to point at
|
||||
offenders without echoing input: `_refuse_selecting` (`__init__.py:1139`), which `_refuse_loose_meshes` uses.
|
||||
- **PG-B6. The tests split by host.** `tools/blender/tests/test_*.py` import `ship_cc`, `hull_grid` and `hull_source`
|
||||
by path with no bpy (`CULTLIB_PACKAGES=<CultLib>/packages python -m unittest discover -s tools/blender/tests`), so
|
||||
they run on Yggdrasil in a python image with msgpack. The `smoke_*.py` files need Blender 5.2's bpy and run
|
||||
headless (`blender --background --factory-startup --python-use-system-env --python ...`). They run on Starfire, one
|
||||
process at a time, as Soul ran them for agent-hull-source. `ShipSchemaPinTests` is C# and pins the slot constants of
|
||||
`ship_cc.py` by regex.
|
||||
|
||||
### Rationale
|
||||
|
||||
- **The language file names its maker.** The ruling needs a comparison between the brief's faction (a language slug)
|
||||
and the product's maker (a Faction key). Matching names (`Pirates` against `pirate`, `Rossum & Douglas` against `rnd`)
|
||||
would be a fuzzy rule. A table in `hull_source.py` would be a second owner of a fact the language file already
|
||||
stands for. So each `factions/<faction>.scad` gains its Faction record key as an eighth element of its `lang` echo.
|
||||
The file that owns the language then also says whose language it is, and the existing "includes its language
|
||||
unchanged" check covers that element too.
|
||||
- **Build records the maker it judged by, and Package compares that record.** Re-reading `hull.scad` at Package would
|
||||
compare the brief as it is now, which may differ from the brief Build judged: an author could edit the brief after
|
||||
Build and then Package. Build already records what it made (`aetheria.hull_built`), so it also records
|
||||
`aetheria.hull_maker`, the maker key of the language it judged against. Package then refuses unless the package
|
||||
holds at least one product and every product's Manufacturer is that key. The check runs whenever the package still
|
||||
ships Build's zones. When her art takes over (the same predicate `_retire_hull_source` uses), the brief no longer
|
||||
governs and no check runs. An operator could edit the record by hand, since it is a custom property; that is the same
|
||||
trust as the fingerprint record, and a hull source cannot reach it.
|
||||
- **This cut fixes the finding.** After it, the faction a shipped hull was judged by is its product's maker. Drafting
|
||||
under another faction stays possible, as the ruling allows. A separate cut would only repeat the Package edit.
|
||||
- **Mirror Mount mirrors each space within itself.** The twin row's Position is `mirror_position` of the row's own
|
||||
Position and footprint on the layout's width. The twin object stands at the reflection of the mount's model point
|
||||
across Ship Root's X = 0. Mirror Mount refuses when either twin would coincide with its source: the same Position,
|
||||
or a model point within 1 mm of X = 0. `CENTRELINE` (half a schematic cell, measured in model metres) was a
|
||||
cross-space constant, so it goes.
|
||||
- **Add Weapon's yaw stays a creation default.** One Rotation choice sets both the new row and the new empty's facing,
|
||||
once. Nothing re-derives either afterwards. The ruling took only the Position derivation out of Add Weapon, so the
|
||||
yaw stays.
|
||||
- **Copies are refused by id, in Build and Package alike.** One helper refuses while two role-bearing objects share an
|
||||
`aetheria.id`. It selects them and names a count, never an object. That covers the collider, emitter, radiator and
|
||||
mount copies Soul built (s2 probes A2 and A5 to A7). The duplicate check in `ship_cc` stays, as the file writer's
|
||||
invariant.
