From 105632df25d9781ebbcd34c5213f8e9b5854e2b0 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: soul Date: Fri, 20 Nov 2026 00:37:22 +0100 Subject: [PATCH] Aetherlight AL2b-2a: PROVENANCE section for the Play-only cut Records what went (with f51275c61 locations), the born-Active genesis and the one gate; restates the AL2b-1 residue as what AL2b-2b still owns and drops the leave-set bullets and the valid_until obligation this cut deleted. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 --- native/aetherlight/PROVENANCE.md | 86 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++------ 1 file changed, 70 insertions(+), 16 deletions(-) diff --git a/native/aetherlight/PROVENANCE.md b/native/aetherlight/PROVENANCE.md index 7ad559f15..ccdd9f276 100644 --- a/native/aetherlight/PROVENANCE.md +++ b/native/aetherlight/PROVENANCE.md @@ -181,22 +181,18 @@ Kept untouched for AL2b: controllers and `ControllerMode`, consumers `#![allow(dead_code)]` still hides the dead code of a crate with no entry point. What the cut deletes is gone; what remains is part B's: -- Consumer lane: `ConsumerId`, `CONSUMER_ID_NAMESPACE`, `bound_to_consumer`, - `PatchGround::Consumer` and the consumer arm of `confine_to_ground`, - `VerifiedPrincipalEvidence`. -- Controller lane: `verified_controller`, `resolve_controller`, `controller_mode`, +- Controller lane (AL2b-2b's): `resolve_controller`, `controller_mode`, `controller_key`. -- `CreateWorldIntent` (no consumer after the mailbox left). - Authenticated-caller vocabulary: `AuthenticatedCaller::fixture`, - `verified_principal`, `verified_controller`, `verified_system`, and + `verified_principal`, `verified_play`, and `requires_owner_restart`; id helpers `text` and `nil_for_test`; `commits_for_test`; grammar `verbs`. AL4's ABI decides which of these it needs. - Patch ingress: `decode_patch`, `check_patch_caps`, `PatchDecodeError` and `MAX_PATCH_BYTES`, `MAX_PATCH_DECLARATIONS`, `MAX_PATCH_OPERATIONS`, `MAX_PATCH_EVIDENCE`; the consumer ingress and elaboration lane read them, and - nothing here does. AL2b deletes them with the consumer lane unless AL4's ABI - decodes patches itself. + nothing here does. They stay: AL4's ABI decides whether it decodes patches + itself. - Mailbox and vault comments (`WorldMailbox`, `vault:` evidence strings). Reproduce the list with `RUSTFLAGS=--force-warn dead_code cargo test --lib --no-run`: @@ -237,20 +233,78 @@ kernel Speak entry, the grammar, `preconditions_hold`). `DecisionScope` stays th grant key and `ControllerAssignment` stays; the owner's `AdmitPatch` and `AdvanceTime` doors and `SystemCapability::Clock` stay. -AL2b-2 still owns, under `aetherlight-play-only-after-genesis`: the owner's and -`Clock`'s post-genesis doors (`AdmitPatch` and `AdvanceTime`), `CallerId::Controller` -and the controller assignment, the consumer lane and ground, the draft phase and -approvals, `VerifiedPrincipalEvidence`, the never-mute rule -(`WouldLeaveSubjectMute`) and the `verify_state_shape` clause requiring a grant per -controlled scope. +AL2b-2a (below) took the writers; AL2b-2b still owns the controller half under +`aetherlight-play-only-after-genesis`: `ControllerAssignment` (which until then +holds only the `Retired` flag and unread identity data), `NewController`, +`ControllerId`, `ControllerMode`, `DecisionScope` as the grant key, +`SubjectState.retired`, `Mismatch::UnadmittedController`, the `admits_human` +rename and the snapshot's controller fields. `last_acted_at` and `minted_at` in `snapshot` still read `state.events` (by `event.actor`). AL3 needs keyed rows instead of a scan; that is the AL3 cut's. +## Cut AL2b-2a: after genesis only Play writes + +Base `f51275c61`. A world is born Active: the genesis commit is the owner's +only act, and `WorldState::empty` has no phase and no approvals. After it +`CallerId::Play` is the only caller any command body admits. `CallerId` is +`{ Principal, Play }`; `Principal` survives as the genesis creator (and as the +refused caller of every post-genesis body). One rule, `require_play`, decides it +at the top of `reduce` and again at the top of `apply_effect`, so it holds on +commit and at replay; the journal gains no caller rule. +`require_ruler` is `forbid_rulings_at_genesis`: genesis may not rule or mint, +Play may. A grant row exists if and only if the subject holds a verb; a subject +may be declared with none, and revoking the last verb removes the row. +`GrantsOutsideControl` is `GrantsToRetired`. `STATE_SCHEMA` and `COMMIT_SCHEMA` +moved to `consumer.v9`. + +Deleted, with their `f51275c61` locations in `lib.rs` unless noted: + +- The Clock and Consumer capabilities and `CallerId::Controller`: + `SystemCapability` (388-406), `AuthenticatedCaller::verified_controller` (433), + `require_system_capability`, `require_clock_caller`, `require_play_active`, + `require_owner` and `require_patch_author` (1456-1514, 3594-3625, 3989-4006), + and `apply_effect`'s capability table. +- The consumer lane: `ConsumerId` and its namespace (317-338), `PatchGround` + (408-419), `NewController::External`, `ControllerAssignment:: + ExternallyControlled`, `expected_caller`, `consumer()`, `bound_to_consumer`, + `candidate_places`, `confine_to_ground` (3628-3792), `operation_ground` + (3826-3987), and in `patch.rs` the mirror and human candidate sets, + `Mismatch::OutsideJurisdiction`, `RetiresAMirror`, `ControllerGrantMismatch`. +- The draft phase: `WorldPhase`, `WorldState.phase` and `draft_approvals`, + `CommandBody::ApproveDraft` and `ActivateWorld`, `WorldEffect::DraftApproved` + and `WorldActivated`, `required_approvers`, `KernelError::WrongPhase`, + `NotDraftApprover`, `DraftAlreadyApproved`, `MissingApprovals`, the snapshot's + `phase`, `draft_approvals` and `required_approvers`, `Mismatch::RetiresAnApprover`, + and the Draft-only shape clause in `journal.rs`. +- The never-mute rule and the controller/grant pairing: in `admit_resolved`, the + resolver, `Mismatch::WouldLeaveSubjectMute`, and the shape clauses in + `verify_state_shape` that required a grant row per controlled scope. +- `CommandId::derived`, whose only caller was `ConsumerId::of_name`. +- `VerifiedPrincipalEvidence` (106-146), `CreateWorldIntent` (366-376) and + `PrincipalCommandIntent` (521-529). The `valid_until` enforcement that + Ghostlight's mailbox did is no longer an AL4 obligation: the type that carried + it is gone. + +Kept: the whole dialogue lane, `decode_patch`, `check_patch_caps`, +`PatchDecodeError` and the `MAX_PATCH_*` constants (AL4's ABI decides whether +it decodes patches itself), the `ghostlight.*` schema namespaces (AL3 renames +them), `Retire`, `GrantAffordance` and `RevokeAffordance` as Play's patch +operations, and `#![allow(dead_code)]`. + +Nothing decides with a controller after this cut. `ControllerAssignment`, +`NewController::{Human, NarrativePersona, OperationalAgent}`, `ControllerId`, +`ControllerMode`, `DecisionScope` as the grant key, `validate_assignment`, +`Mismatch::UnadmittedController` and `admits_human` (the genesis predicate three +places read) stay compiled for AL2b-2b, which removes the controllers and +renames the predicate. + +`last_acted_at` and `minted_at` in `snapshot` still read `state.events`; the +count of code readers of `state.events` did not rise (idea +`cutspecs-1119.al3-needs-keyed-rows`). + ## Obligations this cut hands to AL4 - A cross-crate proof that forged opportunities and ids are refused, equivalent to the dropped `tests/external_admission.rs`, against the ABI's surface. -- Enforcement of `VerifiedPrincipalEvidence::valid_until`, which Ghostlight's - mailbox did and the fork does not. - Removal of `#![allow(dead_code)]`.