|
||||
|
||||
### Model page rows
|
||||
|
||||
| Kind | Identity | Lifecycle | Authority |
|
||||
|---|---|---|---|
|
||||
| A language's maker: the eighth element of `lang` in `factions/<faction>.scad` | The Faction record key in `GameData/Aetheria.cc`. | Written when the language is drafted. Changes only if the language is reassigned to another faction. | The language file, operator-approved like the rest of it. |
|
||||
| `aetheria.hull_maker` on a ship collection | The maker key of the language Build judged against. | Set by every Build. Deleted with `aetheria.hull_built` when Package retires `hull.scad`. | Build From Hull Source writes it; Package reads it. |
|
||||
| HullData layout Position | As before. | Authored in the layout panel only. Add Weapon creates a row at the default Position. | The schematic author. Package and the mount helpers no longer write it (this cut closes AH-B3). |
|
||||
|
||||
### Admitted
|
||||
|
||||
- `aetheria-release:cut_spec:cut-package-agent-hull-guards.r1`.
|
||||
|
||||
## Hull collection states (HS)
|
||||
|
||||
Imagination pass `imag-ag7-hull-states`, session `self-2026-10-19-ag7`, 2026-10-19, pinned to Aetheria f121b464 (head
|
||||
of `eureka/aetheria-release-package-agent-hull-guards`, worktree `C:\aeth-wt\ag7-hull-states-f121`). Three Soul passes
|
||||
(verdicts `cut-package-agent-hull-guards.s1` to `.s3`) each found the one decision "is this hull Build's, hers, or
|
||||
neither" answered by two readers that disagreed. This section is the model that gives that decision one owner. It
|
||||
revises spec `cut-package-agent-hull-guards` to r2 for findings `.s3.never-built-art-deadlock` and
|
||||
`.s3.art-requirement-unpinned`, and admits question `art-over-unbuilt-hull-source`.
|
||||
|
||||
### Body facts (source reads and one probe at f121b464)
|
||||
|
||||
- **HS-B1. Four inputs name the state, and each has one writer.** `hull.scad` in the package (`_hull_source_file`,
|
||||
`__init__.py:1499`): written by agents, deleted by `_retire_hull_source` (:1645) or by hand. `aetheria.hull_maker`
|
||||
and `aetheria.hull_built` on the collection (:1494-1495): written together by Build (:1622-1623), deleted together by
|
||||
`_retire_hull_source` (:1648). Build's untouched zone meshes: derived by `_hull_built` (:1518) from the record and each
|
||||
object's fingerprint. Her meshes: `_own_meshes` (:789) minus Build's untouched objects, so a Build zone she edited
|
||||
counts as hers.
|
||||
- **HS-B2. The regime has two readers today.** `_art_takes_over` (:1627) reads the maker record, Ship Root, the
|
||||
untouched zones and her meshes. `_refuse_wrong_maker` (:1654) calls it, then reads `hull.scad` again on its own
|
||||
(:1663) when the record is absent. `_retire_hull_source` (:1639) reads only `_art_takes_over`. The panel reads
|
||||
`hull.scad` to show the Build button (:1789). Build (:1556) reads `hull.scad` as its input file and refuses her
|
||||
meshes and edited objects of its own (:1562-1568), which is its write-safety rule, not the regime.
|
||||
- **HS-B3. Fourteen states are reachable, and the two readers disagree in exactly one.** Probe
|
||||
`probe_states.py` (scratchpad `imag-ag7-hull-states`) transcribes the f121b464 conditions and enumerates every
|
||||
combination of hull.scad (S), the maker record (M), an untouched Build zone (Z), her meshes (A) and Ship Root (R),
|
||||
with Z implying M and R, A implying R, and M without R (a hand-deleted Ship Root) left out. Of 14 states, one is a
|
||||
deadlock: S, no M, no Z, A, R (an agent's hull.scad Build never ran, with her art under Ship Root). Package refuses
|
||||
"Build From Hull Source first" and Build refuses her meshes. That is Soul's s3 case A. The proposed classifier below
|
||||
gives the same Package and retirement outcome as f121b464 in the other 13 states.
|
||||
- **HS-B4. One state is pinned by nothing.** M, no Z, no A (Build's zones deleted, nothing put in their place): the
|
||||
smoke has no step for it, so the art test inside `_art_takes_over` can be replaced with True and the smoke stays
|
||||
green (Soul s3 mutation `mut.art-needs-no-art`).
|
||||
- **HS-B5. Products matter only in the agent state.** `product_makers` (`ship_cc.py`) is read only by
|
||||
`_refuse_wrong_maker`, after the regime says the hull is Build's. Her art and a plain hull ship with any product or
|
||||
none (smoke step 1.9 removes the product before her art is packaged).
|
||||
|
||||
### The state table
|
||||
|
||||
S is hull.scad in the package, M is Build's maker record, Z is an untouched zone mesh of Build's, and A is her meshes
|
||||
under Ship Root. "Check" means that Package refuses unless the package holds a product and every product's
|
||||
Manufacturer is the recorded maker: no product gives "no product", and a wrong or mixed maker gives "not by the
|
||||
maker". Every Package outcome holds only when the validator accepts. Retirement deletes hull.scad (if present), M and
|
||||
`aetheria.hull_built`, after the validator has accepted.
|
||||
|
||||
| # | S | M | Z | A | State | Build | Package | Retired | How it is reached |
|
||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
||||
| H1 | - | - | - | - | plain | refuses: no hull.scad | no check | nothing | New Ship, no agent hull |
|
||||
| H2 | - | - | - | yes | plain | refuses: no hull.scad | no check | nothing | Her hero or hand-made hull. It is also H6 or H11 after the Package that retires |
|
||||
| H3 | yes | - | - | - | unbuilt | builds | refuses: "Build From Hull Source first, or put your own meshes under Ship Root" | nothing | An agent's hull.scad dropped in. Smoke PASS 3 |
|
||||
| H4 | yes | - | - | yes | **art** (question `art-over-unbuilt-hull-source`) | refuses: not its meshes | no check | hull.scad | Her art over a hull.scad Build never ran. **The f121b464 deadlock** |
|
||||
| H5 | yes | yes | yes | - | agent | builds (replaces its own) | check | nothing | After Build. Smoke 1.1 to 1.5 |
|
||||
| H6 | yes | yes | - | yes | art | refuses: not its meshes | no check | hull.scad, M | Her art replaced every Build zone, or she edited them all. Smoke 1.9, odd hull |
|
||||
| H7 | yes | yes | yes | yes | agent | refuses: not its meshes | check | nothing | Her mesh beside Build's zones, or one zone edited. Smoke 1.8 |
|
||||
| H8 | yes | yes | - | - | agent | builds | check | nothing | Build's zones deleted, nothing in their place. **Unpinned (s3 art-requirement)** |
|
||||
| H9 | - | yes | yes | - | agent | refuses: no hull.scad | check | nothing | hull.scad deleted by hand after Build. Smoke 1.5's hull.scad-gone row |
|
||||
| H10 | - | yes | yes | yes | agent | refuses: no hull.scad | check | nothing | H7 with hull.scad deleted by hand |
|
||||
| H11 | - | yes | - | yes | art | refuses: no hull.scad | no check | M | H6 with hull.scad deleted by hand. Smoke 1.9, even hull |
|
||||
| H12 | - | yes | - | - | agent | refuses: no hull.scad | check | nothing | H8 with hull.scad deleted by hand |
|
||||
|
||||
Ship Root absent (states H1 and H3 before New Ship's root, or after a hand deletion) changes nothing in the table:
|
||||
`_own_meshes` needs a root, so with no root A is false and the row is H1 or H3. A maker record with no root (hand
|
||||
deletion) is agent.
|
||||
|
||||
### Authority
|
||||
|
||||
- **Owner of the state: `_hull_state(collection)`**, one classifier in `__init__.py`, evaluated in this order. Build's
|
||||
untouched zone present gives agent. Otherwise her meshes present together with Build's record or hull.scad gives art.
|
||||
Otherwise Build's record present gives agent. Otherwise hull.scad present gives unbuilt. Otherwise plain. It reads
|
||||
`_hull_built`, `_own_meshes`, `HULL_MAKER in collection` and `_hull_source_file`, and nothing else does so to decide
|
||||
the regime.
|
||||
- **Owner of the maker of a shipped agent hull: its products** (ruling `hull-faction-is-product-maker`).
|
||||
`aetheria.hull_maker` is a record of what Build judged against, read only as the value to compare in the agent state.
|
||||
- **Owner of when hull.scad dies: Package**, through `_retire_hull_source` in the art state after the validator
|
||||
accepts, or the operator by hand. Ruling `hull-art-communicates-form` keeps agent hulls until her art replaces them.
|
||||
The model row of section "Agent-built hulls" names Package's packaging of her art as that act.
|
||||
- **Owner of whether Build may write: Build** (`_build_hull_source`), on its own rule that it never replaces a mesh it
|
||||
did not make or an object of its own that was changed. This is a separate decision from the regime, and it reads
|
||||
hull.scad as its input.
|
||||
- **Display-only:** the panel's read of hull.scad (:1789), which shows the Build button. In H4 the button shows and
|
||||
Build refuses. It decides nothing.
|
||||
- **Forbidden readers of the regime:** `_refuse_wrong_maker` reading `hull.scad` or deciding by the presence of the
|
||||
maker record; `_retire_hull_source` testing anything but `_hull_state`; any reader of `aetheria.hull_built` other
|
||||
than `_hull_built`; the smoke asserting the classifier's return value as its only proof.
|
||||
- **Deletion line:** `_art_takes_over` (:1627-1636) and the hull.scad branch of `_refuse_wrong_maker` (:1661-1665) go
|
||||
before `_hull_state` is added.
|
||||
|
||||
### Rationale
|
||||
|
||||
- **The body decides, not a file or a record alone.** The guard exists so that a hull shipping Build's judged body
|
||||
ships under Build's judged maker. Whether Build's untouched zones are in the collection is the fact that says so.
|
||||
hull.scad (keyed by r1, s1 `guard-keyed-on-hull-scad`) and the maker record (keyed by h3, s3 `never-built-art-deadlock`)
|
||||
each stand in for that fact in only some states, which is why each fix moved the hole somewhere else.
|
||||
- **Order is the model.** Z before A keeps H7 and H10 under the guard: one of Build's zones still ships. A with M or S
|
||||
before M alone makes her art win once no Build zone is left (H4, H6, H11). A must be required (H8 and H12 stay agent),
|
||||
and M or S must be required (H2 stays plain and retires nothing).
|
||||
- **H4 is the operator's call.** Two readings are coherent. Under the first, her art over a hull.scad is hers and
|
||||
Package retires the file, which is what 70c366b5 did and what the "Agent-built hulls" model row says. Under the
|
||||
second, Package never deletes an agent's hull.scad that Build never ran, and refuses with text naming the exit
|
||||
(delete hull.scad). The recommendation is the first, in question `art-over-unbuilt-hull-source`. Either answer
|
||||
changes one condition in `_hull_state` and one message, and both remove the deadlock.
|
||||
- **The "Agent-built" status row above is superseded.** It said the status is the presence of hull.scad. That holds
|
||||
only for H3 to H8. The status is `_hull_state` being agent or unbuilt.
|
||||
|
||||
### Model page rows
|
||||
|
||||
| Kind | Identity | Lifecycle | Authority |
|
||||
|---|---|---|---|
|
||||
| Hull state (plain, unbuilt, agent, art) of a ship collection | Derived per call from hull.scad, `aetheria.hull_maker`, Build's untouched zones and her meshes. No field. | Recomputed at every Package and retirement. It changes when Build runs, when she adds or removes meshes, at retirement, and when hull.scad or a record is deleted by hand. | `_hull_state`, alone. |
|
||||
|
||||
### Admitted
|
||||
|
||||
- `aetheria-release:question:art-over-unbuilt-hull-source` (recommended `art-takes-over`, raised in the spec, which it
|
||||
blocks).
|
||||
- `aetheria-release:cut_spec:cut-package-agent-hull-guards.r2`, superseding r1.
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,101 @@
|
|||
# Prior art for agent-authored stand-in hulls (aetheria-release, 2026-10-19)
|
||||
|
||||
Serves: the stand-in hull prompt bench for the demo cast and freelancer factions
|
||||
(operator 2026-10-19: "Let's see if we can figure out a prompt that gets Opus to
|
||||
spit out some decent stand-in hulls for the demo cast (including ships from
|
||||
non-present factions to be piloted by other freelancers)"). Gathered by Eyes
|
||||
pass `eyes-ag7-llm-cad-prior-art`, session `self-2026-10-19-ag7`. Companion to
|
||||
`2026-10-18-agent-built-hull-art-prior-art.md` and
|
||||
`2026-10-18-faction-form-language-prior-art.md`.
|
||||
|
||||
Evidence levels: **read** (HTML or abstract page read), **snippet** (search
|
||||
excerpt only).
|
||||
|
||||
## Loops and their measured gains
|
||||
|
||||
- **SceneCraft** (ICML 2024, arXiv 2403.01248, read). Removing the render-review
|
||||
inner loop dropped constraint score 88.9 to 26.1, the largest loss in its
|
||||
ablation. Removing the learned code-skill library dropped it 88.9 to 64.5 and
|
||||
CLIP 69.8 to 48.3. Human eval put its aesthetics win rate at 74.5% against
|
||||
BlenderGPT's 14.5%. It measures scene layout from given assets, not part form.
|
||||
- **CADCodeVerify** (ICLR 2025, arXiv 2410.05340, read). Two refinement rounds;
|
||||
no gain observed beyond round 2. Point-cloud distance 0.156 to 0.126. Dropping
|
||||
the reference views or the few-shot questions made it worse. The VLM's own
|
||||
verification answers were correct only 64.6% and 68.2% of the time; human
|
||||
gold feedback (0.120) beat VLM feedback (0.137) on a 50-sample subset.
|
||||
- **BlenderGym** (CVPR 2025, arXiv 2504.01786, read). VLM verifier agreement
|
||||
with human pairwise judgments 0.66 (Claude 3.5 Sonnet) against 0.79
|
||||
human-to-human; Claude was the only verifier that consistently gave full
|
||||
reasoning. Scarce compute favours generation, abundant compute favours
|
||||
verification: a scaled small verifier over 32 Claude candidates beat unscaled
|
||||
GPT-4o and Claude. Generators hallucinate differences, and edits mismatch the
|
||||
diagnosis in scripts over about 80 lines. Metrics miss physical
|
||||
implausibility such as floating objects.
|
||||
- **LL3M** (arXiv 2508.08228, read). Planner, retrieval, coder, critic and
|
||||
verifier agents; the critic sees 5 renders, the verifier checks each fix was
|
||||
applied, refinement loops until the verifier approves. Blender-API retrieval
|
||||
raised complex-operation use 1.20 to 5.86 and cut execution errors 26%.
|
||||
Without retrieval the coder sometimes deleted offending lines to silence
|
||||
errors. Without shared prior code the coder regenerates a substantially
|
||||
different asset. Disconnected handles survive auto-refinement; VLMs struggle
|
||||
with spatial artifacts. Agent ablations are qualitative only; no user study.
|
||||
- **Procedura** (arXiv 2608.26238, read). Named parts with typed mates, per-part
|
||||
compile, mate and connectivity gates, and a vision critic that fixes one
|
||||
diagnosed issue at a time. Ablation on MechBench-36 (judge score): full 0.828,
|
||||
no refine 0.800, no planning 0.791, no 3D feedback 0.819; dropping planning
|
||||
caused the biggest aesthetics drop, 0.827 to 0.775. A floater at 70% span was
|
||||
1.9% of volume, so a volume check misses it. Case study: 24 to 3 to 2 HIGH
|
||||
issues over three critic cycles. CSG suits hard-surface better than organic.
|
||||
- **P3D-Bench** (arXiv 2606.11152, abstract). Multi-part code generation is much
|
||||
harder than single-part: models get identity right, dimensions, part count
|
||||
and part geometry wrong.
|
||||
- **ModelRift Pantheon benchmark** (vendor blog, one run per cell, read). Opus
|
||||
4.7 scored 3.0/5 with "uniform colour and weight"; Sonnet 4.6 3.4/5 with the
|
||||
cleanest massing. Explicit measured dimensions helped; human annotations drawn
|
||||
on the render beat text corrections. A preview PNG looked better than the
|
||||
exported STL, which had non-manifold surfaces.
|
||||
|
||||
## Self-judgement
|
||||
|
||||
- Huang et al., ICLR 2024 (arXiv 2310.01798, snippet): intrinsic
|
||||
self-correction without external feedback often fails and can hurt; reported
|
||||
gains partly came from oracle labels or weak first prompts.
|
||||
- Panickssery et al., NeurIPS 2024 (arXiv 2404.13076, snippet): LLM evaluators
|
||||
recognise and favour their own generations; text domain.
|
||||
- Multimodal self-judging leans on text priors over the image (arXiv 2406.11280,
|
||||
2508.20655, snippets).
|
||||
|
||||
## Failure modes in CAD code
|
||||
|
||||
- BenchCAD and ASSEMCAD (snippets): successful renders still show floating
|
||||
components; union without face glue gives floating subpieces; polar patterns
|
||||
are an error cluster. ASSEMCAD mitigates with safe-union and overlap
|
||||
validators.
|
||||
- Shape-grammar ships (CESCG 2016; 2022 Hacettepe thesis; snippets): primitive
|
||||
sets plus rules give similar outlines with varied detail; unconstrained
|
||||
derivation tends toward unstructured results.
|
||||
|
||||
## Game-art practice (criteria a critic can check)
|
||||
|
||||
- Stellaris Dev Diary 230 (search excerpt): silhouette and proportions read
|
||||
first at distance; big shapes settled before small; shared motifs unify a
|
||||
family.
|
||||
- Fractured Space art direction, Creative Bloq (search excerpt): an arrowhead
|
||||
silhouette reads as a threat across the map; three manufacturers each get a
|
||||
distinct vocabulary (stacked cylinders, brutalist cubes, naval modular
|
||||
shells); human figures dropped in as scale checks.
|
||||
- "Moth" analysis, John Liberto, ArtStation (search excerpt): 3 large, 4 mid
|
||||
and many small volumes; the large volumes dictate the silhouette.
|
||||
- Primary/secondary/tertiary shapes (steveyang.readthedocs.io, read, after Neil
|
||||
Blevins): primary defines silhouette, secondary individuality, tertiary story.
|
||||
|
||||
## Gaps
|
||||
|
||||
No controlled study of design-language or style-spec conditioning for
|
||||
LLM-authored CAD; no measurement of a parts library against floating-part or
|
||||
symmetry errors (nearest: SceneCraft's skill library, LL3M's retrieval); no
|
||||
sweep of render-critique round counts for aesthetic quality; no direct
|
||||
measurement of a model praising its own render (inferred from text-domain
|
||||
work); no source on boxy "lego" look or scale confusion in LLM 3D code; no
|
||||
authoritative game-art source for 60/30/10 ship proportions. 3D-PreMise
|
||||
(2401.06437) and MeshCoder (2508.14879) seen as abstracts only.
|
||||
Loading…
Reference in a new issue